13 ms·
Charlie Munger defends windowless dorm rooms for California students
- swayvil 5y agoAnd of course everybody in this depressing catacomb will wear the face-erasing mask. It would make a great sci fi movie.
- aikinai 5y agoI would rather live here than any of my dorms from college. It’s not like you will spend all, or even most, of your time in the room, especially with the nice shared facilities in the same building. Plus all the other options and opportunities on a college campus. The complainers are only considering an imaginary ideal alternative, not realistic trade offs.
- dsauerbrun 5y agoI'd challenge you to board up the windows in your room so that absolutely no light gets in. just do it for 5 days. you'll find waking up without natural light is an awful experience. I stayed in a room without a window for a week a few years ago. I wouldn't recommend it. if the trade off is that I can't afford alternative housing I'm finding housing in a turn that I need to commute from. I went to ucsb and knew a few people who commuted from Ventura which is 45min away and much cheaper than Santa Barbara.
- xboxnolifes 5y ago> you'll find waking up without natural light is an awful experience Consider I had to wake up before sunrise and got out of classes after sunset, there wasn't much sun to deal with in my dorm.
- dsauerbrun 5y agoyou're right. I think I should have clarified, waking up in a pitch black environment is the real issue, not necessarily the absence of natural light. I still think you want ambient light from outside as opposed to switching a lamp on in the inside of the room. This was my personal experience though so I could be wrong. I feel pretty strongly that data would back up my anecdotal experience though... not willing to take the time to look it up though so i'll stay out of the conversation from now on.
- notacoward 5y agoBeen there, done that, for much longer, because I wanted it that way. Hot tip: people are different.
- dsauerbrun 5y agoAgreed. However, if you're building something as massive as this you likely want to appeal to a broad market. I could be wrong but I suspect that most people would prefer having a window in their bedroom as opposed to not having one.
- aikinai 5y agoI love natural light and get as much as I can when I'm awake, but it's not required in my bedroom, especially if alternative options are a long commute, sharing a room with a stranger, or going deeper into debt. To me it's crazy that you would choose a 45 minute commute over a small and/or windowless room in college, but I understand people have different priorities; I'm sure there will be at least 4,500 students that will appreciate and choose the option to live alone, cheaper, and have the other amenities in exchange for a window. There's no need for outraged outsiders to pre-make that decision for them. And, incidentally, I don’t need to accept the challenge to block my windows. I already have blackout curtains that I never open because the only time I’m in my bedroom is when I'm asleep or it’s too bright/hot to open. And I can’t use the natural light to wake up since where I live sunrise varies from about 4:00 to 6:30am, which doesn't work with my schedule at all. I've considered buying an automatic curtain opener to make use of the light as an alarm, but haven't gotten around to it, so for now the curtains just stay closed.
- dsauerbrun 5y agoI agree with you that we can let people decide what trade offs they value; however, there is an issue where the university could find out that this is harmful to mental health or simply that students aren't willing to make this trade off. Now you have this giant building that isn't being optimally used and it could be expensive/difficult to repurpose it. Also, I sleep with blackout curtains too! It's a much different experience than waking up in a pitch black room. Small slivers of light make it through the edges of the curtains and that makes a HUGE difference in my own experience. Even in the winter when it's dark in the morning is a different experience than the pure pitch black. I know what I'm describing sounds silly and ridiculous but it's hard to explain how unsettling it is to wake up in a room like that.
- tzs 5y ago> you'll find waking up without natural light is an awful experience Isn't California trying to switch to permanent DST? In Santa Barbara that will move winter sunrise to as late as a little past 8 AM. That's going to limit how effectively a lot of people can use natural light to help wake.
- dsauerbrun 5y agoNo idea what CA is doing with DST. As I mentioned in another comment, I misspoke. My issue was less about waking up to natural light and more about waking up in pitch black and using artificial light in place of natural light. In the winter I wake up before sunrise; however, there is still small slivers of ambient light out there(from the moon) that makes it through my blackout curtains which makes a world of difference. Again, all anecdotal evidence but I'm inclined to join the rabble on this building given my personal experience.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y ago> It’s not like you will spend all, or even most, of your time in the room ??? I spent a fairly significant amount of time in my room studying, sleeping, and doing schoolwork when I was in college. I only went out for recreation, meals, and classes. I would argue that I spent the majority of time in my bedroom at college, including sleeping.
- encryptluks2 5y agoThere are people that would gladly live in a basement eating nothing but hot pockets and wear a mask even when walking down the street. Doesn't mean everyone should be willing to.
- toolz 5y agoI would love to see this submission title changed to replace "Billionaire" with Munger, as his networth has nothing to do with the discussion unless you're interesting in attacking Munger's character rather than his ideas.
