12 ms·
Why don't you accept donations?
- syoc 5y agoGorhill has to me always been a beacon of integrity. I always feel a bit uneasy about browser add-ons and the people in control of them and I am really thankful for not having a single worry about installing ublock origin on any browser I spend some time in.
- notum 5y agoBecause the original blocker: AdBlock, did. And some donated more than others. The rest is history.
- fregante 5y ago> And some donated more than others That's unrelated to donations. One can accept donations without putting their soul on sale. As an extension developer I get offers for buying my extensions or adding donator-specific functionality: I just don't accept them, even though I accept simple donations/sponsorships. The extension is still free of ads (except in the readme)
- idrios 5y agoFor those not familiar, what is the history?
- notum 5y ago"Acceptable ADs platform" they launched in order to "help small websites" soon filled with advertiser whales who voted with their money. Suddenly a lot of ads were classified as... acceptable.
- COGlory 5y agoAdvertisers could pay to get unblocked. https://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2016/09/15/justin_kuang_adblock/ https://blogs.cornell.edu/info2040/2016/09/15/justin_kuang_a...
- quickthrower2 5y agoWikipedia also accepts donations
- account42 5y agoWikipedia also keeps devoting significant screen space to asking for more donations from time to time even though they have more than enough money to keep the site running indefinitely. Should donations dry up with they reduce their (largely non-Wikipedia-related) expenses or will they just get more agressive in asking for moeney?
- quickthrower2 5y agoWikipedia is probably in a strange problem where they have more than enough money (they do have a lot of staff though?) and really we would want them to keep going for hundreds of years, so I think it is good for them to keep an enormous runway. We can't trust governments to fund it, as it may not say nice things about those governments and they may want to change that. And by they I mean the USA which would probably end up being the biggest donor and thus get veto powers.
- approxim8ion 5y agoI can't think of too many pieces of software that have improved my life as significantly as uBlock Origin in the last decade. It's been an absolute godsend.
- baal80spam 5y agoI agree to the point that I can't imagine using the internet without uBlock installed.
- flatiron 5y agoI don’t install anything on my work computer that I can’t say 100% is used for work so I could never justify uBlock. It does make a HUGE difference. The web without it is a giant mess.
- Cuuugi 5y agoMoney means responsibility. This is a classy stance imho.
- tombert 5y agoI agree. The second you take any donation, you can't use the excuse of "I'm doing this work for free. Leave me alone if you don't like it" because at that point you aren't doing it for free. While you don't necessarily "owe" donors anything, that won't really matter because in their eyes, you were paid to do work, and you didn't do it.
- The_Colonel 5y ago> The second you take any donation, you can't use the excuse of "I'm doing this work for free. Leave me alone if you don't like it" because at that point you aren't doing it for free. No, I don't agree. Communicate clearly that donations are in no way payment for the work being / to be done, does not constitute any preferential treatment / service agreement, and you're good. This setup works for me well, and I have no issues with people's expectations.
- tombert 5y agoThat's fair, and to be clear I wasn't saying that's how it should be. I just know that a lot of people like to complain when they see "Project X got $N of donations" and feel like as a result they're entitled to "customer service"...at least in some of the drama of I've seen. That said, the drama might be more outlier...I've never really had an open source project that's big enough for people to want to give me money for it, so I will totally admit I'm speaking out of ignorance.
- kokanee 5y agoOne way to think about this is that people should donate based on value that they've already gained from the project, not additional value that they expect in the future. That said, for an active maintainer who is currently accepting donations (ESPECIALLY recurring donations), making a good-faith effort to deliver on requests from supporters (certainly bugs, and ideally features) is expected. Failure to make that effort doesn't mean you owe anyone anything, but it might mean you're a jerk.
- smnrchrds 5y ago> no donations = no expectations No donations should result in no expectations, but unfortunately all sorts of people will have all sorts of expectations from you when you release an open-source project, donations or not.
- KMnO4 5y agoDonations should also result in no expectations. It’s a donation, not a support license.
- irrational 5y agoTheoretically the same applies to Kickstarter. Supposedly it is not a pre-order platform, but everyone treats it that way and gets all bent out of shape if the reward never materializes.
- paxys 5y agoNot quite the same. Kickstarter does require projects to commit to delivering whatever they promised to backers at the time of the contribution as long as the project is fully funded. They themselves aren't going to process refunds, but you do have a legal avenue if you really want your money back, which isn't the case for any random donation.
