7 ms·
Masks may "work" to a limited extent to reduce the risk of transmission in any single interaction, but in the long run that won't save anyone. The virus is now
by nradov 5y ago
Masks may "work" to a limited extent to reduce the risk of transmission in any single interaction, but in the long run that won't save anyone. The virus is now endemic and almost everyone will eventually be exposed regardless of public health measures. You can't seriously expect asymptomatic people to wear masks in public forever.
https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/94646 https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/vinay-prasad/94646
So what are the exit criteria?
- micromacrofoot 5y agoI kind of like them so I just might. I haven’t had a single cold for 2 years.
- naikrovek 5y ago> You can't seriously expect asymptomatic people to wear masks in public forever. why not? I enjoy foiling facial recognition efforts, and those efforts are everywhere. I probably won't ever stop wearing a mask in public.
- misiti3780 5y agobecause there are a lot of people that feel the exact opposite of you - i dont ever want to wear one again!
- formerly_proven 5y ago> i dont ever want to wear one again! Why do you feel so strongly about this? Masks of a few kinds are standard PPE in many fields, it's not like they're particularly restrictive or anything.
- wowokay 5y agoThose fields people choose to join, they made the decision to accept that requirement. Plus as others have said in the grand scheme it's not the most effective Solution. Remote work, contactless services and other similar initiatives would yield a higher success and would reduce other things like crime and environmental impacts, why not pursue that or a contactless society instead if the goal is to prevent transmission
- Geezus-42 5y agoWhy not both?
- jaywalk 5y agoNobody should have to justify why they don't want to wear a mask, the same way nobody should have to justify why they do. Justification is needed when you want to force your opinion on others.
- geoduck14 5y ago>Nobody should have to justify why they don't want to wear a mask, the same way nobody should have to justify why they do. Consider you are doing UX design. You wrote some software that helps your customer, but they won't use it. Why won't they use it? How can you improve it? What alternatives can you implement to keep the benefits that you are trying to give to your customers while also making the product "acceptable"? Short questions like "why won't you use masks?" Can come off as antagonistic (e.g. shame on you! Just use the Fing mask), but they may also be inquisitive (e.g. what concerns do YOU have with masks). This being HN, I prefer to assume the intent is the latter.
- jaywalk 5y agoYou are correct, of course. And if the parent I replied to was simply being inquisitive, I apologize for my tone. But in the current climate, it's hard for me to read it that way without it being specifically pointed out.
- jatone 5y agowhen their refusal to do so in the public sphere endangers others. indeed they do need to justify it.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI have a family member who is a surgeon who is obviously accustomed to wearing a mask frequently in her job, but now that she has to wear it 100% of the time at work she finds it particularly exhausting and rips it off as soon as she is done.
- BoxOfRain 5y ago>Why do you feel so strongly about this? From a practical point of view I think that the plastic ones are probably going to be horrible from an environmental perspective - especially to the marine environment which is where a lot of plastic litter ultimately ends up. I'll admit there's also an element of iconoclasm involved in why I'll be keen to see the back of them when their times comes. From a purely symbolic point of view (ie regardless of their effectiveness) they're quite a dystopian thing in my opinion, it's a signal of "be afraid of disease" or worse still "my fellow human beings are disgusting plague vectors". I can't help that feel that making hiding our faces a permanent social norm would lead to society becoming even more atomised than it already is which is also fairly dystopian. On a purely personal note, I also don't like that they give every moral authoritarian and insufferable busybody yet another thing to harass strangers about, especially when legal penalties for non-compliance exist.
- misiti3780 5y agoI live in a warm/hot climate and they are very uncomfortable when it's 90F+ outside. Vaccines are available to everyone in the US, and I'm double vaxxed, everyone I know is double vaxxed, and I'm not afraid of getting COVID -- why should I wear one? If people want to wear one for the rest of their lives (I doubt they will), have at it. If it is to avoid facial recognition, I guess I get that but have to understand that in that situation you are in a tiny minority of people willing to cover your face in defense of your digital privacy. (Look around you, 90% of the people are uploading themselves to TikToc without a care in the world) At this point, the masking mandates in the US makes absolutely no sense either. If you fly on a plane, you are allowed to take your mask off to eat or drink but then have to put it back on when your not doing either, as if COVID disappears when you're eating. You can cross state boarders without being tested, etc. We need to start learning how to live with COVID, because zero COVID is no longer an option. That ship has sailed.
- dkonofalski 5y ago> as if COVID disappears when you're eating No, but you can't really eat with a mask on so keeping it on for the entire rest of the time minimizes the risk of spreading and transmitting it. Even if it's not 100% perfect, it still has a significant positive benefit.
- misiti3780 5y agoI disagree.
