12 ms·
The Last Soviet Generation
- uwagar 5y agothere's so much literature about soviet people desiring democracy and the 'colorful' west. is there literature where the soviet people were happy with their lot in the soviet union?
- kome 5y agothey don't fit the narrative... happy people are boring news. Read Branko Milanovic take about Yugoslavia: "How I lost my past" https://glineq.blogspot.com/2017/09/how-i-lost-my-past.html https://glineq.blogspot.com/2017/09/how-i-lost-my-past.html
- uwagar 5y agonice! give me more please!
- dredmorbius 5y agoI was going to encourage you to submit that. No need, I see: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29680492 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29680492 (Great essay.)
- mc32 5y agoThe article mentions that the parents of the kids who grew up during the transition period were conservative and compliant and didn't make a fuss. They knew the system was not great, but for them, it was what it was. There wasn't much to do but get on with life. The kids were different, they began to have access to cartoons and other cultural experiences from the West and began to question why they had to make do with so little (during Brezhnev's time, GDP went into guns and away from butter). In any event, why should people feel happy about living under an oppressive system -a system which stunted their potential? Their "police" were soviet milicija, so in a way they lived under occupation to booot.
- twelve40 5y ago> during Brezhnev's time, GDP went into guns and away from butter The peak of shortages happened not during Brezhnev but in the 80's during Gorby's rule. > a system which stunted their potential Did launch man in space somehow. Plenty of people realized their potential.
- mc32 5y agoStores had cigs, vodka, butter and milk and tubers (awesome!!) And so you stunt the growth not only of Russians but many other non-Russian nationalities so that a few scientists might have a summer dacha and a car and plane trips back to the city for wives to and fro the science town in nowheresville --while they are under threat to have their families sent to gulags if milestones aren't met... nice!
- selimthegrim 5y agoIf you read Khalatnikov’s memoirs he realizes that whole country was turned into a gulag ostensibly for scientists’ sake and is remorseful of the fact
- FpUser 5y ago>"while they are under threat to have their families sent to gulags if milestones aren't met... nice!" It was true during Stalin. Not sure about Kruschev era laws. After that nobody would be sent to gulag for not meeting milestones so cut the bullshit. It is like segregation in the US. It was true until it was not. Or that women in Canada could be jailed in specialized jails (they were called differently) for being of wrong moral character. Not true anymore either.
- artem247 5y ago>> Stores had cigs, vodka, butter and milk and tubers (awesome!!) Where do you get it from? Of course it depended on time and place, but you can buy a lot of stuff in Kyiv (for example) in 70's and 80's. Some things were 'deficit', but they were more of a luxury items. Also the quality was rather good, due to not having cost cutting. >> a few scientists might have a summer dacha Dachas were not exactly a sign of the elite. Cars, on the other hand... >> science town in nowheresville These things existed for some sort of top-secret military research, there were plenty of R&D labs in big cities for a more mundane subjects. You just have an axe to bury with communism, don't you?
- wrp 5y agoI indirectly knew Soviet culture during the late Brezhnev era and forward, but never lived in the USSR myself. It seems that Russians were generally proud of their society and optimistic about its direction during the 1950-1960s. It was in the 1970s that disillusion set in. There was much optimistic literature about Soviet life produced in the 1950-1960s that represented honest belief.
- cft 5y agoIn the West that was the same too. Things jumped the shark around 1967-68: the "Summer of Love" and the moonshot. That was the peak of optimism.
- VictorPath 5y agoSoviet sailors would anchor in European ports in the years after the revolution, and people would ask if they wanted to defect to the West. Why would we want to live outside the USSR they replied. Actually, French and German authorities feared the ideas these sailors might put into the heads of their working class and tried to stifle them. Pictures like Battleship Potemkin were banned for similar reasons. This started changing in the 1950s. China declared during the Sino-soviet split that the USSR had played itself out and the Chinese communist party was now at the vanguard of fast-moving change, and that seems to have been correct.
