20 ms·
Phony diagnoses hide high rates of drugging at nursing homes
- heavyset_go 5y agoAntipsychotics are not something to be handed out like candy. They have serious, sometimes permanent and sometimes fatal, side effects in anyone of any age. The article notes how that class of medication increases mortality in elderly people in particular. The fact that some people were prescribed haloperidol as the first line of treatment instead of a newer, safer antipsychotics also blows my mind. I'm terrified of growing old in this country.
- cosmotic 5y agoPersonally, I'm excited to help contribute to the quarterly profits of the shareholders.
- spike021 5y agoMy grandparents were in a care facility for several years. By the end, they were each on so many different medicines that one of my other relatives had to keep records on everything to make sure dosages were right, they were getting the correct medicines for the time of day, day of the week, etc. I feel like this industry for the care of elderly in this country just bears 0 responsibility.
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoThe solution in my opinion to this problem is to permit euthanasia and for assisted suicide to become culturally accepted as an alternative to a drawn out death of dementia in a care home. The quality of life for many (not all) care home residents who are on these sorts of drug regimens is dire and in reality not entirely for their benefit, as is apparent to everyone including those responsible for oversight like Medicare. This system exists (primarily in the West) due to a combination of taboos surrounding death and profit/political incentives on the part of pharmaceutical and care home companies.
- WalterBright 5y agoA nursing home around here for dementia runs $10,000 per month.
- coryrc 5y agoSame time we hardly pay that per year for k-12. Shows how messed up our priorities are.
- kevinmchugh 5y agoSchool aged kids and teenagers also require a lot less individual care and attention
- refurb 5y agoThis is a stupid comment. You think a child is as much work as a psychotic elderly person.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoThat seems cheap if you break it down into per hour of labor needed. I can only imagine how understaffed they are. I would hope I can take myself out before I end up in one of those.
- ctoth 5y agoOkay, let's assume we do exactly what you outlined there. In 2031, do you not expect to read an exposé on how many "care home" residents are being pressured into signing euthanasia papers without understanding what they're doing? How do we avoid that world?
- tbihl 5y agoThe truth we fail to face is that, in the grueling task of caring for the elderly and all the perverse incentives to cut corners, providing holistic care is an enormous labor of love that will tend to not work well outside of family, despite all the money we throw at it.
- R0b0t1 5y agoThis is far beyond that. The doctors are brazenly prioritizing "not being bothered" over the health of their patients. Over prescription of antipsychotics is still common in US psychiatric facilities, and even if not there are alternatives, like very high dosages of SSRIs or other specific medications with complacency as a side effect.
- roenxi 5y agoIf the alternatives are a doctor who cares and a doctor who doesn't then the choice is clear. But it is really difficult staying enthusiastic about treating someone, long term, who is never going to repay any extra efforts. Caring for the elderly/infirm is a really gruelling experience. It seems quite likely that there physically are not enough doctors who have the mental stamina to do that. The options the average person faces if they can't care for themselves are going to be doctors who don't really care, or nothing.
- mindslight 5y agoAlso, these facilities optimize down their number of employees to practically guarantee that they're all overworked. It's impossible to care in an environment like that - if someone has spare time to do anything beyond the rubric, then that is an avenue for optimization. The only thing holding them back is state regulations, and that doesn't make for a good outcome. This article strikes a chord with me. After a long hospital stay, I sent my father to inpatient rehab (aka "nursing home") for two weeks. Before he went, they told me I could do daily visits outside his window. After he was there, they made me schedule visits ahead of time with their "activities coordinator" who told me I was lucky to get twice a week. They didn't bother to make him do any of his therapy, rather they just let him lay in bed the whole time. They put him on a bunch of new meds to make their job easier, double dosed his biannual medication, etc. It was of course impossible to get anybody on the phone to talk about any of the details of his care (and not for a lack of trying). I only discovered the meds after the fact when I requested the records (which was also its own ordeal, and they're not even complete). Administratively though, they were on the ball. The intake paperwork pushed me to sign him up for a long term stay (complete with "sign here" highlights on patently unnecessary forms; I rejected them), and they wasted no time switching his insurance billing address to their own address. His stay ended abruptly one (early) morning, when they punted him back to the hospital with a dubious story. I believe it was because they knew his Covid test was coming back positive but didn't officially "know" yet, and this way they could keep their numbers down. After the second hospital stint, I just took him home despite the extreme burden. I hired some private helpers and between them and myself being extremely involved with the visiting nurses/rehab, he did much better. I would have paid for more bona fide sessions of rehab if I could have, but that's our inflexible system. If you have a good relationship with your family and one of them is in the position of "needing" a nursing home, it behooves you to save them from these horrible institutions that are mainly geared to milk their insurance. Even at decent hospitals and not during Covid, if someone else is not there and continually advocating, their care will be overlooked.
