22 ms·
This is good. The backing of stablecoins is a very real issue. As the Treasury points out, there's a very real possibility of a run. Two stablecoins have crashe
by Animats 5y ago
This is good. The backing of stablecoins is a very real issue. As the Treasury points out, there's a very real possibility of a run. Two stablecoins have crashed so far, SafeDollar SDO, and $TITAN. They went all the way to zero.
Can Tether survive a net outflow? Probably not. They don't have the collateral.
Dai is really a derivative of Etherium. Dai is backed by Etherium at 150%. So
value in Dai is at risk if the price of Etherium drops more than 1/3. Etherium dropped by half back in May 2021, but recovered. DAI could have crashed at that time if it faced a net outflow. It didn't, though.
The real question is what happens in the next recession.
- dustingetz 5y agoRisk is that a tether run causes all of crypto to collapse, not just USDT. How many actual dollars are in the system? Everything real has been exfiltrated through electricity bills, taxes and early adopters selling, the entire crypto economy is a hollow shell, leveraged on retail deposits.
- wpietri 5y agoExactly. Ultimately cryptocurrencies are a negative-sum game in that they take in real money and just move that money around, while spending some on overhead. In contrast, imagine investing in, say, a new fast-food franchise joint. They money you put in there is used to acquire assets that are used to produce goods that people will pay to consume. If it's a well-run business, the value of the outputs will be more than the value of the inputs, making it a positive-sum effort.
- wyager 5y agoThe positive externalities from sound money and the concomitant demonetization of other assets (like real estate, oil, etc.) are massive, especially in the long term.
- arcticbull 5y agoReal estate and oil are not money and therefore cannot be demonetized. One is a productive asset, the other a commodity. Words have meaning.
- wyager 5y ago> Words have meaning. Have you considered that you may simply be failing to comprehend the meaning? In particular, "monetization" literally means "the process of turning into money" - one of several more specific meanings, which should be clear from context, is the conversion of a non-monetized asset with sufficient monetary properties into a monetized asset. A monetized asset (not monetary - that term is too overloaded, although "monetized" isn't much better) is precisely an asset which has a higher value than would be predicted from its expected revenues, commodity consumption value, etc. If people are concerned about currency devaluation, where do they put their money? Whatever set of assets people turn to (equities, commodities, whatever) will be subject to additional demand purely qua wealth storage, pushing up the price of those assets beyond what you would expect from a pure discounted cash flow model - i.e. they become monetized (begin to function as money, in addition to whatever asset class one might naively assign them to). So, with that in mind, let's address: > Real estate and oil are not money and therefore cannot be demonetized If people are using real estate, oil, (gold, equities, ...) as a place to stash their wealth to protect it from inflation or whatever, and all of a sudden there's a better option available for this purpose, demand for random "not money" assets qua money is going to drop, and they will cease to behave like money - demonetization.
- trophycase 5y agoHumanity is just a negative sum game in that we take in real resources and just move those resources around and then die, all while increasing entropy of the universe.
- samtheprogram 5y agoThat would be true if the human population didn’t consistently increase over time; but it has.
- jafo 5y ago> They money you put in there is used to acquire assets that are used to produce goods that people will pay to consume Is a decentralized, public ledger not a good people will pay (via cryptocurrency) to consume?
- TomSwirly 5y agoFor what specific purpose?
- drdeca 5y agoThere were timestamping services which people paid for before bitcoin. So, there is some price people will pay in order to be able to demonstrate in the future that some data existed at or before a given time. A decentralized ledger also provides this purpose. Of course, at current transaction fees on most blockchains, it would be wasting quite a bit of money to make a transaction just to timestamp a single thing. This is why there are services (one of which, iirc, has gotten a, uh, endowment(?) in order to provide the service for free?) which collect large quantities of (hashes of) data that people want to establish existed before a given time, and produce a Merkle tree of all of that, so that all those people can demonstrate that their data existed before a given time. So, that's one useful service. Is it enough to justify all the stuff that goes into blockchain stuff? That's a different question. But, if the question is "Do they have any genuine use?", the answer is "yes." .