- zqna 5y agoIt was always possible that someone in the group of those sailors was affiliated with KGB, so nobody would ever say to the foreigners what they actually think. There would be also consequences for your family if one defects. In the end why would anyone leave your own country without having any prospects and social ties elsewhere. There were of course few naive people who managed to flee, but those were certainly not the stories with the happy end, once they realized that all these shiny bright colors were just empty shell that hides the ugliness of capitalism.
- kgeist 5y agoOh, plenty of old folks fondly remember the Soviet past. Especially those people who liked the idea of communism and benefitted from being active communists, like my grandmother (and I don't mean that evil communist stereotype about sending everyone to Gulag, I mean being active in unions, organizing work etc.). Many people were simply indifferent. Soviet people desiring nothing but freedoms and American merchandise is a very one-sided narrative.
- gumby 5y agoMy son had an assistant teacher who’d grown up in the DDR (East Germany). She was really sad that it was gone and felt West Germany was a disaster. She only moved west because her Land (state) was “mismanaged by the Westerners who showed up” so she couldn’t make a living. An example of one of the tragedies of unification? Her brother had become an entrepreneur and then had to work on Saturdays.
- paganel 5y ago> Her brother had become an entrepreneur and then had to work on Saturdays. In the second part of the 1980s (or maybe since the early 1980s? I can't remember exactly, I was just a kid) Ceausescu's regime imposed work on Saturdays, and for some domains even once every two Sundays (like it happened to my dad, who worked in constructions). One of the first decisions taken in 1990 by the new democratic regime once Ceausescu fell was to eliminate working Saturdays, i.e. to give a full weekend to working people. It's funny cause the newly formed opposition to that new regime (the forerunners of today's centre-right political, liberal forces) were pretty critical of that decision, saying things like "as bad as the Romania's economy left to us by Ceausescu is we need to work more, not less!".
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hackart 5y agohttps://www.goodreads.com/book/show/30200112-secondhand-time https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/30200112-secondhand-time
- dainiusse 5y agoAs someone born in ussr ans still living in Vilnius I can tell you there was no much happyness back then. Obviously there are happy moments in life, no matter how poor you are, but we know it is a bit better when you have something to eat. I am not a fan of consumerism, but I take western culture for having a choice what you do. The soviet erra didn't do that. Orwell's Animal Farm describes well the reality in soviet time...
- vkazanov 5y agoAs someone born in a smaller place in Lt I can totally relate to your words! But somehow my little part of lithuania (very north east) feels like an empty shell these days, compared to what it was 20-30-40 years ago.. No people, no economic activity, just empty. I know this is not how it feels in Vilnius - the place gets better by the day, but deeper Lithuania feels deserted. Is this happiness?
- dainiusse 5y agoThis is time and structure of society, not soviet times or not. I have been to deep Russia places where they had gulags, etc. 10 years ago. Inta, Vorkuta, Irkutsk and plenty small towns around and I can tell a few things which are very clearly seen - when the train passes 200kilometers from Moscow - it is deserted with nothing new. You could even experience that by going to Moscow by bus and back. You will be surprised how clean and amazing everything looks when you pass russian/latvian border on your way back. Yes - living in suburbs can be harder, but the difference in cleanliness and life quality (while can be worse than in city) is day and night in Russia and in the Baltics with Baltics being superior.
- vkazanov 5y agoMaybe you are right, I've only been to, say, 5-7 major cities in Russia. What I am saying is that for people like my parents, grandparents and myself it's really hard to compare life in Lithuania these days and the older times as there's nothing left to compare, really. 27 of 30 of my classmates are spread throughout Europe, including myself. I have more lithuanian friends in uk than I do back in Lt. Good for them, I suppose, not so good for places I care about. And this is how many ppl from remote Lt places feel like.
- daliusd 5y agoI know at least one case where person was happier under Soviets than under democracy here in Lithuania, but I doubt that he did not want democracy. Lithuania had two problems occupation by Russia and soviet regime forced by Russia and you cannot really separate that. Here in Lithuania communism is almost equal to nazism.
- oytis 5y agoLots of such things were written in the Soviet Union, not much is being read today or have been translated into English.
