15 ms·
Clumps of human brain cells in a dish can learn to play Pong faster than an AI
- Geee 5y agoHow do they do it in practice? How do the neurons know when they succeed / fail?
- lucb1e 5y agoFrom my very limited understanding, feedback is done by releasing chemicals. Not sure if hormone is the proper word but that's what comes to mind. Perhaps someone else here knows more about it.
- div72 5y agoAlthough another commenter said that they are signaled electrically, neurotransmitter might be the word you are looking for.
- dr1337 5y agoSo it looks in the paper they're using a theoretical framework called the Free Energy Principle developed by Prof Karl Friston at UCL which postulates that brains have evolved to minimise the amount of information surprise between their own internal generative model of the world and the observable world. The paper uses this as the basis of learning and it looks like the neurons are given a random (electrical) stimulus when they miss the ball and a predictable stimulus when they hit it.
- bookofjoe 5y agohttps://archive.ph/rfVaN https://archive.ph/rfVaN
- CactusOnFire 5y agoThe concept of using human neural networks instead of artificial neural networks is both terrifying and intriguing.
- Razengan 5y agoI have no mouth and I must scream.
- yholio 5y agoThat some unexplainable force cheats the rules of the universe to beat me at Pong.
- polskibus 5y agoCheck out „Black Oceans” by Jacek Dukaj if you’re interested in sci-fi that explores this idea. https://culture.pl/en/work/black-oceans-jacek-dukaj https://culture.pl/en/work/black-oceans-jacek-dukaj
- rzzzt 5y agoDe Lift (1983) / Down (2001) also highlights certain shortcomings of brain-on-chip embedded systems. https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0087622/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0087622/
- ampdepolymerase 5y agoThis is not the first attempt. Growing tiny brain organoids is fairly well understood, scaling it up is not. I have not read the paper but previous attempts at this have struggled with getting useful outputs out of the neural culture, most of the time the spikes just add up to noise.
- BariumBlue 5y agoSamsung Z-35, now with 50% more HBC (Human Brain Cell) inside!
- cblconfederate 5y agoDon't forget to feed your phone, it might die!
- 5y ago
- 323 5y agoThey should also compare human brain cells with chimp/dog/... brain cells. See if the human ones perform better, which would suggest there is an advantage even at the lowest cellular level.
- amelius 5y agoThey should also compare different regions of the human brain. See which ones learn better, and which ones are closer to animals in terms of learning.
- ekelsen 5y agoThey compared against mice. Human cells were better.
- ReptileMan 5y agoWas it Pinky or Brain's cell though?
- cblconfederate 5y agoThey compared human induced stem cells with real mouse cells, and human cells learned better.
- gscott 5y agohttps://singularityhub.com/2010/10/06/videos-of-robot-controlled-by-rat-brain-amazing-technology-still-moving-forward/ https://singularityhub.com/2010/10/06/videos-of-robot-contro...
- pezzana 5y agoPaywalled. From an earlier article in Forbes: > Using real neurons avoids several other difficulties that software-based neural networks have. For instance, to get artificial neural networks to start learning well, their programmers usually have to engage in a laborious process of manually adjusting the initial coefficients, or weights, that will be applied to each type of data point the network processes. Another challenge is to get the software to balance how much it should be trying to explore new solutions to a problem versus relying on solutions the network has already discovered that work well. > “All these problems are completely eluded if you have a system that is based on biological neurons to begin with,” Friston said. https://fortune.com/2020/03/30/startup-human-neurons-computer-chips/ https://fortune.com/2020/03/30/startup-human-neurons-compute... The other main advantage is low power consumption. > AlphaGo, the deep-learning system DeepMind created to play Go and which beat the world’s best human player in that ancient strategy game in 2016, consumed one megawatt of power while playing the game, enough to power about 100 homes for a day, according to an estimate by technology company Ceva. By contrast, the human brain consumes about 20 watts of power, or 50,000 times less energy than AlphaGo used. However, it's not clear whether these hybrid chips will have similarly low power consumption.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoPaywalled?! I don’t see a paywall here, maybe I’m still in the”free articles limit”. By the way thanks for your quotes!
- lucb1e 5y ago> The other main advantage is low power consumption. As someone worried about our climate, I'm very curious about that actually. Is it more efficient to feed neurons biological food (from an energy perspective, since that food needs to be grown on land somewhere and takes up solar energy, it needs water that comes from clouds which were created by evaporation, etc.) than it is to use low-CO2 energy sources (solar, wind, nuclear, hydro, wave, whatever) and power a computer with that? E.g. electric motors are very efficient compared to combustion, but it's only effective if you get electricity from a non-combustion source or else you might as well use a combustion engine in the vehicle itself. I kind of assumed it's the same for computers, that they efficiently calculate things compared to biology, but I never really thought about it. I'm curious how energy-intensive biological computers are (discounting any R&D that I assume is currently still a big part of the equation).
