26 ms·
Bitcoin is largely controlled by a small group of investors and miners
- eraad 5y agoI believe this is a hit piece. The author uses the word "controlled" in a misleading way that leads readers to think that the value offer of bitcoin decentralization is not true or worst, whatever product that builds on it is deceiving their customers. Talks very poorly of the author and everyone else involved.
- giuliomagnifico 5y agoRepost: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29002100 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29002100
- volkanvardar 5y agoSo, can we say that it is kind of centralized?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- IndexCardBox 5y agoPareto's observations back in 1896 about land ownership in Italy still hold true...
- JoiDegn 5y agoYeah I think this is not really surprising. Why would bitcoin be any different than e.g. wealth more generally.
- arcticbull 5y agoMy understanding is it expends unbelievable quantities of resources pretending otherwise.
- mechanical_bear 5y agoWhat is “it” in this case?
- nabakin 5y agoBitcoin
- mechanical_bear 5y agoBitcoin is not a unitary rational actor, exhibiting thought or action.
- DSingularity 5y agoIsn’t it obvious?
- anonporridge 5y agoWhere are people pretending that bitcoin will fix wealth inequality?
- asdff 5y agoIn the thread about Bitcoin and Costa Rica posted a few weeks ago.
- frankbreetz 5y agoI hear this presented as a by-product of bitcoin all the time. People also say it will create world peace. Here are the first two google searches: https://www.forbes.com/sites/martinrivers/2021/06/15/how-bitcoin-can-fix-global-inequality-one-developing-nation-at-a-time/?sh=4c4f679b2aa5 https://www.forbes.com/sites/martinrivers/2021/06/15/how-bit... https://www.businessinsider.com/this-is-how-bitcoin-can-end-income-inequality-in-2020 https://www.businessinsider.com/this-is-how-bitcoin-can-end-...
- m0zg 5y agoAs an asset not really subject to inflation (AKA tax on the poor), it could be helpful for those of moderate means to protect themselves against losing what little they have. I've experienced hyperinflation first hand some 25 years ago - it's not fun. I protected myself somewhat by buying (and then gradually selling) dollars, but that won't work if the dollar starts circling down the shitter, which it might. Going into foreign currencies is also not ideal because they are not legal tender, so you'll have to exit into your local currency, and to protect _themselves_ against inflation the currency exchanges pretty dramatically increase the spread, so you lose some money converting back and forth. BTC is not legal tender either, but it could be used "under the table" in lieu of cash if shit hits the fan, much like silver, gold, or ammo. With a modicum of lawmaking it could also be used for payments between companies, which in hyper-inflationary economy based on fiat currencies make inflation even worse, because there's a latency between the time the company gets supplies and the time it ships product, and the company must be able to afford the new batch of supplies, so they eyeball what the prices will be, say, 2 weeks from now and set their prices accordingly (and sandbag on top of that as well). Do this 10 times through the supply chain and you get eye watering prices for final product on the shelves. BTC would fix that. It did not exist at the time, so people would barter instead, but that's pretty horrible, since you don't always have the stuff the other side needs, so you end up with horrendous chains of exchanges which fall through from time to time, causing a cascade of problems. TL;DR: BTC could come in handy when printer goes brrrr.
- zepto 5y agoIt wouldn’t be, but you wouldn’t know that from the hype.
- exporectomy 5y agoReally? Can you point to any hype from the last, say, 5 years that even hints at thinly spread mining or ownership? Individuals were mining on their PC in its first couple of years, but that ended long ago.
- zepto 5y agoThat’s a straw man. The hype is all about how it’s distributed and nobody controls it, when in practice it’s not much different from conventional money except that those with power are even more hidden.
- exporectomy 5y agoIts distributedness is still worth something even if only a small number of people control most of it. If they go rogue or get stopped by the government, others can take over. That's quite unlike any centralized system.
- mpfundstein 5y agohaha. i feel like everywhere i look, i see the power law in action.
- senectus1 5y agoyup, this has been the way since the beginning. in fact most of the alt coins are the same way. and its super obvious that its being manipulated by those with the largest amounts. the market is too immature. the financial gene pool is too shallow.
- iszomer 5y agoI guess depending on how people define it, Bitcoin would originally be the hedge against the traditional banking and monetary policy just as Ethereum would be considered a hedge against Bitcoin. Other major blockchain platforms like the upcoming Polkadot and Cardano would be hedges against Ethereum and Bitcoin -had it not been for- (hope I'm articulating this right) the philosophical rift of their founding members seeking to improve on their network without causing hard forks which coincidentally happened, both times.
