17 ms·
Wacom drawing tablets track the name of every application that you open
- codedokode 5y agoThere is a myth that if you are a paying customer then you are not a product. As we see, for more and more companies like Wacom, Microsoft or Apple you are a product no matter if you pay or not. Have some self respect and vote with your wallet against such companies.
- Someone 5y agoI thought the phrase was that, if you’re not paying, you’re the product. “If you’re paying, you’re not the product” doesn’t follow from that.
- redwall_hp 5y agoIt's not true anyway, because of FOSS. There are also services that exist to provide a social good without a profit motive; that's why nonprofit designations exist. That phrase has always seemed like an overly cynical take that normalizes antisocial/exploitive behavior by setting an expectation that free services should exploit the user in the first place.
- woolion 5y agoSo is it "with proprietary software you're always the product, but some offer you to pay for the privilege"?
- LdSGSgvupDV 5y agop->q != ~p->~-q p->q = ~pvq So, you are a product. No matter you are paying or not.
- na85 5y agoDo Wacom tablets have any relevant competition? I have one that I use for hobbyist purposes and when it comes time to upgrade I'd be interested in not buying another Wacom.
- bogwog 5y agoHuions are pretty great. Very affordable and very high quality. I'm guessing the premium you pay for Wacom has more to do with the brand name than the actual product. I'm not a professional artist though, so maybe Huions are bad for pro work. Idk, but I'm happy with my Huion.
- thejohnconway 5y agoI guess the question is, what data does Huion’s software send back?
- woolion 5y agoI spent a few years with a Huion screen tablet (GT-19 series), but pressure sensitivity response was really bad compared to a Cintiq. However we are comparing a 400€ product to one that is about 3K€; second-hand it can trade for under 1K, and then it is a reasonable alternative. With a Huion 1060+ the pressure response felt amazing; however that was on Windows, I never got it to work under Linux. For a hobbyist it is a really much better choice than the cheap Wacom (e.g. Bamboo line), because it is important to have a big drawing area, so that you can draw from your elbow and not from your wrist.
- m4rtink 5y agoAFAIK Wacom drivers on Linux are good & upstream. The various Chinese tablets are much more involved to get running on Linux, if possible at all. Also, being fully open source I don't think the Linux Wacom drivers do any of the shady stuff the Windows ones apparently do.
- woolion 5y agoI only use Linux and indeed, drivers work OOtB and don't require you to sign any privacy policy. Although you don't have the fancy GUI that they have on Windows. The Huion GT works OOtB with the Wacom drivers. For the 1060+, I tried all the out-of-tree drivers without any luck, but that was about 3 years ago. https://digimend.github.io/drivers/digimend/tablets/ https://digimend.github.io/drivers/digimend/tablets/ (support was added in 2018, so now it probably works after minimal work)
- 4903000 5y agoIf you're a product, then there is simply a bigger paying customer. Companies are ever tending towards surveillance capitalism because the profit the marketplace for personal information provides them potentially far outweighs the profits of mere direct sales. Withdrawing your business from such a company will achieve very little so long as they still have some user data in the bank. Participating in surveillance capitalism provides a great competitive edge at first, but the race to the bottom makes it a necessary component of conducting business. If Wacom simply needs to sell customers' session data to stay afloat, a not-wacom that expressly refuses to do the same probably won't stay in business for long on just sales. They would need some other revenue source, in crowdfunding, venture capital, SaaS, advertisements, a corporate buyout, government or military contract, renting and franchising, anything. Save for crowdfunding, these kinds of alternate revenue sources serve to tap into the lion's share of currency consumers don't hold. Incredibly inequal wealth distribution prevents money from functioning like a distributed democratic force.
- hyperstar 5y agoI recently bought a Wacom tablet, but didn't install any drivers except those that are in the free-software repository of Void Linux, which I suppose don't do this. I wish it were easier in general, though, to find out whether hardware requires proprietary software to function. For example, I'd like to get a document scanner, but, since I don't know of any model that can run on free software, I just do without.
- m4rtink 5y agoI have MF645C (combined laser printer and scanner) from Cannon and it works perfectly fine (over network) from my Fedora systems without the need to install any proprietary drivers & using the auto discovery system over network. Other printers and scanners from Cannon might work good as well.
