10 ms·
Serbia surveillance law urgently withdrawn
- antocv 5y agoTotal surveillance in Serbia bad, in USA good.
- hirako2000 5y agoIt's bad when others spy on others, especially on you. It's good when I spy on others, especially on everyone else.
- jillesvangurp 5y agoIt actually points to the solution. Surveillance is only convenient when it works one way. As soon as you add counter surveillance to the mix it becomes more tricky. Now you can watch but others will be watching you watch others. Add some laws to the mix and now you actually have to stick to them because others will watch you break the law otherwise. Fine if you control everybody else (i.e. you are a dictator) but less so if those others are your political opponents, other countries, or anyone who might not be under your influence that can call you out on what you are doing; especially if there are consequences to you breaking the law.
- hirako2000 5y agoI prefer no surveillance.but since anyone appears to go their way, I vote for legalising surveillance across the board. Just don't force anyone into doing anything and we will be just fine. Secrets can be well kept if they matter so much. I see your logic though.
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoTwo wrongs don't make a right, do they?
- illuminated 5y agoThe law was withdrawn after everyone noticed its contents: https://www.b92.net/eng/news/politics.php?yyyy=2021&mm=09&dd=23&nav_id=111801 https://www.b92.net/eng/news/politics.php?yyyy=2021&mm=09&dd... Edit: probably a better article to explain the withdrawal: https://www.b92.net/eng/news/politics.php?yyyy=2021&mm=09&dd=23&nav_id=111798 https://www.b92.net/eng/news/politics.php?yyyy=2021&mm=09&dd...
- earthbee 5y agoI know very little about Serbian politics, is this genuinely gone for good or will they just try to reintroduce it later or by other means?
- noptd 5y agoMore likely than not, the bill will sit in a drawer waiting for the perfect reason, or distraction, necessary to be pushed through.
- illuminated 5y agoI don't believe it will ever be forgotten. The PM in the article says he withdraws it as he's facing elections in 6 months, not for any other reason. He's got a strong support among the elderly and/or "conservatives" so it is expected for him to win those elections. Once he does win, I'm sure he'll try to reintroduce the same thing. The capital of Serbia is being covered in surveillance cameras for some time now, a "gift" from Chinese friends, and I don't think they'd let the technology sit unused, especially that the overall unrest of his opposition is rising.
- sm4rk0 5y agoSmall correction: the guy was the PM until 2017. now he's the president (but basically the Big Boss since 2012.)
- illuminated 5y agoYou're right. I stopped tracking his formal roles (or caring in any capacity about them) since the time when the most prestigious position in the state was "the first vice-president of the government" (his, at the time) and the running joke was that everyone, including the PM and the president, were eyeing that position if they wanted to advance their career further.
- mdp2021 5y agoI would like to invite the public not to focus solely on the matter of cameras - especially those who should have realized their territory is full of them and there is a fait accompli to be managed -, and to also notice the proposals that tend to compromise responsibility of powers hence increase the odds of corruption: nameless law enforcement officers (Serbia, this case), criminalization of complaint against them (e.g. Spain after Mariano Rajoy), criminalization of recording them (a number of European Countries - while in the USA I understand it is called basic precaution)...
- NiceWayToDoIT 5y agoIt would be interesting to know how lows that back inside corruption pass into being, and how does dynamic of citizens allow that to happen.
