28 ms·
Android phones are sending significant amount of user data with no opt-out [pdf]
- karlzt 5y agoRelated thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25091823 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25091823 11 months ago...
- raffraffraff 5y agoTL;DR: They track long-lived phone identifiers and some send usage data like: > Xiaomi telemetry logs the user interaction with the dialer app when receiving a phone call, including the start and end times of the call ...and Microsoft SwiftKey logs the apps you open, how many characters you typed (with timestamps), and sends crash dumps that contain who-knows-what.
- scns 5y agoThe /e/ foundation has a visualization here [0]. Better viewed in landscape on mobile. Even iPhone users should take a look at it IMO. [0] https://e.foundation/about-e/#why-/e/ https://e.foundation/about-e/#why-/e/
- Darmody 5y agoI can't recommend Blokada enough. It won't solve your privacy problems but sure will block a lot of apps from sending info to their masters.
- deathjester 5y agoI think it's a bit misleading to say Lineage OS sends data, because it doesn't. It's just the GApps installed with Lineage OS that sends data to Google. But you don't need to install GApps, then it doesn't send anything just like /e/OS does...
- thastings 5y agoThis is the exact thing I was wondering about. As far as I understood, they flashed GApps, even though GApps is not part of the default installation. I wonder what the findings would've been like on LineageOS without the GApps.
- noja 5y agoPlease, technical people of HN, install NetGuard on your Android phone. You will be shocked where your data goes. GDPR? Ha!
- Graffur 5y agoBased on your comment I have installed it and enabled notifications.. immediately it told me that Facebook attempted internet access. I have 432 other apps so it will be interesting to see what else is phoning home.
- aboringusername 5y ago> immediately it told me that Facebook attempted internet access. I am not sure how that information is useful to you or anyone else, not trying to be snarky, but an internet app wanting internet access...is the expected behavior? Most apps and operating systems communicate over the internet for any number of reasons, heck, apps can even check if you have internet access or not (and respond accordingly, such as caching content to send later on). Doesn't make it weird or suspicious...
- Graffur 5y agoI have the FB app but rarely use it. Why would it be phoning home when I don't have it open?
- kaba0 5y agoTo check for notifications? I’m fairly sure they haven’t implemented a complex AI model to determine that “you are using it rarely”, so the check it out each n minutes is a constant thing.
- KennyBlanken 5y agoOn Android, most notifications are handled by Google Cloud Messaging. The app/site developer pushes a notification to GCM, which then puts up the notification on your device. The ugly white elephant in the room is that Google sees the text of the notification; it's not e2ee'd. Some more privacy-oriented apps implement GCM such that it just "pokes" the app on your phone to say "hey, check in with us" and the app then fetches the notification text etc. directly. But Google still knows that you got an event from what app.
- hellisothers 5y agoAnd yet we have articles that say iOS is similar if not worse and people pile in to “both sides” it (1). Why is it I feel it’s clear that fundamentally iOS favors privacy (for profit) and Android eschews it (for profit) yet it’s somehow debatable still? (1) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28819318 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28819318
- rangerdan 5y agoiOS is just as bad, if not worse. See https://gist.github.com/iosecure/357e724811fe04167332ef54e736670d https://gist.github.com/iosecure/357e724811fe04167332ef54e73...
- smoldesu 5y agoIf iOS were an open-source project, we wouldn't need to spend so long speculating what code is running on the devices that we own.
- mattnewton 5y agoIs it possible the feeling is at least in part the result of marketing? Not trying to be inflammatory, but apple does spend a lot of money running excellent ads about how iPhones are private.
- margalabargala 5y agoDo you have any evidence the iOS operating system is better in any significant way? The article you linked focused on the apps available in the store, not the phone OS itself (which is what this article is about).
- hellisothers 5y agoApps draft off what the OS allows, iOS keeps adding features at the OS level (do not track, “app tracking health” metrics, advertising opt out, etc). At best Android grudgingly offers some of this after the fact, at worst does what this article offers.
- 5y ago
- aboringusername 5y agoThe issue with Android is it's extremely restrictive from a firewall perspective, I guess exactly as designed. I cannot dictate what apps chat over the internet or to what IP's (say, a setting to only allow EU-only addresses). Of course this means - rightfully or wrongly - you have to move this to another layer - probably PiHole or router level, but even then there could be gaps (can it use mobile data with you unaware?). I am surprised major OS' still don't allow users to configure this yet. it's pretty basic stuff.
