8 ms·
When I worked at reddit, I refused to run Adblock. I felt like it would be hypocritical to work for a company that made its money from ads, and then block them
by jedberg 5y ago
When I worked at reddit, I refused to run Adblock. I felt like it would be hypocritical to work for a company that made its money from ads, and then block them. Also I wanted to make sure that I had the same experience as the users.
When I left reddit, for the longest time I still didn't run Adblock because as a shareholder it still felt hypocritical.
But a few years ago I couldn't take it anymore -- the web go so awful with ads on it became unusable. And so I relented and went full Adblock. And life got a lot better.
(I did however whitelist reddit and a few other sites that I like whose ads are bearable)
- tubby12345 5y agothis is the weirdest flagellation i have ever seen. do you also believe that alcohol producers must daily consume alcohol? candy manufacturers daily consume candy? how about pharma? the list goes on.
- jagger27 5y agoShould companies eat their own dogfood? Uh, yeah.
- tubby12345 5y agoyou're reiterating GP without addressing exactly the counter examples that i allude to.
- jagger27 5y agoDo alcohol makers try their own products to ensure consistency day-to-day? I would hope so. I would certainly hope candymakers do too. Those are particularly bad examples.
- tubby12345 5y agoask yourself if you're willfully misconstruing what i'm saying in order to low brow dismiss my point. jedberg claims he consumed ads every day in order to empathize with this customers. the obvious implication is that everyone at such a company has the obligation to "try their own products".
- jagger27 5y agoYour analogy is weak, so I pointed it out. Reddit created their experience a certain way; why would you go out of your way to avoid seeing your product the way your users do? You haven't presented a single argument as to WHY an employee of a software company shouldn't experience their product as their users do.
- pessimizer 5y agoTalking about product testing is a deliberate red herring, though. Nobody was talking about some web designer using adblock during the process of implementing ads on a site. That would be a very difficult hurdle to put in front of yourself.
- kordlessagain 5y agoJedberg, who I know for a fact ran Reddit's infra singlehandedly for a while, claimed he consumed ads as a matter of understanding the user while holding the job. Apparently he grew a brain and decided to block ads after that job, as smart and well informed users tend to do. I suggest turning off JavaScript for most sites, which keeps the ad blocking tasks to a minimum. Blocking trolling users is another matter entirely.
- bostik 5y agoMaster distillers definitely do. Not necessarily every single day, but for every single run of the stills, yes. Distillery staff will also occasionally test that the caskets being matured are doing okay. Source: visited 5 out of 7 distilleries on Islay.
- jagger27 5y ago> visited 5 out of 7 distilleries on Islay. Oh that would be _wonderful_. Some day!
- VWWHFSfQ 5y agoI used to work on sports gambling apps and yet I never once gambled using the real production app. Because I saw the data. And behind those data points are real people having their lives ruined by some growth hackers and psychologist PMs trying to increase session length. I know how the sausage is made. I practically have the gambling addiction hotline number memorized because it was required to be on every screen.
- CameronNemo 5y agoMaybe businesses like that have no business existing, then.
- asdff 5y agoPretty much everyone I know gambles on sports and for most of these guys its like a $50 bet, not a lot of money. No more than a few beers these days at a bar. People get addicted to anything, lets work on having people receive treatment if things become a problem rather than ban everything that most users are using responsibly. Might as well ban video games of you really want to get some people out of some deep holes.
- aaron-santos 5y agoSurely you do not work at Purina.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 5y ago> Surely you do not work at Purina I happen to know a handful of people who started pet food companies, albeit boutique ones. (California.) They all taste their pet foods. I've tried some of the treat biscuits, and they aren't half bad, though I wouldn't necessarily reach for them. I'm not an expert on cat or dog digestion. But I think anything they can eat, humans can, too. (Just not the other way.)
- jedberg 5y agoGrowing up in California, one thing we were taught as kids is that pet food is safe for human consumption, and can be used for food after an earthquake as emergency rations. It won't taste good, but it will prevent starvation!
