24 ms·
The metaverse is already here – it's Minecraft
- oskenso 5y ago"it's actually neosvr", "it's actually [insert thing here]" Maybe it's always been here, perhaps it's just another abstraction or simulation of a perceived reality. One could say that MUD systems are metaverses(metaversi?) What I would like to see are more decentralized simulation systems with extensive accessibility features
- aww_dang 5y agoMultiplayer virtual worlds have been with us since the beginning. I think there was a multiplayer high fantasy package for the PDP series of minicomputers? There's a concerted push to foist this buzzword on us either way.
- qvrjuec 5y agoOne of my favorite MUDs HellMOO has a lot of references to Snow Crash (the progenitor of the 'metaverse').
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- api 5y agoI was wondering recently if it might be possible with today's GPU hardware to create a Minecraft-like world with similar dynamics but with fully simulated physics across the entire world. In Minecraft terms this would be a global simulation "tick" that allowed things like gravity to work, more sophisticated creature behaviors to play out globally, etc.
- oskenso 5y agoThe neosvr team is doing just that with the open source bepu physics engine :D
- fwip 5y agoLooks like they abandoned that approach in 2019 with bepuphysics2 - https://www.bepuentertainment.com/blog/2019/1/16/-but-gpus-arent-always-the-right-choice https://www.bepuentertainment.com/blog/2019/1/16/-but-gpus-a...
- api 5y agoInteresting, but I was thinking of something simpler than a full on physics engine. Simulate a whole Minecraft-style voxel world like a big 3D cellular automaton with N states where N is the number of block types. Algorithms similar to HashLife may help: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashlife https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hashlife
- joshu 5y agoi always thought it was WoW. lots to do, but all gatekept and previously defined/allowed
- zemo 5y agonot really, WoW is a game, and no game can be a metaverse, because one of the most core and intrinsic qualities of what makes something a game is that it is a separate space from reality. Games studies people refer to this as "the magic circle" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_circle_(virtual_worlds) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magic_circle_(virtual_worlds)): the boundary separating reality from "game space". For example, let's say you're playing a game of Checkers. That's separate from real life. You can't buy a captured Checkers pieces on eBay and then in your next game of Checkers, start with more pieces than your opponent. Being able to do those things would cause the game to break down, because the game would no longer be a contest of your wits in Checkers, it would be a contest of your existing wealth. You can't purchase points in a basketball game, you can't purchase mulligans in golf, etc. A lot of people in the blockchain/NFT space seem to be of the position that games don't currently let you purchase things with real money or sell them to other players for real money because they lack the technical capabilities, but that is not and has never been the problem. There's also the "trading an item in one game for an item in another game" but that's equally useless, it's the same thing but with a barter system, and the barter system would eventually just give way to money anyway. The problem is that introducing those mechanics causes the magic circle to break down. By contrast a metaverse is a metaverse because the things happening in it are not in a separate, isolated space. Both games and metaverses are virtual in nature, but what makes something a metaverse is the lack of a magic circle, while what makes something a game is the presence of a magic circle. The metaverse is a virtual facet of reality; games' whole thing is that they are not reality. A metaverse can contain a game, but not vice versa. Plus WoW is entirely owned and operated by one entity; a metaverse is pretty definitionally a situation in which any party can create their own space without needing the permission of another party, kinda like anyone can create a website without needing the permission of any party. Well, of course, you need an IP address and if you want people to be able to reach it, a DNS record and if you want SSL some certificates, so that's not a perfect analogy, but the web isn't really decentralized anyway (for these specific reasons).
- sergiotapia 5y agoThey mispelled Rec-room. Play Rec-room in VR and tell me this isn't the future of gaming and online interactions. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ys_OgK2YB4E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ys_OgK2YB4E
- AlwaysRock 5y agoRoblox and Minecraft are great examples of what Metaverses could be. I think that is largely the appeal for many players.
- taylodl 5y agoAnimal Crossing is my wife's Multiverse.
- antifa 5y agoIs there anything GNU or good that's essentially AC for android? By good I mean isn't a slot machine with an AC style minigame. I already know about the current official android AC spinoff.
- achenatx 5y agoits actually roblox
- dandotway 5y agoDoes Minecraft go down for several days like Roblox does? Does Minecraft ban/cancel people like PewDiePie as Roblox did? Aren't monthly active users (MAU) around 100M for each? I think Roblox is eventually doomed to slowly fizzle like Second Life, etc. Internet history is littered with the corpses of dead closed systems. Remember Compuserve, Prodigy, and AOL? Remember Myspace? Microsoft might eventually, say, install mandatory AI inside Minecraft that forces all players to behaviorally conform to the social and political views of the most vocal group of Microsoft employees. Then some other immersive 3D world builder with more open rules of participation will send Minecraft to its grave.