- jq-r 5y agoEasily. Speaking for Croatia's situation but I'm sure it is similar to Serbia. Say you have general elections. You have some regional politicians you can vote for etc, and maybe some of those people get into parliament. Some get in government, some don't. But once they get in parliament, they are responsible to their own party. Not you and me, just themselves. So they can do absolutely whatever they want, with no responsibility. You have absolutely no chance nor mechanism to recall or replace those politicians. Only their party can do it. So you've guessed it, we have "democracy" every 4 years. And each day between those elections we have oligarchy. Back to our politicians. If they are in government, even better, they will introduce laws that will pretty much always pass (as the government has a majority, simple or 3/4 doesn't usually matter), nobody scrutinizes those laws and they will introduce stuff in them authoritarians have wet dreams about. Note here, I didn't say that the laws are written by complete morons, they are not. They are written specifically to introduce corruption, legalize what was criminal act before, or establish monopolies on trading goods or similar. Eg. We have an army of inspectors. And a lot of stuff is left to "inspector's discretion". Or we have a lot of prohibitive clauses like: "you cannot build a house in an area less than 30m from the shore line. But you can do whatever you like if you get a special permit from the ministry (and that means the Minister himself). So yeah, you have mansions with private beaches all over. It just boils down to who you know and how much you can pay. If you're playing by the rules you're completely hosed and you're a fool, and I mean that. Too bad it took me 25 years to realize that. So also you wonder why citizens don't do something to fight that? There are multiple reasons. First, the government is the biggest employer by far. I don't know the fresh statistic but we have nr of government workers which is at least 4x larger than Germany's. And we have 4 million people. So there is a good chance that I'm working for the government or someone close to me is working (or even both). Say something bad, and you'll get fired, good luck getting another job. Second, courts and judiciary branch is also corrupted and completely not responsible to citizens (at all!) so they do whatever they want or pass judgement whatever they want (especially in the case of high profile politicians). So no politician ever gets prison time. Ok, one got prison time out of hundreds of cases. Third, people are not that hungry yet. There were some protests, but frankly, people here don't know how to protest. Even if people protest it is usually looked down upon them or they protest only for their benefit (say medical workers), not for a general problem. Fourth, police is corrupted. They have no problem beating down insignificant people, and completely ignore ruling class. All in all, it is a ugly spiral of bad things and I'm afraid it won't be solved until some war. War resets some laws, deals new cards, removes some bad guys as well (usually paid many times over by everyone else)...
- gjs278 5y agothat would just be making it official, they probably already do it
- amarant 5y agoI find it troubling that a dictatorship like this is expected to be allowed into the European Union by 2025. There ought to be stricter requirements for human rights infractions to join...
- knuthsat 5y agoSerbia is far from a dictatorship. Otherwise these propositions wouldn't be met with internal outrage that influences the progression of the law.
- kodisha 5y agoThere are different kinds of dictatorships. Serbia is externally sponsored one. Angela Merkel visited just recently, and EU, on paper gives support. In exchange Vucic is doing whatever is needed, and they look the other way while he does his moves. OCCASIONALLY he oversteps his limitations, and his sponsors give him slap on the wrist.
- DeWilde 5y agoIt is not a dictatorship, at worst it is authoritarian, and at best a it is broken democracy. Some parts of the government are better, some are worse.
- salex89 5y agoIt's degrading on a daily basis, literally.
- pjmlp 5y agoThe biggest problem with dictatorships, it that most people only notice it is actually one when it is too late. Even back home in Portugal, I fear that when my generation is gone, the one that still felt how it used to be part of one is gone, newer ones will eventually repeat the errors of the past. 1923 goverment was seen as a liberation one that actually fixed things, but that was in the early years.
- NiceWayToDoIT 5y ago
- DeWilde 5y agoTotal surveillance doesn't have to be a bad thing, if it can only be accessed through a court order in order to be used for solving a crime or as evidence in court. However, I can only see this happening in very developed and transparent democracies. Otherwise it is most likely gonna be abused in every way it can. Serbia already leans towards being a police state, at least in comparison to other European states, so that would just make the situation there worse.
- kashug 5y agoMy problem with it is that once you have total surveillance it is hard to get rid of. And even if I trust the current goverment, do I trust the next?
- rcMgD2BwE72F 5y agoEven trusted governments can't guarantee that bad actors cannot access the data captured by the surveillance system. If a government need total surveillance, it is because the government don't trust its people, which is because the people does not trust the government. This cannot fix trust issues with surveillance, you must solve this with more/better democracy, not police.