- glogla 5y agoHere in Czechia (not USSR but close), lot of older people long for the old days. They had one job for life, the state made sure. They had apartment or house, the state made sure (if you were young family expecting child, they would just give you one). The wages and pensions were enough to live on, the state made sure. In their eyes, there were a lot less existential threats (like losing a job or the rent getting too high you lose place to live) than under the new regime, life was "fair", no fancy enterpreneurs making millions while working people struggle. Jumping to a world where nothing is certain and you're two bad months from homelessness after a lifetime of working was quite a shock for them. The message (however not all that real) of the old system was "we're all in this together" and the new one was "everyone for themselves, no caring about others" especially in the wild years after revolution. Some people are still sad about that. (They also turn to fascist and populist politicians now as a replacement which isn't great.)
- uwagar 5y agowhat happens to artists/musicians/poets? did they have to work at a day job compulsorily to have wages/house/pension etc?
- glogla 5y agoAs far as I know, the ones cozy with the regime were cared for (well beyond normal people) while underground artists worked odd jobs like night receptionists, janitors, boiler room operators or were in prison. (edit: also uranium mines for the ones who pissed off the state) Those tend to get overlooked by people longing for the old days.
- uwagar 5y agoperhaps if the artist is cozy with the regime they cant be critical of the regime? can parents support their child that is an artist with their income? or the state knows everything about the artist (her age, fit to work so on) and will compulsorily draft them to work?
- 5y ago
- hutzlibu 5y ago" is there literature where the soviet people were happy with their lot in the soviet union?" Of course. It was a propaganda regime after all, so there are tons of books where the heroic simple workers or even children fight along red soldieres or party members against corruption and the various evils of capitalism. I have some lying around and they are interesting, to get a feel of the time, but are not really the greatest literature ever written. Because to get success as a writer, it was encouraged to write like this. In the sense, that you would loose permission to write and publish, or worse, if the official thought you work was not helping the progressive spirit.
- clavicat 5y ago
- artem247 5y agoI would say it is more about disillusionment with capitalism and democracy after the collapse of Soviet Union. In Ukraine for a decade after collapse the left-wing parties, such as Communists, Socialists, Agrarian party were very popular. I know a lot of people, who are in their 50's and 60's and older, who now see a lot of good in Soviet structure, yet in the late 80's almost everyone was either negative towards SU or apolitical
- romanhn 5y agoI'm part of this last Soviet generation. All in all, I would consider my childhood a happy one. I am of course much happier with my US-born children's quality of life and opportunities, but there was no point of comparison back then and I got to have experiences they will not.
- vbezhenar 5y agoI was born in Tselinograd in 1987. All Russian people of older age who I knew remember USSR with fondness. That could be just nostalgic. Some older Kazakh people are different though, they like independence from Russia.
- sedan_baklazhan 5y agoThere's a lot - mostly in Russian, of course. In my opinion and experience, most people (no less than 80%) of the former USSR regret, many of them deeply regret, the fall of USSR. In the Western opinion bubble, opposite viewpoint prevails. "Incorrect" opinions are usually dismissed as propaganda.
- int_19h 5y agoThere were such people. It really depends on what you want in life. One thing that 1960-80s USSR was very good at was stability. So, you might not have much food on your table, and it might not be particularly good, but you knew it'd be there. Ditto for housing, transportation etc. I can think of some people in US that'd take this deal, even if it meant they would have no freedom of speech or movement, and no political power, thereafter.
- strlen 5y agoI am one of those folks (born in early 1980s in Minsk). One can get a taste of that era by listening to the amazing music from bands like Kino and Nautilus Pompilus. Some example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qWEfVZN64jU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qWEfVZN64jU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=syTqQ-TU_c8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=syTqQ-TU_c8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aew6MJLyVL4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Aew6MJLyVL4
- coolspot 5y agoI agree with Kino, but Butusov (NP) just throws random words together and calls that a song.
