20 ms·
Do you ever avoid submitting something on HN so devs won't ruin it?
Let's say I found a way to bring back the number of dislikes of YT videos. Knowing that some YT devs are on the platform, I'd be reluctant to share it so that they won't know about it [0] and ruin the already-ruined YT experience. It shouldn't be like this, I know. But I've lost hope in the well-intentions of some devs in the industry. I thought we were supposed to have each other's back, but apparently money makes people do anything.
[0]: At least for quite some time.
Edit: By "well-intentions" and "having each-other's back", I mean devs doing something that most devs would enjoy, not making each other's life harder. Going back to my example: As a dev, how many times have you watched a YT tutorial to sharpen your skills? Now w/o the dislikes count, all devs have a much harder time filtering useless videos. Whoever removed the dislike count on YT has caused millions of wasted hour-man. Then again, if they're paid well, many devs would do the same.
- Flankk 5y agoThere's already extensions to bring back the dislikes. Last I heard they're removing them from the YouTube API in three months. And yes, I don't post things here because I don't want to get hacked. Lots of big brains here.
- ushakov 5y agothe ratio will stay though with a like and ratio number you can reverse-calculate the amount of dislikes
- lnanek2 5y agoIsn't there a population shift, though? The users who will install an extension for this have different tastes than the users who won't, so you can't assume the like-dislike ratio for the population who will matches the population who won't.
- gus_massa 5y agoMoreover, it will be easier to brigade (or shill). If a video has 1M upvotes in YouTube and 1K upvotes in the site, then with 1K enthusiast you can tilt the count. (And for obscure videos with 100 or 1000 less upvotes in YT, it will be easier.)
- soledades 5y agoIf not many people use it, there will be much less incentive to shill
- soledades 5y agoBut maybe the signal is even better in the subpopulation
- cphoover 5y agoYou could create like a 3rd party like dislike service... That sends two requests one to YT and one to your 3p service that stores the count in a redis key value store with the id of the video and the count.
- datenarsch 5y agoUnless you get 95% of people to use such an extension, it will be mostly useless. And if somebody succeeded in getting 95% of people to use their extension, they would sell it to the highest bidder in a heartbeat, as has happened many times before. YouTube is dead, it's time to create something new.
- mucle6 5y agoToday I learned that any statistic created using <95% of the population is invalid
- cphoover 5y agoI kind of agree... we need a new YT
- 0des 5y agowhy only kind of, do you have apprehensions?
- cphoover 5y agoOr a subset of people that are like-minded, whose votes you value more than the general youtube population en mass.
- dewey 5y agoI think you are overestimating how many people care about the dislike count. Of course there's a bunch of people who are loud but I doubt most regular users care.
- 1cvmask 5y agoWhatever is here, or anywhere on the Internet, assume the world knows about it. This spot is just a larger megaphone to the developer/tech community. For regular folk they have different watering holes like Twitter or Reddit with overlaps of course.
- teekert 5y agoIf you can bring them back, great, but it should be a complete overlay, not touching YT APIs. That'd be worth an extension.
- throwaway81523 5y ago> Do you ever avoid submitting something on HN so devs won't ruin it? Of course. Do you think I'm going to identify such things here? That's no different than submitting them. See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Don%27t_stuff_beans_up_your_nose https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Don%27t_stuff_beans_...
- dheera 5y agoYes, lots of things. Some services have started to try to detect virtual numbers used for 2FA. I have a way to circumvent that which I don't want to share publicly here.
- ckmar 5y agoI would certainly hate for devs to hate on this top-secret pure orm project [0]. [0] https://github.com/craigmichaelmartin/pure-orm https://github.com/craigmichaelmartin/pure-orm
- eatonphil 5y agoI'd hate for people to hate on this open-source data IDE. https://github.com/multiprocessio/datastation https://github.com/multiprocessio/datastation
- ASalazarMX 5y agoOhhh I can feel the river of hate flowing, good job!