- vmception 5y agoCan you explain how someone that owns an altcoin is manipulating it? If they only have the altcoin then all they can do is sell. Its not like they can manipulate the price upwards unless they have additional assets. For some market participants they have multiple pools of capital. But the mere existence of consolidated ownership doesn't mean its manipulated because that alone doesn't make sense? Curious if you could articulate the process you imagined. I've seen your version of events mentioned alot on twitter, discord, telegram and similar threads, but its just like the reductive "must be money laundering" comment also often seen, how does that work exactly?
- sb057 5y agoMoney is largely controlled by a small group of investors and central banks. [citation needed]
- pcwalton 5y agoThe difference is that traditional money is up front about that fact and doesn't use decentralization as a selling point.
- nickpinkston 5y ago100% this
- KennyBlanken 5y agoThis sort of comment adds nothing of value whatsoever to the discussion.
- glenvdb 5y agoWell... neither does your's, or this one for that matter.
- tshaddox 5y agoWell and also the government doesn’t need to have a “selling point” because of the whole being the government thing.
- anonporridge 5y agoThere seems to be a weird perception that decentralization means that there won't be inequality of power in the system. That's not what it means. Decentralization simply means that there is no central power that can make unilateral decisions about the system like a government can with its currency. This explicit decentralization of power is what people are excited about, because it means any change to the system requires a supermajority of consent and there are no central points of attack that power hungry fascists can target and take over. Centralization can be incredibly efficient, but also incredibly fragile. Bitcoin is the anti fragile monetary system.
- latchkey 5y ago> the ecosystem is still dominated by a concentration of key players, making the ecosystem susceptible to systemic risk like a 51 percent attack, where a group of miners could take control of the majority of the network. Never mind that doing so would destroy the value of the cap/opex invested. But yea... bitcoin is dead, again.
- pcwalton 5y ago> Never mind that doing so would destroy the value of the cap/opex invested. "Bitcoin is centralized, but that's OK because the central authorities can be trusted to do the right thing" isn't exactly a compelling argument. Especially when decentralization is supposed to be one of Bitcoin's major selling points.
- Kranar 5y agoThe people you consider to be central authorities in Bitcoin can not and are not generally trusted to do the right thing. The biggest Bitcoin miner is Bitmain and they have repeatedly tried to subvert Bitcoin such as through the creation of Bitcoin Cash and attempting numerous times to pull off hard forks or oppose updates to Bitcoin. The fact that those efforts have failed, despite them being the largest miner, is pretty strong evidence that Bitcoin is not under the control of any small group of people.
- latchkey 5y agoGreat answer and totally right. There also is no "central authority" since anyone can become a validator. Bitmain, while absolutely huge producer of hardware and a miner, is not the only manufacturer of the hardware. Even better, there is a giant financial incentive to build the best miner [1]. [1] https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/15/square-ceo-jack-dorsey-says-looking-to-build-bitcoin-mining-system.html https://www.cnbc.com/2021/10/15/square-ceo-jack-dorsey-says-...
- littlestymaar 5y ago> since anyone can become a validator By this reasoning, there is no central authority in the dollar system since anyone could become chair of the federal reserve. The odds for an individual without specific hardware to actually mine (and then becoming a validator) a single block are extremely thin. (Granted it's more likely than becoming the chair of the Fed, but less likely than becoming the head of the central bank of Malta for a citizen of that country …)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ofou 5y agoHow much does it cost the sum of all BTC mining?
- graeme 5y agoEasy to calculate. Assuming an efficient mining market, yearly costs are 900 * 365 * price of bitcoin. 900 is the number of new coins mined per day. At current market price, $60,000, bitcoin costs $19.7 billion USD. Or, 13x Tesla’s famous investment. You’d need a Tesla sized investment every month for a year just to balance sell pressure from miners. This is without any existing investor cashing out. And this scales linearly with market price. People often talk of BTC to $1 million. 900 * 365 * $1,000,000 = $328, 500,000 Almost $1 billion per day. The 900 will change to 450 in about 3 years after the next halving, but until then that’s the cost formula. Madness if you ask me. Bitcoin is a heavily negative sum game. You can only take out what others put in, and miners have to take out their share as well, a negative dividend.
- nazgulnarsil 5y agoaround 500 million in USD demand flows into gold daily, what's your point?
- fastball 5y agoThere are only 2,144,500 BTC left to mine. That's 6.5 years at a 900 per day rate.
- graeme 5y agoYeah the halvings slow it. Every four years the rate halves. We’re 2.5-3 years away from next one. Then 450, 225, 112.25 etc
- nightski 5y agoGold trades something like $183 BN per day. U.S. Equities something like $240 BN per day. These are very rough figures. But Bitcoin is worldwide and I don't see how you are hung up on $1B / day. Bitcoin volume in the past 24 hours was actually $36 BN.
- buryat 5y agohow many tullips did the famous families own?
- latchkey 5y agoAlso: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/there-never-was-real-tulip-fever-180964915/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/history/there-never-was-real-...
