12 ms·
Multitasking Doesn't Work
- kosasbest 5y agoI've organized my life in such a way that I deliberately avoid multi-tasking since I read years ago that it doesn't work, and have proven to myself over the years that it doesn't work. YMMV. One thing I have done is introduce friction into my workflow. So I have a dedicated hard-drive that I boot into that is strictly for coding. Another is strictly for news & social media. This way if I'm coding, I am less likely to slide into Hackernews/Reddit/Twitter/Whatever. Friction is good and more people need to leverage it.
- ghgr 5y ago> So I have a dedicated hard-drive that I boot into that is strictly for coding. Another is strictly for news & social media. This way if I'm coding, I am less likely to slide into Hackernews/Reddit/Twitter/Whatever. Friction is good and more people need to leverage it. But then you're also less likely to get back to work once you are in social media, aren't you?
- sharkjacobs 5y agoI don't think that would be a problem unless you often find yourself absent mindedly almost accidentally starting to work when you mean to be taking a break.
- jscud 5y agoI imagine the point is to not slide over to social media until the coding is done, at least for a predetermined segment of time. Is that the idea?
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoI'm fairly certain you do multitask in someone's definition thereof; you have simply defined what you are doing as “one task” and someone else might disagree and this alone makes me suspect of all literature on this matter.
- tyronehed 5y agoIt has to do with whether or not the person being tested is right brain dominant or left brain dominant. The vast majority of people are left brain dominant and for them multitasking is extremely difficult because of the linear sequential nature of the left hemisphere. Right brained people, those with the right brain dominant over the left, have an easier time multitasking because the right brain is image oriented. The right brain processes information as images are processed, In a visual simultaneous manner.
- Guidii 5y agoThere's debate on the left-brain/right-brain model, which I think has been somewhat debunked[1][2] That being said, brains are weird and if you find you can multitask then go for it. I've gathered data on my own attempts to multitask and established that I cannot. [1] https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/08/130814190513.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2013/08/130814190513.h... [2] https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/right-brainleft-brain-right-2017082512222 https://www.health.harvard.edu/blog/right-brainleft-brain-ri...
- falcolas 5y agoAs someone who fights with ADHD, I strive to intentionally single-task. It doesn't always work, but not having to keep several things in the forefront of my mind make it more possible to be productive. Alarms and lists serve as my task manager, since my brain fails at it by default.
- hosh 5y agoCurious, are you able to have parallel thought streams? I know two people who can, and they both have ADD. (But when I asked around, many others who have ADD can’t, though they are capable of fast context switching).
- mullen 5y ago> Curious, are you able to have parallel thought streams? That's the problem. Parallel thought streams is where all my productivity issues come from.
- hosh 5y agoMy wife has to have something occupy one thought stream on a sensory channel in order to focus on the something she really wants to focus on on a separate channel. She usually runs three or four. A friend knows how to fork and merge parallel streams at will, but can get bored. The mental intensity he can achieve when all of his streams merge is much greater than typical. He tells me he’d run podcasts at 4x or something while he works on other stuff.
- falcolas 5y agoNope. My brain will context switch very quickly between threads sometimes, but that's often outside of my control.
- zozin 5y agoHasn't this been debunked for a while? To prove this all you need to do is have test subjects listen to a podcast or audiobook and then distract them with something for a second or two and the results will undoubtedly show that the vast majority of listeners stopped paying attention and what was heard was not comprehended/absorbed. Humans tend to think they are capable of more than they really are.
- hosh 5y agoAlthough rare, there are humans capable of parallel thoughts.
- milesvp 5y agoWhat’s interesting is you can see the seperate patterns on an fmri. It’s also known that people advanced in certain kinds of meditation are very likely to show dual gamma waves. I think it’s suspected that it’s something that can be trained, although it’s very possible only people with the ability are drawn to practice these meditations.
- kaba0 5y agoIt sounds very interesting, could you please expand on it/give me some keywords I can look into it?