- dkrudy 5y agoAfter the initial disgust, I don't have a problem with this. (I do with the pricetag, 300k per single occupancy?!?!?) This is like paying less for a middle seat on an airplane. Somewhat uncomfortable to save money. For the love of God this better be cheaper for the students though, or else, absolutely not. There are plenty of other schools that aren't as sexy where students should feel welcome, and are not due to a variety of issues.
- hprotagonist 5y agoMy chambers were up stairs at No. — Wall-street. At one end they looked upon the white wall of the interior of a spacious sky-light shaft, penetrating the building from top to bottom. This view might have been considered rather tame than otherwise, deficient in what landscape painters call “life.” But if so, the view from the other end of my chambers offered, at least, a contrast, if nothing more. In that direction my windows commanded an unobstructed view of a lofty brick wall, black by age and everlasting shade; which wall required no spy-glass to bring out its lurking beauties, but for the benefit of all near-sighted spectators, was pushed up to within ten feet of my window panes. Owing to the great height of the surrounding buildings, and my chambers being on the second floor, the interval between this wall and mine not a little resembled a huge square cistern. … Imagine my surprise, nay, my consternation, when without moving from his privacy, Bartleby in a singularly mild, firm voice, replied, “I would prefer not to.” I sat awhile in perfect silence, rallying my stunned faculties. Immediately it occurred to me that my ears had deceived me, or Bartleby had entirely misunderstood my meaning. I repeated my request in the clearest tone I could assume. But in quite as clear a one came the previous reply, “I would prefer not to.”
- aqme28 5y agoIsn't this building also a horrifying fire hazard? Two exits for 4500 students sounds like a recipe for a crush.
- giorgioz 5y agoIt's very likely they thought of this and planned sufficient fire detectors, sprinklers, cutting-fire doors and emerging stairs and exits. In a 11 floors building the occupants would not be evacuating from the windows. You can't let 4500 people out of 11 floors building using firetruck ladders or having people jumping out and be caught on life nets. There should be enough emergency stairs and they can be built or not despite the rooms having windows or not.
- josefx 5y ago> It's very likely they thought of this and planned sufficient fire detectors From the pictures in the linked article at least two people per unit can only leave their rooms through the shared kitchen. So I wouldn't bet on it, seems to me as if they optimized for size with little to no thought on anything else. Even without the fire hazard having to go through the kitchens working area to get in and out of your room just asks for problems when it is in use.
- 542458 5y agoIn architecture “entrances” is not equal to “emergency exits”. This structure has two entrances, but a dozen emergency exits (which exceeds fire code).
- chrisseaton 5y agoWho said there were only two exits? You’ve imagined that and invented a problem. There’s two entrances.
- giorgioz 5y agoThis really reminds of the book "The Fountainhead" of "Ayn Rand". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fountainhead https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Fountainhead There is logic behind the words of Charles Munger and also on his opposition. Frankly though if Charles Munger is financing the project they should let them do it. It might work out great or terribly. We'll find out and Charles Munger will pay for it.
- TheRealDunkirk 5y agoSure. Why not. A poor, struggling university -- with only $161 BILLION in their endowment -- probably can't make ends meet without $200M "donations," with specious strings attached, like this one.
- pepperonipizza 5y agoThere is already one which has been built and it has mostly positive reviews. https://www.veryapt.com/ApartmentReview-a7222-munger-graduate-residences-ann-arbor?reviews_page=1 https://www.veryapt.com/ApartmentReview-a7222-munger-graduat...
- danuker 5y agoOne of the comments: > It was great up until the covid started, staying in an apartment with no windows and no access to other facilities within the building isn't worth it.
- m0llusk 5y agoThat one has a different plan with windows in some of the common spaces unlike this new plan which is almost entirely without.
- aqme28 5y agoIf only Munger pays for bad architecture, then that's fine. The issue is that 4500 students will also have to pay for it
- 5y ago
- chrisseaton 5y ago> every single student gets his own private sleeping area. That's unheard of in undergraduate Even in the UK, which is a lot poorer than the US, every undergraduate has always gotten an individual bedroom. The idea of making adults share bedrooms is very bizarre. How do you have a relationship living like that?
- lbriner 5y agoMaybe college is about learning stuff and having a roomie to challenge and help you. I doubt the powers that be are worried about you wanting a long-term relationship. Remember that people having sex while not married has only been acceptable for perhaps 50 years to society, which post-dates many colelge buildings. There might be lots of people who want to dissuade people from "illicit liasons" by pairing them up in rooms to make things harder ;-)
- chrisseaton 5y ago> Maybe college is about learning stuff and having a roomie to challenge and help you. Learn with, challenge, and help you… in the bedroom?! You don’t need to sleep and get undressed in the same room as someone to study with them. > I doubt the powers that be are worried about you wanting a long-term relationship. When I was at Uni they made a big deal about how many people met their future partners there.