- wolverine876 5y agoIs there published research? Looking through verious reports, all I see are references to the New Scientist article.
- cblconfederate 5y agopreprint is available https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.02.471005v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.02.471005v1
- wolverine876 5y agoAlso: Farahany, Greely "The ethics of experimenting with human brain tissue" in Nature (2018) https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-04813-x https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-018-04813-x
- hyperpallium2 5y agohuh now it's playing badly... wait, it's morse code! _._ .. ._.. ._.. __ .
- fouc 5y agoAh, the sentient something communicating a "kill me" message. That reminds me of a scene from a movie, but I can't remember which one it was.
- dole 5y agoMore than likely Johnny Got His Gun, although The Fly or Predator could apply.
- damiankennedy 5y agoI thought of "Johnny Got His Gun" too. That's the film they use the footage from in the video of Metallica's song "One".
- jl2718 5y agohttps://youtu.be/WM8bTdBs-cw?t=306 https://youtu.be/WM8bTdBs-cw?t=306
- kregasaurusrex 5y agoFull paper on bioRxiv: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.02.471005v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.02.471005v1
- fouc 5y ago"In vitro neurons learn and exhibit sentience when embodied in a simulated game-world" Exhibiting sentience, that's a bit awkward ethically speaking.. Even though this type of testing will help us understand how our brains work.
- hlbjhblbljib 5y agoethics only comes in when they exhibit consciousness.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoYou can't prove anything is conscious. How would you test for that?
- contravariant 5y agoYou connect it and one of the researchers to a chat window and the one that first convinces some third party they're conscious gets let out.
- wolverine876 5y agoSentient means "Physiology. Of organs or tissues: Responsive to sensory stimuli." or more generally, "That feels or is capable of feeling; having the power or function of sensation or of perception by the senses." and "Conscious or percipient of something." It doesn't mean human intelligence or consciousness.
- parineum 5y agoSapience and sentience is the differentiating language for what you're describing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bostonbot 5y agoReminds me of the book “We are legion (We are Bob)”.
- omarhaneef 5y agoI know supply chain issues have researchers trying out novel solutions but this was unexpected. Still, I’m not worried about some new ghoulish supply chain unless it mines crypto.
- rzzzt 5y ago"The Matrix is a computer-generated dream world, built to keep us under control in order to change a human being into this." [reveals 1000W PSU and row of graphics cards]
- kadoban 5y agoThe original story for the Matrix was pretty much that, I've heard. I still wish they'd kept that bit, it made way more sense than using humans as batteries or power supplies.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- bobm_kite9 5y agoEveryone seems to be joking about this, but doesn’t this result indicate that human neurones have a better learning algorithm than the ones we are using to train AI? It’s interesting that this is evident in even small clumps of human brain tissue. Really interested to know how this might work.
- ahartmetz 5y agoI'd be very surprised if biological brains couldn't do better than fancy gradient descent, which is what the current standard seems to be for artificial neuronal networks.
- azeirah 5y agoWhat always perplexes me about AI is that while the neuron models may be reasonably representative of how neurons work in brains, the connections are not similar at all. Deep learning uses layers. All neurons in layer one connect to layer 2, connect to layer 3, connect to layer 4, and so on... In a real brain, neurons connect all over the place. It's a bigraph. Deep learning isn't even really a graph per sé, it's a hierarchy, or a weird tree if you will. I suspect a lot of our intelligence comes from neurons living connecting through a bigraph substrate rather than a hierarchy. Is there any research on this? Neurons feeding back onto themselves just seems natural to me, but I don't encounter anything on it.
- fooker 5y agoBackpropagation sort of handles this. The real reason we don't have what you describe is learning algorithms have to be efficient. So, our training/inference algorithms and 'neural' network design is all targeted to be easily representable as matrix multiplications. Maybe with some hypothetical analog computer we could have fast training of arbitrary networks.
- dragontamer 5y agoWith "Evangelion" being in the (Hacker) news recently, I hope to remind people of this one scene... An advanced AI named "The Three Magi" (which are 3-programs which vote for strategic effects) exists in the show. Without going too much into details, a problem occurs in the AI, so the lead scientist Ritsuko steps into the machine to check things out. She comes with a circular saw. She cuts open one computer (the one named "Caspar") ... revealing to the audience that inside is a living brain, hooked up to a bunch of wires: https://imgur.com/MTZ7pzU https://imgur.com/MTZ7pzU This is the first point where the audience probably starts to wonder about the ethics of the main characters. The later reveals of their bio-engineering / morals are more horrifying. But this is perhaps the audience's first look into the inner-workings of the NERV organization / science that they do.
- calo_star 5y agoThat scene was so cool in a disturbing way!
- amelius 5y agoI can already envision HFT traders putting human brains into boxes which are then colocated at the exchanges and everyone thinks it's okay.