- milesvp 5y agoWell, I've been looking, and mostly what I've been able to find is references to papers that show strong correlation with Buddhist monks and exceptional gamma waves. The paper I'm thinking of may have not been reproducible, and fallen off the radar. I would have seen it no later than 2011. I might be quoting a book on neuroscience as well (I went through a phase where I was looking at neuroscience for inspiration for AI research). I think the idea was that people who meditate while doing certain types of "mindless" tasks seem to be able to hold 1 wave around that task, while holding another wave around other thoughts. What I can't remember is if this was a one gamma wave per hemisphere scenario, or 2 for the whole brain. If you're interested at least in consciousness and brain waves, you could do worse than to look into reading some of the references in "States of Consciousness: Experimental Insights into Meditation, Waking, Sleep and Dreams" Dean Cvetkovic & Irena Cosic Editors
- robomartin 5y agoI multitask precisely as a multitasking OS does. It works reasonably well. This is to say, I do focus on one thing at a time and task-switch. When I task switch I store the state information I need to return to the prior task. I generally keep a text document open all the time. When I have to task switch I write down where I am leaving the current task and what I have to do when I come back. Sometimes it is a couple of lines of text. Other times I have to add more to it. For me this works very well. It avoids the issue of an interruption or having to deal with multiple things in a day killing your productivity because it takes an hour to get your brain back into the prior task. Simple. Effective. At the end of the day it looks like you did multiple things simultaneously, just like a multitasking OS. In other words, my system tick is >= 1 hour, not milliseconds.
- PaulHoule 5y ago(1) If you are a software dev you probably have a process that involves waiting for compiles, builds, downloads, etc. At the very least you have to have one thing you do when you are waiting. (2) Frequently people multitask to manage their emotions. It is like having a choice between a room that is too cold and too hot and you can be comfortable moving from one to the other.
- Spivak 5y agoTo expand on (1). Preemptive multitasking is the one that doesn’t work very well because it interrupts your flow and the cost of context switching is high. Cooperative multitasking is fantastic since you only task switch when you’re blocked.
- allenu 5y agoSimilar to (1), I somewhat have a process for async discussions. Sometimes, when I know starting a Slack thread will lead to lots of discussion, I wait until I have mental space to be ready to switch to them. Once those conversations start, it's very hard to concentrate on the current task. Other times, I know people will take a long time to respond, so I'll kick off those discussions early and be comfortable in being able to context switch away from it when needed.
- adrianmonk 5y agoFor #1, I try to pick a task that's closely related to the main task at hand. I think related tasks can help retain focus rather than losing it by shifting gears. For example, while my code is compiling, I might think through the specific steps I'm going to take to try it out when I run it here in a minute. Or try to plan out the next change I'm going to make to the code if this current code works. Or start a list of some unit tests I need to add.
- Aerroon 5y agoI don't doubt that multitasking makes us less efficient and more prone to mistakes, but the question is by how much? Sometimes it might be worth multitasking and being less efficient at both tasks. If I'm washing the dishes and listening to a podcast I'm completely okay if I'm at 80% efficiency at washing the dishes and paying attention to the podcast. Neither activity generally requires all my attention. The same goes for many other activities that we do. Playing a video game and listening to a lecture is probably still better than just playing the video game. Just don't expect to absorb the lecture as well as you would if you were to fully concentrate on it.
- voakbasda 5y agoMore generally, multitasking can improve your outlook and mental well-being. Mix a fun task with a menial task, and the instantaneous toll of the work balances out better.
- katbyte 5y agoYep. And actually provide some Motivation to do the task/help with procrastination.
- Blikkentrekker 5y agoWorld class chess players in tournaments often walk around during the game and do so on their own turn or go to the bar and have a drink. “I think better when I walk.” is a commonly heard statement; many research scientists when thinking about a problem also take a walk outside and find that thinking while walking improves it. But in soft science research without any real definitions it's of course quite easy to not incorporate such things because terms have no meaning and then say that “research proves it” while all it did is prove things about their ad hoc definition of “multitasking” which is far removed from the real world.
