17 ms·
Dealing with the Evasive Witness
- dave333 5y agoThere should be another article for the prospective witness: Dealing With The Snarky Lawyer
- hashimotonomora 5y agoEvasive witness or very effective tactic during cross, depending on who you are.
- giantg2 5y ago"Unfortunately, the probability exists that a witness may answer these questions with something other than an unqualified “yes”. The hedging, evasive answer avoids the truth ..." Hmm, avoids the truth, or avoids the answer you wanted? "The witness who “doesn’t remember” or “isn’t sure” about dates, times, distances, or amounts." Witnesses are notoriously unreliable. It's possible these are valid, truthful answers.
- whatshisface 5y agoThis is written for a lawyer who's on a side, not a curious investigator that's trying to maximize their own knowledge of the truth.
- giantg2 5y agoExactly. The lawyer/author is presenting themselves in the light of seeking the truth. Maybe they actually believe it themself, but it's not a unbiased view. "... a curious investigator that's trying to maximize their own knowledge of the truth." Do we actually have anything like this in the 'justice' system? Lawyers are on sides. Police only investigate to prove guilt, not innocence (most of the time). Judges are basically referees. Juries don't get to investigate, only view what the court allows them to (and society in general has a bias against defendants). In my experience, nobody is interested in the truth.
- vladf 5y agoHow would such a thing like this exist in practice? Who would watch this watchman? When your goal is to "discover truth" as Chief Truth Discoverer of the DOJ the only way to audit you is with grander truth discoery.
- giantg2 5y agoI agree, if we are only talking about some official position/office. You could use things like transparency and metrics released to the public. Right now complaints against the judiciary and many other positions in the system are considered so secret that they wont even release them if the contain exculpatory evidence. The reasoning is that the secrecy is necessary to preserve public trust of the system, and the system itself is more important than any individual's rights or justice. We could evaluate the complaints, wrongful convictions, etc to create better procedures and policies to find the truth.
- elicash 5y agoI kinda wonder the opposite -- is this "adversarial" approach towards finding the truth, where you've got people assigned to make the best case for different arguments regardless of your personal feelings about it, underutilized in other arenas?
- giantg2 5y agoIt depends. Maybe I misunderstood you, but you seem to be implying that I am against the adversarial system. I am not. The adversarial system is supposed to produce the truth in a fair fight. In my opinion, the system does not allow for a fair fight. Usually the party with the most money can win. There is a lot bias that exists as well. The people in the system continue to grant themselves more privileges that those not part of the system. The system even situates itself to where it costs more to defend ones innocence than to just plead and pay a fine. One cannot say that our system provides truth or justice when it allows this to occur.
- elicash 5y ago
- jedimastert 5y agoRemember that this is geared towards representatives of a corporation, not persons representing themselves. These kinds of answers are almost certainly in a record somewhere.
- ghaff 5y agoA record someplace maybe. A record that I have? Often not. Ask me when I first discussed $TOPIC with someone or when I was briefed about $TOPIC or when I talked to a reporter about $TOPIC, I may have a date-stamped note, scrawl in my paper calendar, or an entry in an electronic calendar (assuming I'm still with the same company). But I may also have a vague recollection which no amount of prodding is going to crystallize or just no memory at all.
- giantg2 5y agoI don't see how this changes much. It's very possible they don't have those details recorded, or if they do they still don't remember them. Then they are just reading off of the notes. The credibly that is often given to notes is alarming. Sure, dated notes in combination with memory is good. But if there is no memory to go with them and no validation process, then it's possible there was a mistake in the notes, yet they treat them as truth.
- ghaff 5y agoMore times than I care to admit, I'll have some cryptic comment or action item in my calendar notes and I have to go back to the person I was talking with and ask: "What the hell does this mean?"
- DannyBee 5y agoThis person is not saying every person who forgets something is evasive. They are specifically talking about people who are being evasive (IE the facts are known, this person just wants to argue about it). There's a huge difference between someone saying "yeah, i got no idea", and passive aggressively doing the same constantly becuase they want to be cute. This is not talking about the person who occasionally forgets something. This is talking about a deposition where everything is a struggle because the witness is being passive aggressive. The difference is pretty obvious (in most cases) live.
- Gibbon1 5y agoI was on a Jury for a trial that lasted 2 weeks, dozen witnesses. I came away with the impression that there is what happened, what they saw, what they perceived, and what they remembered. And then memories change over time. Doesn't help that most witnesses are ambushed by circumstances. They're muddling through life when something untoward came out of left field. And so weren't forming long term memories.
- IgorPartola 5y ago> Much wisdom often goes with fewer words.” –Sophocles I love that this quote sits in the middle of the first section of this lengthy article. The section that says to specifically use more questions rather than fewer (some of the questions are for some reason phrased as statements). The section that is followed by an intro that basically defined what an uncooperative witness is at least three times but in more or less the same words. The irony is so strong I don’t think I need to take my supplements today.