- ajvs 5y agoCustom ROMs like LineageOS which is in this study does have an inbuilt firewall. Long press an app and you can deny internet access entirely, deny VPN access, etc.
- johnthuss 5y agoI don't think this is news to anyone (in general), but it is increasingly becoming the differentiating factor between Android and iOS. Apple is all-in on customer privacy and Google hasn't really been able to respond on that front since their business model depends on targeted advertising based on data collected about their users. The question is whether regular people really care about privacy more than they do about the price of a phone. And so far it seems that the lower priced phones are winning.
- chuckee 5y ago> The question is whether regular people really care about privacy more than they do about the price of a phone. And so far it seems that the lower priced phones are winning. To find that out, the privacy intrusions would have to be advertised as prominently as the price.
- Tenoke 5y agoPrice and privacy are hardly the only differentiating factors between the two. And even if they were, those who care most about privacy have more options on Android at the extreme end.
- a_imho 5y agoWasn't CSAM the hot topic just a couple of weeks ago?
- BiteCode_dev 5y agoApple is just better at pretending being all in. They were part of PRISM. They recently added a systematic scan, compare and report routine to all your pictures. They forces you to tie your phone to an Apple account just to use it. My android phone doesn't have an account, or even an email linked to it. Apple now has an entire mesh network of BT devices constantly looking up each others, even if some of them are not connected to internet. The microphone on the Apple device is always on, to answer to hey siri. Finally, you can't install a real alternative browser on iOS, so no real privacy addons. They make big claims about privacy nobody can check because everything is closed source. So you have to just trust them. "But apple doesn't have an ad business" Oh but they do. And they don't have to play by their own rules in the app store, and have the right to track users, gather device informations, location, etc. Fun thing is, they start the list of information they collect (https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/data/en/apple-advertising/ https://www.apple.com/legal/privacy/data/en/apple-advertisin...) by stating "Apple-delivered advertising helps people discover apps, products, and services while respecting user privacy". I don't think they are any better, just different. And better at PR.
- Factorium 5y agoYour opt-out is to buy an iPhone.
- Gunax 5y agoBut I also don't approve of apple's control over what I install and I think it's stance on browsers in anti-competitive. Now I feel stuck.
- aritmo 5y agoAndroid takes snapshots (screenshots) of apps as soon as you switch to another app. When you view the app list, it already has the last view of each app. But the Xiaomi/MIUI Android sends over those screenshots back to the company is new information.
- aero-glide2 5y agoThe article doesn't mention screenshots at all.
- jand 5y ago> System apps on several handsets upload details of user interactions with the apps on the handset (what apps are used and when, what app screens are viewed, when and for how long). I am too far away from Android development to make any claim about what "app screens" are. Is that android-lingo? Could someone please clarify?
- Arnt 5y agoSounds like an attempt at phrasing for the general public. Android apps have zero or more activities, each of which may be thought of as a single screen and a single Intent, which is a bit like a URL (and sometimes very much like a URL). A messenger or email app will typically have a main activity, an activity to view a single message, an activity to view a conversation with someone, perhaps an activity to view a single attached image, probably an activity to view and edit the application's settings, and so on. What is sent is perhaps the app's name and a class name within the app for each activity that's started.
- dr_kiszonka 5y agoExactly right. And you don't have to be a system app to access this information. Any app with sufficient permissions granted explicitly by a user can access these data (no root needed), and it may have legitimate reasons for doing it.
- 5y ago
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agocan i see this "exfiltration" out of an android using a pi-hole? i have multiple androids at home and a etwork wide pi-hole so i would love to see if there is something i can see and maybe block
- eldaisfish 5y agoany DNS-based tool is going to tell you which IP address is being contacted, not what is sent or how much. You can certainly block domains and that will prevent some google telemetry but a DNS-based tool is not what you're looking for.
- sumtechguy 5y agoHas anyone played with adding a cert and using a squid proxy to help log what is going on?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- noja 5y agoInstall NetGuard.
- rangerdan 5y agoNot unless you have a lot of free time to pour through thousands of log lines manually.
- elevaet 5y agoI use Android because of the walled-garden approach to data that Apple tries to funnel its users into. The privacy issues give me pause however.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jonstaab 5y agoFeeling quite smug about switching to CalyxOS earlier this week.
