12 ms·
I was very pessimistic about Tesla and confused by their stock price. But I now believe that they indeed are doing it and that we’re finally at the EV revoluti
by Waterluvian 5y ago
I was very pessimistic about Tesla and confused by their stock price.
But I now believe that they indeed are doing it and that we’re finally at the EV revolution.
I’m not an early adopter type and the Teslas don’t excite me at all, but I’m really delighted that the market is evolving. I’m delighted that I was wrong.
- stjohnswarts 5y agoIt's not going to be a revolution despite all the EV bull market folks say, it will be an orderly transition, people are slow to change and adapt and STEM people should accept that. Electric cars are not in any way an order of magnitude upgrade in tech, which is a necessary trait for any technology that claims to be disruptive. Sure from a green perspective it is but not from a pragmatic one. I of course welcome the change. :)
- unpolloloco 5y agoI'd claim it's pragmatic too - but only if you have ability to charge at home AND you have an ICE car as well (maybe). Halving the cost of commute is highly pragmatic! This applies to something like half the population right now (in the US). And we're on the path to alleviate issues for the other half of the population in the next few to several years. The other major issue (which is probably the bigger one) is that car manufacturers other than Tesla can't seem to actually get out enough cars to do anything other than supply California and maybe NY. Teslas are expensive and have a litany of quality issues that push "regulars" away from them. Once Hyundai has an electric that has inventory nationwide at a reasonable price, then we have a revolutionary orderly transition on our hands.
- chinathrow 5y ago> It's not going to be a revolution despite all the EV bull market folks say https://www.drive.com.au/news/norway-to-hit-100-per-cent-electric-vehicle-sales-by-next-year/ https://www.drive.com.au/news/norway-to-hit-100-per-cent-ele... I'd call that a revolution on a small country scale.
- SavantIdiot 5y agoYeah this is kind of a big deal, like inflection-point big deal. Teslas are still for the well-to-do, but making infrastructure available may encourage even more investment in non-upper-end EVs.
- sdhfjg 5y agoTesla might be "...doing it...", but that doesn't mean the stock price isn't confusing.
- chemmail 5y agoTheir price is fine if you look at the Apple analog. Not even knows they want a Tesla like not everyone knew they wanted an iPhone. It's not that they even want one, you basically have to have a smartphone nowdays. EVs will be similar in many many respects. And once someone tries one, that is it. There is no going back. Of coarse there are other brands of smartphones, but not thing comes close to iPhone in terms of the brand, just like Tesla. There will always be metrics other brands can beat Tesla in, but the overall brand and product is unrivaled and will probably be so for the next 10 years. After that though, it's anyone's guess.
- allenleee 5y agoThank you for the honest feedbacks. Respect.
- stmfreak 5y agoTesla’s stock price is confusing if you compare them to a car company. But they are not just a car company. They are also a car manufacturing supply chain, having brought much of their component production in house. They are also an energy company, both generation and storage, but also distribution, like gas stations. Think Exxon, BP, Chevron, ARCO, etc. They are probably a few other things, but this is the mystery of their valuation.
- rich_sasha 5y agoThat’s true. But also, presumably, these companies outsourced their supply chains etc because it was (or seemed) profitable. There is still a disconnect for me. First everyone outsources, apparently successfully for automotive, and that’s great, all these joint ventures between car makers etc. Then Tesl comes along, integrates everything, and poof that’s also good..?
- jjeaff 5y agoI'm guessing the automotive industry benefited more from outsourcing because they were heavily unionized. Outsourcing parts allowed them to get the parts from sub-contractors that didn't have to pay union wages. Tesla started much later and didn't have this problem.
- rich_sasha 5y agoSo is Tesla another labour rights arbitrage at heart? That would make me sad. It feels to me that even taking the company at face value, this valuation is just silly. And I thought that for years, so clearly as a short-seller I’d be toast. But the more the price levitates, the more unreal it feels.
- panick21_ 5y agoNo it isn't. The difference between union and non union is far smaller then people have in the idealistic fantasies. Tesla employees are payed just as well, and with stock options they actually historically have been paid WAY, WAY better. The thing about Tesla is that its forward looking for a long time since they have a stable leadership with a clear long term plan. This leadership has been leading the company for more then a decade and all their plans have worked out. Tesla now certainty is worth now what they were valued at a few years ago. For myself, I would already consider electric flight as part of their future revenue. Its a logical next step but it will take 10 years. Of course I can understand that other people think this is crazy. But flat out, for me, I see them growing 50% a year for many more years with no end in sight.
- HWR_14 5y agoNote, the EV revolution and Tesla being the winner of the EV revolution are different outcomes. They're certainly winning the EV race now, but it's possible that some of the other car companies can overtake them.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoOn the other hand, if you want the EV revolution for its own sake, investing in Tesla as a generator of hype can make instrumental sense.
- HWR_14 5y agoI mean, if "Make the richest man on earth richer, so a few more news stories will be written about him, because that might lead people to look into EVs" is how you want to spend your hard-earned dollars, I'm not going to stop you. I'd suggest there are far more efficient ways to bring about social change, both in terms of fewer negative side effects and more bang for your buck.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoI mean, phrasing aside, it seems to be working? Recommend some of those better ways to promote EV?