- a1369209993 5y ago> pet food is safe for human consumption This is false in general, and dangerously misleading at best. In particular, some dog foods contain ingredients (bone meal IIRC, but don't rely on that) that can pretty much destroy a human's intestines (which are much less hardy than most animals's because coevolution with cooked food allowed cost-cutting). Pet food sold in California might (might) be required to be safe, but that's dangerously unreliable at best.
- jedberg 5y agoNot sure why you say that. The FDA regulates pet food the same way as human food: https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/animal-food-feeds/pet-food https://www.fda.gov/animal-veterinary/animal-food-feeds/pet-...
- jedberg 5y agoI would find it hypocritical if someone who worked at an alcohol producer joined MADD, or someone who worked at a candy company joining a PAC that supports soda bans. But no, they don't need to consume the product daily.
- nkozyra 5y ago> I would find it hypocritical if someone who worked at an alcohol producer joined MADD Really? Isn't there a pretty big gulf between "drinks alcohol" and "drinks alcohol and then gets behind the wheel of a car?"
- cochne 5y agoNot really the same. The implied agreement when you visit an ad based site is that you get the ads. Otherwise if no one got them, the site could not exist. It’s a form of payment for what the site provides to you, not the product itself.
- Spooky23 5y agoThere's no implied agreement - a product is offered at no cost, and I'm under no legal, ethical or moral obligation to look at anything. I'm a weirdo who still buys the paper newspaper. I throw out the Thursday auto advertisements and the Sunday ads. Content producers made a conscious decision to aggregate their screen real estate and outsource ad placement to unrelated third parties. The result is a cesspool of awful, low engagement content. Its so bad that they enter into awful agreements with aggregators to repackage their content for pennies. That's their problem, not mine. On the flip, I live in a state capital, and when the legislature is in session, interest groups spend 10x what they spend on useless online ad spots to buy full-page or panel ads in the printed newspaper. Presumably they aren't doing that in an effort to set money on fire.
- nickff 5y ago>"I'm under no legal, ethical or moral obligation to look at anything" That would depend on you moral theory of choice; applying Kantian (deontological) moral theory, your behavior violates the principle of 'universalizability'. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kantian_ethics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kantian_ethics
- krisoft 5y agoI’m not following you. In what way would it violate the principle of ‘universalizability’?
- nickff 5y agoFrom the Wikipedia on universalizability: >"The precise meaning of universalizability is contentious, but the most common interpretation is that the categorical imperative asks whether the maxim of your action could become one that everyone could act upon in similar circumstances." >"For instance, one can determine whether a maxim of lying to secure a loan is moral by attempting to universalize it and applying reason to the results. If everyone lied to secure loans, the very practices of promising and lending would fall apart, and the maxim would then become impossible." If everyone were to block ads, the publications that you're reading would not be able to pay for the content they publish. Note that 'universalizability' requires a somewhat static analysis, and usually doesn't look at how systems might adapt to changed circumstances, though this is not a big problem here, as you have voluntarily chosen to interact with ad-supported publishers under the current regime.
- blitzar 5y agoOne should also try out the alternatives as well, regarding the GP, I personally believe there was an equal obligation to experience it without the ads to determine the impact. Likewise it would be nice for the alcohol producer to experience drinking every day, as well as being the only person at the party not drinking. Even being the allocated driver and seeing the consequences of their product up close. Perhaps they would gain some insight or perspective regarding their product.
- crvdgc 5y agoThe reasoning here is not the dissonance in behavior, but dissonance in belief. A person can believe alcohol is not harmful to humans health without consuming alcohol, therefore it's morally acceptable if an alcohol producer does not consume alcohol. But if they don't consume alcohol because they believe alcohol is harmful, while advertising (explicitly or implicitly by helping the alcohol company) that it is not harmful, then that is dishonesty. Because in this case, the person purposefully acts like they believe something for personal benefits, but actually they don't.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoCrack dealers smoke their own crack to ensure they give out a good supply
- no_time 5y agoThey should listen to Ten Crack Commandments by Biggie Smalls.
