16 ms·
Taking apart the 2010 Fisher Price re-released Music Box Record Player
- taddevries 5y agoI have to think this is mostly due to modern toy factories and their standard tooling. You'd probably have a hard time finding a factory that could mass produce the old toy because that's just not how toys are made today.
- jldl805 5y agoI feel like you're about half correct here. For instance, most of these factories aren't "toy factories" they are "injection molding" or "pcb" or "electronic assembly" factories. I would invite you to submit any examples of how you think modern toys are made of "mostly" standard tooling... that's not how this works. China has more mold designers, mold makers, and mold shops in many towns than other countries have within their borders. I do agree with you that the old clockwork motor would be too expensive to manufacture now, but I think you should keep thinking about the rest of your thesis.
- mhb 5y agoNot the same, but this "DIY Hand-cranked Music Box Wooden Box + Hole Puncher + Paper Tapes" might appeal in a similar way: https://www.ebay.com/itm/182794446978 https://www.ebay.com/itm/182794446978
- kcplate 5y agoSomeone out there thinks this is better.
- diogenescynic 5y agoProbably just cheaper.
- Someone1234 5y agoMore reliable too. The old music player was far more resilient compared to a non-toy, but still suffered from gunk/grime on both the records and pin.
- sulam 5y agoRight, a fully mechanical version would have far higher DPPM, and as a result likely not be profitable.
- rrss 5y agoI don’t understand how it could be made profitably 50 years ago but not today.
- zokier 5y agoIt's not a question of being profitable or not profitable, but of being profitable or more profitable. Also the market situation probably is very different, nowdays there is most likely more demand for cheaper toys and more competitive pressure to keep prices down.
- ginko 5y agoI wonder if this was originally planned to be more like the original with songs mechanically encoded in the disks but they either found the cheap microswitches in the tone arm to not have the right reaction speed or they realized developing the sound generation for the IC took too long/needed a more powerful+expensive micro controller so they went with this instead.
- IAmGraydon 5y agoNot sure what you mean. The original had no electronic parts. It was basically a hand-wound music box with interchangeable discs.
- euroderf 5y agoBack in the 60s we had an actual cheap-ass record player for 78s, and the 78s were thick - very thick - like more than an eighth of an inch thick. But these kids' "record players" nowadays? Naaah. A mere shadow. No actual appreciation of retro technology required - or wanted.
- mulmen 5y agoAre you talking about the toy in the thread or actual turntables?
- euroderf 5y agoAn actual record player.
- mulmen 5y agoSo are you suggesting that a 33 RPM LP is not a "real" record? Or that anyone who has a turntable today doesn't appreciate the format? I find both hard to believe. My turntable is from 2014, I am well aware of the principles on which it operates. That's why I bought it.
- IAmGraydon 5y agoWhat baffles me is how this could be cheaper to manufacture than the original design. It was literally just music box tines in the head of the arm, and it was plucked by the bumps on the rotating record, just like a music box. This new version even contains a silenced music box! How does this make any kind of sense?
- imgabe 5y agoThis is the kind of content I come to Hacker News for.
- bb88 5y agoFunny, then you should know that Foone hates hacker news, mostly because they're appropriating Foone's content to push Hacker News and Y Combinator importance ("stealing links" is how Foone put it). I highly recommending following Foone on twitter and using the thread unroll app. There's several more years of stuff like this on twitter.
- imgabe 5y agoFollowed on Twitter, but that’s unfortunate that they feel that way. “Stealing links” seems like a fundamental misunderstanding of how the web works. Websites linking to each other is kind of the whole point.
- fortran77 5y agoPart of the value of the original was kids could see and feel how it worked. That made it a fascinating toy. It's all been lost.
- smegcicle 5y agoand nowadays you could 3dprint new records for it
- Jtsummers 5y agoI have a music box that uses a paper tape, it was an extra as I was making a gift for a family member and Thinkgeek (long before the Gamestop acquisition) accidentally sent me two. It was actually a lot of fun to make extra songs for it, the toy becomes interactive for the player. Which is a much better thing for kids than something that can only ever play 10 songs, and which they cannot alter in any meaningful sense.
