15 ms·
New German government calls for European ban on biometric mass surveillance
- ngcc_hk 5y agoBut ok non-Eu especially china. Or you refuse technology to them as well. Wonder.
- 1cvmask 5y agoNot a lawyer here but it seems that there are exceptions carved out: In particular, we ask the Commission to prohibit, in law and in practice, indiscriminate or arbitrarily-targeted uses of biometrics which can lead to unlawful mass surveillance. - So long as it is discriminate and non-arbitrary that can be ok then? We have seen so many legal justifications and equivocations to laws from the surveillance state that I now assume legal counsel will always find a way to break the prima facie law. German intelligence broke many German laws with the NSA, while Merkel virtue signaled and decried the NSA (comparing them to the Stasi) and Obama spying on her. https://www.dw.com/en/edward-snowden-germany-a-primary-example-of-nsa-surveillance-cooperation/a-50452863 https://www.dw.com/en/edward-snowden-germany-a-primary-examp... https://www.dw.com/en/danish-secret-service-helped-us-spy-on-germanys-angela-merkel-report/a-57721901 https://www.dw.com/en/danish-secret-service-helped-us-spy-on... https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/17/merkel-compares-nsa-stasi-obama https://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/dec/17/merkel-compare...
- mschuster91 5y agoTo quote the original from the Koalitionsvertrag (https://www.tagesschau.de/koalitionsvertrag-147.pdf https://www.tagesschau.de/koalitionsvertrag-147.pdf): > Biometrische Erkennung im öffentlichen Raum sowie automatisierte staatliche Scoring Systeme durch KI sind europarechtlich auszuschließen (page 19) Translated: Biometric recognition in public spaces as well as AI-based, automated scoring systems ran by governments are to be prohibited by European law. > Flächendeckende Videoüberwachung und den Einsatz von biometrischer Erfassung zu Überwachungszwecken lehnen wir ab Translated: We refuse widespread video surveillance as well as usage of biometric recognition for surveillance purposes. To summarize: Using biometrics or other technology for surveillance, particularly any attempt to recreate China's Social Credit Score, is banned. The exception in the English text is to allow biometric measures for identification (e.g. passports) and access control.
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> Biometric recognition in public spaces ... are to be prohibited by European law. That's ok but an exception for law enforcement and national security would be useful. This technology is a tool, like all technologies, and as such it may be used positively or negatively. For instance, here in the UK we have automatic plate recognition cameras that are used to track uninsured or wanted cars. In the same spirit it might be useful to have similar cameras operated by the police to match people with a database of wanted or missing people (with only matches stored and reported for further investigation). Now this may not not work very well yet, there may be caveats and procedures to develop, etc but IMHO this means we should work on it and see if it can become useful rather than killing it off completely so early by having a blanket ban. In any case, individual member states can draw their own laws on this. On a side note, the wording in English might give the impression that the German government decides EU law...
- raxxorrax 5y agoI think the prevalence of CCTV in the UK warrants skepticism about its effectiveness as the UK doesn't necessarily have better crime numbers than comparable countries. I know video surveillance is mostly available in hot spots, but for me it is certainly uncomfortable to be under scrutiny constantly and it isn't something I would want to get used to as it does not provide significant benefits.
- gmueckl 5y agoExceptions for law enforcement have proven to be a very slippery slope in the past. Police is constantly trying to erode restrictions around tools that are only available for serious crimes and unfortunately also has a record of successfully circumventing any access checks for surveillance tools that have been put in place by lawmakers. There is constant and incessant lobbying from these circles to get more surveillance in place. But, when pressed, no one can point to cases where this actually helped. The only realistic way to counter this is to say no to surveillance technology from the start.
- raxxorrax 5y ago
- wolframhempel 5y agoI'm generally positively surprised by the coalition-agenda (Koalitionsvertrag) that was presented by the upcoming German government yesterday. Fairly centrist policies and a focus on modernization. There's a separate question about how much of it will actually be implemented, but the uncommon mix of three fairly different parties seems to have created a sensible equilibrium.
- wirrbel 5y agoAll parties have strong conservative wings. There is some potential for reform-pushing within the Greens and FDP, and I expect we won't see as much of that in the agreement but things will pop up once the chancellor has been elected.