- Pasorrijer 5y agoNot to be nit-picky, but I'd just add the caveat "having sex while not married has become fashionable in the last 50 years, after a few hundred years of Catholic puritanism"... Sex outside of marriage has been extremely acceptable in many non-western societies at basically all stages of human development.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 5y agoIn the US religious context, "Catholic" and "Puritan" are mutually hostile, although neither is very keen on extramarital relationships.
- TheRealDunkirk 5y agoBillionaires gonna... billionaire, or something. > Obviously, it would be better if every student could have a penthouse with perfect views in all four directions. But we don't do that because we can't get enough students to live conveniently close together. This is a logic fallacy, but I don't know the name of it. "We all agree that all students can't have a penthouse. So why do you care if we stuff them in windowless rooms?" He wants to compare windowless rooms to a cruise ship. You spend a WEEK on a cruise ship. I had an openable window in my dorm room (in the days before every room in a university was a hotel suite). I cannot imagine living 9 months of my life in a room with no actual window.
- charbonneau2 5y ago> This is a logic fallacy, but I don't know the name of it. "We all agree that all students can't have a penthouse. So why do you care if we stuff them in windowless rooms?" False dichotomy
- kelseyfrog 5y agoAlso mixed in with strawman. > Exaggerating (sometimes grossly exaggerating) an opponent's argument, then attacking this exaggerated version. The claim in this case being, "residents should have reasonable access to sunlight in their rooms." And the exaggeration being penthouses.
- Frost1x 5y agoNot sure about a fallacy but he's essentially saying: because it can't be the best option, the worst is acceptable. It's as if there aren't options in between and this isn't just optimization and greed run amuck against the human condition. It reminds me of one of the newer plane seating layouts I saw with alternating seats. You know, it would be even more optimal if they didn't actually live in the building at all and just sent him money every week, wouldn't he like that even more?
- BurningFrog 5y agoThe worst option is sleeping on the streets. Quite common in California. This building is a huge improvement over that baseline.
- laydn 5y agoI just don't see Munger's angle here. I mean, why not donate the money and let the university handle everything else? What is his line of thinking exactly? He thinks the university will waste the money or something?
- everyone 5y agoHe's suffering from architecture dunning kruger effect.
- chrisseaton 5y agoCharitable interpretation is that you want to donate to help people, but you think you know better than administrators, who don’t always have the same goals as the people you’re trying to help. Wanting to donate to people in a poor country but not to the local regime, for example.
- prepend 5y agoI think his angle is he thinks this is an efficient design and the best use of his money. Keeping 4500 students in a single 11 storey building is pretty efficient. And using all the natural light space for common areas and classroom is pretty novel. It’s hard for me to know Munger’s mind, but I think his donation is intended to improve how dorms are designed beyond this single building and school. So his investment is not to just house these students, but to help colleges better house students.
- danaris 5y agoIf it's hard for you to know Munger's mind, may I suggest you read the article, which describes his exact rationale for the stipulations?
- prepend 5y agoGood point. I should clarify my comment by saying “After reading the article, it’s hard for me to know Munger’s mind as to the motivation he has in funding this building…”
- 542458 5y agoDiscussed previously here https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29038356 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29038356 It’s worth noting that this isn’t the first mostly-windowless dorm he’s built. His previous work at UM has generally very good reviews and was built without much (if any) protest. Michigan: https://www.veryapt.com/ApartmentReview-a7222-munger-graduate-residences-ann-arbor https://www.veryapt.com/ApartmentReview-a7222-munger-graduat... It sounds to me like the evidence so far is that Munger is correct, and on average people (or at least the kind of people that would sign up for res in a building like this) would rather have a small private room with a fake window and lower rent and than a shared room with a real window and higher rent. I’m not sure why this particular structure has provoked so much more outrage than the previous one. Edit: I previously mentioned the Stanford Munger Graduate Residence as well, but it appears that one is of more “traditional” layout (and is relatively expensive). Thanks dkarp for pointing this out. I've edited it out of my comment as to not mislead.
- nikanj 5y agoBecause people don’t really see opportunity costs, and say everyone should get a large private room with a window. In reality half the people get a massive debt burden and the other half live off-campus, but the complainers don’t really see that part. See also: people who are vehemently opposed to building more density, because a detached house with a large yard is better for mental health
- entropyie 5y agoi see your point, minimum size rules for appartents in Ireland cause similar issues. But I draw the line at windows. They are a basic human necessity and a fire hazard mitigation. I stayed in a hostel underground once in Liverpool, and it was aweful... I was not rich at college and shared crappy houses all the while, but I would not take this up under any circumstances.