- BatteryMountain 5y agoYeah I do this. Most of what I build, nobody knows about it nor is it release into the wild. Latest example: at my current workplace we have some crappy custom compilers for our platform.... I've rebuilt them in a way that I like (and using C# instead of Java), that enables me to use it in a small visual studio code plugin that enables me with real time error messages as I code against our platform, so basically constantly compiling in the background as the file changes. It's great. Can it improve the lives of the 50 or so other devs working on the same platform? For sure (it saves a ton of time and frustration). Will I tell them about it or release it onto our private git repo's and make it part of our platform/build chains? Nope. I can give you 20 good reason why I won't do it but really don't want to get into it. If they want it, they ask for it & while they are at it, they can pay me a cool sum of money for it. Until then, it is my own private competitive advantage that allows me to work 2 hours per day instead of 8. Not embellishing.
- northisup 5y agowow, super happy I don't work with people like this.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoYou wouldn’t know if you did.
- Philip-J-Fry 5y agoI would because they'd be more productive than me.
- OnlineGladiator 5y agoThey might be more efficient, but by working 1/4 as much they're equally productive!
- toomuchtodo 5y ago
- charles_f 5y ago> but apparently money makes people do anything. I don't see the link with your example. How would people profit of finding the number of dislikes on YouTube? Also, sharing this would increase the number of users of the exploit, and its general publicity, making it more likely to be fixed. Nothing to do with having each other's back. And then, considering that you are disclosing a security leak, the "having each other's back" thing to do here is disclosing that to google, not exploiting it yourself
- Uehreka 5y agoThis post is doing a great job at smoking out the narcs.
- charles_f 5y agoSh*, I've been uncovered!
- enumjorge 5y agoI assumed the OP meant that sharing it here would mean someone on the YT team would see it and fix it. As opposed to having their hacker ethos win out and let the bug stay I guess?
- behnamoh 5y agoThanks, yes, that's what I meant.
- jayd16 5y agoYeah, the leap here is that OP assumes the dislike change is inherently bad, or universally disliked outside of some minority at Youtube that also doesn't read HN. Why would money need to be the main motivator?
- pddpro 5y agoI know that it would be a pretty biased response but do Corporates not make large decisions only when they think that it'll make them more money? Removing dislike metrics sounds like a supremely large decision.
- shadowgovt 5y agoWithout assuming malicious intent, you can reach the same conclusion (that people who see a workaround for hiding YT downvotes here will respond by trying to patch out the workaround) by assuming conflicting philosophies and incentives. Some devs think YouTube has the right idea. Probably the ones who implemented the change, for example.
- lupire 5y agoThey have way too much work to do; they aren't going to take time to break your extension. They'll break it by accident anyway.
- m463 5y agoWhat you're describing is hard in any corner of the internet because there's a vocal minority of critics, some of whom just won't let go. On the other hand, I find myself doing it. Take a look at the new tesla model S, a very interesting an innovative car and one of the quickest on the planet. But I can't help but talk about what I think is fatally flawed - the lack of dedicated physical controls and a non-round yoke steering wheel.
- omarhaneef 5y agoI don't have anything they will ruin but I do have the opposite: lots of ideas for plugins, apps, features that I wish someone would build (and profit off of), and I suggest those.
- corobo 5y agoI used to use my bank's mobile web interface to monitor my balances (with Zabbix, it even alerted when I'd been paid haha) The mobile page asked for the full passcode whereas the regular page asked for specific digits which, while still automatable, wasn't as easy The code/method might have been useful to others at the time (especially your Mints and that) but I didn't want them changing it. The mobile site was, as far as I could tell, a relic from an older era that I stumbled across by accident Everything's starting to catch up now so it's no longer needed. My bank now (Monzo) even does webhooks for transactions if you set them up :) On the topic of YouTube I really don't get the reaction to removing dislikes, seems a bit overblown. I am biased in that I've never noticed them other than that one Futurama neutral video that keeps them synced with the positive votes though (which ofc is now broken) Incidentally removing the number and replacing it with a big DISLIKE in caps makes it much more noticeable. I am way more likely to click it if the video is bad now, for whatever that matters Edit for OP edit: > Now w/o the dislikes count, all devs have a much harder time filtering useless videos This is the only argument I've seen opposing the removal of dislikes so far. Are there any others? Even silly reasons, anything other than "bad tutorials tho"
- behnamoh 5y agoYT is similar to Coursera, edX, Udacity, etc. in that they all offer tutorial videos. But with YT as a platform, it's the viewer's job to find the best one whereas Coursera and others already review the videos before publishing. Now imagine YT that has enjoyed thousands of additional tutorial videos due to the pandemic and remote classes suddenly stops showing you what other people thought of such tutorials without offering an alternative (such as a "reviewed by YT" badge, etc.) That makes the platform shockingly unusable. I already click on fewer recommended videos and have less incentive to contribute to the platform by clicking the dislike button because I know it will all be for nothing.
