10 ms·
> The FTC also said in court that Facebook’s fine would have been closer to $106 million, but the company agreed to the $5 billion penalty to avoid having Zucke
by paxys 5y ago
> The FTC also said in court that Facebook’s fine would have been closer to $106 million, but the company agreed to the $5 billion penalty to avoid having Zuckerberg or Chief Operating Officer Sheryl Sandberg deposed and any liability for the CEO, the suit alleged.
This is bizarre. I get throwing in a little extra to shield executives, but $5 billion?
- paulcarroty 5y agoThis is crazy money, yeah, for us.
- ctvo 5y agoIt's not the amount. It's the ratio. They overpaid by over 47 times. A company filled with world class lawyers and business executives, as well as an experienced board does that? Why?
- pjc50 5y agoBecause the boss told them to?
- Reubachi 5y agoyes....that's what's crazy: why? Not sure the why folks are confused about folks being confused about this. There must be some logical reason they would pay out close to 50x the demanded payout, but none of us for the life of us can imagine why beyond shielding personal liability. So, why is that possible?
- Cederfjard 5y agoIt’s not only personal liability - surely Zuckerberg and Sandberg being deposed would be a liability for Facebook as well.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoOr maybe it would be a long overdue cleanup
- intended 5y agoPerhaps precedent. The difference between Facebook as a firm being liable for everything that has happened or will happen, vs an individual being liable?
- bbarnett 5y agoThe settlement happened after the 5B was paid. The 5B likely included a fine they were seeking, too.
- ctvo 5y agoThe fine was 109M. Not sure why you felt the need to clarify that the settlement happened after the 5B was paid when the 5B was conditional on Zuckerberg / Sandberg not being liable in the settlement. The question is what did these people know / do that was worth 47x the fine to keep them safe.
- bbarnett 5y agoThe point is, the 5B was a fine, accepting full penalty for whatever "wrong thing", over that part which was being investigated. The 47x number is apples and oranges. They are two different fines / issues. What Zuck knew isn't relevant, for, the fine was likely "if all the bad things we think you did, happened, then this is the fine". So, in essence, he admitted to all the questions being asked. Zuck / Facebook paid, rather then shine greater light on things. So yeah, bad stuff surely, but I see no direct connection to the other fine. In fact, by relating it to the other fine, people are missing that it may have been an entirely other (very bad) matter. The bit about personal liability, etc, etc is standard boilerplate stuff.
- klyrs 5y agoI believe the term "fuck you money" has never been more apt.
- munk-a 5y agoThis case may have elevated it to "fuck society money"
- autokad 5y agowell zuck basically has full decision rights over FB shares. If I am not mistaken, only he has voting rights, no FB common share holder holds any voting rights
- jdsully 5y agoMinority and even non-voting shareholders still have rights, the majority cannot arbitrarily deprive them of the benefits of ownership. The legal doctrine is "shareholder oppression". If Zuckerberg really did pay more than he had to solely for his benefit at the expense of minority holders then it would be an example of this.
- im3w1l 5y agoHe already has bad relations with minority shareholders[0], so I wouldn't be surprised if someone tries to sieze this opportunity. [0] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8261775/Facebook-investors-launch-attempt-remove-Mark-Zuckerberg-chairman.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-8261775/Facebook-in...
- quickthrowman 5y agoI’m sure a high priced lawyer would argue that Mark Zuckerberg in prison would be a worse outcome than a $5B fine for FB shareholders (I’d tend to agree, but I don’t own any FB outside of index positions exactly for the regulatory/legal risk that FB is exposed to, which I feel the market underestimates)
- tantalor 5y agoThat's a counterfactual.
- quickthrowman 5y agoHaving your CEO in prison would not do good things for the share price, I’m not sure what you mean by counterfactual. It’s a simple calculation of utility: minus $5B in market cap for the fine, vs unknown market cap loss from CEO in prison
- vineyardmike 5y ago> I get throwing in a little extra to shield executives, but $5 billion? If i had singular control of a company the size of FB and the ability to spend it's money to avoid any sort of liability, i'd take the offer too.
- rebuilder 5y agoIt’s a hell of an upsell, though. That’s 50 times the initial price. Zuckerberg must have been really worried, or really, really unwilling to take any personal risk.
- ivalm 5y agoThe marginal utility of $5b of facebook’s money to Zuck is very low, but the cost of even a low chance of serious personal liability is high.
