16 ms·
Solar-powered aircraft flown for nearly three weeks without landing
- amai 5y agoWhy use a solar powered plane and not a solar powered airship?
- sokoloff 5y agoRelated (in at least one dimension): https://www.airspacemag.com/daily-planet/airborne-for-64-days-163974675/ https://www.airspacemag.com/daily-planet/airborne-for-64-day... Cessna 172 flown for 64 days, 22 hours, 19 minutes and 5 seconds.
- etaioinshrdlu 5y agoThe linked article on that page is broken. I’m guessing he somehow refueled in flight?
- sokoloff 5y agoYes. Also added oil.
- ceejayoz 5y agoYes. They flew low and slow over a long, straight road and refueled from a truck that kept pace with them. https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2008/march/pilot/endurance-test-circa-1958 https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2008/march/pilo... > A Ford truck, donated by Cashman Auto in Las Vegas, was outfitted with a fuel pump, tank, and other paraphernalia required to support the aircraft in flight. When fuel was required, a rendezvous would be arranged on a stretch of straight road in the desert near Blythe, California. An electric winch lowered a hook, the fuel pump hose was picked up, and Timm or Cook inserted it into the belly tank. It took a little more than three minutes to fill the belly tank. > The total fuel capacity of the airplane was 142 gallons. Plans called for refueling twice daily. Sometimes weather or the inevitable glitches upset the schedule, and a new rendezvous was worked out by radio. This activity was repeated more than 128 times. The whole article is worth a read; it was quite the hairy sounding endeavour. Two months in a C-172 would kill me, I'm quite certain.
- belthesar 5y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20120429214314/http://www.airspacemag.com/history-of-flight/Moments-and-Milestones-The-Pressures-On.html https://web.archive.org/web/20120429214314/http://www.airspa... Haven't read it to find the answer to your question yet, but bless the Internet Archive
- sologoub 5y ago> When asked by a reporter if he would ever replicate the stunt, Cook replied: “Next time I feel in the mood to fly endurance, I’m going to lock myself in a garbage can with the vacuum cleaner running, and have Bob serve me T-bone steaks chopped up in a thermos bottle. That is, until my psychiatrist opens for business in the morning.” ROLF!!!
- mr337 5y agoI think he sums this up nicely. What a feat!
- mistrial9 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cessna_172 : "From December 4, 1958, to February 7, 1959, Robert Timm and John Cook set the world record for (refueled) flight endurance in a used Cessna 172, registration number N9172B. They took off from McCarran Airfield in Las Vegas, Nevada, and landed back at McCarran Airfield after 64 days, 22 hours, 19 minutes and 5 seconds in flight. The flight was part of a fund-raising effort for the Damon Runyon Cancer Fund.[14][15]"
- JohnJamesRambo 5y agoWas the engine oil okay for that long continuously? I mean I guess obviously it was but is that ok?
- detaro 5y agoaccording to the airspacemag.com link in other comments, they replenished the engine oil in flight.
- j245 5y agoNeat - but not interesting from a technological stand point.
- OJFord 5y agoIs it not? I don't imagine such sustained flight, continuous operation of all the equipment and engine for so long, would've been a design consideration. Presumably there's a number, I just doubt it's tens of days, so isn't it interesting that it was achieved?
- j245 5y agoThis record was set ~3 months after someone else did it for 50 days. From an engineering stand point, performance of components or materials are always assumed to be much worse than actual and the forces / conditions they are subject to overestimated, with further factors of safety applied on top. This is how it should be. It also means properly designed things will carry on working better than you expect (on average). It’s not interesting (to me) from a technological stand point compared to the solar UAV because flying up and down the same road with a truck refuelling you is not useful, and if others (e.g. Military, NASA) could be bothered to do it - they would probably do a better job relatively easily. To me - It’s the same as building the worlds longest domino trail. You could beat the previous record by 1 million dominos which is neat but.. what have you proven, and why does it matter ?