- MichaelMoser123 5y agoI am not a fan of Butusov, but these are not random words 'Скованные одной цепью'/'bound by the same chains' https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sIljdb6I_IA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sIljdb6I_IA (still Akvarium/Grebenshikov are categorically 'the best', no doubt about that! Also there is Shevchuk/DDT, there was Egor Letov and they had Yanka Dyagileva "Всё как у людей ;-)")
- MichaelMoser123 5y agoPunk Rock on an accoustic guitar, you didn't have that anywhere else, i think (actually it's poetry, if you ask me) Моя оборона/My Defense https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U9LHowWc9Qs&list=OLAK5uy_kf0dBycaP247D3zI5pDuqsW7nJikCXzBE&index=7 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U9LHowWc9Qs&list=OLAK5uy_kf0... Пуля дура / Stupid bullet https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2FE9k6XPKhM&list=OLAK5uy_kf0dBycaP247D3zI5pDuqsW7nJikCXzBE&index=5 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2FE9k6XPKhM&list=OLAK5uy_kf0... Мы гуляли по трамвайным рельсам/We walked on the railway lines https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IQ7P1yvcJQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6IQ7P1yvcJQ
- strlen 5y ago“Alan Delon doesn’t drink cologne” (as you probably know) is not random: drinking cologne was very much a thing, due to alcohol rationing meant to combat drinking (which also lead to people drinking methanol and going blind or even worse.) There are also references to other aspects of Soviet household life.
- high_pathetic 5y agoThe day Brezhnev died it was really cold in Vilnius. The school was out and we went tobogganing. I (b. 1973) lived in Vilnius from 1980 to 1986 and after I moved to the central Russia I noticed how much better it was in Lithuania. The food, the clothes, the people, everything had more color in it. I was really surprised how much poorer and bleaker the life was in RSFSR, at least in the part where I lived later. Despite being a part of the USSR, Baltic republics felt more civilized and modern. Many tourists from the rest of the country enjoyed visiting to get the glimpses of the West.
- vogre 5y agoThat was the politics of USSR - to feed the small republics at the expense of russian people. There was supply categories for every region - and most of RSFSR, except Moscow and Leningrad got 3rd or 4rth category, while caucasian republics and Baltics got 1 and second class.
- skeletal88 5y agoThat.. was not exactly true. We had giant pig farms and meat factories, from where almost all stuff that was produced was sent to Russia, whereas meat was scarce in local shops. So if stuff wasn't available here, then it must have been even worse in other places. And at the same time we were producing a lot more meat and foodstuff than the local population would have ever needed, but it was sent to some other places. Instead we got big heavy industry or military factories where the raw materials were brought in to produce useless stuff that we didn't need, that was again sent away to somewhere else. The stupid economics of soviet planned economy..
- otar 5y agoI was born in Soviet Union in 1990. Thinking about that is weird.
- daliusd 5y agoIt is unexpected to see an article here about Lithuania from Aljazeera. It looks quite good as well. I was born when Brezhnev died so my parents were we people in transition (while my father was prepared better for it than many people).
- leto_ii 5y agoAl Jazeera is actually a really serious organisation. I find their coverage to be better than that of the BBC and waay better than that of CNN International. You just have to account for their biases (they're from Qatar etc.), but that holds true of absolutely everybody.
- googamooga 5y agoI was not a big fan of Soviet regime and I‘m still fully agree that the collapse of the Soviet Union was for the good and do not wish it restored in any form. But being born in 1970 in Tselinogtad, middle-sized city in Soviet Kazakhstan, I cannot say that my life in USSR was any kind of bleak or depressing. Yes, there were much less variety of food in stores and clothes were not very fashy, but this is not what makes you happy, at least they meant almost nothing to me. I always wanted travel the world and very early understood that this is complicated in the country where I was living. So at age of 9 I started to prepare myself for a career of a diplomat - my favorite book was “Countries of the World” and I joined “The Club of Inernational Friendship” at the Palace of Pioneers. Gradually I became a “president” of this club and in 1982 went to Artek, famous international pioneer camp in Crimea. Later on, still at school, in 1986, I visited Bratislava to participate the programming Olympiad for children. I went from my native Tselinograd to Novosibirsk Akademgorodok in 1985 to study at physics-mathematics boarding school. Akademgorodok at that time was kind of place from a sci-fi book, where scientists lived and worked. There were 27 research institutes and a university set in a Siberian forest. It was a fantastic experience to study there. What happened to Akademgorodok after dissolution of the USSR is another (sad) story. So, as I said in the beginning, I don’t want to return to the USSR, but I don’t think we lived miserable lives there.
