12 ms·
Privacy Is a Human Right
- apples_oranges 5y agoWe should probably take worldwide action with regard to biometrics and tracking. Face recognition and tracking should be completely outlawed, just like biological weapons.
- beambot 5y agoMeanwhile, at the intersection of crypto & biometrics: Edward Snowden Slams Sam Altman's Worldcoin: 'Don't Catalogue Eyeballs' https://decrypt.co/84277/snowden-slams-sam-altman-worldcoin-eyeball-scan-for-crypto https://decrypt.co/84277/snowden-slams-sam-altman-worldcoin-...
- hef19898 5y agoSam Altman is behind the eyeball crypto? I didn't know that...
- nivenkos 5y agoWhy? I think the better approach is to take steps to stop the centralisation of power. Breaking up the mass media corporations, regulating ownership of media, introducing proportional representation and more direct democracy, abolishing the domestic intelligence services, etc. Trying to ban technology just because it _could_ be used for bad things seems as misguided as it is ineffective. The security agencies and authoritarian governments can just ignore those agreements anyway.
- genewitch 5y agoCapitalism, for lack of a better term, makes conglomerates and winners, in the sense of huge multinationals. Breaking a huge corporation up doesn't really solve anything. Where's Ma Bell? - sent from my post-Bell breakup cellular connection but still totally Bell. (Southwestern... Some DNS responses still show SWBC!)
- rz2k 5y agoI'd add autonomous weapons to that list. They all sound like absurd restrictions, then you imagine from the perspective of a different landscape where those were actually prevented. Then it starts to be unconscionable that the annual body-count from these technologies is accelerating.
- grumbel 5y agoThat's like outlawing knifes instead of murder. We should outlaw what the tech is used for, not the tech itself. Doing the later will just mean companies switch to other equally effective technology.
- moffkalast 5y ago"It's not face recognition, it's a gait and hair identification system! We're breaking no laws..."
- ido66667 5y agoCertain technologies are simply too abusable to be unrestricted. In fact, many technologies only exist to do things we consider wrong, so we outlaw them. Granted, many times these laws are not well enforced.
- sneak 5y agoI hope that more apps can embed tor in the future to hide client unique identifiers (primarily IP, which is city-level geolocation) from services. Trusting Apple with your strongly-ID-linked payment cards for iCloud subscriptions to hide your IP from backend services is sort of a contradiction.
- genewitch 5y agoI agree, even though my IP is part of a huge bank out of Dallas, and driving to the DC and back would take 16 hours. But that's neither here nor there.
- nathias 5y ago'All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They are endowed with reason and conscience and should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.' Even just dignity implies privacy, and not being sold as cattle (selling the app with a userbase definitely qualifies).
- vadfa 5y agoThe Tor project took a political stance a few years ago for no discernible reason at all. To me, Tor is a software project that runs a network that allows users to be anonymous. Period. That anonimity can be used for good or evil, and everybody has a different sense of good or evil. Rebranding the project as a way to spread western liberal values is, in my opinion, overstepping the boundaries of what a software project should be. (One can see an analogy between this change and the changes Mozilla took with their software. Unfortunately, there's no "better alternative" to Tor like there is to Firefox)
- ben_w 5y agoI think Tor has to demonstrate that such values are what the project protects in order to stop it being blocked[0] as a tool for criminals. [0] And/or the developers arrested: I’m so not a lawyer that I wouldn’t know even if I tried to read the actual statutes if that response was even possible in the USA
- raxxorrax 5y agoI dislike some of the things we heard from the project and the drama surrounding some parts of the community. But I also don't believe this statement is overly political. If it were, western liberal values are indeed superior to any alternatives having a different perspective on this. Granted, such a project was founded in a country with such values, so why not live by it?
- austincheney 5y agoWorse, by taking this position Tor has no idea what privacy is. Privacy is not anonymity. Anonymity is the right to remain hidden independently of your communications. Privacy is the right to prevent disclosure. If third parties can access your correspondence you have no privacy regardless of your anonymity. If anybody can assert your identity you have no anonymity regardless of your correspondence, if any. The inability to separately define these terms sacrifices them both.
- anonypla 5y agoMy take is: Privacy is when people know who you are but not what you are doing. Anonymity is when people know what you are doing but not who you are (some people will argue this is pseudonymity but I disagree with them in a practical context). Basically Batman is "anonymous" and Bruce Wayne is "private".
- pulse7 5y ago"No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks upon his honour and reputation. Everyone has the right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks." (Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Article 12) NOTE: Emails are correspondence and we all know, that our emails are shared with governments...
