12 ms·
Intermittent fasting prompts anti-inflammatory response
- oDot 5y agoFor a personal anecdote, IF was the most impactful change I did nutrition wise, and I am currently midway testing diets from carnivore to vegan.
- wpietri 5y agoCould you say more about your IF regimen? And what sort of impacts did you notice?
- drodil 5y agoI have done IF for almost 2 years now. Some personal experiences from my blog if interested: https://link.medium.com/ju1cOdlG9kb https://link.medium.com/ju1cOdlG9kb
- oDot 5y agoImproved skin, clearer mind, less fatigue. I was doing 14:10 after years of irregular eating, then settled on 16:8 which also improved the above. I tried 23:1 for a week but I could not eat enough in that one hour.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> I tried 23:1 for a week but I could not eat enough in that one hour. That gives me a stomach ache just thinking about it. 2000C in a sitting is a lot, even with relatively high calorie food choices.
- wpietri 5y agoThanks. One of the surprising experiments for me with IF is that hunger changes for me. After I'm used to it, I rarely experience hunger outside the eating hours even when I'm losing weight. When you did your 23:1, what was hunger like for you?
- oDot 5y agoI experienced the same when starting IF. With 23:1 I did get hungry a few hours after the meal, but the main issue wasn't that, it was not getting enough nutrients in that single meal. I suspect that if I combine 23:1 with carnivore it'll be much easier to do.
- wpietri 5y agoYeah, in my case I'm thinking of it for weight loss, so that could be a positive. Controlling eating hours for me is much easier than other things I've tried. I'll have to try 23:1 and see how it goes. Thanks for the details!
- scruple 5y agoHow long have you been on an IF style diet? I "ran" it for about 3 and a half years before moving on. I'm curious to know what long term success looks like for people on an IF diet. I did get my weight under control on IF but when it came time to bulk or cut, in accordance with my strength and conditioning training, it simply wasn't working.
- oDot 5y agoSince mid-2017. I agree it is not enough to gain muscle, but it also doesn't seem to hinder that for me.
- throwaway984393 5y agoThe cult of IF among tech nerds is one of those bizarre subcultures I'll never get used to. Here we are, modern human beings who live twice as long as their forebears, and yet a small fraction of them feel they need to regularly and intentionally starve themselves in order to be healthy. Humans are goddamn weird.
- redisman 5y agoYou could phrase most healthy behaviors as bizarre in todays world tbf. Look at these idiots spending an hour preparing green leaves and lean cuts of chicken when I, a intellectual just buy a box of Twinkies and get my calories in a fraction of the time and effort. I am obviously the superior Hunter gatherer
- rootusrootus 5y agoI don't know if it's limited to tech nerds, though, I find that pretty much everyone loves to give diet advice complete with mounds of anecdotes about how it improved their life in immeasurable ways, and IF is popular with them too. Hell, my 80 year old mother lectures me occasionally on how much skipping breakfast has improved her life. I do find it interesting that a group of people I would otherwise suspect of being more pro-science would be so enthusiastic about bro-science.
- BirdieNZ 5y agoThe real pro-tip here is that basically everything you read on HN for which you are not an expert has the appearance of expertise and authenticity. Once you see those same people speaking on a subject which you know a lot about, you realise that HN is only actually high-expertise on tech and entrepreneurship. The users here (myself included!) are probably quite good at programming, business, and maybe project management, which gives us false confidence in our abilities in every other field that exists.
- dvt 5y ago> a small fraction of them Fasting isn't really that weird at all, people have been doing it for literally thousands of years. Christians do it, Muslims do it, Jews do it, Buddhists do it, and so on. A small fraction? I do IF just because it makes me feel better and more healthy, but sometimes I fast for religious reasons.
