25 ms·
The gift of it's your problem now
- gitgud 5y ago> When you try to pay for gifts, it turns the whole gift process into a transaction. It stops being a gift. It becomes an inefficient, misdesigned, awkward market. This resonated with me. When opensource involves money, incentives become misaligned... And all the bad parts of a SASS product become important, vendor lock in, upselling etc...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- beervirus 5y ago
- pmjones 5y agoI expounded on the gift-giving theme as well, some years ago, and am glad to see I was not alone: http://paul-m-jones.com/post/2018/12/11/open-source-and-squeegee-men/ http://paul-m-jones.com/post/2018/12/11/open-source-and-sque...
- draw_down 5y ago[dead]
- hemmert 5y agoThanks for that gift of an article!
- renewiltord 5y agoIt's just a natural outcome of the fact that most programmers are talkers, not doers. Naturally, they go online to talk about how they wouldn't have written the bug and haven't ever. But the truth is that's because they've never done anything worthwhile. It's like the whole OpenSSL thing again.
- jrm4 5y agoI can't help but think so much of this could be solved if we simply had real and effective product liability rules and consequences for things that use software. You give it away for free, no guarantees and such? Great, we appreciate it. You sold something to someone? Okay, well, like with food and buildings and cars and airplane rides, we understand that if it's done wrong it can be really harmful, so we have real legal consequences for getting it wrong. Where you sourced your inputs is not my problem when it does -- whether that input was "free software" or "rotten ingredients" or "faulty concrete."
- pas 5y agoSoftware is everywhere. A 5 USD gadget dies because the software is shit? Nobody cares. (The ewaste is bad still.) An 1 USD app has bugs? Meh. We have liability regulations for the actual things that use software. (And in some cases too much and in some cases too little. See healthcare, medical devices, FDA on one end, and Boeing and the MCAS fuckup on the other end.) One reason Amazon got sooo big is that they do have a consumer protection regulation. (The return everything no questions asked policy. Of course they also have a fucking big problem with scams, and they are too hostile with merchants, because they are a fucking de facto monopoly, and are not forced to work much on those problems or "metrics".)
- jopsen 5y ago> if we simply had real and effective product liability rules... Isn't there a risk it software would become as ineffective as healthcare? It seems to me that private enterprises aren't good at handling huge uncertainties (like liability). So businesses would aggressively minimize liabilities. Sure we would get better software, but we might get less competition, higher barriers to entry, more expensive products, and less capable products. Suing companies for doing the wrong thing is an expensive mechanism. Gradually regulating supply-chain documentation is probably cheaper.
- jrm4 5y agoI literally believe we would likely get the opposite of every possible negative thing you mentioned; mostly because I think the cause of most software problems (or more specifically, the difficulty of discovering and fixing them) comes directly from the monopoly and monopoly-like players that currently exist. I'm aware that a world in which e.g. Microsoft was actually sued to the extent of the damage it has caused is hard to envision, but I can't help but think breaking that sort of thing up by whatever means gets you more visibility, more localism, more shallow bugs, etc.
- hinkley 5y ago> If you wanted to pay someone to fix some software, you didn't want a gift. You wanted a company. > But if there is no company and someone gave you something anyway? Say thanks. This is what grinds my gears. There is no market for a company that tries to provide a better version of the gift. The author completely glosses over the social contracts involved in gift giving. Contracts that software developers seem to be particularly immune to. I think the party analogy is closer to the crux of it, because we all have a story about someone who threw and awful party or bought one pizza for people who helped them move and then retorts with something tone deaf like "you didn't have to come you know." I didn't have to come, but I had other options that day, which I turned down to come to your stupid party. There was an opportunity cost associated with your gift. I'm not some dilettante who is going to crucify you for throwing a boring party. If that's the sort of people you attract then you've done yourself a favor by filtering them out. But an awful party is going to cost the group something. (Also I wish the author had mentioned "Free as in Puppy" which is part of the situation they are describing.)
- janosett 5y agoI don’t think this analogy really holds. Whereas one person or a closed group usually organize a party, open source is, well, open! We could re-imagine this as a potluck I suppose. If you decide to bring nothing, you can’t really complain if the food is awful.