- roenxi 5y agoBased on the stats, you're probably underweighting the damage of very high debt levels and overweighting the importance of windows. Although there are serious questions to ask about the ventilation of these rooms - as long as they've got satisfactory answers it looks like a good idea. The options can't be perfect or nothing. The options should be perfect, good and bad.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI like the design in principle, is there actual evidence for or against the idea of sleeping in a room with fake windows? I have a light based alarm clock that wakes me up, which is a vaguely similar concept, I've also used blackout blinds to block light from real windows in summer.
- nkrisc 5y agoPersonally, I think just knowing that is not real I’d enough to make me lose it if I had to live in a room like that. There’s something magical about waking up to the smell of the cool, morning air to me that I would desperately miss.
- wongarsu 5y agoI think there are far better criticisms of the building than the fake windows. Like sharing a single shower with 7 other people who might take the same courses as me. Or how there's way too few entrances and exits. It's strange how this interview with Munger completely focuses on the windows, the one concern that's both unavoidable in the design and addressed in the planning (by putting in fake windows)
- chaosite 5y agoIt's a single bathroom, but it might have more than one shower installed. Are shared bathrooms really that big a deal?
- wongarsu 5y agoApparently I read the plan wrong, and it's actually two bathrooms with one shower each [1, page 39]. Which is better, but still cramped. Sharing bathrooms is fine in principle, but with more than one per two people you start coordinating who has to wake up when to use it, and it gets worse the more people you have that want to go to class at the same time. 1: https://www.dfss.ucsb.edu/sites/default/files/docs/dcs/DRC%20Meeting%20Packet%2010.05.21.pdf https://www.dfss.ucsb.edu/sites/default/files/docs/dcs/DRC%2...
- kayodelycaon 5y ago> You're not an architect, though, are you? > Well, no, but I've been building buildings all my life, and I've hired a lot of the very eminent architects for over 70 years. This sounds like a manager with no technical skills says they hired a lot of programmers before.
- austincheney 5y agoStrange how often I encounter that on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28988495 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28988495
- kayodelycaon 5y agoPeople that are experts in one field tend to assume they are experts in other fields. I think this is a fundamental human flaw, rather than a personal one, because I easily make the same mistake if I’m not careful. Of course, this belief is based on the assumption on how frequently I see it. Could be confirmation bias or me trying to write off my own problems as not being mine. :)
- Majromax 5y agoOn the other hand, is an architecture degree the right credential to criticize the proposal? The strongest critique seems to come from the social science side with an argument that windowless rooms are bad for mental health. I'm interested in hearing more about that, particularly whether there's a difference between windows and natural-spectrum light (the latter of which can be mimicked). However, an architect has no particular authority on this subject. I can't give his opinion here any more weight than the manager who's hired architects before.
- Aeolun 5y agoArchitects take a lot of stuff into account when designing a building. Natural light is undoubtedly one of the considerations (and I expect them to know how important it is and why).
- eganist 5y agoNo indication of windowless dorms at Munger's alma mater while he attended, the University of Michigan (someone correct me if I'm getting this wrong), so my only guess is that Charlie became self-righteous about younger generations finding themselves more immersed in tech than the world around them. ...and removes windows to force people outside, thinking somehow that'll solve the problem? It only shows that everyone who's sharp in one way is utterly clueless in another. My guess is that people will end up spending more time depressed (e.g via SAD) as a consequence of getting no exposure to nature and daylight in their own rooms while cramming as opposed to making themselves go outside, as Charlie intended. I wonder if these outcomes will be measurable once a generation of students has made it through?
- 542458 5y agoHe funded one of these buildings at his alma matter already. It has very good reviews. https://www.veryapt.com/ApartmentReview-a7222-munger-graduate-residences-ann-arbor https://www.veryapt.com/ApartmentReview-a7222-munger-graduat...
- eganist 5y agoInteresting, the Munger apartments have one to two orders of magnitude more reviews than any of the other mid-rise residences (e.g The Collegian, Zaragon West, Tower Plaza Condo, etc) https://i.imgur.com/8o7TnoL.png https://i.imgur.com/8o7TnoL.png Wondering if it's an odd outcome of media exposure or if it's a consequence of bought reviews. It'd be interesting to compare the reviews of the building to other graduate residences elsewhere.
- motioncuty 5y agoSo does the crap on Amazon. We should probably use studies rather than internet reviews.