- dangle1 5y agoYeah, this brought back an early memory of my sparkling new brain examining the mechanism of the original version of this toy with my eyes and fingers without any words to describe what I was learning. Just some kind of sense of mastery that I couldn't communicate, but made me feel more confident about my understanding of the world. It seems pretty cynical to market this in order to appeal to people like me with memories like this, with a huge dimension of the enrichment value stripped away.
- tyleo 5y agoI agree, I’d pay a little more for a mechanical version. If this trend continues even wooden blocks will some day come with batteries :p
- Symbiote 5y agoI remember playing with the original, although it wasn't mine. A friend must have had it. It would be interesting to know the cost in 1980, and compare it (with inflation) to the current cost.
- mbreese 5y agoThat’s a good point. I wonder what kind of tolerances were needed to make the original records? It probably wasn’t terribly tight, but still necessary to make a playable record. Versus a simple microcontroller that can play any number of songs and very limited physical tolerances. The electric version might actually be cheaper to produce.
- Jtsummers 5y ago"any number of songs" = 10, in this case, and up to 16 but the extra 6 can't be delivered since there's no update mechanism. Versus the original which could play a much larger variety of songs based on the records themselves. Presumably using a music box like mechanism, not a vinyl record style mechanism, which greatly loosens the quality constraints on the records (based on listening to a recording of the original).
- pronoiac 5y agoThe original is very similar to a music box. It's likely doable to make your own disc for the original using 3D printing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Symbiote 5y agoYes, [1] is an instructable from some years ago. It should be achievable on a recent hobbyist printer nowadays, e.g. [2]. [1] https://www.instructables.com/3D-printing-records-for-a-Fisher-Price-toy-record-/ https://www.instructables.com/3D-printing-records-for-a-Fish... [2] https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:4648393 https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:4648393
- johnsonap 5y agoGod I love foone
- polytely 5y agoYes honestly one of the most entertaining follows on twitter
- DaiPlusPlus 5y agoHow does Foone spend so much time on all these "here's something interesting I found, now it's a 12-hour-long deep-dive into something I never thought I could care passionately about" things and still have a job? Turing's living the dream... (the family name has to be a coincidence, right?)
- johnsonap 5y agothey use they, not he, but they have a lot of followers on ko-fi! https://ko-fi.com/fooneturing https://ko-fi.com/fooneturing
- post-it 5y agoDo they have a day job? I thought they lived off their Patreon. They definitely changed their first and last name at some point, I remember a Twitter thread mentioning it.
- shdon 5y agoThey're a Continuous Integrator at Backblaze, according to their LinkedIn.
- frosted-flakes 5y agoIs it multiple people writing the Twitter posts?
- umvi 5y agoDoes foone have a job? I know he has a Patreon.
- memeboop 5y agoI love the irony of the new toy containing an actual music box inside that isnt used to play the music.
- neilv 5y agoPerhaps whatever hapless engineer was tasked with desecrating the Fisher Price toy that might have nudged their own early cognitive development... retreated into a dark sense of humor about it.
- gjsman-1000 5y agoMy family has had one of these for a few years. I remember studying it and immediately realizing there was no way the discs had any data, and sure enough I felt the pins under the head and could make it play different songs by pushing them in differently. As for the dial, I remember thinking it felt so music-box-like, but I had no idea it was an actual music box!! Alas, I never experienced the mechanical version. Such a shame.
- bombcar 5y agoWhich is amusing because the music box is silenced and only sued for regulating the spin. I wonder if the original revamp had planned to have it just be a wind up music box and only play one song.
- Jtsummers 5y agoMy guess is that the toy in the Twitter thread was the result of a kind of refactor. If you find a recording of the original it has a traditional music box inside which actually plays the songs (you can hear the tinny sound of the metal tines). So they probably took the original, figured out how it worked, replaced the audio generation with speakers and the microcontroller and changed the read head. Since the newer ones apparently use a switch and no spring, that was an intermediate step to the current incarnation. The first version was an electronic imitation (complete with winding) of the original. Once the winding was rendered unnecessary, you get the current version without that imitation and it loses the tactile component.