- Kinrany 5y agoI think it does hold: the cost of learning to use an open source project is not zero. It's the same as not asking the party planner about every detail even when they're perfectly willing to answer. Gift giving inherently involves trust from the recipient. And there's no transaction, so it's inherently consequentialist.
- kmac_ 5y agoIt doesn't hold at all. Open source licences usually clearly state that there are no guarantees. The contract is clear and log4j (or any other) authors don't owe anything to anyone. If you want guarantees, pay for it.
- runningmike 5y ago‘You literally cannot pay for it. If you do, it becomes something else.’ This is mot true and imho misleading. You can pay for GPL software. Many people do pay a lot for FOSS software. You can pay devs that develop GPL software. And it will still be FOSS. Payments do not change wether software is FOSS or not.
- jdiez17 5y agoIn that case (using the article's analogies), you are receiving a gift (GPL/FOSS software), and choosing to give them a gift as well (money). Both transactions are 100% no strings attached.
- jopsen 5y agoI bought qcad a few years ago (used it for a hobby project), I payed for it because compiling from source would have been a hassle. Note. qcad is open source. But yes, there is a limit for what you can charge and how far you can scale that model :)
- tonyedgecombe 5y ago>Many people do pay a lot for FOSS software. A few. Most people leech.
- andybak 5y agoIn case I forget when I'm done - I'm half a dozen paragraphs in and I want to say how much I love this style of writing.
- ignoramous 5y agoYou're not the only one: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2320966 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2320966 (2011)
- coderintherye 5y agoSomewhat related to the points about authoritarianism, a book review of "The Conquest of Bread" that had some discussion about a month back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29349688 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29349688
- panic 5y ago> I read a book once which argued that the problem with modern political discourse is it pits the "I don't want things taken from me" (liberty!) people against the "XYZ is a human right" (entitlement!) people. And that a better way to frame the cultural argument is "XYZ is my responsibility to society." I don’t know if it’s the book he’s talking about, but Simone Weil makes this argument in the beginning of The Need for Roots[+]—that the correct way to think about our relationship to society isn’t “rights” (someone else’s problem) but obligations (our problem). [+] https://antilogicalism.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/need-roots.pdf https://antilogicalism.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/04/need-r...
- a9h74j 5y agoI don't recall which of Simone Weil's works this is from, but in terms of suggesting the ineffectiveness of rights, she presented this dialog of one person pleading with a much more powerful one: Pleading: But sir, you must respect my rights. Reply: I do not see the necessity of that.
- stavros 5y agoHow is an "obligation" not the exact same thing as a "right", just from the other person's perspective? Pleading: But, sir, you must fulfill your obligations. Reply: I do not see the necessity of that.
- stock_toaster 5y agoI think the whole point is that it is from the other perspective (they are "jural corelative"?)[1]. Example: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noblesse_oblige https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noblesse_oblige [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corelative https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Corelative
- hdjrudni 5y agoYou didn't flip the dialogue, you just substituted different words. Replier: I should fulfill my obligations to society. Pleader: le suffering Replier: Ya..I should really do that now. It's my duty. That's the difference, the perspective. You aren't asking someone to fulfill their obligations, people are taking it upon themselves because the mindset has shifted. It's now upon you to do the right thing, not hand-wave say "you have rights..but it's someone else's job to realize them"
- zby 5y agoI have only one question: is his blog a gift?
- unnouinceput 5y agoI don't like hair trimmers. I have no use for them and they only occupy space and eventually I return them when I get them as gifts. And yet, every 2 or 3 years I get one as a gift. His blog is a hair trimmer, now I have to kill the memory it occupied in my brain (return the gift).
- fmajid 5y agoThe hair trimmers are not a gift. They are a pointed commentary on your grooming, or so I would assume.
- unnouinceput 5y agoConsidering I have a hair salon I go and do said grooming every 2 or 3 months, it's not a pointed commentary but a poor gift from people who don't really know me. You see, it's fashionable in my country to do such a gift to men, except in my case I get it from people who don't really know me but they enter my my life one way or another. Trust me, they learn and next gift is usually perfume or shaving water. Those gifts are always welcome, no matter how many come.