- OJFord 5y ago> This record was set ~3 months after someone else did it for 50 days. Fair enough, I didn't know about that, I'd have been as interested to hear about either of them first, and like you not so much the other second. (And I doubt the commenter that shared it meant it as 'wow look 64 compared to 50' either.)
- andrepew 5y agoOver 1500 hours of continuous operation is quite a feat. Components like magnetos have service schedules much shorter than that. This also ignores all the unexpected issues that pop up in aviation. My only experience with Cessna 172s are rentals which are treated like crap - those planes need something looked at like every 50 hours.
- cornellwright 5y agoYou can see the aircraft used at the Las Vegas airport. It says "Hacienda Hotel" on the side and I think it's hanging over baggage claim.
- fredliu 5y agoWasn't Facebook working on a similar project (Aquila)?
- wanderingstan 5y agoYes, it was cancelled in 2018: https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/26/facebook-permanently-grounds-its-aquila-solar-powered-internet-plane/amp/ https://techcrunch.com/2018/06/26/facebook-permanently-groun...
- not-my-account 5y ago"Airbus ultimately believes that the aircraft could remain airborne for “months at a time” and could provide internet to both commercial and military customers." What sort of power requirements would this bring? I assume that it would be more sophisticated than just dumping RF energy indiscriminately across a huge area.
- gusgordon 5y agoFor those curious about the physics of these aircraft, here's an analysis I did of the same concept. The goal is to determine the smallest aircraft configuration that can indefinitely sustain flight: https://github.com/gusgordon/atmospheric_satellite#readme https://github.com/gusgordon/atmospheric_satellite#readme
- onychomys 5y agoIs there a reason you optimized the amount of starting energy in the battery? I know basically nothing about how solar power works, but surely you'd just fill the battery up to 100% with an extension cord on the ground before launching it?
- mkr-hn 5y agoBatteries are heavier when fully charged. Takeoff weight matters. It's not much heavier, but it might be enough to affect things at this scale. edit: remember the context. This is about an abstract optimization to find the minimum viable aircraft.
- rrss 5y agowhat kind of batteries are meaningfully heavier when charged? are you just talking about like E/c^2?
- jermaustin1 5y agoA water/gravity battery comes to mind. Definitely not the answer you are looking for, but an answer none the less.
- enchiridion 5y agoDepends on your definitions. Is the water pumped considered part of the battery before it’s elevated?
- akozak 5y agoDoesn't appear to have a payload in the picture. That would add weight & power draw.
- Breza 5y agoProving the concept is huge, since this is an idea that's at least as old as satellites. Once they have the proof of concept, I see three additional hurdles: 1. Safety. Prove you can keep these things in the air for months at a time without any of them crashing. 2. Payload. Exactly what you point out. 3. Operational usefulness. Can this thing stay in the air for months while flying the routes necessary to complete its mission? I really hope Airbus and others are able to make this concept work. It would be nice to have an in-between option between UAS and satellite.
- nabla9 5y agoFirst communications satellites were just passive reflectors. They were just big inflated balloons made with reflective material. Same idea could work with solar powered aircraft. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PAGEOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/PAGEOS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Echo https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Echo
- laurent92 5y agoIsn’t taxi-takeoff-landing what consumes the most energy? It’s often 10% to 25% of the total flight consumption for supersonic planes like the Concorde (but not for the SR-71, since they refueled in-flight to fill the rest with inert gas https://theaviationgeekclub.com/former-sr-71-driver-explains-why-the-blackbird-had-to-refuel-after-takeoff/ https://theaviationgeekclub.com/former-sr-71-driver-explains... ), and still a lot for the other planes.
- OJFord 5y agoBased on your percentages then, I think you mean most per unit time? So then, given three weeks far exceeds normal flight time (by more than 1/25%)...
- zarazas 5y agoBut there is starlink for internet in rural areas
- onychomys 5y agoSure, but even if these planes managed to somehow cost as much as a starlink satellite, it'd still be cheaper to do it this way because having some dude toss it up into the air for takeoff is basically free compared to even a fully reusable Starship flight.