- bennettnate5 5y agoDefinitely on this boat. CalyxOS feels like it strikes a good balance between security/privacy and practical usability--the locked bootloader and app-specific firewall options are a huge plus, while MicroG ensures that I can still use every app I used to with the old Pixel-specific OS without ceding all of my data to Google Play Services. Invariably people bring up the signature spoofing needed for MicroG as some huge security hole, but from what I've seen it's really a non-issue--CalyxOS has tight restrictions to specifically allow only MicroG to use this, it's disabled for any other app.
- markenqualitaet 5y agoCan I expect CalyxOS to support the Pixel 6 rather soon? Is e.g. camera performance dependent on closed source Google code/firmware? What are the limitations there? I was going for GrapheneOS, but tbh seeing that one main developer's personality issues turned me off big time. I don't care about technical advantages, if I have to trust in that guy's impulse control. Too small a project for that.
- xanaxagoras 5y agoYou can expect a dedicated team to start working on it once they're able to get their hands on some Pixel 6 devices. They don't get them early from Google you know, there's no cooperation there. They buy them when they're released just like we do, and it hasn't been released yet so work hasn't started. The general attitude towards GCam seems to be... Calyx isn't going to ship it but it's generally understood most people will be using it. The recommendation I got when I switched was to install the apk and disable all network access via Datura before I launched it for the first time. That works well, the pictures look great too. A recommendation I heard after I did that which I will be following next time is to extract the gcam apk from your new phone before you flash calyx and install that one (to avoid apkmirror or whatever).
- 5y ago
- Dutchie2020 5y agoDoes anyone here have any experience with the /e/OS mentioned in the article?
- COGlory 5y agoI purchased a Samsung Galaxy S9 (in the US) from them. My first impression: Everything works. Apps (if it's not on their store, which is a mix of F-Droid and other APKs, it's on Aurora), Google services works without signing (MicroG), GPS works, OTA updates work (with one click). My biggest complaint is that their App store isn't just F-Droid, and their APKs are often out of date by 1-2 weeks. My biggest compliment (besides everything just working to the point I could recommend it to a relative), is that they are active and engaged in their community, regularly reading their forum, soliciting feedback, and posting weekly updates. https://community.e.foundation/t/week-41-development-and-testing-updates/35345 https://community.e.foundation/t/week-41-development-and-tes...
- Kototama 5y agoIt's rather good and at some point they managed to have release for my previous phone model when the lineageos stopped! I used it without their cloud services. Some of the pre-installed apps cannot be removed (like email, pdf readers) which is slightly annoying. They have their own launcher/desktop but it's not that good, it even crashes time to time. Last time I checked, it was not super transparent which non-FOSS store they used. Overall I think the experience with LineageOS is better but /e/ comes with MicroG so it's practical if you need a few proprietary apps.
- ForHackernews 5y ago> Last time I checked, it was not super transparent which non-FOSS store they used I'm pretty sure that's deliberately opaque because mirroring APKs from Play store breaks some ToS somewhere and they don't want everyone getting their Google accounts banned.
- ForHackernews 5y agoYes, I've been using /e/ in daily use for over a year now. It's pretty good most of the time. It will not satisfy people who want/need a truly "hardened" device, but if you are just a normal person who wants to feed less data to the ad-tech monsters, then it works well. The default /e/ app store has both FLOSS apps from F-Droid and free-as-in-beer proprietary apps mirrored from Google Play store. Whether an individual app works well or not depends on how tightly coupled it is to Google Play Services
- micah94 5y agoSo is the data collected by Google from Huawei phones a function of their OS based on Android 10? I thought Huawei was prevented from talking to Google.
- dont__panic 5y agoDoes anybody know if alternatives like GrapheneOS + microG mitigate these issues? Or should I just switch back to a 2005 flip phone at this point?
- bennettnate5 5y agoIt definitely helps--the vast majority of snooping comes from Google Play Services, so options like GrapheneOS + microG or CalyxOS resolve that issue quite nicely. They also have app-specific firewall abilities, so you can disable background or foreground network connectivity on any app you're suspicious of.
- dont__panic 5y agoThanks! I'm still using an old iPhone SE (2016) as my daily driver, but sooner or later iOS support is going to drop and I'll have to find a decent upgrade path. Considering my size, headphone jack, and fingerprint reader preferences, I think the Pixel 4a is the only device that seems viable to me on the market today... hopefully I'll still be able to pick one up in a year or two and slap GrapheneOS on it.