- xyzzyz 5y agoYeah, I like listening to books when doing household chores, as I can do those almost entirely on autopilot, with very little thought required at all. I also listen to books when doing hobby woodworking, as most of the time spent is on rather menial tasks like sanding or planing. However, not all of it is like that, and you often need to focus, do some calculation or planning. During those times, I need to pause the book, as I can neither focus on it nor on the task at hand. Human bodies have lots of ability to multitask, it’s just their brains have very little.
- winternett 5y agoForgot where I read it, but one of my favorite quotes on multi tasking is: "You're not really multitasking, you're just screwing up multiple things at the same time" I do however feel a great sense of accomplishment whenever I have several browser windows open while I work though. :|
- pdpi 5y ago> I do however feel a great sense of accomplishment whenever I have several browser windows open while I work though. :| This is a subtle point. I can easily have 10 tabs open and swap between them while mono-tasking. E.g — ignoring for a moment the fact I'm writing on HN... — right now I have 4 tabs open on Sentry, where I'm comparing stack traces for a couple of instances of two related errors. I have another tab on the relevant PR, and a few more with docs pages for the relevant APIs/libraries. Swapping between these things isn't multitasking, it's just managing the complexity of the one single task.
- bandie91 5y agoaccording to my experience human multitasking can work until tasks do not conflict which of your "peripherial" they want to use. ie. people can think and talk while peeling potato. but often they can not effectively type on the computer and talk about something else.
- hosh 5y agoMy wife has ADD. Along with one other person I know (who also has ADD), she can have parallel thoughts, ordinary, about 3 or 4 concurrent tasks, usually split along sensory modalities. She can multitask. The closest I have come to multitasking was on the rare occasions, I drink coffee, and that’s more of a predictive optimization and pipelining rather than multitasking. I have asked around of other people who have ADD, and they don’t report parallel thoughts, just very fast context switching.
- fouric 5y agoI think that multitasking between multiple tasks has been somewhat-generally known to not be possible (for most people) for a while now. However, this part of the article was novel: > Other studies suggest that people who frequently “media multitask” (like listening to music while checking email or scrolling through social media while watching a movie) are more distracted and less able to focus their attention even when they’re performing only one task. This was novel to me. Listening to music negatively affects your ability to focus? I guess it's time to throw out my headphones... Well, but that article links to "Multicosts of Multitasking"[1], which references studies made on "heavy multitaskers", defined as having high "MMI" scores. What's MMI? "A high MMI score means an individual engages in a lot of media multitasking (e.g., checking email while also perusing Facebook and watching Netflix), and a low score means he or she does not (e.g., checking email without any secondary media)." Whoa there - checking Netflix and Facebook are completely different than listening to music, and it should be obvious that the former two are mutually exclusive with performing other tasks (simultaneously) - but that doesn't imply the same for music. I think that the HN submission page might be making some unsupported claims... [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7075496/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7075496/
- Pokepokalypse 5y agoMedia multitasking is great. Tragic though, for advertisers.
- 3pt14159 5y agoNo study will convince me about music and my personal ability to focus. It needs to be the right music (Emancipator, Nicola Cruz, etc) but I can write 2000 to 5000 lines of high quality, tested code with the right song on repeat for the day and I know its the same for many others.
- sg47 5y agoI listen to Bach or Beethoven when I need to really focus. Works wonders. I use it sparingly so that I don't get bored.
- sys_64738 5y agoMy job description says I must multitask.
- sleepysysadmin 5y agoI feel like I never quite got the answer of why it doesn't work. It's also pretty nuanced. If I have laundry, dishwashing, etc going. I am multitasking but I don't need to expend attention. So there's certainly a threshold where multitasking becomes a problem. In MSP world, I didn't control my own schedule. If the schedulers thought I only needed 30 minutes to do a 3 hour task. That's all you got. Some coworkers would hard limit. Put the 30 minutes in and leave the job unfinished. The stated rule was double/triple billing; which is a felony but you know they'll throw you to the wolves if you actually break the law and get caught. However, the rule was that if you needed more time. You had to work on multiple things at once. If you did not accomplish a task, you had to set the ticket back with justification why you didn't get it done. About 25% of the time if you didnt get it done and put in a justification. Someone would come talk with you. Not to help, but usually chastise you.
