17 ms·
The bargain at the heart of the BBC is fraying
- boffinism 5y agoIt's worth saying the BBC has been 'doomed' for as long as I can remember. Simply pointing out that it doesn't make sense doesn't seem to have much effect on its continued presence.
- kmeisthax 5y agoYes, and global warming has been a problem for as long as I can remember. Just because the problem doesn't have a deliberate start date doesn't mean it isn't a problem. Collapse, whether it be political, cultural, or climatological, is one of those things that happens on such a long timescale that you don't notice it until it's too late. It's entirely possible that the BBC is maintained for another century, purely as an expensive monument to the country's history that nobody watches, before finally being rolled up in 2092. There's precedent for this in things like the royal family[0] or Brexit. Or tomorrow the Tories wind up repealing the license tax and significantly downsizing the BBC as a result, turning it into an English PBS/NPR. Knowing that the BBC is doomed doesn't tell you how long it has to live, just that things will continue to get worse until something breaks completely. [0] Conflict-of-interest disclosure: I am an American
- dreen 5y agoedit: incorrect info
- chrisseaton 5y ago> BBC World Service, which is an entirely commercial entity This is not truthful - the World Service is funded by the rest of the BBC, not the other way around, and until recently was also funded by the FCO.
- tialaramex 5y agoYou're thinking of BBC Studios, the global for-profit arm. The BBC World Service is an international multi-lingual news and discussion service. Big budget costume drama your commercial broadcaster paid $$$ for? BBC Studios. Guy speaking your language but likely from a radio studio thousands of miles away, telling you stuff that your local news media are too scared (if they exist) to broadcast? BBC World Service. Historically the UK government saw the BBC World Service as an important way to exercise soft power, and funded it directly. That ended, and today it's all paid for out of the profits of BBC Studios and the license fee.
- dreen 5y agoYou're right, I was thinking of BBC Worldwide which is now part of BBC Studios. Still, it makes a lot more money than the group gets from the license fee, which was my point.
- laurencerowe 5y agoThat's not correct. "Licence fee accounted for 71% of BBC funding in 2019/20" https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-8101/ https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/cbp-...
- dreen 5y agoLooks like someone gave me wrong information. Thank you, I stand corrected
- tialaramex 5y ago[Although I should note that just because the World Service says it and your local news are too scared to do so, does not mean it's true...] See for example All Largely Propaganda from "Bang!" - An Open Letter by The Hafler Trio.
- chrisseaton 5y agoI don’t recall anyone predicting the demise of the BBC when I was growing up, and if they had they’d have had no evidence as there were no serious competitors at all back then. Now there are huge competitors everywhere and they’re actually higher-brow than the BBC in many cases which defeats their traditional defence against other media! The BBC looks very small and vulnerable.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoI remember the day Channel 4 started, to a chorus of cries that it would lead to the end of the BBC.
- marcosdumay 5y agoOh, the Monty Python Flying Circus has an entire season with jokes about that.
- Proven 5y agoWell, when customer can't refuse to buy, no wonder they are still in business. It's like those poor bastards in the EU watching "European" programming on national because that's how national public circle jerk continues. National TV gets euro subsidies if they "cooperate" and broadcast public TV content from other EU countries.
- sebow 5y agoMSM is sh*t and it's dying, what else is new? And how exactly is this a bad thing? >inb4 it allows misinformation [...] That has always been the case, and the generations that grew up under the 'protective umbrella' and the golden age of news corporations are the most despised ones(not to mention it promotes the "lack of filter").It's not a new thing, and that's why people are excited when a new medium arises: because usually the old dogs are not there at first.[to regurgitate their rhetorics, if i might add]
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoThe BBC is (overall) great. The licence fee though has always been a regressive tax. Like with libraries, NHS, school, police etc. some crazy person will just have to suggest the unthinkable that taxpayers money creates YouTube (or whatever) content, and the lack of need for it to be a thinly disguised advert will make it much more enjoyable to watch.
- croes 5y agoComparing how much money Disney, Netflix and the BBC put into productions is useless. Netflix in particular has already burned a lot of money and the result was average at best. How many failures are there for a hit like "The Crown", how long can Netflix in particular continue to spend so much money? For quality, you need the right makers, and the BBC has often had the right ones.