- koolba 5y ago> I'm terrified of growing old in this country. Have kids, raise them right, and you’ll be fine. It’s worked out pretty well for a couple thousand years.
- david-gpu 5y agoKids do not choose to be born. We can't expect them to serve us when we get old. They owe us nothing. We forced them into this world.
- Zhenya 5y agoSuch a nihilistic viewpoint. Others consider bearing children a gift of life.
- noasaservice 5y agoWhere was the consent? That's right - it cannot be given.
- gazzini 5y agoI think it’s a pretty great idea for people to “have kids, raise them right.” I’m bullish on that strategy, even if there is no contractual guarantee that those kids will return the favor.
- kortilla 5y agoThey generally do though. Have more than one so you have backups. If you’re not abusive children tend to remember the 18 years you gave them fondly and provide assistance for your last few years.
- cm2012 5y agoIt's an investment, not guaranteed to pay off. It's kind of funny, my wife's mom abused her horribly and is now upset my wife and I won't take care of her. Treat your investments better lady.
- prepend 5y ago
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYeah, that's frightening. Everything I read is exactly the opposite of what my education taught me to do. Antipsychotics are supposed to be the last resort in geriatric care due to obvious effects on patient quality of life and functionality. Not even sure they're approved by the american FDA for such uses. If they must be used, pretty much anything will be better than haloperidol. Reminds me of lobotomies of old. "Make the patient easier to care for."
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoThe epithet of "chemical lobotomies" for antipsychotics is an appropriate analogy not just for the physical effects but also for the potential political uses.
- User23 5y ago> I'm terrified of growing old in this country. This is what convinced me to have as many children as possible. Hopefully at least one of them will care about me enough to not let this sort of thing happen to me.
- winocm 5y agoHeh, yes. I developed tardive dyskinesia from use of antipsychotics over a period of 8 months. It's been over 6 years since I've taken them, but it still has not gotten any better... You can still develop TD regardless of the drug, given that pretty much any dopamine antagonist can cause it in the long term.
- grapist420 5y ago:( I recognize you from Twitter, that’s sad...
- yosame 5y agoI'm not sure of you're aware, but there's actually drug treatments for TD now, such as Valbenazine. From what I can tell, they have pretty good efficacy/safety [1]. [1] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5958944/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5958944/
- tyingq 5y agoSupposedly, a haloperidol and lorazepam mix is effective in sedating someone that's agitated just long enough that it becomes the next shift's problem. Pretty sure that's what's happening.
- heavyset_go 5y agoIt's fast acting so it's a great choice for someone in the ER that's having a psychotic episode or is violent. Yours is the only explanation that makes sense to me.
- Factorium 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haloperidol https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Haloperidol "Haloperidol is relatively inexpensive, being up to 100 fold less expensive than newer antipsychotics"
- thatguy0900 5y agoI work in developmental disabilities, the situation there is much the same. A lot of the time their lives just suck and the consequences of that is "solved" by giving them behavior controling medication because giving them good fulfilling lives is hard and expensive. I don't see any reason it would be different for nursing homes.
- rhizome 5y agoYou could say the same about my use of an antidepressant.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thatguy0900 5y agoThe tragedy of the articles situation is that someone in a nursing home or assisted living has little or no agency to improve their lives, so the meds seem forced upon them. The common man has the perception of having agency to improve his own situation, so it's not as tragic to have to be on antidepressants.
- rhizome 5y agoI probably could have quoted it, but I was referring to "giving them good fulfilling lives is hard and expensive." Absolutely the captive nature of assisted living makes any transgression worse, but I guess underneath my unintentional irony there's a grain of truth in that they aren't trying to give them those lives anyway, they just want them to be easier to manage. In a certain sense it's a maiming.
