12 ms·
Brain implant provided immediate relief to a severely depressed patient
- maxwellwhite 5y agoThe title reads like a joke.
- gchamonlive 5y agoCan we have nice things? A technology to alter brain function to actually make peoples lives better and not be abused to make them also complacent, obedient, work twice with half the pay without complaining and buy the highest bidding brand.
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoEh, sorry. We probably could have, but you just gave me all these great ideas. Then again, if I’ve learned anything from the past decade, forget all that working harder stuff, I’ll just figure put how to sell advertising straight into your brain implant, don’t mind me while I take some of the most talented programmers in the world to do this.
- bobmaxup 5y agoI don't think deep brain stimulation is that sophisticated, so you probably don't need to worry about it right now.
- pram 5y agoMicrodosing taser shots to your brain, just hustle and grind things
- asdff 5y agocan't wait to be able to mount a docker image in my brain
- bArray 5y ago> [..] abused to make them also complacent, obedient, work twice with half the pay without complaining and buy the highest bidding brand. Not to worry, the new brain implant provides immediate relief from negative feelings about the brain implant! You'll be hysterically cackling in no time on your way to work at your third minimum wage job in the mines, with a protein snack made of an assortment of bugs. In all seriousness, this is highly concerning, especially in conjunction with the powers that have been given so easily during the COVID pandemic. Imagine in 10 years time it is declared that there is a 'depression pandemic', and for the better health of yourself and those around you, you must get your anti-depression implant in order to return back to work, and without your implant passport you will not be allowed into bars, restaurants, etc. Those that have already had the implant call you 'anti-Science' and publicly ridicule you as a second-class citizen. The President at the time publicly declares "our patience is running thin", as pressure ramps up to combat yet another infectious wave of depression. The government promises "the implant will only be used to track and trace contact with those suspected of having depression", but soon the police realise that such technology could also be used in "exceptional" criminal cases, where your state of mind around the place of the crime can be submitted as evidence to your involvement. Once there is some acceptance and legal standing, the use becomes more and more common place. Eventually some smart people realize that there is some pattern of behaviour for people who are about to commit a crime, and so pre-crime arrests and thought-crimes arise. The future has never looked so safe!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Taywee 5y agoIn the city I live, people couldn't even be convinced to wear a cloth mask for basically any reason, and people picketed an elementary school because the district implemented a mask recommendation. I can imagine your scenario, it's an interesting enough thought for some dystopian fiction, but I don't think the clear one-to-one analogy between an infectious disease and crippling depression work in any way at all. In the COVID case, it's an infectious disease with some possible long-term damage, high rate of infection, relatively moderate risk of death, and a scramble to try to contain or slow the spread. I don't see how any of that can be compared to depression, a non-contagious disorder that very often destroys all quality of life in the sufferers. Honestly, I don't see any gain in this incredible pessimism. A brain implant seems to have some potential to allow some people to have hope in successfully living a life that isn't controlled by a cloud of grey, and the first worry is in a dystopian government using it to brain control the public, because there is a pattern of behavior in how governments desperately tried to control a pandemic in the past?
- john_moscow 5y agoWe can't. Depression is your brain's reaction to not being able to pick and maintain long-term goals for prolonged time. And the increased number of depressed people in the past decades is an indication that something about our society is going wrong. Dealing with it without resolving the underlying cause is effectively turning people into obedient work force that has accepted its fate.
- diordiderot 5y agoSo the sadness that accompanied working a min wage job full time evenings and weekends through 6 years of university was my inability to pick and maintain my goals, not economic stress and lack of sleep. I feel so daft.
- john_moscow 5y agoIt was a clear signal from your subconsciousness that you were putting time and effort in something that didn't bring long-term value. If we lived in a pre-corporate era, you could have considered a trade, or helping run a small business, building rapport with the owner, or something else that would have had more meaning. Such things build up character, you sort of gain velocity and habits that help you propel yourself further later in life. Except we destroyed that with low interest rates and turning a blind eye for anticompetitive behavior. Now most people are replaceable cogs that ran out of goals that would motivate them. That's the real, and very big problem. I hope the degree was worth it, because otherwise you have wasted 6 years of your life. Paying for some administrators' trips to Hawaii with your student debt. And that depression feeling was a very clear early warning that could have helped you prevent that.