- wolfgang42 5y agoThe original didn’t have a music box in the base; there was a spring motor to turn the record, but the actual music-box part was in the head (running along the record, which had detents in the plastic to pull the tines for the notes)—this is why you could get different songs by changing the disc. This music box in the base of the new model is probably simply the cheapest way to get a spring motor for the turntable these days, rather than custom-manufacturing one that matches the original.
- smashed 5y agoAs an 80's kid I have fond memories of this toy. Being all mechanical you could explore and marvel at it. I remember trying to get the spin faster/slower, stopping the spring, etc. Since it required no batteries it was always working, even when you found it at the bottom of toy bin after months/years. This modern version is a complete scam, especially since the outside look seems absolutely identical to the original. I'd be very disappointed if I bought one for a toddler, only to realize when unboxing it's crap. By the way, we still have the original toy from my childhood. It's been passed around to relatives, but last I heard, it still works after what must be almost 40 years.
- systemvoltage 5y ago> This modern version is a complete scam Applies to pretty much 90% of everything I use and buy. The world is getting shittier by the day.
- tobmlt 5y agoThis should be a proxy measure for inflation. (If only it was quantifiable so easily…) Instead of prices going up in this case, quality goes down.
- nebula8804 5y agoThere used to be an awesome blog site called consumerist that had a "Shrink Ray" section where they would try to track all the consumer products that were secretly degraded in some way. The blog shut down a while ago. Guess big industry got to them. [1]:https://consumerist.com/tag/shrink-ray/index.html https://consumerist.com/tag/shrink-ray/index.html
- mark-r 5y agoThe life blood of any independent site is advertising. Who would advertise on such a site?
- 5y ago
- ReactiveJelly 5y agoRe: vinyl records Has anyone proven / disproven Benn Jordan's video about why vinyl is basically poisonous? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZ2czFuIYmQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aZ2czFuIYmQ I haven't watched it for a while but the summary is: - Vinyl records outgas harmful things that you can detect with air quality meters. (VOCs I think) - You can't dispose of them because they can't be recycled and aren't supposed to go in landfills. So buying new records from new bands violates the "reduce, reuse, recycle" principle "It's just that it's _so_ lame and uncool to shit on vinyl..." "This is just my objective opinion based on a whole lotta research... If you're an avid collector whose peepee hurts after watching this video, understand that my peepee hurts a whole lot more."
- code_duck 5y agoI’m not sure about records, but it is well established that vinyl flooring emits various toxic compounds. Apparently it’s mostly other ingredients besides the PVC. https://floortechie.com/is-vinyl-flooring-toxic/ https://floortechie.com/is-vinyl-flooring-toxic/ Just search “vinyl off gassing”. Here’s an EPA pdf purely about vinyl chloride: https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/sites/production/files/2016-09/documents/vinyl-chloride.pdf https://19january2017snapshot.epa.gov/sites/production/files...
- h2odragon 5y agoI will guess your average human emits more hazardous VOCs than a vinyl record. I'd put this down to "someone thinks something is cool and fun! we have to show them how wrong they are!"
- nemo 5y agoI'd recommend you read up a more about vinyl - you really aren't treating a very dangerous material seriously enough. PVCs are highly toxic, and at this point there are many regulations to ban their use in plumbing, consumer goods, and especially toys because they are so poisonous. Vinyl records are a hold-out. They leach high levels of phthalates into the air quite quickly which are highly toxic, far, far more toxic than the typical emissions of your average human. http://www.safemarkets.org/toxic-chemicals-in-products/pvc/vinyl-the-poison-plastic http://www.safemarkets.org/toxic-chemicals-in-products/pvc/v...
- jsrcout 5y ago> So yeah. The original one required you to crank it up to spin the disc, because spinning the disc was vital to the operation of the original music box. > The modern "classic" one requires you to crank it up, because it won't start playing until you've cranked it up. Maybe I'm just cranky today. But this quote perfectly encapsulates so much of what's wrong with a lot of modern technology.
- xyzal 5y agocranking it up increases 'engagement', probably
- fragmede 5y agoSkeuomorphism is a time honored tradition, eg folders in a filesystem. Users often find its use is annoying, but other times it's a necessary analogy for users to make sense of the UX.