- buryat 5y agono famous families owned tullips?
- exporectomy 5y agoYou mean gold?
- wsc981 5y agoThe famous (wealthy) families were mainly involved in the trade, I guess. Not so much the common man: > Prices could be high, but mostly they weren’t. Although it’s true that the most expensive tulips of all cost around 5,000 guilders (the price of a well-appointed house), I was able to identify only 37 people who spent more than 300 guilders on bulbs, around the yearly wage of a master craftsman. Many tulips were far cheaper. With one or two exceptions, these top buyers came from the wealthy merchant class and were well able to afford the bulbs. Far from every chimneysweep or weaver being involved in the trade, the numbers were relatively small, mainly from the merchant and skilled artisan class – and many of the buyers and sellers were connected to each other by family, religion, or neighbourhood. Sellers mainly sold to people they knew. > When the crash came, it was not because of naive and uninformed people entering the market, but probably through fears of oversupply and the unsustainability of the great price rise in the first five weeks of 1637. None of the bulbs were actually available – they were all planted in the ground – and no money would be exchanged until the bulbs could be handed over in May or June. So those who lost money in the February crash did so only notionally: they might not get paid later. Anyone who had both bought and sold a tulip on paper since the summer of 1636 had lost nothing. Only those waiting for payment were in trouble, and they were people able to bear the loss. > No one drowned themselves in canals. I found not a single bankrupt in these years who could be identified as someone dealt the fatal financial blow by tulip mania. If tulip buyers and sellers appear in the bankruptcy records, it’s because they were buying houses and goods of other people who had gone bankrupt for some reason – they still had plenty of money to spend. The Dutch economy was left completely unaffected. The “government” (not a very useful term for the federal Dutch Republic) did not shut down the trade, and indeed reacted slowly and hesitantly to demands from some traders and city councils to resolve disputes. The provincial court of Holland suggested that people talk it out among themselves and try to stay out of the courts: no government regulation here. [0]: https://theconversation.com/tulip-mania-the-classic-story-of https://theconversation.com/tulip-mania-the-classic-story-of...
- ajkdhcb2 5y agoUsers, miners and developers all have different powers and hold each other to account in an interesting way that few people understand so far, affecting what 'control' really means. It needs to be put in context with alternatives. Compared to the alternative of corrupt governments that have complete control to print money at will, I have no doubt that it is a extremely promising experiment. ASICs do seem to pervert some incentives so people should be more interested in modified Proof-of-Work algorithms like Monero has been doing successfully
- jayd16 5y agoIn what way do users have control over miners or developers? If the assumption is that corruption can overcome a democratic state, I never understood why its so crazy to suggest it can overcome developers or a mining cartel.
- ajkdhcb2 5y agoDevelopers are wasting their time if nobody wants to use what they develop. Miners lose their income if they are mining blocks on a chain that nobody wants to use. Users running software nodes validates the blocks, limiting what miners can do. Miners can be pushed to change the rules with methods like a 'User Activated Soft Fork'. The proof of work algorithm can even be changed, rendering all the ASIC hardware of the mining industry worthless.
- matteotom 5y agoCorrupt governments and central banks can be pushed to change the rules with methods like "voting" or "mass protests".
- sunshinerag 5y agoExcept corrupt governments and central banks do not care for either. Central bank policies are not subject to voting by people. Did any of us vote for bailouts, QE?. corrupt governments also know how to suppress "mass protests". If these are the only ways to hold them to account how would that work.
- mike_d 5y ago2,153 billionaires have more wealth than the 4.6 billion people who make up 60 percent of the planet’s population [1]. Calling 10,000 unaffiliated people "a small group" by comparison is kind of disingenuous. 1. https://oxfamilibrary.openrepository.com/bitstream/handle/10546/620928/bp-time-to-care-inequality-200120-en.pdf https://oxfamilibrary.openrepository.com/bitstream/handle/10...
- jayd16 5y agoThis is just desperate whataboutism. The inequality of life is certainly brutal but it doesn't make Bitcoin a populous utopia either. Besides that the numbers aren't equivalent. Holding stake and controlling its exchange are not the same thing, at least not for Bitcoin or democratic state controlled currencies.
- mike_d 5y agoCalling out poor editorialization of the original papers findings isn't whataboutism, but thanks for playing.
- jayd16 5y agoJust denying something and tacking on but thanks for playing isn't a rebuttal.
- rglover 5y agoA decentralized money that government can't touch is the definition of a populous utopia in money terms. Bitcoin, by nature, is the most democratic form of money to ever exist on the planet. That more people don't get behind it and buy at least a little bit is mind boggling. Government fiat is and always will be a source of controlling the population and limiting their ability to build wealth.