- haxiomic 5y agoThis was a wonderful read I think when I was younger I’d assumed the sheer number of technical users out there would mean it would be hard for companies to get away with things like this but these days I realize this sort of analysis and public exposition is actually rare and the number of skilled developers investing time in this is slim Perhaps collectively as a community we can create public bug and privacy bounties that enable and incentivise more work like this
- tailspin2019 5y ago> Perhaps collectively as a community we can create public bug and privacy bounties that enable and incentivise more work like this Interesting idea! If it was ethical (ie still properly followed responsible disclosure processes etc) I’d donate to something like this. EDIT: Also if supported by someone like the EFF maybe there could be a degree of legal cover for any potential issues.
- wyager 5y ago“Responsible disclosure” is a concept mostly proposed by companies looking to accommodate their own willful irresponsibility. This is even more true in the case of intentional privacy violations by software vendors. The responsible thing is to immediately put these companies on blast the moment this kind of spying is uncovered.
- tailspin2019 5y agoI do see your point, but I still think a standardised way to at least make sure the vendor is aware of the issue would be needed if we're talking about a formal program. Not necessarily holding off publishing to do so though. But I don't mean to back the side of vendors unduly here...
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoWhat ethical issue do you see? What is there to responsibly disclose? Software vendors do this on purpose; they don't need notification.
- lvass 5y agoWould I be compromised if I once ran `$ important-command --key=secret-key`, having a drawing tablet?
- nkozyra 5y agoNot enough data presented in the article to say. All it included was foreground app changes, so based on that you'd just get Terminal opening log messages.
- bogwog 5y agoConsidering Wacom feels justified in collecting whatever they want without disclosing it, I think it's safe to assume that, yes, you would be compromised. It's better to be safe than sorry.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoI never thought I would want a "walled garden" on my desktop, but these shit software stacks that companies are integrating into their products are forcing me to want to fight back to lock down my machine. I would love a simple utility that could not only neatly encapsulate and display the data being sent from my machine out on the network but also allow me to merely check a box to block that traffic. A smart initial config of course would "allow list" the usual web traffic from my browser(s), mail traffic from my mail client, etc. I don't want to mess with proxies, don't want to have to block ports using a command-line tool or by wading through my router config. Maybe I am asking for too much.
- jacquesm 5y agohttps://www.qubes-os.org/ https://www.qubes-os.org/
- xoa 5y ago>I would love a simple utility that could not only neatly encapsulate and display the data being sent from my machine out on the network but also allow me to merely check a box to block that traffic. Does Little Snitch not meet your needs there? I believe even with the challenges caused by Apple's unfortunate elimination of kernel extensions it's still powerful and effective. The GUI is solid and I've had solid success over many years with it for this sort of thing.
- JKCalhoun 5y agoThank (both of) you. I don't know why, I had always assumed Little Snitch was command-line. I'll play with it. In my line of work I had used Charles (but no, that is not something I would consider was to use).
- azalemeth 5y agoIt's worth mentioning that an excellent FOSS alternative is LuLu -- https://objective-see.com/products/lulu.html https://objective-see.com/products/lulu.html or https://github.com/objective-see/LuLu https://github.com/objective-see/LuLu [last commit a week ago!]
- encryptluks2 5y agoStart voting with your wallet. I think this is specific to Wacom tablets, but there are many vendors that provide Wacom hardware without their specific OS. I wonder if there is a good open source ROM for drawing tablets?
- JKCalhoun 5y agoHUION is the larger "Cintiq-clone" product I have used, but I have no reason to believe their software is Boy Scout honest. Of course Apple's "Side Car" means your iPad is a pretty good tablet.
- amelius 5y agoVoting does not work if the majority of voters doesn't care.
- dylan604 5y agoI think it's slightly worse because I seriously doubt the majority of users are simply unware of something needing to be cared about. So they aren't just dubiously doing something, they are doing it knowing that most people won't know it is being done.