- sweetbitter 5y agoMojang would have a problem trying to control Minecraft because it's written in Java, their developers commonly associate with the players who hack the game, and the only control over the gameservers that they have is their authentication servers- which you can disable the use of by editing one flag in your server config files, allowing anyone to play even if they didn't buy the game.
- Zababa 5y agoMojang can control their Minecraft, one of the strengths of Minecraft is that everyone can have their own.
- dandotway 5y agoThis describes the current state of Minecraft, but Microsoft can tie new releases to new restrictions. The unknowing masses will adopt the new version without understanding the loss of freedom. Look at the success MS, Adobe, etc., have had getting people to pay rent each month for software like Office and Photoshop that they used to buy once and run forever.
- bitwize 5y agoIt's Croquet. Which was Alan Kay building the metaverse -- as a mere stepping stone to his real goal which always was to build the Young Lady's Illustrated Primer from The Diamond Age.
- MrFlibbles 5y agoI thought is was already here... Fallout 76...
- Karawebnetwork 5y agoThere is a lesser-known part of Minecraft already used by educators: https://education.minecraft.net/en-us/discover/impact https://education.minecraft.net/en-us/discover/impact This is the kind of product I hope for with the Metaverse but will probably never see.
- kn8a 5y agoMojang have also cracked down on brands from 2016. "Mojang spokesperson Owen Hill pointed to situations where something like a car company would build or commission an independent developer to build a Minecraft server with specific purpose of advertising a new vehicle." https://venturebeat.com/2016/05/31/microsoft-bans-corporations-from-using-minecraft-as-a-marketing-tool/ https://venturebeat.com/2016/05/31/microsoft-bans-corporatio...
- janitor61 5y agowhat is up with those weird recipes in the third section? That's not vanilla
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jesuslop 5y agoI thought it was Second Life
- nitwit005 5y agoThey certainly used the term.
- luxuryballs 5y agothis is what I always thought when playing Minecraft, it’s not just digital legos, even pure vanilla is a living breathing world with day/night cycles, farming, etc, I use a plug-in called Multiverse to connect all of our old worlds together with the current world, so we can go back and use resources we dug up 10 years ago, and it supports a really nice live mapping plugin called dynmap, also built a “meta world” that acts as a go-between to quickly jump to specific builds across various worlds using an “iconic” chunk of the actual build converted to “meta world” materials: http://mc.legacycraft.vip:8123/?worldname=meta&mapname=surface&zoom=4&x=-262&y=64&z=-134 http://mc.legacycraft.vip:8123/?worldname=meta&mapname=surfa...
- maximaximal 5y agoVery nice setup! As a sort of informal successor to dynmap, there's now (or rather since 1.13) also BlueMap [1]. It renders the map in 3D in the browser and you can look sideways at your builds. Truly impressive. https://www.spigotmc.org/resources/bluemap.83557 https://www.spigotmc.org/resources/bluemap.83557
- prox 5y agoThe Metaverse sounds like a protocol for VR/AR worlds, but I don’t think I read there is any consortium working on such an open protocol. Unless such a protocol already exists?
- teraflop 5y agoLack of openness is a feature, not a bug.
- prox 5y agoYou mean for the companies working on metaverses?
- eganist 5y agoThis reminds me of Adobe Atmosphere (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adobe_Atmosphere https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Adobe_Atmosphere), which I greatly miss. It was a highlight of my early 2000s.
- one_off_comment 5y agoI remember that! I loved using an avatar that looked like a bush and then hiding in plain sight.
- thinkmassive 5y agoIt was called VRML[0] and was superseded by X3D[1] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VRML https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VRML [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X3D https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X3D
- prox 5y agoThe article mentions a (discontinued) 3d browser, which would be a necessity probably for any type of metaversial web.
- clpm4j 5y ago(Aware of the fact that I'm taking time out of my day to read HN) I really wonder how many adults > 25yrs and < 60yrs have the time to immerse themselves in any type of digital world / metaverse experience. If I was a teenager or in college, then yeah I can see it... but there are so many things to do in the 16hrs we have each day, and I already kick myself for not finishing that book, or getting an extra workout in, and just sitting in the backyard and resting my eyes. And I don't even have children...
- rocho 5y agoPeople already spend hours and hours per day on social media, very often just to fill time and avoid boredom. I can absolutely see the metaverse taking up some of that time.
- gauchojs 5y agoAs a parent of a 2 year old, I think I'll play again when he plays!
- nottorp 5y agoHaha guess how I got into MC. I bought it for myself about 2 years after the kid wanted it for herself.
- herval 5y agoGiven how much time everyone I interact with (and myself) spend with our heads buried on phones, mindlessly scrolling, I’d say an extremely large number of people would gladly transition to an augmented reality world, and stare at walls for an equally long amount of time
- PicassoCTs 5y agoUnless.. its super easy to convert what obsesses ones day into 3d and park it in the world. But then its just humanitys meme & memory junkyard.. kind of like a book with sad faces.
