19 ms·
NYT journalist hacked with Pegasus after reporting on previous hacking attempts
- sharmin123 5y agoWebsite Hacking Techniques And What Are The Prevention Steps: https://www.hackerslist.co/website-hacking-techniques-and-what-are-the-prevention-steps/ https://www.hackerslist.co/website-hacking-techniques-and-wh...
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoWhy aren't political exposed persons leaving iphones? It has been known for a while that it is not secure for them. An android tablet connecting to wifi hotspots only, or even lan only, with minimal software, and a dumb phone are more secure than iphone.
- seniorivn 5y agono they are not, targeted attack of someone who is capable of using Pegasus is going to be successful regardless a consumer device u choose to use.
- catlikesshrimp 5y ago"No they are not?" I deserved more than that. Iphones are a standardized attack surface. Apple prefers vulnerabilities not to be found than to be discovered and patched, leading to NSO holding on their discovered vulnerabilities for longer. An android device with no modem (baseband) is definitely more secure. Throw in a hardware switch for camera, mics, and wifi, which iphones will never have.
- judge2020 5y agoAndroid is an even larger attack surface when political people don't take any of the precautions you mention, which they most likely won't. The President of the United States does indeed have a specialized phone that is modified by WH staff to either be only for phone calls or only for twitter/news (which means 2 phones)[0], but they're still iPhones. As long as there's not some 0-authorization 0-click vulnerability in the things used (as in, reportedly, neither iphone did texts), it'll be secure enough, but that's still limiting its usage and isn't want any politician is going to do. Just stick to a desk phone for secure comms. 0: https://www.politico.com/story/2018/05/21/trump-phone-security-risk-hackers-601903 https://www.politico.com/story/2018/05/21/trump-phone-securi...
- dx034 5y agoCould anyone deactivate texts on an iphone or did they get a special iOS version from Apple?
- vanchor3 5y agoTexts or iMessage? Texts shouldn't be difficult, just disable on the carrier end. MDM might be able to restrict it further just in case. With iMessage you can just not sign in to an Apple ID. Or use MDM.
- amerine 5y agoWhat!? You’re statement is really wrong. Android tablets on hotspots only??? What?
- saagarjha 5y agoWhen disagreeing with someone, it's usually courteous to explain why you think they are wrong.
- estaseuropano 5y agothey need an actual functional phone. You can't be a journalist and not have a fully functional phone that access the internet whenever needed. I'm sure they use burners for sensitive stuff, but what are they supposed to use for their regular work, calls with the school, car navigation, ...
- catlikesshrimp 5y agoThere are portable hotspots, you know.... I am assuming you use a killswitch VPN to your trusted network. NYT for this journalist. My proposed setup is 3 devices: hotspot, android device without baseband, dumbphone. Hotspot would be the weak link here, security wise, but is easier and cheaper to replace. Nothing on dumbphone would be encrypted. If I were a journalist, I would consider this alternative to being hacked. Remember he even knew there were at least attempts to hack his devices, years in advance. They are just biting the "apple is the most secure alternative" propaganda.
- KatrKat 5y agoiMessage can run over data, right? It sounds like the bugs exploited here were iMessage and WhatsApp holes, not weird mystery-baseband flaws (which are harder to patch but only ever affect a fraction of the phones you want to sell the ability to compromise). So similar Android exploits would just go right through the hotspot and compromise the Android device that does everything. The only way out of this mess is actually correct code on actually correct hardware. Maybe you have to run Linux and Android at the top to run existing apps, but somewhere below there you need a supervisor that makes security guarantees that are actually true. You can't just port a monolithic C kernel onto hardware that's struggling to be faster than the competition and call it good. Journalists need to buy communications equipment that doesn't come with that "NO WARRANTY OF MERCHANTABILITY OR FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE" line in the EULA. Sadly, it is not for sale.
- asdff 5y agoJust use a dumb phone and a garmin like journalists did in the early 2000s?
- sydd 5y agoIt's so unbelievable, that Pegasus can get away with such things unpunished.
- supperburg 5y agoGood. The New York Times lies. They reviewed the model s in 2013, drove it in circles before the review and then said the battery died. Flat out lies. They ought to have a taste of their own toxic medicine.
- mijoharas 5y agoSo, what is the legality of this? I've not followed much about this at all, but NSO group appears to be an Israeli company. Do they just sell, or operate the hacking software for their clients? If they operate it, is it illegal for an Israeli company to hack an American citizen (I assume it is illegal in America, but how about Israel?) Is the sale of hacking software regulated in any way?
