23 ms·
An engineer fighting Texas’s ban on Israel boycotts
- josh_fyi 5y agoSimilar laws exclude those who discriminate against blacks for political (or any other) reasons from government contracts. This person is entitled to discriminate as he chooses, but not to get government contracts.
- Guessnotgauss 5y agoYeah but this is a foriegn government. That government should not dictate how we run our government at all. There should be no bias in domestic policy based on a foriegn actors dictates. What if this were Taiwan. The story would be very different .
- Mikeb85 5y ago> What if this were Taiwan. The story would be very different . Please, people are way more sympathetic towards Taiwan than to Israel or Jews in general. The US government basically ensure's Taiwan's safety and independence, if it were up to half the people in the US, Israel would cease to exist (and there's no need to say what would happen to the Jews who currently live there, no matter what you believe about their right to be there).
- ceejayoz 5y ago> The US government basically ensure's Taiwan's safety and independence Israel's setup is quite similar. > if it were up to half the people in the US, Israel would cease to exist https://today.yougov.com/topics/international/articles-reports/2021/05/19/israel-and-palestinians-where-do-americas-sympathi https://today.yougov.com/topics/international/articles-repor... "Most Americans believe helping to protect Israel should be an important goal of American policy toward the Middle East. On this, Democrats (59%), Republicans (64%), and Independents (79%) agree. However, the latest Economist/YouGov poll underscores the differences in opinions about Israel between Republicans and Democrats." That's a pretty far cry from what you're asserting.
- pauldenton 5y agoAre American agencies even allowed to recognize Taiwan after 1971, and UN General Assembly Resolution No. 2758?
- emptyfile 5y agoExcept Israeli is a legal citizenship not a skin color.
- ceejayoz 5y agoI'm of the opinion that anti-BDS laws are unconstitutional, but: The Civil Rights Act of 1964 prohibits discrimination on the basis of race, color, religion, sex or national origin. You cannot discriminate against an Israeli on the basis of either. You can discriminate against Israel as a state.
- smegsicle 5y agonational origin is different from active citizenship though, isn't it?
- ceejayoz 5y agohttps://www.uscis.gov/i-9-central/employee-rights-and-resources/preventing-discrimination https://www.uscis.gov/i-9-central/employee-rights-and-resour... > A part of the Immigration and Nationality Act, found at 8 U.S.C. section 1324b, prohibits employers from discriminating against individuals based on their citizenship or immigration status, or their national origin, during the hiring, firing, recruiting, Form I-9, or E-Verify processes. > Employers cannot discriminate against individuals when hiring, firing, or recruiting based on the individual’s place of birth, country of origin, ancestry, native language, accent, or because they are perceived as looking or sounding “foreign.” > Employers cannot discriminate against individuals when hiring, firing, or recruiting because the individuals are or are not U.S. citizens, or because of their immigration status or type of employment authorization. U.S. citizens, noncitizen nationals, asylees, refugees, and recent permanent residents are protected from this type of discrimination. There are exceptions if you're, say, working on ICBMs.
- dustintrex 5y agoThere is a world of difference between actively discriminating against American citizens with a certain skin tone, and being told that you cannot "protest [!] the nation of Israel or its products".
- VHRanger 5y agoThere's a difference between "Jews" and "Israel" If you can't see that before spewing out your hot take we can't help you
- Mikeb85 5y agoSo all the companies who support BDS are hiring Jews, right?
- ceejayoz 5y agoI'm quite certain the ACLU employs some.
- Mikeb85 5y ago> While we take no position on Israel boycotts, the BDS movement, or Israel-Palestine From: https://www.aclu.org/letter/aclu-letter-opposing-s-1-combating-bds-act https://www.aclu.org/letter/aclu-letter-opposing-s-1-combati...
- ceejayoz 5y agoThey support the right to engage in the boycott. If you prefer, the "Jews for Peace" organization probably employ at least one Jew.
- sixQuarks 5y agoHow is protesting a nation’s policies similar to discrimination?