- arcticbull 5y agoThe blockchain is a pretty terrible timestamping service as the block time varies based on the current hash rate and difficulty. From as little as 5.5 minutes to as much as 15 minutes. [1] It's at best a coal-powered monotonic counter. Given the massive variability you have to correlate it with an actual clock you trust lol, and if you trust the clock you may as well just use that. [1] https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-confirmationtime.html#3y https://bitinfocharts.com/comparison/bitcoin-confirmationtim...
- 5y ago
- mattnewton 5y agoI'm a crypto bear myself, but I'm not sure I agree with this argument. Plenty of services are built around "just moving money around" - accounting in this way has a ton of real value or else stripe, visa, paypal etc wouldn't be the huge companies they are. The questions are, whether "investing" by buying and holding is the right way to capture the value that this produces, and whether the benefits of doing it on a distributed blockchain outweigh the costs.
- BoiledCabbage 5y agovisa, paypal... all provide value in allowing commercial transitions. Exchange of goods and services, digitally or on credit. The value it is providing is eliminating the inefficiency of barter (which cash also does), and allowing remote digital transactions, again good for societal benefit. There is no societal benefit to buying, holding, selling a crypto currency. The thing that could provide societal value is smart contracts - but that has nothing to do with crypto. Visa (or Stripe) could implement smart contracts in javascript on top of their platform and society gets pretty much all of the benefits without needing any of the crypto.
- swader999 5y agoThere is value in having a monetary system though. And if BTC is a better system and more people find it's utility for barter or wealth preservation better it might appreciate more in relation to something like the USD which has many different characteristics.
- arcticbull 5y agoIt's a strictly worse monetary system by any measure. It's massively more expensive to transact, it's unbelievably inefficient - requiring as much power as Thailand and generating as much e-waste as the Netherlands to scribble 2-3 tx/sec into a ledger. That's 60 days of power for the average US household and 1 iPad of e-waste per transaction. [1] [edit](97% of all mining hardware will be thrown away without ever winning a single block reward). If adopted as an actual currency it would immediately lead to a deflationary spiral savaging the job market. [2] Even the dictator of El Salvador wasn't nuts enough to adopt it as an actual currency. All pricing continues to be in USD and exchanged for BTC at the point of sale - and the point of a gun. (Keep in mind legal tender laws in ES require everyone to accept your Bitcoin for purchases or you face criminal charges). To call it wholly unfit for any purpose except exchanging for black tar heroin would be an understatement. [1] https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption https://digiconomist.net/bitcoin-energy-consumption [2] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/deflationary-spiral.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/deflationary-spiral.asp
- swader999 5y agoYou could make the same claim about any kind of money though. Whose to say the USD or GOLD or CAD or tree bark is real money? A productive asset is an entirely different thing. It's not easy to convert an asset for instance or walk across a border with it. People make the fundamental mistake thinking these things are investments, they aren't, it's just currency or forex speculation that we are doing here.
- adamc 5y agoIn the case of the USD, the existence of a powerful government with a variety of powers (including coercive ones). Nothing is guaranteed in life, but it is orders of magnitude different from a digital currency offered by private individuals.
- swader999 5y agoSure and I agree the USD at the moment has an incredible backing. Also it being the reserve currency and base for most other currencies and commodities is no small thing. You could argue that BTC is backed by one of the most powerful networks of computing power on the planet. I don't think that's better than what the USD has, but it isn't 'Nothing'. The fact it can't be debased as easily as fiat currencies is not a tangible thing but it does compel interest in it.
- arcticbull 5y agoIts network doesn't create value, it extracts value. $60M per day, $21B per year. > The fact it can't be debased as easily as fiat currencies is not a tangible thing but it does compel interest in it. That is not a benefit to a currency, quite the opposite. A deflationary currency would likely lead to a deflationary spiral, savaging the job market [1] It also leads to a monetary system that cannot adjust to a changing population or to transient issues such as COVID. If BTC were the currency of record in 2020, the economy would likely have been utterly devastated. [1] https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/deflationary-spiral.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/d/deflationary-spiral.asp
- scrubs 5y agoAgree! If there was no way for ppl playing in crypto to get their hands on bonafide fiat currency, I don't think anybody would really care about crypto. Remember the Gemini exchange adds looking for qualified investors? Why? because such people have US dollars, which is what Gemini wants to bank.
