7 ms·
NIH director on why Americans aren't getting healthier, despite medical advances
- h2odragon 5y agoAre we tracking the same things as we used to? We traded lots of cases of tuberculosis for lots of cases of Restless Leg Syndrome. Can't imagine a world in which the "National Institutes of Health" could say, "We're done now, everybody's healthy enough." If finding sick people is their job, they're damned well gonna find some sick people, aren't they?
- refurb 5y agoThe demand for healthcare is infinite. Even in healthy people the demand for screening is high. So I agree, there have been massive health advances in the last century. Not surprisingly the advances/$ drops over time.
- Unkulukulu 5y agoI think it's more accurate to say we traded tuberculosis for cancer and heart disease.
- staticman2 5y agoWhat sort of society would say everyone is healthy enough? I imagine one like Logan's Run, where everyone is healthy until 30 then executed.
- kashunstva 5y agoI know of no evidence that the National Institutes of Health - scare quotes or not - is out looking for trivial diseases in an effort to promote its own existence. Its extramural granting program has been remarkably successful and is the crown jewel of U.S. biomedical sciences. Its prioritization process is largely (if sometimes imperfectly) aligned with causes of mortality and morbidity. That said, translational and implementation research is often more poorly funded which is in part why getting from evidence to clinical practice to widespread societal adoption is problematic. Especially in the biomedical sciences, evidence is actually a poor and lagging predictor of diffusion of innovations; so the fact that good evidence is widely available while adoption is slow shouldn't be surprising at all. Of course, having a functioning health care system where the incentives are all aligned toward healthy persons would help, too.
- tayo42 5y agoThe article talks about the steady and consistently lower expected life span of americans. The example in it is we've done things like improve cancer survival rate by 25% but now people are dying from guns, opioids and covid. It sounds like a game of whack-a-mole for death causes.
- LinuxBender 5y agoI am not sure why anyone would expect medical advances to make people healthier. A majority of people eat poorly, sleep poorly, are subjected to stressful situations, live sedentary lifestyles, breath polluted air and so on. Fix those things first, at very least the things you have control over and then whatever remains, turn to medicine.
- gpsx 5y agoI think one problem in the US is that we have a medical system that is paid to medically treat people. We need a health care system that is paid to keep people healthy. In this case, advancement would mean more people are healthy. It might include, for example, figuring out how to get people to eat better food and exercise.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoMedical systems are poor solution for basic individual health. The problem is a rampant consumerist mindset. You can't pay someone to eat healthier for you or exercise for you. We already know how to eat better and exercise, we just don't want to do it. There's no magic words or pills that a doctor can give someone to solve this problem - it cant be outsourced.
- LinuxBender 5y agoI suspect this may change. The same powers used to lock down businesses and people may unfortunately be used to force resolution of this issue. I know that sounds crazy right now but if you look at various CDC and NIH reports, the medical crisis surrounding obesity, heart disease, diabetes alone will be enough to financially end the sovereignty of most first world countries. I have no idea what that will look like but it isn't far away. Whatever that translates into, it will certainly happen in our lifetimes. Here [1] is a brief discussion on the reports. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5LTWJOi3bCo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5LTWJOi3bCo [video]
- 5y ago
- bko 5y ago> We're having serious conversations right now about whether this ought to be a special initiative at NIH to put more research into health communications and how best to frame those [messages] so that they reach people who may otherwise be influenced by information that's simply not based on evidence. Because I don't think you could look at the current circumstance now and say it's gone very well. If people are presented with accurate medical information and they choose to ignore it, at some point you have to accept their autonomy. At some point "framing" becomes propaganda and if ends justify the means, the authorities would be willing to lie in order to get their message across, making the problem of trust even worse.
