14 ms·
Italian Courts Find Open Source Software Terms Enforceable
- CRConrad 5y ago> [The court ordered] that they publish an excerpt of the order on a page of their website, as well as a reference on the site’s home page that’s displayed in double the normal character size of the site. It's there on the front page, but the headline certainly isn't double the size of the rest of their (obnoxiously large) headlines -- it's far smaller than the rest. Also, it is (of course!) buried at the very bottom of the front page -- and since that's one of those "modern Web design" eternal-doomscroll pages, I bet 99% of visitors to the site won't even see it, because who can be bothered to scroll all the way to the bottom of those?
- sofixa 5y agoThat's great news, and the fine is pretty decent!
- stavros 5y agoExcellent, I find both the ruling and the fine reasonable. It wasn't disproportionately heavy, but will make people think twice before violating the GPL.
- pitched 5y agoAt 100$/day (or 300 after the first 15 days), I wonder how large the app has to be before violating the GPL won’t bother them anymore? I can see a medium-sized business just treating this as a rent/cost-of-business instead of a fine.
- pietrovismara 5y agoAs always, if a fine is only a fixed amount it becomes just a regular transaction for the rich. Ideally the amount would scale with your size/wealth.
- josephcsible 5y agoThat violates the principle of equality before the law. What if instead, the fine started at $100 but grew at 5% per day? Then even the biggest companies wouldn't be able to afford to just keep paying it.
- piaste 5y agoEquality before the law applies to citizens, not to bank accounts. Take a broader view.
- vincnetas 5y agoWell, if you fine certain percent of income, so everyone will be treated equally by law. x% of income where x is same for tiny company or mega corp. So principle of equality is not violated.
- usr1106 5y agoThat's incorrect. If you fined some super rich with 90% of their income they could still live a comfortable life . If you fined normal mortals or poor with 90% of their income they would lose their apartment and could not buy enough food anymore.
- vidarh 5y agoTrue, but as an illustration of why "equal" is not objective the above works. To talk about real equality we first need to define what we mean. And certainly, a percentage will also not deliver equal effect.
- pietrovismara 5y ago> That violates the principle of equality before the law Quite the opposite. It would restore equality in the punishment, as it should hurt the same to the offender no matter how wealthy they are. As it is now, we're favoring the rich overwhelmingly.
- cbg0 5y agoNot a lawyer, but based on the last paragraphs of the press release here: https://www.dynamic.ooo/press/groundbreaking-acknowledgment-of-free-software-in-italy/# https://www.dynamic.ooo/press/groundbreaking-acknowledgment-... it seems that they have been ordered to comply within 7 days, so going over that would probably mean that they would also be in violation of a court order, along with the fines.
- seoaeu 5y agoSeems like the amount was decided by the court. Presumably they would have just levied a larger fine if it was a business that might plausibly just ignore the order and keep infringing on the license
- monocasa 5y agoYeah, the courts generally ramp up non-compliance damages like that with continued non-compliance.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoIf they don't care about money, why not license the code from the author?
- fguerraz 5y agoUnlike in the US, in Europe we don't have the concept of punitive damages. Claimants will only ever get, at most, a compensation for the losses they can prove they have had and fines go to the state, not the claimant.
- phkahler 5y agoSomehow I dont believe that. So copyright infringement is just treated as lost revenue? I thought the music and film industries got you too.
- futharkshill 5y agomaybe, maybe not. The EU is not a single country.
- chottocharaii 5y agowhat they said is likely misleading. punitive damages can come substantively in differing forms and guises
- martin8412 5y agoUnless you sell/distribute pirated materials, yes. If you download pirated material from a random https mirror, then all they can come for you for is the lost revenue. If you use torrents it gets more difficult since you're seeding the material
- Dylan16807 5y agoAs far as I understand that's how the US works too. Penalties only for distributing is quite different from no penalties at all.