- Breza 5y agoPlus it can be deployed on an as-needed basis. Large concert in a rural area? Hurricane destroy your city's infrastructure? Toss up a few planes and get the service you need for a week or month until the situation is resolves. (At least that's the theory... I hope this technology works as planned.)
- marcodiego 5y agoComplete outsider doubt: Does this has the potential to replace satellites? Or, why did google project loon failed?
- Breza 5y agoI think it would complement, not replace. There are missions that nicely fit the capabilities of UAS, there are missions that nicely fit the capability of satellites, and there are in-between missions that could benefit from long-duration aircraft like this. I live in the east side of Washington DC. We regularly have police helos flying overhead. I wonder if this kind of platform could supplement their efforts for things like tracking escaping vehicles when the police call off pursuit (car chases are frowned upon here due to the fact that they're so dangerous).
- Breza 5y agoCherry picking examples, UAS will always be best for a construction manager looking at the progress of a highrise, and there's no way an atmospheric vehicle would host a world class space telescope. But things like monitoring deforestation could benefit from a vehicle that can take high-res photos day after day without needing a lot of maintenance and then be packed up and shipped to the arctic to estimate sea ice. A single satellite would have trouble performing both missions.
- elif 5y agoA craft like this is more likely to serve predator/reaper/sentinel missions. Particularly ones in locations you don't want the aesthetics of full state surveilance but still want the same operational capacity.
- Breza 5y agoI envision more unarmed uses. I live in Washington DC, where the aesthetics don't matter as much as the operational capability. We're so used to helos flying around that spotting them has become a game: https://twitter.com/HelicoptersofDC https://twitter.com/HelicoptersofDC When a bank teller says "The robbers drove away in a blue car," the police want the ability to roll back the tape and find all the blue cars that left the bank in the past hour and see where they are now.
- tpmx 5y agoProbably/unfortunately not really a Starlink competitor, right? They don't specify the "cruising" altitude, but I assume it's ~10 kilometers at most, probably less? Airbus would need quite a few of these in order to build a global internet connectivity service then. Edit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_Zephyr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_Zephyr says ~20 km. Starlink sats (will) operate at ~540-570 km: https://spaceflightnow.com/2021/04/29/spacex-launches-60-more-starlink-spacecraft-fcc-clears-spacex-to-fly-satellites-at-lower-altitudes/ https://spaceflightnow.com/2021/04/29/spacex-launches-60-mor...
- Tepix 5y agoThese planes can compete with Starlink in certain scenarios, for example you can launch them in the event of floods that knock out the regular telecommunications infrastructure.
- tpmx 5y agoWith Starlink soon having ~global coverage, why bother transporting, launching and servicing these aircraft for a one time thing? I don't see the benefit. Will also be really hard to reach low prices for end user terminals with this approach. Very high quality visual/signals surveillance seems like a much more obvious market fit.
- Tepix 5y agoFor starters, all network participants need an expensive, large and power hungry Starlink antenna. An airplane could work with smaller devices as endpoints, such as phones.
- btilly 5y agoFirst, Starlink has limited bandwidth per square mile. Therefore it cannot conceivably provide telecommunications for densely populated areas. Second, all you have to do is make these aircraft compatible with cell phones. So your target population already has "end user terminals" literally in hand. Third, this is not a one-time need. Local disasters happen fairly regularly, and sometimes can be predicted in advance. (For example hurricanes.) There is real value to an instant telecommunications network that can be deployed on short notice. Now I don't claim that this is actually economically viable. But it is not exactly crazy, either.