- Mikeb85 5y agoBoycotting Israeli companies (read Jewish as I'm sure he has no problem sending money to Israeli companies ran by Palestinians ie. Muslims) is automatically associating every Israeli Jew with government policies. Boycotting Israel is a dog-whistle for boycotting Israeli Jews.
- unmole 5y ago> Boycotting Israel is a dog-whistle for boycotting Israeli Jews. There are more people with Jewish ancestry in the United States than Israel. The state of Israel does not represent the Jews of the world.
- jatone 5y agolast i knew palentinians had no real political power in israeli and their treatment by the israeli government is precisely why you would boycott israeli goods and services.
- yardie 5y agoI’m not seeing similarities between what this article is talking about and whatever you are talking about. Please elaborate?
- mattzito 5y agoOof. I’m very sympathetic to the complexities around the BDS movement, but this is a pretty challenging take to get behind. Discrimination against blacks is illegal in the context of denying individuals things like employment, access to housing and medical care, shopping, etc. You have to show that the individual or business has specifically taken action in some way to deny one or more individuals their rights. In fact, the same rules apply to discrimination based on religion, or national origin or background. So anyone who has discriminated against someone who is Jewish or from Israel is subject to similar liability. But nowhere in any of these laws does it say that a business has to promise to never protest or disagree with the country that one of those groups come from. I have to hire people from France if they’re qualified, but I’m also allowed to protest the French government’s policies on basically anything. If the law from this article was applied to, say, Saudi Arabia or Mexico, would we be comfortable supporting it?
- Mikeb85 5y ago> I have to hire people from France if they’re qualified, Keep this in mind. > but I’m also allowed to protest the French government’s policies on basically anything. So are you allowed to protest the French government by boycotting French companies? Ie. not doing business with French people? The first half of your sentence is directly at odds with the second. How do you actually boycott France if not by applying the boycott to it's people? The Israeli boycott isn't simply saying you don't agree with their government, it's actively boycotting companies run by Israeli Jews and not hiring Israeli Jews.
- istjohn 5y ago> The Israeli boycott isn't simply saying you don't agree with their government, it's actively boycotting companies run by Israeli Jews and not hiring Israeli Jews. That's simply not true. The Texas law does not say anything about boycotts against Jews. And BDS is modeled after the successful Apartheid boycotts, which were boycotts of South Africa, not boycotts of companies run by White South Africans.
- 5y ago
- Mhaea 5y agoYou are free as long as law let you to be
- PaulAJ 5y agoFunny how the Republicans are so outraged about cancel culture, but not about this.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> Funny how the Republicans As ever, your massive overgeneralisation is bound to generate false ironies.
- foolzcrow 5y agoYou too should be outraged by cancel culture because this is a prime example of it. Freedom is a two way street.
- MichaelRazum 5y agoHow is it a cancel culture? He just can stop his boycot. By the way seems that he brought his anger to the us, don't see anything good in it. PS: Since I got downvoted one more remark. Germany labels BDS as antisemitic [1]. So I think the goverment has any right to act. [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/17/world/europe/germany-bds-anti-semitic.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/05/17/world/europe/germany-bds-...
- skinnymuch 5y agoA lot of the people who get “cancelled” can reverse their behavior. You’re changing the definition of the new meaning of cancel culture by saying he can just stop doing what he’s doing. The point should be no one should be cancelled just for doing things that others might not like while not being violent or advocating for it.
- wccrawford 5y ago"cancel culture" is about boycotting people for things they did in the past. Nobody can go back and change their past. Even if those people apologize and work to do better, they still get "cancelled" under cancel culture. My problem isn't with holding people responsible for their actions, but with never letting up on them. If people can't change and relieve the sanctions against them, they have no incentive to change. They might as well just keep doing whatever they were doing.
- forinti 5y agoHow does this law benefit or protect the people of Texas?