- numpad0 5y agoWacom tablets are special purpose input devices, like Kensington trackballs or 3Dconnecxion SpaceMouse. What is needed is an open source Windows driver. Possible common choices for pen technologies are {Wacom EMR, Wacom AES, Microsoft Pen Protocol(formerly N-trig), Synaptic(unnamed?), Apple Pencil}. Apple Pencil and AES/MPP are well received on lower ends as well as for non-graphic purposes(especially note taking, where EMR is near unusable), so wallet voting can happen in markets for those, but nothing had replaced Wacom EMR in professional spaces if I understand right. That's why the company gets to keep pathetic 32", 4K, non-HDR, 310 nits, 1000:1 contrast, 98% Adobe RGB display for 4 grand as their absolute flagship product. Apple Pro Display XDR has same size of 32", but is 6K XDR(HDR), with up to 1000 nits brightness, has 1mil:1 contrast, has P3 wide color support, for 5 grand. Also I think it's worth considering how or where Wacom got this idea. As Wacom EMR pen market used to be a very stagnating space with zero competition until it had been incorporated into 1st- and 2nd-gen Surface only to be replaced by N-trig on Surface 3 onwards, I think it could be argued that it was that influx of capital that caused them realize they could "modernize" this way.
- ovalanche 5y agoI have depressingly started to believe (accept?) that everything I use tracks the name of everything else that I use. Agreeing with the author’s conclusion: >“This isn’t the dataset that’s going to complete the embrace of full, totalitarian surveillance capitalism. Nonetheless, it’s still deeply obnoxious. A device that is essentially a mouse has no legitimate reasons to make HTTP requests of any sort.” Also, I always disable those “experience programs,” like Nvidia’s. They just give off data collection vibes: >“If you too have a Wacom tablet (presumably this tracking is enabled for all of their models), open up the “Wacom Desktop Center” and click around until you find a way to disable the “Wacom Experience Program”.”
- onlyrealcuzzo 5y agoAndroid and iOS phones definitely track EVERY app usage down to the millisecond - and they have since pretty much the beginning...
- Why_O_My 5y agoI assume that pointing google-analytics.com to 0.0.0.0 in the hosts file is enough to stop this BS right?
- djbusby 5y agoNo, it takes loads more work to protect yourself online
- GuB-42 5y ago> Why does a device that is essentially a mouse need a privacy policy? There are mice that require you to create an account nowadays...
- jasonlotito 5y ago… which is perfectly acceptable because there are customer facing features enabled with this account. Which is shared in the marketing for said mice. And then there are mice which don’t require accounts. And technically, the mice do NOT require you to create an account.
- littlecranky67 5y agoit is only acceptable as an opt-in. Companies right and left try to collect as much data as possible, to a large extend not feature driven but marketing/sales driven, because having the users Email account, country, language etc. opens a sales channel. Oculus' Fb Account requiremet the most prominent example, but I remember also buying a GoPro Hero Black ~2016 that would require the companion App to create a GoPro account, just so you can change the settings of the camera (which some items were not changeable through the on-camera buttons).
- lampenrad 5y agoPrevious discussion from last year: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22247292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22247292
- krylon 5y agoThe sad thing about this is that there are perfectly valid reasons for Wacom to want certain information, like what hardware do their customers connect the drawing tablets to, what operating systems and applications do they use. This is useful information to have, in the sense that Wacom can choose where to put their resources, what applications to test for, etc. But the very fact they are so damned sneaky about it makes it look really shady. Why not openly ask the users those questions and show them what information would be sent to the vendor? (And I am pretty sure Wacom is but one of many companies behaving this way.) I vaguely recall using some applications built-in crash report a couple of years ago, and it was a) explicitly opt-in, and b) showed me (after asking me if I wanted to see it), verbatim, the data it was going to send to the vendor, including stack trace and stuff like that, and then asked me again if I wanted to send that crash report. (Unfortunately, I do not recall what software that was, though. sad emoji) So I know it is not only possible to handle these things differently, but some people/companies actually do that.
- dylan604 5y agomacOS does this any time an application "quits unexpectedly". You can Ignore, View Report, Send Report from the dialog.
- Sindisil 5y agoMost Linux distributions have a similar mechanism.
- m4rtink 5y agoAFAIK for example on Fedora this (ABRT) is opt in and only sends "thing crashed" if you opt in. You need to explicitly manually check and confirm a full crash dump before sending it, so really not anything being done without the user knowing, at least on Fedora.
- duskwuff 5y agoSome parts of the report are deliberately anonymized, too -- for example, if an executable is running from the user's home directory, that path is literally displayed as "/Users/USER/" rather than including the actual username.
