9 ms·
Apple Disables FaceID if you change the screen yourself [video]
- ISL 5y ago(video)
- alphabettsy 5y agoIs this an undescribed security feature or something else?
- steve_adams_86 5y agoIt’s inherent to the security model due to cryptographic signing coupling the components. If you were able to swap out security components, you might be able to spoof messages - it would no longer be secure. A stolen phone could be connected to a fake sensor and used to trick the phone into authenticating.
- nerfhammer 5y agoit also must mean the sensor is indelibly attached to the screen now
- alpaca128 5y agoHow would it hurt that security model if the phone could sign new components only with the permission of the logged in user? > If you were able to swap out security components, you might be able to spoof messages But Apple repair shops can do exactly that (unless they always replace the device whenever the screen is broken, but I doubt that). What's the purpose in this whole cryptographic integrity if a third party - certified or not - can violate it without leaving a trace? If I was a person who has to worry this much about their security I'd much prefer swapping the screen myself without involvement of people that can't even be honest about "water damage" most of the time.
- berdon 5y ago> unless they always replace the device whenever the screen is broken, but I doubt that Why do you doubt that? I'm sure that's exactly what they do. Edit: Well, by "device" here I read "screen + sensor". If you meant the entire phone then I agree with you heh.
- hi5eyes 5y agoApple did this with touchid too?
- nemosaltat 5y agoYes, they did. You had to save the touch sensor during the replacement due to hardware signing.
- egberts1 5y agoGreat, had my macBook Pro keyboard replaced, and now it’s TouchID sensor is gone.
- svnpenn 5y agoI mean, good? People shouldn't be using that anyway, as police could force you to unlock your phone against your will.
- gnicholas 5y agoYou can force the device to ask for a password by pressing the home button several times or by turning it off.
- geofft 5y agoIt's actually slightly easier these days (at least on my phone): hold down the power button as if to turn it off, but don't swipe to actually turn it off, just hit cancel (or home, or power to turn the screen off). The phone will be locked and prompt for your passcode and won't let you use biometrics.
- gnicholas 5y agoFor me (iPhone 11 Pro, iOS 15), holding down the power button activates Siri. The ways I can force lock the phone are either pressing Vol+, Vol-, and power, or pressing power 5 times. But if you have the emergency SOS turned on, the latter will activate a siren and call 911 a few seconds later.
- egberts1 5y agoold iPhone 5s here, vol+ plus Vol- plus Power buttons do nothing.
- ryanlol 5y agoThis is a pretty bad idea if you are worried about your phone being seized, just turn it off.
- josephcsible 5y agoPeople who don't want Face ID don't have to turn it on. People who do want it shouldn't have it held ransom by Apple just because they need a screen replacement.
- RL_Quine 5y agoIt shouldn't be particularly surprising that the two parts are cryptographically paired, the sensors for the IR camera and the HSM within the main processor are extensions of the same security boundary effectively. If you could replace the sensor without something being unhappy, the system would be completely broken.
- PostThisTooFast 5y agoNo, it wouldn't. The sensor is an imager. The back end, which interprets what it delivers, should be separate. This is more petty Apple bullshit.
- user-the-name 5y agoHow can you trust that the sensor is actually delivering what it sees?
- neilalexander 5y agoI suspect this is actually something to do with the fact that the Face ID sensors are projecting unique patterns across different devices. From the Apple Platform Security document: > After the TrueDepth camera confirms the presence of an attentive face, it projects and reads thousands of infrared dots to form a depth map of the face along with a 2D infrared image. This data is used to create a sequence of 2D images and depth maps which are digitally signed and sent to the Secure Enclave. To counter both digital and physical spoofs, the TrueDepth camera randomises the sequence of 2D images and depth map captures and projects a device-specific random pattern. A portion of the Secure Neural Engine — protected within the Secure Enclave — transforms this data into a mathematical representation and compares that representation with the enrolled facial data. This enrolled facial data is itself a mathematical representation of the user’s face captured across a variety of poses. https://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/security/sec067eb0c9e/1/web/1 https://support.apple.com/en-gb/guide/security/sec067eb0c9e/...
- simonh 5y agoThe back end has to be able to trust the data from the sensor, and the only way to do that is engineer them as part of the same cryptographic trust domain. Otherwise you could just swap the sensor for a dummy device that presents whatever data you like to the back end. That would completely break the security model. I know a lot of the other phone manufacturers do stuff like this and think it's ok, but Apple knows what it's doing.