- jayd16 5y agoI have at least some control (though small) over the politics that control my nation's fiat currency. I feel I have much less control over 51% of the mining community. Considering that, why should I feel its more democratic?
- jonas21 5y agoThe Techspot article is a summary of this Bloomberg piece: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-10-25/bitcoin-still-concentrated-in-few-hands-study-finds https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-10-25/bitcoin-s... which is itself reporting on this paper from the NBER: https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29396/w29396.pdf https://www.nber.org/system/files/working_papers/w29396/w293...
- YossarianFrPrez 5y agoInteresting quotes from the first section of the paper: "We first document that 90% of transaction volume on the Bitcoin blockchain is not tied to economically meaningful activities but is the byproduct of the Bitcoin protocol design as well as the preference of many participants for anonymity." "We show that the Bitcoin mining capacity is highly concentrated and has been for the last five years. The top 10% of miners control 90% and just 0.1% (about 50 miners) control close to 50% of mining capacity. Furthermore, this concentration of mining capacity is counter cyclical and varies with the Bitcoin price." "We show that the balances held at intermediaries have been steadily increasing since 2014. By the end of 2020 it is equal to 5.5 million bitcoins, roughly one-third of Bitcoin in circulation. In contrast, individual investors collectively control 8.5 million bitcoins by the end of 2020. The individual holdings are still highly concentrated: the top 1000 investors control about 3 million BTC and the top 10,000 investors own around 5 million bitcoins." I haven't read the methods yet, but the idea that the authors were able to do this analysis is fascinating.
- paisawalla 5y agoAs someone who's read the paper, do you know how they account for ownership by exchanges? There's got to be a large amount of BTC that is held in Coinbase's wallets, but actually owned by many more individuals. I.e. isn't the BTC I have parked at Coinbase is in the same wallet as many of their other customers' BTC, and shows up on the blockchain as one owner by this analysis?
- rmbyrro 5y ago
- CryptoPunk 5y agoImportantly, distributed public blockchains like Bitcoin and Ethereum don't give large holders the power to tax other participants, engage in seigniorage (1), or censor transactions and thereby become gatekeepers/tollgaters. (1) PoW hardware or staked coins, in PoW and PoS Sybil control mechanisms, respectively, do give their owners the power to issue new currency and collect transaction fees, but it is an open market where all capital earns the same percentage return, and thereby does not exacerbate wealth inequality.
- 8note 5y agoI'd consider the deflation to be a tax.
- armenarmen 5y agoIsn’t it the exact opposite?
- anonporridge 5y agoYes. Inflation is a tax.
- superice 5y agoInflation is a "tax" on owning money, an equalizing force if you will. Deflation is a "tax" imposed that benefits large holders of the currency on people who hold less or none of that currency. There is ofcourse also the moral argument for inflation: society pays you because you it values what you sold or did. That valuable service is not going to be worth as much 50 years into the future, so inflation is the cost imposed on withholding that money from public circulation for your private benefit of being able to decide 50 years later what you do with that money for a thing you did back then.
- runeks 5y ago> Inflation is a "tax" on owning money, an equalizing force if you will. Deflation is a "tax" imposed that benefits large holders of the currency on people who hold less or none of that currency. The problem is that these “large holders of currency” are the poorest people. Rich people have their wealth invested in various assets, e.g. stocks, bonds, land. The poorest people live paycheck to paycheck and can’t possibly invest in anything.
- smashem 5y ago"Control" is such an interesting word in this case.
- wmf 5y agoWhy?
- ceilingcorner 5y ago> the top 10,000 individual Bitcoin investors control roughly one third of the cryptocurrency in circulation. The relevant comparison here is to other currencies, not to organizations in general, and to the ability and incentive of these controllers to influence the trajectory of the currency. Two points: 1. 10,000 people controlling 33% is dramatically less control and centralization than the Federal Reserve, which ultimately has about 10 powerful people. 2. These 10,000 people have very little ability and even less incentive to affect the price of Bitcoin. Again, unlike the Fed, which can print money at will and increase inflation.
- neaanopri 5y agoThe federal reserve exists at the pleasure of Congress, and Congress can abolish the fed if it chooses to.
- goldenkey 5y agoSomething something JFK's head blown off.
- rglover 5y agoYou have a lot to learn. https://www.amazon.com/Creature-Jekyll-Island-Federal-Reserve/dp/091298645X https://www.amazon.com/Creature-Jekyll-Island-Federal-Reserv...
- matteotom 5y agoIt would be more helpful if you could actually state an opinion or viewpoint rather than linking to a whole book (which, unless I'm missing it, doesn't even have a description).
- ur-whale 5y ago> The federal reserve exists at the pleasure of Congress That's the theory. In practice, there's always this aspect to consider (attributed to a Rothschild familly member in the 19th century): "Permit me to issue and control the money of a nation, and I care not who makes its laws"
- EastOfTruth 5y agoIt would be much worst if they would switch to proof of stake... because a few tend to hold all the wealth.