- dahart 5y ago> we can also come up with scenarios that involve real harms. […] I personally use Google Analytics to track visitors to my website. This was a well-written fun read, and I also both care about privacy a lot and have also used Google Analytics on a site too, but at the same time I’m a little bit floored how quickly his own use of GA was assumed benign while Wacom’s was assumed malicious. (Using GA is handing tracking data to Google, after all.) I don’t think the “it’s just a mouse” is a valid justification for this double standard. My browser is “just a viewer”; I’m getting tracked before I click on anything on your page. If we’re going to care about privacy deeply, I think we need to be a little more rigorous together. This makes me wonder something as a developer - it’s not just tempting to have analytics and telemetry, it’s very, very valuable data if you care about the customer experience. And for companies that don’t do anything with this data other than improve the customer experience and fix crashes, this data is also valuable to the customers and users. So the big question here for developers is how can we collect usage data safely without compromising privacy? What data is safe to track, and what data is not safe to track? Personally I assume there are many kinds of seemingly innocuous data that could be misused. Even tracking mouse location can reveal things to an adversary. What can we do as developers to prevent customer experience from becoming adversarial? Is the only answer to not send any data? Or is there a technical way to establish and maintain trust between users and apps?
- prox 5y agoI think one way is to show the actual data being sent, rather than a black box with a sign “trust us, send us your telemetry” Some companies allow you to see what they are going to sent. It still takes trust, but it goes a long way.
- jodrellblank 5y ago> "it’s very, very valuable data if you care about the customer experience. [...] What can we do as developers to prevent customer experience from becoming adversarial?" Pay money for the very very valuable data, instead of taking it and trying to hide behind legalese and finger-pointing and distraction and affront. If studying how people use your thing adds value to your company, run a usability lab where you pay people to study how they use your thing. Contact a company with a lot of users and arrange to give them discounts in exchange for data, agree up front what data will be shared and how it will be used. Offer discounts like Amazon's Kindle-with-ads is cheaper than Kindle. Make it opt-in with limited things you collect and what you do with it, and be trustworthy enough that people believe you only do that. Microsoft PowerShell collects telemetry and it's opt-out, which is annoying for a shell/programming language. But there is a public help document about what is collected and how to opt-out[1] and the source code is on GitHub[2]. Even then I wouldn't be surprised if that was the proverbial straw which broke the camel's back. As developers keep abusing people's trust and taking liberties, something will be. It's a tragedy of the commons situation, why would you stop abusing the ~~environment~~ customer a little bit for a good reason when others are doing worse and they won't stop? [1] https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/powershell/module/microsoft.powershell.core/about/about_telemetry?view=powershell-7.1 https://docs.microsoft.com/en-us/powershell/module/microsoft... [2] https://github.com/PowerShell/PowerShell/blob/master/src/System.Management.Automation/utils/Telemetry.cs https://github.com/PowerShell/PowerShell/blob/master/src/Sys...
- amelius 5y agoApple does the same thing. Phones home for every application you open.
- nbzso 5y agoFor OS X: Little Snitch. For Linux: Open Snitch. The other option: Offline first, air-gapped. There is no way that I run a computer without host-based application firewall.
- no_time 5y agosimplewall for Windows. Or a separate hardware firewall device given how much trust microsoft products deserve.
- terramex 5y ago> For OS X: Little Snitch And for open-source (GPL3) macOS solution - LuLu. Switched form Little Snitch about a year ago with no issues.
- reaperducer 5y agoI use Little Snitch, but find it a bit... intrusive. I find myself turning it off occasionally just to get work done. For those of you who are in this same boat, there are Little Snitch config files you can download that come pre-loaded with lots of blocked hosts, so you don't have to do them on your own one-by-one, which is frustrating on a new system. What I wish I could find is a Little Snitch list that only filters out tracking and profiling. I'm OK with seeing ads. I know the web sites have to make money. But I don't want to be tallied by some random social media company just because I visited a web site about artisanal brake clamps. Something that will allow ads.google.com, but not analytics.google.com. Or if they're the same, then dump the whole thing.
- _trampeltier 5y agoI think in future we have to have a law, every App has to have the option, to show you all what they send in cleartext logfile if you wan't. It can't be, we have just to trust every company in good faith.
- marcodiego 5y agoThat doesn't makes sense. This is just a piece of hardware and the only way for it to do that is through the driver. But you can easily check it: https://elixir.bootlin.com/linux/latest/source/drivers/hid/wacom.h https://elixir.bootlin.com/linux/latest/source/drivers/hid/wacom_sys.c https://elixir.bootlin.com/linux/latest/source/drivers/hid/wacom_wac.c https://elixir.bootlin.com/linux/latest/source/drivers/hid/wacom_wac.h If you're using a different driver it is your choice. Wacom does not advertise their support but I bought one and I just had to plug it to make it work. AFAIK, they pay developers to maintain the drivers. At the least, the title should say it is a specific driver that has such problem.