- daniel-cussen 5y agoWell, about pharma: I believe at least one person with veto power at FDA should try the pill personally. And the pharma company management should be able to take it. This would have helped with OxyContin, among others.
- PaulHoule 5y agoTobacco firms were notorious for expecting their employees to be tobacco users. My mom was a sales clerk for Macy's and one of her friends was a sales clerk there who later became a tobacco company rep who went to convenience stores to manage the marketing displays. She smoked like a chimney. After my dad died and her friend got divorced, her friend moved in a for a while with my mom and got my mom smoking again. My mom hid it from everybody and we found out only after she died from a cardiovascular event because we found a pack of cigarettes, one half-finished, in the cupboard.
- CameronNemo 5y agoYeah I think Phillip morris execs should be forced at gunpoint to smoke as many cigarettes a week as the global median. Might lead them to think twice before advertising poison.
- fidesomnes 5y agowell, he did choose, by choice, to work at reddit.
- pbhjpbhj 5y agoNo, but if an alcohol seller practiced temperance because they felt alcohol was deleterious to people, wouldn't it be rather hypocritical? He was not actively consuming ads, he was just not seeking to avoid them.
- lmm 5y agoIf you couldn't stand to consume your own product, you're probably doing bad things and should stop.
- systemvoltage 5y agoIt’s bizarre to me how you can be so loyal to a corporation. What a weird way to inflict self-suffering.
- jedberg 5y agoIt wasn't loyalty to the corporation, it was empathy with the users.
- systemvoltage 5y agoI see. But then you continue to willfully see ads after you left Reddit. I presume you viewed ads everywhere not just on Reddit? Still strikes me as absolutely bizarre to do this. On one hand it’s commendable that you’d like to empathize with users, but on the other hand you’re working at Reddit who earns revenue by glueing people to their endless feed of ads. Expecting anything else is foolish.
- munchbunny 5y agoI used to be in ad tech, and I did the same thing. I didn't use an ad blocker so that I could understand what the users were seeing. A few years in though, it started to get bad enough that I enabled the ad blocker on my personal stuff and kept a browser session for work where the ad blocker was off.
- corobo 5y agoAs a user I have Adblock. Go for it
- xxs 5y agoA real empathy would be advocating for adblocks and installing on all your acquaintance that would not know better.
- NikolaeVarius 5y agoThis is such a dumb hill to die on.
- jedberg 5y agoI agree, that's why I left the hill still alive. :)
- typon 5y agoIt's incredible how people are chastising you for having skin in the game
- unethical_ban 5y agoWhen you view it through the lens of "journalism dies without money, and local journalism survives on ads", I can see some nobility in it.
- jopsen 5y agoYou're probably better off sponsoring some journalism directly instead. The guardian has a supporter tier. Some local news stations where I live have memberships with minor benefits.
- AniseAbyss 5y agoSubscriptions? Could be a local thing but in my country newspapers have always been paid with them. News has never been assumed "free" until the internet came around. In fact the first newspapers all the way back to the 17th century were intended for diplomats, nobility and merchants. Free news is usually shite anyway.
- unethical_ban 5y ago>the internet came around Yes, it did. I have subscribed (and might still be subscribed) to several news magazines and papers, though not my local. It's kind a circular drain of "lower pay > lower quality > fewer subscribers > lower pay".
- NelsonMinar 5y agoI did the same when I worked on Google Ads; I felt it was important for me to have the full ad experience. It was easier back in the early 2000s though, before the Web ad ecosystem got so horrible. Now I block ads and trackers with great zeal. Google's most of all. Surveillance capitalism is bad for almost everyone. Advertising is a mind virus.
