5 ms·
scientists saw observable levels of the toxic metal in about half As a former analytical chemist, we can detect most metals down to the parts per trillion or l
by refurb 5y ago
scientists saw observable levels of the toxic metal in about half
As a former analytical chemist, we can detect most metals down to the parts per trillion or lower.
So the more sensitive our instruments get the “more kids have lead”.
With sufficiently sensitive testing you’d probably find lead in 100% of people.
- wyldfire 5y ago> most of the affected kids ... didn’t have enormous amounts of lead in their bloodstreams, and only two percent had a "high" level. But as the researchers note in their paper, there's no such thing as a safe amount of lead to have in your system. It's possible that more sensitive instruments will allow us to eventually conclude "this small amount X of lead is safe to have ...". But it makes sense to take this seriously. We know lead is bad and we know lots of environmental exposure to lead exists.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoIt's noise. Worry about teaching kids to look both ways etc before obsessing about this one, is my advice.
- zeven7 5y agoI taught my kids to look both ways. Now what do I do?
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoetc
- Symmetry 5y agoSo, I'd agree that there are lead levels too low to be worth worrying about. But I recall a clever study a while back where a researcher noticed that children found to be in the top decile of lead exposure got lead abatement for their homes or apartments by the city. The researchers compared them to the previous second decile (now first decile) and found a pretty significant effect size on life outcomes. This was done on poor people in city centers so the lead levels were high compared to, say, suburbanites but there are lead levels many kids in the US are exposed to that are actually a big deal.
- EL_Loco 5y agoI might be mistaken here, but from what I've read on lead, we already know relatively well what amount of lead is safe, according to body weight etc. We also know that our bodies can deal with these small amounts, by actually getting rid of some of it. Maybe someone with more knowledge on the matter can chime in?
- peteradio 5y agoTotal lead tells you your symptoms today. But it accrues so you'd need to know in advance your future lead intake to know if this small amount today will be a big impact tomorrow. Basically its unknowable so its practical to say that no amount is safe. There probably does exist a low enough level that the body can even clear it but there isn't any will to define it.
- lumost 5y agoMy understanding is that all detectable amounts currently have known negative effects when studied. The Action levels are set based on what is possible to address in an individual child. Lead exists in the environment. It would be impractical to impossible to eliminate it entirely from the blood streams of most people. However certain areas have extremely dangerous concentrations such as dirt near major roads/old buildings, water in certain areas, and lead paints. Lead pipes are an interesting one where it is simply impractical to replace all the pipes and remove lead in old cities. Hence as long as the calcification holds there is no action on the small amount of lead which leaks into the pipes.
- shadowgovt 5y agoIn the US at least, were it structured as an infrastructure project on a city by city basis, it would actually be extremely possible to strip out lead pipes and replace them with something modern. The problem is that pipe ownership in a domestic home is the property of the homeowner, and there's no political will to do that kind of massive wealth transfer from the public coffers to the improved infrastructure of millions of individual properties. But while it wouldn't be inexpensive, it's on par with other expenditures the federal government makes for federal projects.
- alisonkisk 5y ago> "this small amount X of lead is safe to have ...". wouldn't make the popular news media, but "lead in our blood!" does
- chmod600 5y agoThe point is that "detectable" says more about the instrument than anything else. If there's no science that says "one atom of lead anywhere in your body is bad", then saying "detectable" is meaningless. I mean, if you said "we found a detectable number of bullets in half of children", now that would be bad.
- kenjackson 5y agoI think the real point is that detectable levels with modern instruments that are used for such measurements (≥1.0 μg/dL)* is considered bad. *Another poster noted this level.
- marcosdumay 5y ago> If there's no science that says "one atom of lead anywhere in your body is bad", then saying "detectable" is meaningless. It would be meaningless on that case too. Also meaningless is saying that 2% of the kids have a high level of lead, without saying what "high" means.
- dllthomas 5y ago> Also meaningless is saying that 2% of the kids have a high level of lead, without saying what "high" means. Oh, that's simple - it's defined as above the 98th percentile. (I kid, I hope...)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jmalicki 5y agoActually, the CDC defines the 5ug/DL as high based on being the 97.5%ile [1] in children... so you're not kidding... But if only 2% of children have lead levels that were originally defined based on the worst 2.5%, that's a 20% reduction, so great news!? [1] https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/lead/prevention/blood-lead-levels.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nceh/lead/prevention/blood-lead-levels.h...
- tokai 5y agoLook at the actual paper for the actual numbers. Also lead is a problem in any concentration.
- LucaMasters 5y agoTo summarize: They defined these blood lead levels: * "detectable": ≥1.0 μg/dL * "elevated": ≥5.0 μg/dL They found that: * 50.5% had "detectable" levels (50.4%-50.6% for the 95% CI). * 1.9% had "elevated" levels (1.8%-1.9% for the 95% CI [wait, how is the reported amount the same as the upper limit of the CI?]). The paper does start out saying: > No safe level of exposure to lead has been identified. Which I believe to be true, though it's not the same as "no level of exposure to lead is safe". I would be interested in what levels are known to be unsafe. Is 1.0 μg/dL known to be unsafe, or just not known to be safe? It's pretty clear we should be working to reduce lead exposure, especially in children, but it's also true that "detectable amounts" and "harmful" aren't the same thing. The former clearly varies with our technology and the other remains constant (and isn't, afaik, known to be 0).
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Igelau 5y ago> any concentration I'm curious. If there's lead in the water, the air, the soil, the food we eat, is zero even possible? Is there a baseline "side effect of living on Earth" level, even if it's very slight?
- sparker72678 5y agoThis. The death rate of being human is 100%. Every five minutes there's some new paper or study letting us all know why we should be afraid of something new. I'm not saying this particular study is necessarily scare-mongering, but good grief is it tiring to see this stuff all day every day, without any scale of risk for context.
- silicon2401 5y agoIs your implication that we can find every single element in the periodic table (if not compounds and other chemicals, too) in the human body with sufficiently sensitive testing?
- contravariant 5y agoThat's basically equivalent to just saying the human body contains atoms for all isotopes. And other than the unstable or exceedingly rare isotopes I don't see why not.
- Jabbles 5y agoThe number of possible chemicals is vast, due to the exponentially large number of ways you can combine the elements. So although every stable element is present in the average human, every possible chemical (or compound) is not. Recent discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27634549 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27634549
- seoaeu 5y agoThe human body contains something like 10^27 atoms. It doesn't seem that unreasonable that all elements which are at least moderately common on Earth would be present...
- IdoRA 5y agoMore or less. I used to run samples of water from student’s canteens on a Thermo Scientific Element 2 (an exquisitely sensitive mass spectrometer) in their presence, knowing I would find uranium and lead in it. Not a lot, but it’s there. The point to the students was the dose makes the poison, more or less.
- spekcular 5y ago"Detectable" is defined as ≥1.0 μg/dL in the study. This is hardly a negligible amount, given what we know about the health effects of lead.
- yhoneycomb 5y agoNot seeing how being a chemist makes you a medical expert but ok