14 ms·
The way I see it, this makes sense in a hypothetical world of perfect theoretical models (you may recognize this world as being the one inhabited by frictionles
by TeMPOraL 5y ago
The way I see it, this makes sense in a hypothetical world of perfect theoretical models (you may recognize this world as being the one inhabited by frictionless, perfectly spherical cows). In this world, scalpers cause the market to price in "stickiness" - the more critical an item is to the buyer, the more they'll be willing to pay - so the supply ultimately gets allocated to the most desperate of buyers, for the price of "your entire margin", or possibly "literally all you have", if the buyer's survival depends on it.
Maybe this makes sense in that theoretical world - where there's no inertia, no friction, no capital investment, no jobs and livelihoods tied to the outcome. But in reality, scalping seems to be the purest form of parasitism. In a crisis, scalpers' activities may kill perfectly fine companies (or people) who would've otherwise limped through the rough times and survived, upsetting an industry long-term, and it forces everyone to waste their money.
And even if you think that this kind of market culling is fine, I'm not seeing why all that money should go to the first asshole who managed to secure a large loan in time to buy off the entire stock of some good.
- dahart 5y agoThis actually is the idea with truly “free market” thinking, no? The money wasted in a crisis, and the companies killed who would’ve otherwise limped through, is all assumed to be less waste and a better outcome than the alternative we get if we prevent scalpers and/or cap the prices. In this theoretical world, we waste more money when supply runs out too fast, and we get companies that are not as good at competing because they limped through. The big question economically is whether these assumptions are generally correct. We have evidence in both directions, enough that most people can comfortably stick to their opinions and learned assumptions and political tribes. But is there a way to demonstrate that the money wasted is greater with hoarding/scalping than without, and under what conditions?
- awakeasleep 5y agoActually the original ‘free’ in free markets meant free from economic rents
- ben_w 5y agoAh, that makes a lot more sense than the generalised freedom I’d assumed. I really should read Wealth of Nations…
- dahart 5y agoSure, but that’s not what it means anymore, right? Today’s “free” means no regulation.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- awakeasleep 5y agoYeah now it means “free to capture economic rent” almost the exact opposite.
- yholio 5y agoScalpers perform a social service by rationing demand and ensuring availability. They don't eat the whole consumer surplus, rather, they must compete amongst themselves and the price you pay is the amount that makes client N+1 walk away if total supply is N. Some of the buyers will find that close to their margin, but others, for which the product is essential in very valuable (thus socially useful) goods or services, will thank God they have found the supply. Think about hospitals paying 10 times more for antiseptic and performing surgeries, instead of someone drenching their driveway with that 10$ antiseptic while someone else dies without a needed surgery. By raising the price and pocketing $90, the scalper has prevented resource waste and supplied to the patient and hospital a service worth hundreds of thousands. If a scalper becomes a monopoly, they can extract a monopoly rent and really bleed everyone dry - but so can a producer in the same situation, so the problem is low competition not intermediaries.
- nicoburns 5y agoGovernments can do this without the inefficiency of the scalpers profits in cases where the need is great.
- yholio 5y agoAlso known as a command economy, a staple stalinist recipe.
- runesoerensen 5y ago> Also known as a command economy, a staple stalinist recipe No. That’s an extreme, just like your idea of what you call a “social service” performed by scalpers. There’s a middle ground, and it’s certainly possible to regulate a market to mitigate the most pathological consequences of capitalism without Stalinism. In fact, that happens all the time.
- rjzzleep 5y agoSuch an idiotic statement. When every other country was suffering under scalpers buying up mask supplies at the beginning of the pandemic Taiwan, South Korea and some other countries actively took a hand in mask distribution. The result: - cheaper access to masks for the general population - no mask shortages in critical infrastructure such as hospitals or other health care institutions - general better handling and health outcomes during the pandemic Leave it to the Americans that would consider sound policy and good health outcomes stalinist or communist recipes.
- drdeca 5y agoIt seems to me like most of the (alleged) benefits of scalpers would be equally well achieved by selling (some fraction of) the items in auctions, instead of just picking a price. However, my impression is that consumers would view this in a negative light, and that the harms to the seller’s reputation would be enough to outweigh the initially increased income. This seems to be the source of the inefficiencies that scalpers exploit/address. This leads me to an idea which, I don’t believe is typically done, but which I don’t know why not: Why wouldn’t a company just, list a price that they are “going to sell it at”, and then “sell” a large proportion of them at that price to an entity which isn’t publicly connected to the company, and then that organization sells the items via auction (and returns a large proportion of the profits back to the company). While on the one hand, I don’t see how I’d be able to tell if this was what was done, and therefore don’t see how to confirm that this isn’t what is being done in the cases where there are scalpers, I don’t think this is being done, and don’t know why.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- birdyrooster 5y agoI and many other gamers have a negative view of Nvidia because of their inability to thwart scalpers and crypto miners. To quote a wise man, "so Nvidia, fuck you!"
- drdeca 5y agoOk, but like, would their overall reputation be higher if they were to directly put some proportion of their inventory up for auction (like, each item individually, not like one auction for a bundle of a very large number of GPUs) instead?
- jhanschoo 5y agoNo, the prices will still be comparable to scalper prices, and the cost-conscious consumer market will remember the company's price gouging when they make their next-generation purchase
- raducu 5y ago> And even if you think that this kind of market culling is fine, I'm not seeing why all that money should go to the first asshole who managed to secure a large loan in time to buy off the entire stock of some good. Very well said, but I'd go even further -- scalpers know other scalpers will do the same and create artificial shortage so they are actually preying on legitimate customers, so there's an adversarial component to the behavior of scalpers as well. We rationed toilet paper during the lockdowns and there was a legitimate reason people were hoarding it, but we do nothing about scalpers who have no legitimate reason for their behavior.
- WanderPanda 5y agoIf it is about “being the first” then obviously the pricing by the manufacturer is inefficient. In the end the scalpers you describe just fill in the void that is opened up by the manufacturers not adjusting their prices to the demand.
- gnopgnip 5y agoIn reality the market isn't a zero sum game. And there isn't a fixed supply of resources. In a crisis scalpers ensure that the customers receive critical goods that may otherwise be unavailable at any price. Not having that option could kill a company just as well. All of the profit money doesn't go to the scalper either, the original manufacturer can sell for higher prices, reallocate resources to make what is most profitable and meet the demands of the market. And there are price gouging laws to limit this activity for essential goods in an emergency.
- Consultant32452 5y ago"No offense, but it sounds like some commie gobbledygook to me." ~Norm Macdonald