- zenexer 5y agoThis article was written more than a year ago and received significant attention at the time. I suspect Wacom may have made some changes since then—at least, I hope they did. I can’t be sure because the official drivers aren’t actually open source. This article’s analysis took place on macOS. The drivers to which you linked are for Linux. It’s not unreasonable to assume that official closed-source drivers, especially when bundled with other software, might be more intrusive. For example, many Wacom tablets have buttons that can be remapped, but only if you install Wacom’s software. Dismissing it as the user’s choice really isn’t fair. I’m not going to berate my mother for failing to use Linux, but that doesn’t mean she wants all her activity sent to Wacom.
- marcodiego 5y agoI'm sure macOS supports hid devices out-of-the-box. Users should pressure Wacom to correctly support it. They do it correctly on linux, it is a shame users from other OS's are not treated as first-class citizens.
- asxd 5y agoTo be fair, that is the exact intention of this article.
- throwaway09223 5y ago
- marcodiego 5y agoReading the article: Last week I set up my tablet on my new laptop. As part of installing its drivers I was asked to accept Wacom’s privacy policy. And this is where I stopped. You're doing it wrong. Drivers belong to the kernel. You should not have to manually install it. You should pressure the vendor to correctly support their devices. I have a Wacom device, tried it in different recent distros, different computers and never needed to manually install a driver.
- tubby12345 5y ago>And this is where I stopped God I'm so sick of these holier than thou Richard Stallman level unrealistic dismissals. This take isn't brilliant - we all, at all times, know that we have the option to not ____ if we so choose. Not unlike how people say things like "well I would just choose not to work at ____". That we often choose otherwise means we can't but. >You should pressure the vendor to correctly support their devices. Cool like by means of a blogpost that makes it to the top of hn that details how annoying the vendor's process is?
- marcodiego 5y ago> >And this is where I stopped > > God I'm so sick of these holier than thou Richard Stallman level unrealistic dismissals. I understand your position, but they correctly support their device on linux, I'm sure they can do it on other OS's. > >You should pressure the vendor to correctly support their devices. > > Cool like by means of a blogpost that makes it to the top of hn that details how annoying the vendor's process is? I think this is a good step. But people not buying it and pressuring the vendor to correctly support the device is not mutually exclusive. We must consider that it is lack of knowledge and complacency from users that incentivizes vendors to act in such an abusive way. Sorry to sound stallman-like. I just wanted to raise attention to an important point that is mostly ignored.
- m4rtink 5y agoIs it actually Wacom maintaining the Linux Wacom drivers or is it community maintained ?
- jodrellblank 5y agoDiscussed before, and brought up in comments: - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22247292 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22247292 (this article, earlier thread) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22803484 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22803484 (comment by the author of the article) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22512696 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22512696 - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27963867 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27963867 One of those links was me mentioning it, and this got so under my skin it took Wacom's brand from "premium, respectable, best in class" to "untrustworthy, garbage, barrel scraping, avoid even if the alternatives function less well" in my head just instantly. Like Lenovo's "let's ship spyware with Thinkpads" did.
- ClumsyPilot 5y ago> "Like Lenovo's "let's ship spyware with Thinkpads" did." I I did that, I'd be in jail. It's about time we'd started treating this as what it is: data theft and stalking.
- kibwen 5y ago> Like Lenovo's "let's ship spyware with Thinkpads" did. One hopes that companies would value their brand and reputation over some short-term profit (and yet nobody here is holding their breath). To this day I refuse to buy any Lenovo product, and as the tech guy in my family I warn everyone who asks from considering them at all.
- 7thaccount 5y agoSame. It only takes one mistake of that magnitude to lose me as a customer forever.
- breakingcups 5y agoI take it you both also boycott Sony Music Group?
- 5y ago
- jaclaz 5y agoBesides the specific Wacom related issue, I find this snippet fantastic: >The first is a principled fuck you. I don’t care whether anything materially bad will or won’t happen as a consequence of Wacom taking this data from me. I simply resent the fact that they’re doing it. I have rarely seen the concept expressed in such a clear, direct manner.