- bsder 5y agoWhen I have dementia, what is a "fulfilling life"? Personally, if I'm at the point where someone wants to give me haloperidol because of age related dementia, it is probably long past time for me to depart from this Earth.
- tommymachine 5y agoLol but guys medical fraud is suuuppperr rare... As I like to say: In Pharma we trust!
- woodruffw 5y agoNursing homes are part of the medical system, but they tend to be pretty disjoint in terms of the medical professionals who work at them. They're also regulated differently. Evidence of a particular kind of medical malpractice in the nursing industry isn't positive or negative evidence of any malpractice (much less fraud) anywhere else.
- tommymachine 5y agoOh, dang, I forgot how administering and prescribing medicine isn't part of the medical system. Thanks for correcting me.
- lmm 5y agoI'd say it does and should affect the reputation of the overall system.
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoAntipsychotics have horrific side effects but are useful in institutional settings to make residents/patients/inmates easier to manage - psychiatry is the tool used to legitimize drugging people without need for their consent in such settings, for the benefit of others and the institution. It makes me despondent to read an article like this as I believe there are too many perverse incentives and cultural taboos for this situation to change in any meaningful way.
- SamoyedFurFluff 5y agoNot all antipsychotics have horrible side effects. Let’s not lose nuance in response to the terrible unethical behavior depicted here. Modern antipsychotics often do good in helping people function when they wouldn’t otherwise be able to. The illnesses they treat are ones of terror and loneliness. I will note however that there’s no purpose in them here except to force submission, and that’s abuse and spits on the good that can be done.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> The illnesses they treat are ones of terror and loneliness. I will note however that there’s no purpose in them here except to force submission, and that’s abuse and spits on the good that can be done. Modern antipsychotics are useful for conditions beyond schizophrenia. Seroquel is commonly prescribed for insomnia at doses lower than those used for Schizophrenia. Adding Abilify is a common second-line strategy when first-line antidepressants aren't giving proper results. Certain patients with bipolar disorder benefit from antipsychotic medications, particularly in the therapeutic delay before traditional mood stabilizers can kick in. Like you said, the drugs themselves shouldn't be demonized. They're not perfect, but when used appropriately they're often far better than the underlying conditions being treated. However, if doctors are simply making up diagnoses in order to prescribe the drugs, that's obviously not appropriate treatment.
- justinko 5y agoI’m on Abilify and Vraylar. Makes me feel normal. Love it.
- wizwit999 5y agoOne of the most disgusting parts of western culture is how they relegate their old to these nursing homes.
- CincinnatiMan 5y agoWhat do other cultures do for people who can no longer take care of themselves?
- garmaine 5y agoLive in multi-generational family units where the family shares responsibility for (and benefits from) their own elders.
- fires10 5y agoI wonder about the generational demographics of different cultures and how that impacts things. Many western cultures have fewer children to bear the burden of taking care of the elderly. The populations are shrinking for native born.
- Ekaros 5y agoAlso people tend to live lot longer and specially lot longer with limited capabilities. So there is more of those needing support and lot more support needed.
- pempem 5y agoIt'd be remiss to not note most of the time in culture where multi generational family units are the norm, responsibility lands on women in the home or household support in extended families and the economy doesn't often require two incomes to be middle class.
- MattGaiser 5y agoIndeed. The household has a full time employee/manager there so to speak.
- PragmaticPulp 5y agoNon-paywall link: http://web.archive.org/web/20210911161128/https://www.nytimes.com/2021/09/11/health/nursing-homes-schizophrenia-antipsychotics.html http://web.archive.org/web/20210911161128/https://www.nytime... One nit: The article switches back and forth between incorrect schizophrenia diagnosis (11% of residents) and prescription antipsychotics (21% of residents), but those should be treated as separate topics. Antipsychotics can be beneficial in many conditions beyond schizophrenia, such as insomnia (at low doses), bipolar disorder, or depression (to boost efficacy of primary antidepressant treatments). The "antipsychotic" label is an unfortunate holdover from long ago, but the drugs are actually much more useful than they sound. Current generation antipsychotics also have significantly fewer risks than first-generation antipsychotics. The article's attempt to call them "chemical straightjackets" is a cheap shot at a class of medications that can be very beneficial for several conditions. Overprescription is a problem, but that doesn't mean all prescriptions are bad. The truly alarming stat is buried deeper in the article: The fact that 1 in 9 nursing home residents is diagnosed with schizophrenia is way too high. Schizophrenic patients will be overrepresented in nursing homes because they are less able to care for themselves in old age, but that's still an unbelievably high number. These misdiagnoses are what we should be focused on.