- adriancarrieres 5y agoHow surprising /s
- m0zg 5y agoThing is, though, USD is controlled by an even smaller group. Between BTC and fiat, BTC seems like a safer choice at the moment - at the very minimum you can't just go ahead and double the supply. Obvs, not financial advice and all that.
- ehnto 5y agoIt seems like Bitcoin's value is at least partly based on it being fungible to USD. Even though you can technically turn it into many currencies, would a halved USD value not influence the value of BTC as well?
- m0zg 5y agoIt would affect its value wrt USD for sure, by driving it higher. Bitcoin is, at this point, the new "gold standard", and that is by design. You can increase the supply some, but it's exponentially hard to do so, just like with gold - all the easy deposits are long gone. Whereas increasing the supply of USD boils down to a single database "update" statement. I'm exaggerating for dramatic effect, obviously, but not by all that much.
- KennyBlanken 5y ago> Thing is, though, USD is controlled by an even smaller group You can't "control" a currency as widely used as the USD. The Fed (and other countries, and large enough institutions) can try to influence it. The chair of the Fed doesn't just wake up one morning and say "you know, I think I'll do X to the value of the USD." US monetary policy in the very simplest sense is controlled by a small group (governors of the fed) but those people are nominated by the president, appointed by congress. We know who they are, and they do not operate in an isolation chamber. The president can remove them, though not without potential economic and political repercussions. Their actions have to pass muster with a lot of people - for example, investors on the stock market, other countries (ex: China holds a foreign reserve of over a trillion dollars. That is a fairly sizeable lever. But using that lever, again, has repercussions.) The people who control Bitcoin and do the majority of the mining aren't even known. We have no idea how many of them there really are (as pointed out in the article, one person could have an unlimited number of addresses.) There are effectively no repercussions for their actions other than the value of BTC changing. We have no idea if they are colluding. There's nothing whatsoever anyone can do to influence them from taking action that are not in the best interests of stability, the currency, the people using the currency, etc. Someone mentioned recently that a couple of years ago, some people coordinated enough between themselves that they were able to force a rollback of the blockchain...
- McGuive7 5y agoSoooo. . . you're saying a tiny fraction of the population controls the vast majority of the resource? You mean just like every other major resource on the planet? :)
- nuerow 5y ago> Soooo. . . you're saying a tiny fraction of the population controls the vast majority of the resource? You mean just like every other major resource on the planet? :) I understand the need to try to dismiss this problem, specially from those who have a dog in the race, but the dream of having a magical pseudo-currency that solves all problems and unexplainably makes everyone richer and richer just falls out flat if there are actually men behind the curtain manipulating it's value to screw everyone over in order to benefit themselves.
- jimbob45 5y agoI have this problem with crypto in general on here where I can’t trust anyone with pushing arguments centered around pathos or ethos because I can never know if they’re just trying to gin up support for crypto in general so that theirs isn’t the final level of the Ponzi scheme. To everyone I’ve misjudged who genuinely enjoys the theory being crypto: I’m sorry.
- joshuaissac 5y ago> if there are actually men behind the curtain manipulating it's value to screw everyone over in order to benefit themselves The article does not support the claim that the top investors and miners are engaging in cryptocurrency manipulation with bitcoin.
- anonporridge 5y ago> magical pseudo-currency that solves all problems and unexplainably makes everyone richer and richer That's not what's exciting about bitcoin. What's exciting is that it is the first digital, global money that isn't protected by the proof of violence of the state. The US dollar is the world reserve currency because the United States is the best in the world at deploying destructive power, and the British and French currency before that when they were at the height of their power. It's a neutral currency that every nation state on the planet can be ok with, because the system is completely agnostic to who the participants are. The only thing it requires is that you have hash power and internet connectivity. Nation states will have proportional power in the system based on their respective abilities to deploy energy and compute power to the security of the network.
- differentView 5y agoPhilosophical and moral discussions aside, is there any technical risk to this?
- schleck8 5y agoExtreme power consumption and speed. Bitcoin is very inefficient by crypto standards.
- ArtTimeInvestor 5y agoControl is only a problem if the incentives of the person in control are not aligned with ones own incentives. When you drive on the highway, every single driver in the oncoming traffic is in control of a car that would kill you if they just decide to move their steering wheel into your direction. Luckily, there is little incentive for them to do so. So driving is relatively safe. When you invest into Bitcoin, there might or might not be people who could devalue it to some degree. Luckily, those are the people with a substantial investment in the same asset you are invested in. So there is no incentive for them to do so. When you invest in fiat currency, the incentive of the people in power are completely misaligned with the holders of that currency. The people in power gain more power by printing fiat that they then can spend.
