11 ms·
Redditors are right about the unfairness of the market
- auslegung 5y agoThis wouldn’t work, but my hot take is that anyone with potential insider information can only buy/sell index funds.
- autosharp 5y agoThis doesn't begin to address the issue. E.g. if you work at the fed you buy a 3x treasury index fund if you know rates will be lowered, or short 3x treasury index if you know rates will be raised. If you are a judge or legislator and you get to say if 30% charge on app stores is reasonable, this affects 20% of the Nasdaq 100 index. So you buy/sell that over a 24 hour period.
- ziml77 5y agoA couple possible solutions: Disallow them from being directly involved in investment decisions. Make them hand their money over to someone who will make investments on their behalf with influence limited to broad things like risk profile and the term they want returns over. Alternatively, implement a minimum holding period. It's much harder to trade on insider info if there must be a long period of time from purchase to sale. One place where I worked wouldn't let us sell until at least 3 months after we purchased any shares.
- TheCondor 5y agoAlmost seems like it could be a giant captive market for some specialized funds. Like if you’re in one of these positions you can invest with a new hedgefund without needing to be a qualified investor.
- OJFord 5y agoYou do say it wouldn't work, but just to really spell out the obvious ones: - no more options/shares for employees; - significant insider buying/holding is generally considered a positive signal, alignment of incentives, etc. would need replacing with a more complicated compensation agreement linking bonuses to average share price over the year or something. Slightly less obvious one is that you still have inside information on the index fund, not just that your company might itself be a significant constituent, but inside knowledge of the industry, what's happening to a common supplier, etc. And by 'index fund' you probably actually mean/want 'significantly diverse pool of shares', an index can be small. Nothing (other than it being silly) stops it being just TSLA or whatever either, 'My Favourite 1' can be an index of my 1 favourite shares, and you can create a fund that tracks it. Obviously that's silly and doesn't happen to that extent, but it might if you incentivised it by making 'index fund' the rule.
- ianai 5y agoat least consider a ban on stock buybacks like was the case until that regulation was rolled back in the 80s.
- ludamad 5y agoWhat why? Surely you mean stock buybacks in very specific scenarios such as after a bailout? Isn't it just the inverse operation of printing stock?
- nradov 5y agoThere's nothing really wrong with stock buybacks. They're just a tax efficient method for companies without strong growth opportunities to return value to shareholders.
- OJFord 5y agoPresumably GP is worried that (with the company's inside information about itself) there is a strong growth opportunity, as it will turn out, and that the company might decide to reissue once it's realised that growth. Not saying I really agree, they typically offer a premium (which is just like rolling a dividend into it) and it would seem highly unusual to have a company that seemed growth/non-growth according to whether you had inside information. I suppose there might be examples like AMC or GameStop (not that, inside information wouldn't have helped you there!) that seemed on the outside to be dying, they absolutely should return or value to shareholders and cease operations; but actually they had ambitious plans to revitalise etc...
- aqme28 5y agoWhat this would mean is that insiders with large holdings of stock (due to e.g. grants) would be forced to quit their jobs just so they could have some liquidity. That's a terrible incentive.
- sidlls 5y agoMost, if not all, insiders shouldn't be in a situation where they need that kind of liquidity in their company shares. I'd argue that if they are their incentives aren't aligned with their role as an insider and they should be removed anyway.
- nova22033 5y agoMatt Levine had an interesting take in his newsletter. Insiders can buy/sell but they have to announce it in public ahead of time. If you think he's selling to pay his kids tuition, you won't sell. If you think he's buying because he has insider information, you can buy too..
- Jeff_Brown 5y agoIf that were the law, someone with inside information could still give valuable suggestions to their friends, or people they want to be friends with. The result would be as unfair as if they themselves were doing the trading.
- HenryKissinger 5y agoRedditors: complain about alleged market manipulation by "hedgies". Coordinate between one another on subreddits like /r/WallStreetBets, /r/SuperStonk, and /r/GME. Encouraging thousands of others to "buy and hodl" a particular stock sounds like a coordinated scheme to me. In a democracy that values free speech and the liberty of association, combined with the Internet, it was inevitable, but then the bar for what counts as market manipulation punishable under the law is raised considerably.
