17 ms·
British F-35B crash possibly caused by 'rain cover' left on during launch
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tartuffe78 5y agoNext time we have a real war I have a feeling there will be some very interesting dumb "hacks" used against all of these smart weapons.
- twic 5y agoLike a cluster bomb which sprays out rain covers. Devious!
- ryanchants 5y agoWe already had that in Afghanistan. Our LAVs were being defeated by IEDs, so we spent a lot of money making mine rollers. The mine rollers were then defeated with 10 cents worth of lamp cord to separate the pressure plate from the explosive.
- echelon 5y agoIn Afghanistan we were spending lots of money to not kill civilians and cause a PR nightmare. If we didn't care, we'd have carpet bombed the place. Or developed and used chemical weapons. In a real war, we'll be using tactical (not strategic) nukes to take out carriers and bases and supply lines, not toys that avoid collateral damage. If shit hits the fan, the strategic nukes come out and we all die.
- jason-phillips 5y ago> the strategic nukes come out and we all die To borrow from the Bronze Age conflicts between the Egyptians, Hittites, et al, you don't want to annihilate your adversary because you still have to trade with them. Wars are just a strategy to establish a more favorable trading position.
- swarnie 5y ago> to not kill civilians and cause a PR nightmare Estimates sit at around 240,000 deaths, great job. Still better then the Iraqi genocide mind....
- adventured 5y ago> Estimates sit at around 240,000 deaths You're of course referring to total estimated deaths over 20 years from all supposedly war-related causes (which includes poverty), not civilian deaths directly attributable to the US. The Taliban - as the blood-thirsty conquering force attempting to enslave the population of Afghanistan for the past several decades - is responsible for most of those deaths. It's funny how many people try to pretend the Taliban don't exist, their murders don't exist, the consequences of their conquering don't exist, and their aims don't exist, when it's convenient. The actual civilian deaths in Afghanistan by the US is a very small fraction of the number you're quoting, which is the point of the parent comment. The vast majority of violent civilian deaths were from the Taliban and associated groups, via suicide bombings and other intentional mass murder events. And the vast majority of all deaths during the Iraq civil war, were Iraqi on Iraqi murders. The US stepped in-between the warring factions and tried to stop it, which cost a lot of US blood and treasure. This isn't hidden magic information. It's right there in the estimates along with the number you quoted out of context. They break out how they arrive at the death totals.
- hindsightbias 5y agoThe US destabilized Iraq, leading to the Civil War. Not like they’re innocents in the matter.
- swarnie 5y agoThis is a lot of words to say: "We destabilised a region and are responsible for the MASSIVE number of civilian deaths as a result."
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoCompare to the Soviet-Afghan war where the Soviets were not so nice. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Afghan_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soviet%E2%80%93Afghan_War > Civilians: 562,000–2,000,000 killed Most civilian deaths during the US war in Afghanistan appear to be from the Taliban themselves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taliban https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Taliban > According to the United Nations, the Taliban and their allies were responsible for 76% of Afghan civilian casualties in 2010, and 80% in 2011 and 2012.
- sofixa 5y agoThat's naive. Strategic and tactical bombing did jack shit besides kill or at least make life miserable for lots of civilians, and destroy lots of land for the foreseeable future in Vietnam. Afghanistan is highly mountainous. Carpet bombing doesn't work very well for caves.
- dragontamer 5y agoWe pulled our punches in Afghanistan. Commanders on the ground were asking for air-dropped landmines to cover the areas that Bin Laden could have been using as an escape in Tora Bora in December 2001. Air-dropped land-mines would have made navigating those mountains much more difficult for Bin Laden, and may have killed him on his escape. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GATOR_mine_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GATOR_mine_system --------- They may use IADs, but we have far better equipment for that strategy. We can deploy our mines from airplanes and just blanket an area if we so choose. But of course: this strategy means killing innocent civilians who accidentally walk on the mines. -------- Difficult Terrain works for both sides. Sure, its difficult for us to move in, but that also makes it difficult for the enemy to move around. Doubly so if landmines are secretly littering areas.