- swader999 5y agoRight now that's the case but there's no guarantee any currency will always remain the one of choice. And BTC doesn't need exchanges, but of course it does help, especially in the early stages.
- headsoup 5y agoAre we still in 'the early stages?' We seem to always be in the early stages of blockchain/bitcoin.
- robocat 5y ago> imagine investing in, say, a new fast-food franchise joint Let us imagine instead that you want to invest in Burger King. You buy some shares in Restaurant Brands International (QSR). When you own those shares, what does that actually mean - how is that connected to the purchase of burgers? I think share ownership is often a better metaphor for many cryptocurrencies than fiat currency. Especially when considering shares like Tesla, Hertz, or GameStop. Where does the value of a share come from? Can a company steal all your money? What actually records your share ownership? How are profits calculated, and how do you get them?
- giaour 5y agoAs an unaccredited investor, your investment funds can only be accepted by publicly traded corporations (with all the legal protections and reporting requirements that entails). Investing in GameStop is definitely riskier than putting your money in a savings account, but fraud is substantially easier in a totally anonymous and unregulated market like the crypto sector. I mean, just think about how hard the Enron execs had to work to defraud their investors! They had to come up with a novel scheme to hide losses, collude with their accountants to avoid detection, and some of them even had to spend some time in prison. Yesterday, I read about an NFT scam where the anonymous developer just transferred funds to his personal wallet and then disappeared.
- wpietri 5y agoThe value of a share typically comes from the productive assets the company owns. If you buy all 468 million shares of QSR, you get all the restaurants, the brands, the vendor relationships, the employee relationships, the customer relationships. If you have a smaller fraction, you have a smaller fraction of that, plus you are entitled to a share of the profits generated. But if you buy a Bitcoin, you own no productive asset and therefore are entitled to no profits. At one point the theory was you could trade it for something useful, like other currencies. But it's a pretty bad currency, so people mostly have stopped pretending it is useful for that. There are answers to the rest of your questions, which are complicated and depend on exchange and jurisdiction, but people can look up the details if they want.
- nl 5y ago> Ultimately cryptocurrencies are a negative-sum game in that they take in real money and just move that money around, while spending some on overhead. I'm no Crypto fan, but this is wrong. Plenty of new coins get minted which are redeemed for real money. This is basically the credit creation cycle[1] as seen in traditional banking (where banks create money by lending the same deposit out multiple times simultaneously) except in this case there is often no equivalent of a deposit (except sort-of staking in some cases). [1] https://www.economicsnetwork.ac.uk/archive/starkey_banking https://www.economicsnetwork.ac.uk/archive/starkey_banking
- brightball 5y agoI always love looking at “market cap” for these things. As if every coin there could actually be sold for the price listed making it worth hypothetical billions. Even a small cash out will cut the value to pieces.
- swader999 5y agoThat's the same with many markets though. Market cap is a pretty silly metric to use for almost any market.
- habitue 5y agoIt's a useful metric in one particular case, which is if you're looking to buy out the stock
- swader999 5y agoIt depends on the stock and what each individual holder is prepared to sell for. So it's exactly the same. In a corporate buyout the individual sellers typically agree on a sale price, but that's a contract on top of the market. Without that in play you'd be subject to the same unknowns and market cap wouldn't guarantee any buyout price. Hostile takeover is one example.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mminer237 5y agoFor stocks though the market cap is judged against earnings typically. The price can never get too low or the shareholders can just force a dividend to make the money directly from the underlying equity.
- bduerst 5y agoMarket cap for publicly traded corporations is still a good measure of value since there are laws, regulations, public disclosures, etc. ensuring they're equally measured to a degree. If I paid $50000 for a cowry shell and said the market cap of cowry shells is more than MasterCard then there's a few problems...