- DarkWiiPlayer 5y agoSooo... market manipulation is wrong if and only if it is being discussed on a public medium like reddit, but not if an entity like a hedge-fund does it on its own? That's an interesting take.
- autosharp 5y agoYes, you found a contradiction between different Reddit users.
- ziml77 5y agoThe same people who feel like Wall Street is fighting against small investors and manipulating the market are the same ones who coordinate on /r/wallstreetbets. They are specifically coordinating against the big firms. That was the whole idea behind the GameStop thing. They were purposely trying to ensure that a hedge fund wouldn't be able to buy GameStop shares to cover their massively over-shorted position.
- DarkWiiPlayer 5y agoSo what's the point? If one is guilty, everyone is guilty; and I'm pretty sure most of the redditors were going at it from a perspective of "beat them with their own dirty tricks" precisely because playing by the rules while others don't is what people consider unfair.
- pajamaw 5y agoSure you can call them both coordinated schemes but that's setting up a pretty bad false-equivalency. Funds that own full percentage points in stocks making pure top-down orchestrated moves vs hobby investors reaching out into the void with their info that may or may not gain traction are simply not in the same league.
- cryptica 5y agoMoney printing and the Cantillion effects associated with it have created asymmetric playing fields which are fundamentally unfair. The injustice of modern markets can be explained with an analogy: Imagine that you don't have much money and you open a coffee shop; assume that it's your only stream of income... Now imagine that a few years later, a multi-millionaire opens up a coffee shop right next to yours as a passion project. The multi-millionaire has many other streams of passive income. They see your coffee shop is doing well and they feel hurt by this. So the multi-millionaire decides to start buying even higher quality coffee beans, buying more expensive coffee machines, they start dropping the prices too and advertising all over social media; now they make a loss but it doesn't matter to them, their net worth is still increasingly rapidly thanks to their other sources of income; now all the customers are going to his coffee shop instead of yours. You are forced to close your coffee shop. The multi-millionaire is pleased with himself; all his friends congratulate him. Is there anything this guy can't do? no wonder he is a multi-millionaire! Once you're out of business, he can start dropping coffee quality to even lower than before and raising prices, you're now forced to work for one of his companies as corporate livestock; as corporate livestock you add negative value to society (you're now a cog in the money laundering machine) but you're getting paid more than what you did when you were adding value to society. Many of the multi-millionaire's other businesses benefit from government contracts, grants, 0% interest loans, reserve bank bailouts, international capital flight, undetected money laundering schemes, market manipulation by political insiders, etc... The multi-millionaire's edge in the coffee business was founded entirely on them having an unfair advantage in other industries. If there are enough multi-millionaires and wealth inequality is high, all industries will be smothered out of existence by big finance who will always have the upper hand thanks to their access to easy money; all industries and society will be worse off. It's no different from feudalism.
- BrianOnHN 5y agoIsn't this exactly how YC network effects work? Is that why the parent is downvoted?
- sidlls 5y agoIt's how modern capitalism works, yes, and at least some of the downvotes are surely from freemarketeers who truly believe all the stuff described in the GP is just a perfectly fine, fair state of affairs.
- smhost 5y agomilitarize the IRS
- pajamaw 5y agoFunding the IRS would be a great start
- badwolf 5y agoLink IRS funding to defense and police funding. When those increase, IRS funding must be increased by the same %
- good8675309 5y agoYou mean militarize it against people you don't like but what about when it's turned back on you. Once an agency is weaponized and it neutralizes all foes, you can't just turn the machine off, you have to keep feeding it until it turns on you. Btw, it's already been militarized: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IRS_targeting_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IRS_targeting_controversy
- zz865 5y agoI understand that people shouldn't benefit from insider information for their personal trading - but there are rules around this. Blanket banning stock trading has a lot of downsides. Its an important part of everyone's financial wellbeing - esp if you are wealthy or powerful. I left my job in financial industry primarily because of this.
- smiley1437 5y ago> - but there are rules around this Quis custodiet ipsos custodes? From the article, judges aren't even properly recusing themselves.
- elliekelly 5y agoYou make it sound like a quality of life issue similar to having a flexible schedule when it’s really about managing the conflict of interest. Part of the problem is the rules judges and elected officials are held to barely scratch the surface of what a financial professional must do.