- wpietri 5y agoOoh, interesting. This particular study is with full-day fasts 1-2 times per week. I see that insulin resistance improvement was also seen with eTRF (early time-restricted feeding, where one doesn't eat after, say, 2 pm). https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6627766/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6627766/
- sneak 5y agoIt was a very weird transition, as a well-off American, from going to never, ever actually feeling _real hunger_ at any point in any of my normal days (our workplaces, transit hubs, homes, lifestyles, and app landscape are all designed to deliver/provide high caloric density food, in extreme abundance, at all times and places, from snacks to full meals), to regularly/often being actually hungry for some/all of most days. It's done wonders for my well-being - anecdotally, of course. It turns out we don't actually need to never be hungry; our society just pushes us to assume that even the tiniest pang of hunger is a negative health issue that is to be instantly eradicated. It's actually fine as long as you're not skinny or otherwise malnourished. It's ok to fast, and to hear your body demanding sustenance and just say "no, maybe tomorrow" - doubly so if you're 10kg+ overweight like I have been (in my case, 20-40kg) my entire adult life.
- freediver 5y agoYou may be onto something here. I never thought about this effect of IF. The self-control aspect of overcoming hunger, or not just eating when you needn't to.
- scruple 5y agoThis self-control aspect also works in other diets, too, of course. It's why I prefer cheat days over cheat meals in my diet. I've found that keeping myself consistent with my eating, and make deliberate decisions, for 6 days straight leads to much better results than letting my diet slip occasionally through out the week and excusing it by convincing myself it's a "cheat meal."
- nicoburns 5y ago> It turns out we don't actually need to never be hungry; our society just pushes us to assume that even the tiniest pang of hunger is a negative health issue that is to be instantly eradicated. Huh, is that really something you feel like your society teaches you? In my upbringing (UK), snacking was very much discouraged (you won't eat your dinner) and although eating meals was encouraged, going without one was never seen as a health issue and would be seen as preferable to giving me other food if I didn't like what had been cooked for me.
- nailer 5y agoThere’s also a 500% spike in HGH after 48h according to Dr Ekberg
- DrammBA 5y agoCould you provide a source? I tried googling it but I'm getting a lot of obviously click bait and misleading articles/videos.
- johnyzee 5y agoIt is well established that fasting increases the level of growth hormone, quite significantly too. It's the leptin trigger. Just google effect of fasting on growth hormone. I think the OP is talking about Steen Ekberg the keto youtuber. His stuff is legit and well sourced, but unfortunately marketed to look like facebook meme videos.
- jasonhansel 5y agoThat...isn't what the study says, I think. In fact, it says that the level of hsCRP--a marker of inflammation--actually increased in the subjects who undertook intermittent fasting, though the difference from the control group (1.02 ± 2.73 vs. −0.25 ± 5.66) was far from statistically significant (p = 0.23, see Table 3). That's the only part of the study that even mentions inflammation.
- jasonhansel 5y agoAlso worth noting that the sample (as a whole) was 96% white, 91% non-Hispanic, and 33% male. Granted, the study was performed in SLC, but these numbers suggest that this is not even a particularly representative sample of SLC, much less of the nation as a whole.
- nabla9 5y agoCan somebody comment the effects size of improvements HOMA-IR (−0.75 ± 0.79 vs. −0.10 ± 1.06; P = 0.004) and MSS (−0.34 ± 4.72 vs. 0.31 ± 1.98, P = 0.006). Without knowing the normal range it's impossible to say how big change 0.75 (HOMA-IR) or -0.34 (MSS) are. The article says significant, but how much that is.
- ByThyGrace 5y agoAlso, this isn't IF as popularly understood. IF usually means uninterrupted water-only fast for a certain part of the day, e.g. 18:00-10:00. The paper is about "low frequency" IF, which in this case means a 24h water only fast, twice a week for a full month, then only once a week for the rest of the trial.
- phonypc 5y agoFWIW, this isn't atypical. IF in a scientific study pretty much always means some form of 24h+ fast. The more common practice of eating in a time window is usually "time-restricted eating/feeding."
- Dah00n 5y ago5 days of normal eating, 2 fasting, every 7 days. That is the definition of IF in all places I have seen it mentioned. Skipping a meal now and again isn't really fasting at all.