- qaq 5y agoThis is not exactly the common experience of a child in USSR. 99.99% never being to Artek and 99.999% never visited a foreign country. The STEM education was pretty good though.
- lnsru 5y agoI see a stories here of happy Soviet people. One from current Russian minority (upper class back then by default) and one from party member. Let me tell you my family story. My grand grandfather was a clerk in independent Lithuania’s court before Soviet occupation. He went to gulag when Soviets came and died there. For the rest of the family the life was destroyed - they were outlawed. Education and work choices very limited, no party membership, occasional KGB checks. Especially during catholic celebrations like Eastern or Christmas. Few generations later I left for Germany and never looked back. Lithuania lost status of being western country in Soviet Union. Now it is just another weird faceless post Soviet country that made into EU and NATO. No strategy, no goals, no future. People and especially politicians hadn’t learned planing and choice making. At the moment this country is in a silent war against Russia, Belarus and even China: https://www.businessinsider.com/china-threatens-lithuania-withgarbage-bin-of-history-for-taiwan-office-2021-12 https://www.businessinsider.com/china-threatens-lithuania-wi... Oh well…
- BoyRobot777 5y ago> Now it is just another weird faceless post Soviet country that made into EU and NATO. No strategy, no goals, no future. You've been reading too much propaganda. Living in Lithuania is become better each year. Lithuania's GDP is like Belarus, while the population is 3x smaller. Lithuania has surpassed russia in GDP per Capita long time ago. Lithuania is #11 in doing business [1]. Lithuania is Largest Fintech hub in the EU in terms of licensed companies[2]. Lithuania is one of global leaders when it comes to laser technology. And currently, there are talks between Taiwan and Lithuania about semi-conductor factory. And that is being achieved in only 30 years or so. Regarding being faceless. Lithuania has showed that it has a strong spine again and again against authoritarian regimes. By hosting Belarusian pro democracy leaders [3], by support Ukraine in every possible way in their path to democracy, and yes, supporting Taiwan, which resulted in spat between China and Lithuania. While we old western countries talk, Lithuania walks the talk. Lithuania has very much a face. And that's the face of being pro democracy. Yes they are small and they rely on their partners support, but they have values. [1] https://www.doingbusiness.org/en/data/exploreeconomies/lithuania# https://www.doingbusiness.org/en/data/exploreeconomies/lithu... [2] https://investlithuania.com/fintech-report-2020-2021/ https://investlithuania.com/fintech-report-2020-2021/ [3] https://www.rferl.org/a/belarus-lithuania-official-opposition/31342168.html https://www.rferl.org/a/belarus-lithuania-official-oppositio...
- dredmorbius 5y agoFor those unfamiliar with history, today is the 30th anniversary of the final dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991. There's another submission in queue with CNN's broadcast from the night of 25 December 1991 beginning with then-president George H. W. Bush (41st US president, father of G.W. Bush, 43rd) addressing the US and world by television: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29681271 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29681271
- kej 5y agoThey headline reminded me of this story, about the cosmonaut who watched the fall of the Soviet Union from space: https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/the-last-soviet-citizen https://www.discovermagazine.com/the-sciences/the-last-sovie...
- bluetomcat 5y agoI have childhood memories from 1980s communist Bulgaria and the following transition. Though never a part of the USSR, it was considered the most loyal satellite in the Eastern bloc, especially during the Brezhnev era. Drab, dreary, colourless city life, sure. On the other hand, it was a youth-oriented society with many progressive elements. There was zero street crime and drug usage was practically unheard of. Young people were encouraged to do sports and participate in competitions, or study exact sciences and mathematics, or play musical instruments. Parents never had to worry about whether they can afford child care, or whether their children will be admitted in the right school. There was a common base standard and it was good enough.
