12 ms·
Maybe lithium-ion batteries in mass-market vehicles aren't such a good idea. We may need a battery technology that can survive poor maintenance less than perfec
by Animats 5y ago
Maybe lithium-ion batteries in mass-market vehicles aren't such a good idea. We may need a battery technology that can survive poor maintenance less than perfect battery construction, and low-cost vehicle designs. Tesla had to put a titanium plate under their battery. That's not a mass-market solution.
BYD is converting over to lithium iron phosphate, which is much better behaved when damaged. Toyota is working on solid state batteries, which hopefully don't catch fire.
The NYFD reports over 55 electric bike and scooter fires so far this year.[1] Two deaths, 60 injuries, including 18 firefighters. Fires destroying electric bike shops are a thing, with one fire expanding to all the batteries around. All we need now is for a cascade auto battery fire in a parking lot. Or, worst case, a garage under a building.
Boosted skateboards used to use lithium iron phosphate, but were just too expensive.
[1] https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/ny-e-bike-scooter-fires-fatalities-fdny-20210813-otyebxidsne2vltv446y4ir62u-story.html https://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/nyc-crime/ny-e-bike-sco...
- weaksauce 5y agomight want to put it into context though... there are on average 160,000 passenger car fires per year and about 360 deaths due to that. i'd like to see that figure broken down per 100k miles driven or per 100k cars of the type but i can't seem to find that easily. https://www.nfpa.org/vehiclefires https://www.nfpa.org/vehiclefires
- bubbleRefuge 5y agoHow many of those are with the car off and at rest ?
- OJFord 5y agoIs that actually relevant though, or just an implementation detail? Perhaps you could argue a moving car seems more potentially hazardous? But then that's only learned from extant behaviour anyway?
- sbierwagen 5y agoA car being driven is guaranteed to have a person behind the wheel. (For now...) A electric car in an attached garage spontaneously bursting into flame at 2 am is a recipe for burning a house to the ground.
- tialaramex 5y agoIn the former case there's definitely a person inside the thing that's on fire, and in the latter case there almost definitely isn't a person inside the thing (I guess once in a while somebody sleeps in their car but this isn't recommended) and that seems like a much safer situation. Houses are replaceable, that's why people have insurance.
- fomine3 5y agoHumans are replaceable, that's why people have insurance. Just kidding.
- inside65 5y agoHow is it safer for a car to catch fire in your garage while you're asleep? This is clearly the more dangerous situation.
- tialaramex 5y agoSafer than being in a car which is on fire. That's what we're comparing here.
- inside65 5y agoI still dont understand how that is safer. If the car is on fire, you can get out. I have been to many car fires when I volunteered with the FD and unless it's a wreck with entrapment, there's never any injury. In comparison, there are plenty of deaths from fires starting while people are sleeping.
- 5y ago
- api 5y agoI would much rather my car catch on fire when I am not in it. Well I’d really prefer it not catch on fire at all but you get the idea…
- rootusrootus 5y agoThere have been a couple of big recalls in the not-to-distant past for ICE vehicles spontaneously combusting. They have electric components too, which can short out and start a fire.
- wombatpm 5y agoSaturn had a recall over generator fires when the car was off. When running the generator would over heat, when the car was off the residual heat would cause a fire since there was no cooling airflow. My sister had her Chrysler LeBarron go up in flames in her parking garage. Happens more often than you think
- ineedasername 5y agoYes, but an important part of that context is that electric car fires also burn longer and hotter and take significantly more effort to put out. Too little water can actually make the fire worse. Annecdotally, my recollection from other articles is that electric cars do in fact catch on fire less often. But it also seems like they may be more difficult to deal with. This may change as EV's become more mainstream & fire departments adapt: Graphite may be effective in putting out these fires, and maybe it will become a common tool in fire departments. For the time being, rare or not, they post a much larger problem to deal with when they do occur.
- Voloskaya 5y ago> For the time being, rare or not, they post a much larger problem to deal with when they do occur. It seems to me that being harder to put off but occurring less frequently, and most importantly not exploding (leaving significant amount of time for occupants to get out, if they are able) is a pretty good trade off.
- ineedasername 5y agoIt could be a good trade off, it depends on more details though. Do electric car fires flame up faster, giving passengers less time to exit the car? What about toxic fumes emanating from the burning batteries? Since they they burn hotter and for much longer, are they more likely to damage surrounding infrastructure, like a bridge, before being extinguished? I don't know the answer to these questions. They could all be "no". But before judging the trade off those are important factors to understand.
- JshWright 5y agoLithium batteries are far more explodey than modern gas tanks. Battery fires burn much hotter and faster than "regular" vehicle fires (which are generally just the contents of the vehicle burning, not the fuel).