- stareatgoats 5y agoThis is great and points to how solar in some cases already can facilitate continuous operation without the need for refueling of planes, boats, cars, you name it. Expect this to grow as battery and solar cell tech develops further. My favorites atm are the yachts that are capable of sailing just about anywhere in the world without a drop of fuel. The price is prohibitive, but considering that you might not need a house anymore it is actually getting close to possible for a reasonably senior tech employee. [full disclosure: no affiliation] https://www.azura-marine.com/aquanima-45/ https://www.azura-marine.com/aquanima-45/ https://www.silent-yachts.com/silent60/ https://www.silent-yachts.com/silent60/
- wingworks 5y agoThese guys spent the night on the Silent-Yachts one a ~month ago. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iIte4FNI0U0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iIte4FNI0U0
- Tepix 5y agoWhy wouldn't you use the wind energy also? It's a lot of fun, readily available and a lot cheaper…
- jjcm 5y agoFrom the images on the site it looks like it deploys a sailing kite in addition to the solar powered engines.
- KineticLensman 5y agoOh hi jjcim. Another cool research project from where I used to work. [0] Back in the day, the development building had a great view of the runway during the Farnborough air show and my pals on the Zephyr project would give me a shout if anything interesting was taking off. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_Zephyr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_Zephyr
- Retric 5y agoSails have several major downsides, most notably they take up a lot of deck space and cause a boat to tilt to the side. If you’re regularly sailing long distances it’s much faster but top speed isn’t that big of a deal when your living on the boat full time. Other options like kites and wind turbines can work well but they all all significant upfront costs as well as ongoing maintenance issues. Spending that same money on a bigger boat gets you much more space, and of course a generator can give you redundancy or higher top speeds.
- kwertyoowiyop 5y agoIt’s so depressing to read that one proposed mission for this plane is…monitoring oil spills.
- pythonaut_16 5y agoWhy is that depressing? Unless you have some silver bullet to remove the need for oil or prevent any future oil spills it seems like creating innovative technologies to detect them as soon as possible is a good thing. It would be like if someone developed a cheap, non-invasive technology that could detect cancer extremely early, and then you complained because they hadn't cured cancer instead.
- pvarangot 5y agoI worked on a satellite imaging startup. For this kind of stuff usually oil and gas and large scale agriculture are the first ones to show interest. They don't need great resolution or revisit times and their assets span over very big areas so monitoring from the ground/sea or with small drones is really expensive.
- esel2k 5y agoDepends on the appplication. An NDVI analysis or determining vast crop / growth problems yes but if you want to check for disease this is often done by drones to have higher resolution. I could imagine doing regular field visits with these planes and avoid the high labor costs of drone management/flying. Sources: I work in a big agtech company with satellite imagery. PS: We should connect.
- GhostVII 5y agoWhat's the benefit over something like a weather balloon? Pretty interesting thought, tape a few hundred micro SD cards to it and you've got some impressive bandwidth.
- brandmeyer 5y agoGoogle's Titan project was going to deliver internet service (... before it got strangled in the womb grumble grumble ...). LTE from aircraft to client, and a dedicated point-to-point radio from aircraft to backbone.
- detritus 5y agoYou can tell this where to go - weather balloons are utterly beholden to the whim of wind patterns.
- Breza 5y agoAnd this is more than a theoretical risk... https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2016/04/23/the-runaway-surveillance-blimp-that-captivated-the-nation-is-likely-grounded-for-good/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/powerpost/wp/2016/04/23/...
- runarberg 5y agoI thought that you could somewhat control a balloon by using different wind patterns in different elevations. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NvJ2Ei8K2DI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NvJ2Ei8K2DI
- bentcorner 5y ago¿Por qué no los dos? It looks like solar-powered zeppelins are a thing, although with the brief googling I did it looks like nothing really exists just yet.
- GhostVII 5y agoYea I guess I was more thinking of a kind of blimp, where it still has some solar to allow it to maneuver around, but not to actually stay up. If the aircraft needs to stay in one place maybe that would be less efficient though, since it would be harder to fight winds.
- giantg2 5y agoI would love a low cost electric ultralight.
- tehjoker 5y agoI wonder how the engine can keep operating for such long periods of time without maintenance!