- kaba0 5y agoOnce it’s a habit, it is automatically executed without active attention, so the majority of your daily routine is simply not an activity you “partake in”.
- naveen99 5y agoTo me moving your hands and legs independently in dancing is multitasking, and I can’t do it. But some people can dance and juggle. Best I can do is reading hacker news while compiling or training a convolution network. But anyone can hire multiple people to do multiple tasks.
- arichard123 5y agoI still don't understand what multitasking is. When does a series of actions become a single task instead of multiple tasks? Is it purpose?
- agumonkey 5y agoProbably a matter of mental categorization with overlapping intermediate states.
- passivate 5y agoI think its sort of a madeup term. I don't think emergent phenomenon can be divided into "tasks" the way we think of them in the real world. If as you're thinking on a task you're also recalling prior memories - is that multi tasking?
- commandlinefan 5y agoThis has been known and demonstrated for decades, but we're still ordered to do it anyway. If I were more of a conspiracy theory type I would think that Machiavellian managers demand multitasking precisely because they know that it does cause problems that they can blame on their underlings later whenever anything goes wrong so they come out looking great. But that would be crazy talk, of course.
- agumonkey 5y agomultitasking done right can give more pleasure (juggling with more complexity tickles your brain) and productivity but it's difficult to grasp.
- _wldu 5y agoI once worked with a mathematician in a research group who said, "Multitasking destroys me". I did not know what he meant at the time, but I do now. If your job is to be "on the bottom of things" doing careful calculations and designs, you should not multitask. But if your job is to be "on top of things", then you will have to. Can't mix the two safely. You do not want the engineer/architect calculating the load on a beam to be checking email, on slack, answering the phone and other "on top of things" tasks. But some managers think you are a slacker if you are not running around with your hair on fire at all times. They don't understand the difference.
- snarf21 5y agoThat is an interesting way to describe it and makes a lot of sense. One thing that I see discussed a lot is a question of value. Engineers message each other across the day lots of times and it causes the same multitasking issues and break of concentration for "bottom of things". However, sometimes that may unblock two other engineers for several days of productive work. This is where structure matters. Having a tech lead that can handle all these interruptions is ideal but it takes someone who can balance the managing and the execution. It is also the mark of a good manager; someone who understands that their success is actually to make everyone else successful and that means shielding them from the nonsense.
- kaba0 5y agoAnd I’m fairly sure I would perform much better at university if the courses were exactly the same, just serial. I really like getting to the very depth of an interesting subject, but doing a few hours a week of one will simply kill my brain. As soon as it finds it interesting, it has to context switch to the next one.
- jagged-chisel 5y agoEducation disruption: Serial University where you can take a course at a time, spending all your available time on that course, completing the work in much less than a quarter or semester if you like. Graduation from SU should result in a degree or it's no better than every other self-study option available at the moment.
- danans 5y ago> One study found that just 2.5% of people are able to multitask effectively. .. and a queue of anxious white collar parents forms to get their child tested to determine if they are in the 2.5% /s
- at_a_remove 5y agoIf only a hundred million bonehead "managers" understood this concept. They still think they can multitask their way to free FTEs materializing out of nothing.
- nathias 5y agobecause you can't multibrain
- 1121redblackgo 5y agoIts kind of cool seeing this reality become known by more and more people to the point where I think most people kind of understand this now. Just a small piece of evidence for this is the resurgence, and regaining popularity, of the one monitor workflow.
- tombert 5y agoI definitely feel like I'm generally less productive when I have music on for a majority of things, though I will put on headphones with one key exception: if the noise the headphones tune out is more distracting than the music I would be listening to. Though typically when I do put on music to work, it's old Amiga soundtracks or something. I wonder how much the difference in levels of distraction for lyrics vs. no lyrics.
- scrumbledober 5y agoI think there's a big difference between lyrics vs no lyrics, as well as known vs unknown music. I have a much harder time not paying attention to the lyrics (or even melody of an instrumental song) that i know well than music I haven't heard before.
