12 ms·
Yes. Ten years ago, Jeff Hammerbacher, an early Facebook employee, wrote: “The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads. Tha
by Animats 5y ago
Yes.
Ten years ago, Jeff Hammerbacher, an early Facebook employee, wrote: “The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads. That sucks.”
Look at the big names now. Google, which did most of its best work in the early days. Facebook, which is part of the problem, not part of the solution. Amazon, which has figured out how to exploit workers. Microsoft, which is still trying to sell Windows N+1. And the gig economy crowd, which has figured out how to pay below minimum wage and not pay benefits.
What don't we have?
- Really good battery companies. Tesla just packages Panasonic. GM just packages LG. They're not making batteries from raw materials.
- Progress in aircraft. Boeing is still flogging variants of the 737, which first flew in 1967.
- Semiconductors. Does anyone in the US still make commodity RAM?
- Electronics in general. There are few US sources left for small components.
- Telecom. The US no longer has anybody who makes telephone central office equipment. The US can no longer make smartphones.
- Power. The US does not make many large power transformers.
- Appliances. Few US manufacturers remain.
- Manufacturing engineering. Who gets a degree in manufacturing engineering today? Who knows how to lay out a production line?
- dluan 5y agoThe truth is that we're always in late stage capitalism, except for when we can creatively destroy something well enough to keep our minds off of that reality.
- postmeta 5y agoTesla has their own battery factories too, one is already live at Kato in California: https://spectrum.ieee.org/tesla-4680-battery https://spectrum.ieee.org/tesla-4680-battery Tesla is also working with Panasonic and CATL to implement their own factories for 4680 cells and scale production.
- rektide 5y agoeven within software, it feels.like their is so much room & space for new ideas, innovation & novelty. but the best minds are all paid to captivate attention for big systems, or manage various well established rent-seeking comluter offerings. it slays me that the engineers, the techies, have never had our day. we havent gotten good. we havent started new things, havent been augmenting & enhancing the world: we've been well paid to do the opposite, to capitvate & control & take technology, to dollop it out in little well managed productized offerings. the whole culture of innovation has dried up. i think of tech as still having so much prowess, skills, potential, and power, but wow, it is so squandered. it is so hard to break off on our own, to step away from the giant faucets of money & to start pursuing the radical, the good, the possible, the exciting. the potential. and what possibilities do arise, they seem so very quickly picked up, bought out, folded in to the mass corporatized system. comoetition & competency & novelty keep dying before they really get a chamce to bloom. it's the Thiel'ian advice to Facebook to sell, to take the money, get rich now, rather than keep working & trudging on, hoping.
- kcb 5y ago> Tesla just packages Panasonic. GM just packages LG. They're not making batteries from raw materials. That's not really true. Tesla and Panasonic jointly developed their cells. And the latest 4680 cells are fully designed by Tesla. Tesla also seems to be going independent for production at future factories.
- baybal2 5y ago> - Semiconductors. Does anyone in the US still make commodity RAM? Mikron Technology Inc
- ethbr0 5y ago> Who gets a degree in manufacturing engineering today? https://www.engineering.txstate.edu/Programs/MFGE.html https://www.engineering.txstate.edu/Programs/MFGE.html https://mime.oregonstate.edu/manufacturing-engineering-undergraduate-program https://mime.oregonstate.edu/manufacturing-engineering-under... Or anywhere that offers both an IE and ME degree, you could likely build your own.
- baybal2 5y agoYou will be surprised to see where you see American process, and manufacturing engineers today. We had not a few 6 year degreed engineers from USA working in China full time. Similarly in semiconductor manufacturing, quite a lot of US semiconductor process engineers were working in Taiwan, with its really low salaries, long before the TSMC made advances into the US market.
- pessimizer 5y agoThat's Where or How, not Who.
- ethbr0 5y agoTypically, degree programs don't exist without students. ;)
- nosianu 5y agoYes, and a lot of those come from abroad, especially in STEM fields, and China and India lead the list by a significant margin when looking at where they come from, and the largest share by field go to engineering: https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11347 https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/IF/IF11347 (PDF, 2019, so pre-Corona) Sure, that still leaves plenty of native US students.
- swlkr 5y agoMicron makes RAM in the US
- Frost1x 5y agoMushkin used to, but I suspect it stopped quite awhile back now browsing their website. It's apparently now owned by another company as of 2013. I used to exclusively purchase Mushkin memory for systems prior to transitioning to laptops where I rarely swapped memory out. Good to know there's at least something left at Micron.