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI'm just gonna play the devil's advocate here for a moment, because I do think there is an interesting discussion to have. The argument seems to be that we have rights because the UN says so. Who or what endowed the UN (or anyone else) with the prerogative to declare human rights? Let's imagine a that the UN would change its mind and declares the right to eternal salvation, and mandates that every state submit to the authority of the holy see. If the current rights are "true" human rights, and the right to salvation is a "false" human right, what sets them apart given that the UN in this hypothetical scenario declares them both? How do rights become true or false?
- eej71 5y agoI think you've asked a good question. I would rephrase it a bit as - to what in reality gives rise to the concept rights? The answer in this thread appears to be - if enough of a majority of people in power say its true, then its true.
- mdp2021 5y ago> How do rights become true or false Not «true or false»: part of the "social contract".
- marginalia_nu 5y agoThis doesn't really change the question. If two people (or groups) are arguing over whether something is part of the social contract, how can we tell which of them is correct? This also seems to go against the spirit of human rights. How can we motivate minority rights in a society that feels justified persecuting minorities (i.e. in a society where minority rights are not part of the social contract)?
- davibu 5y ago"The core principle of Tor, Onion routing, was developed in the mid-1990s by United States Naval Research Laboratory employees, mathematician Paul Syverson, and computer scientists Michael G. Reed and David Goldschlag, to protect U.S. intelligence communications online."
- baash05 5y agoCovidSafe begs to differ
- tdrdt 5y agoA lot of people don't know what privacy is. They use the argument 'I have nothing to hide'. But that is not what privacy is about. Privacy is your ability to control what others know about you. A lock on a toilet does this. The ability to hide your IP address does this.
- mdp2021 5y ago> They use the argument 'I have nothing to hide' That """argument""" is what people without any experience, just come out a cave hours ago, could put in their head. Under Pol Pot, people had to hide eyeglasses. And this is just an example that stands for many other instances.
- selestify 5y agoBut are there examples that are more salient to your average civilian with non-controversial politics that lives in a developed democratic nation?
- tdrdt 5y agoYes. For example here on HN a blind programmer posted once he/she often had to hide the fact he/she is blind initially to get a job.
- selestify 5y agoBut the average person isn't blind. I'm looking for cases that will resonate with the average person.
- mdp2021 5y agoJoseph McCarthy.
- mdp2021 5y ago> average civilian Why should the average be relevant. Phrased this way, it seemed that the object of concern are the grayest. > with non-controversial [positions] Are those who decide what takes the label of "controversial" reliable?
- ajkdhcb2 5y agoPayment options are only credit card and PayPal... Wtf? Lost my donation
- Veen 5y agoI'm not sure the "Privacy is a human right" argument really holds water. Privacy is a good thing, and people should be able to control their data. But what the UDHR says about it is neither here nor there. It's non-binding and no government takes it entirely seriously. No corporations have ratified it, so it couldn't bind their behaviour anyway. The International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights is somewhat binding, but the U.S. has so many reservations and opt-outs that it has little impact on domestic law.
- theonemind 5y agoSaying something is a human right seems roughly equivalent to saying sentient beings should not abridge another sentient being's right to something, not that any particular corporation or government accepts or practices it. Human slavery was once completely legal in the United States, and before the declaration of human rights existed, and we could still call that a human rights violation.
- omegaBroom 5y agoIt still is if you are a prisoner: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penal_labor_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penal_labor_in_the_United_Stat...
- genewitch 5y agoAnd why does the US have one of the highest per capita incarceration rates on earth? 23¢ an hour, maybe?
- streamofdigits 5y agoIt is actually more than that. Privacy is exclusively cast as an individual / personal concept. But that is just the basis. If people have no privacy, any organizations, or enterprizes they form have no privacy either. Privacy is one of the very foundations of social and economic organization. It is deeply connected with ownership and agency. Holding on to a private piece of the information universe is what underpins also all civic and commercial activity. It is not clear why we still just talk about privacy instead of actually doing something meaningful about it [0]. This is maybe the most glaring example of how modern society has degenerated / cannot solve any of its self-inflicted diseases. [0] That's obviously not a critisism of the tor project :-), these early pioneers are the saving grace of our society.
- PikachuEXE 5y ago> we still just talk about privacy I am not sure what your "we" refers to. I am sure people can "do more" on improving privacy. But in many places the concept "privacy" is vague, without much explanation of why it's an important concept. And I would like to see more discussions about this concept. I do like you saying "Privacy is exclusively cast as an individual / personal concept". Individuals are the smallest unit in our society and has the least protection against larger groups of people (e.g. companies, governments, other powerful groups). Privacy would be one of the concepts as basis of "individual protection".
- streamofdigits 5y ago"we" as in everybody :-), in particular in our capacity of shaping legal frameworks and regulation maybe there reason there isn't more discussion about something so deeply relevant is that we are already in a stage where what is being discussed is pretty much channeled and controlled. I would imagine if somebody declared "your property ownership is dead, from now on you own nothing" there would be quite a bit more discussion about it.