- grapist420 5y ago> Current generation antipsychotics also have significantly fewer risks than first-generation antipsychotics This is true, technically. Newer generations still have severe and often debilitating side effects though. Which gives an arguably favorable risk benefit for severe conditions, but very questionable ones for one in five nursing home residents.
- tcj_phx 5y agoI have the paperwork from my friend's 2015 mental hospitalization. The doctors both said, essentially, "patient expects us to believe that she was psychotic because she'd been drinking 2 bottles of liquor a day, and using cocaine. We know she's a chronic mental patient who needs these drugs because we got her stabilized in 2008 and 2010..." Antipsychotics do not treat alcoholism or broken metabolisms (cocaine, genetics, etc). There are always better options.
- redis_mlc 5y agoFYI: for people who don't know what's really going on. The homes in the US are prescribing unnecessary medication for 3 reasons: 1) To bill for the medication and dose administration. 2) To bill for the skilled nursing staff. 3) To make the resients more docile, reducing caretaking costs. These perverse economic incentives greatly impact the residents' health. It's important, especially in the US, for all patients to have an advocate (asking questions and helping to make good decisions) mediating between the patient and provider. Ideally that's a family member. Besides over-medication risks, there are also lawyers fleecing the elderly out of their assets. It's low-risk to the lawyers because elderly patients die, and what's the family going to do - sue a lawyer? Source: San Jose Mercury News has had several articles on this over the years.
- nikkinana 5y agoI would never put anyone I love in a nursing home without strict supervision and daily contact. Cuomo is a shit head. He killed a lot of people.
- BingoAhoy 5y agoPhony Diagnoses not just at nursing homes, also in mental facilities. Was really surprised (better word-traumatized) that one flippant casual mention of not valuing my life in a private text message was enough to to get me detained by police in a facility for a night. "Doctor" threatened me with drugging just because I refused to answer some of their questions and instead insisted on a lawyer. Funny how freedoms can be taken away so dubiously even when not charged of a crime nor arrested in a system that exists outside the criminal system. I'm surprised and not surprised similar behavior happens in nursing homes.
- thatguy0900 5y agoLook at all the recent brittney spears stuff. An insane legal world out there noone knows anything about. I never would have guessed a situation like that would be possible and for so long.
- quetzlbazaar 5y agoSuicide is offensive to society and many individuals on a deep level, especially of people who do not have a "good reason" (such as a terminal illness). While it may have progressed beyond being a criminal act, it is still taboo enough for alternative and equally good avenues to exist for society to deal with it, in this case, police and physicians empowered by law with the "duty of care" concept. This is of course better than suicidal intentions being dealt with as criminal, but not as good (in my opinion) as it being dealt with as something that someone has a right to do and therefore cannot have force used against them, but perhaps should be dissuaded from, maybe similarly to abortion.
- calvinmorrison 5y agoStep 1) fabricate an SMS Step 2) call police Step 3) enjoy Wow so easy to take down your political enemies huh
- anon9001 5y agoI think you're joking, but this is actually so true that you might be committing a crime by suggesting it.
- mguerville 5y agoThe movie “I care a lot” (fiction) does a good job of showing the incentives issue in elder care. I hope this NYT report will trigger some more oversight and maybe blow a few cases open because the trend it highlights is very concerning.
- babyshake 5y agoWe see it in education, healthcare, and at work. The path of least resistance is to do what makes things the easiest to manage, not what leads to the best outcomes.
