8 ms·
Common cold combats Covid-19
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- MontagFTB 5y agoDespite my deep desire to see modern medicine win out in this war against Covid, I find myself becoming increasingly blasé about these kinds of articles. Regardless of their supposed authority or the site/journal they’re from, subsequent headlines often disprove them. Case in point: there is a raging disagreement about booster shots in the news over the past several weeks, and the conflicting statements drive me to news-weariness.
- dmitrij 5y agoYou are talking about two different topics. The first case: this story is not an article. It's a press release, and I wish we would stop treating these like "scientific publications". The second case: there is a real debate going on, on a global level: should we use vaccines for booster vaccinations, or shouldn't we first vaccinate the whole world to get control of the pandemic. This is not only a question of medicine, this is also global politics, the rich North versus the not so rich rest of the world, patents and corporations versus saving lifes – debate is inevitable.
- goinfar 5y agoInoculate the whole world against a coronavirus.. preposterous. Aren't the current EUA shots for targeting the initial alpha strain?
- swader999 5y agoYes, it's impossible to produce, distribute and vaccinate eight billion people for a virus that mutates every few months and one that can persist in animal reservoirs.
- psychometry 5y agoWhen a virus "mutates" it doesn't replace its entire genetic code. A vaccine might work just as well against a new variant if the mutations are in an irrelevant area (e.g. outside the sequence that codes for the spike protein).
- swader999 5y agoYes it might and it's not all or nothing either. Just like natural immunity can lessen the degree of future mutated infections, vaccine shots can too. The corona's spike protein though is a simple structure that will likely still infect (be able to get inside a cell) after many kinds of mutations - some of which won't be mitigated with previous vaccinations (mu is leaning this way). Contrast this with polio which has a Tetris like key that must link up with complex cellular proteins in our cells to enter. Slight mutations in this render it unable to pass through the cell wall. It's why vaccinating for this is so effective and long lived.
- skyde 5y agothe real question is : Am I less likely to be hospitalized when getting delta strain if I am vaccinated for alpha strain
- swader999 5y agoYes I think this has enough data to support less severity of illness with Delta. And because you are still able to be socially functional with the reduced severity, on average, you'll be out and about spreading it and keeping it alive and changing. This will be an issue when your vaccine immunity wanes and perhaps they don't dial in the next version of the booster to match or get it to you in time It also depends how many months have elapsed since your last shot, more than five and it seems to be waning in Israel. With, mu early indications seem to point towards it not working to reduce severity.
- soundnote 5y agoYes, whatever other issues people have with vaccines or especially the politics around them, vaccines do reduce the chance of serious disease. They seem to be less effective than resistance gained through infection, but do protect against delta.
- MontagFTB 5y agoWell, yes and no. While they are different topics, both are trying to present facts to back up their viewpoint. Is it a _fact_ that a rhinovirus infection helps fight Covid? Is it a _fact_ that booster shots are necessary, or is the current vaccine regimen sufficient? The facts seem to be changing in headlines faster than I can recall.
- skyde 5y agoWhat you are calling fact is interpretation on statistic. But the statistics themself are fact. ex: number of case and hospitalization for vaccinated people vs unvaccinated people. So when you look at box ploy or histogram those are the facts. The fact don’t change every week only the interpretation. The only fact that we can say is really changing is the R0 value of the virus but this is expected because it change over time because of our actions! It’s more like the current price of a company stock on the NeeYork stock exchange will change every week. It change when we get new data about that company and reinterpret how much it”s worth
- lurquer 5y ago> But the statistics themself are fact. ex: number of case and hospitalization for vaccinated people vs unvaccinated people. I wish that as so. The ‘factual’ statistics can be stretched however one wishes. For example, what does it mean to be vaccinated? Or, for that matter, what does it mean to ‘hospitalized’? Does it mean Covid symptoms necessitated hospitalization? Or, perhaps, everyone in the hospital who tested positive? Does it include ‘recovered’ patients who, for unrelated reasons, are still in the hospital, albeit no longer in a Covid ward? Etc. The statistics for this entire fiasco have been garbage. I wish it were not so. They certainly aren’t ‘facts’ as you suggest.
- IMTDb 5y ago> Is it a _fact_ that booster shots are necessary, or is the current vaccine regimen sufficient? The issue is that the words "necessary" and "sufficient" are left to the reader, and are deeply political. Some people will argue that we must do every possible thing in our power to save every possible life, so even a 0.01% of increased protection would be enough to make booster shots "necessary" and the current regiment "insufficient". Some other will accept loss of life, and will even call vaccine shots "unnecessary" since the vast majority of the population - especially the non fragile part - doesn't seem to suffer from covid. In their mind, our our natural immunity itself is "sufficient". Most people arguing on this subject are actually not arguing over scientific arguments, but are arguing over their own position between those two extremes. And they throw in some numbers / quote experts to sound more scientific than they really are in the vain hope to convince the other part that they are somehow more "right".