- bink 5y agoThis isn't just an artistic decision though. The product gives the impression that it's an actual functioning record player, like the old one.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoNo. This toy "gives the impression that it's an actual functioning record player", even though it isn't. The old one was an actual functioning record player. Or at least a cross between a record player and a music box. But the point is: the old one was actually playing music off the disks, the new one only pretends to do it.
- cabalamat 5y agoThis isn't skeumorphism, it's just fake.
- rgarrett88 5y ago
- thunderbong 5y agoBetter readability - https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1454230585933631488.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1454230585933631488.html
- dehrmann 5y agoI'm surprised they still make this. Usually kids toys are modeled after what they see adults doing. Some people still have turntables, but it's rare enough that I wasn't expecting there to be much demand for this.
- Jtsummers 5y agoNostalgia. Parents and grandparents who remember it will buy new toys based on their toys from childhood, regardless of the modern sensibilities.
- lofatdairy 5y agoThat's a good point. lmao what a weird hauntology. the past generation bought the toy for their children because of its resemblance to everyday items in their lives, and the next generation buys a facsimile for their children for its resemblance to the toy from their childhood. i wonder how many iterations will the chain continue
- Ancapistani 5y agoThis comment was striking enough that I thought it deserved more than a simple upvote. Thanks for showing us this perspective :)
- TeMPOraL 5y agoIn this case, it'll end with the current generation of children, because toys like the one we're discussing here have nothing in them to create lasting memories. They cut the things that made the toy special out in the redesign.
- rootusrootus 5y agoExactly. A good business always has to remember who the actual customer is. For kids, in many cases the actual customer is mom & dad, so make sure your product is aimed at them. Same with selling software to a business, the customer is management not the engineers who will actually use it.
- golemotron 5y agoThat music box record player is a perfect metaphor for distributed supply chains in global manufacturing. In fact, one could say that it is a representation of them.
- Bluecobra 5y agoThe updated Fisher Price Tape Recorder got a similar treatment, the original played real cassettes but the modern one does not. https://www.walmart.com/ip/Fisher-Price-Classics-Play-Tape-Recorder/385351545 https://www.walmart.com/ip/Fisher-Price-Classics-Play-Tape-R...
- mcphage 5y agoWith the original Fisher-Price cash register, the 3 different denominations were of different sizes, so each only fit into its own slot. With their modern remake, the 3 different denominations are all the same size. That’s the thing about their remakes, all across the board—they look similar to the originals, but lost their a lot of the details and functionality that made them charming. As a Buffalonian I still have a soft spot for Fisher-Price, but these are just disappointing.
- kps 5y agoFisher-Price once made a toy camcorder that used audio cassettes. A 90 minute tape held 11 minutes of video, monochrome 120×90 at 15fps. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PXL2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PXL2000
- Waterluvian 5y agoMechanical toys can be “screwed with” a lot. Like experimenting with a ton of “what if…” Electronic toys generally don’t give you much of this. And I think this really represents a fundamental change in a lot of aspects of life: there’s a specific way to interact with things, prescribed by the maker. I absolutely loved the quiet weekends as a kid where I could spend hours and hours making ridiculous contraptions by mixing toys and a bit of tape and such.
- erik_p 5y agoGlitch musicians would like a word. Maybe you mean digital. As electronic toys can still be modified/screwed with.
- nebula8804 5y agoJust you wait until your mini-moog has a boot process with a required chain of trust that will reject any circuit bending. That'll teach ya :P
- IAmGraydon 5y agoElectronic toys have much more potential for modification. It just takes a more advanced skill set.
- krallja 5y agoOn sight, I recognize Für Elise on the cylinder.
- rrss 5y agoin case others are interested, I was curious about the original and found a good description the mechanism of the original in the patent: https://patents.google.com/patent/US3710668A/en https://patents.google.com/patent/US3710668A/en.