- aazaa 5y ago> Antipsychotic drugs — which for decades have faced criticism as “chemical straitjackets” — are dangerous for older people with dementia, nearly doubling their chance of death from heart problems, infections, falls and other ailments. But understaffed nursing homes have often used the sedatives so they don’t have to hire more staff to handle residents. This problem will only get worse. A lot of it is driven by demographics: (1) fewer children being born means fewer blood-relatives to share the home care (2) although medical treatments can often improve lifetimes, they can't necessarily improve life quality (3) as people stop dying from ever more diseases (e.g., cancer, cardiovascular disease), they'll start to succumb to psychological and physical ailments resulting from isolation and sedentary lifestyles, and these have no cures - only treatments. (4) people often don't live where they grew up, which means that married couples can face a double-whammy of declining health of both parents, right about the same time and a geographical conflict that gets worse with time. Those claiming the solution is multi-generational households haven't done the math. And I doubt they've attempted to care for a geriatric relative with rapidly-compounding medical conditions while trying to stay afloat financially after having raised a kid or two themselves. And then there's the problem of medical costs that relentlessly rise much faster than inflation, putting ever more pressure on nursing homes, families, and governments. A big squeeze is coming as the boomers enter extreme old age in droves while needing round-the-clock care, possibly for a decade or more, for geriatric conditions without cures.
- taxicabjesus 5y ago> A big squeeze is coming as the boomers enter extreme old age in droves while needing round-the-clock care, possibly for a decade or more, for geriatric conditions without cures. Many old people have drinking problems. Someone I know personally has certainly contributed to his own deterioration. > And then there's the problem of medical costs that relentlessly rise much faster than inflation, putting ever more pressure on nursing homes, families, and governments. Prasadic medicine is medicine that concentrates wealth, but doesn't provide what the patients actually need: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21728864 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=21728864
- arkades 5y agoThere is so much ignorance in this article, and in this thread
- klyrs 5y agoWould you care to enlighten us?
- spoonjim 5y agoThe fact is that moving into a home full of strangers at the end of your life is a very cruel end to one’s life, and people fight it the way they fight kidnapping or torture. The best solution is to have your kids take care of you, the second best solution is to die. Nobody wants this which is why people need to be stuffed up with drugs to be manageable, like those tigers they use in tourist photo attractions.
- glangdale 5y agoThe drugging in those places is an obscenity. If you're going to do that, you should be intentionally shortening people's lives with opiates, which at least is a lot more pleasant than getting loaded up with anti-psychotics to make people compliant. Unfortunately, the jig is generally up with that - everyone knows what opiates do. I'm seeing a lot of bullshit on all these threads from people who are doing the whole "fake bravery about how they would just be euthanized" in this situation, and how life isn't worth living if you're demented, etc. Here's how life goes for a demented person close to me: A "fulfilling life" with dementia isn't that different from one without. You wake up, someone makes you a nice meal, you read the papers, shuffle around a bit, get helped to take a shower and dress, watch a movie (which you won't really take in, but it's some nice pictures), get a call from your daughter (who either lives down the road or thousands of miles away, depending on what you're remembering today), etc. On some days your carers will take you for a drive to look at the ocean, or out to a dinner. You might dream that you went on an exciting adventure down the California coast and tell everyone about it; surprising that an 80-year-old man who can't walk unaided can take a sailboat out by himself. Everyone you talk to will enjoy your story and no-one will try to tell you that you are deluded. Some days will be better than others, which is the same for anyone. That's 24 hour home care - and it's not cheap. Neither is living at a facility at this stage. Often the money spent on medical heroics would be better spent on quality of life. Of course, packing folks off to a facility is necessary for some (in this case, we're talking about outright home ownership plus a modest level of wealth). And then a lot of other people frankly want to put hands on grandpa/grandma's money and/or house which is tricky if they are still living in it.
- crunchytartar 5y ago> That's 24 hour home care - and it's not cheap Why don't they just eat cake? This is the good end of the spectrum. The other end is that the patient lives alone, soils his clothes and doesn't change them for months/ gets lost and becomes homeless, gets infected and dies an animals death. Most of the patients live closer to the bad end.
