10 ms·
S.Africa says vaccines, prior infection help mildness of Covid cases
- kottaram 5y ago
- senectus1 5y agoNow we have large numbers of vaccinated out there I really think we should see a lot less of "new infections" type stats, and a lot more of "in hospitals" type stats... in places with 90-95%+ vaccination rates THAT is the numbers that are important for things like opening up/locking down. Then break that down to "in hospital and vaccinated with X or having had a previous infection and recovered or unvaccinated and having had no previous infection." We're not seeing that here in Australia... its all just about the number of new infections. plus a bit of info about Delta/Omicron. it feels like fear mongering not information clarity.
- heyitsguay 5y agoBasically agreed, but to me whether "new infections" matters or not hinges on the long-term effects of these different variants in vaccinated people. What's the prevalence of "long COVID" if you're vaccinated? If you're vaccinated and boosted? Is there evidence of any more or less lasting lung damage in chest X-rays than in unvaccinated people? Hospitalization matters for short-term policy, but long-term damage could end up affecting long-term healthcare policy even more in the coming decades
- senectus1 5y agooh long covid is another problem as well I agree, but I think the more immediate issue is checking to see if this new variant is so bad that we need to lock down (seems unlikely) or if we're now fortified enough to let it rip :-/
- bluejekyll 5y agoWhile I hope what you are suggesting is the case, “scientists say it is too early to draw firm conclusions” (from linked article). We just don’t know yet what the repercussions of the most recent infections are. It seems like a pretty big gamble to not be cautious. Masking, vaccines, and avoiding indoor crowds in poorly ventilated spaces seems to be helpful. Probably best to at a minimum continue to do that until we have more concrete evidence.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Semaphor 5y agoWe are using hospitalizations here in Germany, but a) it's an even more lagging indicator than infections and b) as a person without a booster shot (I've only been eligible to register for one since today) I appreciate the infection rates.
- markvdb 5y agoYou sound motivated to get your third vaccination early. Did you know that it has been possible for any EU resident to get a booster shot in Aachen, Nordrhein-Westfalen since two weeks at least, without an appointment? This might also hold true for other German Laender closer to you.
- mschuster91 5y agoThe booster shots are only after 5 or 6 months, depending on the state - and the bureaucracy "experts" have managed to turn people away because six hours (!) had been missing to make the six month spacing (e.g. https://www.waz.de/staedte/velbert/sechs-stunden-zu-frueh-keine-booster-impfung-fuer-80-jaehrige-id234003861.html https://www.waz.de/staedte/velbert/sechs-stunden-zu-frueh-ke...). Our bureaucracy and inability to improvise in times of need will kill us all.
- Fnoord 5y agoMy son (1, NL) got certain vaccines a few days too early (they should've noticed that when appt was made, and now he has to get the vaccines again, or he is not offficially vaccinated against them. Infuriating but otherwise where do you draw the line with exceptions.
- rajup 5y agoThe reason boosters are needed after 5 or 6 months is antibody levels apparently drop around that time, booster tops that up roughly speaking. Having a booster dose within that time period does not magically make you more immune.
- qwerty456127 5y ago
- thebigman433 5y ago> Now we have large numbers of vaccinated out there I really think we should see a lot less of "new infections" type stats, and a lot more of "in hospitals" type stats... in places with 90-95%+ vaccination rates THAT is the numbers that are important for things like opening up/locking down. Exactly what should be done. Instead of reporting new cases most prominently, there should be reports on how cities like SF, with 80%+ vaccination rates, have 0, or single digit death averages over the last week. For massive population centers!
- adgjlsfhk1 5y agoThe main problem with using hospitalization is that it lags cases by 1-2 weeks which means it's not ideal for policy making.
- switch007 5y agoPolicy shouldn't be quick, rash judgements. It's got a bigger scope than that. We need longer-term strategies. Quick judgements should be made within an existing policy. And laws, which take time, for good reason, to propose, debate and pass. We can't run a country with by changing direction every time case numbers of one particular virus go up or down
- ggm 5y agoThere was a Qld newspaper report today proposing some state health departments want to focus on hospitalisations as a functional measure of stress on the system. I also heard anecdotal suggestions that contact tracing was going to be dropped as too unwieldy in the face of ubiquitous infection. I find that very scary, close to a "giving up" mentality. The hospitalisations measurement, is I think sensible. I still think underlying case rate means something.