- corobo 5y agoClicking the dislike button boosts the video as much as clicking the like button anyway. You're doing everyone a disservice by interacting with bad videos
- wffurr 5y agoI don't understand this sentiment at all. I have no idea what any of what you're posting has to do with "well intentions" or "money mak[ing] people do anything". Are you just mad that dislikes were removed from YouTube? I don't see what that has to do with any of those statements.
- mindcrime 5y agodon't understand this sentiment at all. I have no idea what any of what you're posting has to do with "well intentions" or "money mak[ing] people do anything". Pretty sure they're saying that the YT developers would break their cool hack if they knew about it, because they want to keep their jobs (eg, getting paid, or "making money"). Sounds like the OP wants to view all developers as adhering to some Platonic ideal version of a "hacker ethic" where they wouldn't do something like that for a reason as banal as money. I can sympathise with this position, but I acknowledge the reality that - at the end of the day - people are usually going to prioritize buying food, paying rent, etc., over adherence to abstract ethical principles. That's unfortunate in many ways, but hunger is a powerful motivation. Are you just mad that dislikes were removed from YouTube? I don't see what that has to do with any of those statements. I get the impression that the OP thing was lamenting the YT thing both specifically and as an example of a general class of similar situations... places where you have to hold back from sharing a neat hack because if you shared it, somebody would come along and ruin it.
- behnamoh 5y agoThank you. Yes, that's exactly what I meant.
- ASalazarMX 5y agoThey will break it sooner or later. IMO it's better to release it and let YouTube break it, so the existence of third-party dislike counters becomes more justified, by their own doing.
- wffurr 5y agoThat's... incredibly naive. And I don't think YouTube dislikes are a clear-cut case of "bad thing done for money". It can easily be argued either way. It's also naive to think that YouTube developers don't already know about said hacks / workarounds.
- legrande 5y agoDesign by internal committees is largely a bad move since your users will always want decisions reversed, or call any new features 'feature creep' or over-engineering. There is a trend of design where secrecy is allowed because devs code for 'the developer experience' and not the 'user experience'. Striking a balance between those two is worth it IMHO. (If that means feedback from your users then so be it, but don't let the users dictate the whole of the system).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hwbehrens 5y ago> I thought we were supposed to have each other's back, There are 3 to 4 million devs in the US alone -- with a sample of that size, you'll get the full spectrum of people. Heck, you'd probably find some that like that the dislikes were removed. From their perspective, by blocking your extension they're actually making the world a better place. It's shades of grey all the way down.
- Quarrelsome 5y agoI don't like that they were removed but that they were used in brigading demonstrates a problem and I can see why some PM considered "fixing" it. I think the more elegant fix would be to temper the downvotes depending on the context (e.g. reduce the impact of a sudden spike in increased viewing to downvote conversion).