- teddyh 5y ago“This is a toy zombie.” — https://twitter.com/wangtian/status/1454329529569218566 https://twitter.com/wangtian/status/1454329529569218566
- pmorici 5y agoThe original Fisher-Price "Record Player" is really a kids version of a Polyphon [0] a type of record like music player that was popular in the late 1800's to early 1900's. You can see some playing on YouTube [1] I thought it would be interesting to 3D print additional records for the thing. Was super disappointed when I bought one for our daughter last year and found that they had changed it to a digital music player that only uses the records for song selection. A lot of the modern day versions of the original Fisher-Price toys don't hold up to the originals. For example on the xylophone they replaced the Wood base with plastic and the thing sounds like crap. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyphon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polyphon [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dk4zjQshq14 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dk4zjQshq14 [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soQLAvqnTOQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soQLAvqnTOQ
- bink 5y agoIt sucks how cheaply kid's toys are made these days, but there are companies that stand out by making things that last. When my kid was little we bought a lot of Melissa & Doug toys because they were actually made of wood and would survive multiple children.
- bluGill 5y agoIf you want music toys for kids look to hohner http://hohnerkids.com/ http://hohnerkids.com/. They make a line that are real musical instruments. They tune their xylophone for example. They are still cheap plastic, but the quality is good enough for real music.
- agumonkey 5y agoThese large polyphons sounds superbly full to me. full metal not so compact disc :) I mean really.. ave maria is a little magical https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tu4FWixsUM8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tu4FWixsUM8 gosh
- chadcmulligan 5y agoFound a little talk and play by Wintergatan (the guy who built the musical marble machine) of a polyphon in a museum in The Netherlands https://youtu.be/LyXY4Bz3PLs https://youtu.be/LyXY4Bz3PLs
- allenrb 5y agoMan, this makes my day. I was born during the original production run and, of course, had one of these. Lovely, fun little toy. So when our first child was born and some kind family member bought her one, it put a big smile on my face… …until I looked closer! Fraud! Deception! And saddest of all, I tried the same thing foone did, knowing that the unused binary codes (maybe not 0000 but surely the other five) were surely hiding a few extra songs. But no, complete and total disappointment. Par for the course. This thing has survived two young daughters now, but it is utterly devoid of soul.
- t0mas88 5y agoThey probably skip 0000, 1111 and all single bit ones because those are the most likely codes you get if you press the buttons with a finger?
- ineedasername 5y agoIt's not that I'm nostalgic for analog, I just don't like the new version because it's basically a fraud. Presenting itself as analog when really it's just a skeuomorphic presentation of a cheap digital music player.
- ansible 5y agoAnd charging more for it because of all the plastic. This is basically the same kind of chip that is in electronic greeting cards. It is a shame, because we live in the age of 3D printers, and making your own tunes is now not that hard for the original music player, but the new player itself is now so limited.
- randomstring 5y agoThis new version of the Fisher-Price Record Player is heartbreaking. I learned so much from trying to understand how it worked. Concepts like stored energy: experimenting with trying to over-wind, under-wide, a few turns, many turns, slowly adding pressure to the winding knob until it would start playing and try to maintain just enough pressure to play. Physically slowing and speeding up the turntable to change to the tempo. Trying to intentionally misaligning the head to play out of tune. Turning it on it's side, upside down, trying to peek at the teeth on the head and manually play individual notes. All at an age before I could read. That toy was indestructible, because if it weren't I would have torn it down to individual components (just like my very expensive 6 million dollar man action figure, to the great chagrin of my parents). It wouldn't be until much later I'd have to tools to dissemble one, and by then I was taking apart real record plays. This toy is a good analog for a real record player and with grooves that move a needle and play sound encoded on the disk. Leading to understanding of sound waves. This new toy is a mix of new and old tech. How can a per-literate child be expected to decipher binary encodings and how they map to individual songs? What deeper understanding of how things work are within the grasp of a child that cannot yet use a screwdriver, wire cutters, and a volt meter? This new toy is boring. Once you learn how to turn it on, it can have no appeal to a child exposed to much better music players all around them: cell phones, iPads, computers, tvs. This is just a piece of plastic and e-waste destined for the landfill, purchased by some sentimental old timer who has fond memories of the original F-P record player.
- pen2l 5y agoAs well, the beautiful vulnerability and realness, the imperfections, the notes sometimes slightly flat or sharp because of mechanical aberrations — they were wonderful to observe. The humming sounds of the windings, the realness of it. The tactile dots, the understanding of how they related to musical notes. What a thing it was to behold, an authenticity that the child in us could always appreciate and be impressed and moved by.