- shapefrog 5y agoGuessing he had a few people fired from their 100k jobs for only generating a mil in profits for the company and thus being a drag on the metrics.
- pc86 5y agoZuckerberg is worth $130 billion. And this $5 billion isn't even his money; it's the company's.
- lostlogin 5y ago> Zuckerberg must have been really worried, or really, really unwilling to take any personal risk. I’m not so sure. If you asked a random person if they could wash the dishes, or not do them but someone other person would have to pay 5 billion dollars, what would the result be?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 5y ago
- dado3212 5y agoThe magnitude is so large as to make me doubt this in its entirety. There must have been some other benefits that were gotten from the deal, or there wasn't clarity that the number wouldn't swell beyond the $106 million number, right? How else do you possibly justify paying roughly 50x what was asked?
- Justsignedup 5y agounless there was a criminal potential, and these billionaires don't like sitting in cages for any amount of time.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tyingq 5y agoIf the liability of what would have been revealed by deposing Zuck is even higher than 50x. The math is "potential damage from a deposition + fine" vs "paying 50x the fine up front".
- TYPE_FASTER 5y ago> If the liability of what would have been revealed by deposing Zuck is even higher than 50x. Was thinking about this. Would be curious to know what information was worth $5bil.
- intended 5y agoIm guessing The precedent of being made personally liable for every ill that Facebook could be responsible for in the past, present and future.
- dado3212 5y agoIsn't the question why was it 50x? I agree that there's definitely a value prop here where it's worth upfront money to avoid potential damage (moral caveats aside lol). But it seems unlikely that the FCC was like "100 million and we depose Zuck, or 5 BILLION and we let it go", which feels borderline blackmail-y. Why did FB propose 50x as opposed to some smaller number as part of the proposed deal?
- samstave 5y agoWhat pisses me off is -- WHERE exactly is that $5B going to be spent. We hear about fines and such going into the "general fund" -- I think this is BS - the public should be specifically the ones to benefit _directly_ from such corporate overreach fines and such. Housing fines should buy houses. Financial fraud should pay those defrauded - directly. Cyber [crimes?] should be paid to directly protect users etc.... We have heard of so many fines in the past, but no real transparency on exactly how they are spent. And it shouldnt be in some obtuse web/budget location to determine... There should be a dedicated fines.gov or some such that lists every single company fined, how much and how it was spent.
- boplicity 5y agoApparently most of the fines go straight to the "US Treasury." Basically, congress decides how to spend the money. That makes some sense: at least it is being spent by people who are elected, so that there is a chance at accountability. However, it also doesn't make sense, because it doesn't seem "fair." The money from fines should be used to compensate victims. That being said, compare this to the common practice of civil forfeiture: The money often goes back to the very same government entities who took the money. This is very bad because it incentivizes government agencies to be way too aggressive. On balance, I think it might be better for the money to go back to the general fund. That way the temptation for corruption is severely mitigated. Though, I'm not sure about this, as I haven't spent much time thinking about it. There could, perhaps, be a more nuanced approach, based on each unique agencies needs/situation. That would require a lot of legislation, though.
- Tarq0n 5y agoEarmarking money at a too granular level is a great way to lower the efficiency of government. I also don't see why it should be the case that this money gets spent in the same domain it was levied, the whole point of democratic institutions is to be able to set priorities dynamically.
- xpe 5y agoMany excellent points -- and this is a key part of the discussion when it comes to fine. The post above has emotion -- and I'm personally ok with that -- but I think it would be better received without the two letter abbreviations for swear words.
- odiroot 5y agoMaybe they can now get sued for securities fraud? (Per Matt Levine)
- spoonjim 5y agoZuckerberg is worth vastly more than $5 billion to Facebook.
- zie 5y agoWell, we don't actually know that. Can a different CEO do a better job with Facebook? We haven't any idea as we have never had the opportunity to find out. But I agree that it's generally bad for shareholders if your CEO ends up in prison.
- spoonjim 5y ago5 companies have ever been worth more than $1 trillion, Facebook is one of them. Could a different CEO have made more money? Possibly. But the notion is a bit like thinking that you could have done better than Tom Brady as a quarterback because he lost 3 Super Bowls. I mean, yes, it's true, you can imagine a quarterback that didn't lose those 3 games. But he also won 7, which, chances are, your replacement QB would have not. When a person has made more money for shareholders than 99.999995% of people in history, it's an extraordinary claim that someone else could have made more, one that would require extraordinary evidence.