- cbhl 5y agoThe ones that I have met did so because their children were into it. An hour or two a day adds up pretty quickly if you're building
- sushsjsuauahab 5y agoThere will never be a metaverse! The amount of electricity and device manufacturing required for it to exist at scale will likely exhaust our capabilities as a planet and lead to yet more conflict and strife.
- wussboy 5y agoAnd that strife will be in the real world. The thing about “real” is that it always wins over “virtual”.
- sushsjsuauahab 5y ago100%. The virtual world is actually a very fragile thing.
- petre 5y agoJust turn off the electricity and it's gone. Imagine what a solar flare could do.
- sushsjsuauahab 5y agoElectricity, lack of physical hardware (which in turn depends on electricity, raw materials, labor, transport), lack of security... the dependencies are all entangled and circularly dependent, like Facebook's data center ;)
- jimmySixDOF 5y agoMy take is almost the complete opposite. In the Metaverse, you can spin up a office building for an unlimited number of users who can access from across the globe. Please compaire that use case, and so many more like it, to the real world alternatives in terms of resource consumption. It's an economy of infinite bits, not limited atoms.
- dragonwriter 5y ago
- Shadonototra 5y agoSorry but these "metaverse" articles are all cringe, boomers trying to regain influence they lost in the real world
- benatkin 5y agoThat's a funny spelling of "Roblox".
- zemo 5y agoall Roblox games run on servers owned by the Roblox corporation so not really. Minecraft is totally federated, anyone can create their own Minecraft server if they want to. Roblox doesn't release the server software and doesn't let you run your own server, so you can never really own your own space; they own all of the spaces.
- mfer 5y agoWho said something needs to be federated for it to be the metaverse? That's nowhere in the definition. I'd argue that scifi examples (like Ready Player One) show that it can be proprietary. I'm not saying it's good to be controlled by one org. Just that the number of orgs controlling the infra has nothing to do with being the metaverse or not.
- zemo 5y agoRaph Koster, for one. https://www.raphkoster.com/2021/09/02/online-world-or-metaverse/ https://www.raphkoster.com/2021/09/02/online-world-or-metave...
- endisneigh 5y agoWhy do people cite fictional examples as if they matter at all? Honestly wondering. It's certainly good for imagining the possibilities, but this thread is talking about something that could actually happen. Facebook itself would be a better example to your point as it's the largest social network.
- zemo 5y agoin the absence of actual examples, fiction can and sometimes does function as thought experimentation. It can be valid, although in this case, I would argue is not, because Ready Player One does not actually offer any real critique of the OASIS or of the metaverse concept generally; in the story, the OASIS is the damsel in distress, not the aggressor.
- sys_64738 5y agoIsn't the Metaverse(tm) really just 2nd Life given a second life?
- HWR_14 5y ago2nd Life is still out there. I say s someone who was invited to (and attended) a 2nd Life based event during lockdown. I also was invited to a bunch of similar virtual events on the 100 competitors that seemed to spring up.
- qaq 5y agoThe Metaverse that will make the most $ is Porn
- WorldMaker 5y agoThat is often considered the primary reason VHS beat out the arguably superior tech of Betamax: one was willing to license to porn and the other preferred not to. Definitely a lesson for any would be "metaverse" to keep in mind.
- curtain 5y agoFor me a metaverse would be a collection of objects overlayed on our physical world.
- fhinson 5y agoGrowing up for me it was Runescape.
- zemo 5y agoMinecraft is great but to my knowledge you can't make a portal in one Minecraft world to another world, you can't take an object from one Minecraft world to another world, and you can't transit from one simulation to another simulation (all Minecraft worlds run the same simulation: the Minecraft simulation). It's not really a metaverse in that it's not one connected uncoordinated space, it's many separate, instanced spaces. But it does at least let you run your own space. Valheim is more metaverse than minecraft is since you can gather resources in one Valheim server and take them to another, but there's no real security on that and there's no public history so it's not really stable; there's no notion of what's "real". Although I do agree with the framing that something being a metaverse has little to do with head-mounted displays.
- Zababa 5y agoI feel like taking an object from one simulation to another and having different simulations are oposites. Either you have the same simulations and thus objects share behavior, or the simulations are different and the objects are just 3D things.
