13 ms·
The Reemergent 1977 H1N1 Strain and the Gain-of-Function Debate (2015)
- rwmj 5y agoCan highly recommend Ken Alibek's book about the Russian biological warfare programme "Biohazard". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Alibek https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ken_Alibek
- inside65 5y agoWhat is it you recommend about it?
- rwmj 5y agoGoes into detail about all of the Soviet bioweapons programmes, from someone who was quite near the top (I think he was deputy director). It's scary as hell.
- walterbell 5y agoNIH has a short history of biowarfare, the first date in Table 1 is 1155, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1326439/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1326439/
- redis_mlc 5y agoSharri Markson's book on corona is released tomorrow. She's been the leading journalist since early 2020 on corona. NTD Media also ignored the global embargo coordinated by the CCP/Peter Daszak/Fauci.
- shakna 5y agoMarkson is also the reason that SkyNews was temporarily banned on YouTube [0], for repeatedly delivering information that was more grounded in the imagination, than in anything with actual evidence backing it. She helped promote and mislead around claims to do with hydroxychloroquine or ivermectin, mis-identifying chemical differences between human formulations and animal formulations, leading to hospital admissions. [1] There's no conspiracy here - she's actively dangerous to people's health. More interested in promoting an alternative viewpoint than whether that viewpoint actually has merit. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/media/2021/aug/04/sharri-markson-says-youtube-suspension-of-sky-news-australia-is-cancellation-of-free-speech https://www.theguardian.com/media/2021/aug/04/sharri-markson... [1] https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/sep/02/sydney-covid-patient-in-westmead-hospital-after-overdosing-on-ivermectin-and-other-online-cures https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2021/sep/02/sydne...
- artificialLimbs 5y ago>> Markson is also the reason that SkyNews was temporarily banned on YouTube [0], for repeatedly delivering information that was more grounded in the imagination, than in anything with actual evidence backing it. Let's be clear about the fact that in 0% of any cases where speech was not directly illegal was censorship the right choice. >> There's no conspiracy here - she's actively dangerous to people's health. So is McDonald's every time they advertise and sell any of their garbage product. And yet we recognize that it is important that people make up their own minds than do 'what is right', because it is not our place to determine what is right for them.
- humanistbot 5y ago> Let's be clear about the fact that in 0% of any cases where speech was not directly illegal was censorship the right choice. In a debate about scientific facts, when you stop defending the content of a position and instead fall back to saying that it is not illegal to express that position, you've lost the debate.
- mwint 5y agoIt is scientific fact that countries which start censoring for “correctness” in increasingly many categories end up being Not Great places to live.
- splintercell 5y agoDoes the logic not work the other way? If you start defending censorship of a position, you have lost the debate.
- arrow7000 5y agoIt does not.
- ctrlp 5y agoThe debate wasn't about scientific fact. It was about whether a journalist was spreading misinformation and according to whom. The debate is about the Orwellian term "misinformation" and has less to do with science than with Scientism.
- okamiueru 5y agoMeta: I was curious to see a dead comment by user redis_mlc here, and also seeing their history about 80% of their comments had the same status. The contents however seemed fine. What's going on here?
- lordnacho 5y agoI've turned on dead comments for that exact reason. A lot of them seem totally innocuous. You do get the occasional spam though.
- okamiueru 5y agoHow do you turn on dead comments?
- ttonkytonk 5y agoGo to your user screen and select "yes" in the dropbox next to "showdead".
- okamiueru 5y agoOh my, time to get some more sleep. I swear I saw through the list a few times. In any case. Thanks.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- the-dude 5y agoI assume he has been shadow banned. Comments which are not completely dead have been 'vouched' ?
- lioeters 5y agoI noticed that user too, and was "impressed" how most of their comments are downvoted to death. Some of them might have deserved it, but others seem totally normal. I guess they're expressing strong and unpopular opinions..?
- tim333 5y agoThe 1977 H1N1 seems not to be a gain of function but them trying it out to test a vaccine. It goes to show labs can do dumb stuff. Given the spread of risky research: > At least 59 facilities, like Wuhan Institute, are planned or in operation across world https://www.ft.com/content/a0badd5d-4d88-4a3b-b019-61c6d8275caa https://www.ft.com/content/a0badd5d-4d88-4a3b-b019-61c6d8275... I hope they regulate this stuff better.
- rjzzleep 5y agoThere's a pretty good discussion(summary) on Covid-19s GoF in the twitter thread below: https://twitter.com/Ayjchan/status/1392127958807162884 https://twitter.com/Ayjchan/status/1392127958807162884
- tim333 5y agoThat discussion from May has to some extent been made out of date by subsequent information revealed by a freedom of information request showing >new viruses increased viral load in lung tissues up to 10,000 fold https://twitter.com/Ayjchan/status/1436301383163129871 https://twitter.com/Ayjchan/status/1436301383163129871 You can debate whether that counts as gain of function research - the virus definitely gained as a result of the experiment but you can argue the experimenters didn't know that was going to happen. It still remains risky research whether the researchers deliberately made a more infectious virus or said oops we've accidentally made a more infectious virus.