- Zababa 5y agoThis looks like a content farm article with no substance. > Other studies suggest that people who frequently “media multitask” (like listening to music while checking email or scrolling through social media while watching a movie) are more distracted and less able to focus their attention even when they’re performing only one task. Compared to what? Music for me is usually a way of escaping the hell that can be open spaces.
- gumby 5y agoWhile I agree with the article, this paragraph is, erm, a distraction: > Other studies suggest that people who frequently “media multitask” (like listening to music while checking email or scrolling through social media while watching a movie) are more distracted and less able to focus their attention even when they’re performing only one task The causality could just as well run the other way: people with poor focus adherence presumnly exhibit it regardless of the amount of distraction.
- rmason 5y agoI worked for a millennial once and multitask was his favorite word. Tried it for awhile but I made way more mistakes. Course he rode me for those mistakes. So I only pretended to multitask and my error rate plummeted. Does each generation have to figure this out on their own?
- aeturnum 5y agoIt's certainly true, in my experience, that trying to do two or more things "at once" disrupt my focus and increase my error rate, but I think that high level gloss on the situation is unhelpful for technology workers. Of course, if I ever had the opportunity to work on a single task, I can be very productive at that. Easiest way to get into flow state. However, that isn't common for my work. Often, instead, I am working on something that crosses many boundaries and has unavoidable downtime. For instance, right now I am working on visualizing erlang processes using Phoenix and d3js to see if I can detect unusual memory use growth. I'm going back and forth between erlang docs and Phoenix views and elixir code and javascript (with, of course, lots of reading and searching in between). I have no idea if that's multitasking, but when I have to move from one layer to another I experience the same kind of disruption and need to refocus as I do when I'm interrupted. Another quality of multi-tasking that I frequently experience is the difference between needing to respond to external stimulus v.s. being able to orchestrate multiple processes to run in parallel. They both involve context switching and loss of focus, but there are huge differences in the order of magnitude.
- overview 5y agoI haven’t read the article, but the title irrefutably contradicts a very interesting understanding of multitasking shared by Dr. Andrew Huberman on the Huberman Lab podcast. Maybe by being provocative and choosing an absolute position on the matter, the author was hoping to attract readers. For those interested in the explanation given by Huberman, skip to the section titled “Multi-Tasking Is Real” found in the description of the video [0]. [0] https://youtu.be/H-XfCl-HpRM https://youtu.be/H-XfCl-HpRM
- joe_the_user 5y agoWhenever these studies come up, it makes me wonder "how exactly are they defining task and multi-task here". For example, driving involves keeping the car at a reasonable, avoiding obstacles on and off the road, deciding whether you need to turn soon, noticing the condition of the vehicle and related things. These could all be considered tasks and are indeed difficult to keep straight when one begins driving. But they can indeed be done together. And while it might be easier to somehow do each separately, the combined task of driving isn't possible without this "multitasking". I understand that nearly everyone talking about multitasking here is referencing whether or not tasks at work can be efficiently combined. But I don't think that addresses the larger issues (what's a single task, when two tasks intersect, how can you not multitask, is the difficulty of "multitasking" a limitation of humans or is it that the task itself becomes inherently more difficult).
- nbzso 5y agoThe part about the music resonates with me. For the known task related to low cognitive focus I use for background classical music (Corelli, Telemann) with low volume. When I want full cognitive load (learning, coding), silence and isolation are working for me the best.
- spurgu 5y agoDefine multitasking. Programming and debugging at the same time can hardly count as being unproductive. Or keeping an eye out for your kid in the playground while talking to a hot mom. Or being mindful or how long you've been frying your fishsticks and what you're going to put in the salad.
- hatmatrix 5y agoI feel like I've written good code while listening to online seminars in the background (and having retained important parts from it). I believed it to be because I use my visual faculties when coding and it doesn't interfere with my auditory channels.
- suzzer99 5y agoI pretty much tune out any article that starts out "studies show". When it comes to soft metrics like "productivity", studies show whatever you want them to show. How many studies never saw the light of day because the result was uninteresting, or ran counter to the narrative the study's author wanted to put out? Just say "there is evidence to suggest" instead.
- jhoechtl 5y agoYes it does No it does