- gostsamo 5y agoIt makes sure that the doomsday evangelist propaganda of the local government won't be challenged. If you are a christian fundamentalist who wants to protect Jerusalem from the Antichrist or you think that islamic fundamentalists will prevent you from visiting the city, you wont allow the godless lefties any chance of endangering the secret land. At least, this is what I've found as justification.
- joelbluminator 5y agoAnd trying to destroy Israel (cos it's just like South Africa!1) is completely rational? Plenty of lunatics on both sides of the fence here. I don't like the woke religion more than the evangelical religion.
- gostsamo 5y agoOh, the question is how this law benefits the citizens of Texas. Not sure how the walk religion is involved unless you think that defending the citizens of Texas from the walk tendencies they might exhibit is for their own good... for the record though, I don't care much about neither the US's culture wars nor for the attempts of Israel to travel two thousand years in the past. Both look like extremely dumb ideas but taking sides means only increasing the idiocy at hand.
- ornel 5y agoHow did the boycott against the South African state "destroy" South Africa? It just made it a democratic country, something Israel is not
- joelbluminator 5y agoIsrael is a Jewish state - it was determined long ago the Jews should get a nation state along side a Palestinian nation state. Considering Jews' unique history of persecution it would be pretty crazy to argue they are not a people, so they are not like white South Africans. Creating "one democratic state" will rob both the Jews and the Palestinians of their right for self determination. It will also in all likelihood create chaos, because I just don't see how you can take two ethnic communities of about the same size, that hate each other for a century, and make them live in one democratic country. It would be about as realistic as turning Russia and Germany into one big democratic country. I actually think that Russia and Germany stand a much better chance.
- tartoran 5y agoI hope he wins his case because this ban is absolutley ridiculous. But I noticed that this is a sensitive topic, it will probably be flagged off here on HN
- cpach 5y agoIt is a sensitive topic and it could also be considered off-topic. I personally found the article very interesting, but I’m not sure it belongs here on HN.
- lowkey 5y agoI agree. It would be very disappointing for this article to be flagged as off-topic. I think it is extremely relevant and I am glad we are discussing it openly.
- joelbluminator 5y agoRelevant to HN how? It's a forum for general political debate?
- lowkey 5y agoI'm speaking about me personally. I am a member of the HN community and I find the article interesting. I believe that is the standard for the site. Simply what we as a community find interesting, so I shared my opinion. You are entitled to yours, but that doesn't mean the article should be removed. You are free to skip it.
- joelbluminator 5y agoAaaaaand its flagged. Guess its not that great for HN? I think you are looking for Twitter...good luck
- s_dev 5y ago>I personally found the article very interesting, but I’m not sure it belongs here on HN. Nerds finding and discussing something intellectually interesting is literally the whole point of HN.
- rubyist5eva 5y agoThis man is free to protest and boycott (freedom of speech) whomever he likes, that does not entitle him to government contracts (not freedom from consequence). You don't have a constitutional right to government contracts. I don't like the ban but the argument is silly. EDIT: I'm being rate limited on replies for some reason, I'd like to respond to some comments on here but I cannot. Mayhaps I will try again in a few hours.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoHow can a government contract have a "discrimination" clause in it? What next? How about a MAGA state saying "You have to acknowledge that Trump won the 2020 elections to work with us"? Wow, the comments in here are really opening my eyes to what HN actually is instead of what I thought it was.
- Mikeb85 5y agoThe clause sounds more like an anti-discrimination clause ie. he isn't allowed to discriminate against a nation while receiving government contracts. No one's stopping him from simply not buying Israeli goods and not saying anything.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoSo, is he or his company allowed to protest against China, as allowed by the 1st amendment? Hmm, no law banning that...
- Mikeb85 5y agoDepends what that entails... Refusing to do business with Chinese-American companies or hire people of Chinese descent likely wouldn't be allowed. Look at the BDS website. They basically equate all Israeli companies with the government. In addition, Israel guarantees the right of return (ie. citizenship) to all Jews. So while BDS claims they're not anti-Semetic, they apply their definitions broadly enough that it's not hard to see what the end result is...