- ignoramous 5y agoapenwarr's posts on (software engineering x startups) are even more lit. As someone who works on FOSS full-time, I wish they wrote about the questions posed in the epilogue section of that post.
- EGreg 5y agoActually, cryptocurrencies and DAOs were supposed to be socialism. The network was going to be owned by the people. The natural way to monetize open source. Well, minus the whole one person one vote part, but still better than the surveillance capitalism of Big Tech companies funded by VCs buying shares, propping up their “free to lockin” model and dumping them on the public, who then made them extract rents forever to satisfy wall street earnings. In my opinion, cryptos were seduced by the dark side of profit, and buyers failed to care that the emperor (blockchain) has no clothes (scalability). I am focused on micropayments and local currencies with actual utility, and moving past blockchain. I am going to link to something — and historically this link was immediately knee-jerk perceived as “shilling a coin” but if you read, there is no coin, it’s just talking about how to ACTUALLY monetize open source projectsand joirnalism and other online content on the WEB using WEB technology instead of government enforcers: https://qbix.com/token https://qbix.com/token
- southerntofu 5y agoThat's an interesting perspective. I've had this debate before with people, but i personally believe the way to build socialism (or anarchy, or communism or whatever you'd like to call it) is to abolish money and private property. Trying to game the system using its own axioms is not going to bring any major change, as history has shown. Only by fundamentally changing the nature of relationships can we fundamentally change society overall.
- EGreg 5y agoWithout money / currency, how do we reward people for their contributions to a project? How do you quantify the needs in "to each according to his need"? If one day a person wants to throw a party, how will they obtain the materials? But if they try to throw a party every single day, someone has to account for this, no? As for private property, I have written about this before -- I believe that private property, like government, is an institution that relies on threats of force to be enforced, and restricts people... but that on small levels, it's good and as the level gets larger (owning 900 houses vs 9 houses) the courts should simply enforce it with less and less force: https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=208 https://magarshak.com/blog/?p=208
- tehjoker 5y agoThe gift economy part was good, the poorly read philosophy on communism lacking in class consciousness was yawn. Points for recognizing authoritarianism from capitalism. Negative points for assuming the US government was designed to secure liberty for all rather than the landed classes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- didibus 5y ago> Authoritarianism is about taking things from me. Communism, in its noncorporeal theoretical form, is about giving things away That seems slightly wrong to me. I feel like this is comparing apples to oranges. Authoritarianism is a ruling arrangement, but communism is an economic arrangement. In a way, democracy is to the right to rule as what communism is to the right to wealth. In a democracy, all citizen has equal right to rule, everyone gets one vote. In communism, all citizen has equal right to wealth, everyone gets the same amount of ownership into the sum total wealth of the country. (in practice, just like there are false democracies where fraud is rampant and not everyone truly gets an equal vote, communism in practice till now seem to not have truly given equal wealth to all) Why has there never been a democratic communist country is a good question, but there are quite a few social democracies and those have worked quite well till now... like most western countries except the US (and even the US has quite a lot of socialism built in and is really a social democracy even if maybe more libertarian than others). I'm not saying that communism would work better, but I do find it annoying when people restrict the search space into alternative economic arrangements by pointing out the correlation between communism and authoritarianism. I see communism as more of giving me things, then giving things away. It only seems to give things away if you start with the assumption you own more things to begin with. But the current distribution is that communism should in theory give more people more things, while only taking away from a small percentage which currently disproportionately own most wealth. The counterpoint being the size of the pie. If we all own an equal share of a small pie, you might still have less pie than if you were to own the smallest slice of a much bigger pie. This is the best argument I've heard for capitalism. And with a little sprinkle of socialism, you can regulate capitalism so that there are limits on how small a slice can be, giving people a reasonable living baseline and growing the overall size of the pie at the same time. The weaker part of this argument is establishing a proof that there are no other ways that would also yield a bigger pie while also having a more even distribution of it.