- chrisseaton 5y agoBut I think this is where it's starting to nose-dive. It used to be there were competitors but they were crass comparative junk, like ITV. Now the competitors are suddenly massively out BBC-ing the BBC. Huge landmark period dramas - used to be only the BBC could competently pull that off. Now Netflix does it better. Serious radio discussion - used to be only found on the BBC. Now I can get it often better from Spectator or New Statesman podcasts. They're being out-done on money and talent in, and results out, for their own game. Really serious problem.
- croes 5y agoWait and see. Netflix was once the place for new fresh shows but it's a victim of it's shareholders value. Most shows don't survive the 1st season. If the BBC tries to copy Netflix they will lose, if they stick to their last it might work out.
- mrkstu 5y agoApple seems to be trying to occupy the quality niche though.
- chrisseaton 5y agoIt’s the quality thing - previously peopled tried to compete with the BBC by being lower brow, now they’re attacking the high brow.
- echelon 5y agoIt's insane to me that Apple and Amazon are making movies. How many things are companies allowed to do? They're clearly making it harder for other players in these markets, and they're leveraging their insane capital to succeed in areas they have no experience in. It's also incredibly annoying now that there are a dozen different subscription services, each with different apps and radically different navigation UX, and many of which don't run on the same hardware. This is insane.
- paxys 5y agoThe numbers listed in the article don't actually support the author's argument at all. > Netflix spent $11.8bn in 2020, Disney is expecting to spend $8-9bn on Disney+ content by 2024, and Amazon is estimated to be spending $7bn this year alone. By contrast, according to the BBC’s most recent annual report, it spent about £980m ($1.3bn) on “programme-related assets and other inventories” in the 2020/21 financial year. Netflix/Disney/Amazon and the rest are catering to a much larger and more varied user base, and BBC should absolutely be able to compete with ~1/5 the budget for its 67 million residents. A British public broadcaster does not need to make Korean dramas or Bollywood movies or launch $25m/episode blockbuster franchises.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoNetflix (and Amazon) literally list UK produced shows they had no involvement with except for buying the global rights to it after the fact as "exclusive/original content". I assume they do the same for other nation's domestic output too. BBC have done co-productions with other enterprises since before streaming and have continued to do them with Netflix.
- michaelt 5y agoIf your model of the future of the BBC is that the license fee, which costs about as much as Netflix, should give you a comparable product - then if Netflix have 10x the budget, the BBC's going to have a tough time competing.
- OneEyedRobot 5y agoIf I were forced to choose between Netflix and BBC's back catalog and current programming for the same price, I'd say that BBC comes out far ahead.
- deadbunny 5y agoIndeed. Especially as the BBC is kneecapped in what they can have on the iPlayer at any one time. If they could put up their entire back catalogue it would be great. They should also sell subscriptions to those outside the UK as well, there is enough demand for sure.
- mdoms 5y agoWhy the hand-wringing over show budgets? One of the greatest shows I have ever watched, People Just Do Nothing - a BBC production - must have had a budget one one thousandth of a Marvel show but I would re-watch it a hundred times before I bothered with a single episode of that generic PG-13 comic book dreck. And I can say the same for all of the BBC greats. BBC doesn't need to compete on budget. Netflix may pour billions into soulless generic crap that attracts eyeballs but if that's what you want from BBC you're missing the whole point of a public broadcaster. (I'm not British and I don't live there, but I am eternally grateful to BBC for producing almost all of my favourite TV shows and podcasts).
- davzie 5y agoAnother fan of the Korrupt FM boys! It’s not often the BBC hit jackpots like this show though, actually tell a lie, Motherland is very well done, all parents can relate! Some of their comedies of late have been really good. I can’t really say the same about Netflix. Perhaps it’s because the BBC content appeals to my British sense of humour.
- mbreese 5y agoIronically, if that’s the same show, “People Just Do Nothing” is on Netflix in the US. At least they aren’t keeping all their shows behind iPlayer anymore and these shows are more available outside the UK.