- nightowl_games 5y agoExactly. I am pro vaccine and am vaccinated, but I still don't trust a lot of the messaging that comes through the media pipeline. I feel as though I have no idea what's going on with myocarditis and with the 'athletes are collapsing' stuff. The "Joe Rogan takes horse dewormer" was ridiculous and really made me distrust the institutions. The Dazsak Lancet letter saying the virus was zoonotic with no conflicts of interest declared. As a parent it feels impossible to really understand the risk profile of vaccinating your child. The _real_ data is so hard to find. When the medical community says "these side effects are rare", that is a meaningless subjective statement. How rare!? I think the 'medical community' is not getting uptake on their scientific credentials because they've destroyed their own credibility. The absolute refusal to acknowledge responsibility for the destruction of their own credibility is abhorrent. It's very similar to how Democratic political strategists are resorting to blaming the voters for Dem's losing. There's a couple vaccine scientists in my own city who have become active on Twitter during the pandemic, and every once in a while they say something inaccurate or in my opinion unethical. I dont comment, as they have an army of people who praise everything they say. I just silently file it into 'more BS said by person X', which then influences my opinion of everything they say, forever. When you are in a position of power, you have to hold yourself to a higher standard of communication. One drop of deception in a sea of science will ruin the whole batch. It is baffling that these people pretend to not know why people don't trust them. It shows a complete lack of empathy, understanding and a refusal to take ownership over something that is their responsibility.
- bluedino 5y agoAs a whole, we eat foods full of sugars/carbs/artificial sweeteners, we eat too much food, and we don't exercise enough.
- techbio 5y agoThese types of foods are more tasty and snackable than following the money and/or turning the justifiable complaints of overworked healthcare professionals to effect systematic prevention.
- zubiaur 5y agoThis is completely empirical and based on conversations with people who, like me, immigrated to the US. I think it’s lifestyle: The environment we came from naturally encouraged walking and physical activity. Diets were also healthier. Here in the US, at least in the Midwest, residential and commercial layouts are completely car centric, there are few places where it’s more convenient to just walk. In contrast, in more densely populated cities, like the ones me and my friends came from, a combination of factors, like traffic, lack of parking spaces and availability of sidewalks makes it way easier to just walk to places. Regarding food, I think due to the labor/capital balance of the US, people spend way less time cooking from scratch. It’s funny that many recipes have steps of the like of “mix a can of that” or “stir half a packet of such”. I don’t think the effect in health is as much when compared to lack of physical activity, but I’m convinced it’s a factor. I’m convinced that for those who have access to it, medical care in the US is one of the best, if not the best in the world. But there is only so much that can be done in a medical setting to offset detrimental lifestyle patterns. To me, that is one of the overlooked factors when comparing life expectancy across nations as a measure of the medical system performance. Ceteris Paribus.
- toomuchtodo 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diseases_of_affluence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diseases_of_affluence
- Daishiman 5y agoI agree with almost all of this, except that I don't think US medical care is good. It's _advanced_, in the sense that it has an array of expensive techniques available to those who can pay it. But in the basic humanity and decency department having been to US doctors feels line going to a production line if you don't have any serious condition. There just felt this enormous personal disconnect. And most of the issues that I'll be going to doctors for are just not that rare.
- inetknght 5y agoAmericans aren't getting healthier because that's not profitable to American businesses. It's not profitable to media producers if you're out and about instead of sitting on your butt consuming some electronic entertainment. It's not profitable to food manufacturers if you're eating easily available fruits and vegetables instead of foods manufactured to have a long shelf life. It's not profitable to vehicle manufacturers if you rode a bicycle instead of drove. It's not profitable to the jails if certain drugs were legalized. It's not profitable to hospitals if you paid to be healthy instead of paid to have symptoms resolved. It's not profitable to write a message "eat healthier" and put that next to unhealthy foods. It's not profitable to write a message "exercise healther" and put that next to your transportation or entertainment. It's not profitable to write a message "drugs are illegal". All of that space would be better served on non-harmful consumer messages like... buy this product! Watch your favorite fantasy! Make your dreary life in traffic less dreary with our brand new (and fresh-smelling) automobile! And there's definitely no harm to consumers if all of those businesses are grouped into huge conglomerates... for efficiency, of course. No harm to consumers whatsoever.
- poulsbohemian 5y agoI took my senior cat in for a check up yesterday because it was pretty clear he had a thyroid issue. Yup, diagnosed and walked out with some pills same day, for a few hundred bucks. Recently my son needed to see some doctors. It of course took appointments with a GP to get to a referral. One of the services - the one that is ultimately really important to his quality of life - of course wasn't covered by insurance and of course the doctor to whom he was referred can't be bothered to call to schedule anything. And of course the GP doing the referring can't be bothered to assist us in any way - we could look up the contact info ourselves, of course not even having a name of the doctor to whom they promised to make a referral. So several hundred dollars later, we're no father along than we were. It's the same basic story why I don't go to a sleep study - it's simply a complete run around to get any kind of actual care. That is why Americans remain unhealthy.