- vineyardmike 5y agoI want to preface this by saying I don't own crypto and I think its often full of scams (eg. squid coin). But it has some real potential and isn't always as bad as it seems. Tether is a real risk, I agree. > Everything real has been exfiltrated through electricity bills, taxes and early adopters selling, the entire crypto economy is a hollow shell, leveraged on retail deposits. Yeah, but that's not untrue for banks. Conceptually, a bank's job is to store money for depositors. That has a real cost, so theoretically you should have to pay for banking service. We know that banks make that money back from lending the money with interest (profiting off interest). This lending behavior is theoretically possible for individuals to do while skipping banks, but it is not practical at scale. So, basically depositors "pay" with opportunity cost - and since the world fiat currencies have inflation, this is essentially paying the devalued difference of money. Crypto is similar... it costs real money to maintain the deposits - aka POW to secure the ledger. Instead of lenders' interest paying the cost, it is paid by deflation by depositor by more currency being circulated. Not too different than fiat-at-banks. Crypto also is potentially more egalitarian since anyone can mine (at a small scale at least) to potentially make some small income, and certain complex financial actions can be done for "free-ish" in contracts (conditional swaps/lending, escrow, multi-sig transactions).
- bubbleRefuge 5y agoBanks do not lend deposits in fiat currency regimes such as the ones most western countries have. Banks create deposits out of thin air to 'fund' loans. The have capital and reserve requirements to meet, of coarse, but they do not lend out deposits or depend on deposits for lending.
- fnord77 5y agoso basically crypto is deflationary?
- viraptor 5y agoThis is a possibility of course, but the second claim is something that would really need some proof. It's sure fun to say, but did you calculate it or do you just want it to be true?
- dragontamer 5y ago> The real question is what happens in the next recession. Well, there was a recession just last year and the stock market / BTC market went crazy. The real question is what happens in the next market downturn (specifically the cryptocoin market downturn, since these "stablecoins" look like they're "stable" only because of assumptions underlying the cryptocoin markets). The cryptocoin markets don't necessarily match up with the general economy.
- nwiswell 5y ago> Well, there was a recession just last year and the stock market / BTC market went crazy. Ultimately this is because central banks are in the driver's seat for asset prices these days. It's been trending that way since the Greenspan Put in the 90's. The economic fundamentals matter, but not as much as the monetary policy backdrop; after all, if there's more cash chasing the same number of shares, it can't help but drive up stock prices. Similarly, low borrowing rates reduce the equity risk premium, drive up growth valuations, etc. So really, the real test for crypto is when the monetary policy regime shifts. But to be honest with you, I don't see that happening. Maybe inflation finally forces the issue -- but then there's the fact that inflation will drive flight to alternative assets anyway.
- bubbleRefuge 5y agoActually, it was fiscal policy which dropped money from helicopters in the form of pandemic assistance of all kinds including small business loans that will never be paid back again. In the 2007 financial crisis, the federal government bailed out banks and big finance ( see AIG). This time it was businesses and consumers who were bailed out. Allot of that money went into crypto and stocks.
- sumedh 5y ago> the stock market / BTC market went crazy. Probably because the govt/Fed is printing more money.
- hanniabu 5y ago> what happens in the next market downturn It's happened a few times before and they're fine
- deafcalculus 5y agoYou mean what happens when economy does well enough that it starts overheating which forces an exit from the liquidity trap and turns real interest rates positive? I guess we'll find out soon.
- bradly 5y agoIs Dai similar to Gemini's GUSD stable coin? It too is backed by Etherium. I think Gemini is paying 8 or 9% APR for holding. Where is that money coming from? Are they loaning out for a higher rate than that?
- rabbitonrails 5y agoIf you are referring to Gemini Earn, they take your GUSD (or other currency) and take a spread then lend it to Genesis, who takes a spread and then lends it to big institutions. None of this is insured. https://support.gemini.com/hc/en-us/articles/360056367771-Are-the-Crypto-Moved-to-Earn-Insured- https://support.gemini.com/hc/en-us/articles/360056367771-Ar...
