14 ms·
Omicron largely evades immunity from past infection or two vaccine doses
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jeidz 5y agoIf it evades immunity from past infection isn’t it a different virus in the practical sense?
- tux3 5y agoNote that the same vaccines are still effective against omicron, just less than against delta. It's also still a coronavirus that binds to ACE2, it's the same mechanism with several new mutations.
- SubiculumCode 5y agoWell, since the booster seems to protect, no? I am hoping that Omicron will boost immunity versus delta while being more mild. This makes me suspect that this will be the case: https://abcnews.go.com/Health/wireStory/omicron-dominant-wastewater-samples-florida-county-81793644 https://abcnews.go.com/Health/wireStory/omicron-dominant-was... "Even though there have been practically no cases of clinical infection, wastewater samples show that the new omicron variant is now the dominant strain of COVID-19 in the Florida county that is home to the nation's largest theme park resorts, officials said this week."
- pakitan 5y ago> Well, since the booster seems to protect, no? That hasn't been proven, as far as I know. Pfizer did some in vitro study but we still have no idea if that translates to real world results.
- SubiculumCode 5y agoThat is an accurate statement I believe. However, given it is the only available evidence we have, it is probably the most accurate prediction that we have, so let's call it our prior.
- corin_ 5y agoFrom the article this thread is about (italics emphasis added by me): > The researchers found a significantly increased risk of developing a symptomatic Omicron case compared to Delta for those who were two or more weeks past their second vaccine dose, and two or more weeks past their booster dose (for AstraZeneca and Pfizer vaccines). > Depending on the estimates used for vaccine effectiveness against symptomatic infection from the Delta variant, this translates into vaccine effectiveness estimates against symptomatic Omicron infection of between 0% and 20% after two doses, and between 55% and 80% after a booster dose. Similar estimates were obtained using genotype data, albeit with greater uncertainty.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoI wonder if they saw more traces from the theme park wastewater... Business idea: device that you plug to your home wastewater output, scans it, and reports to you anything interesting. Of course it'd need to be connected to the cloud and have a stupid subscription fee. /s . At least then "Internet of Shit" will apply to the name non-sarcastically.
- Xylakant 5y agoYou’re late to the party. Smart toilet, identifies you by looking at your butthole https://www.vice.com/en/article/jge377/stanford-smart-toilet-uses-butthole-for-identification https://www.vice.com/en/article/jge377/stanford-smart-toilet...
- kurthr 5y agoUnfortunately, the mutation differences between Delta and Omicron are more significant than from the early Alpha/Beta which it appears to be more related. https://nextstrain.org/ncov/gisaid/global https://nextstrain.org/ncov/gisaid/global (see B1.1.529) It's fitness is driven (in South Africa) largely by the ability to avoid Delta immunity, where a majority of the population has already had that. Whether Omicron is more mild or not seems still up in the air. Saying that it is more mild in Southern Africa (or a theme park?) where the average age is in the mid 20s (rather than 38 for the whole US) isn't all that relevant since we know symptomatic illness falls more than an order of magnitude between those two. That said, I've been expecting COVID immunity in the US to look something like Pfizer-Pfizer-Delta-Omicron-Omega since it was clear that we couldn't get more that 60% vaccination. The goal should be keeping the hospitals available for actual catastrophic accidents (heart attacks, car accidents, ladders) rather than complex suicide lottery attempts. Frankly, at this point it's a choice. You can be a rude nudist/antimasker, a filthy contagion/antivaxer who will spread disease or you can be a regular human who goes about their life. Other than the old/infirm we don't need to protect people from their (bad) decisions any more. I'm glad I'm not immune compromised, 80 years old, or caring for a very young child... it would suck!
- reedf1 5y agoBiological taxonomy is largely arbitrary. From a practical perspective it has very similar characteristics, so not much is gained from distinguishing it.
- thinkharderdev 5y agoNot really, evasion is a continuum rather than a binary distinction. So Omicron seems like it evades immunity acquired from infection with previous variants or vaccines to a certain degree, but from what I have read with vaccine + booster you are still ~60-80% protected from symptomatic infection and almost entirely protected from severe outcomes.