- ocschwar 5y agoI avoid mentioning anything that points to topic-oriented Discord servers that are not yet 100% fedoras.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- DeathArrow 5y agoThese guys are working to get our precious dislikes back: https://github.com/Anarios/return-youtube-dislike https://github.com/Anarios/return-youtube-dislike
- tpoacher 5y agoI once wrote a python script that went through the various ticket prices on the megabus website (which used simple GET queries in the url), to find out future dates with cheap tickets. It's the kind of thing that you could do by hand, but the website (intentionally?) made it a tedious and time-consuming clicking exercise to compare effectively. They changed their API eventually, but I made decent use of the script for a couple of years. To me it looks like the lind of script that, had it gotten traction, Megabus would have changed their interface a LOT sooner (and also I'd be competing with others over the cheap tickets!); so I kept it to myself.
- shmatt 5y agoJust checked my folder of scripts like these, its grown to 76 files The best part is, eventually you hit things like booking something as soon as it gets online. And it happens so fast you figure out there are multiple engineers out there, each with their own script, fighting it out
- unixhero 5y agoI stopped posting to /r/linux and /r/bash for this reason. Made money and success without the recognition and fruitful commentary I was hoping for.
- ryandrake 5y agoWhile the question is a little incoherent (it just sounds like OP is mad about the recent YT change), it kind of brings up the sad state of software development ethics. There's no baseline shared agreement of ethical boundaries in the industry. No Hippocratic Oath for software engineers. For every scam, dark pattern, benchmark cheat, fake progress bar, background bitcoin miner, personal data vacuum, or any otherwise anti-user change the boss asks for, there is always some engineer who wants to keep their job and is willing to implement it. So, basically it's a race to the bottom, with no line that can't be eventually crossed. I think it's a decent explanation of why software seems to be getting more and more user-hostile with no end in sight. Wherever software can make more money by be marginally more evil, it does, and the cycle continues.
- Jiro 5y agoI don't want a Hippocratic Oath for software engineers. "That software is used by abortion clinics, so I am morally obliged not to write it." And even ignoring cases like that, there are too many situations where the programmer needs to be a lawyer, a statistician, an accountant, or otherwise have expertise in too many things outside of his field of knowledge in order to figure out that he's writing something that can harm people. Not everything is as obviously bad as a fake progress bar.
- jareklupinski 5y ago> some engineer who wants to keep their job and is willing to implement it some _person_ it's not just a software engineering problem, every one is susceptible to taking shortcuts in any walk of life: the shopkeeper knowingly stocking expired food, the hotel manager who doesnt clean their rooms, the contractor skimping on materials finding the root cause and delivering a working solution for all these people will probably be a more social than technical challenge. personally i blame entropy.
- pantulis 5y agoOnce it is posted here, it is publicly disclosed, and relevant devs or product managers will catch wind of it. It's not like HN is a closed circle.
- zaptheimpaler 5y agoYes. There are so many reasons but a lot of valuable knowledge and great conversations are no longer public and it doesn't make sense to have them in public. On the internet the only scale is private DM or potentially seen by the entire world. Software is also a big industry with many people in it for the money or they have no choice but to implement what the PM wants anyways. We have been well trained and domesticated by the business folks to not stick our noses where they don't belong. I think it's not just software it's every industry. Companies are structured to bubble up any significant decision making to a few people at the top. Software was just the exception for a short while.
- pytlicek 5y agoSometimes. But a lot of people around me - yes.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 5y ago> I thought we were supposed to have each other's back An engineer's primary concern ought to be the engine. Preoccupation with popularity or feelings seems like a distraction to me.
- b3morales 5y agoI find that I am able to make the engine run more smoothly when my colleagues and I trust each other and can amicably discuss problems that come up.
- duxup 5y agoNot really. As far as dislikes, I've no reason to think that I KNOW what the 'true' dislike number is / should be or that somehow this hack provides the true value ... it just as easily could be something in use by the typical dislike mobs and etc... It's YT's platform as far as I'm concerned, their platform to do with what they wish, I might disagree but I'm not going out of my way to hide things / not talk about things on here because someone might see it. One way or another YT is gonna do their thing for whatever reason anyway. Side note, folks really upset about dislikes thinking fighting the man .. are unwittingly playing the man's game by worrying about dislikes on some website.