- ur-whale 5y agoYeah, many people seem to completely miss the game-theoretical feedback loops built into Bitcoin, the most obvious of which being "fuck with the system, shoot yourself in the foot".
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoOwners of coins have absolutely no control over bitcoin. They can't "vote" with their coins for any change in the protocol. Miners can, but to a very small degree. The real control lies in the hands of those who hold keys to Bitcoin GitHub repository, bitcoin.org web site and /r/Bitcoin subreddit. They can do whatever they want - increase block size, change mining algorithm, increase Bitcoin supply etc.
- ur-whale 5y ago> They can do whatever they want - increase block size, change mining algorithm, increase Bitcoin supply etc. I won't deny that they do hold some power, but I don't think it is as complete as you claim. There is in effect counter-powers to the devs: miners and users. Imagine a scenario where the guys who have commit access tot the repo decided to change the block size via a hard fork (much like what happened with bitcoin cash). The next day, there would be a new github repo with the unforked original code, and there would be two Bitcoins sharing a common history up until the fork. Some miners would switch to the new fork, some would stay on the original one. Much like what happened with bcash, there would quickly be people selling the fork they don't believe in and buying the one they like. Before long, the users (and the miners) would essentially do what amounts to a vote (some with mining power, others with buying and selling), and we would end up in a situation like the one we have today: BTC at $66000, BCASH at $600. So, some power (like with the taproot upgrade, which ended up having actual consensus with miners and did not create a revolution with the users), not absolute power to decide what Bitcoin is and isn't.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoThis is where the subreddit part comes along. You just ban all users disagreeing with your intended change and voila - you have 100% popular support for your change.
- ur-whale 5y ago> This is where the subreddit part comes along. r/bitcoin is and has been for a very long time an absolute cesspit, even before the censorship plays came about. No one I know really interested/involved in Bitcoin goes there anymore.
- sunshinerag 5y agowhat does control mean here? they can print more bitcoins into existence? they can fake a transaction? they can undo a transaction? they can steal from other wallets?
- supermatt 5y agoThey can undo transactions. Its a bit more complicated than that, but thats the gist of what control enables. Basically, the first to mine a block has control over the history since the previously mined block. Because they have superior mining capability, they are more likely to be first to mine a block. They are also able to refuse to accept others blocks, which could effectively fork the blockchain, causing a split head, which results in other other issues. EDIT: just reread, and theres 2 aspects to control. Theres the mining aspect (which i mention above) and then there is the market manipulation aspect (which is to do with pump/dump - unrelated to above).
- ur-whale 5y ago> what does control mean here? In this particular instance, it means "they have more than me".
- EdwardDiego 5y agoYou're aware of a 51% attack yeah?
- 8eye 5y agois techspot a credible source? asking honestly, first time i saw their content
- nathias 5y agoThe centralization of mining is a known problem for more than 10 years and is exactly the reason that altcoins exist.
- sam0x17 5y agoThe death-knell in my opinion for true decentralization of the bitcoin network (ignoring mining for a moment) happened when the blockchain became too large for it to be practical for normal users to have the whole blockchain on their machine and operate a real node. I am sure there is some creative solution to this, perhaps an additional mining process by which old records are combined to save space (i.e. transactions older than a week get squashed so that only the resulting balance is stored instead of the individual transactions, perhaps). It might also help to not even store information about a wallet address on the blockchain unless it has a nonzero balance. I have no idea how this is actually implemented so this is all speculation.
- janandonly 5y agoThe current BTC blockchain size is 422GB [1] so that easily fits on a single 1TB SSD. How is that "too large" ? [1] https://bitcoin.clarkmoody.com/dashboard/ https://bitcoin.clarkmoody.com/dashboard/
- runeks 5y agoYou can easily store the blockchain (which is mostly historical data, ie. “empty accounts”) on an old (rotational) HDD because you access it in a sequential manner, which is fine for old HDDs. It’s only the set of “non-empty accounts” (unspent transaction outputs in technical terms) that you need random access to. But this data can be stored in RAM since it’s only about 3.5GiB.
- krageon 5y agoWho has ~250 euros (excluding the machine this SSD has to be in) to drop on a random hobby?
- robocat 5y ago“The 50 richest Americans now hold almost as much wealth as half of the U.S.” - Bloomberg - https://archive.vn/25Bz4 https://archive.vn/25Bz4 Is there any reason to think bitcoin is that much different from ownership ratios of other financial assets?
- qeternity 5y agoYes, we know who those 50 are, and the wealth they own is in highly regulated markets. We know what they own, how much they own, when they buy/sell. We also dictate that they cannot trade on insider info and must generally play fair. Say all you want about the efficacy of the above measures, they are absolutely not perfect. But it's completely different to bitcoin where none of the above applies, and often the opposite occurs.