- glangdale 5y agoTwo points. First of all, a lot of the grandiose claims here about how "if I was demented I would just get myself put down" are coming from tech people who could afford this end of the spectrum. Second, 24 hour home care - or 'family care plus a certain amount of professional relief' is, while expensive, not much more expensive than medicalized fulltime care in a lot of facilities. You're not paying the overheads of a bunch of salaries and potentially the profit margin. At the lowest end of the spectrum, things are indeed terrible. Aside from fairly extreme small government people, I think most people would want the state to step in. A lot of the places that are over-medicating their patients are collecting vast amounts of subsidies and pocketing the improved profits that come from getting to run staffing levels as low as they can get away with.
- throw18376 5y agounfortunately, there are some people who cannot function in the world without antipsychotics. a large number of people suffer from psychosis which in severe cases makes controlling their behavior, or even basic cause-and-effect thinking, impossible. the side effects of these drugs are terrible, but the alternative is worse. abusing these drugs as tools of control when they aren't needed is evil in itself. on top of that it's just going to give more credibility to the anti-psychiatry crusaders who want to give people suffering from psychosis the "freedom" to destroy their lives and minds.
- grapist420 5y agoI still argue that antipsychotics are generally overused and that many cases that require them are either currently perpetuated or were in the past caused by technological or societal conditions, regardless 20% in these nursing homes is dramatic vs the overall 1.6%, down to .5% among older people. https://sci-hub.se/downloads/2020-10-18/9d/dennis2020.pdf https://sci-hub.se/downloads/2020-10-18/9d/dennis2020.pdf
- tcj_phx 5y agoThere are always causes behind the symptom of "psychosis". People commonly develop metabolic problems. My "crazy" friend was doing okay, back in July [ref: my comment history]. I watched her open a bottle of sugar free electrolyte drink concentrate and drink a serving. Over the course of the next hour she got paranoid and flipped on me, "DON'T FOLLOW ME, I DON'T KNOW YOU", and disappeared. Brains need glucose and fructose, b-vitamins, thyroid hormone, vitamin A, etc. Stressed brains use more glucose than brains at rest. Old people commonly lose their metabolisms. I think what I observed was the fake-sugar in the sugar-free drink causing insulin release -> low blood sugar. The normal response to low blood sugar is cortisol release, but people who have a tendency to psychotic disorders can't make cortisol. It was fascinating to watch & reconstruct. p.s. your sci-hub link is titled "Characteristics of U.S. adults taking prescription antipsychotic medications, National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey 2013–2018"
- cascom 5y agoWonder if working from home will do to this, will change the demand for nursing homes in the future?
- Bud 5y agoJust another devastating indictment of our entire philosophy of how we handle health care in the US—to wit, cynically, and as a profit center—versus basically every single other advanced nation. How many horrifying examples do we need to see before we change it?
- VMG 5y agothe psychiatric system is routinely used as tool to squash political dissent in many countries where it is not a "profit center"
- tartoran 5y agoIt is absolutely true, it happend to my grandmother. She was sedated because she had alheimzer and they didn’t want to deal with it. A tray of food would be brought in the morning and then taken back at night untouched, since she was sedated and they did not care that she didn’t eat for almost a week. Eventually she ended up in ER, had to be intubated and lost her ability to eat normally. That way she became bedbound and her life ended shorly after, something like a month and a half. Beside the alzheimer she was in good health but once in the nursing home it went all downhill.
- bg24 5y agoSorry to hear that. Unfortunately, the system knows just one way for the people who deviate from the normal - INCAPACITATE THEM. I have an autistic child and I get so much pain thinking along the lines of what your grandmother went through.
- msrenee 5y agoI haven't finished the article yet. I got sidetracked by the claim that Haldol is "a powerful sedative." I understand that journalists are neither doctors nor pharmacists, but if you're reporting on a story about medical ethics, maybe know a little bit about drugs, how they work, and what the words you're using mean in a medical context. Haldol is a typical antipsychotic. If the patient has no symptoms that indicate its use, they should absolutely not be taking it. There's a lot of side effects. Some may even persist after the medication is discontinued. One of these side effects is that it can be sedating. I've been on the patient side of a misapplied antipsychotic myself. They can make you very tired and cause you to feel "drugged". This is not the same as a drug being a "powerful sedative". Words mean things. Words in a medical context have specific definitions and nuance. If you're reporting on medical malpractice, it's important to get the vocabulary correct so that the way you word something represents the truth rather than a sensationalized version of it. I can definitely believe that these people were medicated in ways that were dangerous to their health for the convenience of the staff. However, when you call Haldol a powerful sedative, I have to assume you're either trying to make the situation sound as horrible as possible or you have no idea what you're talking about.