- Y_Y 5y agoIsrael does spend a lot of money on American goods though. In fact it spends a lot of American money on American goods[0] in the form of "foreign aid" which is earmarked for US military hardware. It would be a shame to upset that relationship. /s [0] https://www.bbc.com/news/57170576 https://www.bbc.com/news/57170576
- arcticbull 5y agoIf the crux of the argument is it "would be a shame for America to miss out on giving money to Israel to give back to America" you can kind of short-circuit that and just have America give the money to America, maybe in some sort of big infrastructure bill with a fancy name like Build Back Bigly, or something like that, idk.
- netizen-936824 5y agoYea but then we miss out on a step. Less steps = less middlemen = less people leeching to become rich Won't you think of the MBAs!
- cies 5y agoThis misses some detailing: > America to miss out on giving money to Israel to give back to America America[n tax payers] to miss out on giving money [as charitable aid] to [the apartheid regime controlling] Israel to [spend it at] America[n weapons manufacturers]. And in that case it becomes clear why directly from taxpayers to weapons manufacturers is not going to fly: it's too obvious and does not put the weapons where they can be (ab)used!
- arcticbull 5y agoAre you familiar with the defense budget? ;)
- throwaway19937 5y agoGiving foreign aid instead of spending the money directly allows circumventing WTO rules about subsidizing your products. The book The Dictator's Handbook discusses this in detail.
- playing_colours 5y agoWhen opposing a state on such topics you can refer to the Constitution, freedom of opinion and speech. I am afraid of large powerful private companies - now and even more in future. They can fire you, reject providing services that are essential to function in a modern society - if your position on some topics is different from theirs. Now you cannot refer to the freedom of opinion - it is a private entity and they are free to decide whether they want to cancel or fire you.
- Waterluvian 5y agoOne of the problems with modern society is that too many people see these services as essential. When it comes to utilities, I absolutely agree. But not a specific email provider or social media site or video site, etc.
- skohan 5y agoI would argue for certain career paths, not having access to Twitter essentially makes one non-competitive. Also my friend went to a university where the official communication for course-work happened through Facebook. I'm not sure how someone without access to Facebook would be able to participate in that program.
- throwaway6734 5y agoWhich career paths? I imagine "not getting banned from Twitter" is an important skill to have for any job that requires twitter. That's absurd and a failure on the university's part. What country was this in.
- skohan 5y ago> Which career paths? I imagine "not getting banned from Twitter" is an important skill to have for any job that requires twitter. Well this is moving the goal-posts isn't it? The comment I responded to said that the effect of being denied access to a certain social media platform is overstated. I would argue for media professionals it's basically a requirement. > That's absurd and a failure on the university's part. What country was this in. This was a masters program in Germany
- imgabe 5y agoThis is basic freedom of speech. The government does not get to dictate what your opinions are allowed to be. Not even if you sell things to the government. Texas needs to repeal this law asap.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoIf it’s a boycott ban then it’s not really freedom of speech and is more about freedom of association. (Which is still pretty well protected by US jurisprudence.)
- ComputerGuru 5y agoCongress has been pretty clear recently that the right to spend money (or not) is a matter of freedom of speech, not just association. See PACs.
- laverya 5y agoCongress has also been pretty clear that there's no right NOT to spend money on health insurance.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoYou refer to Citizens United and the right to spend money on things like advertisements and PACs and movies about current political candidates? Yes. But that was very speech-oriented spending. I'm not aware of jurisprudence extending the concept of "speech" to general spending decisions in the context of boycotts — but again, it's probably not necessary; freedom of association is a real freedom.
- bsenftner 5y agoIt's not just Texas. Try public voicing anti-Israel anything and you'll quickly learn how our freedoms are a farce.
- cpach 5y agoI don’t follow. Is it not possible in the US to criticize Israel?
- m_a_g 5y agoThis is outrageous. Texas and other republican states boast about small government and unparalleled free speech, and they go ahead and prevent people from boycotting another state. They have no business doing that and this is absolutely ridiculous.
