8 ms·
Stephen Wolfram – re:Clojure Keynote [video]
- znpy 5y agoIt starts interesting but it then kinda becomes a Mathematica/Wolfram marketing stunt ?
- queuebert 5y agoI can't figure out if Wolfram is a brilliant scientist or a brilliant carney.
- pmarreck 5y agoThere's a certain type of "success trap" where one's first success is so significant that they don't ever need to figure out how to work with other people (or at least people who are peers and not underlings), and I think that's where the "carney" element comes from, where you're sort of drunk on your own hubris (regardless of actual merit)
- queuebert 5y agoExactly. It's like he assumes that everything he does is brilliant, when in reality most people think Mathematica kind of sucks and cellular automata are flat out useless. Probably related to being a child prodigy and always being told how smart he is.
- lioeters 5y agoThat reminds me of a quote about arrogance/confidence/self-respect.. > I am persuaded that no one ever achieves anything worth-while in this world unless he has so great a respect for his work that he compels all other men to respect it. Apparently this comes from an article published in 1922 by an anonymous author. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28509935 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28509935
- copperx 5y agoCan you expound a bit on "Mathematica kind of sucks"?
- jonas21 5y agoWhy not both?
- AlexCoventry 5y agoThanks, I came over here to see whether it goes anywhere worthwhile.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Keyframe 5y agoClassic Wolfram then? edit: watching it.. SMP, Wolfram, computational language, he did all of that for past 40 years of course, he even managed to put himself in the same sentence as John McCarthy, they invented notebooks and then he's showcasing Mathematica/notebook.. I actually quite like Wolfram, but sometimes he's just a tad too much.
- dmos62 5y agoI'm normally sensitive to people being full of themselves and I've no such sensation with Wolfram. I'm fascinated by what he has to say; I find his perspective on computational and programming languages, him being a specialist outsider, insightful and valuable.
- motoboi 5y agoThe problem with such accomplished and genius people is that when they talk about what they did, it feels too much. Guess what: it is much.
- copperx 5y agoHe forgot about Clojure after a minute or so. Never forget your audience.
- Keyframe 5y agoneat overview of mathematica, or wolfram desktop or whatever.. angle being language design.. but yeah, clojure disappeared as soon as the camera turned on.
- nightski 5y agoMathematica uses a functional language at its core. As a functional language enthusiast (including Clojure, although I haven't used it for anything professionally) I find discussions about any functional language interesting. In other words, I doubt the only thing Clojure folks care about is Clojure.
- spoonjim 5y agoEvery utterance from Wolfram is Mathematica marketing, even when he writes (amazing) eulogies for his late friends.
- shaftoe444 5y agoWolfram is on from -2:15:40
- sokoloff 5y ago+9:40:10 seems a useful timestamp reference to me if your YouTube client references from the start of video. At +10:06:00, he starts talking a bit about clojure. 26 minutes into his presentation at a clojure conference and he talks about clojure for well under 2 minutes, most of which was analyzing the text on the wikipedia page for clojure... At +10:16, he then very briefly demos a linkage from the clojure repl into the Wolfram Engine, which is arguably the only part that's specifically interesting to most conference watchers. If this were a keynote at a Wolfram conference, it would have been a better fit than as a keynote at a Clojure conference.
- vmsp 5y agoI had never heard of Mathematica before. I'm pretty sure I'd never use it for anything but one thing that caught my eye is how easy it is to generate mock data. E.g. WordList
- spoonjim 5y agoIt’s one of the best pieces of software in the world, with things like Microsoft Excel and Google Maps. It is run by an absolutely insufferable guy but he does a good job with it.
- ithinkso 5y agoCan I ask you how old are you? Or who do you work? Most of people in tech do not use Mathematica but I would put a lot of chips on a bet that most heard of it. That's why I'm courious
- sgillen 5y agoI would bet most techy people my age (mid 20's) are aware of Wolfram Alpha, but maybe not Mathematica.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 323 5y agoJupyter notebook was inspired by Mathematica (as stated by it's author).
- julienchastang 5y agoAnd Mathematica was inspired by REPL-style languages (LISP, APL) that go back to the dawn of computing.
- awak3ning 5y agoWolfram's ego has always been the most off putting thing about him and his project. I was quite disappointed by the lack of Clojure relevant material in this Keynote and the unabashed emphasis on himself and his product.
- okareaman 5y agoI don't know if his narcissism rises to the level of a disorder, but I do think it limits him in some important ways.
- yeetaccount3 5y ago> I don't know if his narcissism rises to the level of a disorder I don’t really know much about him except for his ego, which seems to overshadow all of his achievements.
- pokoleo 5y agoOnce as a new grad I asked (after he gave a talk on the virtues of oss) why the newly released Wolfram language wasn’t open source. He called me naïve, said that my question was childish, then asked for the next question. If dunking on a 23 year old makes him feel good about himself, so be it. I couldn’t imagine working anywhere near him. I wonder what he does behind closed doors.