- zemo 5y ago> taking an object from one simulation to another and having different simulations are oposites not really, we just have to get into some semiotics here and consider the difference between the signifier and the signified (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signified_and_signifier https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Signified_and_signifier). In semiotics, a signifier is a physical artifact; the manifestation of something. A physical stop sign, for example. The signified is the concept embodied by a signifier. All of the stop signs in the world correspond to (roughly) the same concept of stopping, but they are separate instances of that concept. Separate signifiers (instances of "stop sign"), all with the same thing signified (the idea that you should stop). Now in games, we have the notion of the signifier and the signified, too. Let's take an example item from WoW. I'm using this as an example because it's a game I'm familiar with. An item like Staff of Westfall (https://classic.wowhead.com/item=2042/staff-of-westfall https://classic.wowhead.com/item=2042/staff-of-westfall) expresses several things. The first thing that it expresses is that it's a weapon so it uses your weapon slot to equip it, and the stat bonus of +5 intellect that gives you additional mana and +11 spirit that gives you mana regeneration. Great, that's nice. Those things can be taken to be the content of the item: its in-simulation properties and effects. But what does the existence of this item signify? The Staff of Westfall can only be obtained by each player exactly once, cannot be traded between players, and can only be obtained by going to The Deadmines, a particular dungeon, and defeating the final boss. Equipping the Staff of Westfall has the effect that it gives you mana and mana regen, but it also communicates something non-mechanical: that the player carrying the Staff of Westfall has gone to the Deadmines and fought and beaten Edwin VanCleef. Now, can the Staff of Westfall be transferred to another simulation? Yes and no. The signifier, the physical (virtual?) staff can be transferred to another game in some sense. The 3D model can be transferred, the physical appearance of the item can be transferred. But that was always on your computer all along; it's not particularly meaningful. The effects of the item may or may not be transferable; if a game is not the exact simulation that WoW is, what does +5 intellect and +11 spirit mean? The game operator may elect to translate that to some other concept in their game, or they may not. I think this notion of "transfer" is what you're eluding to: the transfer of the signifier. This concept is probably very useless. It's also the concept that people are generally talking about when they talk about the transfer of items between games. I think it has no merit at all. But there's something else that can be transferred: the thing that ownership of the Staff of Westfall signifies: the concept that the person holding that item has slayed Edwin VanCleef (in WoW). Transferring the Staff of Westfall may not mean transferring the physical model or its attributes, but it may mean something more along the lines of transferring the meaning of what the player has accomplished. Admittedly, I'm not sure why this would be useful or what the applications of such a system would be; what I'm getting at instead is the idea that transferring an asset may mean many things, and that transferring an asset from one simulation to another is not necessarily the opposite.
- sweetbitter 5y agoYeah. The totally lawless environments that can be present in Minecraft servers are awesome- the best example of which being 2b2t, a vanilla gameserver running the same map since 2010 that is essentially the 4chan of Minecraft (it even originated there). Despite allowing users to hack to their hearts' content and having no rules, the creativity and sheer amount of media produced by such an environment is stunning. Here is a comic series that was made based on the server, and a neat video animation someone created: http://minecraft2b2t.thecomicseries.com/ http://minecraft2b2t.thecomicseries.com/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEg5UPKPY70 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEg5UPKPY70
- 1ibsq 5y ago2b2t is a fascinating place. I always thought, this is the way Minecraft is meant to be played. The comic series is legendary, but I don't think people can make something out of the animation video without context.
- nottorp 5y agoAnd that is why the "metaverse" will succeed if it's decentralized. I wouldn't touch a MC server that has no grief prevention. But you can have your 4chan and I can have my builder server and we're both happy. Because there's no central authority telling us how to run our pieces of "metaverse".
- moffkalast 5y agoMaybe someone can make the backend run on a blockchain and it's settled.
- hoseja 5y agoAnd it turns out it's been pwned for a couple years by people inserting a vulnerability into a dependency by masterful social engineering where the vuln was introduces as an obvious fix to another less exploitable bug.
- 5y ago
- 29athrowaway 5y agoSome people spent decades in Ultima Online and WOW. Ask them how that went.
- jmcgough 5y agoI've been blown away by the explosion of "urlfest" concerts teenagers have been running on Minecraft during shutdown. A ton of really good music because everyone was stuck inside and needed something to do (digicore / hyperpop blew up last year).
- Zababa 5y agoI've been saying for quite some time that the next big thing (for me) would be some kind of hybrid between a virtual coworking space, VRChat and Minecraft. I feel like being in a 3D space is a completly different experience from being on a Discord server for example. I'd love to go build a house with friends, then code a bit with them inside, and then invite a few people in.
- philjohn 5y agoWhen I started having meetings in Workrooms I was shocked by how much less fatiguing it was than a standard VC, even with the Quest hanging off my face. I also regularly sim race (1-2 hour races on iRacing) in VR and that's a much better experience as it's 3D than just starting at a screen - VR feels like it's reached that critical mass moment where it's not going to fade away as a fad.
- xboxnolifes 5y agoTo be completely honest, I don't really know what people mean when they talk about a "metaverse". But if I had to define it one way or the other, I feel like I already have, and interact with, a sort of metaverse. I play various video games with various people, talking and interacting with friends for these games on Discord, interacting with the larger community of these games on Discord/Reddit, engaging with influencer communities on Twitch/Youtube, and follow game news on Reddit/Twitter/Youtube/Forums. In the same vein, I've learned a tremendous amount about computer science, software engineering, job hunting, smaller hobbies, and plenty of other various things through the same set of things that make up my gaming metaverse (Forums/Discord/Youtube/Reddit/HackerNews/etc). It doesn't overlap with the same people I interact with for gaming, but I wouldn't expect the people to overlap much. The platforms are still the same. And it doesn't really stop there, these are just the two big things I can think of. So I guess I'm asking, what is the "Metaverse" trying to do? Take what we currently already have, but make it more cohesive? The only other thing I can think of would be a full-dive VR world experience, but I'm fairly sure we aren't even close to that.