- Retric 5y agoThis is false. https://www.pinsentmasons.com/out-law/news/punitive-damages-for-ip-infringements-can-be-provided-for-by-eu-countries-rules-eu-court https://www.pinsentmasons.com/out-law/news/punitive-damages-... Punitive damages in terms of IP are allowed in the EU, but up to individual member states. Ireland and Cyprus currently allow punitive damages as did the UK did when it was a member.
- Hamuko 5y agoDo you have evidence that the fine is fixed regardless of the company size? Because the company in question here is a single employee shop according to D&B Business Directory. https://www.dnb.com/business-directory/company-profiles.nerds_farm_srl.9e76b3eeeb212efd8b3d5769f6f6df8f.html https://www.dnb.com/business-directory/company-profiles.nerd...
- snovv_crash 5y agoNote, the degree of the infringement would be considered in any future case. A more serious usage, and more commercial leverage of it, would likely result in higher fines. Courts take a dim view of companies taking the fines as a "cost of business" rather than a deterrent.
- 14 5y agoBack just before marijuana was made legal here in Canada a number of Pot shops opened up. The city and police mostly did nothing but decided they would make some by-laws to make sure certain things were in place and it wasn't just people running it out of their houses. One such requirement was that each shop had a front business window into the shop. A guy I knew who had leased a place and set up shop did not have such a window just a door. The city made the rules after he had set up shop so he was not happy and did not want to move his business. So he ignored the requirement until city by-law officers showed up to enforce it. They gave him a $150 a day fine for not complying. He just shrugged it off and counted it a part of doing business since he was making thousands a day.
- mcguire 5y agoIs the rule still in place? Is he still ignoring it? Code enforcement people aren't stupid. They can and likely would escalate in that sort of situation.
- kergonath 5y agoDepending on the jurisdiction you can sue later if they don’t comply. Then they would be in contempt, which involves much more severe sentences than a €100/day fine.
- eddieh 5y agoThe corollary: reasonable people avoid GPL code at all costs.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BenjiWiebe 5y agoIt's not that hard to comply with the GPL.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sharpneli 5y agoIt would have been weird if they had been unenforceable. As that would mean there is no license to use it at all. And copyright law generally doesn’t work so that if you don’t have a license you are free to do whatever. It’s the opposite. No license, no use whatsoever.
- smoldesu 5y agoI agree. There's a lot of buzz about how "it's never been proven in court" and all that, but open source software licensing is so cut and dried at this point that it just ends up sounding silly. If having a license.md file in your source code isn't enforceable, then how do multi-billion dollar apps get away with hiding their terms of use behind several clicks and thousands of lines of incomprehensible legal jargon? It would certainly be fun to watch Big Tech hire their gold-medal mental gymnasts to fight it in court, if nothing else.
- Hamuko 5y agoThere are probably thousands of terms of service agreements that are not legally binding in the EU. https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/unfair-treatment/unfair-contract-terms/index_en.htm https://europa.eu/youreurope/citizens/consumers/unfair-treat... For example, in 2012 the Court of Justice of the European Union declared that reselling digital software is legal no matter what any EULA attached to the software might say. https://www.engadget.com/2012-07-03-eu-court-rules-its-legal-to-resell-digital-games-software.html https://www.engadget.com/2012-07-03-eu-court-rules-its-legal...
- jeroenhd 5y agoThat doesn't make the terms and agreements any less binding, though. Parts of them are bullshit and ignored, but the other parts are still valid. Only the parts of the agreement that violate the local laws can be ignored.
- luckylion 5y agoWouldn't that only (reliably) be the case if they contain a severability clause stating that, if any clause is found to be invalid, the rest of the license agreement shall remain valid? After all, you're typically agreeing to a package, not individually to each term.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoIt's not that if you are a company you can download a car
- vincnetas 5y agoIf you don't know what "downloading a car" is referring to : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HmZm8vNHBSU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HmZm8vNHBSU
- lnxg33k1 5y agoAh it was steal a car, what a pity :D
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- iso1210 5y agoOf course I know what it is, because I took my perfectly legal DVD of a film that I spent money on a few years ago and popped it in my player, and it forced me to watch it. I then went onto piratebay to get a copy of the film without it. It's ridiculous showing such an advert to people who have already given you money, I have no idea what was going through their heads. (It's been many years since I bought a DVD. I stopped buying family guy seasons because of that type of behaviour. Yes I could rip the dvd and remove it, but then that's illegal, so I may as well go the whole hog.