- copperx 5y agoI had the same impression; however, after seeing a few livestreams with his employees discussing development, bugs, and design ideas, he does seem respectful and does constructive criticism quite well. I know that's not "closed door" behavior, but seems genuine.
- westoncb 5y agoMaybe I'm misinterpreting, but this reads to me like you were trying to get a rise out of him and succeeded... it's posing a question that includes the assertion that he's hypocrite (talk on oss virtues -> own software not oss) live in front of an audience.
- ppod 5y agoI do understand the pushback on Wolfram's egotism and self-branding stuff, but he is absolutely wonderful to listen to and still comes across as a bit of a genius. I think history will be kind to him.
- schappim 5y agoHe has done what many of us want to achieve. Billion dollar SW company that is privately owned, that now enables him to pursue his intellectual interests.
- amelius 5y agoWhat's absolutely admirable is that he managed to start a successful business in scientific computing. That's no easy feat.
- Gatsky 5y agoI beg to differ. I think that in the current era, where there is a lot of live footage of people and uncurated writings like twitter, the stature of 'the genius' will inevitably be reduced. Consider someone like Newton where everything we know is very filtered, and compare to say Richard Dawkins' twitter feed where he says random stuff that is sometimes ill-considered and posts pictures of his broken windscreen. Elon Musk is probably another example. This is probably a good thing overall, seeing this juxtaposition of the sacred and the profane.
- copperx 5y agoThe internet would have not reduced the stature of Ramanujan and Von Neumann in any way. See Terry Tao for an example.
- kaba0 5y agoMusk and the word genius have absolutely nothing to do with each other. He got rich from daddy’s bloody emerald mine, sells himself as a self-made billionaire and pays for his image (buying the title CEO of tesla, etc), without putting anything behind, other than his true self, a whiny scammer.
- 5y ago
- mark_l_watson 5y agoI learned a lot watching the demo. Twice in the last three years I have signed up for Wolfram Desktop (about $30/month) and experimented with it. They even added some semantic web and SPARQL support. Watching his demo was good documentation. Both times I signed up for the service, I canceled after a few months because I didn’t have a real use case. Ten years ago, I experimented with my own Clojure to Wolfram Language bindings https://github.com/mark-watson/clojure_wolfram_alpha https://github.com/mark-watson/clojure_wolfram_alpha
- schappim 5y agoThis has been my experience too. I think it would be more empowering if I were not a dev.
- mycall 5y agoI often go to wolframalpha if I want an answer to something fast and easy. Half the time I don't express the right question or the results go somewhere else. In those times, I need to write some code. Still, it is nice when the answer pops up.
- claytongulick 5y agoI met Mr. Wolfram once, chatted with him for quite a while. He was super down to earth and kind, even though it was obvious to both of us that he was completely out of my league. I saw him give a talk at SXSW and deal very patiently with idiots in the crowd that were using the q & a session to score cheap political points. Overall, I was pretty impressed with the man. Much smarter than I'll ever be.
- mycall 5y agoOh, if I had to talk to him, I would bring up something exotic like rock skipping on water and how he would beat the record. Watch how his brain works.
- frazbin 5y agoWhere does he even get money from? A quick Google suggests Mathematica is used by approximately no one. Some kinda sweetheart university licensing deal?
- coldtea 5y agoNo, it's just that some people are not as good at quick Google searches as they think.
- projectileboy 5y agoMathematica has been pervasive in the scientific and engineering community for about 30 years (although becoming less so as more people use Jupyter, R, and other solutions).
- frazbin 5y agohttps://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=mathematica https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=m...
- frazbin 5y agoalso, on Linkedin: 1500 postings for mathematica, 150,000 postings for MATLAB? Don't get me wrong I use a lot of dead software too, it gets things done. Just saying, Mathematica might be a bit less Apple, and a bit more Amiga, at this point.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rexpress 5y agoFor context, picking on Clojure because it too is a nice, niche language, https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=%2Fm%2F0d2jd,%2Fm%2F03yb8hb https://trends.google.com/trends/explore?date=all&geo=US&q=%... But in fact the long term decline Google Trends gives for Mathematica and Clojure also shows for plenty of other languages, including mainstream ones such as JavaScript and Java. I'm not sure what the explanation is, but I'd be wary of relying on Google Trends to make predictions about the life expectancy of any particular language.
- emmanueloga_ 5y agoThis thread gives me an idea: a browser extension to gray out content using sentiment analysis [1]. I suspect some people may have even seen the video and found some useful stuff to share/comment about it, but it is just annoying/time consuming to find such comments in here in between all the Wolfram hate :-p What's the state of the art on sentiment analysis? Is it more or less reliable these days? :-) 1: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentiment_analysis# https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sentiment_analysis#