- gremloni 5y agoThe gold standard would be the matrix but one that you’re aware you’re in and can leave at any time.
- 72deluxe 5y agoI am pretty sure that the gold standard would be real life. It doesn't require energy or batteries to just exist in real life, unlike the army of devices that will be required to support all this new tech and network infrastructure. Very odd that on one hand there is a push towards saving the Earth and the carbon crisis, and on the other hand excitement towards technology that lets everyone stick their head in the sand.
- CRConrad 5y ago> and on the other hand excitement towards technology that lets everyone stick their head in the sand. Well TBF, isn't that what culture has been for since the invention of the first song and story?
- astlouis44 5y agoNo, it is not. Neither is Roblox or Fortnite, or VRchat. A single game or world is NOT the metaverse, what is so hard to understand about that for journalists and companies? The metaverse is the immersive internet, as a successor to our current one that is more 2D oriented around photos/videos/text today. It's a paradigm shift in how we interact, but most importantly there will be many of these virtual worlds/spaces interconnected together to form an actual network that nobody outright owns. To get to this future, we need protocols/standards to allow virtual worlds to talk to one another and agree that users can hop back in forth between them seamlessly, across all platforms. More specifically, the way we use the web today to navigate from webpage to another is how we we traverse the metaverse. The core problem that needs to get solved right now is interoperability, to enable the "web of 3D". Look to WebGPU, WebAssembly, and WebXR as cornerstone technologies here. Our startup is building the "3D/VR web" in this way, and our current focus is getting proper HTML5 exporting from the native game engines, currently Unreal Engine. We're also building out a suite of tooling to empower developers and creators along with our hosting/discovery platform that includes advanced texture compression + asynchronous asset fetching to enable 3D/VR websites that load as quickly as a regular 2D page. If you're a developer and are interested in our work, you can join our Discord here: https://discord.gg/zUSZ3T8 https://discord.gg/zUSZ3T8
- one_off_comment 5y agoIf the web was created today, it would not be a set of open protocols, markup languages, etc. It would be a product. That's the world we live in, so that's why journalists and companies chase that vision. There's obviously no way to be sure, but the only reason the web was created how it was is because it was a bunch of academics, nerds, and hobbyists who saw a need and filled it. There was no perceived money in it from the private sector's point of view. Now that there's no question that there's money to be made, it's like blood in the water. And the capitalist sharks can smell it. An open standard that's given away for free isn't attractive to the people who have the means to create it.
- psyc 5y agoAnd it was a trade off. I think most of us are well acquainted with the advertised advantages of open standards and web application architecture as we know it. But it came at the expense of both user experience and developer experience on par with traditional desktop applications. E.g. arbitrary languages (esp. compiled languages), fast graphics, great UI toolkits. We get some approximation of such things at a glacial pace, or it’s always just over the horizon. Everybody is leery of adopting a comprehensive framework only backed by a single corporation (is this what held Java back?) but standards bodies take 20 years to deliver a bright idea like compiling your favorite language to byte code that can execute in the browser.
- pknerd 5y agoI have not played Minecraft, my son does but I think that Metaversa is more closer to the Matrix movie instead of Minecraft.
- polycaster 5y agoSince I watched the highlights reel mentioned in the article [1] I wonder if there exists sort of a doctrine in recent PR video production to always include a super annoying aspect of choreography to keep people from thinking too long about the actual message. Here Zuck and friends are trying neurotically to keep their fingertips at 1cm distance at any time. Waving their hands as if they were mockups. In recent Apple event recordings Tim, Craig and the gang cannot get their feet together like anatomically unchallenged humans would do when standing casually. Always more than shoulder's width apart. I've observed something similar once after a mountain biking contest, got to do something with the saddle. It's obviously not pleasing to the eye (or is it me?). But I cannot see a compelling reason and I refuse to take this as a coincidence. Why??? [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gElfIo6uw4g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gElfIo6uw4g
- nottorp 5y agoThat's why you shouldn't watch - or even listen to - someone who's trying to sell you something. You're too likely to be influenced by their acting skills. Just read the transcript or the summaries in written news.