- agumonkey 5y agoWe're still in the wave of digital purity (and the VR/meta chapter won't help). Come back in 50 years for a reappreciation of analog, complex, fragile and non linear. By this time digital computing will probably be chaotic too.
- robbiet480 5y agoFoone has noticed this submission and is not pleased https://twitter.com/foone/status/1454524960488132614?s=21 https://twitter.com/foone/status/1454524960488132614?s=21
- JasonFruit 5y agoFoone does cool things but clearly has high expectations for their own control of how crowds of people will discuss stuff that is, after all, out in public. Foone should maybe try a screened subscription-only paywall and see if that satisfies them more.
- scrollaway 5y agoI'm not sure what Foone is going on about. There isn't a single comment about the twitter format here except for someone linking to an unrolled version. It's just praise about their tweets and content, and shitting on fisher price for building a crappier product. Actually makes for a nice change for once. On-topic conversation!
- bb88 5y agoIt's pretty clear, just read Foone's twitter feed. He feels that HN "steals links" (their words). Google "OH FUCK ME I'M ON HACKER NEWS AGAIN" for the full twitter feed. They don't particularly like HN, for lots of reasons. JWZ feels the same way, which is why JWZ looks at the HTTP referrer for all links that were posted on HN and redirects those links to an image of a testicle.
- 1_player 5y agoWhenever I see a foone thread on HN, I scroll down looking for two things: people complaining about it being a twitter thread (he's got ADHD yadda yadda), and foone throwing a tantrum because he's made the HN frontpage yet again. The absolute predictability of these two events never fails to entertain me.
- Yuioup 5y agoThat's just sickening. I'm disgusted to my core.
- pengaru 5y agoOne of the worse aspects of growing old is having to watch things previously done well and delivering genuine thoughtful value mutate into illusory branded trash done just well enough to fleece consumers.
- nebula8804 5y agoCapitalism at its finest.
- russellbeattie 5y agowhy is this a twitter thread? why not a blog?
- AndrewDucker 5y agoBecause that's how the author chose to write it. Because that's where the audience they write for is. Because they prefer Twitter threads to blog posts. Because they get more readers that way. (And probably anyone here can come up with some more reasons that might be true if they put their minds to it.) But mostly, the format someone chooses to make this available in is the least interesting thing about it.
- russellbeattie 5y agoIt was a joke. https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1454530751475552256 https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1454530751475552256
- rkagerer 5y agoIt's unfortunate, as soon as I saw it was Twitter and waiting for the page to load I left and opted to skip reading this one.
- russellbeattie 5y agoIt was a joke. https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1454530751475552256 https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1454530751475552256
- russellbeattie 5y agoI love that absolutely no one got the joke. https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1454530751475552256 https://mobile.twitter.com/Foone/status/1454530751475552256 Foone is a sociopath who doesn't feel certain words should be used to refer to Foone because they don't like them. In fact no one should talk about Foone ever.
- drtz 5y agoI got one of these for my kids around 2014 and was also hugely disappointed. I realized very quickly that it was just a gimmick to lure the Gen-Xers and Millenials who remember these from their childhood. I, too, was disgusted that it took batteries but you still had to wind the knob, but I was even more offended by the awful staticky sound from the tiny speaker. Like foone, I also got a kick out of playing with the switches and seeing what happened when you held the disc stil, but I was never curious enough to open it up. I'm glad I didn't, though -- I think the sight of an actual music box would have broken my heart.
- codesuki 5y agoThis seems to be a theme. Toy quality going down. There was a tape recorder with mic from fisher price. You could use the mic to record on the tape and keep it around. I thought to buy it for my kids because I had good memories of it, but guess what. They replaced the tape with tiny memory that you have to overwrite all the time. If they at least would have supported some removable memory.
- TeMPOraL 5y ago> They replaced the tape with tiny memory that you have to overwrite all the time. Until that point I fully expected you to say that they replaced the tape with storage on a cloud account. I bet this will happen one day. So many toys are already trying to suck on kids' data and hook up the parents to cloud services (see e.g. toys that feature "extra experiences" that you access by pointing your smartphone camera at them, and looking through the toy maker's app).