- figaroniguzo 5y agoAnecdotal but I currently have Omicron. I had COVID in March 2021 and got vaccinated in September. I have no symptom except back pain.
- triactual 5y agoWhile anecdotal data isn’t very useful, it is good to remember that people actually do get this disease. It seems like it’s always at arms length in online discussions; that someone else will get it surely, probably due to some implied moral failing, but not OP. Thanks for sharing and I hope you get better soon.
- 13years 5y ago> good to remember that people actually do get this disease. Why does it continue to be significantly important to call this out when the trajectory places Omicron and possible future variants within the realms of cold/flu ?
- triactual 5y agoTo remember that normal people from our own social circles get infected and usually survive just fine. Rather than pretending that every infection is an overweight, anti-vaxxer, etc. who dies immediately after destroying the local medical facilities. I think both sides of the severity discussion would benefit from keeping the human consequences in mind, whether they are more or less severe than imagined.
- 13years 5y agoAgreed, yet at some point society has to be productive again. Living in constant anxiety will ultimately be more destructive than the disease everyone fears if it has not already.
- triactual 5y agoI actually completely agree. COVID is endemic so now we’re just prolonging the inevitable getting-on-with-it and the only question is how much damage we do pretending otherwise.
- drewg123 5y agoFrom the article: this translates into vaccine effectiveness estimates against symptomatic Omicron infection of between 0% and 20% after two doses, and between 55% and 80% after a booster dose What I'm wondering is: Is this due to the timing of a booster, since most boosters have been given in the last few months? Or is there some kind of cumulative impact on the immune system? Eg, If I got a booster early, am I still as protected as they state above?
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoAnother question would be, what if someone got their first dose 6 weeks ago and their second one 2 weeks ago?
- SubiculumCode 5y agoMaybe recency is not the sole factor: https://i.imgur.com/OzznuBa.png https://i.imgur.com/OzznuBa.png edit: source: https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.14.21267769v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2021.12.14.21267769v...
- koshergweilo 5y agoNo one is going to trust a random imgur link. Source or it didn't happen
- knuthsat 5y agoOr, another hypothesis, your immune system is busy dealing with the vaccine and just ignores the omicron virus in your noes and this stops the spread?
- thinkharderdev 5y agoThe booster dose increases antibody titers significantly above what they were after the second dose (or first in the case of J&J) so someone who is boosted should be more protected than someone who got their second dose at the same time. Additionally, through the process of affinity maturation, the antibodies you have after a booster will be more likely to recognize Omicron because your immune system has learned to recognize more features of the virus spike protein and is more robust to mutations.
- robbmorganf 5y agoDoes anyone understand why a third dose of the same vaccine improves immunity to Omicron? I'm willing to believe the empirical evidence that boosters make a meaningful difference, but I can't figure out intuitively why the same mRNA a third time helps to address this new spike.
- eagsalazar2 5y agoMaybe it is less about it being the 2nd or 3rd shot and more about how recently you received your last shot? I got my 2nd shot 7 months ago and we've already heard that protection fades over time, so maybe the booster just works because it boosts, not because it is really any different than my 2nd shot.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y ago> Maybe is ... about how recently you received your last shot .. not because it is really any different than my 2nd shot. No. That appears not be the situation. Immunity shortly after the thirds shot is substantially higher than shortly after the second https://twitter.com/PaulMainwood/status/1460191035531878405 https://twitter.com/PaulMainwood/status/1460191035531878405 https://twitter.com/PaulMainwood/status/1458026852249919490 https://twitter.com/PaulMainwood/status/1458026852249919490
- eightysixfour 5y agoI have seen speculation that the second dose was given too quickly.
- wlesieutre 5y agoI wonder if that's a factor in the Pfizer/BioNTech vs Moderna performance. Moderna had a higher dosage, but it was also 4 weeks between doses instead of 3.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y ago
- andy_ppp 5y agoRealistically we are probably going to be exposed to Omicron in the next 3 weeks here in the UK, is there much point in having a booster right now? Are we sure that it will actually be providing protection if I got a booster today and got COVID in, say, the next 7 days?