- hartator 5y agoDoes that mean a 24h fast but frequent is enough to trigger DNA repair mechanism? My understanding so far was you needed at least a 72h fast.
- anonuser123456 5y agoI haven't read enough on the subject, but Peter Attia has discussed this on a few podcasts. His general view is that no one knows; we simply don't have the biomarkers or lab tests to even run good experiments yet.
- dvt 5y ago> needed at least a 72h fast I think you're thinking of ketosis, which is ~72hrs. You can also verify entering ketosis by the smell & color of your urine. We're not 100% sure how ketosis relates to cellular autophagy.
- kilroy123 5y agoAutophagy? It's still unknown but many believe that happens around 48 - 72 hour mark.
- shoto_io 5y agoI am a big IF fan. Specifically, I try to do it 3-4x a week. I skip dinner and start at 5pm and hold it until 9am. I tried skipping breakfast before, that didn’t work well for me. Two things have been difficult for me lately: A) sudden extreme cravings before I start at 5pm B) a sore throat starting at around 9-10pm. I have no clue why it happens. Do you guys experience something similar and how do you deal with it? EDIT: Sorry for the confusion. I meant heartburn.
- nuclearnice1 5y agoI have moderate success solving A) by drinking a glass of water. Also ignore it and it will go away helps.
- nemacol 5y ago>ignore it and it will go away helps. When I was young I would hurt myself somehow and go to my mother saying Me - My arm hurts when I do THIS (bend arm at elbow, back and forth) Mom- Don't do that and it won't hurt. Me - (Pikachu meme face)
- vegai_ 5y agoI fast about once a week or once every two weeks. >A) sudden extreme cravings before I start at 5pm Have you tried apple cider vinegar? That seems to work for me. >B) a sore throat starting at around 9-10pm. I have no clue why it happens. I don't get that specifically, but I do get lowered body temperature. Could sore throat be a symptom of that? Have you tried hot water, perhaps with lemon and/or tea?
- dqv 5y ago>Have you tried apple cider vinegar? That seems to work for me. No comment on effectiveness, but for anyone who is going to do this, make sure to dilute the vinegar with some water.
- primaryobjects 5y ago
- phonypc 5y agoOdd title. Study doesn't mention any anti-inflammatory response. The change in hsCRP in Table 3 actually seems to show a (non-significant) pro-inflammatory measure.
- programmarchy 5y agoI came here to say the same thing. The improvements are to insulin resistance and metabolism. Are those factors well-known to be related to inflammation?
- Swizec 5y agoI’ve long considered my Sunday runs (26km usually) as a form of sped up intermittent fasting. There’s something fascinating about burning a day’s worth of calories in 2 hours. Took a few years of practice to get my metabolism to the point where it can burn ~2000 calories in 2 hours and munge through enough food to feel fully operational the same day. I wonder if the overall effects are similar to intermittent fasting. Anecdotally I’ve noticed that training for long distance running has made me a lot less sensitive to energy-from-food fluctuations. If you can run for 2+ hours while eating 100cal of running gels, what’s a little missed lunch while sitting at a desk?
- DerekBickerton 5y agoI'm a big fan of Intermittent Feasting. Joking aside, I've tried intermittent fasting and had more balance / homeostasis as a result. They say `the first element of discipline starts with your diet`. Control diet, and you control many other things.
- pmarreck 5y agoSo does nutritional ketosis... which is probably why this result was found... because when you fast, you go into slight keto if you don't like CR or fasting (or being hungry), consider keto as an alternative, just realize that you'll have to do your homework I've definitely seen the same anti-inflammatory results that this has. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1IEuhp8RFMU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1IEuhp8RFMU
- encoderer 5y agoI’ve been doing IF with some interruptions for about 10 years. It’s absolutely changed my life because before that I was steadily gaining about 5-20lbs per year and it had really added up over my 20s. Now I’m 39 in the best shape of my life. So I’m invested in this technique, but I really believe the primary and possibly exclusive benefit is simply calorie restriction. In a typical “diet” you attempt to restrict calories by remove foods from your diet. The problem is, cravings are real, abstinence doesn’t work, and there are always new foods and new temptations. On an IF regimen, you restrict calories by removing eating hours from your day. You don’t have to abstain from anything. Temptation is managed by just having a little patience until your next meal. Possibly there is a deeper truth to why this lifestyle works but I personally like the simplicity of it. It’s like a rate limiter, for daily food intake.