- a_bonobo 5y agoWhat's interesting is that in the weeks leading up to the agenda, the Chaos Communication Club put up their own demands written like a digital agenda, essentially prewritten rules. And it turns out that the new agenda includes many of these rules! See https://blog.fefe.de/?ts=9f60b12e https://blog.fefe.de/?ts=9f60b12e Things like companies being legally responsible for security holes in their products, a right to encryption, open standards in government bodies, no 'hackbacks' from German security agencies, software updates and replacement parts need to be available for the lifetime of a product, all these things in the new government's agenda seem to come from the CCC. Lobbbying works! English auto-translation of the CCC's demands: https://www-ccc-de.translate.goog/de/updates/2021/ccc-formulierungshilfe-regierungsprogramm?_x_tr_sl=auto&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en-GB&_x_tr_pto=nui https://www-ccc-de.translate.goog/de/updates/2021/ccc-formul...
- raxxorrax 5y agoThey want to turn around mass surveillance at least, although they did not say anything about state trojans. The state bought NSO Pegasus too. But let us wait on their deeds, most of the new government was also part of the old government, which was very prone to increase "security®" to the detriment of everyone already living in the safest time of humanity. In a country that managed to build a totalitarian nightmare twice in just one century the belief in the state and general fear is already stuffily high in my opinion.
- throwaway55421 5y agoYet scanning a QR code which uniquely identifies an individual to get into any venue is totally fine because we didn't update the source code yet and so it's not phoning home this week. Well, if the source (of the scanner) is even legit, since the app stores provide no way to verify that anyway.
- thepangolino 5y agoThe lack of pushback against that practice literally blew my mind. The potential for abuse is literally limitless. I’ve even personally seen the treatment I’ve received the moment my name popped up on their screen after getting scanned. (My fave doesn’t show it but I’m of heavy ethnic background)
- throemdiwo 5y agoBless you. Of course, such things can only be muttered from throw away accounts.
- soco 5y agoComplaining about straw-man arguments is not bringing much. The facts are: the scanners code is opensource and does not phone home. The rest is fantasy - a valid ethical discussion of course, and it's up to us to discuss it properly (that is, keeping in touch with reality).
- nnamtr 5y agoA restaurant or company could use its own scanner app to save the data, but I assume this would be illegal
- soco 5y agoTechnically they could - if they had the skills (a restaurant with programmer staff?), had a the reason (risking to alienate the customers?) and had the guts to go against GDPR (somebody will spill the beans). So...
- chriswarbo 5y ago
- iso1631 5y agoIt's the automation that worries me. I'm not too concerned about proper companies using CCTV to record, as it's well managed and gets deleted unseen, unless something happens. I'm not too concerned about the police pulling those CCTV pictures to investigate a crime either. Things like ring doorbells on the other hand should be cracked down - the number of times I see people in the UK posting pictures of public areas on facebook is shocking, but if they're just sat there, being deleted unless pulled for a proper reason, that's fine too. What really does concern me is when things like image recognition come into the picture. A corporation can't montior me by paying someone to sift through CCTV pictures. They can montior me by using automation to process everything though. This is a good thing, how successful it is remains to be seen.
- jacquesm 5y agoThe other matter of concern is how many of these bits of data end up on servers outside of the EU, if you want something done about it you are essentially powerless.
- tentacleuno 5y ago> if you want something done about it you are essentially powerless. I wouldn't say people are "essentially powerless", especially in the EU with GDPR. I can't speak for other parts of the world of course (CCPA is the only thing remotely similar to GDPR that I'm aware of in America).
- gunapologist99 5y agoAt the end of the day, does it even really matter where the data is stored? It shouldn't be recorded in the first place.
- disabled 5y agoNot always true. It depends on the circumstances. That being said, I will never get a Ring doorbell or something similar. I also believe that the tech companies should not be allowed to hoard data about people’s private or public lives at all.
- nkmnz 5y agoThanks to FDP and Green Party —- you cannot trust Social Democrats on such issues at all!
- george_kaplan 5y agoNeither can you trust the FDP. When they became part of the governing coalition in the state of NRW they immediately passed a bill for more video surveillance and abolished the requirement for law enforcement to wear visible name labels or badge numbers.