- scaramanga 5y agoPretty sure that the former is just academic jargon for the latter.
- krageon 5y agoAre you sarcastic or do you genuinely not see how those are the same?
- omgwtfbyobbq 5y agoFortunately, or unfortunately depending on how you view it, brains don't seem to work like that. The likelihood of DBS being able to turn someone into an ideal worker/consumer is about the same as it being able to turn a Parkinson's patient into an Olympic athlete.
- caycep 5y agoI would generally agree with this...the electrodes and microcontrollers we have tend to be relatively crude. BUT...I would say apathy as a broad symptom/syndrome is known to be associated w/ an untreated Parkinsonian state...so if some enterprising postdoc somehow finds a target nucleus that improves apathy w/ macro stimulating electrodes in the near future...we could all be wrong..
- omgwtfbyobbq 5y agoThat might be possible, but it's likely more of a person to person difference than something that can be reliably used. Even with people with PD, whether and how well DBS will work is variable, and even after it's put in, assuming it works for someone, programing is about finding a good balance between beneficial effects and unwanted side effects. Even if there is a target to improve apathy, it'll likely come at the expense of some other unwanted side effects.
- caycep 5y agoThe problem w/ PD-DBS is...the practice of implanting and programming the gizmos is much less standardized that it should be. Yes, there is some patient to patient variability...but you can kind of predict what will happen and how the patient will respond simply by mapping the anatomical location of the electrodes using Lead DBS or FSL or ANTS. The folks with well placed electrodes - the pro-movement/anti-tremor effect is remarkably consistent. The folks who either are implanted a few millimeters outside of the targeted nucleus, or roll in the door with some bizarre setting...not so much... That being said, I have heard for less measurable symptoms, i.e. OCD or depression...DBS implantation and programming is much more inexact, as you describe.
- jokowueu 5y agoI think you will like this https://qualiacomputing.com/2016/08/20/wireheading_done_right/ https://qualiacomputing.com/2016/08/20/wireheading_done_righ...
- rzzzt 5y agoGetting on better with your associate employee contemporaries. At ease.
- no_nono_no 5y agoI hope I am dead before all of this .
- judge2020 5y agohttps://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-021-01480-w https://doi.org/10.1038/s41591-021-01480-w
- dangom 5y agoImpossible that it would receive ethical approval, and for good reason, but it would be fantastic if such a study could be conducted as a double blinded placebo-controlled clinical trial. The fact the patient knows she has a myriad of doctors looking at her, and that she had to undergo an extremely invasive and unique procedure means we cannot separate the intervention from the response.
- bertil 5y agoMy partner is defending her PhD on using Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) i.e. a comparable device with constant current, to address severe OCD next Friday. Results are impressive (and published) on a small sample of ten patients. There’s at least three research programs that I know of (and probably a couple more if I had read the bibliography properly rather than just fix the formatting issues) with a dozen patients, some for OCD, other for other psychiatric issues. The approach is widely effective on neurological issues (Parkinson’s notably). Her lab have scheduled double-blind trials as soon as the next patient is operated, which I think is next month, with a protocol that includes 1. implanting the device, 2. only activating the electric current for half for six months, and 3. have another psychiatrist, blinded to whether the device is active, test its effect. There was an ethical debate on testing the device without Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) at the same time: CBT has a meaningful impact, and no doctor would imagine not prescribing that too, but scientifically, having patients with and without CBT, with and without DBS, etc. would allows to measure the effect of the each alone and together. I learned about this seemingly different approach (I suspect the device is similar, but the current is triggered differently, from the vulgarisation — haven’t read the academic papers) recently, but I’d be surprised if most of the protocols didn’t extend without much complications.
- caycep 5y agoWhere are they implanting it in her trial? There's a big and somewhat raucous debate on 5 different (brain) targets so far, but imaging/tractography has come a long way since they started doing it. for the CBT thing...could they just use a crossover trial design?