- RobertRoberts 5y agoThird case: Natural immunity needs to be required part of the discussion on any/all pandemic planning.
- nradov 5y agoThis is yet more evidence that living in overly sterile environments isn't good for overall health. We have a bad tendency to focus on specific narrow health goals while missing the big picture.
- SketchySeaBeast 5y agoI'm not sure how this information improves the fight against COVID. Is the argument that everyone should be constantly sick with a cold instead? How many people have a cold at any one time, and what are the odds those same people would be infected with COVID? There's also no mention of whether that would give lasting COVID immunity, or if it would just swing around for when the person isn't actively sick. I don't know if the Mr Burns method of fighting COVID is a particularly great idea.
- nradov 5y agoMy comment was about overall health, not specifically about COVID-19. There is more to health than fighting one specific virus.
- dilap 5y agoI don't think it does anything to help in the fight against COVID, but it does highlight potential unanticipated adverse effects of COVID mitigation measures -- e.g., what's going to be the impact on the immune systems of kids that end up being "socially-distanced" for N years?
- nkozyra 5y ago> what's going to be the impact on the immune systems of kids that end up being "socially-distanced" for N years? Do you have kids? They're ... pretty good at getting germs, masks/social distancing or not. When they get exposed to a pathogen is largely luck anyway. Nobody's in a sterile environment here. These kids are touching/licking stuff, picking noses, rubbing eyes, you name it.
- 5y ago
- tobr 5y agoThat’s gotta be one of the most useless science illustration I’ve seen. Surely they intended to also show the rhinoviruses in the right image, but never got around to it?
- tclancy 5y agoThe modern equivalent of the comic book ad for an anti-zit popper: it clearly works because the second drawing of the kid has fewer dots!
- fasteddie31003 5y agoThis was suspected early on in the pandemic. Before the vaccine was FDA approved I publicly wondered if we could just give people one of these "colds" that protects against COVID-19. My doctor friends said that would never pass any ethics board. I also suspect there would not be a good way for pharmaceutical companies to make any money on this more natural approach. Today the future looks like a carousel ride of booster shots and people are wearing masks again. My person approach, which would never be endorsed by public health officials, is to be fully vaccinated, not wear a mask and be in close proximity to people in the hope to get a breakthrough case of COVID-19. I want a mild case to build natural immunity, which studies show provides better immunity than vaccines, and get off a booster shot carousel and put COVID-19 behind me.
- dhimes 5y agoThat was my hope too- unfortunately I don't live alone so can't go out and do it. And it probably is smarter to do what we can to avoid it as we still don't really understand the long-term effects of this nasty virus, just that it can have some bad ones for some people.
- hannob 5y agoWhat you're proposing is pretty much how the first vaccine was invented. (Jenner gave people cow pocks because that created immunity against the much more severe small pocks.) That was great at the time, but today's vaccines are just a much better and more targetted way of creating immunity.
- bodyfour 5y agoThe big problem with any deliberate-inoculation strategy: dosage. In the vaccination you received, there was a controlled dosage of the active ingredient. This had been tested in thousands of people and is known to give a certain amount of immune response and an acceptable amount of side effects. When you get have contact with someone who is infectious there is a huge variation in how much viral load they might have and how much they shed. So the first person you mean might only "gift" you a tiny dose that doesn't improve your post-vaccination immunity much at all. The next day you might meet a super contagious person, get basically drenched in viral particles, and then have a breakthrough case that makes you sick for weeks. It's the sort of "clever hack" that probably sounds appealing to a lot of software engineers but is a terrible public health plan.
- joelbondurant 5y agoDiaper Face Alert, Diaper Face Alert, pray to the official religion of communist Science. This bad science must be censored before the USA Fact-Check Algorithm ordains the official narrative of the holy order of Diaper Face Communists.
- coding123 5y agoThis was already announced about a year ago. I love how idiotic the echo chamber is.- Sorry Dang.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dang 5y agoWould you please stop breaking the site guidelines? https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- dr_dshiv 5y agoThis is a great approach to the unvaccinated. I guarantee many of them would be willing to get a "natural" cold rather than the vaccine.
- cblconfederate 5y agogonna be very hard due to restrictions and general distancing