- nkmnz 5y ago…the same kind of bitter pill the Green Party has to take whenever they are a minority partner in a State Government. Nothing new for both parties that they need to compromise - now, it’s new that they can act together on a lot of issues against a relatively smaller and potentially very weak third party. I know from first hand experience how deeply rooted the „law and order“ thought is within the Social Democratic Party, since I‘ve been running for office against one of their hard liners in 2013. Hint: it’s been the one caught buying crystal meth a couple of months later :)
- quakeguy 5y agoMichael Hartmann?
- stareblinkstare 5y ago>Since 2020, the Reclaim Your Face coalition has actively put pressure on decision-makers by uncovering surveillance, publishing research reports, and mobilising people for a society free from harmful technologies such as facial recognition in publicly-accessible spaces. Emphasis mine. This won't do much, and all the surveillance data will be shipped to China anyway. You're already in their database somewhere and they know more about you than the rest of the West combined.
- jchmrt 5y agoI think the defeatist stance of 'it will go to China anyways is quite harmful. We should at least try to legislate useful things and enforce them for the common good. Besides, if companies want to avoid the legislation, sending the data to China will not do them much good: what they are doing will be just as illegal. And presumably companies recording video on EU soil can be regulated from the EU.
- binarysneaker 5y agoI guess now that the UK is no longer part of the EU, this has a higher probability of happening.
- toss1 5y agoHa! I read "biometric mass surveillance" as some new remote sensing method to determine how much people weigh. The actual article makes more sense & is a good thing.
- siruncledrew 5y agoIt’s not just governments across Europe, but this petition also calls for the ban of companies doing it too. I wonder how the “watchdog” piece of this would work, practically speaking, since nowadays almost anywhere with a decent camera can implement some kind of facial recognition or tracking, and cameras are ubiquitous. Maybe places will find a workaround like just export the video to a different geographic zone datacenter to analyze it. I don’t see all governments or businesses agreeing to this because: 1. They wouldn’t want to, 2. It would be hard to prevent if the ways to do it still exist, 3. The “big enough” places will just do it anyway in secret.
- skummetmaelk 5y ago> Maybe places will find a workaround like just export the video to a different geographic zone datacenter to analyze it. Which is also illegal.
- moffkalast 5y agoBelieve it or not, straight to jail.
- isodev 5y agoIn most EU countries you can't just record people in public without their opt-in consent (Nope, not even taking pictures). Shipping the footage to another location is also not allowed unless you get informed consent exactly who and why will have access to your details.
- 71a54xd 5y agoI'm generally confused as to how the EU seemingly gets things right when it comes to privacy like banning biometric surveillance yet seems completely hell bent on creating a surveillance state in other areas (like banning encryption outright [0] or creating outsized penalties for wrong-speak [1]). Of course the US just builds things like this for political gain and taxation. 0 - https://mailbox.org/en/post/it-companies-warn-eu-plans-to-ban-encryption https://mailbox.org/en/post/it-companies-warn-eu-plans-to-ba... 1 - https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/qanda_20_1135 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/qanda_...
- zajio1am 5y agoAnd also forcing biometric data in ID cards: https://blog.hidglobal.com/2021/09/european-union-already-rolling-out-biometric-national-id-cards-travel-and-more https://blog.hidglobal.com/2021/09/european-union-already-ro...
- pjerem 5y agoWhat’s wrong with the biometric data as long as it’s only inside the card and not stored elsewhere ? The only thing you can do is to be able to prove (or not) that it’s your ID. Or am I missing something ?
- dane-pgp 5y agoHow did the data get into the card? And how do you know it isn't stored elsewhere? It wouldn't be the first time a government failed to admit exactly what information it was keeping about its citizens, and how it was using it against their interests: https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/bulk-personal-datasets-how-mi5-gchq-mi6-have-spied-innocent-civilians-over-decade-1556013 https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/bulk-personal-datasets-how-mi5-gch...
- chmod775 5y agoI don't think the UK is a good country to project from when it comes to matters of surveillance. They're quite on the extreme end.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoMaybe I missed it, but to what level is BMS happening already? Mind you, I understand the issue / problem. What I'm trying to gauge is the likelihood of a ban based on how embedded the behaviour is already.
