8 ms·
The worst thing about this is that someone was asked to implement this, and instead of saying ‘fuck no’. They went ahead and did it anyway. There’s a few hills
by Aeolun 5y ago
The worst thing about this is that someone was asked to implement this, and instead of saying ‘fuck no’. They went ahead and did it anyway.
There’s a few hills worth dying on and I feel this is one of them. It is just unambiguously evil.
- grishka 5y agoIf you tell them you aren't doing it, they'll fire you and find someone who will. It'll end up existing either way.
- Engineering-MD 5y agoThis argument can justify anything on that basis, from fraud to murder or slavery. By withdrawing your services to do it, you reduce supply, increasing prices and providing a financial penalty for trying to enact it.
- hdjjhhvvhga 5y agoAm I the only one seeing the irony of it? You are asking the guy who already added a ton of JavaScript junk to the website to have concerns about one delay function?
- grishka 5y agoThere's plenty of people who would do whatever they're told, regardless of their own principles, as long as they're paid for it. I'm not one of them, sure, but as long as there's just ONE person like this, we can't have nice things in the long run.
- inetknght 5y ago> This argument can justify anything on that basis, from fraud to murder or slavery. Interestingly there are laws and whistleblower protections against murder and slavery.
- moron4hire 5y agoAnother poster mentioned H1B visa holders, and I'm sure that is a valid concern there, given how poorly H1B holders are treated. But as a citizen, I've heard this many times, been told it to my face during sit downs with my boss while refusing to do something shady, and it has never happened. On two occasions, the threat was idle. On two more, I quit and they never did find anyone to replace me. But regardless, even if it were true, you still need to protect your own soul. Better to let someone else corrupt themselves.
- Aeolun 5y agoExactly! But what if everyone had a concience and said no? Would they fire all their developers? Anyway, they wouldn’t fire you since just finding someone else to do it is easier than starting any HR process. That’s pretty sad by itself.
- criddell 5y agoIt's one reason that software engineering should become a real Engineering profession and not just a title. If your employer asks you do something unethical, it would give you grounds for pushing back. Who would risk losing their license to practice because of a deceptive cookie notice?
- watertom 5y agoI don’t understand why you are shocked. Ethics should follow the same standard normal distribution model as everything else. Which means that 50% of the population has less than average ethics.
- staticman2 5y agoNot everything follows a standard distribution model. In fact, since some psychological tests are designed to return a standard distribution result, if the traits do not occur in the population along a standard distribution, the psychological tests are designed in a way which will give inaccurate results.
- fumeux_fume 5y agoDespite being called normal, not as much as you would think follows a normal distributon. But if your main point is that there is some mean value of ethicalness and 50% fall above and below that value then I suppose there's not much to argue about there.
- topaz0 5y ago*median. It is commonplace for more or less than 50% to fall below the mean.
- torstenvl 5y agoIt's also common for more or less than 50% to fall below the median. The average M&M fun size package has 15 M&Ms (mode, median=15; mean=15.02). Only 25.6% have fewer than that. As fumeux_fume stated earlier, not everything follows a normal distribution. Since morality is socially mediated, I think it's reasonable to hypothesize it would tend to be N-modal.
- amelius 5y agoWe need an 11th commandment: Thou shalt not apply dark patterns!
- aaomidi 5y agoIf you're an h1b worker you literally don't have a choice. You obey or get yourself and your family kicked out of the country.
- enriquto 5y agoLand of the free, they say!
- Veen 5y agoSo you literally do have a choice. There’s just a consequence (There are worse things than not living in America, hard as that might be for you to imagine.)
- aaomidi 5y agoYou're going to say no to writing a timeout code and risk your entire family going back to your country? What if you have kids who were born here? You're now going to take them back to a place they don't know? Or are you going to let them go to foster care here? How about if you've bought a house here? You're going to have just a few months to settle everything before you can go.
- Veen 5y agoWhy would anyone contemplate leaving their children behind in foster care? That seems an absurdly hyperbolic suggestion. People move countries for work and take their children with them all the time. I mean, if the country was Syria and you literally risk death, then I could understand, but people in that situation are refugees, not on work visas. Perhaps I’m finding this hard to understand since I have no desire to live in the US whatsoever and have turned down several offers from companies that wanted me to move there. Nice place to visit, but I can think of dozens of places I would rather live.
- otterley 5y agoWhat country are you based in? Have you ever lived in a country with extreme poverty or an oppressive government?
- hcykb 5y agoEthics? FFS it's just the stupid Starbucks website... If you don't like the delay then just don't visit it
- imwillofficial 5y agoYeah, ethics touches everything. Might surprise you, but it’s true.
- hcykb 5y agoIn the same spirit, some people say that everything is politics. Sorry but no, I refuse.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- dexterdog 5y agoExcept it's not just Starbucks. It's all sites that use TrustArc. TrustArc is a scummy middleman that is extracting money in the name of privacy without providing any serious protection (except to the companies who pay their protection money). I worked with them when I whored my services to a list broker as a contractor for a brief time. They are a virtual money printer because their certifications are so incredibly expensive for what they actually provide.
- siculars 5y agoDie, eh? Na, this isn’t the one.
- esarbe 5y agoThat's what you get for tearing down any worker protection or ability to organize.
- soheil 5y agoSo a dumb one-minute timeout is the thing that pushed you over the edge? How would you feel if you had to work on drones that kill people or as a nuclear scientist on the Manhattan project?
- Aeolun 5y agoWhen I work on drones that kill people I choose to work on it from the start. There’s no doubt that they’ll be used to kill people since it’s an explicit design goal. The same is not true for a ‘cookie selection dialog’, where the stated goal would be to allow people to easily select what cookies they want to allow.
- eloff 5y agoYeah, I would refuse to implement this and immediately start searching for a new job, whatever the fallout. This is not why I got into software.
- jaclaz 5y agoYep, but that is a dangerous path/metric, besides this specific "artificial" delay, think of the millions, billions, trillions seconds humanity has lost - particularly the poorest - waiting for stupidly bloated sites to load on a slowish connection (or even worse a metered one) when the same content and message could have been delivered with 1/10th or 1/100th of bandwidth usage ... If you adopt this kind of metric/moral stance any web programmer workng in the last 20 years is guilty ...
- soheil 5y agoThere are things you can refuse to work on and there are things that you have to put in effort to make better. Improving a bloated site to load faster is not as trivial as refusing to put a dumb timeout to slow things down. I still think the OP is totally overreacting and even calling something as stupid as this a "dark pattern" belittles truly horrific things that are happening in the world including the cyber world.
- Aeolun 5y agoWe’re talking about “dark patterns” here, not crimes against humanity. I think this is unambiguiously evil, but that doesn’t automatically make it as bad as murder.
- thih9 5y ago> instead of saying ‘fuck no’ This is only possible for people whose job stability or financial situation is above average.
- ralphc 5y agoI'm out of the job market myself (retired) but isn't every developer's job stability above average? Isn't everyone looking for developers now? If you're one to take a stand then now is the perfect time. Unless you're in a H1B situation as mentioned by the comment below.
- acheron 5y agoTons of HN readers work at Google, which is much worse than whatever this dumb thing on the Starbucks website is. Ethics is in short supply.
- amelius 5y agoThose Googlers just follow orders, so you can't blame them. /s