12 ms·
You can no longer bypass microsoft-edge:// links using apps like EdgeDeflector
- d2wa 5y agoThe Register asked the US Justice Department to comment on this. https://www.theregister.com/2021/11/11/latest_windows_11_build_enforces_edge_links/ https://www.theregister.com/2021/11/11/latest_windows_11_bui...
- throwawaymanbot 5y agoits 2021, and Micro$oft still has not changed its ways. And we are letting them interact deeply with the Linux Kernel???? lol...
- coliveira 5y agoI'm always amazed at people who believed that MS would change its ways. It is in the DNA of MS to make everything proprietary and controlled by them. In the last few years they have just prepared the way for MS 2.0: make every company of the world slave of their closed cloud products. It is already happening.
- npteljes 5y agoPR as an industry is getting better and better.
- outside1234 5y agoNext up: Should only allow competitors to use the Edge variant of the Chromium engine to keep users secure.
- adoxyz 5y agoIf Apple can do it and get away with it, why not MS or Google?
- indymike 5y agoSafari much?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoDoes macOS open some links in Safari even if you have the default browser set to something else?
- indymike 5y agoios forces use of Safari flavor webkit on all devices.
- angulardragon03 5y agoThe answer here is no, it doesn’t.
- spacemanmatt 5y agoSecond verse, same as the first. (Eat it, Nadella-fans -- this is what critics said he would do)
- n8cpdx 5y agoWhen I see stories like this, I think about what it must be like to be an engineer on the windows team. You get in, make your coffee in a fancy Microsoft-branded cup, and then a PM gives you the “actively shit on our customers” ticket. Presumably the engineers on the windows team are either in golden handcuffs, or actually derive sadistic pleasure from making the world worse for users, and making the field of software engineering less trustworthy. Are there other fields so thoroughly invested in making the world a worse place to be a consumer? Why is big tech so obsessed with torching their long-term reputation in exchange for a few usage share points in the short term? How do engineers sleep at night, knowing their role is to be a malignant, user-hostile, value-destroying force in the world?
- SahAssar 5y agoTo me it seems like many industries dominated by multinational companies are clearly not acting in the best interest of their customers. Tobacco, Pharma, Food, Electronics, Fashion to name a few. I'd be interested to know if you assume the opposite, that companies in general act in the interest of their customers?
- chrinic4948 5y ago> How do engineers sleep at night, knowing their role is to be a malignant, user-hostile, value-destroying force in the world? They sleep on their USD $200K/year bed (if college grad). Or if experienced with 5 years of experience, then their $400K/year bed.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zeusk 5y agoIt's the PMs from Google
- pinewurst 5y agoIt's the PM culture that everyone has adopted from Google for sure. Along with their grotesque hiring methodology and inordinate respect for the likes of Kubernetes. Clever mediocrity is not the same as genius.
- curiousmindz 5y agoNote that this issue is specifically about microsoft-edge:// links (used in some internal Windows features). Not http/https. I do wish they used a more generic/portable solution, but this is for Windows-specific features, so it would require them to think through an open, stable & forever-supported API...
- dang 5y agoI've adjusted the title to include this information. Thanks!
- hmrr 5y agoYes and no. I suspect the main feature this is used for is the start menu search feature to push traffic to bing. This appears to be unavoidable and really pisses me off on a regular basis. I can’t think of another reason in the windows UI to disable this. I’m sure there are some but at no point should those should require Edge. It’s a web page dammit! This is basically devolving into the 90s again.
- solarkraft 5y agoIf only there was a more generic/portable solution for opening links ...
- selfhoster11 5y agoWe could even call them "protocol handlers", or something.
- chessmango 5y agoDon't think it'll catch on
- dmitrygr 5y ago> stable & forever-supported API You mean like RFC1738?
- JTon 5y ago
- achn 5y agoWindows has become truly user hostile, I went back to it several years ago, but have now moved away from it again (wherever possible).
- spacemanmatt 5y ago> become Don't forget their sabotage of DR-DOS before Windows even came onto the scene. They're old hands at playing dirty.
- hmrr 5y agoIt bugs me that this is clearly intentional. The people who thought this up, implemented it, QA’ed it and approved as well as their entire hierarchy up to Nadella are complicit with monopolistic practices again. Why am I not surprised. Emperor only got new clothes.
- 0xcde4c3db 5y agoIt's not an isolated incident, either; they're playing a very similar game with Bing integration. Removing Bing results from the start menu search went from a supported UI toggle to a straightforward registry hack to a registry hack that also messes with local search.
- matrixcubed 5y agoFool me once … I forget how the rest of that goes.
- djbusby 5y agoWon't get fooled again!! Eeeeaaaaahhhh! Then Pete,John and Keith with the monster sound. Also, that song mentions "meet the new boss, same as the old boss" which is apt for this post.