- xg15 5y ago> but apparently money makes people do anything. Money and being employed. Employees have a duty to act in the best interest of their employer - in many jurisdictions this is an actual legal duty. You'd have to be pretty immature to forfeit that duty for internet points or some kind of nebulous "dev solidarity".
- dawnerd 5y agoI mentioned something we built at work and got the typical HN nitpick about it and decided to never bring anything else up again. If something is open source and you don’t like just move along.
- slingnow 5y agoSeems like a healthy, well-adjusted response! Something didn't work out one time? NEVER DO IT AGAIN!
- pavel_lishin 5y agoCommenter complaints about negative, unproductive responses to things they've posted; immediately gets negative, unproductive response.
- varsketiz 5y agoWhy do you consider it unproductive? I think the perspective provided is very reasonable - if something did not work once, maybe you shouldn't stop doing it forever. What do you think would be a productive response to this complaint?
- HeyLaughingBoy 5y agoActually I think it's on you to say why you don't think the response was unproductive.
- varsketiz 5y agoI did that in my comment by rephrasing slingnow. That I think was the productive bit of their comment. I think the unproductive bit was that dawnerd just wanted to vent and was not asking for feedback, so giving them feedback... is unproductive :) But then, if you are posting something in a forum where people can comment on what you wrote, are you really not asking for feedback?
- jcun4128 5y agoIf not for the YT API itself, next thing seems to be also another extension but I wonder, even if you tried to do something like a decentralized approach (no one holder of data) are you still "infringing" on YT somehow by indexing stuff/keeping track of dislikes. Also would be hard to prove genuine/not fake counts. Regarding question, I would post to get validation/external feedback so as to not feed my own biases/delusions.
- sabellito 5y agoThis is the worst post I've ever seen on hacker news. You're just trumpeting your cause, assuming it's universal, and using an actual valid question to do so. I'm extremely surprised this is still up.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- technotarek 5y agoYes, but usually because of imposter syndrome more than anything.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ZiiS 5y agoYes, I was going submit this: … - I see what you did there!
- edoceo 5y agoWhen I was 20 (c1997) I took this job, it had a FileMaker database for tracking tickets. And then my team mates all had to review that system to manually fill out a Word document with hours. So I made a little code to pull from FM and put into Word. So we could fill these forms, required for payroll, in minutes rather than hours (not a joke). And my team mates loved it. And then our lead claimed it as his own work, presented his accomplishment to the next boss up, bonus, congratulated and promoted. (Fuck you Ed) Most folk only got they own back. It had no impact on my career path and I'm still making stuff GPL and BSD and MIT.
- shadowgovt 5y agoThis is one of the less-obvious benefits of robust version control with authorship history.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoBased on my experience, these problems are not so much technical as political. It rarely gets to the stage where you openly contest your boss saying, "I wrote it, not you, and I can prove it" - because it is often trivial to prove, especially nowadays. But in general you say nothing because you want to keep the job.
- IshKebab 5y agoIf you're at the point where you're going over your bosses head to point out that he's stealing credit it doesn't really matter if you can prove you are right.
- shadowgovt 5y agoOh in my experience it very much does. Companies are loathe to fire someone without a paper trail. Bring them a paper trail and you can unseat an unpopular manager that their bosses have lacked the evidence to fire. ... sometimes. Sometimes the tree is rotten to the trunk. There's no hard-and-fast universal rule here.
- d--b 5y agoNo one cares at youtube whether people can or cannot make an extension that brings back the dislike count. If there is a way to do it, it might be intentional for guys like you to stay on the platform.
- systemvoltage 5y agoI use Youtube Ratings plugin that needs an API key from YT. I heard they're disabling it on Dec 15. Youtube - please don't be assholes. Leave the API as is.