- kemiller2002 5y agoPublic service used to be thought of as a sacrifice for the good of all people. For many people it is. Teachers, social workers, public defenders, armed service people. All of these people make a pittance compared to what they could in the private sector. Saying a congressperson or a judge should be allowed to trade stocks simply because it affects their well being is an argument that appears rather frail. I would be surprised if there is anyone in those positions of power either elected or appointed who would be considered to be even slightly financially disadvantaged. If they want to be wealthy, let them go back to work as attorneys or whatever profession they came from.
- beached_whale 5y agoIf anything, you would want elected officials to be invested in their country as a whole, so indexed funds and stuff like that. Yes they are lower risk, but they also reflect how a larger group of companies are doing vs the ones they have first hand information about.
- wayoutthere 5y agoI hate to be a cynic, but the rules have never really applied to the guys at the top of the market. In business school you’re flat out told that “the role of government is to pick the winners”. And the associated cases were generally about compromising regulatory authorities — with the goal of showing why the side with more money almost always wins. Everyone below you on the food chain sees you as a payday and is willing to be complicit for the right price. If (price of regulatory capture) < (expected return), you’ll do it; and the ROI on government influence is pretty high. Or as the old saying goes, steal a million dollars and you go to jail, steal a billion dollars and they name a business school after you.
- Joker_vD 5y agoAnd don't forget on different ways to perform regulatory capture: sometimes it's cheaper to stage a military coup than to try to make "your" politicians win popular elections. That usually is reserved for banana republics, of course.
- 3pt14159 5y agoWhich business school did you go to?
- wayoutthere 5y agoI like my anonymity; but it was a brand name. Had more than one classmate whose parents were billionaires and many others who were children of sub-billionaire fortune 100 executives; it was the kind of place they sent their kids to learn the unspoken rules of the game.
- lexicality 5y agoI was having trouble getting through the maze of popups even with (or because of?) ublock set to aggressive so https://archive.is/wXjiI https://archive.is/wXjiI
- Semaphor 5y agoWeird, even when I disable uMatrix and Firefox ETP to leave it to just uBlock I get no popups? Maybe they advertise more heavily based on geolocation?
- ploek 5y agoHm. With (only) uBlock I get a subscription overlay that I can't get to go away, keeping me from reading the article. With uMatrix and uBlock I can read the article, but get the subscription thing at the end of it. (Hi CW! It's Fraggy :))
- Semaphor 5y agoHeh, hi :D And I just realized why I didn’t get those: Bypass Paywalls Clean [0] removed the subscription nag and all the popups. [0]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/bypass-paywalls-clean/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/firefox/addon/bypass-paywal...
- _wldu 5y agoI've been down-voted for years for saying this, but I am right. The stock market is a scam. Just like casinos in Las Vegas. The house wins more often than we do. 'You need to diversify' simply means 'Give us more of your money'. Don't fall for it. It's just rich people and politicians taking money from less rich people. If you want to double your money, fold it over and put it in your pocket (and buy real things that appreciate over time).
- everdrive 5y ago>Don't fall for it. It's just rich people and politicians taking money from less rich people. How do rich people make money in the stock market if it's a "scam?" And how do politicians use the stock market to take money from anyone? (usually they use taxes to do this) What about index funds, which usually have proven returns and require no special knowledge?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- boppo1 5y ago> And how do politicians use the stock market to take money from anyone? Well not politicians quite, but IMHO western bond buying is driving up asset values and fundamentally increasing economic stratification. PCE is a trash measure. It's like our monetary policy says "make sure workers keep working, make sure their feedstuffs stay cheap, and don't worry whether they have a meaningful opportunity to acquire ownership of the economy."
- j-pb 5y ago> How do rich people make money in the stock market if it's a "scam?" Definitions: scam (verb): to obtain (something, such as money) by a scam scam (noun): a fraudulent or deceptive act or operation together: to obtain (something, such as money) by a fraudulent or deceptive act or operation Rich/powerful people obtain money and influence by fraudulent or deceptive operations, via the stock markets, from less powerful people, by convincing them that they should participate in said market, either as small investors or indirectly by having their banks, insurance, and pension invest into the stock market. The rules, and conditions on the stock market are in such a way that they reward power and wealth with further power and wealth. E.g. being able to invest into better locations, infrastructure and connections for HFT, being able to hire better analysts and more mathematicians, invest into satellite data and machine learning to track cars in parking lots to estimate the results of earnings calls, pay lawyers and lobbyists to change influence politics and change laws.