- naikrovek 5y agoyou disagree with how statistics work? taking off your mask to eat does not negate the rest of the time you wore the mask. how the hell do people not understand why masks work? I do not understand this. an analogy: let's say I am at work, and I fart, but oops, it's poo instead, and now it's all over this side of the conference room floor, even in places you can't see with the naked eye. should I have worn clothes? clothes are so intrusive and restrict my ability to move and express myself, and it's immoral that you create a rule that keeps me caged when I only crap in the conference room three times a year. the poo in that analogy represents the aerosol saliva and mucus of someone that is contagious with anything, which is stuff that is regularly produced when people talk or breathe. the clothes are a facemask. how do people not understand why facemasks are effective? I don't want to step in anyone's crap that they left behind wherever they coughed or sneezed or touched the break room chair. wash your damned hands and wear a facemask if you're sick, dammit.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoThis visage, no mere veneer of vanity, is a vestige of the “vox populi” now vacant, vanished.
- NoGravitas 5y agoVoilà! In view, a humble vaudevillian veteran, cast vicariously as both victim and villain by the vicissitudes of fate.
- fimdomeio 5y agoFor social reasons. There's so much information you get from one person face that keep using the mask forever would have very negative social effects that are probably almost impossible to measure.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gherkinnn 5y agoGait recognition doesn't care about masks. I don't know how far the technology got, but as a human I find recognising humans by their gait trivial enough.
- AutumnCurtain 5y agoI once recognized a former football teammate from the stands years later when he was in full pads and helmet just from how he ran onto the field. No doubt an AI could be even more accurate, which is why I recommend wearing a mask and riding a hoverboard everywhere.
- geoduck14 5y agoThanks for reminding us that there are A LOT of different ways to recognize people! I had never considered looking at their gait, that sounds like cool research
- naikrovek 5y agothat is a non-statement somehow; you aren't responding to anything I actually said, but what you imagined that I said, and then you came up with a counter argument to the imaginary statement... the things people do really confuse me, sometimes. I .. I am just not capable of understanding why people do most of what they do. I didn't say I wanted to defeat gait recognition, did I? No, I did not. my turn to imagine something you'll say: "oh well you can also be recognized by your voice" I didn't say I wanted to defeat voice recognition, either. etc
- wowokay 5y agoActually there's a simple reason. If I have to wear a mask and social distance, I see no value in a vaccine. The point behind the "political" position isn't that masking is bad, the main position is that a mandate requiring it is bad. In a country where "My body, my choice" this is clearly a contradiction.
- bikingbismuth 5y agoSignificantly reducing my risk of dying intubated and in agony is a fairly compelling vaccine use case for me.
- downWidOutaFite 5y agoMy body my choice is about to be ruled illegal by the conservative court.
- twox2 5y agoLMAO, you're not foiling anything. They've moved to gait analysis years ago... which you probably can't fake.
- TheGigaChad 5y agoYour place is in a mass grave cuckdown faggot.
- BoxOfRain 5y ago>why not? I don't think even the most vocal opponents of masks saying we should ban them, if you want to wear a mask forever that's your business. I'd be monumentally miffed if mandates were in force forever though, especially in the half-arsed way we have them in the UK which is so arbitrary it makes a mockery of the whole concept.
- Angostura 5y ago> You can't seriously expect asymptomatic people to wear masks in public forever. Before we catastrophise, how about we start with the pragmatic - ask people to wear masks while infection rates are high. Which is unlikely to be forever There's a big difference between 'Covid is going to be with us forever' and 'Covid infection rates will threaten to overwhelm health services forever'.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoI agree with this, but in many places in the US health authorities have kept mask mandates indefinitely, regardless of current hospital capacity.
- marcan_42 5y agoFWIW, case rates in Japan are near nil (~15 people daily in Tokyo), the vaccination rate is closing in on 80%, and everyone still wears a mask. I don't know about "forever", but people in Japan have no problem wearing masks in public while asymptomatic with low case rates because we know it's a public health issue, and it's working. That's why we keep wearing them. I wasn't used to masking up pre-pandemic. I got used to it within the first month. Now I can't leave the house without a mask on. It feels wrong. (This doesn't mean I'm deathly afraid to remove/lower it, e.g. while eating at restaurants or when I'm outside with nobody around and I feel like a bit of a break).
- syshum 5y agoYou clearly then do not suffer from poor eye-sight that requires you to where a mechanical device on your face (i.e glasses) to correct for this How every abelist of you. My experience with masks, and glasses is very poor, specifically the more common cloth masks that go over the ears. Something like a Gaiter mask is slightly better but many say these are less effective
- jmopp 5y agoI'm the exaxt opposite. Before wearing a mask I would routinely have trouble keeping my glasses on. When I wear a mask it's actually easier to wear glasses because I can hook the sides into the ear loops and they won't fall off when I look down.