- anm89 5y agoWhy does anyone still interact with Microsoft? No other company is as openly hostile towards its users, at least Google, and Apple and the likes have the decency to pretend they care. But the confusing part with Microsoft is that there are a multitude of alternatives. There isn't nearly as much lock in as with some of the other companies. It seems like enterprise is what keeps them alive and let's them get away with all of this stuff but it's not clear to me why big enterprise feels so locked in on Microsoft in 2021.
- selfhoster11 5y agoEnterprise to enterprise is much easier when they go through a Microsoft intermediary. SSO goes through Microsoft, calendar invitations go through Microsoft, office document interop goes through Microsoft, document sharing goes through Microsoft (via SharePoint).
- coliveira 5y agoMy opinion is that MS is again doing backroom deals with large companies, like they used to do in the 90s. Its the only explanation why companies are not treating MS products as toxic malware, which is what they actually are.
- anm89 5y agoYeah "enterprise sales".
- djbusby 5y agoSupport contract and backwards compatibility. And also pretending those things don't exist on Linux.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y ago> And also pretending those things don't exist on Linux. As in, this kind of misbehavior existing on Linux distros? I'm not aware of any FOSS operating system trying to force one browser over another except for Chrom/ium OS (which isn't what most people mean when they say "Linux")
- djbusby 5y agoWow! Windows is using internal links with the scheme microsoft-edge:// to make things (Windows things) open Edge so that then Edge can nag you to set the default. It's sad, it's user-hostile and smells of desperation. In other news, in the pandemic my parents (+70yr) switched to Xfce on Gentoo when their Win7s died. And are actually getting on quite well (they are pretty good with computers, we've had them at home since before Win3.1)
- jcun4128 5y agoAt least edge is using chromium instead of IE being the default
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoWould you believe that I would have preferred them pushing trident? For two, somewhat contradictory, reasons: 1. it'd help against the blink monoculture, and 2. if it was actually awful it'd make it easier for people to scream at MS about the issue.
- jcun4128 5y agoYeah my comment is about responsive development which thankfully I don't do much of anymore/try not to. I am not familiar with this will have to look it up: > blink monoculture Oh Google rendering engine hmm
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoRight; most browsers today (Edge, Brave, Vivaldi, not Firefox) are just reusing Chrome's rendering engine. This is concerning for reasons that amount to "an adtech giant now de-facto controls the web".
- SahAssar 5y ago> Oh Google rendering engine hmm It would have been the same if it was gecko, webkit, netsurf or anything else being as dominant as blink has become. The operative word is "monoculture", not which engine it is. The web needs independent implementations to continue being about protocols and standards, not programs or libraries.
- FridayoLeary 5y agoWhat is their thinking here? Lets annoy users by opening up a worse version of Chrome at every opportunity. They must be deluded to think that even non tech savvy victims won't notice that the navigation is different. MS is making a fatal error of not realising that the job of an OS is to do whatever the user wants and then getting out of the way as fast as possible. A desktop OS is not a "lifestyle platform", or whatever it is MS calls it, it's a tool, like a screwdriver.
- anm89 5y agoIt would be so awesome if they did this but instead of edge it forced you to open everything in IE7. Just to rub in how much they hate you.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoMany Windows Server 2022 tools still open their reports in IE.
- yepthatsreality 5y agoI’m not surprised Microsoft is pushing their platform in this direction. Apple has done this fairly effectively for years and people claim it as a security perk. The next step will probably be to only allow Edge-based browsers on the platform.
- the_snooze 5y agoI've written this before, but I think it's worth saying again: lots of consumer tech treat their users like abusive partners treat their victims. "I want to know everything about you and who you talk to." "You can't leave me." "I'll do what I want when I want to you."
- kenty 5y agoMicrosoft even removed the default web browser setting from Windows 11. Instead of a single setting for the default web browser, customers must set individual “link associations” for the http:// http:// and https:// https:// protocols; as well as file associations for the .html file type. This is just horrible. They are so desperate to get back market share that they resort to "purposely bad ux in new versions" tactics. What is their goal? Get more users on Bing? Get more tracking data via Edge?
- briffle 5y agoYou know the problem. Some VP somewhere has his bonus and review structured around the growth of Edge. Like a dark pattern, but for employees, not customers.
- sofixa 5y ago> What is their goal Beat their record fine from the EU? None of the others seems like a plausible result.
- jsiepkes 5y ago> Beat their record fine from the EU? None of the others seems like a plausible result. The reason they dare to try is because they know they might even get away with it. I'm definitly not condoning it but the situation is very different from when they got fined. At the time Microsoft was fined smartphones weren't a thing. One might argue that this competes with Microsoft desktops marketshare. Also in notebook sales Chromebooks have on average (roughly) about a 20% market share [1]. On top of that Microsofts browser market share was 90+ % at the time of the fine, now it's almost non existant. If it were up to me they would be fined into oblivion for this anti-competitive behavior but I think they might actually get away with it. [1] https://www.androidpolice.com/2021/07/30/theres-no-stopping-chromebooks-from-dominating-the-world/ https://www.androidpolice.com/2021/07/30/theres-no-stopping-...
