11 ms·
It’s cheaper to stop emitting now than to pull carbon from the air later
- AlexanderDhoore 5y agoPhysically it will require more energy to extract carbon from the air later. But "cost" is a funny, human construct. We just don't know how much it will cost, because we don't have carbon capture at scale yet. As with everything in economics this is just guessing about the future.
- throwaway894345 5y agoRight, but we shouldn’t recklessly pollute on the basis that we don’t know for certain that it will bite us in the ass later. Banking on technological advancements so we don’t have to reform our energy sector and make our various manufacturing and shipping networks efficient is pretty foolish.
- Jeff_Brown 5y agoThat's not all economists do! We also guess about the past and present.
- netizen-936824 5y agoSelf awareness is a good thing to have!
- lozenge 5y agoThermodynamics gives a good idea. You need to pull a huge amount of air through your machine to get some carbon out of it. "At present there are no proven technologies capable of large-scale air capture of CO2. It has been suggested that, with strong research and development support and industrial scale pilot projects sustained over decades, costs as low as ∼$500/tC may be achievable [226]. Thermodynamic constraints [227] suggest that this cost estimate may be low. An assessment by the American Physical Society [228] argues that the lowest currently achievable cost, using existing approaches, is much greater ($600/tCO2 or $2200/tC)." https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0081648#s6 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- bko 5y agoThe article doesn't go into specifics as to the cost of removing carbon. I imagine those costs will drop as technology approves, but the model may assume that. There's also a cost of reduction that's not factored into most model, the cost of coordination. A model can just say "suppose every country restricts their carbon emissions to X%" but that would require a lot of coordination and implications on state sovereignty that aren't factored in. There's also the enforcement and game theory aspects that would have to be addressed. > “Betting on being able to bring temperatures down after a larger overshoot is very risky because of the uncertain technological feasibility and because of the possibility of setting off irreversible processes in the earth system with even a temporary temperature overshoot,” wrote second author Christoph Bertram, of the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research in Germany, in an email to Ars Technica. “Furthermore, such an approach would be unfair to future generations, as it basically would shift more of the mitigation burden on them.” Future generations are likely to be much wealthier than ours. Imagine your great grandparents saving their pennies to buy a nice set of doilys to pass down to you?
- rich_sasha 5y agoThere is also an implicit assumption that we will have more abundant green energy - renewables, born again nuclear, fusion etc. The "cost" is largely driven by cost of non-fossil-fuel energy.
- pydry 5y ago>The article doesn't go into specifics as to the cost of removing carbon. I imagine those costs will drop as technology approves I'm skeptical any tech would go below the price of simply planting trees or growing algae.
- Jeff_Brown 5y agoHard to imagine cheaper than planting trees -- but turning atmospheric carbon into rock takes it out of circulation permanently, and with effectively no space constraint.
- 5y ago
- globular-toast 5y ago
- rc_mob 5y agoYou must really hate your grandkids.
- netizen-936824 5y agoSadly some people seem to give zero shits about anyone or anything that isn't them or isn't benefiting them directly. Not sure if this is a US ideology or what, but it definitely seems to be a prevalent view in the states
- iso1631 5y agoIronically I find this view weighted far more to those who claim to be Christian
- netizen-936824 5y agoReligions are great for making people feel special. Also great for creating in/out groups for easy discrimination too!
- globular-toast 5y agoAs a wise man once said, if you want to know what people believe, watch what they do not what they say.
- globular-toast 5y agoI was worried that people would take my comment literally. I consider it a sad sign of the times that anyone could think I was serious.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoYou post literally what the prevailing attitude has been for the past 50 years, claim to wonder why anyone takes you seriously, then say "just a prank, bro?"
- deepfriedbits 5y agoSure. It is presently.
- tonetheman 5y agoNone of it matters really. We cannot get even the most basic thing done in our own country (wear a mask to protect yourself and the people around you). Any vision of cooperation in the future must factor in some of the insanity we have seen over the last few years. And my words and views are only from inside the US. Imagine having to get everyone on the globe to agree to something. I am certain there are large groups of crazies in every country who think this is god's plan or just want everything to burn for their own reasons. Maybe if there are some Hollywood sized extinction events that can be traced back to climate change. But even then you will get large groups of people claiming it did not happen. Or was caused by some race. Or will claim Bill Gates caused climate change. What I am really saying is cooperation inside of a supposed group of United States is currently impossible. Now do that across the globe. If we have to act now in unison to save ourselves we are in fact doomed.
- sokoloff 5y agoI see a lot of mask wearing where it’s legally mandated. I see limited mask wearing where it’s not required. Neither of those is surprising, of course. That seems like it’s compatible with a framework for atmospheric carbon reduction. I think the challenges are mostly economic and technical, not societal.