- a4isms 5y agoFred tosses and turns, unable to sleep. Wilma sits up. “Fred, what’s the problem? Why are you tossing and turning?” Fred comes clean: “I owe Barney $10,000 and I promised to pay it tomorrow. And I know he needs it, because he bought a new set of golf clubs to use at the company golf tournament this weekend on credit, and if he doesn’t pay, he’ll have to take the clubs back.” Wilma picks up the phone. “Betty? Sorry to call you so late, but would you give Barney a message? Tell him that Fred doesn’t have the $10,000 he promised. Yes, that’s all. Good night!” Fred stares at Wilma, aghast. “What did you do THAT for?” Wilma smiles. “It’s Barney’s problem now. Let him toss and turn, we can go to sleep!”
- 1970-01-01 5y ago>"Internet access is a human right," is just a sneaky way of saying "someone should give people free Internet." This isn't correct. It does not mean someone should pay your ISP bill. Human rights are standards of living that are protected by laws.
- lambdatronics 5y agoWow, the "Authoritarianism" section is the essay I wish I had written, but better than I would have written it! Thank you!
- athrowaway3z 5y agoI appreciate that this is just some over dramatic roast, but claiming that some parts of open source are suboptimal wrt security is a "non causal observation" means you're ignoring the difference between 'warning' and 'example'.
- bcrl 5y agoI think the author is missing (or perhaps just discounting) the fact that not all developers have the same level of competency. Just because someone releases code as free software or open source doesn't mean they have done the work that a more skilled practitioner of the art would do prior to public release. It's not just money that determines code quality, but there are cases in which it can help. Taste in selecting which code and features are accepted by a maintainer will have a huge impact on the resulting security track record of a project.
- hispanic 5y ago> Paying for gifts... does not work. When the context is friends/family exchanging gifts, I agree. But, given the context of the author's argument (open-source software), I disagree. When I pay for (sponsor) open-source software, I'm doing so because I want to encourage the relevant author(s) to continue applying their talents for the betterment of both myself and the world at large. I'm not paying for something I requested of them, nor am I telling them what to build going forward. If I knew a person who spent some of their free time helping relieve homelessness in some way, I'd be inclined to sponsor them in the same fashion.
- garfieldnate 5y ago>a person whose name is now unpopular was at a university, where they had a printer, and the printer firmware was buggy. Is this not a quote from Stallman? Is he really so badly in the internet's doghouse that we can't even say his name?
- h2odragon 5y agoWhat other gifts continue to be the responsibility of the giver after they're given? If I give you a puppy, and it gets sick, should the vet bill me? If I gave you a car, and the wheels fall off two years later, is that my problem? In this instance people have been using this Java package for years I gather without problems. Why is the responsibility for changing the package anyone but theirs, the people using it; now that they're decided they have stricter requirements for that need? Even the entertainment industry's notion of "ownership" isn't so endless. They'd like to be paid every time we use their product, but have settled for "licensed media" ... but that license doesn't extend to replacing the media when it wears out.
- dasil003 5y agoThis cultural expectation follows naturally from the nature of software. Software (especially of the networked variety) isn't something you can just deploy and be done. It has to be maintained to continue running over time as the ecosystem changes. The cost of this maintenance is lowest when amortized across the largest set of users, hence the success of open source software, and the desire to avoid forks. The people who are most qualified to maintain software are the original creators, so that is the path of least resistance. Of course no one is obligated to maintain anything, open source maintainers abandon stuff all the time without any repercussions beyond passive internet rage.
- andrewflnr 5y agoYep. The puppy analogy falls apart when you've given the same puppy to 10,000 people. All of them could pay the vet bill separately, but we instinctively recoil from that as being horribly inefficient (and personally inconvenient) when it's possible for just the one puppy-giver to pay it.