- Zamicol 5y agoMaker Dai is nothing like GUSD. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dai_(cryptocurrency) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dai_(cryptocurrency) >Dai is a stablecoin cryptocurrency which aims to keep its value as close to one United States dollar (USD) as possible through an automated system of smart contracts on the Ethereum blockchain. [...] Dai is created from an overcollateralized loan[.]
- swader999 5y agoAmpleforth is the most interesting 'stable coin' I've seen.
- adultorata 5y agoI agree on this, although ampleforth is not specifically a stablecoin, but nonetheless it's one of the most interesting economic experiments I've witnessed since bitcoin, a true Hayek money had never been possible before in humanity, thanks to chainlink a currency that even Satoshi Nakamoto dreamed of is now possible
- swader999 5y agoYeah you aren't understating it either. I get so excited by it that I have a hard time not sounding like a shill.
- agotterer 5y agoThis is why I'm excited about Djed (https://djed.xyz https://djed.xyz). Input Output Global (creator of Cardano) has been researching stable coins and drafted a pretty extensive white paper on their solution (https://eprint.iacr.org/2021/1069.pdf https://eprint.iacr.org/2021/1069.pdf). The white paper also include a mentions for how they will prevent bank runs.
- andred14 5y agoDjed is garbage Coti, Cardano and friends are all about CBDCs, KYC and tracking people. No thanks.
- tick_tock_tick 5y ago> Input Output Global (creator of Cardano) I worry there target release date of 2042 seems extremely aggressive for them based on past performance and some of there research might not be relevant by the time it comes out.
- tome 5y ago2042? Perhaps 2024?
- JumpCrisscross 5y agoOne of the problems this class of mechanisms runs into, in the real world, is that--particularly in times of crisis--liquidity and prices are discontinuous. Djed doesn't seem to be vulnerable to the former. (Reserve coin holders transparently give up liquidity for their yield. Though, as the paper admits, reserve coin holders are subject to run mechanics.) It would be to the latter. Still, fascinating stuff.
- fMwhy 5y agoI read the first two sentences and immediately pondered "so how could one profit if they knew which volatile coin the bank kept as it's reserve?"
- yokem55 5y ago150% is the minimum amount of collateral. If the USD value of your locked eth falls below that 150% threshold relative to your DAI denominated debt, a liquidator will pay off your debt and take your collateral. So, a conservatively managed Maker CDP's regularly are collateralized to the tune of 300% if not more.
- Zamicol 5y agoCurrently the whole Dai system is 215% collateralized. There's about $8 billion on loan and $17 billion in assets locked in the system. https://daistats.com/ https://daistats.com/
- andred14 5y agoYou are out of it when has the government actually something good for you? It should be obvious now, with thousands dead from the 1nject1ons and no end in sight: All your leaders want is to hurt and control you. If used properly, ie. use Monero and other private solutions, cryptocurrencies can provide us with freedom but if we allow the government to force THEIR crypto verions down our throats then freedom as we knew it will truly be over for us.
- CryptoPunk 5y agoFYI, this individual has been deliberately misspelling Ethereum for 5+ years on Hackernews, as a form of mockery: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9988438 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9988438
- Rexxar 5y agoIt seems just to be a very common misspelling : https://hn.algolia.com/?q=Etherium https://hn.algolia.com/?q=Etherium
- CryptoPunk 5y agoHe's had numerous discussions on the subject, and has been corrected before, including by yours truly. I think it's intentional.
- Lordarminius 5y agoHe can have fun remaining poor.
- trophycase 5y agoActually a huge fraction of DAI is backed by USDC and other assets.
- Scott_Sanderson 5y agoCorrect, OP seems to be referring to single-collateral DAI aka SAI, which is deprecated. The current DAI is backed by a basket of assets. IMO, the basket is too heavily weighted towards centralized stablecoins like USDC. I rotated some of my MKR holdings to Terra/Luna, which may have a better peg mechanism (although it is similar to Titan, which exploded).
- Maximus9000 5y ago> I rotated some of my MKR holdings to Terra/Luna, which may have a better peg mechanism Me too!