- whatroot8 5y agoI’ve been iterating and abstracting a project layout tool into just the right thing for about a decade. It’s like remix and all those frontend bootstrap wizards/tools, but it bootstraps projects in any language with my preferences. It prompts me to ask if it should fetch my favorite deps (Requests for Python, or my own go CLI builder since Cobra is to bloated and complex for my needs) depending on the language I’m using for the project. I don’t always need them but I can get them in place fast. IMO using everyone else’s tools is boring. I don’t see a blacksmith getting tongs from another blacksmith. I can’t hope to be an expert if I just import experts code. Seeing something like bash and being expected to believe that means anything when I can just write my own; those old guys made syntax art which actually just made “computing” hard. That was job security as much as anything. Too many people don’t realize listening to others tell you not to do X is just giving them a monopoly.
- Amorymeltzer 5y agoNot the same sort of thing as OP's example, but a while ago I found something simple and neat that made me think about code a bit differently. I shared it. The first few comments were negative — not ideal but certainly okay! — but then the author started getting harassed off-site. I was contacted and immediately deleted the post. Start to finish, the whole process took maybe 30 minutes, but it was sadly instructive and I think about it every time I submit something here. It's probably made me comment less.
- matheusmoreira 5y ago> the author started getting harassed off-site Because of a post here on HN? What happened?
- Amorymeltzer 5y agoNegative, sexist, belittling comments, and a fair bit of https://xkcd.com/385 https://xkcd.com/385
- cfn 5y agoSince everyone is trading stories, here is mine: I once worked in a newspaper at the start of desktop publishing (DTP) and Word. They received the news from Reuters (as an example) in some strange format and had two people employed specifically to reformat and correct that text using Word before going to DTP. I wrote a Word macro (more like half recorded, half edited) that did 90% of the work because it was painful for me to see those people speed editing that text over and over again. They were very happy but they begged me not to tell their boss as they were afraid they would loose their job.
- speedgoose 5y agoDid you tell their boss?
- cfn 5y agoIt wasn't my job to tell anyone (although he found out and simply got other jobs for them to do). I wasn't even a dev back then but a journalist that took an interest in anything that involved computers.
- nonameiguess 5y agoWhat you're talking about is a very specific special case. Of course, when you develop and a share a way of circumventing a system restriction, the owners of the system will make your exploit ineffective when they discover it. Complaining about that is like criminal exploit developers complaining that patches get developed once their exploits are sold into the wild. Nobody is going to stop your general purpose productivity tools from working because you shared them.
- Nextgrid 5y agoRegarding the YT dislikes, the reason it's still available in the API isn't some sort of oversight by the developers - the rollout is most likely A/B tested and once the test completes they'll remove it from the API completely or hardcode it to a static value (for backwards-compatibility with older clients).
- shadowgovt 5y agoIn general, Google doesn't make immediate API changes. That's hard on API users.
- menmob 5y agoThis is changing. YT has become more aware of archivists saving removed content in the past, and much more quickly lock things down nowadays. Pre-2017 unlisted videos were gone within days, and the community tab cut off within hours. Gone are the days of “removed” features sticking around in APIs for months. :(
- floatingeye 5y agoIt's strange to me that you think this was a choice of developers instead of marketers or business holders. My understanding is the impetus behind this decision is that likes / dislikes have a negative effect on people in the social space. Though it makes things slightly harder to navigate in the youtube space, I think overall it is a well intentioned change.
- andrewla 5y agoI think many of us have tricks for circumventing paywalls, and I avoid posting them whenever possible. I wish there were a way to stop people from doing it in the comments as well because once the trick becomes widespread enough then the glitch will be "fixed" and I'll have to find a new method.
- jonny_eh 5y agoIt's not the developers you need to worry about, it's the PMs or executives.
- xwolfi 5y agoDude it's like thinking blacks or women should help each other. I was born in Normandy, live in China, and work in a bank. Being a dev is like quite low on what will impact my social behaviour :s And I bet you and me are like aliens on every but maybe some agreement on programming which may not even be certain. So dont dream, nobody cares, and Im sure big successful devs like Youtube dev can take it and smile a little seeing how small the critic vs how big the reach of the product :D
- SkyMarshal 5y agoIn your example, even if it you didn’t share it on social media but released it into the wild in back-channels and people started using it, the YT devs would figure it out eventually anyway. They would still notice downvotes happening and realize someone figured out a hack to enable that. Then they would scour the internet and dark web for it till they found it, either that or use telemetry in YT pages to reverse engineer it. Also an idea like that is only useful if lots of people use it. If you only share it with your 5 closest friends, then their downvotes will have no effect on the total up/down ratios. But once lots of people use it, it becomes obvious to the YT team, and they figure out how to fix it.