- daniel-cussen 5y ago> If I give you a puppy, and it gets sick, should the vet bill me? > If I gave you a car, and the wheels fall off two years later, is that my problem? So in Western culture there's this notion that a gift creates no further obligations. The recipient should just be happy he got what he got and not expect anything more. As if to say, at least you didn't get nothing, you can still get nothing, you want nothing? I would say with the puppy if it gets sick and the recipient can't afford it, you should accept paying the bill. Before it was the "giftee's" puppy, it was your puppy for some small amount of time after you got it and before you gave it. Surely when you gave me a puppy you expected me to be able to keep it alive, right? And as for the car, it's not right to give someone a car whose maintenance they can't afford. The puppy and the car are two excellent examples of gifts that cannot be given without forming a relationship between the giver and the receiver. On the other hand a gift you can give and split and that's it is food or money. Just handing money to a beggar, he might ask for more, and you can walk. In some African cultures it's more like, if you do me a favor, do me another favor, and then we're true blue and you can rely on me to help you in return, but never in a tit-for-tat manner. It's in the book Debt: The First 5000 Years.
- jaredklewis 5y agoThis was a long, thoughtful read. I really enjoyed it and mostly see things as the author does. > So it is with free software. You literally cannot pay for it. If you do, it becomes something else. This is really the crux. Everyone is mad there’s no money in writing free/os software, but if there was money it wouldn’t be free/os software. It would just be like what we do at our day jobs. You can write the code someone else wants and get paid for it (aka a day job). You also have the option to write the code YOU want to write, but in this case you’ll need to figure out a plan for making money on your own.
- pronlover723 5y ago> You literally cannot pay for it Sure you can. You can hire someone to fix it to your liking. As an example, I'm pretty sure that's RedHat's M.O. Pay them to fix whatever you want them to fix.
- r_hoods_ghost 5y agoOne of the problems is that if your target market is other devs, there is a knee jerk demand that your software should be foss and free (as in beer). I hope that we'll see a move away from foss licensing to source available licenses over the next few years and an increased acceptance of this model in more areas. Dropping the non discrimination clauses in open source licenses while giving licensees the right to view and modify the source and integrate it with their own software, but not the right to redistribute, is to me a good middle ground for a lot of projects. This would allow developers to charge different rates (or not charge) depending on the licensee and ensure that they can capture more of the value from their work if they need to do so in the future, or if their project becomes popular. It works for Epic with Unreal Engine and more generally in the game industry where it is common to have source available licenses. While free software has its place in certain areas (academia, government, hobby projects), and I agree you should be able to audit and fix the software that runs on your own devices, it also has downsides and I don't think foss licensing should always, or even usually, be the default outside of these cases.
- mcguire 5y ago
- xg15 5y agoFrom log4j to Communism vs Authoritarianism in less than 400 words. Gotta admit, that is impressive even for internet standards.
- mirkules 5y agoWhat’s more is that the author is wrong. Free Software is libertarianism, not communism. “Free” refers to the freedom to modify the software, the liberty of one person to (legally) do whatever they want with the thing they own. Common ownership, or community control of means of production has nothing to do with Free Software. Nobody owns free software and nobody controls it.
- fmajid 5y agoMore precisely anarchism. The ethos of Stallman is completely at odds with that of libertarians.
- mixedmath 5y agoCould you expand on how the ethos of Stallman is at odds with libertarianism a bit more?
- southerntofu 5y agoI think the parent refers to different cultural understandings of "libertarianism". In most of the world, libertarian ideology is anarcho-communism whereas in the USA (and in the startup world globally) libertarian designates so-called "anarcho-capitalism". There is some ideological overlap as both branches advocate against centralized powers. The key difference is in regards to private property: the idea that something can be owned by someone who does not make use of it (i.e. not a personal possession such as your residence) is denounced by anarchists as a way to deprive people/communities from their resources for the profits of a few ("property is theft") whereas libertarians consider that a "natural right". Still, as Noam Chomsky (and others) pointed out, the anarcho-capitalist clique from Silicon Valley always relied on major grants from the State and how you would prevent the people from accessing the resources they produced because they're "owned" by someone else without central powers remains a mystery. Libertarians are well-known for dreaming of employing people to work for them and amassing wealth, but i have yet to meet a libertarian who wants to be the lowly exploited worker. Meanwhile in the anarchist world, we abide by the principles of "from each according to their capabilities, to each according to their needs". Gathering consent and sharing tasks is notably easier when we're doing it for ourselves and not for the profit of someone else.