- chizhik-pyzhik 5y ago> Dai is really a derivative of Etherium. Dai is backed by Etherium at 150%. So value in Dai is at risk if the price of Etherium drops more than 1/3. Etherium dropped by half back in May 2021, but recovered. DAI could have crashed at that time if it faced a net outflow. It didn't, though. DAI didn't collapse because the drop in Ethereum value wasn't sudden. As the price falls, bots are allowed to liquidate your debt and keep the overall collateral ratio healthy.
- lamontcg 5y agoTether can survive a net outflow because Tethers aren't redeemable in that way. If you show up with 1M USDT, they won't give you $1M USD. It'll have to collapse on exchanges with more sellers than buyers, and to determine how that happens you need to actually understand what specific mechanism underlies how the peg is maintained. I suspect Tether is all crypto-backed debt issuance which is denominated in real $USD which gives the counterparty incentive to maintain the peg on exchanges. It'll likely fall apart when crypto falls apart and exchanges have already failed and those counterparties have already gone broke. Tether imploding will probably come after crypto is in the middle of a collapse and be more of a symptom and an accelerant. I doubt that Tether detonating will be the first sign of trouble.
- paulgb 5y ago> Tether can survive a net outflow because Tethers aren't redeemable in that way I think it's worth distinguishing here between Tether the company and Tether the coin. Tether the company isn't automatically destroyed by a net outflow for the reasons you mention, but if they are indeed not fully backed, a net outflow could certainly break the peg and kill the coin as we know it.
- BoiledCabbage 5y agoTether will collapse the same way that Squid Game Coin collapsed - extremely quickly. Assuming a power distribution of coins across accounts, it's likely that 99% of tether accounts don't meet the 100,000 $USDT threshold to cash out. If you have a coin, where 99% of people/accounts aren't allowed to cash out that reeks of scam. You can come up with tons of smoke to disguise it, and the whole "well you have to sell on another exchange, but prices there will be propped up due to 'arbitrage'" disguises and delays things nicely. But fundamentally it is propped up because people can't get out directly. There is no fair price discovery right now on Tether w.r.t. USD.
- Tenoke 5y agoI've cashed out way less USDT, just not through Tether themselves. Comparing it to Squid Game which you can't even sell to others is ridiculous.
- webinvest 5y agoIt’s spelled Ethereum…
- zzleeper 5y agoIs there a way to find out what was the market cap of those two? Searched coingecko and a few other places and came empty handed (they just list "price" but no historical market cap or outstanding coins)
- anonporridge 5y agoCurrently $70 billion Tether, https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/tether/?period=7d https://coinmarketcap.com/currencies/tether/?period=7d
- X6S1x6Okd1st 5y agoI thought dai would continuously be bought and used to liquidate positions as the price drops. I.e. if someone mints 100 dai with 150 worth of ETH and the price of ETH drops then anyone can acquire dai and use that dai to access the collateral. Through that mechanism the supply of dai should contract not the spot price. The bigger worry is that they allow minting Dai from USDC which could freeze their assets
- RustyConsul 5y agoThe thing that is working slightly in the background to ensure net outflows don't happen is during time of downward volatility, stablecoins is what the prudent crypto investor is transitioning into and stores his wealth until they are ready to buy again.
- zabatuvajdka 5y agoIf a recession is bad enough some will panic and pull it all out. The reality is that crypto is not essential—it’s convenient and has potential but it’s value is backed by what? Other financial assets are backed by stuff like voting rights in a company or a physical asset. Hence: people will dump crypto first. I suppose Ethereum is different because it is backed by the functionality provided by the distributed Turing machine and all applications which rely on that. So the folks who wouldn’t pull their money out would be product owners who rely on the blockchain as a revenue stream. My question would be who holds the price up high? Institutions or the broader public holdings of ETH?
- WhisperingShiba 5y agoMoney is not essential either, mind you. Oxygen, heat, water, food. In that order. At least crypto is 'backed' by math. I expect the currency to dump will be related to who, and not what, is backing each asset class.
- unicornmama 5y agoWhat real world applications rely on ETH? All I see are apps that operate in the crypto space playing finance games with cryptocurrencies.