- robertlagrant 5y agoGenerally when things are not nearly as well developed as the original Kickstarter text promised.
- 999900000999 5y agoKickstarter can claim to be whatever it wants, but if I say if you give me $2,000 I'll do my best to delivermagical super shoes... And I end up taking all the money and spending it a 2-month trip to Canada,I've sort of done something wrong. No matter what Kickstarter says, you can definitely be sued if you take someone's money and don't deliver what you promised. I absolutely loved Kickstarter when it came out, but I don't think I've donated any money to any Kickstarter just because it's more stressful to try and keep track of whenever the hell I'm supposed to get my product. Amazon and eBay are full of useless things I can get delivered tomorrow, why go on Kickstarter and wait 3 months or even a year?
- freediver 5y agoThere is nothing wrong with being rewarded for your work. There could be uBlock Origin Pro for people who want to support it. It can offer no other feature other than a Pro icon.
- bspammer 5y agoPresumably the feeling of doing good in the world is reward enough for them, especially if they already have more than enough money to get by (as most devs in the west do).
- freediver 5y agoNothing would prevent him to donating the excess money to causes he cares about?
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThere are other ways of supporting a project than via money. You can talk about it and recommend it to others. That can often be worth more than donations to an independent project that doesn't have much in terms of marketing capabilities.
- pjscott 5y agoWhen people donate to an open source software project, they probably aren't intending to donate to some other cause that the maintainer cares about. It would be at least slightly unethical to solicit donations for the former and spend them on the latter unless the donation page was exceptionally forthright about it.
- matheusmoreira 5y agoI'd totally pay for that.
- BeetleB 5y agoThere's nothing wrong with not accepting rewards for your work.
- tomjen3 5y ago>I want to be free to move onto something else if ever I get tired working on these projects I absolutely get this feeling of not wanting to be trapped, nor should you ever feel like you have to work on it. You have already volunteered your time plenty. uBlock origin is maybe one of the most critical extensions, maybe the most critical extension. If for some reason you don't want to maintain it, please let us know so somebody can take it over.
- abdullahkhalids 5y ago> I don't want the administrative workload coming with donations. It's absolutely shameful that over three decades into the internet age, we still don't have zero friction ways of accepting, sending and accounting for money on the internet.
- vikingerik 5y agoBitcoin is pretty close to this, right? Anyone can publish a Bitcoin address and accept donations with no friction.
- treszkai 5y agoYou still should pay your taxes on Bitcoin you earn. Tax evasion is easier, but not when your address is on the top of your project's website.
- andrewxdiamond 5y agoThe payment technology is less of an issue. Consumers been able to send small amounts of money all over the world for a decade or two. It’s more about the regulatory framework around taxes and income that make this difficult
- viraptor 5y agoThere's still friction. Do you know how to do your taxes on international income, CGT, discounting transfer fees, etc? There are services which will do most of that for you, but that's still time to export/import the transactions, ~$50 to get the summary, some more time to deal with actually putting that info on your tax return. Realistically that's probably 3h of work in a year, but I'd probably pay a bit of money not to have to do it.
- folli 5y agoFor small donations (e.g. $5) the transaction fee off Bitcoin can be larger than the amount.
- paxys 5y agoThat's because it isn't a technology problem but a legal one.
- pictur 5y agoThere are so many people who are collecting donations and advancing all their projects according to their will. they don't even take suggestions seriously :D but I like your point of view.
- ropp 5y agoIsn't that the idea of donations, though?
- Anthony-G 5y agoI understand why gorhill doesn’t want to accept donations. I’ve seen him post on Hacker News every now and again so I would like to suggest that he encourage users of uBlock and uMatrix to make a donation to a favoured charity similar to how Bram Molenaar encourages Vim users to donate to the ICCF in Uganda¹. I usually make a few donation around this time of year to FOSS projects and other valuable services such as archive.org, Wikipedia, FSF, EFF, etc. ¹ http://vimdoc.sourceforge.net/htmldoc/uganda.html http://vimdoc.sourceforge.net/htmldoc/uganda.html
- softwarebeware 5y agoOn any of the open-source projects I've been involved with that wasn't already funded somehow, I never experienced that anyone asked "Why don't you accept donations?" Would have been nice :)
- p2p_astroturf 5y agoBecause I'm not a prick who needs clout for every single unit of hobbies I carry out.
- grouphugs 5y agoi do, but i don't get any
- max_ 5y agoIn use this thing everyday. Thank you very much for your work.