- danaris 5y agoAccording to a number of other comments on here, it also has many more windows. It's also grad student housing, which means students actually have some measure of choice in it, rather than just being assigned to live there when they arrive as a first-year.
- jijji 5y agoIts not mentioned at all in this article, not sure why, but in construction, every state has a building code, and specifically every state has a requirement for a window to be built inside of each sleeping room for egress fire safety. I would question how this would pass any plan review, not to mention inspection [1] [2] [1] https://www.buildingincalifornia.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/01/ResidentialWindowEgress.pdf https://www.buildingincalifornia.com/wp-content/uploads/2014... [2] https://up.codes/viewer/california/ibc-2018/chapter/10/means-of-egress#1030 https://up.codes/viewer/california/ibc-2018/chapter/10/means...
- Majromax 5y ago> and specifically every state has a requirement for a window to be built inside of each sleeping room for egress fire safety. From your second link, that window requirement does not apply to type R.2 buildings (apartments) where there is an automatic sprinkler system.
- notacoward 5y agoRelatedly, an outside window isn't going to be very useful for egress when you're in a high-rise. No, this particular dorm isn't quite a high-rise, but the point is that exceptions are entirely necessary and legitimate. This aspect of building codes probably wasn't mentioned because it's not relevant.
- jijji 5y agoI've never seen an apartment complex that had bedrooms in it that didn't have any windows... I have built apartment buildings and they need to have sprinklers (circa 2010) but more importantly they need to have Windows... the cost savings is probably null considering that you're going to be filling the space with concrete, and when the fire happens, which they do, you'll probably get sued into bankruptcy by anybody living in such a building with no windows. From what I understand you're not even allowed to have an interior room that's a sleeping quarters that doesn't have a window, and if anybody found out that you were doing that it would get shut down immediately.
- rbanffy 5y agoWell… I defend windowless dorms for some billionaires.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI interested in a future where TVs have a good as color and image quality as reality (maybe 50 years out from now). TVs are cheaper per unit area than insulation windows, could be providing a view of exactly what a windows would with streaming cameras, but could also let you travel the world by providing votes from other locations. They would also let you up the r value of the walls easily :)
- pythonlion 5y agoscreens will never replace windows
- yreg 5y agoTV has a disadvantage of not being able to be opened. However in fifty years we might not want to open the windows anyway.
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoYou can have a window AND a TV There is no need for a TV to REPLACE the window Even bird cages have openings. Trapping a student in a hole is rather miserable.
- snowwrestler 5y agoTVs can not have depth like a window, where your eyes have to flex to change focal length to bring distant things into focus. Even “3D” movies and TV cannot do this. It is potentially an issue for long-term eye health. If your eyes spend most of their time within a small range of focal distances, the muscles you use for focusing essentially fall out of shape. This can cause a person to need multi-focal glasses sooner than otherwise. It also limits the mental health benefits of looking “out a window.” Your brains knows whether a scene is real or fake based on focal depth, regardless of resolution.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoLight field displays in 50 years might allow this assuming we can get costs down.
- pythonlion 5y agoare we all stuck in competition with each other about who is more productive and smart? the economy is the embodiment of that fact and will just extract us as much as its can forever? is it possible to build and own our life instead of being forced to labor until near the end of life? why technology improved so much but the work is never done? can individual have control of his life or we stuck in doing what the economy dedicates? is there a place on earth is not owned by anyone?
- catlikesshrimp 5y ago"is there a place on earth is not owned by anyone?" Just tell me what place that is and I will sell it to you so you can own it :)
- gruez 5y ago> the economy is the embodiment of that fact and will just extract us as much as its can forever? No it isn't. The economy isn't zero sum. >is it possible to build and own our life instead of being forced to labor until near the end of life? By "forced to labor", are you talking about having to work for someone else, or having to labor at all? It's clear that the former is possible (ie. start your own business), and the latter is a pipe dream as long as we're not in a post-scarcity economy
- pythonlion 5y agoeconomy is reflected by the the decisions of individuals and groups and what they priorities. Im not talking about post-scarcity economy Im talking about trying to get there, right now it feels we only moving away from it, and the labor we do is not constructive to us or valued very little.
- throw63738 5y agoIn China there is no such competition. CCP gives everyone what they need.
- pythonlion 5y ago
- rendall 5y agoFrom go, this article is bullshit. Yes, I flagged it, and yes, it's against guidelines to say this, but no, I don't think this should be on HN's front page, and it should be flippantly dismissed. Briefly, the article is an opinion piece crafted to stoke outrage. It is crafted to make you stupider. It does not give you full access to all the information for you to make your own informed opinion about what's going on. It is clickbait, and not worthy of your attention.