- cwkoss 5y agoBetween international holdings and shell companies, I'd be impressed if anyone could generate a top 50 list that was more than 60% accurate. We can generate top 50 lists of the more-regulated wealth, but there is also significant wealth hiding with little accountability.
- AlwaysRock 5y agoDo you? We know some of the people. Do you actually know who controls the majority of the globes wealth or are you just happy knowing you could probably look it up while with Bitcoin you couldnt? Functionally I don't really see a difference.
- Softcadbury 5y agoExactly, and they can't influence on the price of the dollar by selling all their assets
- krageon 5y ago> highly regulated Regulated by them, so in practice not all that regulated
- chrischen 5y agoSounds like crypto is just another way for anarcho-capitalists to learn the hard way about wealth distribution and income equality.
- LittlePeter 5y agoI am really tired of Bitcoin articles with pictures of physical Bitcoin. It is silly. Let go of the past. Show instead a mining farm or something. It also confuses older people who may read the article then ask their children to buy them one of those physical Bitcoins.
- sandworm101 5y agoI don't see the problem. Compared to the disparity in realwrold money (dollars) Bitcoin distribution seems rather flat. How many of the world's supply of dollars are controlled by the top 10,000 richest people?
- chmod775 5y agoI've become very disillusioned with this currency. So far the only things of note that Bitcoin has achieved is having a considerable impact on global warming and making it near impossible for mere mortals to buy GPUs at reasonable prices. Even if any of the touted advantages were to finally materialize now, it wouldn't have been worth it.
- abrkn 5y agoGPUs are not used for Bitcoin mining
- thr0waw4yz 5y agoWithout bitcoin, there wouldn't be cryptocurrencies mined with GPUs.
- chmod775 5y agoOn Ebay I can find around a dozen people just in my local area trying to sell their mining rigs with stuff like 5 x 3070 cards: https://i.imgur.com/nI8GYsG.png https://i.imgur.com/nI8GYsG.png Graphics cards were definitely bought in stupid amounts for this purpose. Maybe not for Bitcoin anymore, since there is specialized hardware now, but it doesn't really matter which proof-of-watts-per-hour cryptocurrency we're talking about. They're all shit and the planet would be better off without them.
- cwkoss 5y agoGPUs haven't been profitable for bitcoin mining for ~8 years. Only people who are rationally mining bitcoin with GPUs are those who don't pay for their own power. Hashes per watt efficiency has risen very fast.
- webinvest 5y agoThey’re not for Bitcoin. ASICS are used for mining Bitcoin, not GPUs. Notice which cryptocurrency they’re for.
- SergeAx 5y ago> top 10,000 individual Bitcoin investors control roughly one third of the cryptocurrency in circulation > top 1,000 individual investors accounted for about three million of the 8.5 million Bitcoins controlled by the top 10,000 investors I beleive same stats are available for stock markets. I wonder what numbers are there.
- peskysamurai 5y agoAccording to the article below, it seems like there’s a similar level of inequality in the stock market as well. https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2021/10/ownership-inequality-in-the-stock-market/ https://awealthofcommonsense.com/2021/10/ownership-inequalit...
- danbruc 5y agoBut are stocks the the appropriate thing to compare Bitcoin with? Why stocks and not money supply? And do you pick a national stock market or money supply or do you sum across the globe? But maybe it also does not really matter and all those things have similar distributions.
- fsflover 5y agoIt probably just means that stock owners bought bitcoins.
- SergeAx 5y agoI believe that currently Bitcoin is much more investment vehicle than payment matter.
- danbruc 5y agoIn which case I don't care. If you offer 10% of your company and keep 90%, the allocation is heavily skewed, but whatever, it's your company and before you offered 10% in stocks it was skewed even heavier, you owned 100%. But if the government would give a third of all the money that will ever be printed to a small group of people, that does not sound like a currency I would want to adopt.
- hnbad 5y agoThe majority of crypto is controlled by a small group of extremely rich people? Wait until you hear about the proportions in other industries that have a far more direct impact on the real world than Internet funny money does.
- longhand 5y agoHere’s a good counter-thesis: https://mobile.twitter.com/n3ocortex/status/1356673243734822912 https://mobile.twitter.com/n3ocortex/status/1356673243734822...
- mudlus 5y agoHow was, or is, this avoidable even now, and in existing monetary systems? One caveat is that though there are a few major actors, no one can be sure where they are physically. It is detached from political jurisdictions, which is the unique goal of Bitcoin.