- lettergram 5y agoCovid is endemic and increasingly less scary. > I find that very scary, close to a "giving up" mentality. Everyone can have a vaccine, there are multiple highly effective therapies and even the risk of death without intervention to the majority of people (under 55) is already astronomically low. To put it in perspective, if you’re under 30 with asthma, your risk of death from the original covid variant (not the less lethal variants) is the same as being struck by lightening. We haven’t given up, we’ve successfully mitigated fatalities until we have effective treatments and a vaccine. Now it’s time to move on.
- spockz 5y agoI think dying from COVID is the least scary part. The long COVID is way more common in my area. People stay ill for longer or lose fitness. We have one acquaintance that now has issues finding the right words. Personally I lost a few points of eye sight in just the three weeks. (Coincidentally we measured just before I got ill.) other friends just are tired quickly all the time. So I think preventing all that loss of quality of life is also worthwhile.
- nradov 5y agoHow do you propose to prevent it? The virus will be around forever and everyone will occasionally be exposed. https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/94646 https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/94646 https://www.businessinsider.com/delta-variant-made-herd-immunity-not-possible-astrazeneca-developer-2021-8 https://www.businessinsider.com/delta-variant-made-herd-immu...
- lettergram 5y agoYou actually need to go further, many people are not hospitalized FOR covid. You need those numbers. Further, we couldn’t contain delta. If Omicron is 10x more virulent (as claimed), then we have no hope. Masks didn’t help, Lockdowns didn’t help. Luckily, these illnesses are treatable with the plethora of therapeutics that were discovered. Plus, the strains have become less lethal over time. It is fear mongering on the part of media (to make money) and governments (to seize power).
- nyokodo 5y ago> If Omicron is 10x more virulent I think you mean “10x more infectious” as virulence is how serious/deadly/damaging the infection is. Omicron is no more virulent and maybe considerably less virulent than previous strains.
- asimpletune 5y agoSo I was a little confused about the definition myself, because when I looked it up a while back my iPhone dictionary suggested both as a definition. Is the key difference that in an infectious disease expert context, virulent means severe and infectious means contagious? I always thought virulent was ability to spread because that’s what viruses do, but that was way before the pandemic.
- sterlind 5y agocorrect. it's confusing terminology, but virulent means severe. so MERS is very virulent (30% mortality) but not very infectious (R0<1). SARS-COV-2 is the opposite.
- lettergram 5y agoYou’re correct, brain was working a bit slower late at night -_-
- ako 5y agoHow do you know the masks and lockdowns didn't help? Things might have much worse if not for the masks and lockdowns?
- dukeofdoom 5y agoOntario provides a breakdown of the data. If you go to the the third graph, click on the cases, you will see a worrying trend. The vaccinated cases are growing exponentially. 2997 vaccinated cases vs 905 unvaccinated cases in the last week. https://covid-19.ontario.ca/data?fbclid=IwAR2pRUq9GN9EEoDTm0OetspYalQy0Otcc41JS6b-L9BnzLOdhl1eZ1L4FHg https://covid-19.ontario.ca/data?fbclid=IwAR2pRUq9GN9EEoDTm0...
- senectus1 5y agojeez those stats are not as great a result as what I was hoping for. thanks for the link
- dukeofdoom 5y agoIn ontario the unvaccinated as a group have to do rapid antigen testing 2 or 3 times per week testing to keep their jobs. So much more likely to report a positive. The "doctors" on 4chan think it's ADE in the vaccinated.
- senectus1 5y agoADE?
- nradov 5y agoAntibody dependent enhancement. There are some infectious diseases for which the antibodies created by vaccination actually make it more likely for patients to get infected by the actual virus. There is no reliable evidence of this happening with COVID-19. https://www.nebraskamed.com/COVID/antibody-dependent-enhancement-in-vaccines https://www.nebraskamed.com/COVID/antibody-dependent-enhance...
- nawgz 5y agoBut these are case numbers and not hospitalization numbers… which is the parent’s point, Ontario ICU numbers are stable since nov 20 even with all this omicron news and increased case count
- heavyset_go 5y agoIt's the earliest indicator of all COVID-related trends, and it's the variable the that others depend on. Every new infection results in rolling the evolutionary dice a few hundred billion times, and is how we get diseases that evade our defenses, and new diseases in general. Also, being hospitalized isn't the only bad thing about COVID.
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y ago"Every new infection results in rolling the evolutionary dice a few hundred billion times, and is how we get diseases that evade our defenses, and new diseases in general." That frames it as if that was a new and scary thing and not something that has been going on for millions of years.