- lnxg33k1 5y agoDon't forget that in the current society you're guilty until proven innocent
- riffraff 5y agoI prefer the one from "The IT Crowd": https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALZZx1xmAzg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ALZZx1xmAzg
- 5y ago
- luckylion 5y agoI'm sure there will be a few people here that are much more knowledgeable than me in all things licenses and GPL, so if I may: WordPress states the opinion [1] (I'm not aware of changes on that claim) that the PHP code in themes and plugins are derivative works of WP and therefore must be GPL (or compatible) because the PHP parts of themes/plugins are "combined" with the rest of WP at run time. Is that (still) a common opinion on the matter? Has it been tested in court? [1] https://wordpress.org/news/2009/07/themes-are-gpl-too/ https://wordpress.org/news/2009/07/themes-are-gpl-too/
- sokoloff 5y agoThis seems analogous to the readline/editline issue (which I think has not been tested in court either, but I’d be fairly surprised if rms’s position [that optionally linking to readline means your work must be released under GPL] would be sustained.) If it mattered to me, I’d have a close look at the recent Java API case and see if that gave guidance in the direction that a generic (but functional) Wordpress theme that was engineered from the ground up without copying Wordpress GPL code would be in the clear legally. I’m not a lawyer, but I’d be betting in that direction.
- luckylion 5y agoThank you, the Java API case is a good hint.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoThe combined ball of WP and a plugin might be GPL, but that's not how it's distributed, is it? A plugin separate from WP is unrelated to WP except for API.
- mikejulietbravo 5y agoI think the large news here is that there haven’t been many rulings. And for the companies like mongo and elastic that have changed their licenses, this likely gives them more teeth
- gjsman-1000 5y agoJust because a license says something doesn't make it enforceable - though, thankfully, the GPL was found fully enforceable in this case. Something to ponder though is whether an open-source license could, potentially have unenforceable clauses on it. I think it's unlikely, but if a part of a major open-source license was found unenforceable (i.e. the definitions of networking in AGPLv3?) the open-source ecosystem would be thrown for a loop. So much of the open-source ecosystem (and it's contributions!) rely on the licenses being valid legally. I would just say that there are some licenses (AGPLv3 in particular) that are so long and verbose there's bound to be something that could be twisted into unenforceability.
- mcguire 5y agoCertainly there could be unenforceable clauses---one Fortran compiler I ran across years ago had a clause saying it couldn't be used for "military purposes". That would be so vague I can't see it being enforced. (It also makes it not Open Source, so there's that, though.)
- adrr 5y agoCopyright licenses aren’t EULAs. You can’t tell an end user of the software how to use the copyrighted art. It only affects distribution where copyright law operates. If I don’t distribute the software, i don’t need to abide by a copyright license. It also only covers the person doing the distribution.
- foxfluff 5y agoDepends on jurisdiction. In EU some goof decided that the transient copy/copies your computer makes to run software constitutes copying, and therefore you must have a license to use software.
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoOpen source licenses restrict themselves to distribution, but it's not the only thing possible. Distribution is you getting a copy, if you don't comply with the license, you return your copy to the author.
- bdowling 5y agoNote that the court ordered the defendants to comply by removing the GPL code from their product, not to comply by publishing their source code. [0] [0] https://www.dynamic.ooo/press/groundbreaking-acknowledgment-of-free-software-in-italy/# https://www.dynamic.ooo/press/groundbreaking-acknowledgment-... Edit: Link changed to press release w/ copy of court's order.