- djbebs 5y agoNo, surveillance is a bad thing period. No exceptions.
- ivanhoe 5y agoThere's a big mobster war going on in Serbia (and region) right now, and almost all of the dozens of recent big murder cases were at least partially solved thanks to surveillance cameras, phone tapping and cell towers logs. So surveillance when used for good can be extremely useful tool for justice and increase the safety of the public. It's the same mentality as with the nuclear plants paranoia. Yes they can be dangerous if protocols fail, and yes that makes them a liability and requires constant care - but it's not a reason to completely ban a technology which also can give so many benefits to the society.
- cocoggu 5y agoIt's not a big surprise to me and I think this is linked to the fact that Serbia is one of China's biggest partner in Europe. I can easily imagine that chinese companies now want to export their tech, including surveillance tech, to other countries and that they're lobbying for it. Glad it was withdrawn that easily.
- ubavic 5y agoI am not sure why are you being downvoted. Mass surveillance in Belgrade exist for some years and China helped the government with implementation. Serbia will continue to buy surveillance equipment from China regardless of this law. Serbia is definitely becoming a Chinese colony. China is placing dirty industries here, effectively cutting transportation costs to the EU and reducing pollution in China. Also, a few years ago there were official government proposals (like this) to bring Chinese police to Serbia. Unfortunately, the EU absolutely doesn't care about any of this and actively supports the Vucic regime.
- cocoggu 5y agoThanks for your support, but just wanted to point out that Serbia is not part of EU yet.
- bobthechef 5y ago> I can easily imagine that chinese companies now want to export their tech, including surveillance tech And I wouldn’t stop there. Why wouldn’t China want to profit from the surveillance of others as well? It would give them an edge, at least ostensibly, and a way to keep spreading their tentacles and to displace the American empire.
- BelenusMordred 5y agoFor biometric surveillance I honestly wouldn't be surprised if it's happening at some level of government in the UK, I vaguely remember a bit of outrage about such things in London and the government backing down, but do we really expect the intelligence services to follow rules anymore? The way liberal democracies are going there's probably already some secret law allowing it to occur.
- mdp2021 5y agoI think the orientation towards "one camera per scenery" in the UK predates the 2001 western revolution.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoIt only works on honest people. Russian spies enter and deploy weapons of mass destruction without any difficulty.
- viktorcode 5y ago> it will become the first European country conducting permanent indiscriminate surveillance of citizens in public spaces Formally, no. Large Russian cities (Moscow in particular) already employ this technology on mass scale.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 5y agoAn acquaintance in Moscow had been hiding from police. Agents showed up at his apartment next day wielding photos taken by the building surveillance camera.
- wolframhempel 5y agoI'm taking the fatalistic position on these developments. Any tool that can increase power will eventually be used. Maybe not in this law, maybe not in this exact shape, but inevitably. In the long run, there is a clear trajectory towards surveillance and authoritarianism. Is there a way to change this trajectory, to permanently prevent this from happening? I can't think of one...
- d--b 5y agoI genuinely don't understand how lawmakers do not see that they are the ones who will lose the most from privacy-invading laws. As a political person, the less you control what's being recorded about you, the more it's likely that it is going to be used against you. Would anyone be elected if their entire google search history were made transparent? I certainly wouldn't. Now add location history, and everything you say near a smartphone...
- pjc50 5y agoControl over who gets elected moves to the security apparatus. There's always one party for which that's a feature.
- 57844743385 5y agoYep, there it is… forget all the half measures and flouncing about, go straight for the total surveillance of all people all the time in all situations. Cut out the middle man.
- null0pointer 5y agoI wish there was some kind of soaking in period with laws like this (maybe even all laws). Something like “Those who implement new laws are first themselves subject to them for one year before being rolled out to the general public.” Perhaps it might slow the descent into an insane techno-dystopia. Of course that would never happen though.