- skohan 5y agoIt's just bizarre. What's Texas' compelling interest in punishing the boycott of foreign state? If I were a Texan, and I found out that my state government is potentially over-paying contractors based on a completely irrelevant criteria to the work, I would not be pleased.
- ramraj07 5y agoFor the most part the folks who continue to call themselves Texans don’t seem to actually care about things such as logic or freedom, only about reinforcing whatever it is they have been told to reinforce on that day. I feel bad I wasted so much of my life in such a place, but happy that I didn’t contribute my money to them because of their own inane policies.
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoNot to defend Texas, but every federal contract contains the same language. That's just as true if you live in San Francisco.
- leeroyjenkins11 5y agoIt's a strategic ally in the region. US strong support of Israel was the foundation of the Abraham accords that got several major players together and provide stability. The government also does this with domestic companies. There are contractor criteria that requires companies to meet political goals. I guess the question is, does a company have a right to a government contract? I would say the elected government of a state has the right to define the criteria for it's contractors. It doesn't stop those companies from operating, but they don't get public funds. If they don't like it, they can leave for a state that's ok with their boycott. Or the people can change the legislators out.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoStates really need to get out of pursuing their own foreign policy. Regardless of what you think about the foreign policy issue in question, the only level of government that should act on it is the federal government. Ironically, on almost every other issue, it should be decided at the state level, and it's the federal government that is unconstitutionally meddling,
- thedream 5y agoImagine being so terrified by scrutiny that you push for laws like this. What is there to hide?
- saltmeister 5y agoisraeli pigs
- netcan 5y agoI'm kind of confused. It's not the first article that I have encountered on this, but they all seem very light on specifics. What/where is the "particular legal clause? This article veers from there into a personal biography. Is it part of his contract, a local bylaw? What's the legality or legal history of such actions? Sigh. So much journalism is just tweet + fluff.
- lakecresva 5y agoApparently this is the statute: https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/GV/htm/GV.2271.htm https://statutes.capitol.texas.gov/Docs/GV/htm/GV.2271.htm
- netcan 5y agoI see. So this statute requires a contract clause. Are there other such statutes, requiring certain clauses as boilerplate?
- CodesInChaos 5y agoSlightly different, but the federal government uses highway funding to entice/force states to introduce certain laws (e.g. the 21 year minimum drinking age): https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/07/four-times-the-government-held-highway-funding-hostage/454167/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2014/07/four-ti...
- CodesInChaos 5y agoThere are many variants of these "don't boycott Israel" laws, which try to find ways around the unconstitutionality of such laws. It sounds like the variant in the article is a state level law that requires the state to not contract with parties boycotting Israel. So in the end this is part of his contract with the government, but the city has no choice but to include such a clause. For example a similar law in a different state was found unconstitutional by a Circuit Court: > The US District Court for the Eastern District of Arkansas heard the case involving Act 710, a statute that forbids state parties from establishing contractual agreements with companies that boycott Israel. > The Court ultimately concludes that supporting boycotts of Israel is protected under the Constitution and that Act 710 violates First Amendment rights. https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest/eighth-circuit-state-law-forbidding-government-contractors-from-boycotting-israel-is-unconstitutional https://jolt.law.harvard.edu/digest/eighth-circuit-state-law... But these kind of laws are controversial and different courts have come to other conclusions.
- elzbardico 5y agoOne of the funniest things in American politics is that almost all uncritical support for Israel comes from the evangelical christians. For them, Israel is always right, no matter what, and must be defended at all costs. The jew friends I have are way more balanced and critical of Israel human right abuses than the christians, who seems to feel that criticizing Israel is the same as denying its right to exist.
- notsureaboutpg 5y agoAgree with the other commenter. This isn't true. Most politicians on both sides of the aisle are way out of touch with the average American who is usually pretty critical of Israel, namely due to the shocking amount of aid we send them each year.