- eric_b 5y agoWell well, another anti-capitalist op-ed from Bloomberg. The least surprising thing I've read today. "Recent events suggest their [Redditors] suspicion that the decks are stacked against them is justified – which is a terrible look for capitalism." Insiders profiting from private knowledge is hardly unique to capitalism. I think the author should check out China over the last 20 years to see truly stunning examples of insider profiteering. Feels more like the author wants to fill out their 2021 finance article bingo card than make a real connection here. "[Insiders] also increased their buying and selling in the gaps between audit reports being produced for company boards and being made publicly available, and exploited rules governing scheduled trading schedules for profit." I mean - insiders are required to schedule their trading activities ahead of time. There are whole groups of people who's trading strategies revolve around reading those disclosures and make the same trades. And of course a little bit of the 2021 media's favorite tactic: "guilty until proven innocent" "And while they said the trades were within the central bank’s rules, both are being scrutinized further. “We’re looking carefully at the trading that was done to make sure that it’s in compliance with our rules and with the law,” Fed Chairman Jerome Powell told the Senate Banking Committee." So wait, no concrete evidence their trades were against the rules, but Bloomberg will publish this hit piece anyways. "And the growing prevalence of the fastest-growing companies staying off public markets and funding their expansion instead with private capital keeps them out of the portfolios of retail buyers, further stoking suspicion that the covenant between capitalism and society is asymmetrical and biased against individual investors." What....? Loads of IPOs this year. And for those that are still private, or eschewing the public markets for whatever reason: no private company has an obligation to give Joe Retail Investor the ability to buy and sell shares of the entity. Bloomberg has really become a joke.
- DisjointedHunt 5y agoIf you haven't worked in Finance, here are a few items you might want to consider before commenting one way or the other on stories from the world of finance: -There are regulations on paper only and VERY rarely is monitoring conducted because of the firms asserting "confidentiality" to not share data -Regulators are fully aware of illegal practices such as literally creating fake shares from thin air which has been illegal for over a decade and yet, THERE IS NO WAY to know if this is happening or has happened in the past year. The data is not public[1] -Even when such blatant illegal behavior amounting to billions of dollars , the penalties are mostly fines and no one goes to jail -Court filings indicate suspicious sales of specific securities by insiders at Citadel before they restricted retail sales. Contrast this with you, as an employee of a FAANG tech firm, trade stock on inside information and you're looking at prison time. [1] https://www.reddit.com/r/GME/comments/m9bfp0/naked_short_selling_the_truth_is_much_worse_than/ https://www.reddit.com/r/GME/comments/m9bfp0/naked_short_sel...
- Atlas667 5y agoJolly, what a surprise... This article is just paying lip service to everyone who already feels this is the case (most sane people) and redditors. Just for gathering some traffic. The real truth is in understanding that this is fundamentally unstoppable within our economic mode of production. No ammount of regulation or de-regulation will prevent a system based on individual profit accumulation from becoming corrupt. You can stop individuals, but the economic incentive will still be there, waiting. Profit means leverage and economic freedom means using that leverage. It's a feature not a bug. Its all corruption and exploitation masquerading as economic freedom and individual freedom, always has been. Liberalism and Convervativism are just the cultural views that carry the ideological justifications for their exploitation (be them progressive, regressive, static or mixed). Really, if we were in their position we'd be doing the same. Which leads into why it is important to fundamentally transform our society.
- Clubber 5y agoThrow people in jail for insider trading. Prosecute it as hard as we prosecute people stealing $2 bags of chips from the grocery store or passing counterfeit $20s. Also, why are government employees accused of malfeasance allowed to quit and not get prosecuted? Why is that even a thing?
- mrpf1ster 5y agoWhere is the un-corruptible agency that is going to enforce these laws? Someone stealing a bag of chips has no recourse to get out of prosecution. A wealthy insider trader has the resources and influence to reduce or even eliminate any consequences.
