13 ms·
The Off-Grid Laws of Every State in America
- DoreenMichele 5y agoInteractive map makes it easy to get to the section for a specific state. It even worked on my cheap, dysfunctional phone.
- analognoise 5y agoCool now let's all get together and buy some land and make some kind of hacker collective.
- EarlKing 5y agoGreat! Then we can spend six months arguing about the color of the bike shed while the crops die.
- motohagiography 5y agoGoing to space, don't care.
- grp000 5y agoEven if you did get into space, unless there was a massive leap in propulsion tech, you'd probably have to be self sufficient doing mundane tasks. You'd have to farm and put up space-bike sheds, and then, yes, paint them.
- mdndmkd 5y agoLOL to live with the people that self select to live in a commune with people from THIS SITE?? Of all places? Sounds like Hell
- osipov 5y agothis is such a great start up opportunity! we can use a search engine for buying land taking into account offgrid laws.
- npteljes 5y agoTangent, but I like reading about utopias, and Wikipedia, as usual, have been a goldmine. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_utopian_communities https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_American_utopian_commu...
- BoxOfRain 5y agoThat does sound like a cool idea, though can you imagine what a nightmare organising it would be? We’re an opinionated bunch as it is, organising would be like herding cats.
- hasbot 5y agoI have 11 flat acres outside of Asheville I'm going to put up for sale next year.
- m0ngr31 5y agoPretty high overview, but good overall. I built an off grid home this last year and it's pretty great.
- kortex 5y agoThe New York blurb seems hilariously off the mark. Well water and septic systems are pretty much the norm around here, and it's solidly suburban to semi-rural. Yeah, NY is strict relative to many states, but it makes it sound like you need some super special variance to have off-grid water and sewage. Also plenty of people up north have rather lax opinions about code enforcement. Been to many off-grid residences where code enforcement is a quick glance and a tire kick.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- sandworm101 5y agoDripping with assumptions about what people want from 'off grid living'. I have family members who are totally off-grid, totally disconnected from all physical services (they have internet). I helped setup many of their systems. They do not use anything like a "pit toilet" nor do they "collect rainwater". Off-grid living isn't medieval. It can be just as luxurious as any city. Water comes form wells drilled deep into the ground. Sewage goes to the same septic fields, not pits, that are common in older suburbs across NA. Bathrooms have in-floor heating. Televisions are just as big as anywhere else. The kids play minecraft with their friends while mom and dad stream netflix. Step into a modern off-grid house and you wouldn't see any differences. A modern solar rig can generate so much energy in summer that my relatives are seriously considering bitcoin mining. Once the batteries are full that power capacity is going to waste. Their electricity cost during such times is literally zero.
- fnord77 5y agoI would argue that having internet access is not "off-grid"
- lotsofpulp 5y agoI would say it is the most important grid. Or least replaceable.
- ghaff 5y agoHopefully Starlink and similar help. Water/sewage is fairly straightforward anywhere you can drill a well. And there are various options for electric and heat. But if you can't get wired broadband, your options today are either satellite (expensive, laggy) or microcell (expensive, not available everywhere)--neither of which allow you to "just use" streaming and other data-intensive services a lot of people increasingly see as necessary. And outside of a short-term vacation home, it's not unreasonable to think that at least minimal (e.g. no video streaming Internet) is something of a requirement for most people.
- nazgulnarsil 5y ago
- WaitWaitWha 5y agoThe giant caveat that needs to be recognized: > The laws about going off-grid are usually determined by local government and not the state, and they vary drastically. You can be in one county where off grid, septic or open privy, and rain catchments are the norm, and in the next county in the same State they are all highly restricted or outright prohibited. Have to check with the county or equivalent, if you have any off grid plans. Going by State level laws only, can be very expensive mistake.
- Gibbon1 5y agoHave to check for each property. A property can be part of a utility district for any of power, water, or sewage.
- geocrasher 5y agoIn rural Washington State, "off the grid" is often just one step above being homeless. I've seen some pretty bad looking shacks and yes, there are people living there. I don't think to ask them where their poo goes, but suffice it to say it's primitive. Somebody doing it The Right Way is bound to have it easy.
- curation 5y agoI've lived 'off-grid' in Canada (Near Wilno Ontario and Near Nelson BC) and thankfully it never occurred to me that there may be laws about _that_.
- nkssy 5y agoQuite a variety of rules, laws and regulations. I'm fairly sure there are errors in this list but the effort to compile it must have been significant. Kudos. Its so strange to think of rainwater collection as illegal. That is utterly dystopian. But there it is across multiple areas. Rules against solar? Wow! That's backwards and just screams stupid. On the flip side, I fully get regulation for any connection to the grid as with some kind of permit for the house wiring in general. House wiring should be up to some agreed upon code so its not made of sticky tape and extension cords.
- lelandfe 5y agoI can sorta kinda dream up a reason for solar rules to exist. Not good ones, mind. But can anyone take Devil’s advocate here and explain why a state might want to limit or prohibit rainwater collection? I’m struggling. Surely it can’t just be financially motivated, right?
- pkaye 5y agoIf a lot of it in diverted it might disrupt the ecosystem of ponds and streams that existed.
- kwhitefoot 5y agoCollecting rainwater disturbs the flow of water to downstream users.