- JimDabell 5y ago> When a person has made more money for shareholders than 99.999995% of people in history, it's an extraordinary claim that someone else could have made more That claim is not being made. The question is not whether another CEO could have made money from the start, the question is whether another CEO could have made more money from the point at which Facebook paid billions to shield Mark Zuckerberg. What has he personally done to move the needle that much in the past two years?
- brudgers 5y agoA Google side panel says last quarter Facebook doubled it's net income to $10 billion. So year over year, Facebook made that money back last quarter. If the lower settlement might have slowed year over year growth, five billion would likely be money well spent. Particularly if there wasn't an obviously better return for the cash. When you have billions of cash on hand finding investments that size is a hard problem. Keep in mind that the fine is an operational expense. Right off the top, there's potential double digit return from reducing taxable income. In addition, the company better maintains the book value of goodwill assets without the depositions and can borrow money at more favorable rates. On top of that, executives and staff aren't spending time in depositions and answering tough questions from the press. The interesting thing is figuring out why it makes sense despite my direct experience. Even though I would have preferred they gave me some of that money instead.
- encoderer 5y agoYes nailed it. Executives of a certain vintage learned a lot watching the carnage from US v Microsoft. Talk about destruction of shareholder value. I would say for Facebook this is money well spent.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> Executives of a certain vintage learned a lot watching the carnage from US v Microsoft Please elaborate.
- encoderer 5y agoI’m sure there have been books or well researched blog posts you could dig up but here’s my best take: Look at the influence and trajectory of Microsoft before and after the lawsuit. The executive team was distracted for a year. The employees were demoralized by bad press coverage. Competitors were emboldened. And for internet and mobile, Microsoft got put on the back foot before the 21st century even began. Facebook management and board is full of people who observed and lived that experience. There is a case study of corporate distraction and they have read it.
- stickfigure 5y agoIf the narrative doesn't make sense, maybe it's not true. Or wildly exaggerated.
- throwawaylinux 5y ago> This is bizarre. I get throwing in a little extra to shield executives, but $5 billion? I think it's bizarre that is what you find bizarre. You've already accepted paying more to shield the executives, so after that it's just negotiation. What I find bizarre is that essentially "donating" money to a government regulator can induce the regulator to cover up and turn a blind eye to a person's alleged or suspected breaches in the course of investigations and prosecutions. In the world of plebs, this is either bribery or blackmail, depending on who blinks first, and conspiracy. I understand corporations "agreeing" to punishment with regulators like it's some cordial negotiation. It seems perverse but if the alternative is horrendously long expensive court cases that the regulator can't afford and doesn't have a good chance of winning, then sure. It does tell me the legislation and regulatory environment is broken (probably by design), but at least I understand regulators operating as they do in the environment they find themselves in. But this? "Slip us some cash under the table and Mark's little problem goes away" veers into the fundamentally unethical and unjust to me. I'm sure it's just that my tiny pleb brain is not sophisticated or rich enough to understand.
- JohnFen 5y ago> this is either bribery or blackmail, depending on who blinks first, and conspiracy. It doesn't much matter to me what the flavor is, what matters is that this is corruption in action, pure and simple.
- bawolff 5y ago> I think it's bizarre that is what you find bizarre. You've already accepted paying more to shield the executives, so after that it's just negotiation. To one up you - i find it bizare that you think that's the bizare part. The entire point of a corporation, as a governance structure, in general is to limit liability for its shareholders. That's true for all corporations not just facebook. Its the reason people establish corporations instead of running businesseses informally as an individual. The only surprising thing is the cost benefit trade-off here seems a bit much. Its not surprising that the facebook corporation tried to do its entire reason for existing.
- 5y ago
- electriclove 5y agoWhat does the FTC do with that $5b?
- JohnFen 5y agoTypically, proceeds from large fines go to the US Treasury.
- bawolff 5y agoThe other bizarre part is why did ftc agree? The ftc isn't motivated by shareholder profit, why would they take the $5B deal if they thought something was there?
- compiler-guy 5y agoAs a regulator, having one of the largest settlements ever paid by a social media company (or any company at all for that matter) is a major win. Especially traded off against the possibility that you lose in court.