- space_fountain 5y agoMy experience of ads is that they're much better than they were in the early 2000s. Back then major websites would have literal scams advertised on their site. Things like you're the 1 millionth visitor click here to collect your prize. Now I rarely see that sort of thing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- robocat 5y agoPerhaps scams have a high selection pressure to evolve to be less detectable (while we are also being trained to detect them better). You might be seeing plenty of scams, but they are just camouflaged far better?
- kwonkicker 5y agoThis has to be the most misunderstood comment. Honestly eve tho I don't work for an and centric company I do feel what you went through. Because of how much YouTube helped me, I couldn't bear myself using an ad blocker. Then things like Patreon and sponsorship deals came along and I decided to treat myself a nice ad blocker. Still couldn't do the full thing, so I went with one called "fair ad blocker" that actually let's in some no -intrusive ones so it's a little light on my conscience. Still using it. It let's in some annoying pop ups too sometimes, but such is the price.
- everdrive 5y agoBut the real question is, did you ever use the new interface instead of old.reddit.com?
- jedberg 5y agoI tried for a week. When my CPU melted I switched back to old.reddit. But I use the mobile app (which is basically the new interface) for about 50% of my redditing, so I sort of use both. But always the old interface on the computer.
- vlowther 5y agoI hated the Reddit app so much I bought BaconReader.
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoApollo all day.
- shostack 5y agoAnd do you use RES?
- rvba 5y agoi.reddit.com is best for mobile
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xxs 5y ago>you ever "use" What do you meany "use". It's totally unusable even with full adblock
- drdeadringer 5y ago> old.reddit.com This is what I use.
- lordnacho 5y agoI've never had it explained to me what's wrong with hypocrisy. None of us live by our high ideals, do we? It's funny when a comedian points that out, but why should we do as we say?
- ianmcgowan 5y agoSounds like a quote from The Diamond Age: https://www.google.com/search?q=the+diamond+age+hypocrisy https://www.google.com/search?q=the+diamond+age+hypocrisy
- fouric 5y agoHypocrisy is usually dishonest ("I'm going to tell you a lie in hopes that you believe it; my behavior shows that I don't actually believe the lie") or unfair ("I'm going to try to convince you to play by a more restrictive set of rules than I do so I can get an advantage over you (or just avoid having the drawbacks of those rules myself)", both of which are bad things. Moreover, just because you're not capable of perfectly adhering to a set of principles doesn't mean that it's not worth trying. "Oh, I know that I'm not going to be able to uphold every single commitment I make, so I'm not going to worry about upholding any of them."
- lordnacho 5y agoYes it might be a hint that you don't believe what you say, but that shouldn't detract from you saying being potentially correct. After all the truth value isn't affected by who says something. I bet there were smokers who were part of discovering that smoking is unhealthy. The thing about pointing out hypocrisy is that you're actually lending authority to the person you criticize, you're saying that you believe in the side he's revealed to actually support.
- lmm 5y agoMorality is important, but self-righteousness is unpleasant to be around. Punishing hypocrisy helps strike the right balance.
- darkmarmot 5y agoI once criticized one of Reddit's advertisers (AMC) in a sponsored comment post (they no longer allow comments on these). Reddit shadowbanned my account sitewide. That's enough reason for me to never, ever view Reddit without an adblock.
- CameronNemo 5y agoI loved commenting on ads. What a shit show that was. They were smart to remove the feature, but I do miss it.
- fridif 5y agoMe too, the Velveeta comments were the best
- ohashi 5y agoI am pretty sure I still get comments on my ads. It's almost entirely spam and those comments you think are probably spam it's just a 'good job' response.
- heavyset_go 5y agoDon't worry, Twitter allows commenting on ads.
- dunnevens 5y agoFB allows commenting on ads. This does not go well for certain types of advertisers. Political and religious ads especially. Even the bland corporate advertisers have to spend some time cleaning up the inevitable mess. What's especially puzzling is that FB allows image uploads as an ad response unless the advertiser was smart enough to disable it.