- nkrisc 5y ago> You can't seriously expect asymptomatic people to wear masks in public forever. Why not? Many societies expect that you wear clothes in public, and most people willingly comply every day. In many places it's actually mandated by law! Where are the anti-clothers protesting in state capitals? Oh yeah, they're nudists and most people don't take them seriously. Why is being required to wear a mask in public any different than being required to wear pants?
- shockeychap 5y ago> Where are the anti-clothers protesting in state capitals? > Why is being required to wear a mask in public any different than being required to wear pants? I was one of the people defending the mitigations early on, speaking out against the "conspiracy theorists" - those who said the new controls by those in power would never be given up and that this would be the new normal. I slowly came to see that they were right. Sentiments like this prove it.
- afavour 5y agoPerspectives like this baffle me. Why would those in power never give up the power to… make people wear masks? It’s a pretty shitty power. It also makes ubiquitous surveillance more difficult because you can’t scan people’s faces reliably. I also don’t understand why sentiments like this prove anything. Is the OP a person in power? Nothing suggests that. They’re just a person that’s being (overly) cautious. FWIW I don’t agree with them but I also don’t think they’re a lizard person.
- claytongulick 5y agoBecause it's an incremental step along the path to reducing or eliminating the right to self-ownership. If you can normalize something like mask wearing, there's a strong psychological effect. There's a sort of built-in obedience that's a clear signal to those around you. Arm bands also come mind. Is it then such a leap to grant the power of forced vaccination? I mean, it's all for the public good right? Flu is a deadly killer. We should probably go ahead and mandate that vaccine too, while we're at it. Traffic accidents are a leading cause of death in the U.S. - why are we allowing private car ownership? We could save tens of thousands of lives per year if we centralized control of transportation. Guns? They're right out. While we're at it, there's no good reason to allow fast food restaurants to continue to exist. Obesity is an epidemic and costs the U.S. billions, if not trillions and is a leading cause of heart disease. Let's get rid of all fast food restaurants. Since we're doing that, we should also probably mandate that every restaurant remove the deep fried. They can make something more healthy. And on. And on. This never ends. You say that the perspective baffles you. I'm trying to illustrate the perspective that those of us who believe in maximizing personal liberty hold. Incrementalism is a real thing. An affront to liberty must be stopped at the beginning, if it is to be stopped at all. Many people reading through what I just wrote actually believe doing all of those things would be a good idea, and they may be right. I think a better idea is to allow people to live their lives the way they chose.
- the-dude 5y agoNobody claims masks need to be worn forever. That is your statement. We still need to slow down the spread though, as several operations otherwise can't handle the load. In NL, our undertakers have employed external cooling cells again, just like last winter, to be able to 'service' the dead.
- temp8964 5y agoThe top comment uses Japan as the example. They do wear masks forever. So maybe the top comment shouldn't used Japan as the example.
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoJapan doesn't, and hasn't, had an indefinite mask mandate, like SF has had. If wearing "forever" means individuals wear masks when they're feeling ill, or when they're in a place with current high transmission of respiratory illness, then I'm all for wearing masks "forever".
- sharken 5y agoExactly this. We have to live with the virus same as with the flu. And I agree that having healthy people wear masks just to be safe is unacceptable.
- dd36 5y agoIs having drunk driving laws just to be safe unacceptable?
- sharken 5y agoI don't think that's entirely the same thing, but let's say it is just for arguments sake. Without the vaccines you might have a point, except that Corona and the large flu seasons are not that different for most countries if you measure hospitalizations and deaths. With the vaccine it's two wholly different things as the vaccine is your way to protect yourself. A SUV driven by a drunk driver can kill a dozen people, that have no way of avoiding that.
- helge9210 5y agoDriving a car is not a right. It is privilege. Since when breathing open air become a privilege?
- dd36 5y agoWhy isn’t it a right?
- Griffinsauce 5y ago> in the long run that won't save anyone > eventually I don't know exactly about the US but in NL that is precisely the sticking point. It doesn't matter that everyone will get it, it matters when everybody gets it because we don't have the ICU capacity to treat everyone at the same time (+ regular ICU patients and overhead for scheduled surgeries)
- hef19898 5y agoIn Germany, a country with among the highest rate of ICU beds per capita, we reached a point where scheduled surgeries for cancer patient are delayed because of this. Yet alone to speak about emergencies, in some regions it really is a bad time to have a heart attack or a stroke. Or a serious accident. Which is why I am so frustrated with people refusing to be vaccinated and with our politicians that ignored all warning over a calm summer, again after they did the same ting in 2020. Because reasonable, innocent people are suffering now. Sometimes I wished voluntarily unvaccinated people would be consequent enough to refuse treatment.
- galaxyLogic 5y agoI think unvaccinated people's healthcare premiums should simply go up.