- salusinarduis 5y agoI use GraphineOS and LineageOS without Google Play Services. They are great and are suitable replacements for Apple and Google. - Osmand(FOSS) for maps (supports being fully offline!) - Signal and Discord for messaging (Discord is sandboxed) - Newpipe(FOSS) for Youtube - F-droid(FOSS) for my FOSS appstore - APKmirror for the few non-free apps I need - Libretorrent(FOSS) and VLC(FOSS) for watching movies - Firefox(FOSS) and Vanadium(FOSS) for browser - K9 Mail(FOSS) for email - Infinity(FOSS) for Reddit - Secur(FOSS) for 2FA - Taskkeeper(FOSS) for reminders Almost everything you need is in the F-droid FOSS app repository. It all works, and it works well. You can buy a used Pixel 3a for around $80 on Ebay and have a better experience in every category than iOS, hardware and software.
- doc_gunthrop 5y agoFairEmail is also a nice open-source, privacy-focused email client available on F-droid. https://f-droid.org/en/packages/eu.faircode.email/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/eu.faircode.email/
- commoner 5y agoFairEmail is really great, almost as fully featured as Thunderbird with the best support for multiple accounts/identities that I've seen on Android so far. The developer asks for a small donation to unlock a few advanced features,* which I recommend doing. * https://email.faircode.eu/donate/ https://email.faircode.eu/donate/
- CountDrewku 5y agoJust bought a pixel to test lineageOS out. Worth mentioning that if you want less Google and still want to use normal Android services in the OS you need to install the MicroG lineageOS ROM. Otherwise, you're still sending Google a lot of info through Gapps or MindTheGapps. Graphene or lineage without any of those is also an option but you'll be missing a lot of the normal everyday apps you use. IMO if you're going that far though you might as well just go back to a flip phone.
- 5y ago
- ir77 5y agoit's always amazing to me that a typical android user tells me they hate iOS because it's locked down and android is much more open -- whenever i follow up with what apps they've actually side loaded they don't know what i'm talking about, never mind about whether their phone is rooted and they're running a rom. yet a majority of them use very expensive handsets that compete in a premium space to iOS devices and ciphen data not only back to google to to their respective manufacturers and anyone else that puts bloat on their phone -- bloat that they can't remove on their "much more open devices". what was the silly movie that had the quote "the greatest trick the devil made was to convince the world that he didn't exist.".
- detaro 5y agoOf course anecdotal here too, but it seems highly unlikely that that's a typical android user perspective. Even among fellow nerds that argument is not that overwhelming, and they are a tiny group of people.
- nicoburns 5y ago> whenever i follow up with what apps they've actually side loaded they don't know what i'm talking about, never mind about whether their phone is rooted and they're running a rom. An android phone is more open even without side-loading or rooting because Google's play store much less restrictive than Apple's app store.
- imwillofficial 5y agoYou are correct. I have the same experience often. *siphon “The Usual Suspects”, Keyser Söze
- doc_gunthrop 5y agoA distinction needs to be made clear here with regards to the data being transmitted to Google by LineageOS in this study. In the cited paper (https://www.scss.tcd.ie/Doug.Leith/Android_privacy_report.pdf https://www.scss.tcd.ie/Doug.Leith/Android_privacy_report.pd...), the device used to test LineageOS was a Google Pixel 2 running LineageOS 17.1 which also included an installation of OpenGapps 10.0 nano. It's not the OS that is transmitting the data over to Google, but rather OpenGapps (ie. Google Play). OpenGapps is software that can be optionally installed after the initial installation of LineageOS (but before first boot). A user can still use LineageOS without OpenGapps, though they just won't have the benefits (and drawbacks) that come with it (such as being able to use apps that require GSF). The user can instead opt for an app manager like F-droid or possibly Aurora Store. In addition, there exists an alternative to OpenGapps called MicroG. This is like Google Play but allows users the option to anonymize themselves. One can find custom LineageOS builds that include MicroG from the MicroG website (as the members of the LineageOS project do not advocate for its use, instead giving preference to OpenGapps). Keep in mind, however, that there are fewer devices supported by those builds.
- CountDrewku 5y agoYep MicroG is the route I'm going on Pixel3a I just bought. You don't need to sign into any Google services to use them. For now I'm just using maps. I found a nice Reddit article on de-googling even more as well. If you install OpenGapps you might as well forget it- https://www.reddit.com/r/fossdroid/comments/clg2ca/how_to_degoogle_lineageos_in_2019_xpost/ https://www.reddit.com/r/fossdroid/comments/clg2ca/how_to_de...
- tertius 5y agoMy exact setup. Using Gaia for maps.