- KerryJones 5y agoI came here to say the exact same thing.
- contingencies 5y agoI am a long time Wacom customer and this pisses me off too. I will certainly be trying out alternative brands in future. How about organizing an open source hackfest for alternative tablet brands? Some alternative tablet manufacturers: https://www.veikk.cn/products/ https://www.veikk.cn/products/ (绘客) https://www.huion.cn/ https://www.huion.cn/ (绘王) https://www.gaomon.net/Pen_Tablet/ https://www.gaomon.net/Pen_Tablet/ (高漫) https://www.ugee.com.cn/ https://www.ugee.com.cn/ (友基) https://www.parblo.cn/ https://www.parblo.cn/ (Parblo) http://www.penpower.com.tw/ http://www.penpower.com.tw/ (蒙恬; Taiwan) https://www.xp-pen.com/ https://www.xp-pen.com/ (XP-Pen; Japan)
- citboin 5y agoI’ve been avoiding those products because they’re Chinese. Can a pihole be used to stop tracking?
- contingencies 5y agoSome are Chinese, some are Taiwanese or Japanese. There's nothing wrong with hardware from China per-se. The local market is Windows-centric though which means drivers for other platforms often suck or don't exist. Also, mainland Chinese market tolerance for spyware/malware/general iffyness is high, which means pushback on vendor driver software bullshit is low. To sidestep this, open source can solve the bad-actor-driver issues and we can all get cheaper hardware.
- Buttons840 5y agoI've used a Wacom tablet with Linux and an open source driver.
- hiccuphippo 5y agoI block google analytics at the DNS level so I guess I'm safe? It's good that they don't send the tracking data to the same domain that sends driver updates.
- Pxtl 5y ago... this is a strong argument for a pihole. Easy network-wide anti spy functionality.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoFrom another perspective, this was a great intro to BurpSuite. I've always wanted to get around to using it, this was a cool demo.
- Pxtl 5y agoI assume it's because the Wacom has some value-adds for specific software, like custom software-specific hot buttons, erase functionality, the zoom circle, etc. and they want to know which applications users are using with the Wacom. But the fact that there's a legitimate customer-oriented explanation doesn't make this okay. I mean, if I added an always-on internet connected forward-facing camera and mic to a washer and dryer, I don't think we'd accept "to help you debug issues" as a good answer.
- tigerBL00D 5y ago> Some applications, like web browsers, co-operate very well with proxies. They allow users to explicitly specify a proxy for them to to send their traffic through. However, other applications (including the Wacom tablet drivers) provide no such conveniences. Instead, they require some special treatment. You may be able to tweak your /etc/hosts to direct traffic to a machine you control, just look out for certificate issues.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- the_flinstoned 5y agoThe Wacom data collection program is OPTIONAL. Mr. Heaton buries this in his rant in the second to last paragraph. Any professional digital artist (especially 3d) will tell you they use multiple pieces of software and that many benefits from having the tablet buttons assigned differently to facilitate efficiency as an artist. This is (probably) why Wacom products track the software you're using. Finally, "Being a mostly-normal person I never usually read privacy policies." - Robert Heaton Sure, blame Wacom for your impatience, Mr. Heaton.
- mkl 5y ago> The Wacom data collection program is OPTIONAL. Mr. Heaton buries this in his rant in the second to last paragraph. I don't see that in the second to last paragraph, and the word "optional" doesn't seem to appear anywhere. The driver being aware of which software is active makes sense and is legitimate. The driver sending that information to others is unnecessary and illegitimate (since explicit consent was not given).
- userbinator 5y agoI strongly believe this sort of behaviour comes from companies who for some reason think they need their products to have some sort of "experience", usually the ideas of marketing people. I remember many years ago buying an unbranded tablet from Alibaba -- direct from an OEM -- for a fraction of the cost of a Wacom, and it didn't even need drivers to start functioning. What drivers did come with it on the CD were minimal, unsigned (very common at the time, along with the instructions to click past the warning when installing) and surprisingly even had source code. The configuration utility wasn't a bloated abomination and didn't add itself to autorun on startup. In other words, it felt like a humble servant ready to work for you, rather than attempting to coerce you into its "experience". It probably wasn't as responsive or featureful as a Wacom, but worked decently for the cost.
- bdavisx 5y agoThere's a reason that Wacom tracks what application is running - it can change the functionality of the pad based on the program in the foreground. They probably want the information so they know what programs are most popular with their customers. That doesn't make it right, but it's part of the reason.