- ModernMech 5y ago> “The best minds of my generation are thinking about how to make people click ads. That sucks.” I noticed this around the same time. It was 2010 and I was still in grad school, my lab mate and I used to poke fun of what we called the "Twitter researchers", who were working on what we perceived to be very boring projects (i.e. figure out the optimal ranking of N articles on a page to maximize some objective function). They also didn't like the research, but Twitter/Facebook/Microsoft/Google was paying for their tuition and stipend, so they didn't have much of a choice. When the big grant funding agencies are funding projects at a rate of around 20% - 25%, if you're a researcher hurting for federal dollars then that big tech money looks really good. I can only imagine this dynamic being replicated at universities across the country, how many young minds are wasted on this pursuit. And for what? So Google can sell more ads and become even richer? So Facebook can suck all of your attention just to make you depressed and suffer from body dysmorphia and an eating disorder? I'm in the robotics field, and in our lab we used to draw a clear line that whatever we worked on would not have a direct military application, because we couldn't stand the thought of our work being used to kill people. Obviously the line is blurry (will my localization algorithm be used on a predator drone?), but there was always at least an eye toward ethical considerations in our research group. We always asked ourselves "How could this be used to hurt people?" It was in our culture, because our work had such obvious evil implications. Just watch pretty much any sci-fi movie ever, there was no shortage of ideas about how robotics research could go wrong. But there's not a lot of sci-fi source material on how page-ranking algorithms can destroy society. These "Twitter researchers" as I called them never really had a notion that their work could be used for evil purposes, and who could blame them? In 2010 it seemed so benign. But looking around at the state of social media, maybe there should have been more conversations early on about the ethical implications of the research they were doing.
- Jesus_piece 5y agoAgreed completely. Crazy to see this endless iteration on ad optimization and maximizing screen time has made disinformation, polarization, and conspiracy so common. Really destroying society from the bottom up IMO
- 5y ago
- random314 5y agoWould you rather watch cabletv or YouTube? Would you rather fish out a map and look for directions or simply ask your car for navigation directions? Would a cancer researcher use his library card and read literature or simply Google it? Would you like to solve the protein folding problem? All of these have been paid for by advertisements.
- echelon 5y agoOutside of protein folding, each of these has been solved for 15+ years. And protein folding isn't exactly solved.
- random314 5y agoYouTube was solved 15 years ago?
- echelon 5y ago> February 14, 2005; 16 years ago https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YouTube https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/YouTube It had a lot of content back then. Work since has gone into scaling and transcoding, but much more work has gone into ads, platform stickiness, music rights management, abuse detection, etc. Not really solving problems at the forefront of humanity.
- goodpoint 5y agoThe following technologies have been researched between 1900 and 1990 almost entirely with *tax money*: Semiconductors, computing theory, GPS, GSM, satellites, airplanes, X-ray, optical cables, analog radio transmission and spread spectrum, industrial chemistry, solar power, nuclear power, vaccines, genetic research, and much more. Private companies putting together a search engine or uber or deliveroo are sitting on the shoulders of giants.
- simion314 5y ago>Would you like to solve the protein folding problem? Isn't Deep Mind a british company that Google bought it? Seems to me that most of the credit should go to UK society/education and just a bit to advertising industry.
- baybal2 5y ago> - Manufacturing engineering. Who gets a degree in manufacturing engineering today? Who knows how to lay out a production line? Apple, Amazon, Google, Facebook, all have engineering centres in China. When Zuckerberg was flying to suck up to Xi Jinping, he didn't fly there in hopes of getting Facebook.com available in China. What he got from Xi is a permission to setup an office to sell ads, and hire cheap Chinese engineers. Apple famously tried to conceal even the fact of the existence of their RnD office in China, claiming that they don't have "design centres" outside of USA. Up to some point, people working in Apple RnD centre in China had a contract clause prohibiting them from posting the fact of their employment there on their LinkedIns. Google... almost the same story as the two above, it almost felt as if they felt "beshamed" to admit that they were opening an RnD shop in Shenzhen. "A small auxiliary office" that takes a few floors in Shenzhen's biggest building. Amazon started their Echo, and Fire RnD in USA, and then sent it off to China after a few releases, and repeated flops of Fire.
- echelon 5y agoSo when does the US collapse for not knowing how to do anything anymore?
- Animats 5y agoAround 2030-2035, when China gets annoyed at the US over something and just stops shipping tools and componenets. Consumer goods shipments continue, but nothing that would allow the US to make anything.
- echelon 5y ago10-15 years to re-industrialize or shift to other countries. Not going to happen. Why doesn't the US try to onshore critical manufacturing? This is braindead stupid behavior. Existentially risky.