- codesuki 5y agoI can totally see that happening. And then it's 'oops we leaked all your kids audio', 'our ml researchers are listing to your kids audio to improve ads that will soon play on your tape recorder', etc.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoYup. > And then it's 'oops we leaked all your kids audio' Especially that this has already happened at least once - there was a company storing unencrypted audio from a plush teddy bears in a publicly-accessible MongoDB instance. https://www.techrepublic.com/article/iot-connected-teddy-bear-leaks-millions-of-kids-conversations-exposed-database-to-blame/ https://www.techrepublic.com/article/iot-connected-teddy-bea...
- codesuki 5y agoThanks for sharing! Didn't read about that one.
- amelius 5y agoSkeuomorphism at work ... :(
- jaynetics 5y agoI'm not sure how common this is in other countries, but here in Germany we have quite a few "water playgrounds". There are some pumps in the sand, sometimes small aqueducts and the likes, so during summer, the kids can play with water. The pumps used to be real pumps. Now they are electronic. They have a sensor to detect how fast the handle is moving and at a certain speed you'll hear a clicking sound, a valve opens and the water starts flowing. I think some children will realize how these things work. They might start to find them dumb if they find out that the strenuous repetitive movement is in fact unnecessary. At least to me it feels like a dishonest contraption and I'd prefer if they simply put a button on it.
- alisonkisk 5y agoThis is how the Wii works too. It tells you to swing the wiimote like a bat or a golf club or a tennis racket or steering wheel, but it works better when you just flick your wrist.
- Aeolun 5y ago> I think some children will realize how these things work. Conversely, I’ve seen some kids play with real pumps and they seem to find it incredibly fun when they realize that more and faster movement brings more water. Hell, I thought it was fun myself just seeing how fast I could make it go.
- neom 5y agoAm I the only one who loves the meme that Foone hates being on the front page and always ends up on the front page? :D
- varjag 5y agoIf space aliens ever get this as an artefact they'll never make sense out of it.
- dejawu 5y agoA friend of mine from engineering school had pretty much this exact idea for a joke record player: Require the user to provide a record and place the needle on it, but then use image-recognition to identify the label/cover art and stream the album while the record spun uselessly. Seeing someone do this, but unironically and for a real product specifically meant for humans who are actively developing their sense of how the world around the works, feels somewhere between cynical and outright deceptive. It reminds me of the Mechanical Turk (the original one, not the Amazon service): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_Turk https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mechanical_Turk - a machine deliberately designed to mislead.
- mikepurvis 5y agoCan't seem to find it now, but a while ago there was an art project posted on here that was basically a mock tourist camera where it would use the GPS and IMU to infer your subject, and combine that with time of day info to grab you a top-rated picture off Instagram instead of whatever lousy one you were trying to take yourself. And here's the inverse of that— a camera that blocks you from taking photos too many other people have taken: https://philippschmitt.com/archive/2018/work/camera-restricta.html https://philippschmitt.com/archive/2018/work/camera-restrict...
- MarkusWandel 5y agoThere's also the modern version of the See 'n Say. The original one is mechanically brilliant. The new one has much better sound quality and a flip-over semicircle that gives it two full circles of things to point to. Is it better? Hard to say. On the other hand some modern electronic toys are brilliant. The Leapfrog one with the 8x8 LED array and the light pen is absolutely brilliant in how much play value it gets out of that simple hardware and already feels like a classic.
- ddingus 5y agoThe new toy is an insult. I had the old one as a kid and kept it long enough to take it apart and learn so much... This one has lessons too, but not the same ones. Maybe just as useful, in a dark way.
- tekstar 5y agoVintage Fisher Price toys are an absolute marvel of engineering. We have a few of the "little people" sets - my favorite is still the garage with an elevator that still works, including raising and lowering "stop" gates and a floor that raises on an incline only when the elevator reaches the top and the gate opens. My second favorite is the "sesame street play house" featuring a pathway where the little people can "walk". As you turn a crank the pathway moves slowly forward, and then jerks suddenly back. The result is your toy slowly steps forward, and then the track jerks back too fast for the toy to follow, so the toy "walks" and then goes down the slide. It's just a complete joy to operate.
- joshu 5y agosomething something baudrillard, especially the music box
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- OOPMan 5y agoThe future of cargo cults is now!