- ramsundhar20 5y agoBiometric surveillance should get stopped. People deserve their privacy. EU should focus on greater human interests.
- throwawaysea 5y agoI don’t get why people want to ban facial recognition. There shouldn’t be an expectation of privacy in public spaces. And facial recognition is simply making a manual task police need to do a lot cheaper, helping them identify suspects who break the law. At least in the US, west coast cities definitely need greater surveillance of public spaces, with facial recognition (and other such tech), if they want to deal with the contagion of large raids on stores which began in SF and now has spread to LA. I feel like we can use this tech with some very simple controls like requiring reasonable suspicion of a crime, and keeping a human in the loop to verify matches, and make the best of this technology to help society. The group processing facial recognition matches can even be separate from the police force, essentially providing tips to police dispatch when they find a likely match.
- mekal 5y ago"There shouldn’t be an expectation of privacy in public spaces." Perhaps not to some degree, but facial recognition takes it up a notch. And ultimately what we should or shouldn't expect is up to us right? Suppose someone found a way to passively and remotely read people's minds. And as a result you can't go anywhere in public unless you were OK with your thoughts being captured and recorded. You could see how that would suck right? And the potential for abuse? Might be great for the police I suppose, and would probably lower the crime rate. But would you want to live like that? Facial recognition isn't that extreme of course, but they are both in the privacy ball park, at least in my opinion. So maybe its just a matter of degree...like what you're willing to put up with / feel comfortable with.
- charcircuit 5y agoIt wouldn't suck. Nothing would change for you. The impact to the average person's life would be 0.
- shapefrog 5y ago> Suppose someone found a way to passively and remotely read people's minds Can a trained chimp do that now? No. Can a trained chimp recognise a face. Yes. Computer facial recognition is simply digitising human workflow, like converting a speech to text. I assume people also have a similar problem with electronic transcription or 'word recognition technology'. Scanning peoples brains and reading their thoughts is literal mind reading science fiction.
- cyberpunk 5y agoMeanwhile from 2022 onwards all entry to the EU from non-eu citizens will require Fingerprints and Facial scans to be saved [0]. One rule for us, one for the rest, it seems. (For the record, I am absolutely against this, having recently lost my EU citizenship). 0: https://ees.secunet.com/en/about-entry-exit-system/ https://ees.secunet.com/en/about-entry-exit-system/
- bserge 5y agoCopying the other guys, as always. The US has been collecting fingerprints for decades, and many other countries do it, too.
- schleck8 5y agoIt's good meassure to prevent abuse of immigration opportunities. It's not possible for everything to be ideal, this is an acceptable compromise for most.
- cyberpunk 5y agoI'm curious why I've been down voted here -- I'm an EU resident, legally, and I am also Scottish -- so my EU citizenship that I was born with, was taken from me by the members of a country I consider rather different to myown, but who unfortunately rule over us due to pure numbers.. But I don't think I said anything offensive or false.. Fuck brexit, but also fuck fingerprinting foreigners (of whom I am now one apparently)...
- Kbelicius 5y agoIt isn't one rule for us, one for the rest. As a EU citizen my fingerprints and facial scans have already been saved and I didn't have to travel anywhere. Do you not have any form of ID in Scotland? If you do, does it not contain your picture and were you not required to give a fingerprint when you first requested it?
- cyberpunk 5y agoOh super late reply, but yes my photo is on my passport, no I didn't have to give fingerprints and I live in Germany, which has a rather tight view on such surveillance given their history.. I would refuse to give fingerprints, if asked, unless compelled to by a court. Same for my children.
- blurbleblurble 5y agoHow can they stop 5G?