- cookiengineer 5y agoTechnically, the Internet Connectivity Check on LineageOS also sends your position/IP to Google, and also avoids a VPN tunnel because it's lower down the stack. I can recommend LineageOS, however be aware that lots of malware infected builds have made it to xda dev in the past, so you should build it yourself if possible (or use the official downloads). Regarding the Connectivity Check: You can add all google related domains to /system/etc/hosts if you have root/sudo access. Additionally I'd recommend everyone to use RethinkDNS as a DNS adblocker and app firewall - and AppWarden to patch out the Analytics parts of proprietary Apps.
- joemazerino 5y agoAlways mind blowing. I recall a video from Copperhead showing the difference between a gApps enabled phone vs no-gApps. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zemRALtU4OY https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zemRALtU4OY
- salusinarduis 5y agoI use GraphineOS and LineageOS without Google Play Services. They are great and are suitable replacements for Apple and Google. - Osmand(FOSS) for maps (supports being fully offline!) - Signal and Discord for messaging (Discord is sandboxed) - Newpipe(FOSS) for Youtube - F-droid(FOSS) for my FOSS appstore - APKmirror for the few non-free apps I need - Libretorrent(FOSS) and VLC(FOSS) for watching movies - Firefox(FOSS) and Vanadium(FOSS) for browser - K9 Mail(FOSS) for email - Infinity(FOSS) for Reddit - Secur(FOSS) for 2FA - Taskkeeper(FOSS) for reminders Almost everything you need is in the F-droid FOSS app repository. It all works, and it works well. You can buy a used Pixel 3a for around $80 on Ebay and have a better experience in every category than iOS, hardware and software. The only limitation is push notifications, which isn't a problem because FOSS apps like Signal bundle their own notification system that does not use Google Play Services. Discord however, does not get push notifications (which I wouldn't want anyway)
- krageon 5y agoOSMAnd is visually difficult to parse (especially at a glance) and fairly complicated to use. It is not a good map app.
- ptidhomme 5y agoI had the same feeling. I now use Organic Maps which I find much better.
- phh 5y agoFun, I guess this is just a question of habit. Nowadays I use OSMAnd mostly, and when I have to use Google's Maps (OSMAnd's search isn't great, and public transportation isn't there), I'm lost, and the app never shows the information I want. It's happened to me a lot of times with Google's Maps (with regard to how frequent I use Google's Maps) that I'm looking for something, I KNOW it's there, I'm searching for it (like "groceries" for a grocery store), and the only way Google's Maps would ever show it to me is by zooming it until the ONLY thing on screen is building, and then it does display it.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y ago
- codefeenix 5y agoCopperhead advert?
- jpm_sd 5y agoWhat is the actual value of all this privacy invasion? Is the data even useful to anyone? Or is it just getting collected endlessly for no reason?
- dylan604 5y agoTo the people collecting the data that can sell it, it is useful only in that someone will buy it. Once it is sold, they don't care one bit about how/where/why it is used.
- criddell 5y agoWhere can you buy it?
- jpm_sd 5y agoBut are the third parties buying the data actually getting anything useful out of it?
- dylan604 5y agoI'm not sure why you'd think it's not useful to someone somewhere. Game devs see how much time you play games, what type of games, if you purchase IAPs, etc. News feed apps sell what kind of news stories you read/follow/subscribe. Commerce apps sell what kind of things you buy, the prices you pay, the items you look at but don't buy etc. From all of that "metadata", one can build up a profile about you that's pretty accurate. If you can't imagine why that is useful to someone, then I'd posit you're not trying hard enough.
- MattGrommes 5y agoIt seems worth talking about the fact that it appears to be the vendor of the phone putting this kind of snooping in place. Blaming Android is missing the real culprit. Like they say in the article, we need stronger controls on people's data for whoever happens to make the phone's OS.
- 3np 5y agoThere’s still data sent to Google as part of Android except for currently obscure ones like /e/ and Graphene. It’s like a combination of the desktop Windows of the 90s (malware preinstalled by vendors) and today (increasing surveillance by the OS developers) with Apple (you need to basically risk breaking the device and void the warranty to get away from it)
- closeparen 5y agoFor practical purposes Android is not just the open source codebase but also the economic institution, where various middlemen get to do sketchy and low-rent stuff in between the trusted brand and the consumer. That is the “openness” that sets it apart from its competitor.
- brundolf 5y agoAnd at the end of the day that's the reason I don't use it anymore. It's just the wild-west.