- deadbunny 5y ago> At least they aren’t keeping all their shows behind iPlayer anymore and these shows are more available outside the UK. They have always sold their content overseas...
- tomjen3 5y agoIt is fine that you do not like comic book shows. I find most of them cheese too, but evidentially lots of people disagree and they want the most possible for their money too. Personally I don't think the BBC should produce entertainment at all, only scrupulously neutral news and explanations because that is what society needs if it is to be held together.
- glugc 5y ago>Even if you don’t engage with Newsnight’s coverage of the Namibian Presidential Election6, or you don’t tune in to hear what the fishing conditions are like in the North Sea, it’s good that at least someone, somewhere is being paid to care about these things. Why?
- wyager 5y agoYou’re being downvoted but I think this is a fair question. I don’t accept this assertion as true at face value. Presumably the BBC, as with any other government-controlled revenue source, acts as some sort of patronage mechanism, and a lot of these roles exist as a jobs program rather than something the taxpayers actually extract a benefit from.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y ago> The BBC, as with any other government-controlled revenue source Point of fact, the BBC was not intended to be "government-controlled", and it is not a "revenue source" for the UK government. https://www.quora.com/Is-the-BBC-the-state-owned-and-state-controlled-TV-operator-in-the-UK https://www.quora.com/Is-the-BBC-the-state-owned-and-state-c... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC# https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC#
- msla 5y agoThe BBC is government-controlled in that its money is collected by the government, which can punish people for not paying, and organizations know where their funds are coming from and attempt to prevent those funds from being stopped.
- SideburnsOfDoom 5y agoReread. I used the word "intended" deliberately. There are many indirect mechanisms, that are open to abuse. You described one. It's not the same though as direct control.
- M2Ys4U 5y ago
- iso1210 5y agoMy kids have no concept of linear TV. My 9 year old came back and told me that a friend had a broken TV as when they turned it on, the program was already half way through. Their 'channels' are netflix, amazon and disney. When I had the choice and they were pre-school then sure, we watched things like Alphablocks on iplayer. I can force them to watch Attenborough or Blue Peter, and they enjoy it, just not enough to want to watch them over things on disney. There's so much competition of things to do. I do watch BBC (iplayer obviously) occasionally, but the material I'm interested in isn't as accessible as it is on disney/apple/prime/netflix/youtube. We watched Eurovision and Euro2020 (England games) this year. Aside from that the only BBC output we watched was Roadkill about a year ago, and the one Doctor Who episode which had John Barrowman in. I would watch have I got news for you, but whenever I remember to watch it, it's not on. This itself might not say a lot, and I still have a TV license despite the limited direct value I get (listen to a lot of BBC radio, and the news website), but what's interesting is I actually work for the BBC. If my household barely watches it, where does the future lie. Linear TVs days are numbered, but the underlying cultural links that prime time TV provided in the 60s through 90s has already gone. 1 in 4 people in the UK used to watch the same shitty sitcoms in the 80s because there was very little choice. It's not just BBC or the UK that has this cultural difference. "It's a wonderful life" is an American classic. It is because it was shown on every channel every christmas year after year, generation after generation, and kids watched it, because it was that or reading a book. I think Star Trek was right with its outlandish prediction from 1988. TV as a form of entertainment won't survive much past 2040 (I think linear TV will still be going in 10 years time, but probably not 30).
- nate 5y agoI got such a kick out of my 7 year old at my grandparents. We turned on some random movie that was half way through and she said: "Oh, let's watch this, start it from the beginning." When I told her that's not how cable TV works, she looked at me like I was telling her some kind of stupid dad joke.
- aclelland 5y agoMy 6 year old thinks that the screen goes black in some shows because that's when the exciting part is about to happen. Of course, it's actually where the program would normally break for ads . On Netflix/Disney+ this doesn't happen (yet!) so he's come to the conclusion that it's just a signal of impending excitement :)
- gootler 5y agoWhat a crock of crap.
- zwieback 5y agoBBC (and other national broadcasters) should focus on news, children's TV and maybe a small selection of cultural stuff that otherwise wouldn't have exposure. It makes no sense to compete in the commercial entertainment space. I'm already noticing that there's stuff on streaming now that includes funding from several non-profit or national cultural organisations, I think that model can work well. I enjoy watching European or Asian productions with subtitles and get a break from the usual fare. There are huge economies of scale to be had.