- Someone1234 5y agoThe military is bored and loves to spend money on shinies. Everyone works hard to un-learn the most important lesson of war: In war, more of something beats less of something. And it isn't simply a "morer is betterer" argument, even strategically if you can place assets in multiple concurrent locations even if those assets are "dumber" then you're forcing the enemy to split their force into multiple beachheads. Embraer EMB 314 Super Tucano ($18M~) Vs. F-35A ($79M~). One F-35A obviously beats one Super Tucano but does it even have enough weapons onboard to beat 4.3? What if you split your Super Tucanos between two locations, which one is the F-35A going to defend? And the Super Tucano is even the endgame here, the endgame is drone swarms. $1M~/ea and you have a 79-1 ratio, and it is indefensible and laughably so.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThe F-35 is useless for long engagements, dead if it gets into a dogfight, and can't fly near thunderstorms or it might explode. This is assuming it doesn't suffocate its pilot to death, because Lockheed still can't get the oxygen system to work properly. The finest plane $350M (and climbing) can buy (for the F35-B variant. The A variant is down to "just" $100M or so.)
- nradov 5y agoThe primary threat is surface-to-air missiles, not other aircraft. A Super Tucano is simply not survivable against modern SAMs, nor does it have the sensors necessary to attack hardened ground targets. The F-35 at least has a chance.
- Someone1234 5y agoThe F-35 isn't completely stealth, it only offers a reduced sized signature for an aircraft of its size (no aircraft is completely, but the F-35 isn't even the best the US has in terms of stealth it isn't even in the top three). Before stealth small nimble aircraft avoided anti-aircraft fire by flying low where the horizon and or terrain would keep them shielded or provide physical barriers against missile intercept. That of course requires good low altitude, long duration flying which is also something the Super Tucano happens to excel at. I'd argue that the SAMs is an argument for "morer is betterer" since you're essentially pretending that the F-35 has perfect stealth instead of limited stealth, and relying on it being never shot down as your win condition (as opposed to building in losses and utilizing strategies not dependent on a technological advantage).
- Causality1 5y agoThe implications, if that is the cause, are shocking. Forget about the deck crew and the pilot being blind morons. It means the flight computer for a plane that took twenty years and a trillion dollars to develop can't detect that there's a fucking cover blocking the engine. How does a twenty thousand dollar sedan have a more robust readiness-detection system than a hundred million dollar airplane?
- elif 5y agoIt's possible (I would say likely) that there was a warning light. During normal aviation takeoffs, there are procedures that govern when it is too late to abort, and procedure dictates that it is safer to attempt flight. For a carrier, I imagine that point-of-no-return is about a few feet from stationary.
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoThe NEXT version of the software will surely add this check!
- ChuckNorris89 5y agoWait for the subscription-ware version where you need to pay 2 Billion per year to the defense contractor for the feature.
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoThat sounds like what we have now. We just haven’t formalized it. :-(
- m0zg 5y agoThat'll be another hundred billion dollars and five years tho. Maybe by then they'll install some functioning cannons on these.
- ChuckNorris89 5y ago>Forget about the deck crew and the pilot being blind morons. I thought aviation is THE industry that runs on procedures and checklists you need to tick before and after each flight to make sure the even if you're a complete klutz, nothing like this can ever happen. Did that go out the window? >It means the flight computer for a plane that took twenty years and a trillion dollars to develop can't detect that there's a fucking cover blocking the engine. This is pure gold. Even my robovac can detect when something is chocking the suction intake and shut down and send me a notification on my phone. The fact that a trillion dollar weapon missed this feature is hilarious.
- marcodiego 5y agoHow to shoot down a F-35B crash: "Dealing with what caused the F-35B crash, the British media outlet The Sun reports that it may have been a “cheap plastic cover” that was left on during take-off." Of course, this may be a simple strategy, red herring, to fool unfriendly nations, but... Also, makes me think about the MiG-29 which has special opening on the top of the engines so it can tak-off/land on unpaved runways: https://www.quora.com/How-is-the-Mikoyan-MiG-29-able-to-take-off-with-its-main-intakes-completely-shut-and-is-it-able-to-fly-in-this-configuration https://www.quora.com/How-is-the-Mikoyan-MiG-29-able-to-take...