- dane-pgp 5y agoThe parent comment may look like a baseless conspiracy theory, but it is worth considering the unintended consequences for privacy of bombarding public areas with more radio data. For example: > Researchers in the US have used WiFi signals to detect the gait of people through walls and match it to video footage in order to identify individuals. https://www.theengineer.co.uk/wifi-walls-walkers-gait/ https://www.theengineer.co.uk/wifi-walls-walkers-gait/
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoExactly right. But I wouldn't be sure those who agreed to the new coalition agreement understand any of this. Germany's legislature is hopelessly clueless when it comes to tech stuff (and other matters). It also appears to me that even many who do understand the danger aren't thinking their stance through properly. We live in a data world now more than ever. Data is power, data can be used as a weapon. I'm completely against mass surveillance, the same way I'm against war. At the same time, if the EU forbids any data collection in that regard, even by private companies, then the ones producing and controlling this data will be the likes of the US and China without doubt. Already facial recognition is used in machine learning, to auto-verify IDs, to catch criminals on the run, and for all sorts of other purposes. This is part of a much larger problem. We're under surveillance not just by cameras but microphones in devices all over, satellites, the various sensors in our phones, digital payment, social media activity, and so forth. Heck, most EU citizens have "smart" meters monitoring their electricity use now, which have been found make the leaking of all sorts of private information possible. The internet makes it all possible and in all cases I know about governments have not been proactive in legislation making. A blanket ban seems like an absolutely helpless and populist "solution" to the problem.
- blurbleblurble 5y agoThere are dozens+ papers like that specifically focused on mm-wave stuff, "passive" localization/identification/sensing. Gait doesn't go far enough to describe it. It's basically the equivalent of face recognition tech but in the mm-wave spectrum with standard router hardware. The various mm-wave bands being used in 5G (and being proposed for "6G") are much more dense (spatially and information theoretically) than the < 5GHz bands, but sparse enough compared to visible light that many obstacles are quite translucent. mm-wave antenna arrays are kinda just big low frequency eyeballs. Here's an old comment with some references: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22480444 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22480444 And a video to drive it home: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kBFMsY5ZP0o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kBFMsY5ZP0o
- streamofdigits 5y agoI just hope that the new balance of power in Germany will energize Europe to take concrete next steps towards an altenative way of organizing digital life.
- dane-pgp 5y agoAnother good opportunity for improving digital life in Europe is with the proposed Digital Markets Act[0], which looks set to mandate that phone OSes allow side-loading, and require social media & messaging services to interoperate with competitors. [0] https://www.euractiv.com/section/digital/news/eu-parliaments-key-committee-adopts-digital-markets-act/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/digital/news/eu-parliaments...
- streamofdigits 5y agoThese measures are good and necessary but on their own will not solve the problem. It is not sufficient to say "no", you need to provide (=invest)in alternatives that show what "good" looks like. For some bizarre reason the European continent has outsourced digital infrastructure. It is then no surprise that what is on offer is not congruent with the values and attitudes of its citizens.
- m0zg 5y agoThere will 100% be generous carveouts for the government and the security state by the time this is signed. Bet money on it. I'm sure it'll be "for the children" or "against terrorism" or "against COVID" or whatever, but the capability will remain. No government has ever willingly relinquished a capability like this.
- newtoy 5y agoWhere this all becomes problematic is either government or corporate entities using it to manipulate and punish individuals for being individuals but not harmful to others. Controlling whether you can even get water food and shelter and imprisonment for not promoting or for demoting their own world view.
- newtoy 5y agoBiometric mass surveillance is a problem because bad actors in government and corporations have and will use it to the individual’s detriment. People are prevented or made to endure hardship at acquiring food, water, shelter and clothing, imprisoned and punished, for nothing more than not being part of the party holding power.
- denton-scratch 5y agoI read the title as being about a ban on profiling fat people.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoI hope to see more of this all over the world. Just because you -can- do something doesn't mean you should do it. Technology that infringes on the right of privacy should be heavily curtailed as a matter of first intent and should only be reversed for things like criminal warrants. I would hope this would become a basically understood right if the West really wants to maintain liberal democracies rather than forever inching towards one-party fascism like we are currently headed in the USA.
- Animats 5y agoBut not phone-based mass surveillance, which is much lower cost.
- vegai_ 5y agoTheir new government seems like an absolute dream: legalize cannabis, push European federation, now this. There's gotta be a catch somewhere.
- hawk_ 5y agoThe "catch" is the doubt if they can get all these proposals through without significant watering down.
- raxxorrax 5y agoI will respawn as a barbarian if we create a European federation. I think this is populism from Scholz to pick up naive voters. I mean I understand the want to be part of something greater and I like all the countries in the EU, but this would basically be a foul compromise for everyone. The rest seems decent. It won't be implemented tomorrow and we have to wait if they keep their word.