- throwawaywindev 5y agoThey teach that stuff in business school. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cFLjudWTuGQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cFLjudWTuGQ
- VikingCoder 5y agoI want a single contiguous Minecraft world that everyone can use. Each account could get a range of blocks allocated to them, after Credit Card validation, to prove you're a real person. You could pay to own some more blocks. The blocks you get are just a land grab. You can trade blocks you own for blocks someone else owns, and there could be a monetary transaction to go with it. You can build what you want to on your blocks. How does all of this pay for itself? We set up Pay To Download blocks. If you want to fly around my creation, you can, and it just costs a little bit to do it. For the blocks I control, my Server lets me make permanent changes to those blocks. I can let other people on my Server, and I can give them permission to help me make changes to those blocks. We can make a shared Access Control List, and pool our blocks together, and edit them together. If you visit my area, you're using some Server to do it, and you can be on the same Server as your group of friends. And y'all can make a Copy-On-Write set of modifications to my blocks. And those blocks will stay, as long as your Server caches them. But no one else sees your changes. Maybe add some minor annual fee to blocks, so that if someone abandons their blocks, that they fall back to the public domain. If you want to get fancy, you allow block owners to set up royalties for visiting, and clients can set some rate limiters for how much they'll pay, and etc. I get that Minecraft itself has licensing terms that prevent us from doing this, and especially if money changes hands. I get that people build things that infringe copyright, and the only reason it's tolerated is because money isn't changing hands. I get that if someone hosts this, they'll have to deal with DMCA copyright teardown notices, and etc. And I get that it's not like the true Metaverse where you randomly bump into people you don't know, and can make permanent changes to the world together. But I just think it's bizarre that someone will make a really cool Minecraft map, and I can't explore it, even if I have money and I'm willing to pay a bit. If this whole system came with the ability to click a URL to immediately appear in some blocks? I mean, I just think that would be so cool. Okay, I saved my idea, and hopefully someone will implement something like it.
- 4ggr0 5y ago> You could pay to own some more blocks. Let's bring wealth-gaps to the metaverse, what could go wrong ;)
- 5y ago
- i_like_apis 5y agoWe will see several evolutions of the metaverse and there probably will continue to be more than one.
- recursive 5y ago> Mojang thus far hasn’t built microtransactions He must have a different Minecraft. Minecraft on xbox has a shop for skins and plugins and all kind of stuff right on the very first menu you see. It even has some kind of daily deal. It has its own funny money currency system. (Google "minecoins")
- kQq9oHeAz6wLLS 5y agoI think the author is talking about "in-world" microtransactions. The Xbox (really, Bedrock edition) marketplace exists outside of your world. You have to leave the world to go there, even though you can use items purchased there in-world.
- cesarb 5y ago> He must have a different Minecraft. Minecraft on xbox [...] Given how much he talks about custom servers and mods, yes he has a different Minecraft: he's talking about the Java edition, not the Bedrock edition which is the one which runs on the Xbox.
- recursive 5y agoAnd yet Mojang did build it.
- m3kw9 5y agoLike Web3.0 we are gonna get every shade of meaning of Metaverse shoved down our throats for the foreseeable future.
- dane-pgp 5y agoBut what if Web 3.0 is the Metaverse?
- ksaj 5y agoLast year they were trying to hype XR (eXtended Reality). I guess that didn't fly and now they're trying to see if Metaverse will interest the target market. Kids will love it for sure. It is indeed Minecraft, but with different/better graphics.
- Allower 5y agoNo. Minecraft is ugly AF, literally unplayable unless you have the mind of a toddler. Do better
- polypodiopsi 5y agoThe metaverse.. Made to make prople forget that they cant afford that resource getting scarce: space. Escaping from the narrowness of a shitty appartment into the constriction of a vrheadset... Appealing.
- justapassenger 5y agoDropbox is already here - it's rsync.
- a9h74j 5y agoDumb question: Is 'metaverse' (as Meta wants to use it) in some sense born generic in Trademark/IP terms?
- mrkramer 5y agoSo at the end of the day any virtual world is metaverse? Video games' worlds like the ones of Minecraft, Roblox, World of Warcraft etc.
- randomsearch 5y ago“What is so hard for people to understand” says HN commenter: “the metaverse clearly means [my definition of the metaverse] why can’t people see this?!!” Well, Zuckerberg didn’t give a clear definition, the term itself is made up, and it doesn’t currently exist (otherwise, what would we be building?). So no you don’t know what it means or how it will turn out, and neither does Zuckerberg. He might have a vision of what he’d like it to be and how he’s going to make money out of it, but he’s very probably very wrong. It’s obvious a deeply immersive experience will eventually arrive but it seems far from obvious how it will be used, much like predicting the rise of Tik Tok in 1990 based on email and usenet. The best way to predict the future is to make it. Hackers built much of the early internet, so let’s go build the early metaverse and at least make something insanely experimental and magical and beautiful before the next Zuckerberg comes alone and devalues it.
- micromacrofoot 5y ago>It’s obvious a deeply immersive experience will eventually arrive This is like "self driving car" obvious. It seems like we're close, but we're really really not.
