6 ms·
> How do we neuter the power of Twitter mobs? Stop listening to them? EDIT: That's especially effective since the Twitter mobs keep moving targets every coupl
by ekianjo 5y ago
> How do we neuter the power of Twitter mobs?
Stop listening to them?
EDIT: That's especially effective since the Twitter mobs keep moving targets every couple of weeks anyway. They don't have any patience.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoSeems like a very simple solution. I struggle to see any material effect to MIT had they simply ignored these complainers.
- civilized 5y agoMany such cases. That's why we need to look more closely at why the professional administrative class so eagerly does the wishes of activist mobs. Could it be that the activists and the administrators believe the same things?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoOr the admin feel like they are taking the easiest way out? But if I was an admin, the easier thing would be to ignore it.
- AwaAwa 5y agoI thought it was because, if the mob doesn't get their way, they single out the 'admins' as the next target. At least that's what I remember before I cut out on following twitter as a first party platform.
- civilized 5y agoIt's very conceivable, but I haven't seen any examples in a long time, if ever.
- fighterpilot 5y agoThat could be part of it. According to surveys the administrators are very left-wing, even more than the professors who are already almost completely left-wing themselves.
- jjoonathan 5y agoYeah. Over the years I've seen a number of incidents where (someone in) the Harvard administration assumes that the student body, professors, and alumni universally share their view that Affirmative Action is an unquestionable good and then gets caught off guard when this turns out not to be the case.
- pessimizer 5y agoThey do the wishes of right-wing activist mobs, too, and the original victims of campus "cancel culture" were Palestinians. Could it be that the administrators believe in nothing?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- SteveDR 5y agoOr administrators don’t want the mob’s fight to be amplified into mainstream national news. I’m sure this would upset donors.
- epicureanideal 5y agoI had the same thought. Maybe the mob is just the excuse the administrators can point to to do what they wanted to do already. Perhaps they both understand their role.
- wepple 5y agoThe power they have isn’t over us, it’s over institutions and businesses who seem to bend to the will of the mob. I’d like to see some data on whether a Twitter storm in a teacup has any measurable negative consequences for a typical large organization, and whether they need to listen as often as they do.
- version_five 5y agoThe more decoupled an organization's or its leaders' incentives are from the "market" - the more risk averse they become. Everything is about keeping your head down and avoiding controversy. The goal for many orgs now is not to make customers happy anymore, it's to avoid the ire of a small group, and keep rent seeking. As we move towards post-capitalism this will only get worse.
- hallway_monitor 5y agoNobody ever got fired for canceling a controversial speaker
- hanklazard 5y agoThis is basically the problem, as I see it. On one hand, keep the speaker. The potential downside: social media outrage that may escalate and get covered on MSM if it gets big enough. You and your dept / uni get a lot of bad press or if things go really sideways, your job could be on the line. The potential upside of this decision? People go to a talk and consider some issues, but it’s not like you (the committee / administrator / dean etc) get any real tangible incentive from this outcome. You basically just did your job, if you’re lucky, everyone just moves on. On the other hand, cancel the speaker. The upside: MSM will congratulate you or ignore it, but regardless, you’ll be seen as making the “right” decision by most people you interact with. Some free speech types (a dying breed it seems) might get upset but they don’t seem to have much power over the general public’s perception or decisions about firing made by the university. So the decision is obvious and it’s the one that gets made time and time again. And it’s the way the Twitter mobs continue to hold sway, especially because so much of the MSM lives on Twitter. A similar rubric occurs in a large corporation by the C suite. Once the mob forms, there is everything to lose and almost nothing to lose by taking a stand on an issue seen as unwoke. If this is to change, incentives need to change, mainly creating disincentives for cowardly execs / deans and incentives for those who make principled and/or courageous stands. (None of this is a carte blanche endorsement against activism, it’s just to say that there are reasons that no one stands up against Twitter mobs and we may want to explore ways to change this dynamic unless we desire a future ruled by mobs)
- fighterpilot 5y agoIt's not that simple. We have a collective action problem. The first mover sticks out like a sore thumb (or tall poppy) and takes all the heat from the mob. If everyone simultaneously became sensible and simultaneously refused to bend to the mob, the problem would go away, but it's difficult for heterogeneous agents to coordinate in this way. Being brave and taking the first step entails a lot of private cost and a lot of public benefit, which is why so few choose to do it.
- SamuelAdams 5y agoExactly. Considering Twitter accounts and likes and retweet’s can be bought amplifying a particular message might only represent less than 10 actual people. Additionally I’ve never discussed with someone in real life, person to person, about a single Twitter “cancelation” effort. If these issues were truly significant, they would engage the (actual) media, engage (in this case) with official university complaint systems, etc. These things take more time and effort than retweeting a hashtag though, and most people won’t follow through with it. Which tells me they’re really not all that bothered about it in the first place.
- dartharva 5y ago>Stop listening to them? You can, but institutions and businesses won't. That's the entire problem.
- zeven7 5y agoI don't understand why this isn't the norm. It seems obvious that if you ignore them, they'll go away. But nobody's trying it.
- refurb 5y agoPrecisely. Just because you have a Twitter account doesn’t mean your ideas or opinions are well thought out, rationale or even coherent.
- tsss 5y agoI would argue the opposite is the case. What political opinion expressible in less than 500 characters can be worth listening to?
- jasonladuke0311 5y agoTo people with a facile, grade-school understanding of the world, 500 characters is plenty.
- rdtwo 5y agoUse the same Twitter mob to target and destroy the spineless administrators what made the decision in the first place.
- phtrivier 5y agoIt's possible to assume that most twitter mobs are harmless and insignificant. The problem is that once in a while, the twitter mobs becomes the yellow jackets. So you need a way to jauge how likely it is that the keyword-activists will get up over a particular topic.
- silisili 5y agoExactly. To quote Dave Chappelle, out of context to avoid further debate... "...they dragged me on Twitter. Well I don't give a fuck because Twitter isn't a real place."
- AzzieElbab 5y agoWell, what if Netflix had comments and likes?
- silisili 5y agoIIRC, Netflix used to have voting until Amy Schumer's special was mass downvoted. Comments wouldn't be practical I guess. But I'd imagine his opinion would be the same, really.
- effingwewt 5y agoTo quote[1] Dave Chappelle- 'Twitter's not a real place.' [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kS-E6VtD_rE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kS-E6VtD_rE