- vharuck 5y agoThis is what Japan's NHK does, and I watch it a lot on Roku. Documentaries, cooking shows, talk shows focusing on Japanese culture, etc. They're basically cultivating and training tourists, which is great! I want to know about famous places that I can visit, new food I can try, and enough Japanese to at least get directions or buy things from people who can't speak English. And, while the production values aren't Hollywood-level, I expect they're better than what prefectural tourist offices would make. If I were planning a trip to Great Britain, I'd happily watch a similar channel.
- ghostbrainalpha 5y agoI agree with you, but we need to reevaluate our values when it comes to public funds. When Florida paid Emeril Lagasse to produce a show that's purpose was partly to promote Florida tourism, people freaked out and it ruined his career.
- deadbunny 5y ago> It makes no sense to compete in the commercial entertainment space. If the authors figures are right and they are spending a fraction of what the competition are spending while still producing solid shows (which are then sold on to other markets for a decent price) then why not?
- golemiprague 5y agoLooking from the outside I like many British shows but it doesn't really matter whether they are a BBC show or ITV or whatever other channel. I don't like the politics though and I wouldn't want my tax money financing a news channel as I don't believe it can be "objective", let each political group finance their own propaganda themselves.
- botwriter 5y agoHonestly the last show I think I watched on the BBC was McMafia or possibly Peaky blinders. When I go on I player I'm just bombarded with content about minorities other nonsense. BBC are going the same way as the Labour party they're alienating themselves from the classical British working class in favor of middle class Londoners and minoroties. Radio 4 is about the only reasonable thing the BBC produces and even that has gone down hill dramatically.
- klelatti 5y agoIt's worth noting that the BBC's reputation has also been harmed in the course of the divisive debate over Brexit with commentary that has kept neither side of the debate happy. On a lighter note (which I admit reflects my personal inclinations): they should buy back live coverage of Test Match Cricket from Sky - a series of broadly unifying national sporting occasions that used to have distinctive BBC coverage (and still does on the radio of course). Good for cricket too.
- Traster 5y agoThe political decision to lose national sports coverage from the public domain made both the BBC and the nations sense of identity weaker.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- kmeisthax 5y agoIs it even possible to cover Brexit in a "neutral" way that everyone likes?
- klelatti 5y agoProbably not. I do think it was less courageous than it might have been in calling out issues on both sides - I think it could have emerged with no side happy but possibly with more respect.
- nostromo 5y agoThey were so anti-Brexit, it got a bit ridiculous. One example: "Brexit threat to sandwiches" https://www.bbc.com/news/business-44960293 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-44960293 I am happy to report that there are still sandwiches in the UK.
- hfkwnfb 5y agoThis article is from after the brexit vote about what might have happened in the event of a no deal brexit. We are currently in a grace period on import checks, and this week we've seen warnings from food suppliers about what will happen after the grace period [1]. This shows it wasn't "ridiculous". Frankly I think the BBC did pretty well. Political parties didn't draw clear lines at first, and covering the full spectrum of opinions was probably impossible. Overall Farage got more airtime than his MP count would suggest was necessary, and he was sort of balanced by the Lib Dems. Even with a deal sandwiches have been confiscated as a result of brexit, so in some way there really has been a threat to sandwiches [2]. [1] - https://news.sky.com/story/m-s-warns-of-price-pressure-and-less-choice-after-brexit-import-rules-take-effect-12400723 https://news.sky.com/story/m-s-warns-of-price-pressure-and-l... [2] - https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/brexit-uk-eu-food-rules-travel-b1786462.html https://www.independent.co.uk/travel/news-and-advice/brexit-...