- jimmaswell 5y ago> cravings are real, abstinence doesn’t work, and there are always new foods and new temptations If IF worked for you that's great, but you shouldn't imply every other diet doesn't work. In my case all I did was track calories of everything I ate (Lose It app, highly recommended) while maintaining a normal eating schedule. Down 105lbs so far. For me I feel like if I just ate whatever I wanted in specific timeframes it'd still be too easy to eat 3000-4000 calories.
- claaams 5y agoI was like that too but eventually after doing one meal a day Ive been feeling full on anywhere from 1200-2200 calories. Really depends on the food where I'm at and what's around. But you're absolutely right, there's not one BEST method for everyone. I personally cannot stand the minutiae of calorie counting and measuring portions so it's not good for me. I will measure portions to learn to eyeball things but yeah, can't do it every time I put food on a plate.
- jimmaswell 5y agoFor me it feels uncomfortable eating something I can't track accurately, like it's going to actually have 5 times the calories I think it would, since that's the story for so much food. Like once I was hungry after a dinner and there was stuffing left, so I had some assuming it was a lighter food, then I looked it up and it's actually extremely calorie dense.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoI accidentally did intermittent fasting as a teenager for years. I just didn't have breakfast, had lunch and dinner and oddly enough it matched the requirements to be considered IF. One day I got interested in IF, looked up the rules and found out I was already on it. I can't say whether it did anything but it definitely made it hard to consume enough calories, so despite training a lot and despite eating a lot at lunch and dinner, I've always been skinny. I assume IF could be a good choice for someone who's overweight and barely training or not training at all. I was training bodyweight and gymnastic at the time, making significant progress in terms of strength - despite that, I saw very little muscle building. I suppose being that lean lowered my testosterone production resulting in little gains. I had the brilliant idea of even trying going vegetarian, vegan for a while, shifting to a source of proteins which is not as complete and not as well absorbed as proteins coming from animal sources. After 20 years of reading on the subject and looking at what studies are saying nowadays, if I could go back through my teenage years I would eat close to paleo, 6 times per day and lift weights.
- LightG 5y agoColitis - I haven't read the article but will soon. But here is a data point for anyone with Colitis, if it helps. I started IF in July as a means to lose a bit of lockdown weight. No breakfast, no lunch, only a substantial dinner. 4-5 Drinks taken throughout the day. No real restriction. Lots of walking to keep busy. I've noticed a significant improvement in management of Colitis. No flares. Enabling me to get back to normal life without worrying about the condition throughout the day. Just (sorry TMI), emptying bowels first thing in the morning (2-3) times. Then don't have to worry all day. Considering colitis is a primarily inflammatory response (I believe), then this article rings true. YMMV Once I reach target weight, not sure what I'll do. Maybe just add some more protein or good fats to evening meal. It's been too helpful to give up the routine.
- boplicity 5y agoWhat does your diet look like otherwise? I have Crohn's, and mostly manage it through diet, and am always curious what other people are doing for their IBD.