- encryptluks2 5y agoReally don't like different opinions getting out? What is it like working for the secret police?
- seoulmetro 5y agoThe dorms look amazing provided they're at the right price. And since there are so many of them, I can guarantee the price will be right. I don't know who "this billionaire" is, but he is definitely 100% right here. Dorms in Asian cities are like this and they're a godsend for students, workers, etc. for inner city, affordable and temporary living.
- adhoc_slime 5y agoFrom go, this comment is bullshit. Yes, I flagged it, and yes, it's against guidelines to say this, but no, I don't think this should be on HN's comment section, and it should be flippantly dismissed. Briefly, the comment is an opinion piece crafted to stoke outrage. It is crafted to make you stupider. It does not give you full access to all the information for you to make your own informed opinion about what's going on. It is clickbait, and not worthy of your attention.
- _red 5y agoMunger is a real proponent of Chinese-style capitalism and generally praises the idea of social-credit systems. It only makes sense that his architecture style would also favor brutalism. He probably repurposed some of the designs of the old commie-blocks from eastern europe.
- giorgioz 5y agoNO, China arrested Alibaba's Jack Ma: https://www.forbes.com/sites/georgecalhoun/2021/06/24/what-really-happened-to-jack-ma/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/georgecalhoun/2021/06/24/what-r... China inprisons successful entrepreneurs and takes away their property. The concept of private property in China is there just to show. So no, Munger is far from being a real proponent of a Chinese-style capitalism.
- everyone 5y agoDo you know what brutalism means in architecture? It means exposed concrete, Munger's design is not brutalism. Also what "commie-blocks from eastern europe" are you referencing? I can't think of any eastern european apartment buildings that resemble this design in any way. (They tend to have windows)
- cushychicken 5y agoWhy does it take $200 million to build a dorm building? I know it's in Santa Barbara, but even still - that seems like an excessive amount of money.
- bondarchuk 5y agoNo, it takes 1.5 billion, of which this guy furnishes 0.2. https://www.independent.com/2021/10/28/architect-resigns-in-protest-over-ucsb-mega-dorm/ https://www.independent.com/2021/10/28/architect-resigns-in-... Housing 4500k students it is about 333k per student. Which does seem incredibly expensive given the tiny and low-quality space per student, but I have no idea about building costs in general.
- 542458 5y agoPart of the shtick here is that the common spaces are large and of very high quality (for dorm rooms). The sticker price may also include land purchase, and almost certainly includes furnishings. The last thing to note is that all construction is very expensive right now due to materials shortages.
- LatteLazy 5y agoI'm a Brit so it's it's a bit different here but... I was glad to have the option to stay in a shitty little room with no ensuite and bare brick walls at the bottom a of steep hill that campus was atop. It saved me 1000s of pounds over people who paid literally twice as much just to have gold coloured taps. Since my day that option has been removed because the government have decreed everyone have their own toilet and shower. But the result is kids in vastly more debt.
- m0llusk 5y agoYes, but that is because Britain is absolutely terrible at land management. Huge tracts get no or minimal use because owners are land banking or whatever. This slows or stops development all over the place and results in high property costs.
- Wolfenstein98k 5y agoNice "journalism" with that headline.
- cletus 5y agoThis dorm really is an abomination and the correct response here would've been for the university to say "thanks, but no thanks" to Munger's money with the stipulations he placed on it. In following this story someone raised the comparison to University of Cincinnati's Sander Hall [1], which was actually less crowded than this. This now demolished building had problems from criminal offences to evacuations caused by people intentionally setting off fire alarms. Evacuating this dorm in such cases is going to be a nightmare given the ratio of students to fire stairs and you know that's going to happen. Architecture matters. The experience matters. Common areas, such as they are, with this many students will undoubtedly turn feral almost immediately. Putting people in windowless cells but defending it as "everyone gets their own room" is not the solution. Billionaires reach an age when the only thing they value is putting their name on everything. It's why there are so many concert halls, colleges, etc named "Carnegie" (after Andrew Carnegie, the 19th century steel industrialist). You don't have to take their money. I'm sure UCSB isn't struggling for cash. [1]: https://medium.com/@spncrtckrmn/the-rise-and-demise-of-ucs-sander-hall-239eacf2788e https://medium.com/@spncrtckrmn/the-rise-and-demise-of-ucs-s...
