10 ms·
You can raise hell about this. The FCC regulates 911 service. Here's the form for filing a complaint about 911 service: https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc
by Animats 5y ago
You can raise hell about this.
The FCC regulates 911 service. Here's the form for filing a complaint about 911 service:
https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us/requests/new?ticket_form_id=35840 https://consumercomplaints.fcc.gov/hc/en-us/requests/new?tic...
States also regulate 911 service. Try your state's office of emergency services.
There's something called "Kari's Law" that may apply here. This was passed in 2018 after someone was being attacked in a hotel room and their 9 year old daughter tried to call 911. She couldn't get through because the phone system required dialing 9 for an outside line. So, now, all business phone systems are required to recognize and pass through 911 to the main phone network. There are criminal penalties. (Microsoft might argue that "Teams" is not a "multi-line telephone system". That probably wouldn't go far with a jury. The clear intent of the law is that if you interpose something between a phone handset and the 911 network, it has to pass through 911 calls.)
The whole 911 area is heavily regulated, since it requires that so many things interoperate reliably.
- strenholme 5y agoFor more on Kari’s law: https://www.fcc.gov/news-events/podcast/personal-story-behind-karis-law https://www.fcc.gov/news-events/podcast/personal-story-behin...
- protomyth 5y agoMicrosoft might argue that "Teams" is not a "multi-line telephone system". That probably wouldn't go far with a jury. The clear intent of the law is that if you interpose something between a phone handset and the 911 network, it has to pass through 911 calls. Google may blame Microsoft but there is no way an app should be able to disable 911 calling on a phone. This means that other apps could disable 911 intentionally. This is Google's problem to fix. A phone OS needs to guarantee certain things and 911 is one of them.
- Forgeties79 5y agoThe problem is Google already does virtually nothing to manage/vet the apps on their store. It’s basically a free-for-all.
- raverbashing 5y agoYes. And other countries emergency numbers as well. The perils of treating phone as "just another app", lack of testing, etc.
- jeltz 5y agoI think 112 must work everywhere according to some standard (the GSM standard?).
- martopix 5y agoGSM standard + standard in the EU also for landlines.
- nly 5y agoIn many other countries 911 works as well, simply because it's pervasive across TV.
- plebianRube 5y agoI've would have dialed: 0118 999 881 999 119 7253 I thought it had been changed for ages.
- midjji 5y agoI wonder if this is a result of various ways microsoft software is trying to force users to login to a microsoft account. If so the problem will be systemic as the microsoft programmers will be in an ongoing battle to disable as much unrelated stuff as possible.
- llampx 5y agoCan you use MS Teams without a MS account?
- tjoff 5y agoEvery once in a blue moon you get logged out and need to log in again. Teams seem to cache some stuff and not others so in that case behavior isn't exactly intuitive. I am not the least surprised that it trigger crashes.
- organsnyder 5y agoOr if your account is deleted (such as when you leave a company), I could see this happening.
- cure 5y agoNot last time I tried. That flow (i.e. you are not part of/logged into an institutional Teams account) is completely broken. Teams makes you go create a free Microsoft account, which then doesn't work to log into Teams.
- midjji 5y agoIts almost like microsoft utterly fails to understand why zoom dominated... Its strange how many companies believe their own lies about anything requiring an explicit account being a good idea...
- ddingus 5y agoOn Mobile, I do it with a browser "Show Desktop Version" and click on the "Continue on this browser" option. This is only an option when one doesn't need to fully participate in Teams, which is the case for me. I do not currently use a Microsoft account for anything. I have one, and once in a while, I log in with it for some reason or other. Everything else is a Office 365 account tied to an email provided by the people funding that access. For me personally, using OSS gets the job done for all my computing needs otherwise.
- dessant 5y agoHalf of Google's response is corporate speak that plays down the issue. The priority here should have been to explain and disseminate the workaround, not to start with several sentences of establishing that the blame must be shared. https://web.archive.org/web/20211209094433/https://www.reddit.com/r/GooglePixel/comments/r4xz1f/pixel_prevented_me_from_calling_911/hnrvsr1/ https://web.archive.org/web/20211209094433/https://www.reddi... https://archive.vn/20211209094437/https://www.reddit.com/r/GooglePixel/comments/r4xz1f/pixel_prevented_me_from_calling_911/hnrvsr1/ https://archive.vn/20211209094437/https://www.reddit.com/r/G... > We will also be providing an Android platform update to the Android ecosystem on January 4. They postpone the fix to the next regular patch release, while fully knowing that other apps could trigger the same bug, including malware. This is criminal negligence. Google also has the power to immediately disable Microsoft Teams on most Android devices, until the fix is rolled out. They are taking down apps for dubious reasons all the time. But when a popular app triggers a life-threatening bug, then let's wait for them to issue an update, here are some tricks to avoid the bug, don't forget to tell grandma.