- pkilgore 5y agoI would just like to remind folks that depositions are a hostile form of communication. As many other lawyers can tell you, choosing to adopt these techniques with friends and loved ones will generally be perceived quite poorly. And without an actual judge to force both parties to be there and a fact finder and standard to apply, everyone involved will lose. That said, this was really excellent and concise advice. I hope it might be obvious how much preparation time this takes, which is just one of the many reasons litigation is so incredibly expensive on non-corporate financial scales.
- hashimotonomora 5y agoIt depends on your goal. Depositions are not taken with a judge. It’s great as a method for asking specific, exhaustive, exploratory questions and not letting the “witness” word herself out without at least making it obvious to you. I’ve used it a lot with sneaky suppliers and in general as a method to find truth. With friends a loved ones you should make it much softer and know when to stop. But the underlying conceptual framework is the same.
- kayodelycaon 5y agoInterrogating family and friends in these way is inherently hostile because the goal here is to catch people lying. By doing this, you’re telling the other person you don’t trust them. As someone on the receiving end of this, it destroyed any trust I had with my parents and teachers. The problem was that I wasn’t lying, but that I couldn’t tell a story in a coherent and linear order on the first attempt.
- xyzelement 5y agoSome of this advice is simply how to structure a conversation that helps the other person communicate what they know. If doesn't need to be hostile.
- kayodelycaon 5y agoThe article does not tell you how to use these techniques in a non-hostile way. You need to have good social skills to even pull that off… in that case, why do you need them?
- smcl 5y agoSo this reminds me of an amazing situation during a deposition for a case involving voice actor Vic Mignona suing some people because their tweets and calls[0] caused him to lose work. So a guy called Ron Toye is being questioned over some tweets and Ty Beard (the lawyer conducting the deposition) just needs to get him to authenticate that some tweets are his: Ty Beard: Look at all these pages, are these all your tweets? Ron Toye: I don't recall making them, but that's my twitter handle yeah TB: Are those your tweets? RT: It looks like it, yes TB: Yes? Is that a "yes"? RT: It looks like it, yes TB: I need you to say yes or no [1] RT: ... or it looks like it So this goes on for pages, the frustrated lawyer (who appears to be pretty poorly equipped to handle the situation) being given the runaround by just A Guy. There is a really funny discussion of this - including more of the deposition transcript - in the ALAB podcast's episode "Weeb Wars Pt 2" @ https://soundcloud.com/alabpodcast/episode-5-weeb-wars-pt-2 https://soundcloud.com/alabpodcast/episode-5-weeb-wars-pt-2 (deposition chat starts 28 minutes in, lasts 10 minutes). It even escalates, it's great :D edit: to be clear, I think the person being stupid in this scenario is Ty Beard, not Ron Toye :D [0] - arguably Vic Mignona's own general creepiness caused this, but these guys tweeted about that [1] - he really doesn't
- lovecg 5y agoI guess you can follow up with something like “what are some reasons it looks like it to you” and then follow that trail.
- wodenokoto 5y agoThere is a similar story about an office worker not knowing what a photocopy machine is. The New York Times did an amazing reenactment from transcripts of the legal deposition https://youtu.be/PZbqAMEwtOE https://youtu.be/PZbqAMEwtOE
- mtlynch 5y agoI loved that scene. It features the fantastic but tragically underused John Ennis, most famous for his work on Mr. Show. I remember when it came out, I felt like the Verbatim series was really well done, but it was surprising coming from the NY Times since it was so outside their wheelhouse. It seems like they abandoned it pretty quickly but I wish someone more like Funny or Die would pick up the idea.
- WJW 5y agoAn interesting style of questioning for adversarial situations. Engineers are usually taught to use very open questions (why/what/who/when/etc) so as to not inadvertently steer the situation to a predetermined conclusions. This is very useful for cooperative situations, such as a team trying to find the root case of some outage so that it can be fixed. In more adversarial situations such as pitching your manager on a raise, I can see how using many short and closed questions will steer the conversation much more effectively by closing down options for the counterparty to evade. It's very similar to the "yes ladder" used in some sales courses.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Lifelarper 5y ago> lawyer > My friend we.... > lawyer The police and justice system are never your friend irrespective of innocence, anyone with enough money and no infamy can just walk away, get a lawyer always, the justice system is irrevocably broken, don't fight that.
- GavinMcG 5y agoI'm not sure what your comment has to do with the article, which is about depositions in a civil suit.
- cosmojg 5y agoAll I see is a spinning three-quarter circle.
- rectang 5y ago> The advantage of the "one fact – one question" technique is that when a witness "runs", i.e. they try a long non-responsive narrative; the question can be repeated easily again and again. "Colonel Jessup, did you order the code red?"
- wodenokoto 5y agoIs it illegal for a witness to withhold knowledge? I.e., saying "I don't remember" in regards to facts that they somehow can be proven to know?
- toyg 5y agoIt's not an absolute principle. It obviously depends on the country, but also on the type of trial (civil, criminal...), down to the particular type of issue being considered and the position of the witness in the dynamic.