- endymi0n 5y agoThis stuff is pretty sturdy. The lifetime of brushless electric motors used in this kind of dirtless environment is basically the lifetime of the bearing used and can usually be measured in years of nonstop operation without any modification already.
- JCM9 5y agoIn 1958 two guys flew a Cessna 172 nonstop for 64 days without landing. They refueled mid-air via a truck that drove under them during a low pass.
- orzig 5y agoEven more impressive, they did it before audiobooks!
- njovin 5y agoI had never heard of this record until now. Cross-country flying in small planes like this can be incredibly tedious and the refueling sounds very dangerous. I can't imagine doing it for this long. Apparently, neither can the guy who did it: > When asked by a reporter if he would ever replicate the stunt, Cook replied: “Next time I feel in the mood to fly endurance, I’m going to lock myself in a garbage can with the vacuum cleaner running, and have Bob serve me T-bone steaks chopped up in a thermos bottle. That is, until my psychiatrist opens for business in the morning.” Source: https://www.airspacemag.com/daily-planet/airborne-for-64-days-163974675/ https://www.airspacemag.com/daily-planet/airborne-for-64-day...
- hodgesrm 5y agoGood Lord, what an adventure! Thank you for posting!! I had no idea about this flight. Here's an account that popped up on Google. https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2008/march/01/endurance-test-circa-1958 https://www.aopa.org/news-and-media/all-news/2008/march/01/e...
- markl42 5y agohow did they um...."defuel" their bodies and such in the air?
- philk10 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18158207 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18158207
- 5y ago
- hellohntoday 5y agoI'm assuming the flights were achieved mid summer when they days are longest and it can't yet operate outside this window. If this is the case, shame they don't just admit this up front
- alwayssmh 5y agono mention of their recent faults too... (https://www.reuters.com/article/airbus-zephyr-idUSKBN26J0NU https://www.reuters.com/article/airbus-zephyr-idUSKBN26J0NU)
- Breza 5y agoAll of this comes with a big "Work in progress" caveat. Still, this type of technology has been theorized for decades so it's nice to see Airbus making progress. Let's see if they can get it to the point of commercialization.
- phnofive 5y agoPerhaps they are aware of eatrh's axis and will move operations to the southern hemisphere? Or adjust the drone's speed to stay in sunlight?
- Arrath 5y ago> Or adjust the drone's speed to stay in sunlight? Depending on altitude, that would require an awfully fast aircraft.
- Johnny555 5y agoThey ran the 18 day flight test in September, so not the dead of winter, but also not on the longest summer days: A solar-powered aircraft has completed an 18-day test flight offering hope it could be used to create internet access for billions of unconnected people around the world...The test flight touched down in Arizona on September 13. https://www.thenationalnews.com/world/the-americas/2021/10/11/solar-powered-airbus-zephyr-completes-18-day-test-flight/ https://www.thenationalnews.com/world/the-americas/2021/10/1... Phoenix has about 12.5 hours of daylight on Sept 13th. (compared to ~14.5 hours on June 21st, ~10 hours on Dec 21st.
- jcun4128 5y agoThe wing tips look wicked, not sure if necessary
- elif 5y agoI like the optimism of the article but I can't help but believe that the primary purchasers of this capability will be armies and spies.
- kbenson 5y agoThey're hoping to get six months flight eventually out of a propeller craft. I can't help but wonder what we could eventually get out of a solid state craft.[1] They mention batteries in this article when referencing that six months target, but I have to assume servicing the propellers is important as well. 1: https://www.engineering.com/story/how-the-worlds-first-solid-state-aircraft-achieves-propulsion-with-no-moving-parts https://www.engineering.com/story/how-the-worlds-first-solid...
- bagels 5y agoTo fly through the night, you need energy. I'm wondering if it's more efficient to store it in the batteries, or as stored kinetic energy by flying to a high altitude and descending through the night.