- esquivalience 5y agoDisagree. They provided context allowing people to understand the reason for what would otherwise seem a bizarre set of steps that seem to cure the problem in the meantime. It's clear and direct.
- dessant 5y agoContext can be provided without all the filler expressions that play down the issue as the sentences progress. By the time they arrive to the workaround, this is how they continue: > Out of an abundance of caution, in the meantime, we suggest Does that suggest urgency to you? > Because this issue impacts emergency calling, both Google and Microsoft are heavily prioritizing the issue, and we expect a Microsoft Teams app update to be rolled out soon – as always we suggest users keep an eye out for app updates to ensure they are running the latest version. We will also be providing an Android platform update to the Android ecosystem on January 4. I believe heavy prioritization shouldn't involve planning to wait an entire month to issue an Android update.
- lr1970 5y ago> Google may blame Microsoft but there is no way an app should be able to disable 911 calling on a phone. Google runs a battery of automated tests on any app before admitting it to the Play Store. A part of this testing should be simulated 911 calls. Failing to do so could open Google to liability through negligence.
- gruez 5y agoIt's obvious now that such a test should exist, but hindsight is 20/20. Does the law actually require that?
- lr1970 5y agoThe law mandates the functionality. How to enable and test this functionality is the responsibility of the carrier. Whether the compliance is achieved by testing third-party apps or via an in-house bypass implementation is immaterial. On the other hand, assigning liability for non-compliance is tricky and for Google the jury is still out (pan intended).
- nvarsj 5y agoAndroid is a general purpose embedded OS, it's not just used on devices with cell radios. It doesn't manage the BP (cell phone processor) either afaik. For example, a voip android desk phone - it relies on voip to make calls. Android is agnostic about it and allows third party software to handle underlying calls, whether it is Qualcomm/Samsung/etc software for cell calls or Microsoft Teams for VOIP. There isn't a straightforward approach here for Android. It's not like iOS where Apple owns the entire software stack, including modem software.
- bobbylarrybobby 5y agoWouldn’t the straightforward approach just to be to test 911 connections on devices with telephony available?
- tacobelllover99 5y agothank you captain obvious
- OJFord 5y agoWhat if you want to dial an external line that begins 11? How long should it wait before deciding you're stopping at 911?
- corobo 5y agoCan we not just change the 9 for an outside line to a 0 or 3 or something? Seems like we put too much stuff on the 9, it's not like we're still using rotary phones
- AstralStorm 5y agoNormally 0 or + are supposed to be used for external lines. Then you would call 00 for an international call.
- 0xffff2 5y agoBizarrely, my work office phone (at a US Federal agency no less) was switched from 7 for an outside line to 9 just before the pandemic hit. People really like 9 for some reason.
- testplzignore 5y agoIn the North American Numbering Plan, a phone number (neither 7 digit or 10 digit with the area code) can start with a 1.
- OJFord 5y agoAnd no 'special' ones (like 911)? e.g. 112. Relatedly, countries usually implement each other's codes for tourists' and children who watch foreign films' benefit - 999, 911, and 112 will all work in the UK for example. And when you say area codes [can't] start with a 1, is that only when you include a 0 prefix? Country codes can start with 1. There doesn't seem to be a +11~, but is it forbidden? Are there no US or Canada (+1) numbers that start with even a single 1?
- jcrites 5y ago
- leokennis 5y agoWhy raise hell about this? There is an issue in Android/Teams/inbetween, a user reported the issue and all involved parties acknowledged the issue and are "heavily prioritizing" fixing the issue. What would filing a complaint improve to this process?
- pdpi 5y ago“All parties acknowledged and prioritising” is a fine state of affairs for a “file sync ate my data” bug, but you don’t get to sweep a potential criminal issue under the rug like that.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- OneLeggedCat 5y ago"heavily prioritizing" here means Google doesn't currently plan to fix it until some date in January, from what I read in their response to the Reddit post.
- cesarb 5y ago> "heavily prioritizing" here means Google doesn't currently plan to fix it until some date in January Like Microsoft with Windows, Google releases their security fixes for Android monthly. And January 4 is obviously the date for the next one (it goes out at the beginning of each month, and AFAIK the December one has already gone out). So the fix (which might even be ready already) is going to be released on the first opportunity.