- memetomancer 5y agoNeeds pointing out: You are asserting stuff like "This dorm really is an abomination" and "Common areas, such as they are, with this many students will undoubtedly turn feral almost immediately" with out actually seeming to support your arguments. This comes off as hyperbolic and biased, and more likely, some combination of thoughtlessness and arrogance which makes the opposing view seem more honest. Your reference to a 50 year old dorm in another state, with a completely different layout and a culture more informed by the film Animal House than Instagram hardly bears up. The building is shorter with more space for emergency exits. It may well have integrated fire suppression and active monitoring. And each of these sleeping spaces with no windows is said to attach to a 'house' with a private common area and real windows. Nothing like the isolated skyscraper dorm you link to. Moreover, touchy feely points like "Architecture matters. The experience matters." only raise red flags for me, especially when considered with your next point: "Billionaires reach an age when the only thing they value is putting their name on everything." This particular billionaire clearly has an enthusiastic engagement with the details of the project and a vision for solving the problems he's mentioned in the article, namely removing the need for freshmen to lodge with a stranger. A billionaire that just wanted to "put their name on everything" would pay the money, let the architect do their thing and never consider what it would be like to live in the results, right? This guy seems to be trying to fix the complaints from his eight(!) children, so future generations don't face the same. You might have a point buried in your post somewhere, but in your rush to slam this whole thing without backing it up, you've lost me.
- traveler01 5y agoIn Portugal socialists make windowless student dorm rooms and nobody complains about it. Read the pdf file of the project and let's be real. Thing looks amazing.
- numair 5y agoI can't believe people are resorting to blatant whattaboutism to defend this nonsense without getting called out on it. Depriving humans of natural light for "economic" reasons is insane. Every study we've ever done on the effects of natural light on mood, happiness, whatever have always turned out the same: it's super-important for people. I can't imagine going through the hyper-hormonal ups-and-downs of early college age without a window to stare out into while contemplating my nothingness. This guy isn't just a "billionaire." Munger, through his involvement in Berkshire Hathaway and his law firm MTO, is the "billionaires' billionaire." This tone-deaf nonsense just shows what he thinks normal people should be grateful for accepting, as a gift from his tax write-off account... And if you think Munger is some sort of architectural genius, I look forward to your defense of "Mungerville." Because, you know, Santa Barbara is totally where you want to put a bunch of French Normandy crap: https://www.californiacoastline.org/cgi-bin/image.cgi?image=201308334&mode=sequential&flags=0&year=current https://www.californiacoastline.org/cgi-bin/image.cgi?image=...
- erfgh 5y agoWhy do you need a window when you can go outside at any time? It's not like it's a prison. If you want a room with a window pay for a room with a window.
- giorgioz 5y agoI lived in Hong Kong island for 3 months in a student accomodation called Appledorm where 50% of the rooms did not have a window: https://web.archive.org/web/20210414214205/http://www.appledorm.com/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210414214205/http://www.appled... https://goo.gl/maps/c4EhADc9A35du7hA9 https://goo.gl/maps/c4EhADc9A35du7hA9 7 years ago a windowless room costed 300USD and room with window costed 450USD. All the students were hanging out and partying on the rooftop of the building. The rooms were barely larger than the bed. The project of Munger seem to have larger bedrooms and nicer common spaces for each flat.
- aaron695 5y agoThe fact a billionaire did something so cool means HN has to hate it because the media tells them to. It's a fucking embarrassment. Even to the insanity that it might actually break from fire code. Because children out of high school on HN can think deeper than a team creating and checking a $200 million building across multiple organisations. The plans for this are online even - https://ceqanet.opr.ca.gov/2021070120/2 https://ceqanet.opr.ca.gov/2021070120/2 There are studies about access to windows. These generally were done pre-current lighting techniques and this is a room designed for sleeping. But if you're rich they are good else it's the same as the Navy or a lot of the developing world you can sleep without them. Except this is for kids who get to hang out in amazing communal spaces on top of having what 90% of the world does not, their own room and one assumes at an affordable price. > You're not an architect, though, are you? This line was done by a lot of the media. He should just say neither are you. You're just a shitty journalist with at best a shitty arts degree. Why do you get to question me? Many people do it themselves with the help of builders and engineers. Journalist (And HN) are so crippled and out of touch it's somehow normal for them to think only architects can do this.
- phrz 5y agoThis is the unfortunate outcome of a life lived without anyone telling you "no," without ever telling you that your ideas are profoundly bad.
- chinathrow 5y ago> The bedrooms have artificial windows instead of real ones, but they've got perfect ventilation. Well, to be honest, I'm a bit speechless about this phrase. Way to educate the future generation that it's fine to live in small, confined, window less environments.
- hoseja 5y agoI think I've seen that design in Dwarf Fortress.
- botchedditch 5y agoCould anyone please explain, why is it not possible to have windows there? For example, if every room had a 1x1m window. Is it because of heating issues?