- JulianMorrison 5y agoProbably some, if not the full amount.
- sp332 5y agoSure. The effectiveness of the vaccine rises over time, which means you will have some protection even after a few days. And the vaccine also protects against serious illness, so if you get covid in 7 days you might be wishing for lighter symptoms about a week after that. Basically, getting your immune system any amount of head start would be great.
- thebruce87m 5y agoI’m sure if you got COVID a few days after you’d be protected you’d be kicking yourself. I got mine yesterday after booking on Monday so you might be able to get it sooner than you think. I didn’t even take the first day available due to a conflict.
- dragontamer 5y agoI took the Moderna booster. In my case, I had fatigue and cramps within 24 hours (not as bad as the 2nd dose, but felt worse than the 1st dose). Clearly, my immune system was responding immediately. The stats say I'm not fully protected until 2-weeks later. But I know for a fact that my body was reacting within a day.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tehjoker 5y agoYes, get it ASAP. You should not assume that you'll get it that soon and therefore it's pointless even if many many people will. The booster also triggers a secondary immune response which rises faster and bigger than the primary response. Get your boosters ASAP! You want to go into this crisis with shields up, weapons online.
- makomk 5y agoThis news came out shortly after the UK mandated proof of two vaccine doses (or a negative test, though there's some suspicion this option will be removed like in many other European countries) for access to nightclubs and other large events. It is also not surprising and was expected when the decision was taken. Between this and other recent news I don't think trust in the establishment is exactly high right now.
- valine 5y agoThe sooner they mandate a third does the better. Not sure why this news would lower trust in the government, can you elaborate on that?
- chiefalchemist 5y agoBecause the promises aren't panning out, and with each stutter step comes another heavy handed proposal (e.g., tracking, vax passports, etc.) In desperation the public has abandoned "trust but verify." Put another way, given the lessons of history, governments should be trusted less, not more. The default shouldn't not be, "Sure, whatever you say."
- mypalmike 5y agoGovernments are adapting to new information. If you expect government policy to be based on an all-knowing oracle, of course you are going to be disappointed.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 5y agoIf I said that. If I implied that. Please point it out to me.
- mypalmike 5y ago
- marban 5y agoNot really a new finding. Norway's curve gives a decent hint at where we're heading to.
- snewman 5y agoIt's worth clarifying: un-boosted vaccination or past infection seem to have greatly reduced ability to prevent infection with Omicron. There is still substantial (lessened, but not as drastically lessened) protection against serious illness / death. My understanding is that protection-against-infection and protection-against-death rely on different aspects of the immune system. The primary protection against initial infection comes from antibodies, which are narrowly targeted. Other systems are more flexible, but don't kick in quickly enough to ward off a mild infection. And the takeaway is still: get vaccinated, get boosted.
- abduhl 5y agoWhat you’re saying sounds correct, but is there any evidence that shows omicron is resulting in less serious illness/death because of the vaccines? The reports seem to indicate that the overall risk profile of omicron is lower including for unvaccinated people. Are we just parroting the same fact as for the alpha/delta variants without any substantial evidence here when we say vaccination helps avoid serious illness for omicron? Why would a variant which has apparently evolved to evade the vaccine continue to react to prior vaccination? We see the opposite with flu vaccines sometimes when vaccinations prime against the wrong strain.
- ugjka 5y agogive it a month or two and we'll see who's right or wrong
- snewman 5y agoHard information regarding serious illness / death from Omicron is scanty; it's still early. I've read indications that the vaccines (and/or previous infection with another variant, such as Delta) do seem to provide substantial protection against serious illness/death, but I don't have a link handy. IIRC at least some of the data we're working with is based on lab experiments of how various immune system components react to Omicron, which of course is less definitive than clinical outcomes, but is worth something. > Why would a variant which has apparently evolved to evade the vaccine continue to react to prior vaccination? This is over-simplified. In particular, "react to prior vaccination" is conflating a bunch of different things, involving antibodies, B cells, T cells, etc. My understanding is that (1) such data as we have seems to generally point toward protection-from-infection being badly eroded but protection-from-illness/death being only moderately eroded, (2) if you're boosted, protection is less badly eroded, (3) all of this seems to fit with our general understanding of how the immune system works. I don't have the domain knowledge to unpack that further.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoI didn't download the full report (pdf) but this news (?) article and the link to source (in the first line) don't mention sample size.