- uhtred 5y agoI use /e/os and have found it to be a great experience. https://e.foundation/ https://e.foundation/
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoI've made a complaint to the police and my local privacy regulator (in France) more than a year ago, regarding blatant and widespread illegal data collection by Google on probably most Android devices on Earth. I have not yet heard back from them and I doubt they'll even consider this report. Here it is in a nutshell. 1. set up a brand new phone (Pixel, OnePlus or else) 2. do not connect to a Google account at first or if it is required, log out and remove the account as soon as possible 3. create a contact on your phone with any Contact application (with a name, email address and phone number). Do no enable sync for this application. 4. open the Play Store to download any application (e.g one from your government). You'll be asked to connect to a Google account at this stage, of course 5. now, try to log into your Google account to download the application but *not have Google automatically collect all your contacts' details* (stored locally). You can't! This is not possible because: 1. by default, adding the Google account will enable the automatic synchronization for all Google-related apps and services (incl. Contacts). You can disable this before login. 2. You cannot stop the sync of these Contacts while connecting Google Play to your account. It is done in the background and by the time you switch from Google Play (or the login page) to the Settings menu of your device, the sync will have started (if not completed already). 3. You cannot do all this in airplane mode obviously, as it it's impossible to log into a Google account without an Internet connection. This is illegal per GDPR, because at no point you consent to have your data collected by Google. Also, Android does not inform you of this collection so it's up to you to discover this by browsing your device's settings, down a a sub-levels. It is a massive collection (and fraud) because most people have probably a hundreds contacts or more on their mobile device. Most mobile devices run Android. Google Play is almost impossible to avoid nowadays (Twitter, Facebook, Youtube, Whatsapp, Signal, Firefox, your bank's app, your employers' apps... they all require Google Play and Services to work correctly). Worst, your contacts' information isn't yours, but your contacts' too. Google simply helps themselves. With 73% of mobile OS market share, around 99% of Android users being probably logged in just to access the Play Store, Google probably has collected the names, email addresses, phone numbers and lots of private information (birthday dates, home and work addresses, employers' names, job titles, digicodes, etc) of every person on Earth, and probably more than once. Without asking for permission. This is easy to reproduce, 100% illegal (at least per GDPR), everyone is affected and yet, _crickets_. If you're in the US and believe this is illegal there too, please contact a privacy organization or any entity that might do something about it, at least if you don't like having all your contact details collected by Google without consent.
- streamofdigits 5y agoHow far are we from a phone that: ships fully formed - no flashing and stuff, has reliable supply chain and production, is open source only, usable on a daily basis (stable, normal battery life, all basic apps, easy upgrades) and ideally repairable / recyclable as much as possible? I would leave "high-end" specs and price constraints out of scope to make this a reality sooner than later. There are several contenders and combos /e/, lineageOS, pinephone, fairphone etc and I wish them all godspeed (also other small efforts out there I am not aware of), but its not clear which one is ready for just the simple, honest, society and environment friendly mobile computing that we should have had all along and it is really a crime that we don't.
- jmnicolas 5y agoFar in never. There's no (real) money to be made, manufacturers don't care. I use GrapheneOS. It's rough but at least it gives me peace of mind.
- streamofdigits 5y agoWhy is there no money to be made? I would at least pay to buy the hardware and possibly for ongoing software support as well (depending on how they structure such support or any other "soft" features). E.g. I think its a jolly good idea if somebody really checked for a living all those open source apps. In any case if there is really no viable business model for private mainstream mobile computing we have been duped big time: This is not a consumer device, it is track-and-trace machinery.
- PeterisP 5y agoIn order to have a reasonable, stable supply chain at all, you need quite large scale; and even then your phone would have much smaller scale than the mainstream competitors and so would be be significantly more expensive than their models with similar hardware, both because it's targeting a niche and also because all this tracking&targeting does result in some revenue stream for the manufacturers. It indeed is a jolly good idea if somebody really checked for a living all those open source apps, however the math works out only if you allocate the salary of those people over a million phones, not if you have only 10000 customers. Perhaps you would actually be willing to pay a large premium for that, but the vast majority people are not. Perhaps a meaningful number of people would be willing to pay a small premium like 10-20%? But that's not what's reasonably achievable, the differences are much larger as soon as you go off mass market production or start needing software modifications which are a large fixed cost that is cost-effective only if you're distributing it over very many phones. There have been many companies in the past which have found out the hard way that few people really care about privacy that much (or they care but can't really afford much, which has the same effect), but for a recent example, you can look at the troubles of Librem 5; IMHO it's trying to do similar things, but its price/performance is suffering because of that and you be the judge whether their business model looks viable. And if you want a trustworthy supply chain, then your (already high) costs literally double, again, Librem 5 "USA" model is an example of that - a $2k phone where the core functionality (excluding the privacy) is essentially the same or worse as a $200 phone from a Chinese brand.