- delaaxe 5y agoWait till DAI gets backed by real estate bonds.
- Stevvo 5y agoFor some time now DAI has been backed by a basket of coins precisely to mitigate the risk of one coin dropping.
- AlexandrB 5y agoBut many coins seem to move in concert (just based on casual observation). Additionally diversifying in traditional equities has the benefit of being exposed to multiple industries - lets say farms and chip manufacturers - that don't depend on the same commodities as inputs and don't sell products into the same markets. Crypto doesn't have this property - besides requiring an input of energy, they're not involved in any kind of production at all. So what does diversifying even mean for that kind of asset? In a recession, why would there be any reason to think that ETH would behave differently than BTC?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- arcticbull 5y ago> Can Tether survive a net outflow? Probably not. They don't have the collateral. Luckily for Paolo & friends, their terms of service clearly state that they do not ever have to offer redemptions of USDT for dollars. Or even whatever IOUs and bits of string they may or may not have in reserve. Out of all the stable coins its the most likely to withstand a "run" because they do not have to pay you if you ask. In fact if you're a US person, you're not eligible at all. If you're not a US person, it's at their discretion to deem you a "customer." Even if they do that, they can delay your withdrawal arbitrarily. Even if they don't do that, they can pay you out with whatever is actually in their backing. [1] What would get destroyed in a run is every other crypto, as folks desperately try and exchange their USDT for something they can sell at a fiat-backed exchange. The Crypto-USDT pairs will quickly go no-bid, and as people rush for the narrow exits at fiat exchanges, prices will plummet. [1] tether.to/legal
- roywiggins 5y agoI don't get it. If everyone starts selling their Tether (because they're afraid of it not being able to maintain the peg), even if they can't sell the Tether back to the company, won't that crater the Tether price- possibly to zero- effectively killing the currency? Like, this happens with currencies that are pegged to the dollar. The government that's supposed to be maintaining the peg starts to run out of dollars and starts limiting dollar redemptions. People turn to the black market to obtain dollars. The price of a dollar (in that currency) goes up. The value of the currency (again in dollars) drops. Now the peg is broken. Tether the company could walk into the sunset with whatever they're holding- they can just honor "friends and family" withdrawals, but that doesn't prevent the coin going to zero for everyone else. It actually makes it even worse for the currency: suppose it's collateralized at 50%. Tether could honor withdrawals at 50 cents on the dollar, force every holder to take a 50% haircut. The price might settle to something less than $1 but more than $0 and continue on. But if they abscond with the money instead, the currency will have even more reason to drop to nil.
- potatolicious 5y agoExactly this - the idea that Tether not being legally obligated to let you cash out USD somehow being a shield against a run seems ridiculous. Being unable to redeem your USDT for dollars - regardless of reason (because Tether is out of money or Tether is refusing) - is what causes the run and the crash. An entity that is holding a bunch of cash but refusing to honor IOUs it has issued will find that the value of those IOUs will rapidly approach zero. Permanently. Even if it laters starts honoring those IOUs, the IOUs have lost their utility forever and the price will remain at/near zero.
- stepanhruda 5y agoThere is a very important aspect of opposite pressure. If DAI price ever loses peg and goes to eg 0.90 anyone with open positions immediately starts buying a shitton of them and closing their position, because they just got a 10% discount on paying off their debt, sending the peg back. If the price ever goes to 1.10, anyone with free capital around immediately starts minting new coins and floods the market with them, because they just got an instant 10% bump on the size of minted capital, sending the peg back.
- thehappypm 5y agoThat’s true if there’s faith it comes back up from $.90. If it starts falling to $.99 then $.98 then $.95 then $.90.. you have to decide if it’s really a dip or the end.
- hjorthjort 5y agoNot really. The point is: there's always someone who has a debt in DAI they need to pay off. If they thought the dip would go even further , they would wait longer, because to them, the DAI does have value: it is what they need to get their hands on to get their collateral back.
- thehappypm 5y agoWhat if they think DAI is going to go to $0?