- bob229 5y agoGarbage article that totally misses the point. The reason the BBC is doomed is because it is metropolitan elite trash. Emily Maitlis talking nonsense, mad transgender propaganda antics, etc. DEFUND THE BBC. we will be far better off without it
- swalls 5y agoI like the original programming content the BBC produces. I don't like the BBC, and BBC news in particular, at all. They propagate bias in insidious ways like 'creative' titling of articles, pushing articles off to side channels, and cutting HoC footage, all the while claiming impartiality. Their quality of their writing on the site has truly tanked in recent years, too. And that's not to mention the harrassment of people who don't pay their license fee. Complain about Netflix's content all you want, at least they aren't lying about having signal detecting vans and sending threatening letters calling you a criminal. (To the non-Brits, the license fee is optional if you don't watch TV. But even if you tell them you don't have a TV, they'll send you letters every single month threatening you with court[1]) [1] http://www.bbctvlicence.com/ http://www.bbctvlicence.com/
- mattl 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vv2ZqZmC7u0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vv2ZqZmC7u0 is worth a watch on the subject too
- rocknor 5y agoThe bias in BBC's reporting is well known. For example, anti-India bias. Lots of other examples here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_BBC#Specific_allegations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criticism_of_the_BBC#Specific_...
- EricE 5y ago"The BBC’s legitimacy is predicated on it being a universal service." And this is the issue. Once they got super political they ceased being universal :p
- deadbunny 5y agoThe BBC are super political?
- mrlonglong 5y agoWitness Laura Kneussburg (chief BBC "zampolit") fawning all over Boris Johnson when she should have been giving him a hard time about his fuckups!
- nivenkos 5y agoBBC News is basically Pravda these days: https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-43463496 https://www.bbc.com/news/entertainment-arts-43463496 That was reporting on the opposition leader.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ChrisKnott 5y agoThe best thing about these comments is trying to guess whether they are about to complain the BBC is too left wing or too right wing.
- deadbunny 5y agoIndeed, that's has always been my argument for the BBC. Both sides are constantly claiming that the BBC is biased the other way so they are probably falling in the middle for the most part.
- traceroute66 5y agoThere are just so many things the BBC in its current form is doing wrong I don't know where to start: - Paying too much for too little (both quality *and* quantity of "talent") - Repeats, repeats and more goddam repeats in increasingly short timeframes - Recent actions such as putting Spitting Image on BritBox (paid commercial service), it should have been on license-paid TV ! I certainly refused to pay for it. - Taking Political Correctness to extremes. Whether race, gender or disability it has become like *every* BBC programme has to fill a quota. Don't get me wrong, diversity is important, but do you really have to cram every form of diversity into every single programme to the point where it starts feeling forced and artificial ? - Turning BBC News into a joke (newsreader reads summary, over to "our correspondent" who has been expensively transported to the scene to tell the viewer *the same thing*, then back to the studio for someone else on the BBC's payroll to tell the viewer *the same thing* again). During the COVID lockdowns, I can probably count on one hand the number of hours of BBC programming I watched. Everything else came from Apple/Amazon/Netflix and perhaps one or two services. If you want the BBC summarised in a nutshell, just look what happened when DoE died. They cleared their schedules across pretty much all TV and radio channels ... to broadcast the exact same mirrored content ... for god knows how many hours it was (48 ? 72 ?). Completely nuts. I mean one channel fine .... but the entirety of your major broadcast channels?
- carnitine 5y agoI think the BBC needs to reject the premise of celebrity entirely and start summarily getting rid of people when they start demanding exorbitant fees. Particularly for programmes which are factual, Huw Edwards and Gary Lineker are simply not worth their fees, people are tuning in for the content.
- caoilte 5y agoSpitting Image is made by ITV not the BBC.
- ChrisKnott 5y agoIf you watch less than 5hrs of BBC content a year, perhaps you aren't best placed to comment on it? This criticism is so hackneyed it could have been copy pasted from a 2002 Daily Mail comment section.
- gorgoiler 5y agoHow dreadful would life be if Auntie went radio only? It’s the only content I really care for. TMS, Radio4 to Radio2 inclusive, and a 198LW service detectable in the deepest of valleys. The gutting of the R4 schedule with repeats and the downsizing of the radio news team could happily be reversed. The jewel in the crown is R1Xtra. It’s absolutely at the cutting edge. How?! Oh, and erm The Last Kingdom, I guess. Thanks Netflix for saving it.