- GavinMcG 5y agoIn general, in this setting, yes. The English (and thereby American) legal traditions assume a right "to every man's evidence" and depositions are taken under oath. An actual perjury charge is extremely unlikely, but the judge the case is assigned to could hold a witness in contempt for persistently refusing to play ball. In reality, though, what the deposing side needs is to know what facts the witness will testify to, or alternatively, to be able to show that the witness can't be trusted. So if they can prove that the witness lied, it's likely sufficient for their purposes to just show that at trial and thereby discredit the witness.
- leetcrew 5y agohow can you prove that someone knows something? if you could, presumably you wouldn't need to question them about that thing.
- i_like_waiting 5y agoby other questions that imply that very simplified example: have you drove your car from pub? don't remember were you in a morning at 6 Random street? Yes 5 mins later... Did you took a taxi? No sir, I came by car Can anybody confirm that for you? No, I was driving alone It would be probably more elaborate questions, but you get the idea
- FpUser 5y ago>"The witness who “doesn’t remember” or “isn’t sure” about dates, times, distances, or amounts." That would be me. I honestly can't ever remember any date / phone number / time / etc without writing it down. FFS I can't even recall license plate of my car. >"Q. How far apart were your truck and Mrs. Agan’s car apart the accident? A. I don’t know. ... and it goes on and on" Yes I do not remember the distance. I can tell that it is probably between 5 and 15 feet. There is no fucking evasion here. Learn to ask correct question instead. >"Effective exhaustion is the use of simple follow-up questions like the following after each answer: ... "Tell me more" ... " I am sorry Mr. Lawyer. I am not here to create stories possibly endangering sides without merit. Ask fucking particular questions.
- loeg 5y agoThe questions are intentionally leading to the conclusion the lawyer wants a jury to reach. It’s intended to be hostile. If you react angrily, that serves the lawyer’s purpose.
- Nasrudith 5y agoAnd lawyers wonder why they are considered lowerer than a subterranean snake's belly when they openly waste vast amounts of people's time to manipulatively build a sophistic self serving narrative....
- FpUser 5y agoIf I calmly tell lawyer to go back to high school and learn haw to ask questions that could be answered without the doubt whose purpose does it serve?
- tptacek 5y agoClassic illustration of this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZbqAMEwtOE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PZbqAMEwtOE
- jedimastert 5y agoSuper duper off topic, but the second period in the second paragraph is in bold and it's surprisingly distracting. Not like "can't bare to read the rest of the article" but it did make me stop and check the source to make sure I wasn't crazy.
- stickfigure 5y agoWould you agree that one of the standards of safe product design is that the risk of severe injury or death is always unreasonable, and always unacceptable, if it could be prevented or minimized by reasonable safety measures? That word reasonable is doing an awful lot of heavy lifting here. Reasonable to whom? Seems like it makes the question almost meaningless.
- kixiQu 5y agoI think this is a fundamental difficulty of depositions: "reasonable" has a really clear and precise legal meaning that does answer "to whom" it must be reasonable, but if I, a non-lawyer, don't know that legal meaning, I am terrified of the consequences of getting it wrong.
- antognini 5y agoThe word "reasonable" does a lot of heavy lifting in the American legal system in general. There is even a meme (sorry for the low quality): https://m.facebook.com/comedianoflaw/photos/a.2039413752958126/3189218351310988/?type=3&is_lookaside=1 https://m.facebook.com/comedianoflaw/photos/a.20394137529581...
- jacquesm 5y agoLawyers don't give a hoot about the truth, they care about billable minutes and winning their cases, and if that requires bending, twisting or breaking the truth then so be it. If lawyers cared about the truth then there wouldn't be any lawsuits, just mediation and settlements out of court.
- rectang 5y agoThat's the nature of the adversarial system, and the argument (which I agree with) is that it's better to to avoid the idea that there is only one "truth", or at least to defer winnowing down what constitutes "truth" until after all sides have made the case for their own "truth".
- jacquesm 5y agoI've seen enough lawsuits up close to know for a fact that the truth rarely comes out during a lawsuit. What does happen is that (1) either party's lawyer has incomplete understanding of the case, (2) either party runs out of money before the case concludes, (3) either party folds because the other party can afford to endlessly extend the case and (4) either party settles because the cost of the lawsuit exceeds the settlement. I've seen cases won that should have been lost and vice-versa if it depended on the truth. When you go to court it's alway a crap-shoot, no matter how sure you are of your case going in. This is something people with iron clad faith in the legal system should realize. Courts are at best an amplifier of who has the most money to throw at a particular lawsuit, unless both parties are equally matched and are willing to take it all the way to the highest court the courts are not a fair and level playing field. Rather the opposite.
- rectang 5y ago/me nodding vigorously in agreement The question in my mind is what a system would look like where lawyers were legally bound to serve "truth" in some way above and beyond their current ethical obligations. The question immediately arises, who is the arbiter of that "truth"? What got me on this question was this passage from the root: > If lawyers cared about the truth then there wouldn't be any lawsuits, just mediation and settlements out of court. But court system rot doesn't begin from the personal moral failings of individual lawyers (except insofar as they choose to participate). The litigants — primarily powerful commercial entities — create an inexorable demand for an unlevel playing field.