- randomsearch 5y agoI think that’s a very good analogy, not least because our incremental steps to self driving cars and similar to our incremental steps towards immersion - we already have some components (parking assist, social media) but there’s still a large gap.
- tim333 5y agoThough there's no problem understanding what a self driving car should be - like an Uber but with no human driver in. The metaverse on the other hand - no one really knows.
- randomsearch 5y agoGood point! Metaphors fail so easily.
- t0mbstone 5y agometa (adjective) pertaining to or noting a story, conversation, character, etc., that consciously references or comments upon its own subject or features, often in the form of parody ------------- It's obvious to me that the real reason they called it "Meta" is because the entire goal is to collect information about YOU, the user. It's an entire platform and suite of products designed to extract as much "meta" information about its users as possible, and then monetize that information.
- Ono-Sendai 5y agoSomething with only voxels (blocks) can never be a great metaverse in my opinion. You need more general geometry - such as triangles. Have you ever tried to model a sphere or a smoothly curved surface in voxels? Allowing arbitrary triangle meshes is technically harder to implement for various reasons (more data, harder physics, harder for artists to create). But I think it's worth it. I allow arbitrary user geometry in my metaverse - https://substrata.info/ https://substrata.info/
- wellthisisgreat 5y agoHow about there is no Metaverse and never will be? There is Internet that’s good enough.
- chiefalchemist 5y agoTrue but of minor importance. The idea of a social network wasn't invented by FB, and it worked out well - so far - for it and its shareholders. The metaverse doesn't have to be Zuck's. He only needs to time the wave, with a pinch of wave self-creation obviously.
- kristopolous 5y agoFacebook is a cloner. They were first a Myspace clone. Then they invented the feed, "like" and "share" when Twitter came around with their feed, heart and retweet and "disappearing" stories when Snapchat started and then "reels" when tiktok picked up. At first Twitter didn't support images and the Facebook feed didn't either. Then Twitter did and the Facebook feed did. Whoop dee doo There's nothing mysterious about this. Just see what's popular and imagine it blue, boxy, and boring. Congratulations, that's Facebook's next feature. Even the strategy itself is just a copy of the Bill Gates playbook from the 80s and 90s. They should have renamed themselves "Derivative" instead
- short12 5y agoCool, I have now just lost the little interest I had in the metaverse because Minecraft is really stupid
- mark-r 5y agoThe only reason Minecraft doesn't have microtransactions is because they haven't gotten around to it yet. I recently interviewed for a position on the team that's going to make it happen.
- charcircuit 5y agoBedrock edition already has microtransactions. Unlike what many JE players think you can still download resource packs, skins, maps, etc off the intend instead of the marketplace.
- charcircuit 5y agoI think Minecraft is a really good influence for people wishing to build a metaverse but Minecraft is too limited and Mojang has too much control over it.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoKind of a cringe video. Zuckerberg doing a convincing impression of Data from Star Trek. It's like that episode where Data tries to understand human emotions, and only succeeds in vaguely faking a smile. Except this time he wants to build a virtual world for humans. But he doesn't understand it's limited by his android brain's concept of what humans are.
- adminscoffee 5y agoi am not interested in any of these companies bringing us the metaverse. let's do a public utility version of it then
- randomsearch 5y agoA little OT but related and want to bounce this off HN. I think we’ve reached a turning point in history and society, aided by lockdowns, where young people spend more time interacting online than IRL. This has major consequences for society and tech. Young people present themselves to the world primarily through their online persona. The physical world is secondary. To reiterate, what happens online, what is shown and seen online, is more important to them than the same in physical space. You could probably write a book about the consequences of this (maybe someone has?) but two particularly salient points: (1) if you’re not an onliner then it’s hard for you to understand how the future will look, and (2) your desires are just going to be fundamentally different from other people. I know from talking to CEOs that those entering the workforce now are most comfortable interacting through Slack and WhatsApp. Physical interactions are sometimes difficult, because people have less experience of it - usually it takes them longer to bond, and more formal social situations are challenging because they’ve not had much practice and to learn the rules governing behaviour in certain physical spaces. It’s easy for oldies to mock Zuckerberg with his embarrassing meta presentation, and indeed I think his influence is waning (because he’s also out of touch) but for sure the future is going to be driven by people who are living online. Avatars may seem like a 90s throwback but that’s just because of how we conceive of them; the truth is _we already have avatars, they’re just messy and distributed and mostly text based_. Personally I don’t like this conclusion. I think the physical world is superior in many ways, for example physical activity and exercise are fundamental to wellbeing, and I can’t see that being properly and healthily replicated in the virtual world for a very long time. I think there are more noble and worthwhile goals to be pursued in the physical world. But just because I don’t like it doesn’t mean it ain’t true. I’ve half a mind to join ‘em, half a mind to go build a log cabin.