- pclmulqdq 5y agoIn New York City, I have been seeing decreased compliance with mask mandates as the pandemic has gone on. It really seems like people have limited capacity to comply with unpleasant rules. Carbon rules may end up in the same category, with rampant noncompliance.
- sokoloff 5y agoCarbon charges could reasonably be applied at the supply chain level, making compliance closer to sales tax compliance than to voluntary action.
- tonetheman 5y ago
- wombatmobile 5y ago> What will it cost if the climate exceeds the Paris Agreement temperature goals this century—even if we later remove carbon dioxide from the air and manage to bring temperatures back down to meet those targets by 2100? And how does that compare with the costs of staying below those targets? Those questions may be good ones for people who are concerned about climate change, but who is going to be persuaded to take action by the argument they induce? To be persuasive to consumers now, a cost comparison has to appeal to the consumer's hip pocket right now. More like one of these format: Are you paying too much for gas? Click to save 25% on your next tank. Save 47% on home heating costs this winter. Send your kids to college with the money you save over the lifetime of your next car. It's difficult to do in the context of the article but that's what's required to change behaviour. Well, it isn't the only thing that's required. What is also required is the alternative energy products to be available to consumers at attractive prices. How do we make that happen? As an ordinary person who pays for energy but isn't an energy scientist, I don't know. That's why I'm still spending $700 a month on fossil fuels. But give me a way and I'll click on it.
- andreilys 5y agoThere’s also the moral hazard problem. Yes it’ll be more expensive to remove carbon dioxide from the air in the future but i will be dead by then, so why do I care? Also this moral hazard is made worst by decision makers whose financial outcomes are tied to not adopting extreme climate measures. Especially those without children, taking the long view of society seems to be very difficult.
- Biologist123 5y agoWe know people are concerned about what happens to their families after they die as inheritance taxes are so unpopular!
- actually_a_dog 5y agoInheritance taxes only apply to rich people. So, at best, that tells you rich people care about what happens to their descendents. Do you have any evidence rich people care about the descendents of poor people?
- ianai 5y agoThe laws of thermodynamics mean we'll have to expend at least as much energy removing CO2 as we did emissing it initially. Right now, from what google searching I've done, the best option would be planting the fastest growing bamboo species and sequestering them once cut down. The sequestering is 'tough', but I suspect more surmountable via a range of means than other carbon removal strategies. Anything else is a poor approximation of a tree.
- homo_nullius 5y agoRegular forests work just fine, and we have been doing logging for a while so sequestration is not a problem. We just need to do it more, and selectively, not cutting down everything at once.
- frankbreetz 5y agoThe laws of thermodynamics doesn't take into account the assumption that future energy production is cheaper then today's. If there is a change in energy production like a breakthrough in fusion or an over production of renewables, it is at least theoretically possible that would be cheaper to remove then to not emit
- ianai 5y agoRight. The costs of future production have to be less than they were in the past or it’s even worse. Regardless though it represents a huge transfer of wealth from the future to the past.
- nradov 5y agoEven if we get working fusion power the laws of thermodynamics tell us that it's not going to be much cheaper than current fission power. The heat will be generated in a different way but the process for using that heat to boil water and spin a turbine will be basically the same. That means huge capital investments and then constant maintenance to keep everything running.
- twobitshifter 5y ago
- thisistheend123 5y agoThis is going to be very difficult. But we should be able to do it if all of us thought real hard about it. Think of how to remove CO2 most efficiently from the air. Then scale to global while keeping it cheap. Then get all the world citizens involved. We can have movies, concerts, video games, political campaigns, social media campaigns, support from big tech like Apple, Alphabet, Amazon. Then when all the world citizens will come together and they will push together, this will be achievable and we will win the race against time and humanity will survive and thrive. It is not impossible. Because impossible means i m possible.
- libertine 5y ago> Then get all the world citizens involved. We can have movies, concerts, video games, political campaigns, social media campaigns, support from big tech like Apple, Alphabet, Amazon. The problem here is that we will, once again, ask developing nations to also pull the weight and pay the cost that allowed developed countries to reach their current position.
- inglor_cz 5y agoWhy is it a problem? They are people too and they too contribute to climate change. I can understand reducing the demands on them appropriately, but letting them off the hook completely does not really make sense to me. At the end of the day, you do not want to create any totally exempted zones (carbon tax paradises?), because that is where the polluting industry will move if having the opportunity to do so.
- libertine 5y agoThe problem if there's a cost to it, and you make it sound like we're all going to pay the same. Developed nations should pay way more than others if you want to make it right. Such paradises would only exist if we allowed them to exist. The same goes to tax heavens, we just opt to let them exist.