- jlmorton 5y agoThe bear thesis for Tesla has been something like, "Tesla might have an innovative EV-first design, but when the major manufacturers with a century of manufacturing know-how wake up to EVs, they will drown Tesla in vehicles." I think part of what's driving the increase in Tesla's value is the realization that this thesis was wrong. Tesla is now beating all the established manufacturers at gross automotive margins, and it's really not close. Toyota is around 18%, Ford and GM around 15%. Tesla is up at 27%. Part of that might be demand-driven higher prices. But Tesla continues to reduce their cost of goods, and Tesla has emerged as the most innovative manufacturer, which we already see in teardowns of the Model Y, with huge sections cast as one piece, but particularly in the design of Cybertruck, and Gigafactory. Tesla is far out in the lead on software. They appear to be rapidly improving on manufacturing. Tesla has paid down its debt with stock issuances, the company has $16 billion cash on hand, and the ability to go get a lot more nearly for free. If the major manufacturers aren't going to catch Tesla with manufacturing prowess, or capital, what are they going to catch them with?
- codebolt 5y agoI give them full credit for their EV technology, but I'm still pessimistic about FSD. How much of the current stock price is hinged on the assumption that FSD is 'right around the corner'? What happens if Elon pushes FSD out and it turns out to be a fiasco, possibly with catastrophic consequences?
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI've always been optimistic about the EV (and solar and battery) revolution, but I still don't understand the Tesla share price. If there genuinely is going to be a revolution, then Tesla can't own it all.
- TeMPOraL 5y agoRevolution is years from now, the stock will surely readjust, especially once competing players enter the field (and people actually believe these players are playing in Tesla's league wrt. EVs).
- blueblisters 5y agoTesla's stock price has become a self-fulfilling prophecy. It seems like Tesla's success combination of a genuinely good product, the Musk hype (and troll) machine, early mover advantage, and most importantly access to cheap capital to build vertically integrated manufacturing and distribution operations that are unheard of in this industry. Tesla's playbook is also unusual and contrarian to traditional wisdom on a number of things - unlike most tech companies, they outsource very little of their core manufacturing, making it an extremely capital intensive operation; they rely on their CEO trolling on Twitter for building hype for their products; they make promises which they almost always underdeliver and frustrate early adopters with quality issues; they make unsubstantiated claims about their self driving tech and yet are still making progress that skeptics are ignoring. This is what keeps short sellers, stock analysts, economists and B-school profs on their toes when it comes to their predictions on Tesla. Reminds me of the early days of the iPhone era where a lot of folks were convinced it is going to fail.
- guiriduro 5y agoLucky they have cheap equity capital because their debt is junk status. And some of the self-fulfilling prophecy is the cycle of good old WS analysts overrating an asset, Tesla, and their simple endorsement creates an inflationary cycle that generates a huge bubble and more me-too analysts - where have we heard that before? And we know how those end up despite all the transient commentaries that 'its different this time'. I doubt the Fed will be eager to bail TSLA investors out the way they did the banks in 2009 though.
- panick21_ 5y agoTheir rating just got upgraded. Tesla as a company has basically retired all debt, they have 16 billion in cash and no debt. Their position is far better then other car companies. > I doubt the Fed will be eager to bail TSLA investors out the way they did the banks in 2009 though. Even if the Tesla stock dropped by 90%, Tesla would be perfectly fine. They do not really on raising money anymore. They create large amounts of free cashflow and enough profit to finance considerable future investment.
- flexie 5y agoI am very happy with the Tesla company, CEO, marketing, and cars, but I can't believe that it should be worth 1 trillion dollars. A trillion is one with 12 zeros. I know you can't compare valuation and production of a company, but still. If Tesla were making 10,000 dollar profit per car - and they don't - they would have to produce 100 million cars just to make a trillion. They produce less than 1 million per year. I know they also sell batteries etc. but it's still mainly a car company. Their yearly profits might be a few billion. So their value is more than 100 times their yearly profits. This is insane for a manufacturing company. Currently their P/E ratio stands at more than 330. VW, a very well run auto manufacturer has a P/E ratio of less than 6, Ford 17, Mercedes-Benz 7, BMW 5, Hyundai 15. These are all companies with electric cars on the road and a future that is totally committed to electric vehicles. These are all companies that already have production facilities, etc. I like Tesla and their business model. I just think the stock is hyped way beyond what is sustainable.
- machiaweliczny 5y agoStock is usually valued at 10x profits, so they just have to 10x production to be quite resonable (given your assumption).
- NicoJuicy 5y agoDon't forgot the potential conflict of interest between the investors that saved the company and the statement of Hertz. We don't know if this was a decision after thorough analysis or just a quick money grab.
- potamic 5y agoThe thing to understand about stock price is that it is based on perception and not necessarily on potential. Ultimately it boils down to whether you think someone will be willing to pay a higher price for this at a future point in time more than whether you think the company has potential. Retail investors, and particularly first time investors, in the market have been growing rapidly. These kinds of investors tend to be less careful with where they invest, relying primarily on the media, word of mouth and hype than on fundamentals. With enough people you have a critical mass, creating a chain reaction that's impossible to stop. This is literally free investment for a company. As a serious investor, you would be foolish to ignore this. Even if the company was not positioned to do well earlier, this new found cash flow gives them a huge edge. And thus this creates a sort of a self fulfilling prophecy where more and more people invest, because they believe everyone else is investing, and because everyone else is investing the company will surely become #1 irrespective of where they are today, and inadvertently propelling the company to become #1 in the process.
- heavenlyblue 5y agoNot to throw any pebbles in the garden, but if you compare to how religions work (the self-fulfilling prophecy side), I would not be surprised if that's how the humanity will proceed. Semi-religious leaders speaking of hypothetical progress collecting money to do anything they want with them from a bunch of retail investors.
- xyzzy21 5y agoIt's "melting up" due to Fed QE injecting money into markets. It's NOT REAL. Just money that is increasingly becoming Monopoly money.
- samfisher83 5y agoThey are worthmore than every car company combined. If they start making as many cars as Toyota will they be worth 10x as much as all companies combined?