- 0134340 5y agoSo as a dev is reponsible for alpha testing before possibly unleashing it to the public and possibly ruining someone's minute, you want lawmakers to test their own laws first before possibly ruining someone's life? Come to think of it, car makers, product creators and such are also responsible for testing before unleashing to the public. I wish it wasn't such an amusing notion with lawmakers but good luck with that.
- Factorium 5y agoSerbia's mistake was proposing this via law, instead of just forcing the population to track themselves with COVID check-ins and then tapping into the data: https://theconversation.com/police-access-to-covid-check-in-data-is-an-affront-to-our-privacy-we-need-stronger-and-more-consistent-rules-in-place-167360 https://theconversation.com/police-access-to-covid-check-in-...
- vkou 5y agoYou must realize that in the developed world, we already track ourselves by virtue of using credit cards at every business we visit. How is tapping into that any more difficult than a COVID app? The three major credit rating agencies already have complete knowledge of every place I visit, and every single thing I buy. They will happily sell this information in aggregate to any Tom, Dick, or Harry who wants it, and hand over every detail in response to a police warrant.
- Dudeman112 5y ago"Yeah, but it's not the government so it's fine" Just thought I'd proceed the discussion with the argument that will inevitably be brought forward.
- vkou 5y agoThe government has full access to this data, though. Whether or not a private agency with a profit motive, or a public health agency with a public health motive collects it first is irrelevant.
- refurb 5y agoJust pay cash?
- sudosysgen 5y agoIn real life an increasing amount of businesses don't accept cash anymore.
- bobthechef 5y agoDoes this guy have ties to China? Serbia has been developing ties with China for some time. Who would provide the technology for this mass surveillance? Certainly not the Serbian economy.
- naiwenwt 5y agoAlmost certainly China, the article seems to allude to Huawei tech being used. I don't have a source for this but in Serbia it's well-known that Vucic and Xi Jinping have a closer-than-expected partnership.
- UltraViolence 5y agoIt's clear the Chinese are trying to undermine the EU by introducing these kinds of systems in a aspiring EU member state. BTW the EU isn't directly against such systems. There's always the loophole that it CAN be used in the fight against "crime" (especially child porn, the new witchcraft).
- ashtonkem 5y agoI think the thing that’s baffling me is this: why? What’s the emergency, fake or otherwise, that governments are using to become so totalitarian. Seems like they’re just … going for it without even a fig leaf to hide behind.
- intricatedetail 5y agoMostly a) contracts to implement technologies b) watching people who could potentially expose corruption.
- ashtonkem 5y agoAgain, not what I was saying. Usually there’s a cover story for such actions. A Reichstag fire, or a terrorist attack that makes a turn towards authoritarianism a necessity. I don’t see how one exists here other than “NATO scary”.
- petre 5y agoOr a pandemic for that matter.
- ashtonkem 5y agoThey missed the boat if that was the plan.
- intricatedetail 5y agoI think you are missing the point. Authoritarianism is not a goal, but certainly helps. They just want money. If money become worthless, then so the plan.
- ashtonkem 5y agoI disagree strongly with this. I think authoritarianism is a goal for a lot of people. It wouldn’t be such a consistent threat if it wasn’t something regularly sought after. Some people crave power, others crave a strong man to protect them and guide their lives.
- ctrlp 5y agoAnyone who is alarmed by this law but not by vaccine passports able to explain why? Genuinely confused.
- marcosdumay 5y agoIn what way is this even remotely similar to vaccine passports?
- ctrlp 5y agoLegislating mass surveillance and vaccine passports look very similar if the digital implementations are any guide.
- menimax 5y agoTracing everyone's movement and life, and putting that into database, can be used for creating the perfect sims simulation :) Anyway real time cam face recognition can be passed easily, som hat, sunglasses and the new classic - mask. Using covid pass- will use someone else's qr, it doesn't have to allowed, but will be placed in that database like that person was there. Also face recognition can be manipulated and used for targeted attacks. And selling info about someone's movement...well..."nothing to hide?" - everyone has something to hide, like from his wife...