- runawaybottle 5y agoLabor costs are too high. Look, once you spend decades paying pennies on the dollar for labor, it’s very hard to go back. It’s the same when people discovered free music via p2p and YouTube. How do you dial that back? Nothing short of global war will fix this. Enter war with China where all trade is halted, and I promise you we’ll figure out how to on-shore manufacturing in a jiffy. A terrible price, but the only solution.
- zachguo 5y agoWell, SpaceX is in the U.S.
- coldtea 5y agoYeah, and who knows, soon might even manage to get to the moon, something we already did in 1969. But now better and cheaper (with tech made 50+ years after the last mission, it would a challenge not to do it better and cheaper - but is it half a century worth of better and cheaper? Considering the dreams then was a moon base and mission to mars coming in the next decades, something that never came to be).
- tbihl 5y agoThe space race was possibly the pinnacle of the principle that government spending can accelerate technological progress in particular fields by raining money on those fields. The progress puts it way ahead of what could be expected and occurs to the detriment of sectors from which the money was taken. We now have a good understanding of just how far ahead we pushed ourselves beyond what market forces were going to pursue: 50-60 years, which is pretty cool.
- nosianu 5y ago> The space race was possibly the pinnacle of the principle that government spending can accelerate technological progress in particular fields by raining money on those fields. Actually, that might be electronics and computers. The basis for Silicon Valley was created during WWII - by unrestrained debt-based government spending. https://youtu.be/ZTC_RxWN_xo https://youtu.be/ZTC_RxWN_xo -- "Secret History of Silicon Valley" Of course, maybe trying to rank the developments by industry or sector makes no sense, sooo much was influenced by what happened in that period. Agriculture too, if what I read and remember correctly a lot of WWII chemical industry was reused for things like fertilizer, but I don't have a good (i.e. direct and good quality scientific study instead of some blog post or pop book) source for that. I dislike this separation of "government" vs. "business". I remember an MIT biology course (genetics) where the professor explained Gregor Mendel (the guy with the beans) a bit more - his circumstances. That man wasn't some random person who purely by chance happened to be interested in biology and inheritance. Turns out he was part of a far wider effort of church, state and industry to produce economic progress. Historically, even looking at how England became a world power, there never was such a separation. Government always acted as an extension of economic interests in combination with the merchants, later with the capitalists.
- c54 5y agoI agree with your point, and it makes me really sad. Let me try to make some optimistic spins? - Intel is hopefully turning their foundry business around. I think this will be a slow (1-2 decades?) process but will pay results. - Tesla and SpaceX are actually really positive spins, though I agree Tesla isn't completely isolated from the rest of the eletronics world. It's what we've got and it's not half bad. SpaceX in particular I is world-class at this point and hopefully will continue to get better - Toyota makes more cars in the US than not. Worst case, these are still functioning production lines staffed by good workers, that talent and working knowledge (hopefully) doesn't just disappear - A lot of your examples are lower down the value chain, for instance Intel doesn't produce commodity RAM since they famously got out of that game in the 80s(?) to focus on the higher margin CPU business. Maybe this is good? Ultimately though, I agree that working in ads or finance is largely flat or negative sum to society (as someone who has or is in both). It's worse than that, too. People actively look down on manufacturing, as somehow less exciting and less complex than finance.
- baybal2 5y agoUSA sells quite a lot of cars to China, out of all places... But these are not American cars, these are German cars made in America. Americans I meet are always surprised when they see how close are manufacturing jobs salaries in China, and US.
- dragonelite 5y agoI was surprised when I discovered that the VW group sells like half of their inventory in China and ASEAN region.
- HPsquared 5y agoIf they're German cars made in America, what about all the American goods made in China?
- pm90 5y agoThat’s a little naive. No political entity in history has been able to reverse economic decline by looking at what it did best in an earlier age and try to do that again. There are other countries that are simply better than the US at doing certain things. I don’t understand why Americans can’t just accept that. Embrace the things we’re really good at, work with others to get from them the things they’re good at.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jauer 5y ago> - Telecom. The US no longer has anybody who makes telephone central office equipment. The US can no longer make smartphones. Adtran (Huntsville, AL & just acquired ADVA), Infinera (fab in Sunnyvale, CA). Both make optical transport systems. Adtran also makes access network systems (POTS, DSL, PON, Ethernet). Adtran has (or had) some manufacturing capability in Alabama.
- bobthepanda 5y agoWith planes the 737 upgrading is a feature, not a bug. It is extremely costly to develop a new airplane and to train staff on it, at the price point and fuel efficiency for airlines to sell ever cheaper tickets. Airbus is doing the exact same with its neo models. Bombardier and Embraer were driven into the arms of the duopoly because they cannot afford to develop new aircraft. Russia, China, and Japan have all tried their hand at pumping billions of dollars into commercial aircraft manufacturing and haven’t been successful.