- ineedasername 5y agoAlso a gasoline car actually exploding is exceedingly rare. It generally takes a bit of effort to get gasoline to explode, rather than simply catch on fire. The tiny explosions that occur in the engine are only possibly due to gasoline being aerosolized into a fine mist. Take a gas can with a soaked rag & trail of gasoline leading to it & set it on fire and you'll have quite a fire on your hands, but no explosion. Now, add a tiny bit a black powder to the equation to disperse the flaming gasoline into the air and you've got a small fuel-air bomb on your hands. But that-- or similarly explosive circumstances-- just don't happen with cars much at all. Pop culture, where a few guns shots result in an explosion, gives the wrong impression here.
- mcguire 5y agohttps://www.nfpa.org/-/media/Files/News-and-Research/Fire-statistics-and-reports/US-Fire-Problem/osvehiclefires.pdf https://www.nfpa.org/-/media/Files/News-and-Research/Fire-st... 56 vehicle fires / billion miles driven. 15 vehicle fire deaths / hundred billion miles driven.
- dangs_dingdong 5y agoThen go break it down and tell us what you find, big guy.
- gameswithgo 5y agoThe risk of lithium ion fire is very obvious and real. But to decide if this is a problem relative to the current alternatives (gasoline) we would need to compare the rates and severity of fires between the two. Gasoline cars also have complicated parts to help mitigate their fire risk.
- philwelch 5y agoI’ve never heard of a gas tank spontaneously bursting into flames.
- eloff 5y agoThere are about 160,000 fires involving personal internal combustion engine vehicles per year.
- ineedasername 5y agoI think the key word there was "spontaneous", along with the relative danger and difficulty of dealing with them. An EV fire can take 24 hours to secure. A gasoline car takes about 300 gallons of water. I'm not saying EV fires are a bigger issue than gasoline cars. I'm saying that you cannot look merely at incident rate to determine the issue.
- adamredwoods 5y agoCATL sodium batteries, maybe in 2023: https://qz.com/2041051/chinas-catl-unveils-sodium-ion-battery-to-diversify-from-lithium/ https://qz.com/2041051/chinas-catl-unveils-sodium-ion-batter...
- wffurr 5y agoSodium reacts explosively with water.
- ceejayoz 5y agoPure sodium, sure. You're full of sodium, though, and you don't explode.
- fy20 5y agoAs a kid I remember watching a documentary on spontaneous human combustion. That gave me nightmares for weeks...
- jlawer 5y agoSo does pure lithium
- wffurr 5y agoWhich is exactly why I am wondering how sodium batteries will be any easier to manage.
- ceejayoz 5y agohttps://spectrum.ieee.org/sodium-ion-battery https://spectrum.ieee.org/sodium-ion-battery > Sodium batteries are also more stable and safe than lithium-ion. They have a wider temperature range, are nonflammable, and there is no thermal runaway—which can cause lithium-ion batteries to catch fire—under any condition, says Pouchet.
- api 5y agoGasoline fires happen all the time. They just don’t get press. No method of packing enough energy in a car for hundreds of miles of range is going to be perfectly safe. Stored energy is stored energy and any material with that much really wants to party. It does seem that the Bolt has an issue. I’m glad I opted for the 62kWh Leaf for an affordable EV and so far I think there has only ever been one Leaf fire. It happened years ago and they have been on the market about the longest. The Bolt has slightly more range but I looked at both and liked the Leaf more. This was before I heard about fires.
- rootusrootus 5y ago> The Bolt has slightly more range but overall the Leaf is better. I'm curious how you determined this? Everything I've seen suggests the Bolt is better in most ways, and overall. Excluding the current minor risk of fire, of course.
- avernon 5y agoThe problem here is the form factor of the cell as much as the chemistry. Pouch style cells are very difficult to regulate temperature in. This is a key reason why other automakers like Tesla use the small cylinder cells. Chinese companies like BYD have always used lithium iron phosphate. It has less energy density than lithium nickel batteries like NCA and NMC, but is cheaper. The patent was never taken out in China and the key patent expires for the rest of the world in April 2022. As much as 3/4 of vehicle batteries might end up being LFP. Improvements in the chemistry and less need for cooling systems and packaging mean its disadvantages aren't so glaring. Plus there aren't enough nickel mines to supply the coming avalanche of demand. Lithium, iron, and phosphate are plentiful.
- beamatronic 5y agoIf batteries are easily swappable with minimal tools, then a lot of range concerns go away as well. I think battery ownership and care needs to be decoupled from the vehicle. I also think the federal government should enforce interoperable batteries between vehicle brands.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoThey are too heavy to swap them by hand
- beamatronic 5y agoTesla actually had a battery swapping machine at one point, I think it was at the Kettleman City location. There's no reason the battery and charging infrastructure can't be leveraged for all passenger vehicles. The battery on your electric vehicle should be like the propane tank on your gas grill - just swap it out when you need to. (This doesn't preclude recharging it) Not to mention, when the battery reaches the end of its normal life cycle. Just goes straight into the recycling pipeline.
