4 ms·
And let's not forget that people with natural antibodies are being fired from their private sector jobs too. We seem to be focused on measuring output rather t
by giantg2 5y ago
And let's not forget that people with natural antibodies are being fired from their private sector jobs too.
We seem to be focused on measuring output rather than outcomes. Other countries are giving recovered people the same status as the vaccinated since they have the antibodies. But I guess that makes too much sense...
- whymauri 5y agoNatural antibodies + vaccination is basically a win-win for everyone, especially noting that the US is wasting vaccines rather than using them. You don't lose anything by getting the vaccine and there's a strong upside in resistance (around 10x more resistant than people who are simply vaccinated). Like, between a 100-200$ blood test to prove natural immunity* vs. a free vaccine, it should make sense to get the vaccine. * IMO, honor system should be de-emphasized for people claiming natural immunity. If they want to fight on this hill, they should be able to prove they have that immunity in the first place, otherwise it's simply inconsiderate.
- francis-io 5y agoWhy would you risk side effects (which are really low, but do exist) if you already have antibodies? Is argue you do "lose something" if you get a vaccine after having recovered from covid.
- dragontamer 5y agoBecause we know that natural immunity only lasts 6 months and vaccination immunity lasts like 8 months (for Pfizer at least. Moderna probably a little bit longer, unsure how much longer though). Either way, you need a round to re-up your immune system. A lot of these Delta cases are "breakthroughs", in vaccinated populations... or reinfections (ie: in already infected populations) For example: South Dakota was something like 50% infected + 50% vaccinated (Roughly 75% with some kind of immunity), and SD still had a huge Delta-spike in July/August. It has been shown that the effects of vaccination + naturally getting the virus leads to the strongest immune response. The current levels of vaccination are insufficient to prevent spread (see July/August spike). With the big winter rush coming in just a few months, now is the time to prepare (just like in 2020, the virus seemed to have retreated between September and November. But come December, I expect it to come roaring back unless we up our collective immunities).
- AuryGlenz 5y agoNatural immunity doesn’t only last 6 months. Where did you get that? I’m coming out of my second COVID infection now. Long story short, I was in the local hospital and the fact that this was my second infection caused a really big hubbub in the COVID ward and a nurse told me I was the first reinfection she has seen.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Natural immunity doesn’t only last 6 months. Where did you get that? https://www1.racgp.org.au/newsgp/clinical/delta-raises-covid-reinfection-risk-by-46-study https://www1.racgp.org.au/newsgp/clinical/delta-raises-covid... You got 180 days before natural immunity wanes and Delta poses a risk of reinfection.
- rajin444 5y agoThat's looking at relative risk not overall. It's not saying you lose immunity after 180 days.
- dragontamer 5y agoNatural immunity wanes enough to cause a "2nd surge" in cities that were 75%ish infected, such as Araraquara city, Brazil, and Manaus, Brazil. I can agree with you that the 180-days thing is just an estimate from one study. Further studies are needed to narrow down the exact time when natural immunity wanes. But its a good "first guess" at the phenomenon, and should be within a magnitude of the truth. From what we've seen around the world, COVID19 (or at least its variants, like Gamma/P.1 or Delta/B.1.617) is more than willing to reinfect populations in less than a year.
- disgruntledphd2 5y agoThe Manaus study used a convenience sample, meaning that you cannot infer population rates from it. Who would have thought that reading the abstract of a paper could be a super power?
- giantg2 5y ago"Like, between a 100-200$ blood test to prove natural immunity* vs. a free vaccine, it should make sense to get the vaccine." The antibody test is about $45 from places like Labcorp. The vaccine is $40 per dose (so $80 total for most), with the government picking up the tab. Yes, vaccination plus infection provides more antibodies. I'm not sure that it is correct to quantify that as "10x more resistance" as we would need to know where the threshold for resistance lies and all the factors involved (they don't know the min effective level of antibodies, and they are seeing protection in individuals before the antibodies are being produced). "You don't lose anything by getting the vaccine..." There are some people with valid concerns about the possiblity of autoimmune antibodies, which in theory, could be substantially higher if having already been infected. Sadly, I haven't been able to find any real research into this one way or the other. "... they should be able to prove they have that immunity in the first place, ..." Yes, other governments such as Isreal are issuing green passes for those confirmed to have recovered. I don't believe they are doing antibody testing, but we aren't testing vaccine recipients for antibodies either.
- nradov 5y agoYour numbers are incorrect. Vaccination appears to boost immunity after infection by a factor of 2×, not 10×. The duration of additional resistance is unclear. https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-protection.html https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0806-vaccination-pr...
- yupper32 5y agoThis is just a talking point coming from people who don't want to get the vaccination. Those people who don't want to get the vaccination largely exist because of misinformation, not because of any real risk (read: very very very very minimal risk) that comes with taking the Covid vaccine. Everyone (who can) should take the covid vaccine, regardless of their antibody status.
- drstewart 5y agoCan you explain why a "talking point" immediately invalidates something? >A talking point, often used in the plural, is a pre-established message or formula used in the field of political communication, sales and commercial or advertising communication. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talking_point https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talking_point Let me ask you this: is "Everyone (who can) should take the vaccine" a message that medical organizations are communicating with minimal variance?
- yupper32 5y agoIf "talking point" is getting us tripped up here, maybe "convenient excuse spread mostly to help the vaccine hesitant continue to not get the vaccine" would be a better phrase. I'm not an English major here. Just trying to get my point across.
- giantg2 5y agoIsn't the vaccination rate of healthcare worker only about 60%? If the reasons are strictly misinformation, then it seems you have an almost 40% chance of getting an incompetent healthcare professional. In my mind, that suggests there are rational and reasonable reasons, since I find that more likely than 40% being blatantly incompetent.
- enragedcacti 5y ago96% of practicing physicians are fully vaccinated [1]. That number goes way down as you look at nursing home aids, nurses, and home aids. If the argument is that healthcare workers not taking it makes it rational and reasonable, you need to contend with the fact that the more educated you are in medicine, the less hesitant you are. It seems more likely that nurses and aids can't interprete dense medicalese or understand mRNA any better than the average person and are no less susceptible to misinformation than the average person. That doesn't make them incompetent at their jobs, which aren't about creating complex treatment plans using the latest and greatest medical research, but finding veins, delivering meds, scrubbing sores, changing bed pans etc. [1] https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M21-3150 https://www.acpjournals.org/doi/10.7326/M21-3150
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoNatural antibodies are fun until you've waited a year and now you don't have them anymore.