- mpmpmpmp 5y agoI think your points are still valid, but "still notice downvotes happening" doesn't make sense. You can still dislike a video on youtube. The difference is that when you go to a video with 12 million views making extraordinary claims you'll no longer see 65k downvotes and realize it's a waste of the next 12 minutes of your life and skip it.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y agoI'm not particularly concerned about devs "ruining" my work. I won't be posting the project I'm developing now; but only because it is aimed at a specific demographic, and the last thing I want, is a whole buttload of mayfly-lifespan signups from curious geeks. Almost every project that I do, is designed and supplied as a finished, released repo. Most are modules (as opposed to apps). I do have the source for several of my apps in the public domain. It's never been a problem for me. Most of the modules I release are for my consumption. I don't really care if it gets starred or forked on GH. In fact, the less, the merrier. If others aren't counting on my utilities, then I can play around with them, if I need to. Most of my work is of extremely high Quality. It's designed for serious developers (like me), that are interested in bottom-to-top native development. It's actually surprising how few people do that. When I release a module, I liken it to having a child. It is now my Responsibility to maintain and care for it.
- jancsika 5y agoAssuming you have prior evidence of YT purposefully breaking its interface-- Did you contact your local area user group about it? I haven't used YT in ages but if it's legit obfuscation your rep will immediately escalate that shit all the way to the AG if that interface is indeed serving up commons to a large enough userbase. (Even with their dwindling numbers I'd bet they still qualify as a public carrier.) In the meantime I'd suggest going through Looksie, or Shoop... hell even teh craggy old Gnuflix gateway. Seriously, why torture yourself? Oops wrong timeline... glorp
- batch12 5y agoYes, I have made a few censorship resistant solutions that I won't post here because of this. No reason to dare devs to start cat-n-mousing me -- or get arbitrarily banned from unrelated services because someone gets upset.
- mathgladiator 5y agoA little over a decade ago, I stopped a project* that got submitted to reddit and hacker news which is how I learned about hacker news via the referrer header. I was young and not exactly entrenched in the culture as I was in the midwest writing code from books without any desire of community, so I wasn't used to opinions. The negative things expressed caused me a depression since I was proud of my work. Unfortunately, for the business, the right thing to do was to stop developing the language and use shit that the local labor market could handle. This awareness of what the market could support was depressing as hell, and I eventually couldn't be an effective leader for that company as I was more interested in doing interesting things versus the right thing. I found it boring, and that's when I went into big tech to work on interesting things. Now, I'm older, and I'm up to my shenanigans again with a new language: http://www.adama-lang.org/ http://www.adama-lang.org/ One thing that I have learned is that you can't make everyone happy, but you can make a small group of people ecstatic. Next year, I intend to work on my language full-time (ish) and ship something that people can use with just a command-line. * https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/6ori0/kira_is_a_programming_language_that_compiles_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/programming/comments/6ori0/kira_is_... * https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=226480 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=226480
- jszymborski 5y agoVery interesting to see emmett, a founder and CEO at Twitch, comment on your project c. 2008. Some of those reddit comments are less than constructive, sorry to hear you had a bad experience. We're likely worse off as a community for it. Glad to hear you're back on the horse! Best of luck on your future projects :)
- makecheck 5y agoThere is a skill not taught in schools that I might describe as “how to conduct code reviews” and it applies in industry as well as HN comments. A reason to be afraid to submit may be that the number of respondents that don’t know how to review may exceed the number that do, causing the net result to be more destructive than constructive. Which brings me to another skill — how to ignore input that (even if you receive it) does not really matter, or at least not right away or not as much as other things. If only as a profession we could resist the urge to quibble about things that probably are fine (or at least not pressing) so that there is more time to dig into the heart of a design or implementation. Yes, that’s an interesting algorithm; no, let’s not segue into the choice of back-end on the web site that happens to host the documentation; yes, that will help with maintainability; no, the number of spaces here does not really matter; yes, that is a good recommendation but not under these time constraints; no, I will not rename 125 variables to suit your arbitrary choice instead of my arbitrary choice. I would also add that “review” is often misinterpreted as “pure criticism” (again, in code or in HN comments) and it can be nice for unsolicited positive feedback to occur too. Things like “I like how this was done”, or “I’ve never seen anything like that, clever” as opposed to an unending wake of negativity that tries to tear apart any given project.