- deadbunny 5y ago> How dreadful would life be if Auntie went radio only? Pretty awful for those of us that enjoy (some) of their TV output. > It’s the only content I really care for. And this is where the problem lies, because the BBC has to try and please everyone you get people assuming because everything doesn't appeal to them then the rest should be axed.
- petercooper 5y agoHow dreadful would life be if Auntie went radio only? I'm glad someone else has asked this! I spent some time earlier this year thinking about the responsibilities of the BBC and given the diversity of freely available video now, I think they could satisfy most of their cultural and journalistic obligations with radio/podcasts for a fraction of the budget. (BBC1 alone takes up 28% of the BBC budget. Their entire radio budget is less than their annual government grant.) I say this as someone who loves BBC documentaries but is also trying to be realistic about resources and waning public appetite to pay the license fee.
- open-source-ux 5y agoThe challenge the BBC faces is one that all public service broadcasters face across Europe. Although they cannot compete with the enormous budgets of streaming services, that doesn't mean they can't make programmes the public want to watch and which can be popular. And not every series needs a huge budget to succeed. Co-productions are common throughout the industry and a lot of BBC content ends up on Amazon and Netflix. For those not familiar with the BBC outside the UK, the variety and scope of content they produce is simply massive. Some argue too much. It's not just big-name TV shows though - there are national radio stations covering music and speech, a further 40+ regional radio stations and the BBC World Service. They fund 5 orchestras, produce the biggest classical music festival in the world (BBC Proms), also support UK artists to get exposure with their BBC Music Introducing scheme. Children's TV programmes are free of commercial influence and ad-free. Educational materials cover the entire UK school curriculum and are extensive. (Remember the recent bbc micro:bit project to get kids coding? Only the BBC would have taken the initiative). The entire BBC website is completely ad-free for everyone in the UK (not ad-free outside the UK though). The list goes on... There are lots of things I dislike about the BBC, particularly their domestic news output. I hate the 'dumbing down' of some documentaries. But I think we in the UK would be worse off without the BBC despite all it's faults.
- parenthesis 5y agoWhy isn't everything the BBC has ever made available on a streaming service for license free payers? I'd love to able to watch the TV news for days when interesting things happened; old dramas with `low production values' but actual acting and writing and stories and no constant gratuitous cuts and close-ups …
- deadbunny 5y agoI believe there is historical reasons. When they started iPlayer they were told they coudln't just put up everything the BBC had produced in it's history as it would be "an unfair commercial advantage" or some other bullshit.
- M2Ys4U 5y ago>Why isn't everything the BBC has ever made available on a streaming service for license free payers? 1. Rights issues. The BBC doesn't actually own the bundle of exclusive rights to a lot of the content that they commission. The rights belong to the independent production companies that actually make the shows. 2. Regulation. The BBC has often been blocked by regulators from having a comprehensive SVoD service other than for catch-up, because it was seen as a threat to commercial entities (like Netflix). 3. Missing archives. Not so much an issue these days, but historically archiving was not a priority, at all. Many programmes were broadcast and then forgotten about. There are episodes of classic Doctor Who which are just lost to time now, for example.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoThe truth about untrue truths changes the moods of the crowds. [F] https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9958679/BBC-admits-Syria-gas-attack-report-flaws-complaint-Peter-Hitchens.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9958679/BBC-admits-... Nobody applauds...
- a-dub 5y agohasn't the bbc always been outspent by commercial production houses? what happens when the streaming giants start focusing on pumping out low risk crap as they mature into what they're replacing? i always thought the thesis of the bbc was that you didn't need huge budgets to produce high quality programming. and that, in fact, the opposite is true: moderate budget in the hands of the capable and passionate can produce outstanding results.
- enaaem 5y ago> What happens when the streaming giants start focusing on pumping out low risk crap as they mature into what they're replacing? You can stop subscribing and stop giving them money.
- te_chris 5y agoI can’t take an article about the BBC seriously that only talks about TV
- thrillgore 5y agoIf getting the BBC more money is the issue, do what Canada does with Foreign Movie/TV Productions, and tax the revenue to return back to its state-owned production company, the ONF/NFB. They can't get by on TV licenses and their deal with AMC Networks forever.