- zaphar 5y ago
- ehnto 5y agoIt was cheaper to stop emitting ten, twenty, thirty years ago, but capitalism can't see very far ahead. People are making too much money still, and societies are too slow to change without immediate incentives. Whether it's cheaper or not is irrelevant if we are incapable of action, so, we'll have to pull it out of the air anyway.
- c7DJTLrn 5y agoPlease, let's stop being silly and start being realistic. We aren't going to meet the lofty emissions targets or pull GHGs from the atmosphere. It's just not viable. Even if we halted emissions completely today it wouldn't be enough. Let's think about what we're actually trying to prevent. Mainly heatwaves and natural disasters. We could use geoengineering to try to reduce the impact of such disasters, build things with resiliency, and relocate people from disaster zones as a start. The vulnerable land can be repurposed for crops. This would be by far the cheapest option.
- dcolkitt 5y agoExactly. Stratospheric aerosol injections are ready to roll today. They're extremely well understood because we have so many historical records of natural volcano eruptions lowering global temperatures. The technology is already mature. The cost is dirt cheap. On the order of $10 billion/year to completely neutralize all warming since the industrial revolution. Are stratospheric aerosols perfect? No, of course not. There's still peripheral issues associated with ocean acidification. It's also not a permanent solution, since the aerosols have to be refreshed every year. But the tech solves 90%+ of the issues with climate change instantly. It also requires no global coordination that's been the perennial issue with emissions reductions. It's cheap enough that even a mid-sized military could unilaterally undertake it. There's absolutely zero reason that we shouldn't start a pilot program today. Start testing at small doses equivalent to 0.1 C temperature reduction, then scale up quickly over the next 10 years.
- qayxc 5y ago> There's absolutely zero reason that we shouldn't start a pilot program today. Famous last words? It's funny how armchair climatologists claim to know the solutions for problems that aren't even fully understood...
- thereddaikon 5y agoWhile actual climatologists advocate for programs that require an unprecedented level of societal and governmental cooperation? Seems to me a partially proven out technology technology that can be done unilaterally is more feasible than a a cooperative initiate that to this point has zero success. Hell, China has slid back on CFC's, something that was supposed to be solved in the 80's. International cooperation is a pipe dream. Global politics are zero sum game and always will be.
- wazoox 5y agoYou want to figure out the climate problem? Think of climate rise as your body's temperature rising: when you're 1°C over normal, you're sick but that's manageable. When you're at +2°C you're really sick; 4°C over normal your life is at stake. Or think about this: 20000 years ago, Scandinavia, Canada were under 2 or 3 km of ice (like Greenland today). The oceans were 120 meters lower than today. Most of today's temperate countries (Europe, USA, China) were a cold tundra with reindeer, wholly rhinos, bison and mammoths, cave bears and cave lions. In these harsh conditions, only a few hundred thousand humans could scrape by; and the average globe temperature was only 4 to 5°C lower than in 1850 (let that sink in). The 4°C temperature rise that brought us the neolithic revolution, agriculture and the first population explosion, was a 4000 years affair. Now we're talking of bringing a similar change over the course of 100 years, on a crowded planet of 8 billion people. The question isn't "what could go wrong?" at this point, but can we imagine ways out of a looming catastrophe?
- lexapro 5y agoHow is that "figuring out the climate problem"? You're just stating the problem.
- wazoox 5y agoFiguring out the magnitude of what's coming. Almost everyone still seems to believe that "2°C, who cares, I'll just wear a lighter jacket" or something like that.
- y4mi 5y agoI'm so glad I'm already in my thirties. I'll be dead by the time the shit will really start to hit the fan. I'm pretty sure that people of the future will consider the time between 1950-2050 century to be the golden age of our current Civilization. There are so many basically unsolvable issues on the horizon that I see absolutely no chance that our society will survive in it's current form. My bet would be that we'll devolve into another form of aristocracy as soon as AI/automation make a human workforce mostly redundant. Technological progress is likely going to stagnate entirely at that point, we all know how rich people generally behave without outside forces...
- jlangenauer 5y agoIt's cheaper from the point of view of entire societies, or the planet. But it's much more expensive from the point of view of a company to stop emitting now, compared to having someone else in the future pay to pull carbon from the air.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoIt might be cheaper in the present, but we’re richer in the future, and can afford more, because we have invested the savings in the meantime. Article fails to mention discount rates and like assumptions, so I am unable to compare and determine which trend is more powerful. Maybe the paper is better? > We find that discount rates of less than about 2% would make the perceived cumulative costs of most 1.5 and 2 °C scenarios overall less costly without overshoot (see Fig. 2c for the cumulative GDP losses and Supplementary Fig. 1.1-13 for the net present value (NPV) of the carbon price). Assuming higher discount rates on the other hand would favour relatively delayed mitigation with overshoot. Wow!!! 2% is pretty damn low in terms of discount rate assumptions. Contrary to the article, this paper would advocate against immediate action unless you hold some pretty extreme assumptions. Typical values for the discount rate are more like 3-5% in developed countries, and they can be especially high (like 7-15%) in developing countries. (The overall merit of intervention now vs later in reality, and not just in this paper, is left as an exercise to others.)