- dr1337 5y agoThey're already doing it with mice! - https://www.pymnts.com/cryptocurrency/2021/crypto-trading-rodent-beating-the-market/ https://www.pymnts.com/cryptocurrency/2021/crypto-trading-ro...
- wombatpm 5y agoOnly until they can put clones into an isolated environment to build a sentient AI. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destination:_Void https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Destination:_Void
- serf 5y ago>This is the first point where the audience probably starts to wonder about the ethics of the main characters. that's a very impactful scene, but honestly there are moral/ethical red flags about many of the main characters from the very first episode.
- T-A 5y agoFrom 2004: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2004/10/041022104658.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2004/10/041022104658.h...
- gus_massa 5y agoI cant find the part about "faster than AI" in the research paper. It's very difficult to compare. Do you use a single computer or a cluster? Do you compare wall clock time, or energy consumption, or weigh of the processor, or ...?
- cblconfederate 5y agoMe neither, i don't think that was the interesting part about the paper at all, but the fact that they were even able to train a clump of cells to do something is very exciting. Also their finding that human cells work better than mouse cells.
- dr1337 5y agoYeah, I don't think it's mentioned in the paper however in the New Scientist podcast it was alluded to by the lead author that there is currently work being done to compare. I'd reason that they are looking at wall clock time since ML systems can train in no time if done in a batch-accelerated process.
- dr1337 5y agoFound the visualizer they used for the videos here - https://spikestream.corticallabs.com https://spikestream.corticallabs.com Very cool WebGL implementation. I hope they release the dataset so that we can visualize all the games and maybe do our own analysis on them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- damiankennedy 5y agoBut seriously, I wonder if the "clump of human brain cells" gets tired or needs to sleep or, need any other nourishment. The COHBC might learn faster but can it then keep playing at the same level 24/7? edit: disclaimer, I am a COHBC.
- subroutine 5y agoAs far as I can tell, this is just a clever trick. The cultured neurons aren't really learning anything. The researchers are stimulating one side of the array (top or bottom), to indicate if the ball is above or below the paddle, and based on the ensuing response the computer moves the paddle up or down. Here's the trick - if you stimulate a group of neurons, their spontaneous activity will be (briefly) different from an unstimulated group. You can use this fact to make it seem like the NN is learning to play pong. It would be like claiming a network of cats can learn to play pong. I put cats in two different boxes. To tell the cats whether the ball is above or below the paddle I will spray water into one of the boxes. Then I will listen for hissing from both boxes. Based on where I hear the most hissing is the direction i move the paddle.
- gentleman11 5y agoI’m really disillusioned by science this year. Almost every study I’ve read about on hn in the last year had serious methodology issues
- wolverine876 5y agoPerhaps that's in the HN comments more than in the research. IME, for as long as I've read HN, commenters have claimed to have found errors in methodology or similar basic problems. I don't know if I've seen any research posted that didn't receive that response.
- zzt123 5y agoI feel like academica kind of incentivizes this. It’s hard to resist without a good base of support, and I feel like having such a base isn’t the average. I notice this pressure felt strongly across the board by my friends who are adjuncts (or tenure-track, but not yet tenured) in the soft sciences. But this is just anecdotal of course.
- wolverine876 5y ago> I feel like academica kind of incentivizes this. It’s hard to resist without a good base of support Incentivizes what? What is hard to resist?
- simmo9000 5y agoSo we may be able to use brains instead of GPUs sometime? Phase 1: Collect brains... Phase 2: Phase 3: Profit!
- wolverine876 5y agoThe New Scientist part before the paywall mentions only human brain cells, but the paper is specifically about cells "integrated with in silico computing via high-density multielectrode array". The abstract: https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.02.471005v1 https://www.biorxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.02.471005v1 Integrating neurons into digital systems to leverage their innate intelligence may enable performance infeasible with silicon alone, along with providing insight into the cellular origin of intelligence. We developed DishBrain, a system which exhibits natural intelligence by harnessing the inherent adaptive computation of neurons in a structured environment. In vitro neural networks from human or rodent origins, are integrated with in silico computing via high-density multielectrode array. Through electrophysiological stimulation and recording, cultures were embedded in a simulated game-world, mimicking the arcade game ‘Pong’. Applying a previously untestable theory of active inference via the Free Energy Principle, we found that learning was apparent within five minutes of real-time gameplay, not observed in control conditions. Further experiments demonstrate the importance of closed-loop structured feedback in eliciting learning over time. Cultures display the ability to self-organise in a goal-directed manner in response to sparse sensory information about the consequences of their actions.
- signal4him 5y agoThe last bit is a spicy summation of what we're all here for.
- wcoenen 5y agoRat neurons hooked up to a flight sim in 2004: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2004/10/041022104658.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2004/10/041022104658.h...
- celeduc 5y agoTypical human brain cells, they just want to play retro video games.