- r00fus 5y agoWell, you could call this "engagement", at least people are clicking and investigating. Also it appears Twitter does it as well - so many promoted tweets are just roasted in the replies.
- tEgJUbpL1H 5y agoI use adblock, makes it so much easier as an experience also surprises me how many companies are tracking me on some of these webpages. But, I am sympathetic to the idea of businesses depending on ad revenue. I like how some websites e.g. news websites, put up a message that they depend on ad revenue and ask for adblockers to be disabled, I did it for some websites where I like the content, but then I also feel I am perhaps very unlikely to click on any of the ads (at some level I suppose my mind has learned how to focus on the content and ignore the ad space e.g. on google search I remember I had developed a habit of scrolling down and ignoring the first few ad results without actually consciously doing it). So, considering I am way less likely to click on an ad, perhaps I am not actually hurting the business, or maybe actually helping improve conversion if I can go that far :)..
- laurent92 5y agoMost clicks on ads are certainly misclicks. The business is to make store owners believe that they are getting exposure, not to actually give them sales. All of the little guys like me who tried to run a Goggle Ads and Microsoft Ads campaign know that we can spend a few thousands dollars without a single impact on sales. Then the salesman from Google calls you and tells you it’s because you’re doing it wrong. Try such and such keywords. Link to your payment button to see your ratios! Try to optimize for CTR and EWQ and ASDF (not the strange proximity between those ideas and random letters on a keyword). It must be you. It must be YOU! The business is to make the business owner believe as long as possible that it will work.
- a1369209993 5y ago> The business is to make store owners believe that they are getting exposure, not to actually give them sales. To be scrupulously fair, the business is to make store owners believe that they are getting exposure, regardless of whether they actually get sales. Much like snake oil salemen, it's prefectly fine (nice, even) if the patient improves; that just means a chance to sell them more and 'better' snake oil ("brand maintainence", I think they call it) later.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y agoI once tried not running an ad blocker or noscript on a work computer. That lasted for a couple months until the day I got a redirected to a porn site from an innocuous search result. There are too many ways to weaponize a site to let your guard down. If the site operator can't or won't vet all of the code they send you then you should feel no obligation to execute it.
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoI work for a company and on the very team that serves billions of ad impressions a year. I use adblock every fucking day. The internet is simply unusable without one.
- jandrese 5y agoInsert Michael and Webb "Are we the baddies?" sketch here.
- BLKNSLVR 5y ago*Mitchell and Webb https://yewtu.be/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU https://yewtu.be/watch?v=hn1VxaMEjRU And advertising is marching under the rat's anus banner.
- snuser 5y agothanks for making the world a shithole dude
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoEh, do what I can.
- snuser 5y agowell, a lot of people manage not to.
- edm0nd 5y agoI really wish reddit would begin to pay small amounts to its moderators. I feel like it would be a basic income experiment and kinda neat since the mods do most of the content and user moderation for reddit and spend thousands upon thousands of hours there.
- Cycl0ps 5y agoI disagree. If income was paid out Reddit would then be sending out 1090s or W2s to every mod. Analytics and time tracking would be put in place. An entire team would need to be stood up to oversee mod management. Mods from certain regions of the world would be disavowed, and the barrier to enter would naturally be higher for new mods. I say mods should be either full employees or volunteers, you can't mix between the two.
- shostack 5y agoI've been in a similar situation. For me it was a different type of struggle... More, I need to be informed about the space. I am a firm believer that there are ways to do ads in a manner that respects the end user, is not obnoxious as well, and isn't privacy invasive. And this applies to both buy and sell sides of the industry. But much of the space is garbage and in some cases malicious, so I block ads with a prejudice, run NoScript on Firefox on desktop and mobile, etc. It's a PITA, but a better experience overall. It is a bit amusing to watch the changes Reddit is making to "improve the user experience" though, when to people in the industry, it seems like fairly transparently telegraphing development of surfaces for new ad placements or signal collection for targeting models. What pisses me off is Reddit leadership can't seem to just be transparent about it.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]