- dado3212 5y ago> Miraculously the Internet Consensus is always the same both before and after these kinds of events. In engineering we call this a "non-causal system" because the outputs are produced before the inputs. So funny.
- Snetry 5y ago> As a result, they started a nonprofit organization to rewrite all of Unix, which the printer did not run and which therefore would not solve any of the original problem, but was a pretty cool project nonetheless and was much more fun than the original problem, and the rest was history. That is an incredibly bad retelling of the GNU story
- sja 5y agoI interpreted this bit as intentionally reductive for the sake of humor. And I thought it was funny!
- Snetry 5y agookay after a reading it a few times I can see how it could be considered tongue in cheek I'll give it that
- rfrey 5y agoThis article was not about retelling the GNU story. Think of that sentence as a cultural reference, not an explanatory history.
- Snetry 5y agookay but even then it botches it
- shadowgovt 5y agoAs with most legends, it left out the details but got the crux of the situation right.
- badsectoracula 5y agoThe crux of the situation was that RMS started GNU because he realized that not having access to the printer's source code put whoever had access to it in a position of power over his use of the printer and the implications that has when extended to other aspects where software is concerned and will be concerned with as computer use increases. This was not mentioned at all in the blog post.
- mherdeg 5y agoHmm, re: > how startups tend to go bankrupt and their tech dies with them I have this mental model, which may not be entirely accurate, that the original Iridium corporation successfully launched satellites into orbit, erased the multi-billion dollar costs of the launch using bankruptcy, and then handed over control to a successor corporation who inherited control of the constellation but none of the startup costs. Do I have the story right? Is there any other example like this where a failed company manages to leave us with something useful while its immense costs were just … evaporated?
- CommieBobDole 5y agoThat's roughly true, but it's sort of a special case; as I recall it, the US Department of Defense had come to depend on Iridium and didn't want to lose service, so they facilitated the orderly bankruptcy and re-emergence of the company, in part by offering an enormous multi-year contract to the successor company.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kingcharles 5y agoDo things like Tumblr and Skype count? Where a legacy Internet behemoth mistakenly clicks "Buy It Now" on a startup for eleventy billion dollars during some drug-and-drink fueled bender and then wakes up the next day and offloads it to some rando on Twitter for whatever they have lying around in their PayPal balance.
- neilparikh 5y agoIt's funny, I think Yahoo has done this twice now: once with Tumblr and once with Delicious (although the chain of ownership for Delicious is much longer).
- kingcharles 5y agoYes, I forgot about Delicious. Yahoo destroyed both of those companies. Unbelievably all the Delicious data is still available. Delicious was one of the only accounts I could log into after eight years in jail. It was amazing to see that 99% of my bookmarks were dead links.
- tarsiec 5y ago“Everything I don’t like is communism!”
- zaphar 5y agoThat isn't even close to what the author wrote. The "quote" reflects nothing of substance from the article.
- adamgordonbell 5y agoThere is a book, called 'The Gift: How the Creative Spirit Transforms the World' that is popular in author circles. It's about the gift economy and how it's different than capitalism and how creative endeavours are really part of the gift economy, not the cash economy proper. I honestly got a bit bored of reading it and stopped, but the idea stays with me. This essay captures some of that idea - why you can't pay for a gift, how gifts work differently. They are a form of capital in that gift givers get social credit or something, but it's a very different system, a more traditional one than capitalism.
- ignoramous 5y agoDoes the book talk about one among the dangling questions the author posed but didn't answer: how simultaneously, whole promising branches of the "gift economy" structure have never been explored.?
- jboynyc 5y agoYou might have more fun reading Marcel Mauss' classic, also called The Gift, on the structure and function of gift exchange across various societies.
- gowld 5y ago"gift economy" is also the model underpinning Free Software.
- throwaway4aday 5y agoIt's also the model underpinning bribery. It's multi-purpose.