- sofixa 5y agoI don't know, Apple are being investigated for anticompetitive behaviour in the App Store[1], while iOS market share is below 30% across Europe ( I can't find the numbers for the EU only), and no in no EU country is iOS at more than 35% [2]. (In both cases, market share in smartphones, not general computing devices). You don't need to be a (quasi) monopolist to be anticompetitive, and I'm glad regulators know this. 1 - https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/es/ip_20_1073 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/es/ip_20_... 2 - https://www.statista.com/statistics/639928/market-share-mobile-operating-systems-eu/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/639928/market-share-mobi...
- tonmoy 5y agoThe title is super misleading. It don’t not block other browsers from opening links, it prevents “microsoft-edge://“ links from being intercepted. While still hostile towards users, it is not as bad as the click baity title suggests!
- Mikeb85 5y agoAnd this is why I don't use anything MS (nor Apple, but that's a different story). Even with some of their apparent open-source friendliness, they're still the same MS of old.
- jimbob45 5y agohttps://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/apple-safari-getting-mobile-browser-extensions-before-chrome-and-thats-a-big-deal/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/apple-safari-getting-mobile... Most likely, someone found a legitimate Windows 11 bug that will be patched out within a month. Meanwhile, Apple premeditated releasing extensions for their own mobile browser while blocking FF/Chrome from doing the same until some point in the future. I know it's fun to hate on MS but Apple is far and away the worse offender here.
- dnebdal 5y agoNah, I've looked at it alongside the author. It feels like extra work done for that single protocol (but none of their other weird ones) to handle it in a new and nonstandard way. It would take a very weird bug to make the "select program for protocol" dialog ignore all entries except all versions of Edge; an even weirder coincidence to also ignore the relevant registry setting in favor of Edge when clicking links, and yet more so when when it only affects that protocol but not the other weird ms-specific ones. Combined with how there was just a small burst of publicity over Firefox and Brave now also support capturing microsoft-edge: links, it feels like the "random bug" explanation is not the more likely one.
- pinewurst 5y agoWhy can't one overwrite the Edge binary with what's effectively a small proxy that does nothing but pass links to a preconfigured browser or browsers?
- reincarnate0x14 5y agoMS has had "software protection" systems, probably three different schemes by now, that check for this. It's more to prevent malware but also means it's incredibly difficult to patch out MS-approved malware without running afoul of the system integrity checks. On of the appeals of the LTSC branch is that it doesn't have a lot of user-hostile feature kits in it to begin with, so you're not constantly fighting to keep them turned off.
- MarcellusDrum 5y agoPeople will come with ways to bypass it for sure, but Microsoft is hoping to make it as hard as possible, so that the average user doesn't bother to switch. And unless the government intervenes, it will work.
- d2wa 5y agoYou can do that. But programs like EdgeDeflector can’t be distributed doing changes like that. Every antivirus vendor including Microsoft SmartScreen will rightly block it for doing destructive changes.
- aksss 5y agoAt least they aren't submitting it to Bing via MS Edge instead of a direct url. <Instantly regrets saying this >
- jszymborski 5y agoWhen I heard Windows was transitioning to rolling release, I was a little bummed about the "every other version is bad" advice becoming moot. Luckily, Win11 is here. Maybe it's time to make a T-shirt?
- BizarroLand 5y agoXP was the best. Vista was good but wasn't optimized for the average hardware of the time. 7 was pretty darn good all around. 8 was bad. 8.1 was better than 8 but still worse than 7. 10 was better than 8.1 and almost as good as 7 until they started tightening the thumb screws on all of the telemetry and forced redirects to edge and bing, then they started blasting you with ads and foisting new services on you left and right and taking control of your taskbar layout against your will, nagging you to stay with the setup that serves their desires and not your desires. Now 11 makes it twice as difficult to get your personal baseline setup, actively fights against user alterations, and disables crowd-sourced workarounds. I'm guessing that Windows 12 will come with a drone that will taze you every time you open firefox and Windows 13 will require you to stare lovingly into the eyes of a bust of Bill Gates to activate the login prompt.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- paulryanrogers 5y agoJokes on them. I'm building a extension to auto route links out of the usual browser info my preferred browser (per site or all). Seriously though this seems to violate the public trust given their dominant position. And moves like this make me more likely to go back to desktop Linux.
- xnx 5y agoIs there a new workaround? Can I replace "C:\Program Files (x86)\Microsoft\Edge\Application\msedge.exe" with a small redirect utility?
- d2wa 5y agoYou can rename EdgeDeflector.exe to msedge.exe and it works as-is. However, it will cause other problems with your system. The Edge background update system will also reverse the change within a day or so.
- pwinwood 5y agoPerhaps use "Image File Execution Options" on Microsoft Edge. Edge will never see the 'microsoft-edge://' links? https://wikileaks.org/ciav7p1/cms/page_2621770.html https://wikileaks.org/ciav7p1/cms/page_2621770.html
- d2wa 5y agoIt’s not Edge that makes the decision on what program to use. It’s the Windows shell itself. I’m not aware of any third-party alternatives to OpenWith.exe.