- landemva 5y agoIt will be interesting to see if this data is collected, '... having had a previous infection and recovered'. And then did not vax. It is the control group of the natural circumstance.
- top_post 5y agoWe don't have 90-95% vaccinated in Australia or any state of Australia. It's of the eligible population and it's excluding the under 12 year olds. The whole covid is mild in children argument aside, the fact is the population simply is not 90+ vaccinated.
- jen729w 5y agoAhem from the ACT where our 16+ double-dose rate is “>99%”. [0] I’ll give you the technicality that you said “state” but still, we’re doing pretty good here in the territory! I had my booster yesterday morning. I’m 45. [0]: https://www.health.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/2021/12/covid-19-vaccine-rollout-update-jurisdictional-breakdown-20-december-2021.pdf https://www.health.gov.au/sites/default/files/documents/2021...
- top_post 5y ago16+ is not the whole ACT population and was my point. Undoubtedly 99% are great numbers for 16+… but an entire cohort is excluded from vaccination statistics of which are vulnerable to infection.
- jen729w 5y agoAh, gotcha. Still, with our 12-15 at ~97% you’d have to think that we’re a good city to watch. Nowhere else in the world is this vaccinated. If Omicron takes hold here, we’re all buggered. Thankfully, so far it doesn’t seem to be.
- phillc73 5y agoAustria is using ICU bed occupancy as a key metric now. This was used to justify the most recent lockdown. The publicised critical point is 33% of ICU bed capacity occupied by COVID patients. This page has the data [1]. What I now believe is missing, and would like to see, is the number of ICU COVID patients who are vaccinated and unvaccinated, as well as an age group breakdown. This is the type of data required to make informed decisions. If I had a teenage child, I’d be wanting to understand the true likelihood of them contracting COVID and ending up in an ICU bed, in order to make a decision about vaccinating them against it. [1] https://covid19-dashboard.ages.at/dashboard_Hosp.html https://covid19-dashboard.ages.at/dashboard_Hosp.html
- rsynnott 5y ago> Now we have large numbers of vaccinated out there I really think we should see a lot less of "new infections" type stats, and a lot more of "in hospitals" type stats... in places with 90-95%+ vaccination rates THAT is the numbers that are important for things like opening up/locking down. So, the trouble with that is that hospitalisation is a lagging indicator. By the time hospitalisation starts rising rapidly, you could lock everyone in their houses and it would still rise rapidly for another week or so. Which will probably overwhelm your hospitals. Even in places with 95% vaccination, case counts are still _generally_ a reasonable indicator of where hospitalisation is headed; some fraction of those cases will convert to hospitalisations due to that vulnerable 5%, and due to people for whom the vaccination doesn't work very well (immunocompromised and extremely ill people, generally).
- lngnmn2 5y agoWhy, this is exactly how vaccines work - they prime (or condition) the immune system, but it is the immune system that actually do the job in case of exposure to the virus. Vaccination is neither prevents infection nor spreading. Its about efficiency of the response.
- justinpombrio 5y ago> Vaccination is neither prevents infection nor spreading. Vaccines frequently prevent infection and spreading. (And yes, they do this by way of priming the immune system.) For example, we eradicated Small Pox with vaccines: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/788150/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/788150/ My understanding is that vaccines do reduce the chance of Covid spreading. But with the Omicron variant, they help a lot with preventing severe illness and only a little bit with helping reduce infectiousness. And Omicron is ridiculously infectious, so it's going to whip right through well-vaccinated areas just like everywhere else. But in general, reducing the chance that one person infects another is one of the primary purposes of vaccines.
- withjive 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kkjjkgjjgg 5y agoMost people, including governments, seem to be under the impression that the vaccines prevent spreading. It is the only rationale for vaccination mandates that are being rolled out all over the world.
- EB-Barrington 5y ago
- ycombinete 5y agoA little anecdote from South Africa that agrees with this. One of my sister-in-laws is a doctor working at a government hospital in South Africa. She and my brother both have Omicron right now. They caught covid in the first wave. Subsequently vaccinated with pfizer (brother), and Johnson (his wife). She had mild symptoms the first time around (Doctor's immune system); he was bed-ridden for days and even fainted at one point. This time around she has zero symptoms, and he's got almost none.
- GameOfFrowns 5y ago
- raziel2701 5y agoI don't know why you're coming at that poster so strong. They said it's anecdotal evidence, they're just throwing it out there, they're not saying it PROVES anything.