- jessaustin 5y agoWhile this is plausible for aircraft in general, in the case of the 737 Max it clearly isn't true. Boeing would have been better off not killing hundreds of passengers and losing $20B.
- bobthepanda 5y agoThe 787 cost $32B to develop. So the jury might actually be out on whether a new clean-sheet aircraft would've been more disastrous, given that its rollout was not very smooth either. I am just saying that the economic incentives are not aligned so that a decision other than the 737MAX would've been the prudent, competitive move.
- selfhoster11 5y agoYes, but come on. 1967. We surely have made a lot of progress since then. 50 years of holding back is a bit much. Are we going to still hear "but retraining is soooooo difficult" in 2067?
- gruez 5y agomaybe we reached peak aircraft? After all, we don't complain that we're using a knife design from a few hundred years ago.
- bobthepanda 5y agoretraining isn't difficult but retraining is expensive. Southwest, Ryanair and their competition are literally nickel and diming everything to offer ever cheaper seats to fliers. Until that changes, airlines will balk at new aircraft. It's why 737Max was developed instead of NMA; Airbus came out with the 320 and 330neo series, which did not require retraining.
- bobbytit 5y agoThis has been a deliberate destruction of a once great nation since the moment Kissinger sold the US out to Chairman Mao. The world is now China's bitch but just have woken up to it.
- mschuster91 5y ago> This has been a deliberate destruction of a once great nation since the moment Kissinger sold the US out to Chairman Mao. Nope. What has been going on over the last decades is simply the consequence of unregulated capitalism - by design, capitalism seeks to eliminate or reduce cost to increase profit, and China (as well as India and Vietnam) were/are the most cost-efficient locations to produce goods and provide services.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThe need for people to have a villain in their stories always disturbed me. I guess it gives people a semblance of control if they “know” something, rather than acknowledging the innumerable causal factors intertwining with each other to create an unknowable future and unattributable past. I am sure Kissinger played a part in many things, but he seems small pickles compared to labor costs (and hence quality of life) in the US being multiple standard deviations above the mean compared to the rest of the world. How long did people expect that arbitrage opportunity to not be taken advantage of?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoThe only reason that this could be taken advantage of in any real sense, was the removal of capital controls, which was very much a political choice. Also, adding China to the WTO was probably a bad thing for the lower half of the income distribution in the developed world.
- 5y ago
- renewiltord 5y agoDon't have semiconductors? News to me. I bet if you studied CS and you know any electronics engineers (who should be not too far from your department) they'll know wafer fabs in the US. I haven't been in uni for ages and I know like three fabs in Colorado where I don't even live. In fact, there are like famous semiconductor companies that make their stuff in the US. Makes me suspect the rest of the list as similar doomsaying.
- mschuster91 5y ago> The US no longer has anybody who makes telephone central office equipment. You don't need that kind of equipment any more since the advent of VoIP and software-defined radio/networking. > The US can no longer make smartphones. Apple is US-based as is the world's leading provider of mobile communication chips Qualcomm (and for what it's worth I seriously believe Apple is going to go vertical on that part too!), and with Google you have a second US-based vendor of operating systems. Or are you referring to the capability of produce all components of a smartphone on US soils?
- bsenftner 5y agoLong before we were born, our parents and their parents sold us out. This is just the lingering remnants, the propaganda for what was never accomplished, America only produces the carrot as a lure for a nation of endless corruptions.
- nemo44x 5y agoI’d say open source software and business models around it. Being a developer today and starting a company is so much more dynamic and accessible today than 20 years ago. I’d also say the creative works has seen a massive revolution from technology. Anyone can make professional video/audio/graphics today and distribute it.
- jmeister 5y agoImagine reducing Amazon to “exploits workers”. For starters, what about all the startups powered by AWS? Amazon lets my programmer cousins in India buy the latest technical books in days, while my generation used to torrent and print 15-20 years ago.
- fourtrees 5y agoI'd disagree with aircraft. The modern 737, the NG or the MAX, is a world apart from the plane that first flew in '67. Almost everything except for the seating configuration has been upgraded or changed on the plane. The type-rating laws also provides Boeing with an incentive to keep the plane just similar enough that a crew can transfer from one class to another without too much training. It's also not Boeing's fault that there's a huge international market for a plane of that size and range. Boeing does have its faults though.
- AdrianB1 5y agoTrimmers auctioned by wires and pulleys, requiring more brute force than a fit male pilot, that is not modern by any standards, it is backward compatibility for profits.