- darcys22 5y agoThen they would be able to get their ethereum collateral back for free
- stepanhruda 5y agoSure, if more people who hold DAI thought it would than it wouldn’t, it would be a problem. At this point there are so many arbitrage bots and protocols on top that it won’t even budge to 0.95 though, because this incentive balance has proven to be solid. The main downside really is that it’s overcollateralized by assets in 2x or so value.
- nradov 5y agoIf there's a run on a stable coin then so what? Systematically important financial institutions don't have very much exposure so there wouldn't be a significant impact on the real economy.
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoI hate to be pedantic, but you aren’t spelling Ethereum right.
- np_tedious 5y agoTitan/Iron is (was?) an algorithmic undercollateralized stablecoin pair. Iron was the $1 one actually. This is not a meaningful comparison to fully collateralized coins like USDC or Tether. They may have their own issues, but the certainly don't have Iron's
- nanexcool 5y agoYou misspelled Ethereum 4 times. Dai is now backed by a lot more tokens than just Ether, and 150% is really the minimum to avoid liquidation (145% now). https://daistats.com https://daistats.com
- FatalLogic 5y agoAnd as well as those errors: OP doesn't realize that DAI has sailed through falls in ETH value of far more than 50% (I think the worst was over 90% in 2018) OP, despite his obvious great intelligence, doesn't realize that another, stronger question about DAI would be the potentially-worrying linkage to USDC etc to provide stability (though critics should note that even before that stability module, PSM, was introduced it had never deviated by more than 1%, AFAIK) Seeing that this is, despite all those errors and omissions, the top comment here, is extremely dispiriting
- hparadiz 5y agoWhat you described is the opposite of "stable" so I'm highly concerned by the terminology being used here.
- cs702 5y agoI agree, with one caveat. There's always a chance that the organizations issuing these "stablecoins" pull off something analogous to what Nixon did when he ended the convertibility of the US Dollar into gold, making it impossible, in fact illegal, for anyone to call up the US Treasury and request that they exchange a bunch of dollars with gold from Fort Knox.[a] Many so-called "gold bugs" and "Austrian School economists" predicted the transition to a non-convertible dollar would surely lead to monetary and economic disaster... but so far, they've been wrong: Things have actually worked remarkably well for half a century. Could Bitfinex pull off something like that? I'm not sure, but I wouldn't rule it out 100%. [a] https://www.federalreservehistory.org/essays/gold-convertibility-ends https://www.federalreservehistory.org/essays/gold-convertibi...
- ElderMillennial 5y agoCitation needed. The last 40 years have been a period of high inflation, shrinking (real) wages, and "shrinkflation" losses in quality of life. One could argue that this has happened precisely because financial institutions can invent "wealth" independent of creating things with intrinsic value through labor/industry -- leaving an unproductive segment of society nominally wealthy by fabricating dollars for themselves. For example, in the past two years, "elites" have handed themselves trillions in fabricated dollars. Something that couldn't happen, if dollars were gold backed.
- panarky 5y agoHow much trust should we place in crypto analysis from someone who cannot spell "Ethereum"?
- MuffinFlavored 5y agoHow does Tether make money/profit?
- EGreg 5y agoI used to think it was backed by Ethereum and overcollateralized with oracles. But now I hear it’s backed by USDC … LOL I kind of preferred the algorithmix approach !
- josefrichter 5y agoJust a correction: there have been far more stable coin crashes, there was a time not so long ago when every week one of them crashed. There’s dozens, or more likely hundreds, of stablecoins out there.
- ButtSpark69 5y agoSurvived the 90%+ drop about 4 years ago. I don't know if it's backed or not, but it means something.
- bradwood 5y ago> The real question is what happens in the next recession A massive inflow of capital to crypto, bitcoin in particular.
- sizzle 5y agoThoughts on UST and USDC?
- neals 5y agoDAI is backed by vaults of various crypto assets. Because there already was a crunch of DAI a few years ago, the USDC was added to the mix. A fiat collaterized stablecoin.
- jules-jules 5y agoIt's Ethereum with an 'e' my friend.
- eru 5y ago'Backing' via reserves doesn't actually matter much in practice. What you want is a thick equity cushion.