- drekipus 5y agoGood thing that everyone's getting depressed! A brain implant has come to the rescue! Now if we could only find a wealthy entity who could be a good Samaritan and help fund it for the people who need it most ... Never mind that "cackling laughter" isn't a sign that depression is gone, nor is depression a bad thing on the whole. The causes for depression are well known, so why are we trying to electrocute our brain into not acting in it's own best interests? This whole study is completely absurd.
- cyounkins 5y ago> why are we trying to electrocute our brain into not acting in it's own best interests? Depression leads to suicide. The indirect suggestion that suicide is in a person's best interest is ridiculous.
- drekipus 5y agoThat's as silly as saying a headache causes you to chop your head off. If you look at a screen all day, and get a headache, what do you do. Painkillers and back to the screen? Drink water and rest a bit? Pull out a hacksaw?
- cyounkins 5y agoIf you liken depression to a headache, it demonstrates we're not talking about the same thing. Depression is not the same as sadness. Analogies only take us so far, but a far better one would be physical pain so severe that, like severely depressed patients, the victims want to kill themselves to end it. Think torture, which is often how depressed patients describe their own intrusive thoughts.
- reedjosh 5y agoI'm so happy this is the top comment. Even if it doesn't stick. Most of modern society is a reason to be deppressed, but lets fix slavery induced depression with a dopamine triggering brain implant.
- goldenkey 5y agoWhich came first, the shape of the body or the depression? Because whenever I don't work out I get pretty damn depressed. I think we humans are built to get adrenaline releases regularly or to suffer from chemical imbalances. Running, weight lifting, whatever it may be, you need to do strenuous activity or you're gonna have a bad time.
- jasonhansel 5y agoIt says something when your first response to a story about a severely disabled woman is to judge the "shape of her body." If you only get "depressed" after not working out for a while, you've never actually experienced the sort of depression that the article is talking about.
- goldenkey 5y agoHave you ever heard of the para-olympics? There are tons of disabled folk who workout their upper body if their lower body is disabled. Average folk, not genetically gifted either, if you goto bodybuilding.com forums and search 'disabled' you can marvel at their accomplishments. I've experienced a general meaningless and wanting to die after not working out for months. Working out is the best antidepressant (aside from hallucinogens) that nature has to offer us. It's hard to get out of the slump and get started, but once one does, it really does help out one's brain. So don't tell me I haven't experienced clinical depression when I've been diagnosed with it many times.. This woman may have issues other than her obesity but I can guarantee that the obesity and lack of physical activity is a large reason for her depression. You don't get to walrus proportions by eating human portions and by exercising even sparingly unless you have some type of endocrine system issue.
- bserge 5y agoLol, Look at all the obese happy people and think again. Plenty of examples of rich people in good shape who killed themselves or said they have depression.
- goldenkey 5y ago
- monkpit 5y agoWasn’t this a Michael Crichton book?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nelsondev 5y agoIf this technology was made safe, effective, in patient control, and relatively non-intrusive, would you consider it? I’m imagining an app on your phone where on a day you’re feeling down, you turn it on for a bit.
- bciwayaway 5y agoNope. When I was a student maybe 5-10 years ago, I got to attend a conference on brain/computer interface research as part of an extracurricular. There were lots of interesting posters and products, but what really grabbed me was one of the headlining presentations. A group of researchers had learned how to use deep brain stimulation to do exactly this: provide immediate relief to a severely depressed patient. The video was dramatic, but I found it creepy. One second, the person looked sunk in misery as they talked about their bleak outlook on the world. The next second, they started smiling and saying that everything seemed alright. The on/off procedure repeated a few times with the same effect: misery, relief, misery, relief. I would take a brain implant to help me type faster, or treat a degenerative brain disease. But something that acted like a rapid mood-altering drug? Never, not after seeing that video.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> I’m imagining an app on your phone where on a day you’re feeling down, you turn it on for a bit. That’s not really what this brain implant does. The patient was experiencing certain obsessive thought loops leading to depression. The brain implant was targeting at disrupting the thought loops allowing for recovery. A brain implant that directly induced positive mood would be something else entirely. I suspect it could quickly lead to addictive behaviors as patients give up on naturally improving their condition and learn to rely on pressing the button for more happy thoughts instead.