- ryanlol 5y agoThis is incorrect. FaceID is not disabled if you perform the screen replacement correctly, you just need to transplant the faceid bits between the screen modules.
- lelandfe 5y agoNot to be that guy, but source?
- ryanlol 5y agoWait, isn’t this the nutjob who came up with the weird conspiracy theory about macbook webcams spying on him? E: Oh yeah, it’s the same guy. He has an interesting track record https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20507037 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20507037
- leshenka 5y agoWow that's rich, you're trying to pass him off as some kind of fringe conspiracy theorist. All those points got debunked in the comments. As for that thing with the batteries -- you can't blame people for buying illegally imported and/or counterfeit [citation needed] parts when there is no legal way to obtain them outside of AARP. Oh yeah also, stuff like this is the reason why Apple is a two trillion dollar company.
- jtflynnz 5y agoAlso to points I've seen made elsewhere; Apple has begun placing trademark material (ie logos) on individual parts (including ribbon cables, etc) to make use of trademark enforcement for otherwise legitimate third-party refurbished parts. He notes this in his videos discussing why he cannot source screens for phones anymore. Where previously they could have third parties remove cracked glass from broken screens and re-laminate them to make legitimate refurb parts. However, these were deemed unauthorized refurbs (but not illegal/unlawful to make) so instead they used the logos on cables as justification to have customs seize them as "counterfeits" on behalf of trademark enforcement.
- ryanlol 5y agoThis is nonsense, refurbished screens are not counterfeits. The problem is screens that were manufactured with apple logos without apple authorization.
- ryanlol 5y ago> you're trying to pass him off as some kind of fringe conspiracy theorist He is. Just watch the webcam video. >you can't blame people for buying illegally imported It’s only illegal to import counterfeit parts. >there is no legal way to obtain them outside of AARP It is perfectly legal to buy generic replacement parts without apple logos, but the chinese factories don’t find it worth their time to produce such as “authentic” parts earn them more money. And yeah, he ended up admitting it and bragging about buying counterfeit parts. > Oh yeah also, stuff like this is the reason why Apple is a two trillion dollar company. These things have nothing to do with each other, but I rather doubt that you even read Apples financial statements.
- paxys 5y agoEveryone commenting with "security" is missing the point (and hasn't watched the first minute of the video). In previous versions of the iPhone the screen was not part of the FaceID system and could be independently replaced. The sensor/cable/motherboard were all still cryptographically paired and secure. This is a brand new limitation in iPhone 13.
- SpicyLemonZest 5y agoI'm sympathetic to the guy, but I still don't really see this as a big deal. There's not a ton of space in a modern smartphone, so it seems entirely plausible that some legitimate design change or manufacturing difficulty caused the signed components to get moved to the screen. (He says it's not purely a new limitation, which would be more questionable - the cable which was previously cryptographically paired now is not.)
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoMaybe but why can't the end user simply be tasked with accepting the new screen signature? That's how GPG, Secure boot, etc. all work. You just have a persistent list of trusted signatures.
- robbedpeter 5y agoBecause not allowing customers the opportunity for competence or independence increases the amount of money Apple can extract. The walls in the garden only ever get higher.
- user-the-name 5y agoBecause now you can defeat the security on a stolen phone by replacing the screen and clicking "yes".
- alpaca128 5y agoEvery biometric system on phones also forces the user to set a password/pin as fallback. So no, you cannot just gain entry into a stolen phone like that. Any phone that lets you just circumvent security by removing a part wasn't secure in the first place.
- bilekas 5y agoI wouldn't expect this from a phone I can pay up to $2000 for.
- tinus_hn 5y agoYou can just pay Apple to swap in an original screen. It’s not cheap but it isn’t $2000 either.
- AlfeG 5y agoIn Ukraine for iPhone 13 max 1tb you will need to pay $3000
- wayoutthere 5y agoIt’s actually less insane than it used to be; Apple’s first party repair for screens isn’t significantly more expensive than unauthorized repair shops. There used to be a much bigger price difference but the newer iPhones have so many sensors on the screen that the part itself is most of the cost. Apple’s site is showing ~$250 for a screen replacement (a little more or less depending on the model).
- danlugo92 5y ago> Apple’s site is showing ~$250 for a screen replacement (a little more or less depending on the model). Can you link to this please? I cannot find it.
- tinus_hn 5y agohttps://support.apple.com/iphone/repair/service/screen-replacement https://support.apple.com/iphone/repair/service/screen-repla...
- intricatedetail 5y agoThe security has become a weasel word to justify anti-customer practices. It should be called out! The only reason is profit and most certainly it will create more e waste.