- PeterisP 5y agoSince this is an international issue and there's no global "legality", the effect is that locations matter a lot. Presumably, the hacking was done by Saudi authorities from SA, using NSO-developed tools. Citizenship of the target is not very relevant, but it does matter where "the event" happened. If the reporter was in Saudi Arabia when the hack happened, then Saudi laws apply and essentially Saudi government gets to set conditions on whether it was legal or not, and if it was forbidden by their laws, then what consequences (if any!) that should have. If the reporter was in USA at the time, then it would be reasonable to apply US jurisdiction and try and investigate it as a crime in USA. However, Saudi Arabia can refuse to cooperate and even if USA prosecutors identify the culprits and convict them, Saudi Arabia can refuse to extradite them and choose to protect them. In essence, if it's not a random foreign criminal but someone from the actual foreign government that has harmed USA citizens in USA, it's not really a criminal matter as much as a diplomatic one, where all the other aspects of USA-Saudi relationships matter much more than any facts about the actual case; USA can choose to make a big deal out of it or ignore it, but historical precedent shows that it likely will be ignored as the Department of State considers all the other factors of Middle Eastern politics as much more important, SA could likely get away with literal murder (e.g. Khashoggi), not just some hacks. In a similar manner, perhaps you could argue that NSO is an accomplice in that crime (I'm not saying that this would succeed - in general, arms exporters are not considered liable for whoever the purchasing country harms), but that essentially comes down to (a) whether USA prosecutors are willing to pursue this, and (b) whether Israel is willing to cooperate, as in the absence of specific treaties it would be legitimate for Israel to say "NSO did not violate our laws, we won't enforce any foreign judgements about this event"; if so, then any action would be limited to seizing whatever assets NSO has in USA (if any!) and/or trying to capture the involved people (if specific people can be identified) when they are traveling outside of Israel somewhere within the reach of USA. USA could apply diplomatic pressure to get Israel to restrict NSO, however, it doesn't seem likely that USA wants it so much to actually try and change that. For another of your questions, sale of hacking software can be regulated by countries in whatever way each country wishes. In this case, as far as I understand, Israel treats is as essentially an equivalent of "arms export" where NSO has to obtain approval from Israel government for their foreign customers, but in this case it is not contested that NSO did have all the required approvals to sell their tools to Saudi Arabia.
- runnerup 5y agoThis feels like a much, much better analysis/exposition than Jeff Bezo's report via Gavin de Becker.
- FridayoLeary 5y agoSo how do we protect our privacy from the advance of technology? It doesn't seem possible. Just going after NSO is useless.
- hyperstar 5y agoRejecting the smartphone might be a start.
- joe_the_user 5y agoI don't think you can escape the use of the smart phone. But treating them as "throw-away", as not your device, etc. I think the original landlines, which were/are a few switches connected to a write on one side and some microphones on the other, were close to inherently insecure. Phones haven't ever been "your device" whereas a laptop might, maybe be rendered trustworthy.
- throwawayay02 5y agoHow can you possibly not escape the use of a smartphone?
- bart_spoon 5y agoPlenty of jobs these days essentially require one, be it for communication, authentication, or what have you.
- hyperstar 5y agoPreferably, don't take those jobs. Or, if you must, tape the cameras and remove the microphone. Use a wired headset for talking and unplug it when not in use. When not on the job, turn it off and wrap it in aluminium foil.
- heavyset_go 5y agoI recently had to file an insurance claim with my car insurer. The entire process happened through their app. They require you to send them pictures that you took using their app. One of my banks has been closing branches left and right, and if I want to use my accounts for anything other than debit purchases, I need to use the app. Some banks even charge you when you go to a branch location in person and use a teller to access your accounts. Some jobs require you to install and use apps on your phone. Last time I was a big box retailer, the floor staff had the company's app installed on their phones so they could do instant price look ups and confirm discounts on their store's inventory. Even just applying for a job requires an internet browser, and many people's only access to the internet is through their phone.
- 1cvmask 5y agoIt would seem to be the rational thing for NSO to hack a journalist who is writing on them, so that they better prepare for what’s coming. As for all the countries that buy and use NSO, to target and kill journalists, they are all close all allies of the US and Israel. And the US and England were also spying on the journalist Julian Assange, and have kept him in prison and tortured him for over a decade. Ben Hubbard luckily just got hacked.
- chinathrow 5y agoRational? Maybe. Ethical? No. Legitimate? Hell no.