- dreamcompiler 5y agoAt this point I don't think there's a solution for this crap except regulation. Any PM of practically any product that has a software component is now expected to include revenue-generating spyware in the package; if she doesn't she gets fired. Regulation is the only solution. And the fines need to be stiff, like $10,000 per incident per user. It's gotta hurt or companies won't stop doing it.
- Iefthandrule 5y agoDon't companies lobby legislators to prevent this?
- jdavis703 5y agoWell the thing is, it’s really hard to define what “spyware” is from a legal sense. For example anti-malware software is highly invasive by definition. It seems the real problem is consent… There should be a “nutrition facts” for software that is enforced at the OS level through an aggressive permissions model and backed by a privately run app stores subject to audit by government regulators.
- eitland 5y agoIt wouldn't surprise me a single bit if this is against the GDPR. Actually it would surprise me slightly if this is not against the GDPR. Contrary to what many, both companies and individuals, seem to think, GDPR is not about cookie pop-ups but about regulating collection, storage and use of personal data.
- hanspeter 5y ago> include revenue-generating spyware Is this what you believe happened with Wacom in this case? How could these tracking points be converted into revenue? Personally I think this was a good case of "Any sufficiently advanced incompetence is indistinguishable from malice", but maybe my imagination is just insufficient.
- dpacmittal 5y agoI don't understand why desktop operating systems still don't ship with mobile style sandboxing. It would be so darn useful to restrict applications from using filesystem, or have access to only certain folders, or restrict them from internet access. I recently wanted to install a crypto currency wallet on my linux machine but I was terrified of the fact that every single software on my machine can access the whole of filesystem and can easily steal keys to the wallet. Eventually decided it's just not worth the constant worrying.
- jiveturkey 5y agomacos does and has for a few releases now. in this case it’s a kernel driver that interacts as an HID with every application. it also loads app specific macros so it needs to know WHAT app is running.
- imiric 5y agoYou have several options for that in the F/LOSS world: Linux containers, BSD jails, Qubes OS, or plain old VMs, etc. As with anything on these platforms you're free to pick your tool of choice. On Windows there are also a few options, Sandboxie being the best one IME. It's open source now as well, though the quality and stability have taken a hit. And there's Windows Sandbox, which has been shipping since Windows 10. I'm glad users can still make a choice on desktop OSs. As great as app isolation is on mobile devices, there's little from that ecosystem I would want on desktop. Even though OS manufacturers are desperately trying to merge the two...
- drexlspivey 5y agoThat’s why you use a hardware wallet.
- mleonhard 5y agoThe real problem here is that our OSes do not let us control the outgoing connections from software that we use. Device drivers should not have network access, unless they are drivers for network devices. The OS should enforce an allowlist for each application with the network names/protocols/ports it is allowed to use. Users should have control over this allow-list. The OS should require the user to review the allow-list before they can use a newly installed program. Software must install and work properly even when the user restricts its network access. When software fails to do so, the OS maker should not sign the software or allow it to market itself as "OS-compatible". We cannot depend on good intentions. Good quality of life requires accountability for all.
- emmelaich 5y agoWacom drivers have often been a clusterfuck. And they were absurdly secretive in the earlier days of Linux about their hardware. Generous view -- they're attempting to find combinations of software in an attempt to correlate software and their own issues.
- jp0d 5y agoI one tried using my wife's Wacom tablet on my office Mac. It kept prompting me to allow it record keystrokes from all applications. Naturally I didn't allow it. It didn't work but then the spyware was quite difficult and and hard to remove. I was shocked.
- surfsvammel 5y agoDamn. I hate this. I use my Wacom tablet a lot… Is there a website that keeps track of these things, that I could consult before buying stuff? If not, could someone please build it?:)
- Dah00n 5y agoSo does pretty much every Apple device made in the last ~20 years but HN loves those.
- shmerl 5y ago> As part of installing its drivers I was asked to accept Wacom’s privacy policy Never had such issue on Linux with Wacom tablets. Having blob drivers is terrible in general.
- raxxorrax 5y agoThat is a bummer since I like their tablets for drawing. But I cannot in good conscience support such practices. If they ask the user, fine. But this is certainly the worst form of spyware, even if it is only used for "legitimate" purposes.
- footlose_3815 5y agoi’ll avoid wacom now