- trentnix 5y agoBeing unvaccinated is a pre-existing condition. It should inform treatment strategies the same way other co-morbidities might. And since being vaccinated produces better outcomes that result in a decrease in medical costs (which overwhelming evidence indicates it does), higher premiums for unvaccinated is a good idea. It's the best approach to encouraging vaccination, in fact. But the entire premise of raising premiums for unvaccinated people assumes people should bear any financial responsibility for their own healthcare (and consequently, any financial responsibility for their own health-related choices). But if unvaccinated people pay higher premiums, then that logic would follow that other pre-existing conditions might be met with increases premiums. And to continue the logic, some ethnic groups have higher incidences of certain diseases. Should they pay higher premiums or would that be branded discriminatory? And so politics enters the fray. And another good idea is crushed under the weight of vote-seeking, political correctness, and the desire to punish wrongthink.
- JoachimS 5y ago> Masks may "work" to a limited extent to reduce the risk of transmission in any single interaction, but in the long run that won't save anyone. Could you elaborate on the statement at the end - "but in the long run that won't save anyone.". Anyone, as in nobody? How come?
- aqme28 5y agoHe's saying (approximately correctly) that everyone will get COVID eventually. Though I'd like to add that you could get a vaccine instead.
- afavour 5y ago> So what are the exit criteria? Vaccination. Which is one of the reasons it’s especially infuriating when anti-maskers are also anti-vaccine. By far and away the easiest way to do away with masks is for everyone to just get the vaccine. For myself, I have two small children that are currently not eligible to be vaccinated. So I will be continuing to wear a mask indoors until they can be. > You can't seriously expect asymptomatic people to wear masks in public forever. Another shame this has become such a culture war topic because there’s nothing wrong with the idea of wearing masks when appropriate, indefinitely. As the OP said, in Japan people wear them during flu season and when they feel themselves coming down with a cold. There’s nothing wrong with that, nor is it a particular burden on the vast majority of the population. I live in NYC and might continue to wear a mask when I’m on the subway during flu season, it feels like common sense. But I know if I try to do that in other cities in the country I’ll be looked upon as if I’m a leper.
- blindmute 5y agoThere is nothing wrong with wearing a mask however long you want. There is however something very wrong with being forced to wear a mask against your will however long someone else wants.
- TheBlight 5y agoDo you not pay attention? Have you not seen case numbers in Gibraltar? Fully vaxed Lebron James caught it. In what world do you live in such that you can ignore the vaccines are obviously not preventing transmission?
- afavour 5y agoVaccines dramatically reduce the danger of the virus. I have friends who caught COVID pre-vaccine and it was horrendous. Some are still dealing with the effects today. I have other friends that caught it while vaccinated. They felt rough for a few days. The public health argument is very clear: vaccines reduce transmission. No, they don’t stop it. But they also reduce the strain on ICUs and other healthcare facilities needed to treat people with extreme cases. In what world do you live in such that you can ignore that?
- bluecalm 5y agoThere might be effective drug treatment in the near future. It would be nice to not get COVID to then.
- nradov 5y agoWe already have effective drug treatments. How much more effective do you want? https://www.covid19treatmentguidelines.nih.gov/about-the-guidelines/whats-new/ https://www.covid19treatmentguidelines.nih.gov/about-the-gui... And remember that while the vaccines don't reliably prevent infection, they're pretty good at preventing severe symptoms.
- noasaservice 5y agoWorst case: what if there isn't exit criteria? Are you that weak of a human to not wear a mask when you're sick, or during a pandemic? Or is this just a "Lets Go Brandon" (aka: fuck joe biden) dogwhistle? Cause your "question" isnt certainly about anything scientific.
- claytongulick 5y agoYour comment perfectly illustrates the concerns that those of us who resisted mask mandates from the beginning hold. From your comment I can infer that when you observe a person not wearing a mask, you make an immediate assumption about their political ideology. I believe that this was the main purpose of mask mandates, not public health.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoRemember when this started, and we wanted to reduce 'R0' to slow the spread so hospitals could manage? Masks help with that, whatever absolutist arguments folks come up with. Sure they're not 100%, won't guarantee anything. But they DO slow transmission. So lets quit with the indignation and blamethrowing, and wear the damn mask, do your part.
- syshum 5y agoWhen this started it was "2 Week to flatten the curve", and that 2 Weeks was not masking, it was stay at home, do not travel, do not interact, and DO NOT wear a mask. We were told to NOT wear masks, so much so the government was confiscating masks from businesses.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoThat's apocryphal. For instance it didn't happen around here. Sure some folks over-reacted in some places. But in the interest of not spreading more indignation and outrage, it's pointless to go on about that.
- dkonofalski 5y agoNot commenting on the nature of your comment but just wanted to point out that the author of that article was one of the authors of the Great Barrington Declaration that attempted to convince the Trump administration that "herd immunity" was the best solution in dealing with COVID-19 because the people that signed it were losing money.