- simfree 5y agoHaldol, Benadryl and one other drug are part of the common rotation used by nurses to sedate troublesome patients so they can skate out of handling said patient during their shift. When said patient regains control of their faculties they are often confused and angry as a day is missing from their memory.
- atdrummond 5y agoI assume the “one other drug” you are referencing is Ativan (lorazepam)?
- grapist420 5y agoBenadryl and Haldol arguably don’t belong in the same sentence at all, considering their ridiculously different effects and profile. You’re right that they’re used though. Is there any reason Haldol should be used like that at all, beyond it already being available as a psych drug? And even if Benadryl isn’t as effective (I dunno) surely something that isn’t as bad in side effects could be found? Many instances of said sedation are totally unnecessary, but many are eminently necessary to restrain someone actively violent.
- grapist420 5y agoThere needs to be judicial punishment for the care workers and higher ups who administered the drugs. Merely sweeping it under the rug is not enough.
- Clubber 5y agoIt's probably because of cost cutting. If you care for 10 patients in a shift, that's one thing, if you care for 50, that's when bad things happen. The buck stops at the top right?
- sharmin123 5y agoWhy Is It Necessary To Hire A Professional Hacker?: https://www.hackerslist.co/why-is-it-necessary-to-hire-a-professional-hacker/ https://www.hackerslist.co/why-is-it-necessary-to-hire-a-pro...
- mlang23 5y agoThis is nothing new, and a worldwide phenomenon. If you have to read about this in nytimes for the first time, please get a life and talk to your fellow humans. Its a mixture of personell being overworked and sometimes being plain mean. This is the price we pay for not investing enough into the system that cares for the elderly, or, in other words, this is the price for having outsourced caretaking. And dont fool yourself. If you put a relative into a nursing home, you have absolutely no idea how they are treated after you close the door behind you.
- aguasfrias 5y agoThe "hide" part from the title: > But there is an important caveat: The government doesn’t publicly divulge the use of antipsychotics given to residents with schizophrenia or two other conditions.
- thetruthisout 5y agoAnd yet, these are the "experts"/"doctors" that the Americans trust when it comes to telling them that they need to get vaccinated.
- vsareto 5y agoI've never made a phony diagnosis or incorrectly prescribed anti-psychotics in my life or made any medical errors of any kind so clearly I'm perfect. You should trust me when I say that you should get vaccinated.
- temptemptemp111 5y agoRight
- EMM_386 5y ago> “People don’t just wake up with schizophrenia when they are elderly,” said Dr. Michael Wasserman, a geriatrician and former nursing home executive who has become a critic of the industry. “It’s used to skirt the rules.” What will likely happen is that they will simply approve Haldol for additional uses, such as the cases where elderly are hallucinating and highly agitated due to the effects of Alzheimers. Then doctors won't be use the schizophrenia diagnosis, they will diagnose "Alzheimers-induced psychosis" instead. The effects can be remarkably similar, which is one reason this may be occurring and not just staff shortages or cost cutting. I am not taking sides on this, but there would be no uproar if Haldol was on-label for late-stage symptoms of Alzheimers. It would just be another medication used to help ease symptoms. I'd be curious if manufacturers are trying this route. If I was in this terrible situation I'd probably want the Haldol but that's just me.