- LightG 5y agoNon restrictive. I definitely enjoy all manner of food, sometimes even fast food. Though I'm 95% vegetarian and very occasionaly eat fish, which I love. Have to admit, I'm quite carb-dominant at the moment, potato, bread, pasta, but I do consciously try to balance that stuff out. Sadly and strangely, any time I've made a concerted effort to really eat a model, healthy diet, I react badly after a few weeks. So, as with everything, I guess, all things in moderation has generally been the key for me lately. Along with IF. How about yourself? I'm similarly curious.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoThe study seems to say the opposite of the title. A marker for inflammation (hsCRP) increased. Weight and waist circumference decreased. Risk of diabetes (HOMA-IR) decreased. Risk of cardiovascular issues (MSS) decreased. Nothing extraordinary, I think the caloric deficit reduced the weight and weight loss brought down risk of diabetes and cardiovascular issues. I don't think it says much about IF.
- spfzero 5y agoI've been doing time-restricted eating for maybe 5 years, only eating between 12 and 7-ish. It's not what this experiment studied but is supposed to have similar effects. One thing I can say is you get used to it quickly and no longer feel hunger in the same urgent way as before. Hunger is more of a vague "yeah, I could eat now" feeling in the back of the mind, which can be easily ignored for several hours. Mood never changes, either. On the few occasions I've gone 24 hours+, the hunger feeling is a little stronger, but still pretty easy to ignore. For one example, there is no difficulty going to sleep. None of this applies when you are first starting out though :-)
- gnarcoregrizz 5y agoIt seemed to have helped my epilepsy. It’s mentioned in the bible as a treatment for the disease, and diet based treatments are experiencing a resurgence in use. Keto is sometimes prescribed in kids with difficult cases, and low GI (the south beach diet) is similarly being prescribed to adults since keto is too difficult for most. I haven’t heard of IF being prescribed but my doctor said it may be effective when I brought it up. I did low carb/cal AM (1 egg) and didn’t eat til 3 PM. I did this most days of the week. There are other confounding variables so don’t take it as medical advice, since the diet can also exacerbate seizures.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoCould you give that Bible reference please, thanks.
- gnarcoregrizz 5y agoMark 9:14-29, depending on the translation. The translation of biblical fasting is suspected to be one meal a day type thing, like Ramadan. More about the history of fasting and epilepsy here (which also cites the Bible verse, god forbid): https://www.medlink.com/articles/ketogenic-diet-in-the-treatment-of-epilepsy https://www.medlink.com/articles/ketogenic-diet-in-the-treat... Of course I’m being downvoted because I mentioned a religious text. It’s in other secular ancient texts as well. My point was more about how fasting and the ketogenic diet has been recognized as a treatment for mental diseases for a long time. As it relates to the title, a lot of them are suspected to have roots in inflammation and metabolism.
- tharkun__ 5y agoFWIW, I just saw the downvote and I totally did not understand why you were downvoted. You're just spot on w/ keto and epilepsy and I nowadays find religious fasting quite interesting. In fact I find religion more and more fascinating the older I get. Not in the sense of actually believing in a super human creator being but in the wisdom distilled into these texts. Unfortunately I don't remember the name but very recently I heard a (Christian in this case) scholar on the radio talk about the bible and religion in general that really resonated. He wasn't reading the bible and other ancient texts quite literally like so many of us do. He saw them as regular people describing the world they saw and distilling the wisdom they gained and wanted to preserve in the pictures of their time. His interpretations just made sense to me and I says that as a totally non-religious person. And that's because they weren't dogmatic and "religious" or prescriptive, like so many a preacher is the Sunday before an election, telling everyone who to vote for. As mentioned before (both here in another comment and other posts on HN), I find the population control aspect of religion very fascinating. In the currently active world religions this will probably not be seen kindly and more like heresy. But just the fact that many of the major religions will see each other that way too is fascinating. Or even slight variations of the same major religion for that matter. Usually it's much easier to talk to people about this for long lost/dead religions and it's fascinating how they see those aspects in those religions, but not their own.