- Clubber 5y agoIt's supposed to be us, by voting out politicians who are dirty. Unfortunately, most of us have been duped into being on some "team," and are willing to ignore the corruption of one team to feel good about pointing out the corruption of the other. Since there are only 2 teams, this works beautifully for the politicians. It's an endless cycle that needs to be broken, shipped jobs overseas, shrank our already pathetic safety net, gutted middle America, pushed 2 wars and emptied our treasury. Vote out the incumbent every election cycle for 10+ years, and maybe it will fix it.
- bern4444 5y agoOne of the biggest misconceptions is that the stock market is a zero sum game. Its absolutely not. One person can make money without another person losing money. Is that always the case? No. But that doesn't make it a zero sum game. If I buy a few shares from someone, I could be buying them from someone who is up on that investment and wants to cash in on their profit. If that stock continues to do well, everyone wins. I make money, the person I bought the shares from makes money. Who cares how much the other person made, I'm focused on myself. If someone does a good job, and opens their expertise to the public - like Cathie Woods and her ETFs - even more people can benefit. No one is hurt by her success. Of course people lose money, but that's not always and only because someone else is then making money from your loss. Everyone knows nearly every hedgefund does worse in the long run. Maybe they have 2-7 incredible years. Years 8 - 12 though aren't likely to go so well and they'll end up closing up shop. Only the top 20-50 hedgefunds likely consistently outperform a market index fund. The other few hundred are running on luck or just doing poorly anyway. Despite the issues of insider trading in this article, individuals are still able to do remarkably well by buying VTSAX (or whatever index/mutual/etf fund you like best) consistently over a long period of time.
- theknocker 5y agoAlmost everything in this post is either irrelevant or wrong. Do you actually know anything about the stock market or are you just repeating things you saw on Reddit?
- fairity 5y ago> One of the biggest misconceptions is that the stock market is a zero sum game. Its absolutely not. No, it's by definition a zero sum game. Fundamentally, owning shares in a company grants you rights to a fraction of all future company earnings. For any given stock transaction: - there's an agreed upon price, $X - there's a true value, $Y, which equates to the net present value of all future company earnings that the transacted shares give you access to - if $X > $Y, the buyer is the loser in the transaction and the seller is the winner - if $Y > $x, the buyer is the winner; the seller the loser You may not know what $Y is in any given transaction, but the value certainly exists. And, therefore, a winner and loser exists in every transaction (even if you don't know who it is). Furthermore, the "amount" won in a transaction is always equal to the "amount" lost by the counter party. This value exchange is abs($Y-$x). If all individual transactions are zero sum, it should be obvious that the sum of all individual transactions are zero sum. As you call out in your examples, it's possible for individual (and groups of) participants to come out ahead. But, this is certainly at the expense of other participants in the transaction chain.
- ramesh31 5y ago>A rallying cry of the day traders that hang out in Reddit Inc.’s stock market forums is that only by joining forces can they prosper in an environment inherently hostile to small investors. Anyone who thinks they're "joining forces" to trade stocks is just the mark for a pump and dump. There is no honor among thieves.
- Geee 5y agoWhy are they blaming capitalism? It's just dishonesty and corruption, which happens under any system if it's not kept in check. It's actually more likely to happen under socialist or authoritarian regimes, when power is more centralized.
- sophacles 5y agoI see a lot of evidence in the article that the current system (capitalism) doesn't work as well as you pie in the sky idealists like to say. You can attribute it to dishonesty and corruption - I'm not disagreeing, but a system in which those thrive is a bad system. Any system that relies on key players to act right and doesn't have counters to collusion between those players is doomed to be gamed like this. (See for example all the problems with the internet that have come from assuming everyone will act right, and the problems that come from groups deciding to not act right together). What I don't see presented is any evidence for your claims, just a random set of "these guys are even worse so my not quite so please stop criticizing the problems with my bad choice"... it's not a counter, it's deflection.
- Geee 5y agoIt's not a problem with capitalism, it's a problem in the system that should protect capitalism. Free-market capitalism doesn't work if someone is cheating, and that's why we have these systems and regulations that try to prevent cheating. There is a systemic risk where the protectors and cheaters are the same people, which (again) is not the problem of capitalism, but a problem of the system that protects it. More regulators and more central power is likely to increase the risk that the regulators become cheaters.
- andrekandre 5y ago> More regulators and more central power is likely to increase the risk that the regulators become cheaters. so whats the solution?