- caycep 5y agowell...you can turn that Neuropace device they are using on and off w/ its smartphone controller...
- arp242 5y ago
- gonehome 5y agoAn interesting thought experiment is if you could recognize and interrupt other thought patterns to change behavior and preferences because you want to, but have a hard time implementing the change. Obvious example is addiction - there's some evidence that LSD and Psilocybin 'cure' alcoholics, I'd bet a targeted affect similar to this depression targeting could in theory work. Maybe other things too, making it easier to practice or less afraid of trying new things - overcoming other obstacles. Obviously there are risks, but the positives are interesting to wonder about.
- knaik94 5y agoI am honestly glad this sort of researching is leading the way towards a quantitative measure of depression. I am not sure if we'll get to the level of a finger prick blood test that we use for diabetes, but research like this makes me think more positively of the future. I know the medical healthcare community is slow to change to an evidence research based approach because "we do it because it's shown to work in the past". Doctors overriding novel research papers and going based on intuition is something deeply ingrained in healthcare culture. I hope and am optimistic that this changes with the current generation of doctors where research papers and UpToDate is a few clicks away. Depression is subjective because it's defined by symptoms rather than quantitative tests, but that's a limitation of the current technology. Psychiatry is one of the few fields of medicine that reminds me of when the answer to a lot of ailments used to be bloodletting. Some drugs like benzos and lithium help stabilize mood at the cost of cognitive functioning. Those aren't drugs of the past, they're used by doctors today. The zapping a brain with electrodes, sounds liked a more selective way of using ECT. I am sure the patients in these clinical trials understand the risks and I understand we're not in the age of medicine where lobotomies are done negligently or from a patriarchal view of how a man and woman should behave. I think the first major step to ridding the idea and stigma around mental health, such as when people casually call themselves depressed or say they're addicted to shopping, is to quantify it. I hate the idea that suicidal thoughts and attempts are the benchmark that the general public uses to gauge the severity of depression. This might not be a perfect study and it's so specialized to the individual. But even if this study shows which biomarkers from which parts of the brain are correlated with what kind of depressive symptoms, that would be leaps and bounds ahead of what current clinical psychiatry looks like. Edit: I just remembered the extrapolating that some people are doing in the rest of the thread. The Penfield Mood Organ from the world of Philip K. Dick's, Do Android Dreams of Electric Sheep. The first chapter describes one of the characters dialing the device to make herself feel deep despair and depression for a set amount of time twice a month to feel human. It's an interesting read if people haven't yet, Blade Runner is the movie based loosely based on it. They are different enough that the book is worth reading even if you've seen the movie.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> The zapping a brain with electrodes, sounds liked a more selective way of using ECT. This method is entirely different than ECT. The researchers used an electrode to disrupt specific ruminative thoughts that were causing, or at least perpetuating, the patient’s depression. It’s more analogous to traditional therapy methods applied by brute force at the physical level. Whereas traditional therapy would train patients to identify and break negative thoughts loops, this patient was apparently unable to do so. The brain implant physically disrupts part of the brain that contributes to those loops, opening the door for recovery from the self-defeating process.
- drfxyjhdyfrhgc 5y agoNo need for the implant. We all deserve to feel good. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trepanning https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trepanning
- aszantu 5y agoHaving my own history with depression and paranoia bordering anxiety I can only encourage ppl to look into food intolerances. Good treatment is just one part of it, my guess is that if the symptoms are treated, something else will go wrong long term.
- _def 5y agoYou're right, but depression is so tricky. It can help to treat the symptoms short term, which can enable you to treat the root cause long term.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoExactly that, and depression is rarely just the one issue, or rarely has just the one cause; if you're depressed because of e.g. poverty, just taking pills won't solve the root cause. I mean it might break a cycle and be a first step towards a better life of course, but that cycle could be broken by better circumstances as well.
- stef25 5y agoDid your problems get solved by eliminating certain foods and if so, how did you go about narrowing down the culprits? One problem with depression, as mentioned in the article, is that it's hard to define exactly what the problem is (there's no "depression center" in the brain) which means treating the symptoms is often the only option.