- teraflop 5y agoIt's a good idea, in principle. But according to the sources I could find, to get enough gravitational potential energy to equal the electrical capacity of Zephyr's batteries, you'd have to lift the entire craft by about 70km. https://www.aviationpros.com/engines-components/aircraft-airframe-accessories/batteries/press-release/12438400/amprius-amprius-silicon-nanowire-lithium-ion-batteries-power-airbus-zephyr-s-haps-solar-aircraft https://www.aviationpros.com/engines-components/aircraft-air... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_Zephyr https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airbus_Zephyr I can imagine you'd want to take advantage of gravity to a certain extent, but it seems a bit tricky to estimate how much. Presumably there's a particular altitude at which the aircraft's overall efficiency is at a maximum. Deviating from this altitude allows you to store a bit of extra energy (which means you can get away with a smaller battery) but you don't want to deviate too far, or you'll lose more energy to various inefficiencies than you're saving. And you probably need to keep some electrical reserve power anyway, in order to be able to actively navigate away from unfavorable winds.
- kbenson 5y agoThere's also the fact that this is optimizing for power usage in the air, when really what we'll want to optimize for most likely is power usage while doing some specific task in the air, and that task may necessitate specifics of what altitudes it can function at.
- Breza 5y agoThat's the real challenge. Being able to, for example, loiter over a suspected clanlab 24/7 for a month to gather evidence is far more taxing than flying an optimized route.
- 5y ago
- Tade0 5y agoNot mentioned in the article, but the li-ion batteries onboard the aircraft have a silicon nanowire anode thus achieving amazing energy density: https://www.amprius.com/2019/10/airbus-partners-with-amprius-leader-in-high-energy-density-battery-technology https://www.amprius.com/2019/10/airbus-partners-with-amprius...
- stavros 5y agoDo you know what sort of density and discharge rates they're talking?
- Tade0 5y agoOnly the company's own marketing materials, but as a data point six years ago they partnered with a Chinese phone manufacturer to create a device with an absurd (at the time) 5800mAh battery: https://www.gizchina.com/2015/04/27/bluboo-x550-will-feature-ampirus-battery-and-mediatek-pump-express-plus-for-super-fast-charging/ https://www.gizchina.com/2015/04/27/bluboo-x550-will-feature... They've made some improvements since, but the exact parameters haven't been disclosed.
- stavros 5y agoHmm, that seems interesting, but it's not very specific (Ah/g), so who knows what the actual capacity is... They do mention a 1.25A discharge rate, at least.
- jack_riminton 5y ago“ It is a sustainable, solar-powered, ISR and network-extending solution that can provide vital future connectivity and earth observation to where it is needed” This military-industrial style of English always sounds very odd and is ubiquitous with these companies. Is it because they’re selling to Military buyers?
- Ice_cream_suit 5y agoUnfortunately the first commercial application of this is likely to be helping loitering munitions stay aloft longer, to lethally target humans. https://www.brookings.edu/techstream/loitering-munitions-preview-the-autonomous-future-of-warfare/ https://www.brookings.edu/techstream/loitering-munitions-pre...
- anaganisk 5y agoFunny how tech these days end up majority in use either for targeting Ads or warfare or surveillance.
- sandworm101 5y agoI love that these aircraft are built so lightly and fly so high. They are probably cheaper than any missile capable of shooting them down. They could operate over enemy territory without much worry. Send dozens. Shooting them down will cost more than their replacement.
- ebawho44 5y agoWith a cruise speed of 30kn, better hope its not too windy wherever you are flying, winds aloft can often be much higher than this
- Breza 5y agoThat's a definite problem for ISP duties. Law enforcement is used to "sorry no air support tonight, it's windy."
- wiz21c 5y agoLooks more like a drone to me (ie, there's no useful load).
- marvinblum 5y ago> "which is designed to stay airborne for weeks at a time in order to provide internet to users on the ground" The hardware for this purpose doesn't require a heavy aircraft, I suppose.