- rswail 5y agoThis is not a "security" fix. This is a health and safety fix. This is at the same time as we head into a) the holiday season in much of the world, b) winter in much of the world, c) an ongoing pandemic that is dealing with the spread of a new variant and the roll out of not only initial vaccines but also boosters. Having emergency calls not go through because of a bug needs to be fixed immediately, not subject to some update cycle.
- nickff 5y agoTeams is actually integrated with many PBX multi-line systems, including the popular 3CX. You can place calls via the PBX from Teams.
- swiley 5y agoPeople who argue Android is superior to PMOS take note.
- giantg2 5y agoIn my experience, the feds don't have the resources to investigate many of the things that the law says they can/will. Usually they look at the most egregious ones, it takes a long time to get around to it.
- danlugo92 5y agoFrom the link: "Google Support reached out to me through here " So multi million fine threats is how you get to a human at Google.
- taneq 5y agoIsn't that how you get any organism's attention against its will? You scare it.
- willis936 5y agoGoogle is not scared of fines. They're more akin to a machine. if fine cost * probability of fine being issued > cost to address then address else end.
- mikepurvis 5y ago"A new car built by my company leaves somewhere traveling at 60 mph. The rear differential locks up. The car crashes and burns with everyone trapped inside. Now, should we initiate a recall? Take the number of vehicles in the field, A, multiply by the probable rate of failure, B, multiply by the average out-of-court settlement, C. A times B times C equals X. If X is less than the cost of a recall, we don't do one."
- technobabbler 5y agoTo be fair, though, what would you do if you were the decision maker? Would you really give up one of your yachts this year just to save ten thousand lives?
- mikepurvis 5y agoUnfettered capitalism says that the corporation has no conscience and if it can clear responsibility for the death with an out of court settlement, then that's it done and there's no further business. The obvious fix is some kind of government/regulatory involvement that introduces additional fines/costs for bad behaviour, whether specific to endangering the public or more broad. And of course, sometimes this is upfront standards stuff like we have for emissions, lighting, seatbelts, etc, whereas other times it's prosecuted as a negligence charge after that fact.
- tallanvor 5y agoPersonally, I would argue that if Teams is able to somehow interfere with dialing 911 from outside of the app, that's a major Android bug much more than a Teams bug. --The last thing you want is any app to be able to interfere with emergency calls whether it's intentional or not. But Microsoft is certainly not going to try and argue that Teams doesn't have to be able to make emergency calls, at least not when it's used as a VOIP solution - they have plenty of documentation to help ensure emergency calls are routed properly: https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoftteams/what-are-emergency-locations-addresses-and-call-routing https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/microsoftteams/what-are-eme...
- herbst 5y agoTo be fair it is my phone, so I kinda expect to be able to use it however I want. If I want to overwrite these numbers I should be able to. I don't see why Google is to blame here
- codyogden 5y agoThis is probably the most preposterous take I’ve seen about this situation. “It’s my phone!! If I want to disable 911, I should be able to!!!” What ridiculousness! There are so many regulated, built-in fallbacks to ensure anyone can reach emergency services from any cellular device that is within any network range. You don’t need a SIM, an active plan, and you don’t even need to unlock the phone first. Google should be handling emergency services calls on the cellular network, and should have always prevented any third-party software from interfering.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> Personally, I would argue that if Teams is able to somehow interfere with dialing 911 from outside of the app, that's a major Android bug much more than a Teams bug. --The last thing you want is any app to be able to interfere with emergency calls whether it's intentional or not. Ironically, Microsoft wrote a lot about compatibility in Windows and all the tricks they used to make sure apps that were using APIs wrong (or just flat out pulled crazy stunts to hook themselves into Windows) could still run fine even on newer versions. Sad to see Google didn't apply the same engineering principles and are trying to shift the blame. Maybe because most Pixel phones are outside of their two years of updates... > But Microsoft is certainly not going to try and argue that Teams doesn't have to be able to make emergency calls, at least not when it's used as a VOIP solution - they have plenty of documentation to help ensure emergency calls are routed properly Teams can also run on devices where it's maximized and the only app available from the UI (think conference rooms). In this case it makes sense for it to handle emergency calls. But on Android where the user can be signed-in to N different phone apps at the same time? Not so much.
- technobabbler 5y agoDo you really think Google gives a damn about the FCC, much less the state governments? They'd probably just ask them to submit a feedback request with a screenshot.
- la6471 5y agoGoogle should pay for it. These phones should be off the market until it is fixed. Where are the goddamn regulatory bodies?? This is crazy.