- PikachuEXE 5y agoThat would be too obvious. The enemies these days will come with "justice" and "ensure your safety" and "save you from dangerous X". And hey just at a price of "a little" privacy and freedom!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoI see an important part of the debate is recognising there are two distinct parts to privacy Secrecy is where you prevent others from having knowledge of a piece of data, or explicitly share it with a limited set of others whom have the same ability to shield the knowledge. This is not privacy obviously. 1. loss of control of knowledge. This is often the bit we worry about. We want to keep control over our data and data about us. But mostly this ship has sailed. Even if there was some reduction in tracking cookies and so on, the usefulness of widespread data collection (from traffic warnings to epidemiology) is enough for most of us to want those benefits in society 2. loss arising from others knowledge or use of data To me this is the kicker. The use by others of our non-secret data-about-us should be at the level of medical data - held and used in the patients best interests. We are entering a world of trolley problems - from how to code driverless cars reactions to what is an is not acceptable use of private data. We need to recognise there is huge upside value in the tracking that happens now (and I hope we will see those benefits whatever) but there are pollution-like downsides and we can massively limit those. The cost benefit analysis should make society judge the loss of a few million(#) in advertising revenue worth this (#) I am dubious about the value assigned to privacy-breaching tracking to drive advertising versus say using the words people type in a search alone to give them a result.
- moffkalast 5y agoI think the medical data example is interesting. Right now where I live medical records are kept in physical cardboard form only in the name of patient confidentiality. So in effect if you go to a new doctor, or get into the ER unconscious they'll have no on-hand data on who you are, what are your allergies or pre-existing conditions. They might actually accidentally kill you over privacy ideals.
- lifeisstillgood 5y agoYes. But we lack two things to make that paper to digital move convincing 1. A clear unambiguous security framework (HSM, FIDO, on disk encryption, standard terminology for roles access etc) that is just as common as HTML. There are so many competing strategies here let alone implementations that we just really need one winner that everyone can just drop in to their industry CRM / HR app whatever 2. Legal framework around private data that has social benefits baked in, but limits the crappy side. 3. Stop thinking we can solve the rest of the worlds problems (with technology). There is a tendency for say crypto or tor to think it will create another Arab Spring and whole world will be free. A far far better bet is to build our democracies better, clean out our corruption and uneven playing fields, to make a free and fair society that is just so damn enviable, others have to follow. Anyway enough of that.
- ebanana 5y agomedical privacy as well or..
- freddyym 5y agoThe best agrument is that privacy is power.[0] It is the power to influence you, show you adverts and predict your behaviour. Our personal data is being used as knowledge against us - as power against us. It is used to make us do things we otherwise would not do: to buy a certain product or to vote a certain way. As companies share more information with governments, they are able to learn more and more about their citizens. Take Facebook, a company that Laura Poitras described as 'a gift to intelligence agencies'[1]. Facebook allows governments to arrest people planning to participate in protests before they have even begun. This is just the tip of the iceberg. Our privacy is eroding. As a society, we are beginning to accept this lack of privacy as normal: and this is extremely dangerous. Privacy provides a place for us to be ourselves, to express ourselves in new ways without fear of being watched by preying eyes. If we lose privacy then we lose this ability to experiment, and, more importantly, we lose our power. [0]https://aeon.co/essays/privacy-matters-because-it-empowers-us-all https://aeon.co/essays/privacy-matters-because-it-empowers-u... [1]https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2014/10/23/snowden-filmmaker-laura-poitras-facebook-is-a-gift-to-intelligence-agencies/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-switch/wp/2014/10/23...
- Valakas_ 5y agoPlaying the devil's advocate here but there could be a good side. It can also help us buy things we didn't know we needed, bringing our unconscious forward and making us realise things about ourselves we didn't know. I wouldn't mind that, if only I knew only I had access to that information though.
- IanSanders 5y ago> It can also help us buy things we didn't know we needed, bringing our unconscious forward and making us realise things about ourselves we didn't know There is no commercial incentive to do any of that
- dexterdog 5y agoMost commercial incentive I have witnessed is to do precisely that.
- qwerty456127 5y agoIn my opinion it's the most important and the most neglected one. General population doesn't care because it doesn't understand how does the Internet and related technologies work and "has nothing to hide". So legislators don't care much either and violate it routinely.
- freddyym 5y agoThe question about privacy is not about hiding, it is about sharing. It is not that I have nothing to hide, I just do not have anything I want to share, especially unknowingly.
- qwerty456127 5y agoGood point. But apparently most of the people don't care.