- akatechis 5y agoThis is absolutely untrue. When you look at the political landscape, evangelicals have no power. And yet, when you look at any vote in Congress regarding Israeli issues, such as the recent vote to replenish the Iron Dome system, it was overwhelmingly voted in. The only "controversy" was the 3 or 4 people who objected initially, and were then bullied BY BOTH PARTIES into voting yes.
- istjohn 5y agoEvangelical Christians have enormous political power. That's why the last three appointees to the Supreme Court were vetted by pro-Life organizations and Roe v. Wade is in imminent danger.
- akatechis 5y agoThis is how you know who really owns America.
- dhx 5y agoWhat do the clauses look like? Do they actually mention "Israel" by name? Could it perhaps be poorly drafted clauses that are meant to convey a requirement that contractors to the government must equally consider procuring goods and services for the government from all countries and/or suppliers without bias of personal preference or opinion?
- ComputerGuru 5y agoThese are anti-BDS laws specifically and only banning boycotts of Israeli goods (yes, by name). This site indexes them happily: https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/anti-bds-legislation https://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/anti-bds-legislation Here’s the Texas info, for example: Texas Governor Greg Abbott signed HB89, an act relating to state contracts with and investments in companies that boycott Israel, on May 2, 2017. The bill prohibits the State of Texas from contracting or entering into business with companies or entities involved in the BDS movement against Israel. The law ensures that public funds will not go to companies that participate in BDS. In 2019, Texas started to divest $72 million worth of stock in the Norwegian financial services firm DNB ASA. Two state pension funds – the Employees Retirement System of Texas and Texas Permanent School Fund — own $68 million and $4 million, respectively, in stock in the company. This is the first action taken under the anti-boycott legislation. In April 2019, a U.S. District Judge ruled in favor of Bahia Amawi, a former speech pathologist who sued the state over the law after she was fired from her job for supporting BDS. The court found “the statute to be a viewpoint-based restriction intended not to combat discrimination on the basis of national origin, but to silence speech with which Texas disagrees.” In response, the legislature rewrote the language limiting the application of the law to companies with more than 10 full-time employees and contracts of more than $100,000 with the state. The governor signed the bill.
- fennecfoxen 5y agoIsrael is mentioned by name because that’s who all the boycotts are against. Notice, though, the stark difference between the legality of Texas’s own divestment and the firing of a Texas employee for an opinion. Plenty of states boycotting plenty of things; that’s normal. California bans official travel to 18 different US states (with limited exceptions to pursue taxes, and the like) over their lgbt-related laws, and CalPERS divests from oil and tobacco and the like.
- daggersandscars 5y agoAt the time I'm writing this, this hasn't been mentioned. How this interacts with state laws, I have no idea. When it comes to businesses, the US government reserves the right to institute international boycotts. Companies may not, generally speaking, boycott a country (or people from that country, etc) unless that country (or person) is being boycotted by the US. There are mandatory reporting requirements that surround this. If you work in finance and you have not received training on this topic... For more info: The Office of Antiboycott Compliance -- https://www.bis.doc.gov/index.php/enforcement/oac https://www.bis.doc.gov/index.php/enforcement/oac. From their intro: "The Office of Antiboycott Compliance (OAC) within BIS is charged with administering and enforcing the Anti-Boycott Act of 2018, Part II of the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 (ECRA), and the antiboycott provisions set forth in Part 760 of the Export Administration Regulations, 15 CFR parts 730-774 (EAR). These authorities discourage, and in some circumstances, prohibit U.S. companies from taking certain actions in furtherance or support of a boycott maintained by a foreign country against a country friendly to the United States (unsanctioned foreign boycott). U.S. companies must report to OAC their receipt of certain boycott-related requests for information designed to verify compliance with an unsanctioned foreign boycott. Prohibited activities include, inter alia, agreements by U.S. companies to refuse to do business with a boycotted country or with blacklisted persons for boycott-related reasons, furnishing information about any person’s business relationships with a boycotted country or with blacklisted persons, and implementation (by U.S. banking entities) of letters of credit that include prohibited boycott-related terms or conditions."