- afrcnc 5y ago"significant amount of user data" = telemetry to catch and fix bugs something the study doesn't tell you
- dlevine 5y agoIn the book Post Corona, Scott Galloway talks about red vs blue companies. Blue companies (e.g. Apple) charge a premium for their product and offer you some level of privacy, while red companies give you their product (the Android OS and Google Apps) for "free" and then collect lots of data on you (and use that to make money). Amazon is clearly going this route too with the ridiculous number of ads they have started putting on their Echo Speakers. He predicts that over time there will be paid versions of a lot more products for people who want (and can afford) privacy. I know there is a lot of hate for Galloway, and I take everything he says with a grain of salt, but this struck me as pretty astute.
- literallyaduck 5y agoPrivacy is an illusion and premiumification of items is selling the sizzle not the steak. "Therefore whatsoever ye have spoken in darkness shall be heard in the light; and that which ye have spoken in the ear in closets shall be proclaimed upon the housetops."
- jstrebel 5y agoDo yourself a favour and and disable the Google Play Services on your Android Phone. Almost all apps will keep on working, the power consumption will decrease dramatically, your battery lifetime will be about 3days on one full charge. (My observations on a Samsung Galaxy A41). I assume that the Google Play Services are the culprit that phones home all the time.
- autoexec 5y agoLast I checked the default keyboard samsung installs on their phones was collecting what you typed and sharing/selling that data with third parties. I try not to store or access any personal information on my cell phones when i can avoid it, but at a certain point, just having one is enough to seriously compromise your privacy. Strong regulation with real sharp teeth is the only thing that can fix this situation.
- ibeckermayer 5y agoStrong regulation by whom? The organization that brought us the CIA, NSA, FBI, and the rest of the alphabet soup of “security” bureaucracies that spy on us arbitrarily? Strong regulation could easily worsen the problem, as it can lead to a ratcheting up of the regulatory burden until only mega corps like Apple and Google could afford to make phones, and upstarts like Purism and Pinephone get squeezed out. How about before getting so gung ho with pointing the government gun at everyone’s head, we consider the option of rolling back the unjust regulations that already exist which give the mega corps undue government privilege (patents are a good place to start), and encouraging (by voting with our wallets) organic alternatives to emerge, like they already are doing.
- autoexec 5y ago> The organization that brought us the CIA, NSA, FBI, and the rest of the alphabet soup of “security” bureaucracies that spy on us arbitrarily? Which origination do you think that is? you think they all came from the same place? Every one of these agencies came into existence under very different circumstances at different times and they fall under different branches and operate in different areas. Do you mean "government" in general? Yes, it's a horrible thing that these agencies are being used to spy on all American citizens in violation of our freedoms, but that fact doesn't mean that we shouldn't allow any government agency anywhere enforce regulations. How that does that make any sense at all? You could say the same for literally anything. "Who should regulate the amount of lead in our drinking water? The organization that brought us the CIA, NSA, FBI, and the rest of the alphabet soup of “security” bureaucracies that spy on us arbitrarily?" > Strong regulation could easily worsen the problem, as it can lead to a ratcheting up of the regulatory burden until only mega corps like Apple and Google could afford to make phones, and upstarts like Purism and Pinephone get squeezed out. It literally couldn't worsen the problem of our privacy being violated and used against us by cell phone companies. If it's illegal for Google to do it, and we had regular independent verification that they were not violating those laws, than it wouldn't matter if the only cell phones that existed on the whole of Earth were made by Google. Google still wouldn't be doing the bad thing we're trying to stop. Yes, I'd prefer to have more choices but there's zero requirement that regulations make it prohibitively expensive for any company even an upstart. In fact, because this would be regulation against collecting, securing, maintaining, analyzing, marketing, and selling our personal data it'd actually save companies tons of money since they'd no longer be dong any of those things. Established companies who are currently exploiting consumers won't get to profit off of them as they are currently, but they will still save a lot of time and money not exploiting the public. > How about before getting so gung ho with pointing the government gun at everyone’s head, we consider the option of rolling back the unjust regulations that already exist which give the mega corps undue government privilege (patents are a good place to start) This isn't an either/or type of thing. There's a lot of great and important things we should be doing. This is one of them. Let's do them all. > and encouraging (by voting with our wallets) organic alternatives to emerge, like they already are doing. If "the market" were going to solve this problem, if it were capable of solving this problem, it would have been solved already. It's not. Until strong regulations are in place there will continue to be a very very strong perverse incentive to not solve this problem. We're coming up on 50 years of mobile phone technology and at present there are no comparable options for cell phones and mobile networks that preserve privacy. None. It's not regulations forcing Google and Apple to collect our personal data. They are choosing to do it. They could stop tomorrow if they wanted to. They don't want to. They won't stop until they are forced to stop.
