8 ms·
Facebook documents offer a treasure trove for Washington’s antitrust war
- strangesongs 5y ago"Reels users said they sometimes stopped the sessions early, finding it hard to hit the 10 minutes required because the videos were “stale, boring or repetitive,” while TikTok users self-reported using the app for hours a day beyond the study. The Reels users also found that Facebook’s algorithm didn’t stop showing them content they weren’t interested in, and rarely showed videos made by people of color to white viewers." obvious they can't innovate on their own at this point
- pwned1 5y agoAre you being facetious? If they can't innovate and they are losing customers, how does that support breaking them up? It seems to make the opposite point.
- mike00632 5y agoBecause a company should be able to stand on its own merit, not be sustained through entrenched monopoly power.
- munk-a 5y agoLots of monopolies suck at their core business - because they've lost the need to compete due to either suffocating the competition or growing into adjacent markets to lock down their user base. Facebook can both be incompetent and an economic danger.
- joe_the_user 5y agoBut FB loses eyeballs when it fails to innovate, which is kind of a demonstration that it doesn't have monopoly power.
- munk-a 5y agoSo if, when Standard Oil was still operating as a monopoly, a single well had decided to refuse to sell to them - or even a dozen wells - or a conglomerate of wells - that means they'd no longer be a monopoly? Just because you don't own 100% of a market doesn't mean you don't have a commanding position.
- joe_the_user 5y ago1) Comparing Tik Tok to a single oil well is laughable. 2) If someone who owned a single oil well in time of Standard Oil could get their oil to consumers and profitably sell it, then however big Standard Oil might be, then it didn't have a standard monopoly. Of course, that's not how things work back then. Standard Oil controlled the refineries and so well owners were over a barrel. Facebook has tried to control the Internet pipes but basically failed everywhere.
- cududa 5y agoIs your argument that if they got broken up they could innovate more to ... get more people to spend more time on new products that push them into radicalized rabbit holes?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mrits 5y agoAs a student of history this means you should go all in on out of the money calls.
- adventured 5y agoThere could be substantial lag. Microsoft went net sideways from 1998 to 2013, and then up ten fold since.
- jonathankoren 5y agoI still don't understand how Microsoft reinvented itself. Did they manage to sell some very large and entrenched companies on Azure, or what?
- fidesomnes 5y agosubscription models for everything.
- cududa 5y agoOne culture mostly evaporated due to the consent decree. The people left fought over resources and fiefdoms of what was left/ within new parameters. Ballmer left, Satya built a new culture with new values. Sounds pedantic but that's truly it.
- adventured 5y agoFinancially, cloud has become an extraordinary profit machine for Microsoft, far beyond anything traditional consumer Windows ever has been (for a long time obviously it was far and away the cash cow). Their operating income margin, for a company so massive, is mind boggling. $70 billion in operating income from $168b in sales (41.6%). By comparison it was 28% in 2013. So their margin has rather dramatically re-expanded during the Nadella era, like they're a younger company again. I think Microsoft is benefiting from not gorging and becoming obese again (employee count vs sales) as it did during the late Gates years and the Ballmer years. Microsoft could trivially load up on people for no great reason other than to always be expanding to fill the margin (many companies do that), but they seem to have made a conscious decision to be more disciplined. I bet that's working in their favor, as high levels of bloat usually acts like quicksand for larger older companies. They're probably more nimble now than when they had half the sales back in 2013. Nadella seemed immediately able to relax on the Windows-everything philosophy in a way Gates and Ballmer were unable to (they were perhaps too wed to the first chapter of Microsoft, people get blinded by such biases, even very smart people). And to his credit, Gates didn't try to get in Nadella's way as he made changes, Gates had been chairman of Microsoft from 1981 to 2014, with his stature and financial capabilities he could have been a real slag in the way of change.
- slownews45 5y agoThis is so weird as a support for the FTC complaint. My own read. Facebook is fighting for - and likely losing - the attention of younger users. Tiktok and others are doing relatively well. This is the problem with these networks, they become your parents network. Myspace gone, friendster gone. The FTC claims of monopoly are laughable? Tiktok seems to be crushing Facebook in downloads and in time in app, and now I heard was even crushing youtube (all of these folks are competing, youtube has youtube community and patreon style features now with chat etc as well). is facebook huge? For sure. Is it a monopoly? Have folks not heard of things like tiktok. Will be interesting if China goes after tiktok the way the US is going after facebook.
- echelon 5y ago> My own read. Facebook is fighting for - and likely losing - the attention of younger users. 100% agree. Mark's seen the numbers and he knows the demographic ship is sailing. That's why he's leaning so heavily into Metaverse. He wants his company to compete in 3D/VR/AR/games.
- jimt1234 5y agoAll this reminds me of MTV in the late-90s/early-2000s. We all watched it, even though we all pretty much hated it. Then, something magical happened: the internet became a content platform (MySpace, YouTube, Facebook, etc.), and MTV became basically irrelevant - my teenage niece-and-nephew don't even know what MTV is. And this seems to have happened to Facebook; it's still popular with the olds, obviously, but once again, my teenage niece-and-nephew don't have accounts on Facebook. They laughed when I asked them about it, said Facebook was "annoying", just like us olds thought MTV was annoying back in the day. Not really adding much value to this whole conversation; just an observation.
- lapetitejort 5y agoDo they use Instagram? WhatsApp? Oculus? Even if none of these, they probably still "have" an account, waiting for someone to come claim it.
- bob229 5y agowho cares, we already know that facebook is evil and is destroying humanity. These apps simply shouldn't be allowed to exist
- beebmam 5y agoI'd like to think that congress is looking at regulating Facebook (and social media in general) and not only thinking about antitrust law.
- akyu 5y agoYes. The antitrust suit seems to be a tool for legal discovery. And its a nice way to apply pressure from all sides to make Zuck feel the burn. This is about the government getting its hands into moderation and content control on Facebook. I'm not sure how I feel about that. Not saying it's good or bad, but that's what this is.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoWhat's weird here is this: >All told, Facebook has 174 million daily active users in the U.S., according to the internal data. By comparison, Google-owned YouTube has 122 million If you want to see basically any video online, from funny cats to Facebook depositions, you're using YT. It seems to me that if you're an "internet user", at least in this countries I've know anything about, you're a "YT user".
- benplumley 5y agoPerhaps "daily active user" is just too short an interval to measure Youtube users by. Everyone on the internet uses Youtube, but not many use it daily.
- KptMarchewa 5y agoAh, it's DAU. Then it makes sense. I'd expect MAU to be higher than FB though.