- nix23 5y agoFun fact, the CIA had/has a rule not to impersonate priests etc, journalist or personnel of NGO's in undercover missions (because they have a hard life in some country's already). But then there is that excellent movie Spy Game....
- nuclearnice1 5y agoThe CIA reportedly used the “Save the Children” charity as a front for a fake hepatitis B vaccination program in Pakistan to help confirm Bin Laden’s location. A ban on the polio vaccination program in some Taliban territory and attacks on vaccine workers followed.
- nix23 5y agoHint to Spy Game where Brad Pitt plays a Journalist as an active CIA agent was no mistake.
- nuclearnice1 5y agoI’ll look for it on streaming.
- 5y ago
- otoh 5y agoOn the other hand, perhaps the hardware/OS designs of iOS and Android devices are fundamentally flawed, when viewed from a security-first perspective.
- Azsy 5y agoThis is definitely part of the problem. But the fundamental flaw is the departure from simplicity. The solution is to have a processor that is so simple that it cant do more then what you expect, and building the tools to make the unexpected stand out. However, there is a bigger market for a processor with 3 extra layers of root access to ensure your boss can spy on you and Disney&Co really want this to be the norm.
- saagarjha 5y agoYou’re making this out to be far easier than it really is, to the point of being an armchair commentator. People want phones that can call and text and shoot perfect video and play demanding games. All of this necessitates complexity. The average dumbphone is far less complex than an iPhone but it’s obvious which one people want. (And, I should also note that “simplicity” doesn’t necessarily mean “security”: people have found bugs in ridiculously small pieces of code. The rest of your comment of making “the unexpected stand out” is similar in intent to “just find the viruses bro, how hard can it be?”)
- UweSchmidt 5y agoBy now every piece of software and hardware that is in use, every abstraction layer in that computing tower of bable has been thoroughly hacked. Anywhere from plaintext passwords on a server to insane exploits like Rowhammer, those security websites and podcasts have long weekly litanies of tragedy. Additionally there is all-knowing Google, chinese phones phoning home, undocumented functions in intel processors, ISPs sabotaging user encryption, small-time browser plugin writers that get offered high sums for their plugin to get a front row seat to users' browsers, programmers pulling who-knows-what from npm and are probably pwned by time they write 'hello world', phishing, billions of smart devices constantly listening and often filming and we probably only know 10% of what's going on until a Snowden 2.0 comes along. Yes, all of it is 'fundamentally flawed', and it would take a herculean effort to start over with a clean slate, yes, to figuratively burn it all down and make simple provably correct and safe hardware and a small and minimal OS that has browsing and communications built in. Anyone?
- atdt 5y agoForget Y Combinator -- come build the next great surveillance start-up at the IDF's Unit 8200, the world's greatest hacker school and incubator for mass surveillance start-ups. With generous subsidies from US taxpayers, Unit 8200 lets you level up your surveillance game by practicing on 4.5 million Palestinian beta-testers. (Go nuts, it's not like they can sue you!) Plus, say goodbye to those moral qualms -- at 8200, you'll acquire the unshakeable conviction that you're a Good Guy fighting the Bad Guys. When you graduate, the IDF will keep the data you collected, but the skills you acquire and the friends you make are yours to keep forever.
- vnchr 5y agoWhere do I sign up?
- RNCTX 5y agoYour local ADL office
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- greatjack613 5y ago@dang This comment is negative, and doesn't contribute anything productive to the conversation. Please remove
- kvathupo 5y agoEh, the comment made me google to learn more about Unit 8200. That said, surely you can agree the removal of comments we don't like is undemocratic. Further, no one user is the boss of this site's moderators. Here's a relevant article [1]: moderators are human too :) [1] - https://www.newyorker.com/news/letter-from-silicon-valley/the-lonely-work-of-moderating-hacker-news https://www.newyorker.com/news/letter-from-silicon-valley/th...
- midasuni 5y ago8200 has many alumni including many security products, including those protesting about the treatment of Palestinians This is despite being members of the IDF https://www.richardsilverstein.com/2014/09/12/israels-nsa-staff-refuse-to-fight-palestinians/ https://www.richardsilverstein.com/2014/09/12/israels-nsa-st...