- matthewmacleod 5y agoAlso important to note: The study finds no evidence of Omicron having lower severity than Delta, judged by either the proportion of people testing positive who report symptoms, or by the proportion of cases seeking hospital care after infection. With the qualification: However, hospitalisation data remains very limited at this time. So, hopefully this proves to not be the case. Given the speed at which this variant appears to be ripping through the UK—with cases doubling every ~48 hours—it could quickly cause quite a lot of pressure on the healthcare system – not to mention the knock-on effects of so many people isolating.
- mygoodaccount 5y agoWhat about both? I have both past infection and I'm double vaxxed. Based on the data, should I get boosted? From what I'm reading the answer is yes but does anybody have an estimation of my protection right now?
- ugjka 5y agoIt is called hybrid immunity and it is much longer lasting https://www.news-medical.net/news/20211202/Hybrid-immunity-provides-the-highest-and-most-durable-immunity-against-SARS-CoV-2-infection.aspx https://www.news-medical.net/news/20211202/Hybrid-immunity-p... "The overall protection provided by two doses of ChAdOX1 was considerably lower than that given by BNT162b2. However, infection-acquired immunity boosted with vaccination-induced immunity remained high over a year after infection. Based on these observations, the authors recommend the strategic use of booster vaccines to prevent SARS-CoV-2 infection and transmission in the population."
- jwineinger 5y agoIs there any indication if double-vax + exposure carries similar benefit? My wife had 2x Pfizer and then she and our kids got delta. I had 2x Moderna and never had symptoms and tested negative 3 times. No quarantining whatsoever -- slept in the same bed as my wife, the kids still crawled all over me. I still got boosted a few weeks ago, but I've been curious if living in a sick-house with 100% certainty of exposure would carry its own booster effect.
- sdeframond 5y agoWhat do you have to loose?
- mygoodaccount 5y agoWell I had a pretty bad second dose response. I was bedridden for a week. That said, my COVID infection was far worse and I'm still struggling with long COVID today. I guess I'm going to have trouble taking a shot (active decision) I know I'll respond badly, albeit temporarily, to. As opposed to waiting around (passive decision) and trying my chances with COVID a second time. Now that I'm writing this all out, I think I'll get my booster, maybe a fourth if I can weasel my way in.
- mbfg 5y agoHas there been any studies if switching vaccines for the booster is more effective or less effective?
- jwineinger 5y agoWhen the CDC released the statement that you could mix, my dad (a physician) was a bit upset. I remember him telling me that they seem to have based that on a single paper that had a sample size far too small to generalize for the different combinations of vaccines, age groups, genders, and races.
- wooque 5y agoSo like a common cold?
- senectus1 5y agofor vaccinated people yes. unless you're really compromised or unlucky. then its near death or a death experience.
- alpineidyll3 5y agoOmg I have this garbage right now and I'm doubly vaccinated. I recommend anyone visiting vulnerable family get tested before heading out. It's going to be a very weird NYE, again.
- goldenchrome 5y agoWhat happens when it mutates again? Do we need to keep society shut down and enforce a booster for each variant?
- timbit42 5y agoPossibly. It depends on how it mutates.
- spicyusername 5y agoIt's either that or everyone openly accepts the ensuing suffering and death as an acceptable tradeoff. Neither are particularly great options, but nobody said life was guaranteed to be easy or simple.
- a0-prw 5y agoHere's some numbers from 15 December in Denmark, relating to Omicron infections: 76,93% of the poulation are vaccinated. Of Omicron positive cases 89,59% were either double or triple vaccinated. 8,49% were unvaccinated. Why are the unvaccinated underrepresented? Source: https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/status-paa-coronavirus-lige-nu https://www.dr.dk/nyheder/indland/status-paa-coronavirus-lig...