- hackeraccount 5y agoCame here for this.
- fuzzfactor 5y ago>It’s cheaper to stop emitting now than to pull carbon from the air later I thought this was one of the reasons Carl Sagan stepped up in the 1980's to try and make things like this understandable to non-scientists.
- johnklos 5y agoYes, but this neatly ignores the reason this can't work: to WHOM does it cost more? The polluters make money now. I bet many are even planning how they'll make money from the damage they're causing. Later costs borne by governments of the world are a potential benefit, not any sort of disincentive at all. So long as politicians are bought and sold, and so long as capitalism is allowed to run full speed ahead with no regulation, the whole planet will be victim to today's greediness.
- sempron64 5y agoThe article is totally unconvincing. It estimates 2% higher GDP in 80 years, with initial effects in 50 years. 2% over 80 years is ridiculously low ROI, spending money on literally any other kind of infrastructure will have better returns. That's disregarding that it's a very long term economic prediction, which makes it ridiculously unlikely to be correct.
- andrewgleave 5y agoNo one knows what technology will be created that will have an impact on the severity and costs of climate change. Much better to make progress as fast as possible with research and scientific progress than diverting time and resources to endeavours that will only marginally slow down the pending catastrophe and have the side effect of slowing progress toward solutions that actually solve the underlying problem (dependence on fossil fuels). The only way out is by increasing our knowledge so we can actually solve the problem. The other way is parochialism and staticity.
- Mildlypolite 5y agoDo you, at least, know why the Paris agreement set the limit at 1.5 degrees? Because over 1.5° we will hit points of non return and feedback loops like the permafrost one. There is no coming back after that, we are talking about a food crisis. We are talking about parts of the earth which won't be possible to cultivate. https://youtu.be/1BDmIis9STE https://youtu.be/1BDmIis9STE Reading the comments here is like being on the "don't look up" set, and it's not funny. Google feedback loops permafrost,please.
- freemint 5y agoI have found nothing so far which convinces me that below 1.5°C rather than below 2.4°C protects us any more or less from positive feedback loops. There seems to be a lot frightening going around with regards to tipping points into positive feedback loops however if those exist and are so bad how comes that climate models don't show those and rather show that it is possible to reach equilibrium over 2°C?
- radu_floricica 5y agoIt's below HN to state something so significant, and offer a youtube link as a source. Or it used to be.
- zaroth 5y agoThe excessive focus on carbon will eventually need to change. The problem is average surface temperature, to which atmospheric carbon levels are only one of many drivers. The most important driver of surface temperature is TSI. [1]. TSI can be economically moderated, as-needed, to cool the Earth. [2] If we (as in Humans) ever decide we truly need to do such a thing, we can have all the infrastructure in place within a decade and for merely a few trillion dollars. Perfectly reasonable for all the carbon to be left in the atmosphere when you control TSI directly through refracting a small percentage (e.g. 0.1%) of TSI by launching moon dust at L2. People don’t want to admit it’s a relatively* easily solved technological problem, because then the social moderation aspect becomes less existential. [1] - https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/Glory/solar_irradiance/total_solar_irradiance.html https://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/Glory/solar_irradiance/to... [2] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24933161 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24933161 * Relative to mediating the CO2 output of every country / every human on the planet
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- parkingrift 5y agoThe book “Termination Shock” covered the topic of aerosols in the stratosphere to reduce temperature while we work on actually improving the climate. The book itself is a decent read, but the science behind the premise is surprisingly well researched and understood. https://www.wired.com/2008/06/ff-geoengineering/ https://www.wired.com/2008/06/ff-geoengineering/ One of the unspoken critiques in the book is that “climate activists” will shun good solutions in favor of a perfect solution, even if the perfect solution is impossible to achieve. Reading the comments here it seems this particular bit of fiction is already playing out in reality. Can we… organize the governments of the entire world to work toward a singular goal? A goal that will cost a hundred trillion dollars? A goal that we’ve been trying to achieve for decades with virtually zero success? Or… spend $10B per year on geoengineering. We’re approaching the supposed runaway climate temperature. Shall we act now and do what we can while we wait for technology to advance? Or shall we doom humanity to an uncertain future by refusing to adopt trivially cheap mitigation options?