- clouddrover 5y agoNio's cars support battery swaps: https://electrek.co/2021/07/09/nio-plan-open-battery-swap-stations-to-other-electric-automakers/ https://electrek.co/2021/07/09/nio-plan-open-battery-swap-st... You can rent the batteries and upgrade and downgrade the capacity as you like. It also makes it easy to replace the battery in the future if you buy it outright. They offer 70 and 100 kWh packs now. They're aiming for 150 kWh packs next year: https://insideevs.com/news/465188/nio-150-kwh-solid-state-batteries-2022/ https://insideevs.com/news/465188/nio-150-kwh-solid-state-ba...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brightball 5y agoWe need to hurry up with Graphene Aluminum batteries
- alex_young 5y agoTesla is shipping LFP batteries in it’s new cars.
- pavon 5y agoI was about to correct you that it was only for cars in China, but it looks like my information was out of date. An article for others who hadn't heard: https://insideevs.com/news/529228/tesla-model3-lfp-battery-option/ https://insideevs.com/news/529228/tesla-model3-lfp-battery-o...
- Robotbeat 5y agoTesla already uses lithium iron phosphate for some Model 3s as it's cheaper (not more expensive like you claim). And Tesla has basically already solved the fire problem through careful engineering, and other carmakers will figure this out as well. But also, car fires happen all the time. They're just normal and so don't get to the news. My grandfather died in a gasoline fire (which can happen a lot faster).
- FartyMcFarter 5y ago> And Tesla has basically already solved the fire problem Have they? So why did a Tesla Model S Plaid (a new car) catch fire while being driven just a few months ago? https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2021/7/2/22560662/tesla-model-s-plaid-fire-driver-battery-pennsylvania https://www.theverge.com/platform/amp/2021/7/2/22560662/tesl...
- codeulike 5y agoThere are 1.5 million Tesla cars out there on the road. Most of them, nearly all of them really, are not on fire.
- FartyMcFarter 5y agoI understand that. But if I tell someone at work that I "solved the XYZ problem", I mean that XYZ doesn't happen any more. If there's a claim that Tesla has "solved the fire problem", I would hope there's a good explanation for why fires still happen with the newest model delivered 3 months ago.
- sli 5y agoNot to imply I know what I'm talking about, but I really wish we could find some way to create carbon-based batteries (graphene or something) so we could develop a carbon capture -> battery process. That would be pretty damn cool.
- Tagbert 5y agoThis was a manufacturing failure of a particular battery design. Other pouch batteries with a different design built by LG have not had problems.
- martin_a 5y ago> Fires destroying electric bike shops are a thing, with one fire expanding to all the batteries around. All we need now is for a cascade auto battery fire in a parking lot. Or, worst case, a garage under a building. As a firefighter let me add some context: Electric car fires are no big deal anymore. Yes, they're not "out" when there's no more flames or smoke for the moment as the damaged cells might be reacting further and further. Easy solution: Put them in a tub full of water for at least 24 hours, better monitor the temperatures of the water and only lift them out once it has not changed for a few hours. Most fire departments nowadays have some kind of container that can be filled where you can lift the car into. If not, they'll call somebody who has such a container, like landfills and alike. Yes, the car is done after that, but it wouldn't be different with a gas-powered car either. This might have been new five years ago, but so were solar panels 20 years ago and everybody was worried that nobody could ever extinguish a fire under solar panels. Real life has shown, that you just rip the panels of the roof (if they're not already burned when we arrive) and work as if nothing has happened (simplified, but not too far away). With eletric cars you sink them. Easy as that. "Improvise. Adapt. Overcome." it is. Also: garage fires are special in itself due to the lack of head room and "place to go" for heat, smoke and fire. It's not really a big difference after that. Basic rules of engagement are to be followed: Get the fire out and then the cars out of the garage. WIth electric cars you'll have to sink them once they are out of the garage, obviously. Please stop fearmongering with "electric car fires".
- mschuster91 5y agoThey do require a lot more water to be put out though. > "Improvise. Adapt. Overcome." it is. And here is the problem: most fire departments are horribly underfunded, meaning their machines are old, water tankers don't have enough capacity, water lines are un(der)maintained and the firefighter training has been ... spotty to put it lightly.
- martin_a 5y agoDon't know where you're from, but for Germany this is mostly solved, but those tactics are obviously still "new" for most and need to be refined, yes. edit: > They do require a lot more water to be put out though. As OP was mentioning garage fires, I was expecting urban neighborhoods, where getting enough water should (hopefully) not be a problem in 2021.
- codeulike 5y agoThat's not a mass-market solution Tesla have sold well over 1.5 million cars at this point
- cptskippy 5y agoTesla is using Lithium Iron Phosphate in Model 3s and Ys manufactured in China. It's giving buyers of the SR+ in North America the option of the LFP version if they want faster delivery. The downside of LFP is lower energy density which means an LFP Model 3 has a slightly reduced range compared to the Lithium Ion version. The upside is the LFP likes to be charged to 100% where as Lithium Ion prefers 90% charges.