- EGreg 5y agoSo in the USA today we have: 1) Both adults working long hours to move up the corporate ladder, neglecting their kids and their elderly parents in order to afford the rent etc. 2) Kids are stuck in public school as a glorified "day care center", and if they fidget or can't sit still they are diagnosed with ADHD and given amphetamines like adderal and ritalin. Boys are diagnosed with ADHD more than girls, for perhaps obvious reasons (https://theconversation.com/why-is-adhd-more-common-in-boys-than-girls-92151 https://theconversation.com/why-is-adhd-more-common-in-boys-...) (However, we can improve this. Finland doesn't have nearly as much ADHD diagnoses, for instance, because the kids are able to have a lot of exercise during the day, rather than only being trained to be corporate drones https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-37306818 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-europe-37306818) 3) The elderly, as we can see here, are being drugged also 4) One in four middle aged women is on antidepressants (https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/cifamerica/2011/nov/21/one-in-four-women-psych-meds https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/cifamerica/2011/no...) 5) There is an opioid epidemic, primarily among men whose jobs have disappeared (https://www.brookings.edu/policy2020/votervital/how-can-policy-address-the-opioid-crisis-and-despair-in-america/ https://www.brookings.edu/policy2020/votervital/how-can-poli...) The #4 and #5 have gotten worse since 2007, as many men started making less money, but women continue to want to be with men who make more than they do. Single, childless women make more than men, and sometimes choose to have a child and raise them as a single parent. (https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704421104575463790770831192 https://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704421104575463...) We could fix a lot of this by giving people a Universal Basic Income. Then, both men and women would have the power to negotiate shorter workweeks with their employers, spend more time with their children, and take care of their parents – things that are currently not remunerated by the market (although there are some government programs that pay family members for taking care of their own parents). They might contribute to open source software, do science, learn a musical instrument, practice their religion or learn something from a massive online course. A high enough UBI would also allow us to abolish minimum wage laws, allowing companies to give free internships legally, so teenagers and new entrants can gain skills on the job and become competitive. Finally, it would reduce the pay gap / penalties that a woman has for choosing to have children, because both parents would be able to afford to work shorter hours. Rather than teaching women to "lean in" and work 10 hour days like many career-oriented men, we should be teaching both sexes to "lean out" and spend more time with their family. I would argue that women had a better work-life balance than men, until recently. At least during the pandemic, many have learned that they don't have to commute long miles just to sit in a chair. That's already good for the environment and gains people a few hours every day.
- dukeofdoom 5y agoSudden infant death syndrome (SIDS), hides high rates of women killing their infant babies. Apparently society is not ready to admit that women are capable of doing this. So this is just a convenient disease to hide it under. Watched a documentary on this many years back on CBC.
- tathisit 5y agoSIDS is much more likely if the mother is underage or a smoker.
- Haga 5y agoIf you have Alzheimer, you have the panic attacks of a person waking up in a foreign city among foreign people. Some have flashbacks to bad parts of their lives. Like getting raped in a war bad. They will throw things at you, and try to escape to get home to loved ones who are dead. Yes, there are "lazy wardens" who drug entire floors when they are responsible for a nightshift with 300 people. Because society pays as little as possible for caring for the elderly. Old age without family is a horror show, please at least drug me.
- ciconia 5y agoIs there any doubt that there is an over-consumption of medical products? This is not just limited to nursing homes or mental institutions. The chronic consumption of pain killers, sleeping pills, anti depressants etc is seems endemic to developed countries. Of course there's the angle of financial incentives, but to me it seems that modern society has chosen the easy path to deal with the health implications of our modern way of life - namely popping pills - instead of taking a hard look at our health problems and working toward long term sustainable solutions, especially for environmental problems. The current COVID-19 crisis is a case in point. I'll risk being ground to a pulp by the HN community and say that IMO vaccines are one solution but not necessarily the best. To date they have provided neither herd immunity (very hard to reach on a global scale), nor long term protection (look at Israel). A better solution would be providing a better environment - cleaner air and water, a less stressful life style, and better integration of human habitats with natural ecosystems. We know that the virus kills mostly people with pre existing conditions. A better long term treatment would have been to reduce those pre existing conditions - diabetes, obesity, heart and lung diseases. This can be done through better food, less work, more physical activity, and even more social involvement. Sadly, modern society demands short term gratification over long term sustainable sobriety.
- blablabla123 5y agoNot really on-topic but related. Until 10 years ago in Germany there used to be compulsory military service but alternatively it was possible to work instead in social services of which nursing homes were a large quantity. I think coincidentally this was a good way to let not completely indifferent people work in not really great circumstances. Probably the dynamics there aren't the greatest, low pay and some people are probably just there because it was easy to apply. Apart from the dirty work I think nursing homes could be actually great places for the inhabitants and so much better than living isolated which is more common the older people get.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]