- dpratt 5y agoI am but one atom in a molecule in a drop in an ocean, but I have pledged to never be involved in the hiring of any person who has had any willing association with any organization responsible for efforts similar to Pegasus, with no exceptions. I will also immediately resign any job that violates the above as well. Trends like this are not to be taken lightly - for the first time in human history, the concept of an all encompassing tyrannical dystopia is a realistic possibility, and you deceive yourself if you think that there aren’t very very powerful people that get an almost erotic thrill at this possibility. Contributing to the advancement and deployment of this technological capability is the very definition of a violation of whatever meager ethics our profession possesses, and should be taken as essentially a credible threat against literally every other living person.
- systemvoltage 5y agoI can't get behind bifurcation of job market based on what political side you belong to. This seems destructive at best, dangerous at worse. It's like the classic Palantir vs Google argument. I won't hire anyone if they show any sort of activism at work.
- dpratt 5y agoThis is not a political argument. If you willingly participate in the construction and deployment of technological systems that are designed to be used to monitor, suppress and ultimately threaten the physical security of people who are non-violently opposed to the current group of people in power, you have essentially declared yourself an enemy of mankind, and I choose to personally act accordingly.
- systemvoltage 5y agoWould you hire a plumber if they worked at an ammunitions factory before?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- intsar10 5y agoEdward Snowden still hasn't withdrawn his allegation that the NSA routinely hacks allies' phones - most notably, Angela Merkel's.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 5y agoI really hope the blur on the picture (https://citizenlab.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Hubbard-Image-1.png https://citizenlab.ca/wp-content/uploads/2021/10/Hubbard-Ima...) isn't hiding anything actually important because that can almost certainly be de-blurred with the right tooling.
- boppo1 5y agoReally? Seems blurred enough to me that even some sort of ML would spit out wrong characters.
- birdyrooster 5y agoNot at all, I can already make out the characters and recognized quickly that all but the last 4 blurred characters are hexadecimal and the last appear to be [a-z][A-Z]
- seba_dos1 5y agoIt's blurred lightly enough for me to be able to tell at least some characters just with my eyes.
- generalizations 5y agoKnown font, known range of possible characters (almost certainly ascii), and probably several blurred characters in there that we know (like the t in attachment). If the blur is differentiable per-character, it's probably reversible.
- warent 5y agoEven without automation. Just make a list of blurred alphanumerics, then match every blurred character in the picture against the character list. with some patience probably doable in a single day
- spicybright 5y agoProbably the most time efficient way to do it tbh.
- appleshaveholes 5y agoMy security researcher buddy at Apple responsible for investigating this vulnerability told me that the hack is very complex; Apple couldn't even fully figure it out before pushing patches; the patches do not fix all the known bugs used in the vulnerability; the attackers most likely have access to Apple internal source code as well. They are very thankful for Citizen Lab without which the bugs wouldn't have been discovered. Also, there are likely many more compromised phones out there and Apple is kind of scratching their heads on how to fix, or even detect it. How do you fix a vulnerability that's secret and that no one knows is actively exploited?
- consumer451 5y agoWell, if you have billions just sitting around... pay 10's of millions for such a bug bounty?
- ralston3 5y agoDo these types of iMessage attachment exploits require the victim to do anything on their end? Downloading the attachment? Opening the message ? That part is unclear to me
- zionic 5y agoNo, most are zero-click silent exploits. They own your phone persistently then delete the incoming message that pwned you.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 5y agoAre other messaging apps on iOS ever getting RCE exploits like this? Can’t they sandbox iMessage so this isn’t possible no matter how many bugs the app has?
- can16358p 5y agoThey actually did it with iOS 14 (named Blastdoor) but apparently it's not helping much. Considering how tightly integrated iMessage is with iOS, it doesn't seem likely that it will really be fixed in an easy manner.
- judge2020 5y agoIronic that Apple limiting their apps in the same way they limit 3p apps would've likely solved this vulnerability, unless the attack was only "0-click access to full chat.db"
- Godel_unicode 5y agoExcept there are tons of examples of iOS sandbox escapes over the last few years. I definitely don't consider iOS sandboxing a security control at this point.
- marcan_42 5y agoThey do limit their own apps (they even specifically sandboxed part of the iMessage handling, more than a standard app). The exploit chains that NSO uses include sandbox escapes.
- alienalp 5y agoIt should be explained to public how such exploit take place, with open sourcing necessary parts. Otherwise there is no way for us to know it wasn't intentional at first place. I am not meaning there is a possibility like Apple as a company decides to put exploits. However governments can easily do it with single engineer at right place.