- rini17 5y agoThere's confluence of factors that naturally results in power law (or pareto's law) distribution. The direct consequence is "stuff largely controlled by small group". How to mitigate that? It is IMO understudied area of economics because economists prefer thinking of "value" of anything as a scalar, not as random variable. In cases where it isn't possible they just conveniently assume normal/gaussian random distribution. (See @nntaleb)
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> How was, or is, this avoidable even now, and in existing monetary systems? Transfer payments. Historically made under the threat of violence by a populist king or warlord. Who, in almost all cases where the transfer payments continued, was swiftly replaced by a republic. Bitcoin turns the clock back to the feudal reality of land-owning nobles. We just made the cost of defending the land vanishing.
- olalonde 5y agoThat's a pretty misleading headline. Miners and investors do not control Bitcoin regardless of their hash power or amount of BTC owned. 50+ miners is also well enough to prevent any 51% attack. Finally, the ownership estimate is flawed given that it relies on blockchain analysis. The existence and popularity of custodial wallets (e.g. exchanges) makes this sort of analysis extremely unreliable.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> 50+ miners is also well enough to prevent any 51% attack That number sounds trivial for even a very wealthy private individual to get them each in a vulnerable position. For example, how many are in China or the U.S.’s reach? Because that means literally two people, Xi and POTUS, could round them up and effect a change. (Not saying they would. But a damning vulnerability for a libertarian ideal.)
- olalonde 5y ago> Not saying they would. Incentives are actually an important part of the equation. Why would a wealthy individual or government spend billions of dollars to do a 51% attack? There's basically no incentive to do so. The best they could achieve is to censor transactions for a while until the Bitcoin community decides to fork to a slightly different PoW algorithm.
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Why would a wealthy individual or government spend billions of dollars to do a 51% attack? There's basically no incentive to do so. China has banned cryptocurrencies [1]. So there is precedent. (Until recently, I believed nobody had an incentive to mess with cryptocurrencies. They're too niche and too attractive as a revenue source.) > best they could achieve is to censor transactions for a while until the Bitcoin community decides to fork to a slightly different PoW algorithm In the scenario that close to 50% of Bitcoin miners and a similar fraction of Bitcoins become possibly (though not irrefutably) state controlled, you're claiming it would be trivial to just fork them away? Who makes that decision? If those people can just uncoin wallets of their choosing, why bother with a cryptocurrency in the first place? [1] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/24/business/china-cryptocurrency-bitcoin.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/24/business/china-cryptocurr...
- jessaustin 5y agoSomeone should put together some sort of counter-BTC investment vehicle, so all of these loud-and-proud BTC skeptics can put their money where their mouths are. It's really unfair to them that the only people benefiting from BTC price movements are those who hold BTC.
- jrsj 5y agoMaybe I’m paranoid but I wonder if the whole reason these articles are even coming out now is to help drive price down sharply enough to crush leveraged longs before the bull run resumes
- LocalH 5y agoIn theory, Bitcoin was decentralized. Then again, in theory, theory always trumps practice.
- tata71 5y agoIt still is. Money ebbs and flows with time. It may be a long time, but... Anyway, we won. The attributes in the title look like the ones that describe a currency to me!
- mattwilsonn888 5y agoThere is an obvious misconception in the title; two in fact: 1. If you are saying that investors separate from miners have "control" over Bitcoin, then you are strictly talking about the price and not the protocol. Investors (who are not miners, so no point in mentioning them) have zero influence over the Bitcoin protocol on a technical level. Perhaps you could make a separate argument about manipulating the community. 2. Barring the previous misnomer, miners alone do not control the Bitcoin protocol. Miners in combination with full nodes (running a full node requires a relatively tiny investment compared to mining) control the future of the Bitcoin protocol. Miners may choose to go down a certain protocol or ledger altering fork, but if even a small amount of full nodes go a different direction and users/holders follow the full nodes, then the path the full nodes chose will "win out," or at least survive. If you want to talk about investors controlling crypto currencies at any scale, then look towards proof of stake. Otherwise you are conflating price control and protocol control.
- frankfury 5y agoThat's how things work. Early adopters are the first one who owns the majority. You can't definitely deny that.
- nathias 5y agohttps://insights.glassnode.com/bitcoin-supply-distribution/ https://insights.glassnode.com/bitcoin-supply-distribution/
- spraveenitpro 5y ago67 Rich people in the world own the same wealth as the bottom half of the world.
- kerng 5y agoThis is a good article, that hopefully can lead to some insightful discussions. One thing the article or some people interpreting the article miss is that miners actually don't control the future of bitcoin as much as they think. From 2017 we actually know that the people running the nodes have more power then the big miners - because the biggest miners back then were not able to push the protocol changes (like block size) through - because nodes just didnt validate/accept those new blocks. So in the end the end user decides. This is true for changes to the protocol or code, it is not true for doing fraudulent transactions within the current protocol version. So colluding miners can have impact in that realm I'd say.
- LoveMortuus 5y agoIsn't this basically the 80/20 principle that's present pretty much everywhere in life?