- seccess 5y ago"Instead, they’ll be reminiscing about watching a Twitch streaming millionaire child screaming racial slurs as he rail-guns his opponents on Fortnite." This perspective is reductive and insulting. There are many great, wholesome creators on YT/Twitch who put a lot of work to make their content welcoming and intellectually engaging, even if they are seemingly just playing video games. Just because the author doesn't like it doesn't make this remotely accurate to the real world.
- syntheticcorp 5y agoIt’s a reference to one of the most popular youtubers, who had the highest subscriber count for years.
- richardjennings 5y agoI believe that the BBC can provide value for money and remain relevant if and only if there is an internal recognition that any competition they face as an organisation is against the best social value that a public broadcasting utility can provide. Any notion of commercial competition needs to be squashed.
- gandalfian 5y agoBe honest, would anyone really be worse off if the iPlayer left out asking you to login, choose a profile, confirm you have a TV licence, decline the parental lock and click through the add roll?
- xqcgrek2 5y agoBBC ceased being universal and viewed as legitimate when it delved into politics and political issues. PBS in the US made the same mistake. The era of publicly funding TV should have ended years ago when information and news became free (essentially when US household internet or smartphone penetration reached 85%+)
- tablespoon 5y ago> BBC ceased being universal and viewed as legitimate when it delved into politics and political issues. PBS in the US made the same mistake. I've been watching a bit of PBS Newshour recently (easy, since full episodes are on Youtube), and if it's done that, it's done it to a far lesser extent than the commercial cable networks. Also, you can't have a good news program without "delv[ing] into politics and political issues." Often times when I see similar criticism, the real issue is the programming is not 100%-yourside inoffensive, but you won't get that from anything that's not Yourside-Pravda.
- xnyan 5y agoI'm interested to know which years you consider the BBC and PBS to have been "non-political" or not engaged in propaganda (propaganda in the dictionary sense, not the pejorative sense)? I've watched both for 30 years and also significant amounts of archival footage from both as a hobby/interest in broadcast history, and it's very clear that they have always had politically motivated narratives.
- tablespoon 5y ago> For example, Disney reportedly shovels $25m per episode into its prestige Marvel shows. The Crown on Netflix costs7 between $6.5m and $13m per episode, and so on. > With the best will in the world, there’s no way in hell that Doctor Who is ever going to have that sort of money spent on it8... > My fear for the BBC is that as generational turnover takes place, the BBC will remain outpaced and its cultural relevance will continue to decline. How can the BBC compete in a world where Disney can crank out an infinite stream of Mandalorians and WandaVisions11, while the BBC has to make do with less cash and an obligation to make worthy documentaries... Oh no, it can't afford to make superhero-themed stuff. We're doomed! There's an important place for stuff that isn't easily-translated superhero-themed special effects blockbusters. Frankly, I view the dominance of those blockbusters to be more of a disease than an important trend that needs to be aped.
- 908B64B197 5y ago> Oh no, it can't afford to make superhero-themed stuff. We're doomed! They absolutely can. If you make a show people want to watch, they'll pay for it.
- dageshi 5y agoI have often thought the BBC ought to create individual youtube channels for their tv series and put teasers for new episodes as they release on iplayer, along with the most popular clips from those shows. An audience of young people who almost certainly visit youtube regularly would then have a chance of being able to be notified when a show they actually like on the BBC releases.
- throwawaylinux 5y ago> Don’t get me wrong. I love the BBC, and I’m always the first in line to defend it from its many stupid critics. Ah, one of the "everyone who disagrees with me is stupid" types. Good of him to make that clear right up front so I didn't waste any more time reading.
- hamburgerwah 5y agoState funded propaganda has always been a bad idea. Maybe the BBC is the best example of a bad idea but either way, good riddance.
- RickJWagner 5y agoAs an American consumer of BBC shows and web news, I've got mixed feelings about this. I really like shows like 'Dr. Who'. I find the news interesting, but am puzzled by the focus on American politics (and always from the left side. I feel they truly don't understand the conservative half of America.) I wish them luck. I wish they'd present a more balanced view of America, but I wish them well.