- victorvosk 5y agoThis study seems a little weird (crap) in that they started with a hardcore twice a week fast for a month then dialed it back to once a week. Unless I missed it, I don't see an explanation of why this approach was taken in the paper. Given the subjects were high cholesterol and/or diabetic, it makes me think their life styles sucked already. I couldn't imagine living like then suddenly being told to stop eating for entire days. I would not be shocked if people didn't really adhere to the guidelines. It seems a food diary was the only thing keeping them "honest". Also a staggering 40% of all participants refused to answer how much alcohol they consumed on average. If you are going crazy with food or lack of exercise for 6 out of 7 days, I don't think taking a break for one day a week is going to make much of a difference.
- skerit 5y agoThe worst thing I ever did was start eating breakfast. Turns out I was doing IF for over 20 years, because only after I started eating (even a healthy) breakfast did I start to gain weight.
- koonsolo 5y agoYeah, they never should have started the "breakfast is the most important meal" when there was no evidence to back this up. For me also breakfast doesn't come natural to me, unless my kids bake croissants in the morning ;).
- CodeGlitch 5y agoI think this starts in childhood. My daughter always wakes up starving, so she usually eats a big bowl of porridge. I think we all do this, and out of habit continue this into adulthood.
- koonsolo 5y agoWhen I was a kid, I never ate breakfast. It was too much on my stomach. I only started with it when I was around 10 or 11.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI accidentally started IF after being annoyed at my lack of mental alertness after lunch and breakfast. I found that one coffee for breakfast, lots of water/herbal tea throughout the day, and then eating a huge dinner and whatever I want between 5-9 works for me. It seems I can consume over 2k calories in those 4 hours.
- godDLL 5y agoIt's very important to know when you're heading for bed, if that's the case. My own time window is 2-5, but I turn in at 9.
- 1024core 5y agoFor those who are upbeat about IF: some simple questions: 1. Does coffee/tea count as a "meal"? I can't get through the day without a couple of cups of coffee and tea. 2. This study mentioned a 24-hour water-only fast, not the IF that most commenters are talking about in this post. Thoughts on that? 3. I've been thinking of going on the "Phil Mickelson" diet: https://golf.com/instruction/fitness/phil-mickelson-age-defying-fasting-diet-explained/ https://golf.com/instruction/fitness/phil-mickelson-age-defy... Any thoughts on that?
- tomp 5y ago1. no. a "meal" could be sugar or cream in the coffee though. zero-calorie drinks don't count as a meal some people "cheat" by considering cream-only coffee acceptable as well (it's keto/zero-carb so might not raise blood sugar levels) - see e.g. "bulletproof coffee" by Dave Asprey (NOT ENDORSING ANYTHING ELSE BY THIS SCAM ARTIST)
- kilroy123 5y agoI regularly do IF and I drink black coffee in the morning while I'm fasting. I try to time it so even that is at the tail-end of an 18 hours fast.
- theodorewiles 5y agoI SLAMMED coffee the first few weeks and would also drink like a gallon of water a day. Helped a lot. I think the key is to choose the schedule that works for you.
- boplicity 5y agoIf you want to have an "anti-inflammatory" response, then try to maximize your fiber intake from a wide variety of plants. This will increase the quality of your microbiome -- which in turn, will produce substances that are anti-inflammatory.
- johnyzee 5y ago"All disease begins in the gut" -- Hippocrates It seems we just keep discovering more effects of the microbiome on health. I heard about this anti-inflammation effect just yesterday. I think it was explained as gram negative bacteria overgrowth in the gut (due to a bad bacterial balance). Those bacteria have a hard 'shell' that triggers a potent immune response (with inflammation) when present in the blood stream, which they enter from the small intestine. So I think your advice to maximize fiber intake is sound. This feeds gut bacteria (unlike most other food which is broken down before reaching the small intestine). Another intervention would be fermented foods.
- consumer451 5y agoJumping in to share my anti-inflammatory story. I used to have a limp for the first 2-3 hours of the day due to very early onset arthritis at 30 in my ankle. Around 38 I discovered that minimizing by nightshade intake nearly "cured" me of the problem. What a huge change in quality of life. I still eat some potato, tomato, and eggplant - but I never make or order nightshades on purpose.