- js2 5y ago> Anyway, let’s wait for the official investigation to provide more confirmed details about the incident and its root cause(s).
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoI highly doubt the initial story since it doesn't really make sense. There are tons of checks before takeoff. Jets also go full throttle during takeoff so this isn't something that would just show up during the roll
- fnord77 5y agoIs there a roll on an aircraft carrier?
- yborg 5y agoThere is on this one, it's a jump ramp carrier, not a catapult launch.
- trackone 5y agoI agree with you, this doesn't make much sense. The source quote is saying that someone saw a red cover in the water. How would the cover survive going through an engine? It should be shredded. Also, if the cover was left on it would have been sucked into the engine as soon as the pilot turned the engines on or when he when to full power before taking off. Makes more sense if a cover was left unsecured on the flight deck and was sucked in during take off. It still would be shredded though I would think.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- davewasthere 5y agoYeah, I can't see it quite happening the way the Sun intimates. Can't rule out FOD ingestion, but highly impropably could it have been an intake covers left on.
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoSurely there is video?
- dotancohen 5y agoI 𝐚𝐦 serious.
- nradov 5y agoYes aircraft carriers always have video cameras running during flight operations. However cameras mounted on the islands might not have a clear view of some sort of cover left on an aircraft.
- N19PEDL2 5y ago-- Possible stupid question here (apologize, I'm not an expert) -- How can a cheap plastic cover block the engines of a fighter aircraft? Even if they forget to take it off, shouldn't it be destroyed by the jets?
- jaywalk 5y agoNot a stupid question. The explanation doesn't make sense, for many reasons. A large one being the sheer number of people who would have to be blind to a red cover over the engine intake that they all know is not supposed to be there.
- yborg 5y agoThis article is literally repeating an article from The Sun, a tabloid with a better track record of reporting on royals caught on holiday with their knickers off. There are a lot of covers on ports and weapons on a combat aircraft sitting on the flight deck, the implication is that it was the inlet covers, which is impossible, the engine wouldn't have operated with those on and they are kind of obvious. It's much more likely this was a cover on something like a pitot tube or AoA sensor. It's also possible that something just blew off the deck and it had nothing at all to do with crash, The Sun is reporting on some hot tip from the shipboard rumor mill, not the Ministry of Defense.
- _moof 5y agoI thought it might be some other (non-engine) cover too, but the more I thought about it, the less likely that seemed. I seriously doubt a pilot would eject just because of a lack of airspeed indication, for example. The airplane is still flying, and if the pilot knows the airplane well they can still land it.
- toss1 5y agoIt's probably not too much of a conjecture to assume that these fit in front of the stator vanes and would be effectively supported by them, so would not come in contact with the the rotating turbine blades. Even if the turbine blades could create a vacuum, the maximum pressure it would have to hold is 14 pounds per square inch bridged between the vanes. I'd also guess that "cheap" is relative and they are using something between high-end commerical and engineering-grade plastic (still way cheap compared to the composites on the aircraft), and that this could withstand the pressures for at least the few seconds/minutes it took to fire it up and toss it in the drink. I'm more surprised that they didn't notice it in firing up the engines - don't they run it briefly to full throttle as part of their checks? Seems it would at least sound badly off-tune, but what do I know... Major fck-up all around...
- immmmmm 5y agoI understand now better why my country (Switzerland) wants to purchase 30-ish of those for "National Skies Protection". It is well in line with their past strategies and accomplishments: 1) Provide a sky patrol, but on only on office hours (9 - 17). 2) Buy for 1B CHF worth of radar, that would unfortunately lock on cows pasturing. 3) Buy for 0.5B CHF worth of software, then discard it because it's incompatible. 4) etc, etc, etc ....
- swarnie 5y agoCould you possibly adopt the Irish model and just get someone else to do it? Germany have a few working planes i think.