- wbl 5y agoYou never know whether something is going to work thr first time you do it.
- lanevorockz 5y agoI love how we are pushing the agenda that laws are irrelevant and the government should be allowed to break them as they wish. Very Liberal
- lanevorockz 5y agoHave you ever thought that Covid was not Pharma’s way of saying.. we own you !
- api 5y agoFYI the moratorium mentioned was lifted in 2017: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/u-s-lifts-moratorium-on-funding-controversial-high-risk-virus-research/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/u-s-lifts-morator...
- stevespang 5y agoMore speculation . . .
- walterbell 5y agoIn addition to not making new viruses, we should consider a moratorium on further digging up of old viruses, e.g. securing Arctic graves of Spanish Flu victims, or ancient viruses in the sea bed or icebergs, https://www.nature.com/articles/437794a https://www.nature.com/articles/437794a (2005) > It is thought to have killed 50 million people, and yet scientists have brought it back to life. In this issue of Nature, scientists publish an analysis of the full genome sequence of the 1918 human influenza virus … Some scientists have already hailed the work as giving unprecedented insight into the virus. Working out how it arose and why it was so deadly could help experts to spot the next pandemic strain and to design appropriate drugs and vaccines in time, they say. But others have raised concerns that the dangers of resurrecting the virus are just too great. One biosecurity expert told Nature that the risk that the recreated strain might escape is so high, it is almost a certainty. Photos: https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/reconstruction-1918-virus.html https://www.cdc.gov/flu/pandemic-resources/reconstruction-19... Only two years later, a version was created in a lab, https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/01/17/AR2007011701113.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/0... > "We know that the virus itself is different, and we know that the host response is different," said Yoshihiro Kawaoka, a virologist at the University of Wisconsin who headed the international research team. "The virus is really a bad actor," said Anthony S. Fauci, director of the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases. The virulence of the 1918 virus has always been a mystery. > ..The experiment was done in a Canadian biosafety Level 4 lab, where researchers work in the equivalent of space suits. Kawaoka's team does not have permission to experiment with the virus in the United States. In the new experiment, Darwyn Kobasa, a scientist in a Canadian government microbiology lab in Winnipeg, Manitoba, synthesized the 1918 virus from scratch and infected seven macaque monkeys with it. > ..The monkeys infected with the 1918 virus were so sick within eight days that they had to be euthanized. "Profuse watery and bloody liquid" filled 60 to 90 percent of the their lung tissue, "greatly reducing lung function," the researchers reported ... The animals infected with the 1918 virus produced less interferon, a type of cytokine that suppresses virus growth by limiting the microbe's ability to infect new cells. The virus continued to replicate and spread, reaching in one case 5,000 times the levels seen in the tissue of the monkeys infected with the modern virus. The ability to selectively limit interferon production is seen in other microbes, including respiratory syncytial virus, Ebola virus and parainfluenza virus, Fauci said. > In response to the virus's unchecked growth, the monkeys' immune systems produced large amounts of inflammatory substances aimed at killing it and the cells already infected. That ultimately did lethal damage to the lungs of the animals. That lethality was before Gain-of-Function research, which followed a few years thereafter :(
- gregwebs 5y agoTLDR for the paper: GoF is not necessarily the strongest candidate for this flu outbreak. However, all the candidates are man-made due to research efforts. To me this points out that every study on a pandemic-possible virus should have an extremely high bar to meet in terms of both safety and reason for performing the study in the first place. Effectively the only reason that is needed now to perform such research is that you want to publish a paper. The linked paper points out one possible source of the flu pandemic: vaccine development. This may have been a worthy enough cause but greater safeguards are needed. We should take the money we spend on GoF research and spend it on ensuring better safeguards for existing research. GoF research has an explicit goal is to make a virus more human transmissible: if it is too successful, you end up with the possibility of a pandemic. We now have a COVID pandemic that might have been caused by GoF research. On the flip side we can't show much benefit from this kind of research.
- indymike 5y ago> On the flip side we can't show much benefit from this kind of research. In many ways GoF seems to bee like a site reliability team's "dynamite monkey Friday" where they try to break things in staging in unpredictable ways... hoping whatever they do to our staging environment doesn't leak to production. Fortunately, our app is not likey to cause bodily harm to anyone and not likely to cause a pandemic.
- m0llusk 5y agoThe article notes that a lab leak or gain of function research or both are suspected because research with cultivated influenza strains was common at that time. In contrast, attempts by researchers at Wuhan to consistently cultivate coronavirus were unsuccessful. That is why they decided to work with chimeras instead of pursuing gain of function research. All of this focus on the point of origin is misplaced. We know that there will be new viruses. What matters is how we respond to them. In this case the US response was completely botched. This is in part because the team that had been in place to deal with emerging virus threats was disbanded and also in part because the CDC was forced to focus on making the president look good instead of dealing with the virus. What is ultimately being argued here is that instead of being prepared and responding reasonably all we have to do is control research and nothing like this will happen. Unfortunately, this is obviously false.