- kop316 5y agoSkimming through the article, they compare a few ROMs from significant phone manufacturers, LineageOS with Google Play, /e/, and Stock Android. It seems that LineageOS has GApps installed and /e/ does not (presumably since they use MicroG?), so it is looking like for LineageOS, it's really Google Play leaking this data.
- jeroenhd 5y ago> It seems that LineageOS has GApps installed It doesn't come with GApps installed, you need to flash those packages manually. That said, LOS also comes without an app store whereas /e/ has a custom F-Droid-compatible store pre-installed. Combining LineageOS and MicroG is kind of hard (relatively), because LineageOS enforces signature validation, which MicroG needs disabled to properly fake the proper Google APIs. There are non-enforcing builds and build instructions available, but that's not the default. /e/ seems to have the necessary patches enabled by default, which makes using popular apps without flashing GApps a lot easier.
- Guest42 5y agoCan you recommend a couple phones that are compatible with LOS + microg? I looked on their sites and it wasn't quite clear
- dron57 5y agoI've been using the Pixel 4a 5G for about 6 months with MicroG and Lineage. Works really well. Other than Whatsapp and Google Maps I don't miss anything, but those apps have alternatives too.
- Guest42 5y agoFantastic!!!!
- commoner 5y agoLineageOS for microG supports all phones that LineageOS does. Here's a spreadsheet of the full list along with the specs of each device: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1bx6RvTCEGn5zA06lW_uZGZ_dq6qQyCZC_NifmyeC1lM/htmlview https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1bx6RvTCEGn5zA06lW_uZ... If you want a more specific recommendation, could you provide your budget and your requirements?
- snvzz 5y agoCompanies like Google hold a lot of power over their users. It's all-or-nothing, and not being part of the Google ecosystem is extremely inconvenient as more and more services depend on it. Only legislation can give power back to the users. It shouldn't be necessary to put up with this level of surveillance by big corps in order to function in society.
- cute_boi 5y agoyou mean the legislation that forced banks to use google safety nets create hindrance in rooting the phone? I really find myself in hopeless position these days when Google can do anything freely because they have enough cash to lobby anything.
- snvzz 5y ago>the legislation that forced banks to use google safety nets create hindrance in rooting the phone? You're saying some legislation made SafetyNet a legal requirement?! You should try and elaborate on that.
- winternett 5y ago>Only legislation can give power back to the users. It shouldn't be necessary to put up with this level of surveillance by big corps in order to function in society. Don't worry, after about 7 years there will be a low key class action suit and we'll miss the $7 payout and lawyers will collect the leftover millions for the sake of symbolic justice. Then perhaps big industry won't ever learn it's lesson again. Congress has already proven that they're the Rip Van Winkle of IT awareness unless it pertains to boosting their personal investments.
- user3939382 5y agoI would go further and say that this describes the ineffectiveness (I’d say corruption) of Congress and the justice system across all industries. This is just the one you notice because you’re well acquainted with it. If you have a strong stomach go look up Steven Donziger.
- Tepix 5y agoI'm wondering if Nokia phones with Android One are not snitching on their users like the others are.
- durnygbur 5y agoNokia licensed their mobile brand and now it's some Chinese producer slapping the logo on the devices. Probably on pair with Xiaomi and Huawei.
- commoner 5y agoI don't think this is accurate. Microsoft acquired Nokia in 2014, but then spun off the brand to HMD Global (a new Finnish company) in 2017. HMD and Foxconn have a partnership in which both companies co-design the Nokia phones that are then manufactured by Foxconn in Taiwan. https://www.anandtech.com/show/10879/hmd-closes-nokia-brand-and-patents-deal-with-microsoft-nokia-smartphones-on-the-way https://www.anandtech.com/show/10879/hmd-closes-nokia-brand-...
- summm 5y agoprobably below Xiaomi even: they promised an open bootloader once, but broke that promise and every bootloader after that was fully locked up.