- crazybLanKeT 5y agoIF is great. IF + low(ish) carb is even better. IF + low(ish) carb + eating calorie amounts matching your healthy weight is amazing. There is more than one way to lose weight just like there is for gaining weight. Minimize as many of the offending behaviors as possible. Consistency is key. Don't pick something you cannot consistently repeat unless that limited time run is all you're after. Of the different IF schedules people pick -OMAD, 20:4, 16:8, 5:2, etc-, start with anything that you can do initially without getting frustrated and giving up. You will be able to increase the fasting window over time. It just really works. Don't get discouraged by words from people that tried and failed (or gave up too quickly), or not even tried but talk out of prejudice. Listen to the encouragement from so many that successfully do it. Best of luck!!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rewgs 5y agoWondering if anyone is in a situation similar to mine (probably not but it's worth a try): Earlier this year I developed about 30 food allergies (IgE-mediated; I'm using the term "allergy" accurately, not in the fuzzy way we colloquially use it to refer to intolerances, etc, which are entirely different, mechanism- and prognosis-wise). This has absolutely decimated my ability to eat out at restaurants (I literally can't eat anything I don't prepare myself). Logistically it just sucks. It'll be evening after work and someone on the other side of town says "come hang out." I'd love to, but I'll have to drive home one direction, eat, then drive twice as far the other direction. With traffic it'll be 9pm before I can leave, so...yeah, not happening. It's destroyed my social life. My allergies have also affected things that are "quick" or "travel" foods, so basically I always need to heat stuff up. God it sucks. Naturally, I've arrived at the thought of training myself to "officially" work IF into my life. Unofficially, I do it all the time by way of just...having to go somewhere unexpectedly or staying somewhere longer than I thought, and I don't have any food. About 50% of the time I feel fine and can power through, the other 50% I feel faint and hangry. Can't figure out why. The other side of this coin, though, is that I'm trying to build muscle mass. Nuff said. Anyone find a way to satisfy all these competing interests successfully?
- godDLL 5y agoI got repeated food poisoning x4 around January last year, and since can't do sugar at all, carbs very little, coffee once a week (if that). Also can't do any oil but olive oil. Butter I can. Kinda similar to your situation. I have to prep my own meals, always (it's OK, I'm a very well versed cook, and enjoy everything about that). I sourdough my own bread and portion to two slices a day max. I do a lot of soups and salads (that's new). And I have a keto week, once a month. That starts with 3-4 days of basically water fast, where I am allowed a cup of soup after sunset, but that's all. Also no smoking or coffee these three days. I do a lot of stretching, but little exercise at that time. It helps to have something to do when a craving comes, so I just go stretch or do hot-cold-mild shower, Wim Hoff style. You feel amazing at the end of day two. Just gotta hold out. And it continues to the rest of that week where I eat in a window between 14:00 and 17:00, limiting carbs to 20g, protein to 180g and having lots of fat with it. I try to have my protein first, as well, so that the two meals are a salad with olive oil dressing and three eggs in butter for the other one, or whatever. That's where I do exercise. Short, violent bursts, short rests, stretches. Feels great, helps with the keto, and redistributes body mass towards eh, fighter-style body, I'd say? The windowing of eating stays, but the amount restrictions go for the remaining three weeks. Before I added that keto week it was a struggle, as you describe. But now it is not. There might be many reasons for that, but maybe you should try something similar and find out how it maps onto yourself. Cheers.
- GDC7 5y agoFerritin is a marker of inflammation of the liver and anecdotally it rises when fasting.
- kaminar 5y agoIntermittent fasting is NOT waiting 8 or 16 hrs to eat. IF requires minimum 48 hrs of fasting. 1 meal per day is not fasting, it's eating. For IF to work, your body must focus on something other than digestion. For most of us, digestion in one form or another occurs 24 hrs per day...it's constant. Once the body competes all digestion, it can focus on healing and building. Don't take my word for it. Dry fasting is also great. IF creates insane amounts of free time...so much you'll be hard pressed to fill it.