- hannasanarion 5y agoT̶h̶a̶t̶'̶s̶ ̶n̶o̶t̶ ̶t̶r̶u̶e̶.̶ ̶Y̶o̶u̶r̶ ̶o̶w̶n̶ ̶l̶i̶n̶k̶ ̶c̶o̶n̶t̶r̶a̶d̶i̶c̶t̶s̶ ̶i̶t̶.̶ ̶T̶h̶e̶y̶ ̶a̶r̶e̶ ̶o̶r̶d̶e̶r̶e̶d̶ ̶t̶o̶ ̶"̶b̶r̶i̶n̶g̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶s̶o̶f̶t̶w̶a̶r̶e̶ ̶i̶n̶ ̶c̶o̶m̶p̶l̶i̶a̶n̶c̶e̶ ̶w̶i̶t̶h̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶l̶i̶c̶e̶n̶s̶e̶"̶.̶ ̶T̶h̶e̶y̶ ̶c̶a̶n̶ ̶d̶o̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶t̶ ̶b̶y̶ ̶r̶e̶m̶o̶v̶i̶n̶g̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶G̶P̶L̶ ̶c̶o̶m̶p̶o̶n̶e̶n̶t̶s̶,̶ ̶o̶r̶ ̶b̶y̶ ̶a̶d̶d̶i̶n̶g̶ ̶t̶h̶e̶ ̶a̶c̶k̶n̶o̶w̶l̶e̶d̶g̶e̶m̶e̶n̶t̶s̶ ̶t̶h̶a̶t̶ ̶G̶P̶L̶ ̶r̶e̶q̶u̶i̶r̶e̶s̶.̶ Don't mind me, just being a dummy :)
- bdowling 5y agoThanks. A statement of the court's order was included in the "press release" link, not the link I originally posted. Link updated. > The Judge, considering the articles 156 I.d.a. and 700 c.p.c., > Orders the defendants (Marco Poglie, Francesco Pesce and Nerds Farm Srl) to cease any use made available to the public, as well as any publications, of the software named E-addons for Elementor, if not after having eliminated every recurrence (exception made for a maximum amount of 500 lines) of the code included in the 1.9.5.2 version of Dynamic Content for Elementor, sub doc.2 produced by the Applicant, within seven days of the communication of this provision. https://www.dynamic.ooo/press/groundbreaking-acknowledgment-of-free-software-in-italy/# https://www.dynamic.ooo/press/groundbreaking-acknowledgment-...
- edoceo 5y agoI don't understand the exception. Like less than 500 line chunks of GPL can stay? Or only chunks that are 500 or less must be removed in the time allowed?
- iso1210 5y agoThat's ridiculous. If the GPL weren't valid, then you have no right to copy the code under normal copyright law and the Berne Convention, and thus you're breaking the law. In the US I believe the charge tends to be somewhere in the $150k per copy, so if you use a GPL, don't agree to the license, and sell 1,000 copies of your sofwtare, you're simply distributing "pirate software", and should be on the hook for a $150m fine. I don't know if Italy has similar statutory damages
- gjs278 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- alpb 5y agoThe site has failed under the load from HN. Here's a mirror http://web.archive.org/web/20211224205455/http://ifthisbetreason.com/2021/12/italian-courts-find-open-source-software-terms-enforceable/ http://web.archive.org/web/20211224205455/http://ifthisbetre...
- YPPH 5y agoI suspected the hug of death would cause this site to fall over. Right after it was posted I linked an archive link [0]. However I started getting downvoted so I deleted my comment. Not sure what was wrong with doing that. [0] http://web.archive.org/web/20211227162115/http://ifthisbetreason.com/2021/12/italian-courts-find-open-source-software-terms-enforceable/ http://web.archive.org/web/20211227162115/http://ifthisbetre...
- mitchtbaum 5y agohttps://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http://ifthisbetreason.com/2021/12/italian-courts-find-open-source-software-terms-enforceable/ https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:http:/... archive.md also shows bandwidth limit exceeded version
- timnetworks 5y agoThe person or people running that website are a tad obsessed with a certain somebody.