- freddyym 5y agoA recent study found that younger generations said that it was easier to leave their partner than to leave a company that did not respect their privacy [0]. It is easy to adopt the mindset of 'privacy nihilism'[1]: your data is out there and you cannot escape it. Yet that same aforementioned study also noted that 75% of Americans were concerned about online privacy. And there are more reasons to believe that attitudes to privacy are changing for the better. Research by Demos found that half of young people in the UK said they were either extremely or very concerned by 'online privacy'.[2] Arguably the biggest obstacle to privacy is the effort it requires. People perceive reclaiming privacy to be far harder than it actually is. But for most, privacy is achievable. As individuals, we have the ability to chose which services we use. You might just want to switch to a few more privacy respecting alternatives, using Startpage instead of Google, or ProtonMail instead of GMail. Sites such as Privacy Guides, of which I am a team member, showcase tools and knowledge to protect your privacy. It is surprising how few steps it can take to massively increase your privacy. [0]https://www.securitymagazine.com/gdpr-policy?url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.securitymagazine.com%2Farticles%2F94560-of-americans-very-concerned-about-online-privacy-but-most-dont-take-any-significant-action https://www.securitymagazine.com/gdpr-policy?url=https%3A%2F... [1]https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/08/the-age-of-privacy-nihilism-is-here/568198/ https://www.theatlantic.com/technology/archive/2018/08/the-a... [2]http://demos.co.uk/press-release/demos-young-voters-concerned-more-about-online-privacy-than-immigration-or-the-eu-2/ http://demos.co.uk/press-release/demos-young-voters-concerne...
- Proven 5y agoNot entirely correct. You have the right to privacy on your own property. > With commercially available spyware, with covert monitoring of our communications, with ads that track us around the internet, with pseudo anonymous data sets purchased and sold and used to manipulate sentiment and sew division. If you access the Internet or go to a nearby public park, it's questionable if you have the right to privacy unless you have a contract to that effect (and many of you don't and usually agree to give up privacy). Don't enable JavaScript, use Tor, don't install crap on your phone, use privacy-oriented messaging apps and you won't have issues. You can be for privacy but you don't have to make stuff up. The government has no business protecting you on the Internet just as they have no business stealing money from others to fund that task. As for "with covert monitoring of our communications", most of you voted for Biden & Deep State. Please take your complaints to the White House and don't vote for Deep State candidates.
- shadeofblack 5y agoJust saw this reddit post the other day: https://www.reddit.com/r/offmychest/comments/qfk0zj/if_youre_ambitious_dont_use_coursera_youtube_or/ https://www.reddit.com/r/offmychest/comments/qfk0zj/if_youre...
- pbalau 5y agoWhat does that mean?
- reyqn 5y agoI find it kind of ironic that I'm getting an access denied when trying to view the blog post on my VPN (hosted by OVH) that I'm using specifically to protect my privacy (certificate pinning at work)
- bsedlm 5y agoBut now that everybody's information is on the market, privacy has computable cost, who will pay for your privacy? In general, he advent of information age had turned explicit many formerly implicit costs. I think a similar argument may be made about freedom, it has a cost and somebody has to pay for it (this is my way to reason about the seeming rise of autocracy).
- e0a74c 5y agoDoes anyone know why the tor browser doesn't let users change the guard/entry node and why the guard nodes are often located in the same country as the user? As a dictator who hates free speech and has full control over the tor guard nodes in my country, doesn't this make my job easier?
- beckman466 5y ago> The United Nations codified that in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948. Article 12 states that, “no one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with their privacy” and that “everyone has the right to the protection of the law against such interference or attacks.” the united nations also promises the right to affordable housing... where's my fucking house Blackstone?
- timmattison 5y agoI just get a page that says I’m not authorized to access this page. Privacy to the max!
- naomeux 5y agoI agree that Tor should be modernized. This move will definitely encourage a lot of people to try Tor. After all, privacy is our human right.
- raxxorrax 5y agoI don't even think it needs to be modernized as it has become quite easy to use, even the standard configuration provides some protection*. It needs to be popularized. But for that you must offer a good explanation to common people why their data is worth so much in aggregation and that they might not want to share too much. Far more difficult problem than making it more accessible on the technical side. * and some disadvantagse to privacy if the number of users is low.
- blew_job 5y ago"Human" being the keyword here. You're no longer considered "human" if you have gotten the vaccine, since what has been injected into you is patented. You are no longer considered a human, and you have given up your human rights. You are now, by definition, part of the Transhumanism global agenda.
- gigel82 5y agoThis is a losing battle to be had individually. I don't have the time and energy to regain my privacy. Where do like-minded individuals gather to cooperate?
- derekzhouzhen 5y agoAccording to one of my lawyer friends, there is a subtle difference between US law and EU law regarding privacy: In the US, if you don't protect it and you lose it, it is your fault. In the EU, No one can lawfully take it away from you.
- dukes82 5y agoI believe individual privacy should have an inverse relationship to individual power. The more power an individual wields through wealth, and possibly fame/influence, the less expectation they should have of privacy.