- dotancohen 5y ago> Germany have a few working planes i think. Oh, yes, history has proven that we want cats guarding the milk, ahem, Germans protecting other European nations from invasion. ))
- saiya-jin 5y agoWe are well past that mentality here. Germans basically keep EU going not only financially which I consider a win overall for Europe despite its drawbacks. Not another Versaille hanging over them to humiliate and keep the nation poor to piss off somebody down the line.
- swarnie 5y agoIt was intentionally tongue in cheek. I love the EU nations online =)
- dotancohen 5y agoYes, of course, I'm well aware that Germany of today is not the Germany of 1939. Otherwise I wouldn't have Bosch appliances at home. )) > Germans basically keep EU going not only financially This could be interpreted as meaning that Germany _has_ conquered all of Europe, finally!
- the-dude 5y agoNo thread is complete without : why don't they train a AI/ML/RNN network to screen jets before take off? I mean, it could probably be done within a weekend, tops.
- glitchc 5y agoUltimately it's the pilot's responsibility to do a visual inspection of the entire aircraft. Of particular importance are the propulsion components and the control surfaces. We can blame the ground crew for missing an item on the checklist, but the pilot should have caught it. Those covers are red for a reason, so that they're easy to spot and remove. Furthermore, the ladder to climb into the cockpit is right next to the intake, and if you see one, you have to check the other side. How was it possibly missed?
- sokoloff 5y agoI think this is not true in military aviation. I’ve heard it’s a sign of trust in the aircraft’s ground crew for a military aviator to walk out, strap in, and blast off, trusting that the ground crew has done their job thoroughly and correctly.
- _djo_ 5y agoI don’t know who practices that, but it’s not a very professional approach. The only time I’ve known that to happen has been for quick reaction alerts, when it’s considered an acceptable risk to save time. For normal operations the pilot doing their own check isn’t a lack of confidence in the ground crew, it’s the prudent, smart, and responsible thing to do when playing with people’s lives and very expensive aircraft. I’ve never known ground crew to get upset over it.
- pie42000 5y agoThis is the stupidest thing I've ever heard. It makes sense for something that you personally own and maintain yourself i.e. a Cesna. Do you expect Air Force 1 pilots to do walk around? Astronauts? Submarines? These are mostly war machines that have to be scrambled asap, meaning the pilot is expected to jump in and fly. To alter that during peacetime would be silly, as you want to establish habits.
- AdrianB1 5y agoAll pilots, no matter what aircraft they fly, do the pre-flight walk around. Too many people died by not doing it, so they do.
- LatteLazy 5y agoIf the source here is The Sun then we should really not take it at all seriously. The Sun are about as reliable as Reddit comments for factual accuracy.
- bellyfullofbac 5y agoThe article links to a Sun tabloid news article as a source, and the BBC article/a defense minister who said: > Mr Wallace added that operational and training flights onboard HMS Queen Elizabeth are continuing despite the incident. and presumed the root cause was well-known. Since they used the Sun, maybe take it with a grain silo of salt.
- f322323jiojio32 5y agoRussian submarines are probably already swimming around collecting parts of the plane.
- thih9 5y agoThis is reported by The Sun; I'd apply Betteridge's law [1] generously. The crash may have been caused by the rain cover, but just as well there might have been a different reason. > Sailors saw a red cover floating in the sea after the stealth jet splashed into the Mediterranean. It could have been anything, from a red herring to a literal red herring. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridge's_law_of_headlines
- tibbydudeza 5y agoNow we need a rain cover detection sensor.
- efitz 5y agoWe’ve had hardware interlocks forever to prevent this sort of problem.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- raldi 5y agoThis is only the first of the Five Why’s. I’m much more interested in numbers 3-5.
- walrus01 5y agoso I opened this article and did a ctrl-f for "pitot" or similar, didn't find any mention to a pitot tube or pitot-static sensor. somehow doubt that an entire engine air intake cover was left on... they're huge and the engine wouldn't have spun up correctly, or would have sucked it in.
- WalterBright 5y agoDidn't follow the checklist. Sigh.
- dd444fgdfg 5y agoso are they missing a cover from inventory?