- menmob 5y agoIf you do legitimately have a workaround for this, I can put you in touch with those grabbing metadata for the return dislike extension. They’d love to see it. (If it’s the averageRating endpoint, then they’re aware, and it’s likely going to be removed anyway.)
- yourapostasy 5y agoAbsolutely, all the time. Most recent example: I coded an efficient appointment availability data retrieval bot against a government site, even worked around its rudimentary anti-bot measures. Kept it to myself even after I got what I wanted out of the appointment.
- junon 5y agoYes.
- bsamuels 5y agoIt's really easy to sound smart when criticizing something, and HN promotes content that sounds smart. I used to play a drinking game with friends where we would read HN submission titles and try to guess how the top comment was going to criticize it. HN is simply not the place to go to share new ideas, projects, or anything that might undermine the consensus opinion.
- bigdict 5y agoOne approach is have someone comment "dislike", then count all likes on that comment as dislikes on the video.
- davehcker 5y agoSorry to read about such experiences people might have had, but I actually have had the exact opposite experience. I made few submissions/comments about 'dev' things, and because of the support of the HNers, I felt really good and was even more excited to work on them. First was a firefox plugin, and the first plugin I ever wrote. It basically bans some results from google. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23295989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23295989 Second is my current moonshot I'm working on where I was expecting a lot of criticisms and negative comments, especially from programmers/devs in the AI space (Fully AI driven indoor farm, kind of deep mind for agriculture and understanding plants better than any human). But the largely positive feedback of the community was really energizing and uplifting.
- busymom0 5y agoI often watch YouTube tutorials for coding (recently flutter and rust tutorials) and other DIY projects stuff. Removing the dislikes has been horrible and a waste of time for me.
- hanse-den0 5y agoI avoid communicating with HN completely and this is an account I just created to respond to you. > Let's say I found a way to bring back the number of dislikes of YT videos. Knowing that some YT devs are on the platform, I'd be reluctant to share it so that they won't know about it [0] and ruin the already-ruined YT experience. It shouldn't be like this, I know. But I've lost hope in the well-intentions of some devs in the industry. I thought we were supposed to have each other's back, but apparently money makes people do anything. Think you are blaming the wrong people here. Developers do not decide what will be done/removed in an app like YT, managers do. Of course they do it for the money (or some personal thing). Sure there is people upholding solidarity as a principle and support you but there will always we those who play zero sum games (see Watzlawick) and those who really don't know better than to offend others being insensitive. > ... watched a YT tutorial to sharpen your skills? Now w/o the dislikes count, all devs have a much harder time filtering useless videos. Only very specific topics and most of the time I have to find out if the approach taken in the video (still) works either way. On a personal note: I prefer learning new stuff from other people (not only devs), by reading the documentation and get some hands on experience. YT feels like it's making me unproductive because it seeks attention too much and also a lot of people there are behaving in a very annoying way (because they seek attention, too and because they want to make money). The reason I don't communicate with HN (anymore) is the strong US-centric view which in my opinion is prevalent here and it's just not my community because I don't share much with them (believes, lifestyle etc.). It is a news aggregator for me and the comments let me know what (rich) people in the US think about those headlines.
- gaws 5y ago> Let's say I found a way to bring back the number of dislikes of YT videos. This already exists: https://returnyoutubedislike.com/ https://returnyoutubedislike.com/