- amanaplanacanal 5y agoThis is the real answer. In some cases that water is already owned by someone downstream. Here is the scenario: you are the first settler in an area. You settle by a stream and use the water for irrigation or whatever. Then someone settles upstream from you and diverts the water for another use. In many places you have property rights to the flow of that stream based on prior usage.
- denton-scratch 5y ago
- kwhitefoot 5y agoSo much for the land of the free! :-)
- friendly_chap 5y agoMe and my brother are both engineers and we tinker with off-grid existence on our vineyard. Some things we had to implement: - Electricity: Modern solar tech is suprisingly powerful. We have a tiny 1.6kw system with 3kw batteries plus a Chinese inverter which works amazingly. While it is small, it only cost about $2k altogether, including fittings. We installed it ourselves for the miniscule cost of risking our lives on a roof that's ~30 feet high :)). - Water: Next problem was water. We already had a 42m deep well, we just bought new pumps and some tech which controls water flow, so when you open the taps and pressure decreases, the pump starts. Works beautifully. Overall cost is a few hundred dollars for parts + installation, which we also paid a few hundred dollars for (we don't always have time to do things ourselves). - Heated water: once you have water you quickly realize 10C is not always pleasant to shower in. So for $150 we bought a water heater that heats water by 25+ C as it flows through. It works with a gas cannister since our small electric system is not powerful enough to heat water. - Sewage: we currently only have a compost toilet (ie. a hole dug into ground with a shed around it). We are moments away from having a proper English toilet and a septic tank (? another hole dug into the ground, but this time connecting the toilet inside the house to the pit with pipes) - Heating, cooking: we have massive masonry heaters and stoves all over the property. I think we heat the house in around -10 C for $3-$5 worths of wood per day. All in all modern solar enables off grid houses at a scale we could not imagine even a decade ago imho. 10/10 would do it again.
- Scoundreller 5y agoAn thoughts on incinerating toilets? They’re like $4k, but that’s cheaper than septic usually and no plumbing. Can run off LP or electricity. A big appeal is that you don’t have to worry about temperatures since they’re waterless. And you can take it with you if you move. > Heated water: once you have water you quickly realize 10C is not always pleasant to shower in. So for $150 we bought a water heater that heats water by 25+ C as it flows through. It works with a gas cannister since our small electric system is not powerful enough to heat water. I’ve had good success with an ~40L pot of water on the wood-stove/gas-stove (or sous vide cooler if you have the energy budget) and an immersible battery pump with shower head: https://m.aliexpress.com/item/1005003145415630.html https://m.aliexpress.com/item/1005003145415630.html Works well for dishes too. Since we don’t have running water in winter, these are great on top of a large bottle to fill a cup or wash hands hands-free: https://m.aliexpress.com/item/1005003145230040.html https://m.aliexpress.com/item/1005003145230040.html
- can16358p 5y agoHow on Earth using solar power on your own property be illegal or taxable in the first place?
- giantg2 5y agoAnother thing that isn't mentioned here is the hassle they can put you through if you have kids. For example, before they discharge you with a newborn they will ask you if you have electricity and some similar questions. If you answer no, they call child protection and have them investigate.
- BostonEnginerd 5y agoInteresting. I don’t think we got those questions for either of our kids. We do live in an urban area though. I recall some questions about food security and heat security though.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe only thing they (east and west coast hospital, last 5 years) asked is if we have a car seat. And for the mom to do a depression screening.
- giantg2 5y agoPA asks these questions, the car seat stuff, and makes you sign a paper saying you watched a shaken baby video. If they're worried about shaken babies, then they seriously need to fix the potholes we're so infamous for.
- denton-scratch 5y agoSo you're required to have a car?
- ghaff 5y agoThe standard process--can't speak to having a newborn--but it you've been under sedation is that someone will pick you up in a car from the hospital. Now, if you're at an urban hospital and happen to live just down the street might someone walking to the hospital to pick you up be OK? Maybe. Can't speak to what the rules literally say. ADDED: An of course someone picking you up may rent or borrow a car, take a taxi, or otherwise arrange for transportation.
- ashildr 5y agoSo in the land of the free you can’t use solar from your own roof because that would be communism.
- denton-scratch 5y agoWe get the rules on off-grid solar for 50 states; but no mention of wind. Almost every photo I've ever seen of a US farm (homestead, rural dwelling, what have you) shows a windmill in the yard. I think these windmills are really for pumping water from wells, not for power generation; but why is it assumed that going off-grid implies solar power?
- ghaff 5y agoThe short answer is that photovoltaics and associated storage have gotten much better (cheaper/efficient) over the past decade or two whereas a personal windmill probably doesn't look a whole lot different than it did 50 years ago. There were small ("micro") wind turbines being talked up for a time but the economics didn't make nearly as much sense as their backers promised. I've also seen small turbines used for cabins where there's fast water and not a huge amount of sun. But, for the most part, solar's going to make the most sense for personal power generation for most people on an ongoing basis. (Generators can still be the most economical approach just to cover outages.)
- CyanLite4 5y agoBeing fully off-grid is one thing, but I’d rather be self-sustaining. Like being connected to the grid but have enough solar and batteries to not need it most days, or at least could survive a few days without it. Connected to modern septic system and not have to pay high costs of sewers monthly. And connected to municipal water, but have a rainwater collection barrel just in case.
- xutopia 5y agoOne thing I love about the US is that there is always someone that does this kind of work for you. In Canada it seems to be way harder to know what we can do and where. Laws are posted online but they're so unclear for a layman like myself that I can't understand anything.