- lr4444lr 5y agoSome states implement their own versions of this, but even if not, if the state agencies in question are funded federally, they may obligated to carry out the same federal contractor compliances.
- justin66 5y ago> prohibit U.S. companies from taking certain actions in furtherance or support of a boycott maintained by a foreign country against a country friendly to the United States (unsanctioned foreign boycott) This would seem to be referring to boycotts instituted by nation states against other nation states that are friendly to the United States. It doesn’t seem applicable to a discussion about BDS.
- 1cvmask 5y agoI always find the inconsistencies and hypocrisy around free speech to be almost absurd comedy. Conservatives bemoan and attack "liberal" cancel culture. Yet they do the same like this Texan ban. Both sides want to censor and cancel. And yet both conservatives and liberals attack China and other alleged culprits for being censorious and not being "free" . This muzzling of alternative voices is not even specific to the US. A British professor was canceled/fired from Bristol University for remarks deemed critical of Israel: https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-bristol-58765052 https://www.bbc.com/news/uk-england-bristol-58765052
- mytailorisrich 5y agoThere is some irony in wanting to prevent others from boycotting you because you want to boycott someone else.
- adolph 5y agoKey claim of lawsuit: Participation in boycotts of Israel constitutes protected speech and expressive conduct. Lawsuit text: https://www.cair.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Memorandum.pdf https://www.cair.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Memorandum.p...
- parasense 5y agoI would like to think it's an invalid contractual clause at face value
- adolph 5y agoI guess thats for the courts to hash out eventually. If it is invalid, then standing seems to be more of a stretch: Although A & R’s boycott has not materially affected any of its business decisions through the present, A&R would refuse to buy an Israeli-sourced product were the opportunity to otherwise arise. Moreover, even if A & R was not boycotting Israel, it would refuse to certify that it would not boycott Israel for the duration of the renewal contract because, by signing, A & R would be compelled to speak in furtherance of a foreign government’s interests. But for the renewal contract’s certification requirement, based on the Anti-BDS Law, A&R is ready, willing, and able to enter into the contract and perform the agreed-upon engineering services for the City.
- sndman 5y agoTaking away the right (or punishing) of individuals (or groups) to boycott would seem unconstitutional at face value. Where would the Civil Rights movement have been without boycotts? I was once asked in an interview whether "The State of Israel had a right to exist". I replied that no state has a "right to exist" but that individuals have a right to self-determination. A human right that various international laws and conventions give both Israelis and Palestinians. Needless to say, I did not get that job. BTW, there was a good documentary about this recently in DOC NYC: https://www.docnyc.net/film/boycott/ https://www.docnyc.net/film/boycott/
- adolph 5y ago
- jleyank 5y agoYou’re free to do whatever the government wants you to do. Anything else requires a fight in some fashion…
- jleyank 5y agoYou disagree with what I said or how I said it?
- throway453sde 5y agoI did not get the issue. Who is stopping him from boycotting whatever?
- sndman 5y agoSince he's being forced to sign an agreement, the state of Texas is forcing him to hold a particular political position in order to work and get paid by the City of Houston. His political opinion (and you can agree or disagree with it) is to boycott Israeli institutions as part of an international Boycott Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) campaign because he disapproves of the treatment of Palestinian people living in the Occupied Territories. You can read about how Palestinians are treated in a recent Human Rights Watch report (just google, "Human Rights Watch Israel apartheid") and decide for yourself. This seems to violate the First Amendment rights to free speech and this is what the lower courts have held. So while the right to "free speech" is not absolute (one can't yell "fire" in a crowded theater), you are free to hold (and talk about) any political views. And a state (or federal) entity cannot punish you for your thoughts and speech (outside of work, of course). The reason this is important is that boycotts (and talking about and organizing them) have been a powerful tool for non-violent political action and have been used throughout the world since their origin in 1880's Ireland. But why is this important now? If a state or federal agency can require employees to hold certain political views, they can create all sorts of requirements (via laws) for not only employment, but other benefits and or services they provide. Hope this helps.