- GameOfFrowns 5y agoThen let me throw my own anecdote out there. I got covid in the second wave before the vaccines were available, recovered quickly within 3 days without any medication or hospitalisation. I mysteriously developed long-covid symptoms and heart palpitations only AFTER receiving the Pfizer vaccine. I received my two doses of Pfizer but I decided won't get any of the booster shots and take my chances until the Miniluv goons come to kick down my door. Which anecdote is more valid? Only one will get flagged though.
- sjg007 5y agoDid they have the Beta variant? One hypothesis is that Beta confers more immunity to Omicron than the original variant.
- ycombinete 5y agoI'm not sure. It was very early on in the first wave.
- randomsearch 5y agoSurprising to see some of the same “but hospitalisation rates low” comments on HN when we are literally supposed to be the world’s foremost users of complexity theory and big O notation. Even if hospitalisation rates are a small constant factor lower, doesn’t everyone remember from CS101 that O(k^x) is bad news bears and that constant factor ain’t gonna save your assignment once the problem size grows just a little more.
- krona 5y agoThe average hospital stay is much shorter and so you're ignoring queue theory 101 and Little's law.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dtech 5y agoWhen x trends to infinity, which is irrelevant in this case since you're limited by population numbers.
- toper-centage 5y agoNot just that, but after 2 years of pandemic you start having very few new people to infect effectively.
- DrScump 5y agoHaving been infected with one strain of SARS-CoV-2 doesn't protect you from all other variants. It's not even clear that it protects you from reinfection with the same variant indefinitely.
- Auracle 5y agoI was infected with Delta 9 months after one of the initial strains. I was more or less as sick as I was the first time for a full two weeks. That said, when I looked up studies on that the chances were about 1% for that to happen to me (at that time).
- qwerty456127 5y agoWhy doesn't this solve the whole problem? I would intuitively assume almost any given person has already been either vaccinated or infected or both by today so severe cases should be rare.
- iso1210 5y agoBefore say 1 in 100 went into hospital, meaning 100k infections means 1000 hospitalisations Now 1 in 1000 go into hospital, that's great from an individual basis and a population basis. Still means that 1 million infections leads to 1,000 hospitalisations.
- qwerty456127 5y agoThis reminds me of a broader question: why our health systems are so incapacitate they can't handle every 1 in 1000 (or whatever the number actually is) being hospitalized?
- franga2000 5y agoBeing prepared for such an increase necessary means having that much capacity unused for the rest of the time. The private sector sure as hell isn't going to do it and the public sector is beholden to the general population, which won't stand for "inefficient spending". What politician would dare run on a platform of "we'll build 50% more hospital capacity and hire 50% more doctors, then have them sit idle just in case a global pandemic hits". Two years ago, they would've gotten laughed out of the room.
- eru 5y agoThe private sector could totally build the extra capacity. Look at 'peaker plants' for electricity generation. It's worth quoting Wikipedia here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaking_power_plant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peaking_power_plant > Peaking power plants, also known as peaker plants, and occasionally just "peakers", are power plants that generally run only when there is a high demand, known as peak demand, for electricity.[1][2][3][4] Because they supply power only occasionally, the power supplied commands a much higher price per kilowatt hour than base load power. Peak load power plants are dispatched in combination with base load power plants, which supply a dependable and consistent amount of electricity, to meet the minimum demand. > Although historically peaking power plants were frequently used in conjunction with coal baseload plants, peaking plants are now used less commonly. Combined cycle gas turbine plants have two or more cycles, the first of which is very similar to a peaking plant, with the second running on the waste heat of the first. That type of plant is often capable of rapidly starting up, albeit at reduced efficiency, and then over some hours transitioning to a more efficient baseload generation mode. Combined cycle plants have similar capital cost per watt to peaking plants, but run for much longer periods, and use less fuel overall, and hence give cheaper electricity. > As of 2020, open cycle gas turbines give an electricity cost of around $151-198/MWh. The issues is that the natural mechanism that incentivises the private sector to provide peak capacity is what some people call 'price gauging'. And that's a big taboo for 'sacred values' like anything to do with medicine or health.
- thinkingemote 5y agoPeople are speaking across each otber in propaganda messages and all sides are wrong as each side says the other is wrong. That's a classic sign of a propaganda war. There's no understanding going on here. The best move is not to play, professor falcon.
- toraway1234 5y agoMeanwhile pfizer and moderna are laughing all the way to the bank. At least I'd like to be not on the side of big corp interests.