- OhHiMarkos 5y agoWell, I would say that by eliminating foods is only part of the problem and can guarantee you success. I think changing the way we eat and live is better. For starters, you could eliminate the extra-processed foods from your diet and add more natural sources of food. Then you could follow a regiment of 2-3 meals a day. Put the protein heavy + fatty foods in the first meal of the day and the carbs heavy foods as last meals. Make sure you are eating enough nutrients. Don't be afraid of salt. Add lots of fermented food cause there is a link with improving the gut and its ability to fight inflammations. Add movement and exercise, and make them a habit. Get a fitness buddy. Make sure you are a getting regular good sleep. I would recommend you a great podcast series called the Huberman lab, where this Stanford professor offers great insights about how the body works and what are the latest news from various research fields. https://hubermanlab.com/ https://hubermanlab.com/
- caycep 5y agoI think the interesting thing about this paper is: 1) it is a closed loop approach, using the Neuropace device to stimulate based on local field potential recordings from sensing electrodes listening...somewhere (once I bug my librarian to pull the PDF for me I'll look more closely). The biggest effort for depression so far was the Mayberg/Emory group's constant waveform stim in the subcallosal cingulate (medtronic devices which output a set voltage/pulse duration/frequency, which have to be changed manually). W/ mixed results... Neuropace has been out for, what, 10+ years out now, so it's not the latest/greatest tech but maybe good enough for what they are trying to do. 2) Busy year for Eddie Chang's group. They published the brain LFP -> synthetic speech paper a few months ago...
- ruined 5y agohow long until prisons just start diagnosing inmates with depression to wirehead them in the context of this https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/11/health/nursing-homes-schizophrenia-antipsychotics.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/11/health/nursing-homes-schi... it doesn't seem out of the realm of possibility what comes after that?
- hellbannedguy 5y agoI don't think our (U.S.A.) penal system cares enough to even bother with the procedure if it ever gains FDA approval. I have been told the Psychiatric Care at most prisons is atrocious. The prison in my county has had a running want ad for a Psychiatrist since the 80's. I'm referencing San Quentin. I once heard a perp confess to a crime that would send him to prison for life with one caveat, and it was, "I just want to be sent to a prision anywhere that has a good Psychiatric Unit."
- BarryMilo 5y agoIs this supposed to be an argument against the development of technology? Any technology can be used for ill or good, we just have to hold people accountable. Not sure what you would expect the device to do expect help people with depression. The US prison system is a horrible blight, but this really has nothing to do with it.
- bserge 5y agoLol, why wouldn't they do it now and give them pacifying medication?
- gremloni 5y agoDepression is so subjective that this “relief” is just one person’s word. I wish we had a way to quantify this better.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoAlso if n=1 then it could just be a placebo, no?
- cyounkins 5y agoWe have some measures like PHQ-9, QIDS, and MADRS. https://www.mdcalc.com/phq-9-patient-health-questionnaire-9 https://www.mdcalc.com/phq-9-patient-health-questionnaire-9 https://www.mdcalc.com/quick-inventory-depressive-symptomatology-qids https://www.mdcalc.com/quick-inventory-depressive-symptomato...
- webmobdev 5y agoCognitive Therapy has made depression "objective" and even provided a reliable diagnostic tool for it that even a layman can use it - https://therapydave.com/docs/burns-depression-checklist.pdf https://therapydave.com/docs/burns-depression-checklist.pdf ...
- gremloni 5y agoHow is that objective? It’s asking a person to assign a score on very subjective questions.
- bawolff 5y agoThe article indicates that previously she was unable to care for herself. While not exactly fully objective, i feel like - do you need someone else to take care of you, is not a purely subjective measure.
- trhway 5y agoi'm happy for the people whom it is going to help, especially with the stuff like Parkinson's. I'm just kind of surprised that our brain is so "simple" that such simple things do work.
- arketyp 5y agoThe SAT question related to the 366.25 rotation question can be interpreted as "revolve [around its own axis]" and you'd be correct in answering 3.