- meheleventyone 5y agoIt’s not either or. These are complementary things. I’ve been extremely online since the mid-90s for example. There’s nothing sinister or world changing here. Online isn’t a separate universe it’s just a part of IRL.
- ZephyrBlu 5y ago
- sabujp 5y agoIf you feel handicapped now without your cell phone, just imagine what's going to happen when you lose/break your AR headset you wear everywhere (hopefully except when sleep) or when the bionic implant Elon plugged into your brain stops working. Pay up peasant.
- samsaga2 5y agoMetaverse it's only a marketing label. It has been here forever.
- axismundi 5y agoNo, it's not. Minecraft is just a single game. If you could teleport between Second Life and Minecraft, then we could start talking about multiverse.
- bullen 5y agoThe most important fact about Java Minecraft that most people are missing is that long after Notch left the company they started distributing deobfuscation maps for it: C:\Users\Username\AppData\Roaming\.minecraft\versions\1.17.1\1.17.1.json Look for: client_mappings & server_mappings https://launcher.mojang.com/v1/objects/e4d540e0cba05a6097e885dffdf363e621f87d3f/client.txt https://launcher.mojang.com/v1/objects/e4d540e0cba05a6097e88... https://launcher.mojang.com/v1/objects/f6cae1c5c1255f68ba4834b16a0da6a09621fe13/server.txt https://launcher.mojang.com/v1/objects/f6cae1c5c1255f68ba483... The tricky part is they don't provide deobfuscation tools, so everyone makes their own and it's a mess. But Minecraft is for all practical purposes open-source since 2018! Legally you cannot distribute the deobfuscated binaries, so most people map the code. I would probably use the 1.17.1 as the last "open" minecraft and start a fork that you compile and work with after deobfuscation and then re-obfuscate at each release. Dunno what the legal team at Microsoft would think about that!
- bullen 5y agoSo apparently I'm not allowed to redistribute the re-obfuscated jar but instead I need to map my changes to be compatible with the official jar. That puts a quick end to my interest in this project... But I still deobfuscated 1.14.4 and 1.17.1 and compared the file additions/removals here: http://move.rupy.se/file/diff.txt http://move.rupy.se/file/diff.txt
- Hasnep 5y agoI wouldn't say "for all practical purposes" because one of the practical parts of open source software is the open source licence. It's more like a "source available" project, and only once you've bought it which seems fair enough to me. I'm sure it makes modding much easier which I'm grateful for.
- google234123 5y ago> Dunno what the legal team at Microsoft would think about that! I’m sure they would think something like “No good deed goes unpunished.”
- VLM 5y agoThe problem with businessmen trying to make a metaverse is its got uncreative people trying to make tools for creative people, and trying to engineer unscalable and impractical cargo cult solutions. The uncreative part is best seen in how businessmen think you should buy books online by simply emulating, 3d game style, the experience of going to a shopping mall in 1980 and walking the aisles and waiting in line at Waldenbooks. The actual way books are sold online is instead of a very user unfriendly POS terminal based on a 5150 terminal connected to an AS/400, its a pretty and easy to use UI web based point of sale terminal. Essentially Amazon tricked us into doing free labor for them, being our own cashier/salespeople. Gotta admit that's more creative than "put the mall in GTA3 (Edited: more like GTA Vice City, and that was an awesome game LOL) as a map and pretend to visit the mall in 1980" like the businessmen thought online shopping would resemble. The cargo cult is the businessmen never think thru how to scale and make things work. The main reason it took until 1900 for heavier than air flight was too many of 'those guys' in charge trying to make airplanes by emulating birds. Just make a 747 by packing ground beef around glued together chicken bones and I'm sure it'll eventually fly real well, says the businessmen. Obviously one makes railroad engines by building steam powered fully articulated four legged mining donkeys. Obviously teen socializing using technology will be putting a "Mall Rats" movie map as a level in Doom. (edited: Jetson era portrayal of robot factories, lol.) Meanwhile I lived thru the 90s 00s where the legacy media, which is finally near dead, decided everything internet and VR was actually bad special effects as an analogy for a LSD trip. Why bother with actually "doing VR" if you could replace all the hardware in a video game console with a acid tab dispenser. I mean, they're not wrong in a sense, but only Hollywood people would have expected/demanded that everyone wants to be high all the time.
- HeavyStorm 5y agoOr it's second life. Or gta. Or any number of games out there that allow for user to create content.
- corndoge 5y agoNo, it's VRChat
- akacia 5y agoPeople have too much of dopamine rush from the ordinary social media to get engaged in such complex projects. Second Life was an expection created in times where there was no social media and people were looking for alternative ways to pass time and were willing to invest their time in learning how to use Second Life (it is a quite complex creation tool and game client at the same time).
- akacia 5y agoWhat Second Life is missing is the decentralization and newer graphic/scripting engine. Creator of Second Life already tried to create VR metaverse with those issues solved and it didn't catch on.
- hypertele-Xii 5y agoNo, it isn't.