- drakonka 5y agoEven though I was born just a few years before the collapse of the Soviet Union, some of the descriptions in this article resonate. I don't remember what time of the year we had mandarins, but when it happened it felt like a very special occasion. I also had a little notebook of chewing gum wrappers. I think sometimes they also may have come with stickers inside. I especially collected the ones with wrappers and stickers of sports cars. I knew of the concept of a Christmas-esque celebration. We did have a big celebration at that time of year with a tree, presents, and Ded Moroz with his granddaughter Snegurachka, but I always associated these things with New Year's eve. I still have trouble remembering what day exactly Christmas is some years and have to look it up, it seemed like such a random date compared to the big last day of the year. I remember my childhood as being happy, but of course the vast majority of these memories came after the collapse. One of my favorite memories was our school getting a computer lab. For a few weeks, they let a few of us come in for special computer classes on Sundays (school was Mon-Sat). I remember having to copy instructions from pieces of paper, and once we finished we had a playable game. I always finished before the rest of the class and had a lot of time left to play. I'm glad I was born on the brink of the collapse. My family's stories of the Soviet Union were complex, but didn't make me want to live there. On the one hand my mom talked about the good education and technology she got to work with. My grandmother was a math teacher and some sort of party official, so she was in good standing. On the other hand, apparently when I was a baby my parents still had to line up to buy bread and I would sometimes hear mention how my grandparents had to survive on grass during the Holodomor.
- markvdb 5y agoIn my experience as a westerner, the '80s and early '90s are subjects better not discussed. The exception are close friends and family, and then only when the subject comes up. That, or funny exotic stories from the '80s. Random bits I've picked up that way: - winning a car (well, a https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZAZ_Zaporozhets https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ZAZ_Zaporozhets) in a lottery and driving it without a license. "Officer, I just forgot it at home. I wouldn't be so stupid to risk driving without a license." 1980's Latvia. - having to grind up pasta to make a birthday cake. In 1980's Riga. - having to eat bananas for days on end because a large box of bananas was what could be found. 1990's Latvia. - dumping gasoline in the ditches. The kolchoz had so much one could take, but what do you do if you have no use for so much gasoline? 1980's Latvia. - selling the privatisation certificates for a song in order to survive. 1990's Latvia.
- ethics13 5y agoMy biggest fear when USSR collapsed was highlighted in these threads. People are either ignorant of what WAS USSR and eventually start reminiscing about the great childhoods they had. I’m older, born and raised in Soviet Ukraine. God help you all with your naïveté.
- d0mine 5y agoThe fall of USSR is a destruction of the civilization in a sense (the lasting victory of "the dog eats dog" world over "all people are brothers"). Do you sincerely think that there is not enough dirt voiced against USSR--it is laughable: the propaganda made USSR to be equivalent to the fascist Germany (the irony)--no help is required.
- elzbardico 5y agoThe USSR was in terms of violence and human rights violation at least equivalent to nazist germany, and in practical terms worse, as the Soviet State was far more long-lived than the Nazist State.
- d0mine 5y agoYou are just confirming my point.
- ethics13 5y agoThere's not ENOUGH dirt in the world to lay at the foot of that regime.
- int_19h 5y agoOne can have no regrets over USSR as such, but still be unhappy about how it fell apart. Did we really have to go through the whole bloody mess of late 80s to early 90s? Armenia vs Azerbaijan in Karabakh and elsewhere, Georgia vs Abkhazia/Adjaria/Ossetia, the bloody civil war in Tajikistan, numerous ethnic massacres all across Central Asia (e.g. the Osh riots), and so on.
- amai 5y agoWhat I noticed from many people growing up in former communist states is that they seem to have similar issues as people that lived in jail for a long time. In jail you have a very regular live and you don‘t have any responsibility for anything. You also cannot change anything. You try to make the best out of it. But after you leave jail live outside seems awfully complicated. So many decisions, so much responsibility, so many expectation what you should or what you should not do is often overwhelming for these people. And if they don’t get help (and many people from former communist countries never got any kind of help) they struggle with their new freedom. So many of them glorify their time back in jail, where everything was so simple. And this is of course true to some extent. But it still was a jail.