- TheBlight 5y agoDisagree that it's misplaced. If it was caused by a lab leak it's easier to address before it happens next time via a simple change in protocols for this type of research e.g. all GoF work is done in an isolated environment not in the middle of major population hub.
- halfmatthalfcat 5y agoThe means by which a virus appears is much less relevant than the response to the virus. We need a robust plan on dealing with viruses regardless of their origin. All this talk on trying to find the origin is missing the forest for the trees.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThis depends on the priors you assume for future events, e.g. if one ignores the GoF research and it therefore increases the likelihood of continued research, does that also increase risk of periodic outbreaks akin to this pandemic and a higher frequency than natural outbreaks from animal>human?
- 5y ago
- ImaCake 5y agoOP's link is fascinating. It is interesting to see that there is strong evidence for a lab leak leading to a pandemic at least once in the past. I think it is striking how clear cut the evidence for this is: a strain absent for 30 years suddenly reappears. Lab leak isn't the only possibility, but at least it makes the most sense here. I don't think we have the same evidence for COVID.
- tim333 5y agoIt's true it's pretty clear the 1977 virus had human involvement though I'd lean towards the vaccine trial explanation. Yeah the origins of covid seem up in the air at the moment.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoImagine we did have evidence one way or the other, half of people would believe it and the other half wouldn’t due to the stonewalling by various relevant institutions.
- 8bitsrule 5y agoThere are a lot of related-articles links on the Wikipedia page for this topic. [https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Russian_flu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1977_Russian_flu]
- ImaCake 5y agoIt looks like a lot of those references are the results of an edit war on the page. The consensus seems to be it was a lab leak (probably). You can read about alternative hypotheses on the talk page here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:1977_Russian_flu https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:1977_Russian_flu
- goolulusaurs 5y agoWhy the hell would you put a virology lab in the middle of a huge city with millions of people? I am not a virologist, but to me it seems like if covid was a lab-leak then it could have been avoided very easily just by having the lab in the middle of nowhere, like in the desert or the artic. Instead of the whole world having to go into lock down, with millions dying, just put the lab in a remote location, and make it so that before anyone leaves they have to quarantine for 2 weeks. This seems obvious, why isn't it standard protocol?
- indymike 5y ago> This seems obvious, why isn't it standard protocol? Would you take a job that had that requirement? Want a few days off? 2 week quarantine. Would investors be ok with this? Want to pay expensive PHD for vacation plus quarantine time (which could be days off x 10 working days every time). The problem is that the workers in the lab are just as human, have the same needs for relationships and contact, and some have enterprises outside of their day job. Want to speak at a conference? 2 week quarantine...
- goolulusaurs 5y agoSure that makes sense, but you could crank their pay way up to compensate, build places for their family to stay if they desired like the families of the scientist working on the Manhattan project, present at conferences through teleconferencing. There are scientist who stay in Antarctica for months and the international space station. Yes it would be inconvenient, but look at what (maybe) happens if you don't.
- indymike 5y ago> Sure that makes sense, but you could crank their pay way up to compensate, Some things aren't for sale. I'm not going to take a job that makes it impossible to see my family on short notice at any price.
- goolulusaurs 5y ago
- bob229 5y agoGain of function research is insane
- photochemsyn 5y agoVirology labs can play important roles in the eradication of infectious disease around the world, but they must be stringently and transparently regulated. They are needed because if we have a natural outbreak of an infectious novel virus, labs need to be able to rapidly isolate, identify and characterize (sequence) the virus. From there vaccines can be made, mode of transmission can be analyzed, etc. However, there's a huge risk - concentrating all these viruses in one place means accidents can result in infection of lab workers or other releases. There are many examples, such as the 1978 smallpox case in Birmingham: "It turned out that the building that Parker worked in also contained a research laboratory, one of a handful where smallpox was studied by scientists who were trying to contribute to the eradication effort. Some papers reported that the lab was badly mismanaged, with important precautions ignored because of haste. (The doctor who ran the lab died by suicide shortly after Parker was diagnosed.) Somehow, smallpox escaped the lab to infect an employee elsewhere in the building. Through sheer luck and a rapid response from health authorities, including a quarantine of more than 300 people, the deadly error didn’t turn into an outright pandemic." Vox Mar 2019 (pre-pandemic) As fas as Sars-CoV-2, it's very plausible that it accidentally escaped from the Wuhan lab, which housed bats and mice infected with a whole variety of bat coronaviruses and which had a very active coronavirus research program. The lack of governmental transparency in the early days also helped the virus spread, i.e. an early quarantine was possible but was not implemented. Probably the only real long-term fix will involve a lot more spending on public health infrastructure and vaccination globally. At present the virus is circulating in poorer communities around the world and new variants are likely to continue to be spawned as a result.