- w6rpv3om 5y agoJust put money in something else, no big deal.
- stuaxo 5y agoThe students will all become short sighted.
- almeria 5y agoThis windowless thing is just a bunch of crazy suppositions by an ignorant man. Wow. For the sake of its reputation, legacy and future funding from other sources, which, over time, will utterly dwarf the dollar amount of this toxic "gift" that this crank billionaire is trying to twist their arm with -- Let's all hope that UCSB comes to its senses, and cuts all ties with this bully as soon as conceivably possible.
- Traster 5y agoIt was truly amazing to hear him say that and follow it up with utterly trivial considerations.It's not like he has some amazing insight that no one else has, he literally has just made a decision to force a load of value judgements on exploited teenagers. The US university system is already a capricious mess, without billionaires coming in to run experiments on their students.
- rkk3 5y agoSeems like you are embracing the outrage narrative rather than thoughtfully examining the tradeoffs. 1 in 20 UC students are homeless and SB has an acute housing crisis [1]. They are building a dorm for 5,000 students and also need to deal with cost, zoning, etc. Personally I would have been glad to give up a window to not share a room when I lived in the dorms. I also lived in an effectively windowless (against a brick wall) apartment in NYC, you just spend less time in your room. [1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-02/what-critics-of-the-windowless-mega-dorm-are-missing https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-11-02/what-crit...
- almeria 5y agoIt wasn't "embracing the outrage"; rather facing up to the fact that -- whatever the merits or lack thereof of his proposal -- the donor's language was intrinsically manipulative: This windowless thing is just a bunch of crazy suppositions by an ignorant man. At the end of the day, this just isn't the kind of person you want to sit down and do business with. No matter what dollar amount he's trying to jerk you around with.
- helen___keller 5y agoHonestly, putting aside complaints about windowless dorm rooms, my biggest complaint is that this development is not particularly cheap. By sticking so many students in one building, they had to include a ton of amenities; by including all those amenities, the cost ballooned to $1.5B, or $300k per housed student. After the $200MM grant, it's something like 260k A mortgage calculator suggests that, unsubsidized, the price is $1146 / mo for each student. Given that it won't be full occupancy, particularly during the summer, plus add in an "HOA fee" for the building services (gym, etc) and I could see this rising to $2000 / mo per student, maybe. Is this reasonable? Can we do better? I'm not sure. I'll bet it's appetizing compared to current prices that students pay in Santa Barbara, but I wonder if it's really the best they could do.
- mucholove 5y agoLockdown would be so miserable in this building. This is why I moved from Barcelona to DR—to avoid this kind of thing.
- cardanome 5y agoI think the general idea of mass housing with big communal spaces is good but cutting out windows is way too extreme. Housing many people while providing windows and decent living conditions is a solved problem. Just look at ex Soviet-block housing. Everyone got their own modern flat while still being pretty space efficient. Sure they wont win you an architecture price and some consider them "ugly" but they are still the best option to provide decent housing for a lot of people in a very short time.
- mdp2021 5y agoSorry for the aside note, but the planned building with the windowless rooms is for the University of California, Santa Barbara, which - did you know - as a motto has Fiat Lux ("light be done"), which some translate as Let there be light The irony! (I suppose Mr. Munger would note that artificial windows are, light-wise, more flexible; some would add that this way light is effectively, literally (artificially) "done".)
- mlac 5y agoWhat I don’t see folks mentioning is that you don’t have to get blackout blinds. It’s really optimal sleeping conditions. As long as air quality is healthy and filtered, it would make a great place to sleep or quietly study. Meals and all other items force you out of the room into a common area, and honestly the lack of windows would motivate me to get outside and meet people, which is what you want in college. No reason to make a single dorm comfortable enough that you never have to leave or use another study space on campus. I lived in a single one year, and the window looked into other windows, so it was closed most of the time. I might have preferred windowless if it meant I could get black out sleeping conditions. The two entry ways are also good for bumping into people / making conversation. It’s good for socialization, which is important. COVID makes all of this very weird, and isolating in place due to COVID exposure in a windowless pod with 7 other people and two shared bathrooms and no natural light for 2 weeks would be awful.
- Shadonototra 5y agowhen money is a justification for a bad and unhealthy life, then maybe our model is just not the one we need? I can't believe some are saying "i would have accepted a windowless room" I lost faith personally, we are doomed..
- xg15 5y ago> Well, everybody would prefer to have real windows if it were feasible. But it's a game of trade-offs, architecture. Somehow, real windows are feasible in any other residential building. And what's with all the diversion on single-occupancy rooms? Those two aspects have absolutely nothing to do with each other.