- javajosh 5y agoAccording to wikipedia[1] Pegasus is usually installed via a zero-click iMessage exploit. Open-sourcing Pegasus doesn't seem likely as NSO Group sells it for big bucks. It seems unlikely that Apple has colluded with NSO, as Pegasus is actually a bit of a black eye for the company. I'm not sure what governments can do with an engineer in the right place - in general I'd say "not much, and certainly not as much as with the courts and guys with guns, the other things a government can do. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(spyware) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pegasus_(spyware)
- saagarjha 5y agoI understood the parent comment as requesting that iOS be made open source to allow a further understanding of how the exploit works. My response to that would be that making things open source makes this process easier, but is not, by and means, a requirement for this ability.
- christophilus 5y agoInteresting. Didn’t realize it was zero-click. I got a bunch of weird iMessages a few months ago which I didn’t open. How do I check if I’ve been compromised?
- username190 5y agoiMazing[0] can analyze an iTunes (or Finder in macOS Catalina and later) backup to determine whether Pegasus is present. [0] https://imazing.com/ https://imazing.com/
- h0l0cube 5y agoDarknet Diaries recently had an episode with John Scott-Railton from Citizen Lab on how he was allegedly being spied on by the makers of Pegasus, and then lured them into a trap https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/100/ https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/100/
- Xavdidtheshadow 5y agoGreat rec! This is one of my favorite technical podcasts. The host does a great job getting into the technical details of the subjects while still appealing to non-techincal listeners. It's really impressive.
- bduerst 5y agoSubbed. Any other recos? Been looking to scratch that Reply All itch.
- dpacmittal 5y agoMalicious Life is pretty good, so is Security Now
- Xavdidtheshadow 5y agoVery different show, but I enjoy the Accidental Tech Podcast (aka "ATP"). It's a weekly news show that focuses on tech (mainly Apple). They do a good job with technical details and talking through tech product decisions (why did Apple/Google/FB do X? What are its merits?). People have sort of polarized opinions about each of the 3 hosts, but IMO they each have their moments.
- microtonal 5y agoI have been listening to ATP for years, and I love it. I didn’t know that there were discussions about them. To me, one of the powerful things of ATP is that it’s one of those cases where the sum is more than the parts. The hosts complement each other very well. I also like that, although it’s an Apple-centered podcast, they are willing to take a critical stance towards Apple. I once listened to one of the other major Apple-related podcasts (not Gruber) and the level of fanboyism was cringeworthy.
- boardwaalk 5y agoI feel like phones should just have a "scrub anything that isn't ASCII text" option for paranoid folks. No unicode, no emoji, no media. I mean, I guess they could still f*ck that up, and maybe it'd be admitting defeat, but still.
- marcan_42 5y agoAIUI part of the problem is that iMessage is a poor legacy design and relies on generic macOS serialization primitives. It's not like HTML where you can just scrub all the tags out. This can't be changed without breaking compatibility due to end to end encryption (the server can't adapt between versions). So there is a big attack surface inherent to the design, and Apple are stuck with it.
- zrm 5y agoThere is a known solution to this. You version the protocol. New endpoints talk to each other with the new version, old endpoints that only understand the old version use that. After a period of time there are few enough people who still have the old version and it gets disabled.
- Griffinsauce 5y ago> Apple are stuck with it. Are they? They have an enormous level of control over their deployed software. It seems like they could push out the required changes and nearly all clients would support it in no time. For the remaining clients it seems consistent with the feature to simply block incoming messages in the wrong format. Now, whether they'd want to implement a feature that essentially advertises that they have a security problem is another thing. (the answer is quite obviously no, regardless of what's best for their users)
- saagarjha 5y agoThis necessarily excludes people whose primary language for communication does not fit in a Latin alphabet.
- 5y ago
- orteam 5y agoBen Hubbard wrote about it in nytimes [0]. One thing he doesn't make clear - was the hacked phone a US phone or a local (Lebanese?) one. He mentions that he's now using a US number as NSO blocks targeting US phones. Not saying that hacking a non-US phone is ok, but I do think it's an important context, given the allegations that NSO software targets US nationals. EDIT: This is a third article on the same topic. This time the focus is on a US journalist being hacked. The agenda is clear but having an agenda is everyone's right. It's a shame that citizenlabs conveniently omit that the hacks occurred while Ben Hubbard was reporting from Beirut, and apparently using a local phone. So all the comments here of people triggered by 'NSO now hacks us' are unfortunately based on fake news or a lie (lying by omission is still lying). [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/24/insider/hacking-nso-surveillance.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/10/24/insider/hacking-nso-surve...